The Value of Classic Fieldcraft (Patreon)
Content
When it comes to classic fieldcraft—for example, tying knots, applying face camo, building poncho floats, starting a fire, and the like—I often experience two colliding schools of thought within the military. One school essentially argues that none of this matters anymore. According to them, with fast-paced maneuver warfare, modern supply chains, and modern image amplification, there is little value left in these traditional skills. The other school of thought is the exact opposite. They hold onto the idea that infantry will always operate cut off from supply lines, and that building shelter, purifying water, and knowing when to change socks matters more than marksmanship and tactics. I think being a subordinate to leaders in either of these camps is the worst thing that can happen to soldiers, and I also think neither of them truly understands what fieldcraft is.
If you are subordinate to the “new school” that neglects fieldcraft and views it as an artifact of World War II, you will go through a lot of fast-paced combat training. But once there is a contingency, you will have a hard time remembering the very basics. At some point, you may notice that fieldcraft has become more important than ever before.
The “old school” fares even worse, viewing fire and maneuver as "high speed" and fancy. If you fall under this camp, your core warfighting capabilities will suffer. Imagine spending multiple days a week tying knots, building poncho floats, applying face camo, and constructing fire pits. The inevitable result is that marksmanship, maneuver, and communication become an afterthought. The commute to the mission suddenly becomes more important than the mission itself. You are essentially a lawyer constantly learning how to wear a suit properly instead of learning how to win lawsuits.
What is Fieldcraft?
Fieldcraft is essentially the ability to move and sustain in the field. This is a broad topic, and we really need to understand that we can break it down into two areas, which I will call Category I and Category II skills.
Category I skills are your bread-and-butter skills, and they are of utter importance for mission success. They include, but aren’t limited to:
Preparing fighting positions
Estimating distances
Dispersion of formations
Hand-and-arm signals
Describing and naming terrain
Terrain sketches
Camouflage
Route selection
Category II encompasses the skills that most people nowadays associate with fieldcraft; they largely revolve around sustainment and tinkering. In a modern environment, however, they are not necessarily always crucial for mission success. They include:
Building shelter
Tying knots
Fire and warmth
Water purification
Foraging
Long-term sustainment
Let’s be honest about Category I and Category II: Category I is severely under-trained, even by those who heavily endorse fieldcraft. If you look at the “old schoolers” from an unfiltered perspective, they largely try to focus on capacities that resemble “cozy” hiking and outdoor activities. This also explains their disdain for “fancy, high-speed things.”
On the other hand, those who solely focus on combat will quickly realize that without hand-and-arm signals, describing terrain, estimating distances, and applying proper camouflage, their shooting and tactics become almost useless. Even some Category II skills can become important if the terrain and mission demand them, but this is not an excuse to make them the focus of a training curriculum. The reality of near-peer combat is that supply chains—while occasionally interrupted—are present. Infantry is largely fighting along the Forward Line of Own Troops (FLOT), as seen even in Ukraine.
Finding the Balance
A good training curriculum needs to be driven by demand. The core pillars of every infantry training program should be marksmanship and tactics, followed by a steady repetition of Category I fieldcraft skills. Category II skills don’t need to be trained very often because they are: A) largely contingency skills, and B) not highly perishable (you don’t forget how to tie a knot within three months).
At the end of the day, it is about finding a balance. Proper military training shouldn’t look like a cringe-worthy private tactical shooting class, but on the other hand, it shouldn’t look like a bushcraft convention either. Training priorities should always be based on realistic expectations.
As always, thanks for your attention.