Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

Miles

After watching Zains stream I feel like they completely missed the point of what he was trying to say with the tweet.

Isaia Ruiz

I think the way F1 has become a sport where 3 out of every 4 new fans are women is a good example that modern social media that prioritizes short-form content has made it much easier for women to become fans of a sport that's heavily personality based and narrative driven. Robert Pattinson is already huge in that short-form social environment and that would maybe not immediately double viewership, but the women who primarily drive social promotion would eventually get it way up. F1 is awesome and women becoming fans of a sport because of likable figures in that sport make it even more awesome

Shrapnel

I think charismatic excellent players are great for the community's they are a part of. If Wolfe was an ass I think VGC has a smaller player base, same for AoE and hera, or grubby for WC3.

chrispified

i met ludwig at a diet tribe once

Jon Price

Easily an all timer

AustiBear

generational goons, also what if it was zendaya

noah swan

I think representation of cool people do help niche topics, Henry cavil did increase the war hammer fandom however I feel as though it’s not as impactful as lud would think, like zayn malik with yugioh it’s sometimes just a cool story you see on twitter

Evan Waara

10 year old baby who loves Robert Pattinson

SpookyGodzilla

A lot of Rob's fans would also then have to buy melee and a console to play it on and also have friends to play with. I don't think he could make a wave. Viewership would uptick, but I don't think the amount of players changes enough to sustain the wave

Paul Patterson

Ludwig moving like a republican senator in this episode

Sludgelover

My foreskin was taken from me and I’m team Zain just for the data

RichardLong

id trust you with my life

Seth Criger

People play melee for free online using slippy

the yard

after having the direct context of the guy himself explaining himself I feel like these guys interpretations might be off laughing emoji

Miles

I meant that more as a source confirming my thoughts rather than changing them. I just thought you guys gave a bad faith interpretation of Zain’s tweet.

RoTaMo

Just want to jump in on Texas Roadhouse. They haven’t done the peanut thing since COVID. Big Peanut won, they do not want you to deshell your streaming counterparts and litter it on the restaurant floor anymore

Craig

Genuinely banger primo

Colby Belanger

If mang0 was named James Bond, would that be talked about more than Robert Pattinson being named James Bond?

ChickenGoesBAWK

Aiden is definitely wrong and I think he undervalues the demographic that thinks Robert Pattinson is cool. Yeah his fan demographic is probably skewed to a type of person who wouldn’t play melee but if I saw a headline that he was the best at the game I would tune in because it’s a spectacle and I think he is cool even though I don’t consider myself an active fan.

Mico

Imagine how many people would show up to tournaments if there was a chance to meet Batman/Bond

Ryan

First yard debate that had me torn

Doddy

As described I guess

SpookyGodzilla

Idek what that is and I'm pretty tapped in to gaming stuff. Not saying I'm the norm, I haven't played many nintendo games so this could just be a huge blind spot of mine.

Adam Nielson

I think its bad faith to shrug off any criticism with "its just a comedy podcast". (regardless of whether the criticism is valid or not)

qZona

I think you proved the point he was making while trying to disagree with him which is funny

the yard (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-19 06:00 you only are saying that with the ultimate knowledge of his intent, your comment should be something like "zain explained his thoughts and its actually pretty different from what they are interpreting" also you still qualify it with "I feel" which is kinda funny because shouldnt it be definite if you now have direct authorial intent
2026-11-19 02:53 you only are saying that with the ultimate knowledge of his intent, your comment should be something like "zain explained his thoughts and its actually pretty different from what they are interpreting," but even then its like trying assign correctness to what we said, maybe more productive is "zain explained his thoughts on stream, they were off in what they thought he was doing" also you still qualify it with "I feel" which is kinda funny because shouldnt it be definite if you now have direct authorial intent just a kinda dumb sounding comment is all that is close to being more significant as a way to tell people if they want to hear the guys thoughts they can go check it out

you only are saying that with the ultimate knowledge of his intent, your comment should be something like "zain explained his thoughts and its actually pretty different from what they are interpreting," but even then its like trying assign correctness to what we said, maybe more productive is "zain explained his thoughts on stream, they were off in what they thought he was doing" also you still qualify it with "I feel" which is kinda funny because shouldnt it be definite if you now have direct authorial intent just a kinda dumb sounding comment is all that is close to being more significant as a way to tell people if they want to hear the guys thoughts they can go check it out

Erik Lees

Courage JB/ Courage JT

avonx

one of the best premo eps

Nicolas Rubinacci

As someone who got into melee and gone to tournaments because of the yard and by extension lud. I think aiden is just wrong because lud isn’t Rob pat. Also, why would he think a donut is a croissant.

Miles

I realise my original comment was poorly written so now anything I say comes off as mega hindsight, but I just thought your reason for agreeing with cody was uncharitable to Zains tweet and was surprised you interpreted it in that way.

the yard

I think I (slime) was charitable to zains tweet every time I agreed that cody was likely really lame to be around and listen to and play against, even if I myself think the guy is fine, but yeah I would’ve loved to have seen his explanation before we debated this lol

Micor

What would be the biggest bump for melee? A good adaptation for the switch? Or a big streamer hype Wave? Nintendo openly allowing Slippy/PM?

Inkayea

Unless you just started watching the pod recently then you should know what slippi is by now

Miles

Like I said, I know my original comment made it seem like I only came to my conclusion after the Zain stream and I came here with hindsight, and I’m sorry for that.

SpookyGodzilla

Idk what to tell you it probably just slipped my mind

EB

If your response to a sensible argument is a personal insult then you lose the argument, simple as that

jason mcdorman

All of you are so bad at arguing except for Aiden and it’s crazy

Sympt0

Idk I feel like of Nick and Alex can revive BO2, Robert Pattinson could revive melee

Hannah

Would Shohei Ohtani or Jack Black have a bigger impact on Melee?

Aiden McCaig

Yeah but would you tune into every major tournament for more than a year? Probably not, I think I say almost exactly what you’re saying in the ep

Aiden McCaig

I actually thought about Henry more after and thought that if someone can show he brought a lot of lasting traffic to Warhammer than my argument is like moot

Shwabae

I’ve never been more opposed to Aiden’s perspective, it’s black or white anyone of influence at all would change a player base of anything

Sven Stucki

I'd say having a charismatic Person as a figure head for a community is the main way games thrive these days. Just look at all the other big games that thrive of of the back of one singular charismatic Person. Minecraft Speedrunning has Feinberg, Trackmania has Wirtual, Valorant has Tarik. While they aren't necessarily the best at the Sport still thousands of people watch the game purely because of them and part of those viewers will pick up the game themselves.

La4rsh happyface

If Robert Pattinson is the best player thousands of more eyes will be on the game and it’s insane to say that people won’t get hooked.

La4rsh happyface

Also saying Ludwig and the yard boys had no lasting effect on the melee scene is crazy

Tony Smith

Henry Cavill said he liked warhammer and then was made producer for a live action show

the yard

take your sensitive ass back to LS

Cumfart

Bros responding to comments

Olivia DeSouza

Robert Pattinson wouldn’t change the viewership but any member of BTS playing it would instantly revolutionize the industry.

Mason Wood

26:36 look at taylor swift bringing viewership to football? I know football already got huge numbers, but there were definitely more people watching when she was first like being shown so much on TV.

Harley

One time harry styles wore a crocheted cardigan to a concert. Thousands of women flooded 5 year old crocheting tutorials on youtube to learn to crochet the harry styles cardigan. And I can’t prove it but I feel pretty certain that there was at least a percentage of the pie that liked crocheting and stayed with it long after that. This argument also depends on your definition of how many people need to stay with the game for Robert P. to have made an impact. But melee is small enough that I think it would definitely have an important impact. Type shi

aidan eckles

My perception of this argument was really confusing because everytime they mentioned the “doc” I thought they were talking about dr disrespect. I am obviously not well versed in the melee verse. But RP is literally Batman so he’d push numbers.

ACooks

I think your two best examples of this are F1 (which someone else stated) and not even the biggest guy in the world but Jinyx who without a doubt revived R6. I know many of people who have never touched that game and people who had and didn’t like it come back and play more because of him. The power id a charismatic figurehead is insane, crazy that LS Aiden couldn’t recognize that fact.

ACooks

Also I think saying viewership wouldn’t hold for the game overall is just an unfair argument, as someone who loves sports, I don’t watch every basketball game or football game. I do always show up for my favorite players, teams, rivalries etc. Someone like LeBron brings in viewers for his sport because he’s the best and charming even when his team sucks or is losing people still pay to watch him play

Salmon

Fun fact, peanuts grow underground like a carrot! The more you know

Nathan Ware

Gunz the duel mentioned?

Walker Morgan

Aiden’s dumbest take^^^^^ warhammer sales literally increased statistically after Henry made that comment. People would GO TO MELLE just for a FLEETING chance to play Robert

Jinouga

If anyone ever asks you what The Yard is about, it's this episode.

Colton Jones

It sounds like Cody needs to become the most famous actor in the world.

Medium Hollow

30 something’s that read and explained the Zain and Cody tweets to your wives we are UP

gadros

great episode guys

Korbin Podolak

Absolute aiden believer feels incredible, love the glee in nicks voice, fantastic premo

Korbin Podolak

I do also love millennials acting like melee is a good game for anyone that didn’t grow up with it or is already in the scene, it’s a miserable game to pick up as a new person and melee heads drive me insane

Nibby

I love when u can hear Aiden take a life or death breath of air after arguing Batman wouldn’t increase overall long-term viewership. What a serious debate to be had over a dead game.

WoodBurn

Most of the time I'm on your side, I'm even on your side with the lights ep. But he's Batman you're just wrong.

Ricktov

So riveting I almost forgot Robert Pattinson isn’t the number one melee player

Jared Shultz

aiden cares about raising floors, ludwig cares about raising ceilings. kinda the vibe i got

Jared Shultz

was thinking about f1 the whole time lmao

Jonathan Thomas

Tip to tip, Mexico, Ludwig is speaking too much Spanish

Tiger Zuo

The biggest flaw in Aiden’s argument is that he assumes that R Pats needs to get new people into melee. Like there are thousands of people that stopped playing melee that would be reactivated if he was the best player.

Swiggy Booty

I'm telling you right now if Robert Pattinson had Cody's fox it would without a doubt usher in a new era of melee to the point where even Nintendo might have to make concessions

Swiggy Booty

Robert pattinsons fame exceeds anything melee has ever seen and considering melees already roach-like staying power as a competitive game it would keep the game alive for another idk like 1000 years

Swiggy Booty

But we're looking at this person being the best in the whole world at this thing. Not just a guy who's into it. I'm not a Warhammer guy but imagine if Henry cavil was consistently just at the apex of whatever equivalent to the Warhammer community.

Swiggy Booty

For christs sake even the first fan page I found on insta has 375k followers like what are we doing

Swiggy Booty

Mangos twitter has 254k followers and that's like the actual guy and I can only assume he's the melee player with the most followers. Idk man

friteusenbozz

What a jump scare ,warhammer mentioned

Zach

I think Aiden is just drastically underestimating how many people give a fuck about Robert Pattinson. Like fractions of a fraction of a % would increase viewership. Robert Pattinson has more wannabe stalkers than melee has viewers.I also think Aiden has a misconception about sports and sports fandom. Most football fans didn’t play other than backyard football. I got into melee through the yard and have never in my life played the game. Fandom is about identity far more than it’s about the game. Fans of Robert Pattinson would watch because it’s a part of their identity to follow what he’s doing. I don’t care about the Eagles because I played football. I care about the eagles because that’s my city and those are my people. Edit: also over a long enough time frame everything goes out of public consciousness what the fuck is he saying

Ben Hurley

i think aiden got really caught up on the (true) observation that the vast majority of robert pattinson “fans“ are not the demographic of people who will be interested in playing melee, but why i strongly am team lud is that that doesn’t really matter. the f1 example in the other comment is really illustrative, where social media and short form can make something like smash more digestible, and just the raw amount of extra attention melee would have if one of the biggest movie stars of this decade is the goat would be huge. talking about his “fans” misses the point: young people, regardless of whether they are fans of robert pattinson, would be ENAMOURED by a movie star ALSO being the goat of a video game, and would see him as a role model. i also think what lud was trying to say is that melee wasn’t big solely due to other factors like the doc or nostalgia, it was big because it’s a great game, and if there was some reason for new people to watch it out get into it (maybe like a mega famous charming charismatic movie star being the goat), it could be big again or even bigger

Avery Guyer

I think Aiden's argument here might actually be like, the most infuriating argument I ever heard. He even references Henry Cavill with Warhammer and Slime references Vin Diesel with D&D. I'm decently educated on the history of tabletop popularity as I have followed them for a decade and a half. Their inputs as high end celebrities that genuinely enjoy their hobbies not only brought attention momentarily, it grew the fan bases long term as others began to interact with the activities when they otherwise wouldnt have. Saying that the documentary only works because of a myriad of other factors seems devoid of any sense. Of course Melee boomed because of the alignment of Factors, thats just how cause and effect works. So if Robert Pattinson became the best Melee player of all time. That brings new eyes that would pick up the game when they otherwise wouldnt of AND other factors like this Podcast and Im sure the other things these guys do make up the other parts of the cause and effect relationship. Ludwig seems to kinda intrinsically (bad spelling? Idk) understand how popularity works, which makes sense tbh

Frank

Lud is full on ragebait on this one

Ashe

nick this episode

Big Wheel

I know this is a community, hosts included, values Melee very highly (and it’s a very good / significant game in its history) but melee is not mainstream enough to hold any traction from a big celebrity in the same way something like D&D, F1, or other examples would imo

Alex Nelson

yes but i think this example is more so a representation of the argument where the doc is coming out at the same time as robert pattinson being the goat. the f1 growth is a combination of drive to survive (the doc) and top players with rizz. there’s also a point to be made that f1 has had a disproportionately large boost in content SURROUNDING the sport. i think a decent portion of this section of the f1 fanbase is more interested in the content surrounding it. not at all saying that they aren’t watching the chinese gp or whatever, but it’s certainly less interesting to them than carlos sainz edits. i think it also complicates this argument that f1 is inherently cool. it’s this glitzy world where we are all drinking champagne in monaco driving fast cars (oh and they are all hot)