Bad Ideas: Missile Tanks (Patreon)
Content
The Cold War was essential for the evolution of modern weapon systems and doctrine. It produced a lot of ideas—many of which were great, while others were entirely bad. Usually, bad ideas—no matter if it's designing a vehicle, a plate carrier, or even building your own kit—start with the perception that you are building something the world has been eagerly waiting for. It is a concept that makes perfect sense on paper, right up until practical application proves it fails. I bet you’ve had moments like this before: you had an idea that sounded incredible, until either you tried it out and it sucked, or someone with more experience told you the solution simply wouldn't work.
Even large defense contractors and militaries are not safe from such ambitious, yet disastrous concepts. In the 1950s and '60s, the Soviet Army became a huge proponent of anti-tank guided missiles (ATGMs). After a few proxy wars, ATGMs indeed performed above all expectations when used by infantry. At the same time, Western tanks were becoming increasingly lethal. This was largely due to highly accurate rifled tank guns—most notably the famous British 105mm L7—which, combined with the Western edge in fire control systems, made long-range dueling situations incredibly difficult for Soviet tanks to win.
The Soviets were hardly lagging behind in gun design; in fact, they were busy pioneering the world's first mass-produced smoothbore tank guns for the T-62. However, Soviet leadership, spearheaded by Premier Nikita Khrushchev, had developed a different obsession. Khrushchev heavily favored missile technology, genuinely believing that conventional tank guns and heavy armor were rapidly becoming obsolete. Driven by this political doctrine and the desire to consistently out-range Western tanks, a new idea was born: "Instead of trying to out-shoot Western main guns in a conventional duel, let's just equip our tanks entirely with missiles."
This sparked the development of the IT-1. Officially designated as a tank hunter, the IT-1 and other proposed comparable vehicles were ultimately supposed to replace all conventional tanks. Thanks to a lighter chassis and the precision of ATGMs, the IT-1 would not only out-range Western tanks, but it would also be faster and smaller, ushering in a new era of armored warfare. Before committing to a full transition, however, the Soviet Army deployed the IT-1 as a fire support vehicle for existing tank units.
Generally, the concept sounds fantastic on paper. If you look at the small silhouette of the IT-1, you can easily imagine how it becomes an incredibly hard target for approaching conventional tanks. In the West, missile tanks had also been dabbled with, especially in the form of lightweight tank hunters like the German Jaguar. ATGMs are great because they lack recoil and can therefore be mounted on very lightweight chassis. This is why they are still seen on platforms like Infantry Fighting Vehicles (IFVs) today. However, those vehicles have a broader purpose: their main task is to support armored units and transport mechanized infantry, getting an ATGM simply to combat tanks if necessary.
So, why don’t we have dedicated missile tanks?
The first issue is that a missile tank reloads relatively slowly. Furthermore, it has to wait until the missile actually hits its target before it can even begin that reload process. With SACLOS (Semi-Automatic Command to Line of Sight) missiles, there is also the severe limitation that a tank will have a very hard time moving and shooting simultaneously. A conventional tank's main gun is terrifying precisely due to its ability to shoot and move at the same time, targeting enemies with a high rate of fire. The typical, relentless rolling advance of an armored fist simply wouldn’t be possible with missile tanks.
Another issue the Soviet Army didn’t fully take into account was that Western tank guns operated at the exact borders of practical, real-world range. Back in the '70s, a typical Western tank would be able to engage targets at a maximum distance of 2,000 to 3,000 meters. While the Drakon ATGM fired by the IT-1 had a range of at least 4,000 meters, the reality of combat zones is that you can rarely even see targets beyond 3,000 meters due to uneven terrain, vegetation, and obstacles.
Ironically, current-generation Western tanks can reach the ranges of the Drakon missile with their main guns with ease. But even with modern ATGMs capable of firing at 5,000 meters and beyond, there is simply no need for a heavily armored missile tank just to exploit that range. Modern ATGMs are far better suited for smaller vehicles, right down to the size of ATVs and trucks. Let's be honest: if the primary purpose of a vehicle is to sit back and destroy tanks from extreme long range, why even weigh it down with heavy armor?
Last but not least, the entire concept revolved exclusively around dueling other tanks. Neither attacking and suppressing fortified positions, nor urban combat, nor anti-infantry work was taken into account. While the IT-1 did have a coaxial machine gun, the vital ability to simply swap out an armor-piercing round for a canister shot or high-explosive shell to engage infantry or strongholds instantly was gone.
Most likely, the Soviet Army could have just asked an experienced tank commander for his opinion, and he would have told them, "No, that won't work out." Sometimes the harsh nuances of real-world application destroy a concept that looks flawless on paper, and the missile tank is the perfect example of just that.