How War Works: What is Doctrine? (Patreon)
Content
Doctrine. A term that immediately makes you sound smarter. What a great term. But aside from often using it, only a few people truly understand what it means.
Often, people have a hard time understanding what Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs) are and how they differ from one another. But doctrine adds an even vaguer, harder-to-understand layer of high-level military theory. To explain doctrine properly, we first have to understand the nature of war itself: War is Art.
There is no scientific formula, no set training, and no manual that guarantees a win just by sticking to it. The tactician and the strategist are masterminds. As Carl von Clausewitz liked to say, they are composers—artists who know a craft.
So, if war is a bunch of artists doing their thing, providing solutions by coming up with creative tactics, where is the border? What limits them, and what unifies them? That is exactly what doctrine does.
Let's look at the US Military definition of doctrine and dissect it. According to the United States Department of Defense (specifically outlined in Joint Publication 1, Doctrine for the Armed Forces of the United States), doctrine is defined as:
"Fundamental principles by which the military forces or elements thereof guide their actions in support of national objectives. It is authoritative but requires judgment in application."
Let's break that down piece by piece:
"Fundamental principles..."
Doctrine is not a rigid set of instructions, a checklist, or a step-by-step tactical manual. It represents the accumulated wisdom, best practices, and historical lessons learned by the military. It is the "canvas" that establishes the baseline of how forces operate.
"...guide their actions..."
It provides a common framework, language, and understanding. When combined forces (e.g., Navy, Air Force, and Army) operate together, doctrine ensures they are working from the same sheet of music, moving toward a unified goal rather than operating as disparate elements.
"...in support of national objectives."
Doctrine bridges the gap between high-level political strategy (what the nation wants to achieve) and operational realities (how the military will actually achieve it on the ground).
"It is authoritative but requires judgment in application."
This is the most critical part of the definition, and it perfectly mirrors the assertion that tactics and strategy require a "mastermind." The military officially recognizes that while doctrine dictates the standard way of doing things, it cannot account for the friction and chaos of actual warfare. The commander on the ground is expected to use their judgment, intuition, and tactical artistry to adapt, bend, or even break the doctrine if the specific situation demands it.
That last paragraph is the most important one: Doctrine can be broken if we know the risks.
Keep in mind that national doctrine is a result of culture, industrial capabilities, political realities, geography, and many other factors. But at the end of the day, you have to do what you need to do to win. It's crucial to understand doctrine so that you know how and when to bend it.
Let's look at what most NATO countries focus on: decisive victory through fast and massed strikes with very little depth. This is due to the fact that most NATO countries have professional armies; their soldiers are qualified to strike fast and violently, and will most likely provide an overmatch in terms of technology and training. At the same time, without the depth of full conscription, war needs to be won with a sledgehammer and/or a scalpel. A single cut or blow. This essentially sets the tone of our art.
Going back to the art comparison: If war is an image that you paint, doctrine provides your colors, your canvas (and canvas size), as well as the style. Everything else is up to you.
Doctrine is a collection of ideas, conceptions, best practices, and limits. Think of it like a typical art "school" of thought, like Bauhaus. The artists who adhered to an art school had creative ambitions, but they stuck to a rough framework of established ideas.
Ultimately, doctrine sets the stage to develop your Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs). It gives you the canvas and the colors—but painting the masterpiece that wins the war is entirely up to the commander on the ground.