Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 787336354.mp4

Downloads

Content

[cams fix after the ~6 minute mark, sorry!]

  • 00:00:00 - the lacy feastables machine

  • 00:03:40 - theburntpeanut

  • 00:05:10 - peanuts

  • 00:09:40 - the zain vs cody drama

  • 00:22:50 - The Robert Pattinson in Melee Debate

  • 01:05:00 - thanks for watching!!

Files

Comments

Savin Miller

Dude the timestamps doing an Olympic long jump is so great we’re in for a treat

Issac Perez

Ludwig hits the lacy pack?

maTo (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-20 22:00 I smah bros with no patting on my robert, son.
2026-11-19 19:10 I smash bros with no patting on my robert, son.

I smash bros with no patting on my robert, son.

Rodney Ringling

I didn’t read the full title yesterday and now i’m so so curious

kirbearZ

Subscribed to the Patreon for little treats like this

AustiBear

Nick’s childlike glee is genuinely the worth a lifetime subscription to the patreon

Aaron

been listening to the audio ep since yesterday and holy moly this argument had me up a wall there's just no way Batman JamesBond L canceling wont just permanently grow the game let alone he's top 3 or sm

funktorial

"but he's batman and james bond" is such a powerful argument. hard to deny

Eric

long ass timestamps just like the good ole days

Thepink1

This is an important enough conversation yall should release this as a Christmas gift on main

Jeremy Koehn

the only thing that matters to me when i watch melee is there is a falco on the screen that is shmoving. WOO

Julian

52:00. I play melee bcz of Aimen crying video. I wanted to try it out. now i play everyday and go to tournaments

Jacob

never thought I’d watch big chungus ludwig die of botulism in 4K UHD but I guess it was inevitable

[OMEN]

This is the most interesting debate yet. Also I know multiple people who got into warhammer by being fans of Henry Cavill's work. Ludwig was right.

Jeremy Koehn

OMG I just got to the part where he plays falco and this is no longer an argument

yawmperz

ludwig nobel prize episode

Louis

Aidens neck veins are going to explode

Samuel McLeod

I think this was my favourite Yard episode Main or Primo of all time

asai

Surely the coolest guy in the world who’s also the best Melee player is also gonna be a good streamer/figurehead for the game. Regardless of his existing fanbase

Griffin Steinke

unironically the first time ludwig has been correct on something like this i think

Rahul Ramkissoon

I literally only watch melee stuff if it involves someone from the yard. Ludwig is right. Aiden acting like people wouldn't stick to a hobby when this is literally how people start hobbies. Also I never knew about the melee scene until I watched the yard. Imagine the millions of people who would discover this community.

Mady

i think aiden thinks robert pattinson has the same fan base that he did when he did twilight. hes fucking batman, man.

ramnslam

its staring at me through the chair

Jacob Wolosik

A hypothetical of Robert Pattinson being the best at melee really turned into a healthy philosophical disagreement. That’s dope.

Karma Status

"guy who thinks babies are 10" 🙌

Jayden Manasse

this might be the best collection of main and premo episodes they’ve ever had.

jemiGnome

I think one of the best points in this entire argument was where Ludwig says that Pattison’s impact would be more than just his direct, die hard fans. I can see many young people not being “fans” of him, but knowing the name, playing video games, and seeing, “Oh wtf? Robert Pattinson just won this gaming tournament?” - Clicking it, and having a chance to fall in love with the game. It’s not necessarily about Pattinson, it’s about the “brand” of Pattinson. It’s exactly why advertisements exist, it’s the reason why brand ambassadors exist, partnerships, LOGOs, literally the idea of associating what you are trying to advertise, with something or someone cool/recognizable is how you draw people in. It is quite literally impossible to say that any type of showcasing of something will not have a long-lasting impact. There is always a chance of someone seeing something and falling in love with it. Even if you were to go with the idea that “fan-cam fans” created these videos of him with the cropped face-cam, that draws its own, separate audience of people who will also make Zain fan-cams, Cody fan-cams, etc. There are, and will be people who would watch the tournaments just to see Robert Pattinson. Why do you think the Clippers sell out when LeBrons in town? It’s not because the Clippers are a popular team. And, the more people that show up to a clippers game, allows for more people to FIND a Clippers game, and BECOME Clippers fans, rather than just LeBron-heads.

Wren Eaton

is cody kinda lame? yeah but i think fictions tweet summed everything up pretty perfectly. id rather our top players be kinda socially inept/awkward than you know. actual criminal things like sexual harassment

Kas

these are my favorite type of episodes

Mason H

So many people got into Warhammer because of Henry Cavill and Pattinson is vastly more popular than him. People would get into melee just for the chance to play against him.

Fad42

I fully agree with Ludwig's Cody take BUT I am in no way a "Melee Head" so I don't think my opinion really matters. Historically, the best player in sports is also hated by most people, often because they're a bit of an unlikeable asshole! Comes with the territory.

GravyLord

The Reddit is gonna be stinky this week bro

Kirby

Ludwig don’t play about dada Pattinson.

Fad42

I will say this, I only got into watching competitive melee because of Ludwig & The Yard. I never owned a Gamecube, and my first smash bros was on the 3ds. I have no nostalgia when I watch the game, I just root for Magi, Moky, Zain & aMSa.

sharknateo *

Aiden is just so wildly wrong, he's acting like everyone has already chosen to not like melee, Pattinson has fans who have never heard of the game, and if even 5% of those fans end up liking the game there would be a massive spike

Swift inabox

With robert pattinson i think it just becomes a raw numbers game. Hes got millions of young fans who are super impressionable, i cant believe even 1% of them wouldnt become engaged with melee after seeing BATMAN win a tournament

MidoriUsagi

i wonder how much impact Neymar Jr's presence in CS community made considering he is i would say as famous as Pattinson

DiabeticDan

What if for money matches instead of giving the winner money, they get the loser’s controller?

DiabeticDan

What if for money matches instead of giving the winner money, they get the loser’s controller?

Rune Walkingshaw

The whole conversation is moot cause when in 5 years moky is the most famous male actor and the number one rated player we will have the answer

Rory Elio

I’m only halfway in and this is a top five the yard episode for me. Nick saying “I feel like you are all acting like me” fucking killed me

Jonah

Weird comparison but most big fashion houses livestream their shows now and the chat is almost entirely Kpop fans looking for their fav in the audience, and all of these people chatting are 56 year old women with 3 adult children who have all gone no contact with them. If Robert was playing Melee tournaments his super fans outside of the Melee demographic would absolutely tune in.

Matthew Ritt

If you shit on the floor of a Tommy’s they might put it on a burger. It’s gotta be the easiest restaurant to take a poop in by far.

TheElusive

Also, the Witcher series. I set up the game on my partner's PC after watching the first series on Netflix. She never plays games.

rsolbes

Taylor Swift being the best player in the world would revive melee

aple_sto

I think one thing lud is missing is the consistent turnover of the player base of any game. Absolutely robert brings new viewers to melee and some of those new viewers become part of the player base. But because his fanbase is so broad and a considerable proportion of them just don't play games in general I don't think it completely overcomes the consistent leak of players that any game has over time.

Luke Liljenstolpe

i made this comment on youtube but its crazy to see ludwig just sits with a single nylon strap spreading his cheeks the entire episode

aple_sto

1:03:40 Faker absolutely increases melee viewership and player base because when his fans go and try melee they realize that video games can actually be fun

phineas

This might be the wrongest Aiden had ever been straight up

Katie Foster

As a casual Robert Pattinson fan (would watch a movie if he’s in It but not watch fancams etc. ) who has never cared about smash a day in my life, I would absolutely watch a game if he was the best in the world out of sheer curiosity. From there it’s narrowing slices as Ludwig said, if the game was interesting to watch I would try it myself and possibly get invested and so on. If even one iota of fans follow this same path then there is lasting impact.

Schmunk

I asked my 2 roommates (both females close to 30 who don’t know much about melee) if they would watch Robert Pattinson play in a major because he is the best smash melee player in the world. They both responded with “I’d watch him eat a bowl of nails” or “I’d watch him watch paint dry”

Leo Maxwell

Here I am dying on Aiden hill again

strad

wow

Lachlan

ludwig is so clearly right on this it’s marketing right, robert pattinson will bring hundreds of thousands of more eye onto the game and surely a volume of which will stick, even if it’s only thousands it’s still more than what it is now.

phineas

Four divine beasts is sick though I'll give it up

Zander

I think the Robert Pattinson thing is kinda funny cause on a much smaller scale ludwig himself has done this with mcsr ranked while hes not THE main guy his popularity though did bring more eyes to the game and raised the viewership

Nate

Aiden is so wrong, it’s great how passionate he gets about it though

frunnahaus

we are all slime and nick on this day. just watching the argument in silent fascination

Inkayea

I love it when they argue so passionately<⁠(⁠ ̄⁠︶⁠ ̄⁠)⁠>

Nicholas Swift

going from the Maya hell in the cell main ep to giggly bear Nick the whole premo was such an enjoyable contrast

Inkayea

Also whether he's right or wrong, I love that lud still goes to bat for melee

Dan

Thinking of a world where Robert Pattinson makes all super majors hit 100k concurrents and it stays like that for years to come but eventually becomes the norm so we would take it for granted and say it's falling off cause it's not growing anymore.

Zander

Oh he mentioned it fire

Redkiwi

bro deadass

Ben Prasifka

The fact that Cody gets away with “oh he doesn’t care” when he’s still playing 10 hours a day is part of Zain’s point. Why does he get to keep saying he’s retired when he’s more active than half the top 100 and practicing 40+ hours a week?

Chris

Modern poetry

Thomas

Good god look at ludwig in that chair

Giulio Spetia

31:11 the whole debate was very nick-adjacent

Halomateo

guy who thinks 10 year olds are babies has a business/news podcast, more at 11

hrideyesh

I am 20 I got into melee cus of lud and ik many others who watch tourneys and play js through watching lud who is exponentially less famous than Robert, presumably Pattinson would also be similarly streaming and playing and going to tourneys and watching

bee

If he knows one thing, it's streaming

bee

I feel like Aiden is discounting that the girlies are equally capable of being exposed to what is fun and cool about a traditionally male-dominated activity, and embracing it and making it their own. Look at what Drive To Survive did for F1. Will every single Pattinson super fan watch melee independent of him for a decade? No, but a lot of them would get interested and fall in love with it the way y'all did. It's an in-road to a whole new audience. It also just increases awareness of the game as a whole to have a celebrity play it. There are millions of people who don't even know what melee IS that would find it via Robert Pattinson increasing its exposure. I had never played a single video game before I found The Yard, and now I'm about to beat Elden Ring bc I watched Nick stream it like a year ago. So in my opinion and my experience: many such cases!

Chrust

last example is so different tho, lebron fans are extremely likely to enjoy a lebron basketball game even if it’s at the clippers, robert pattinson “fans” which is honestly less then lebron in that same type of infatuation way because pattinson is much less of an icon/ character then lebron (people like pattinson roles, people like lebron the guy). anyways the pattinson fans have no reason to enjoy melee wheras the lebron fans have a huge reason to enjoy basketball. I think there is a small venn diagram of guys who actually like pattinson and also would like melee but it’s nothing like lebron playing the clippers

Chrust

i’m not gonna hold u bro pattinson fans do not fw him like k-pop fans fw their oshi. people r like yah pattinson a good actor, k-pop fans deadass would die for them no joke

bee

Oh Slime pretty much called this out 30 seconds after I typed it lol. Thank u Slime.

dj khaled

i gotta be honest. devastating to hear this convo and know that robert pattinson will never be the best melee player in the world. i would give anything to be in that timeline.

Cody le

If trump can get half the country to vote for him and he's not the COOLEST GUY. Imagine the COOLEST GUY (they just chose it as Robert Pattinson) says he is the best Smash bros players. Aiden is pushing the goalpost perpetually for that whole argument.

Andy Hackett

I mean, another example of it working the opposite of what Aiden is saying, I only came across The Yard because I searched for Hank Green on Youtube because I wanted to see more Hank Green. Now The Yard is my main podcast, the only thing I subscribe to on Patreon anymore (I'm poor), and the only Podcast I religiously listen to every week. I literally did not know who any of them were before I clicked on the Hank Green episode. I didn't watch anyone on Twitch, didn't know anyone they hung around with or made content with. Complete absolute disconnect, but turns out it happened to be my favourite thing, I just hadn't been exposed to it yet in any way. To add to this, I now watch Slime regularly on Twitch (when he streams, I know saying regularly is probably misleading), occasionally watch Ludwig, and watch other people from Twitch like NL, before I watched The Yard I didn't engage with any of it. So it wouldn't just be the act of people tuning into the Melee tournaments, it would be the ancillary things around the edges, like other creators in the space that would get more eyeballs on them that then grows their viewerships which then has a feedback loop of just generally putting more eyeballs on the game and the people who earn a living from engaging in content about the game. It's giving it more of a chance of being seen by some guy or girl who goes "Whoa this looks sick, how do I play this". So yeah just replace podcast with video game and multiply Hank Green's reach by a factor of a thousand.

Angus Johansen

Obviously it would do insane things to the viewership. If you have any respect for the game you love you’d have to think that of the millions more people who have eyes on the game for even one clip or one tournament enough would stay around to be able to say the viewership has meaningful increased. Also if he’s the best in the world surely he would actively be encouraging fans to view the thing

Angus Johansen

I wish the lemonade stand fans could see Aiden here. They’d be salivating

Maple

I’m glad I’m not alone, that is also what got me to try melee for the first time. Now I helped start and run local in WA

Devan

Cant stop laughing at his cheeks poking out the bottom of that chair 😂😂😂

Scott

Was going to go shower when the Robert convo ended, just checked the stamp and its just the rest of it lol

Jtag

Someone probably brought it up already but Henry cavil bring up he likes warhammer kinda skyrocketed the popularity and brought it wayyy more into the mainstream. At least that’s where most people I’ve talked to irl heard about it first. Edit:top 3 main ep into a top3 premo

TenaciousDealer

This is a rare Aimen incorrect vs Ludwig, I don't know if that's ever happened before. My goat can't be right about everything. Also anecdotally I have stopped playing certain games entirely because the people who were the "faces of the game" were simply bad people and it really took away from my motivation to engage with the community. Without a doubt there will be people that tune in to their first smash tourny, see Cody being a twat, and decide it isn't worth following. Also babes the amount of eyes that would suddenly be turned on to a game if Robert Pattinson was the best at it doesn't even need to create instant super fans of the game but just by the process of that many more people trying it there would be a large broad increase in players. It really feels like Aiden is thinking Robert Pattinson is just like a minor celeb. This might be the most right Ludwig has ever been.

Medo

Unskippable title

gurvir

unironically the best premo yet i love watching them debate stuff like this!!

Shadow

the best main/premo combo ive seen holy shit we got spoiled

Scott

Tenet was another one. I liked him in that

Jaime Mango

I think even if Robert Pattinson didn’t even post that he was ever into melee or went to a tournament, it would spike viewership. The problem with the argument is that melee’s skill gap makes it not a good game to retain people even with a spike from him. It’s not Pattinson himself, it’s the game being what it is. Also, never even heard or seen about that documentary being mentioned before Aiden brought it up lol

grok

They need to talk to a normal fucking person for once

Sunny D

This is a great arguement, probably one of the best on the show because it's so 50/50. Ultimately I think Aiden is correct that Robert doesn't move the needle enough. Traditional media is still too separate from esports. Like yeah it'll come up in an interview like once as a cool tidbit but Robert Pattinson would need to actually galvanize his fans into playing Slippi and go to tournaments for things to change. His Best in the World aura doesn't do it alone. He would get MOBBED by fans of his in IRL tournaments but those fans do not make the jump to being melee fans; at least not a significant amount.

Adrenaline

why Lud got he cooter out on the pod

ShotKawla

This episode and the Maya one were both excellent!

Shan

team zayn bc hes just saying the vibes are shit with Cody. If he did it when he won, Cody would have just clapped back when he eventually won, which ruins the argument and devolves it into who is better, when its more about the dogshit vibes Cody is bringing as someone who represents the scene as its best player. This is as someone who knows nothing about the scene

terminallybill

kind of a stupid argument because Juan is already the best in the world

ray

this is genuinely worse than the lighting debate

Sleep for Dinner

Judging by the timestamps do we have another “the boys argue about donuts for 30 minutes” in our slop buckets

D

Nah Ludwig is right this happened in Germany recently, a guy who used to be a kind of well known rapper 10 years ago is now one of the best Beybladers in Germany and he recently won the German championship and since then a shit ton of people started watching Beyblade tournaments simply because they know the name of the guy who is now one of the top players (yes I know how insane this sounds but it‘s 100% true)

Jamie Hauken

It's the Dungeons and Drag Queens phenomenon or the Hockey Players try Figure Skating. The concept is more enticing than the individual elements would be.

jesse ramirez

Pattinson is going in a generational run 21-26 year olds all around me (25) are fw pattinson heavy

jesse ramirez

people will get mad educated on it but it wouldn’t not blow up but also the change wouldn’t be negligible

Dragau4

Im camp Zayn 100%, the face of a game is what brings views... If the best player of a game ia considered a good person, yes views come. Faker is one of the most respectful guy we've seen in League, if he was a dickhead ppl wouldn't be for T1

Dragau4

Aiden, you're smoking, I stopped watching smash when mang0 stopped playing, if robert Pattinson was the best melee player, i would watch, he's james bond dude

jemiGnome

It’s not that the LeBron/Pattinson fans would have a chance to enjoy the Clippers/Melee games, it’s that the more attendees in general promotes and enlarges the community in general, pushing out for more eyes to see.

Tom

Ludwig clears here

jonas lilley

what did you do to ferb? did you touch him again?

butler18

I don't watch melee but if Pattinson started playing I'd take a peek each time, and maybe more in general. Why is it so hard for Aiden to comprehend that a world famous person wouldn't affect viewership? I think he's too lost in just trying to defend the stance he started the episode with lol

Cooper Guthrie

100% Pattinson would make melee way more popular for at least a decade

Cooper Guthrie

Every single Instagram reel about this fun fact adds someone in the world who knows about the video game. And it would help melee so much if everyone online suddenly found about it through the fun fact that Batman is the unbeatable gamer at this extremely competitive game.

jonas lilley

i think the outcome of influence ultimately comes down to how much publicity melee would get by pattinson winning. in this hypothetical is he just the best and continues on his normal day life or is he; making social media posts, talking about it in interviews ect. if its the latter it will move the needle undoubtably. more eyes = greater reach = bigger number = more money. whos to say in this hypothetical where he does post on social media a big sponsor like red bull for example decides to capitalise on this and invests in big prize pools.

Daniel

Aiden saying Robert Pattinson's fanbase is only women HAS to be homophobic -A bisexual man who's had his eyes on bro since i first watched twilight

DaddyWarbucks

Not giving a shit is probably helping cody, fully void of any nerves/pressure

han

in regards to the fan longevity and still tuning in 1, 2, 3 years down the road, i think in that hypothetical you WOULD still see an increase in viewership, even if it's small. there's still a noticeable increase in female viewership of the NFL post-taylor swift/travis kelce, you have a bunch of millennial/gen z women who would've never been interested in sports before learning what special teams and o-line mean for the first time. if robert pattinson was the best in the world, and even if he wasn't, im sure there would be a real chunk of fans who would be tuned in even if it's just for a chance to see RP, and then some who tune in bc they genuinely get into melee

Nick E.

Cody is a child.

DaddyWarbucks (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-21 00:00 A celebrity can bring an audience to something, IF that audience was already capable of enjoying that thing but just hadn't been exposed to it. I don't think the thing holding melee back from being bigger is exposure, and I don't think the average person is capable of actually getting into competitive melee. Robert Pattinson can boost something's popularity, but he can't manufacture it beyond a very short explosion of interest. I think Ludwig is the same, yeah if he's streaming an event the viewership of the event goes up, but I don't think that actually converts meaningfully into more people tuning in when Ludwig isn't streaming the event. I think melee just has way too much friction for getting into it to convert regular gamers. It is not a game that appeals to a wide modern audience, especially the way it plays competitively. It also has a huge debuff in being a game that never changes. Sure the way players play changes over time, but that doesn't create the same excitement/intrigue as things like league adding new characters, CS adding new maps, or even smaller adjustments to things like item economy.
2026-11-20 20:25 A celebrity can bring an audience to something, IF that audience was already capable of enjoying that thing but just hadn't been exposed to it. I don't think the thing holding melee back from being bigger is exposure, and I don't think the average person is capable of actually getting into competitive melee. Robert Pattinson can boost something's popularity, but he can't manufacture it beyond a very short explosion of interest. I think Ludwig is the same, yeah if he's streaming a melee event the viewership of the event goes up, but I don't think that actually converts meaningfully into more people tuning in when Ludwig isn't streaming the event. I think melee just has way too much friction for getting into it to convert regular gamers. It is not a game that appeals to a wide modern audience, especially the way it plays competitively. It also has a huge debuff in being a game that never changes. Sure the way players play changes over time, but that doesn't create the same excitement/intrigue as things like league adding new characters, CS adding new maps, or even smaller adjustments to things like item economy.

A celebrity can bring an audience to something, IF that audience was already capable of enjoying that thing but just hadn't been exposed to it. I don't think the thing holding melee back from being bigger is exposure, and I don't think the average person is capable of actually getting into competitive melee. Robert Pattinson can boost something's popularity, but he can't manufacture it beyond a very short explosion of interest. I think Ludwig is the same, yeah if he's streaming a melee event the viewership of the event goes up, but I don't think that actually converts meaningfully into more people tuning in when Ludwig isn't streaming the event. I think melee just has way too much friction for getting into it to convert regular gamers. It is not a game that appeals to a wide modern audience, especially the way it plays competitively. It also has a huge debuff in being a game that never changes. Sure the way players play changes over time, but that doesn't create the same excitement/intrigue as things like league adding new characters, CS adding new maps, or even smaller adjustments to things like item economy.

Nick E.

Aiden is so wrong on this debate.

Will Wright

Im usually an Aiden defender but omg idk how you could be more wrong ofc the current most popular actor in the world doing ANYTHING publicly would bring at least SOME extra attention to that thing. I love some aimen gamin but it felt like you just didn’t want to concede today.

Will Wright

Nvm the 10 year old baby thing won me back he’s based

Nick E.

Holy moly, Aiden really took his nihilistic views from main ep and applied it to all his views, huh?

beans

They’re calling it Aiden’s worst take

Rodney Ringling

This may be the greasy primo i’ve ever heard this is amazing

DaddyWarbucks

I think warhammer is significantly easier to get into than competitive melee. You can enjoy warhammer from multiple angles, whether it just be enjoying painting, collecting things, playing tabletop games at home, or going to your LGS and getting serious about it. Competitive melee is a much narrower interest that appeals much less broadly IMO for a variety of reasons. Obviously watching a melee tournament stream is a lower barrier to entry than buying a set of warhammer minis, but actually getting into competitive melee in a way that results in meaningful viewership/participation increases long-term is a much higher barrier to entry than getting into warhammer in my eyes.

DaddyWarbucks

I think Melee is just much harder to fall in love with than any other competitive game. Something like League is pretty easy to get into and start playing, and you can enjoy it at an extremely casual level. Enjoying melee at a casual level in the modern day is extremely difficult comparatively, and getting into a game with a high of a skill floor as melee without any kind of casual introduction point is an insane obstacle that most people aren't going to overcome. Hell most people are going to turn away just at the fact you have to emulate the game and use mods to even start playing it at all.

DaddyWarbucks

Melee might be better than every other smash game, but it's harder to play and harder to understand which means less interest. Dota 2 is a better game than League, which I say as a Dota 2 hater, but League is way more popular because it's so much easier to get into and play casually.

the yard

can tell by you spelling his name wrong no more talking ever

the yard

what does this even mean? whats your attitude about

grok

I dont have any attitude i thought this was one of my favorite patreon episodes (light main episode is one of my favorites for context) but my comment does come off as insanely angry my fault g I dont know a lot of famous people and I think im pretty average on famous people knowledge and Robert pattinson blows everyone out of the water in this conversation. He was in the odyssey. Hes batman and james bond at the same time. Speed maybe but I feel like speed would move on too quick to leave a lasting impact. Then again to be the best at something as technical as melee takes a lot of time. Idk I think if tom cruise went crazy again and was the number one melee player a stream of a tournament would break records we've never even heard of I usually agree with Aiden but I feel like he was very wrong on the one

SnowyJop

I feel like you only ever interacting with Melee unless the Yard is involved is more of a point in Aiden’s favor. You’re not really falling in love with melee at that point, you’re just interested in the personalities of people there.

JuanM

???? Do you really not see how your first sentence proves Aiden right? If your only interaction with that scene is when a Yard Member is near it you aren't a melee/smash fan you're a Yard fan.

Peyton Cummiskey

Wonder what both sides would say for how T Swift brought in new NFL fans

Woodus

Id say Slimes analysis of it is only fair if ur assuming the thesis is "Zain is posting this cause hes losing a lot to him, ultimately he wouldn't care how cody acted if he could BE the positive symbol- but he cant cause he isn't the best" What nick said is not how i read him not wanting to play cody. Zain wants to play Cody's melee brain, mechanics and etc, he just doesn't want to play with the mouth and the words. he doesn't like the attitude and tone of cody- not the melee side i think. I think hes fine with how cody plays the game- its how he talks and treats the game. i think if you interpet it that way as He NEVER Will or WANTS to play cody again- but i agree w it being lame from the anti competitor lens when read that way. and as a non player i really cant fathom "States of the game" when the game doesn't get updated. i always assume its just controller shit.

Devan

I'm so team Aimen on this

Tristan Vosburg

How many viewers do we think Lucia Doncic pulls if he streamed regularly? Not the best overwatch player in the world, but still good.

Rahul Ramkissoon

Yep, I was giving a point to Aiden. The point that I'm not expressing well enough is that I would of never interacted with the community at all if not for the yard. Melee didn't stick for me, maybe it will for others. With Robert Pattersons fame, that's alot of potential real future fans of "insert literally any hobby'. I really liked brennan lee mulligan from his improv and comedy skits. I started watching dimension20 because of it. I am now a DM and play in multiple campaigns. Dnd community bigger. I never really cared for the final meals show until Ludwig went on and I was introduced to it. I watch every episode. I never cared for the other yard boys but I started watching because of ludwig and now slime is my favorite streamer. Ludwig is right in my opinion. But I'm honestly open to being wrong, I just feel my above reasoning is sound.

krooz

I hate you guys for making me agree with Aiden

Rob Carlstrom

I think if robbie p was the best smash player, thatd be pretty cool :)

Diego Jimenez

i might watch quavo once if he was the best warzone player but i dont think id watch a robert pattinson melee tourney

Jason Queen

I dont care if he comes off like a bit of a pissbaby, Zain was spitting flames

Tidysalads

Comms guy take: the biggest thing that Ludwig and Aiden are talking past each other on is what's called a "passive" vs an "active" audience. It doesn't matter if 99.9% of Robert Pattinson's fanbase doesn't care about Melee. TikTok fancams make it into the mainstream because him being goated would be novel, and that INEVITABLY reaches gamers adjacent enough to be interested. Parents would send their kids magazine articles about it because they know their kids play games. So many of these people that are RP's "active" audience won't like melee, but they KNOW someone who might. Ludwig didn't really properly articulate the sheer reach and cascading effect that would have. Every single person reached is another person who could find their local, could innovate a new meta of streaming melee that isn't capped at 1k, could even be a new runner for the goat. That kind of short term high novelty push, which is me being as charitable as possible to Aiden's perspective, is so much kindling for the scene you couldn't even begin to measure it if you tried

Nick Santana

At first I was Aimen-pilled but Lud is right. He’s Batman and James Bond. It may be true that a majority of Pattinson’s diehard fans are not in the demographic that would get them into the Smash scene but Pattinson is on a generational run in his career. That novelty could bring in such a huge uptick in viewership at first and while that may not sustain in 5 years, the more people in that uptick means there’s a higher chance for people to see Melee and think it’s worth a shot. It could even be regular joe schmoes like me who are like huh the odyssey Batman guy is playing game let me see. The pull would be tremendous

o

i appreciate the content warning for the argument episodes so i know to skip lmao

Alejandro Lopez Ovalle

I’ve genuinely only watched Melee like once or twice and it was because it was a small segment in a Ludwig event. But if you told me Robert Pattinson was a top player and PARTICIPATING in tournaments!? Yeah man I’m a regular viewer then 😂

Kobe Abraham

Most of the comments saying lud is right are some variation of "I would watch X famous guy do X thing out of sheer curiosity" which ignores the main part of aiden's argument which is like, sure, but will you still watch it out of sheer curiosity, every competition, between then and one year on, two years on? Probably not. I think aidens argument is also correct about hitting the zeitgeist in 2015 for melee. That's why ludwig pivoted to saying that Pattinson is a force and when a wave comes it blows up. He has to agree with aidens first argument, that Pattinson on his own, being the best player, won't make melee famous again. Lud is arguing that there needs to be other forces for it to happen, which i think is probably true.

Daimondz

By far the best part of this episode is nick in the corner kicking his feet and giggling

Talon Earley

The man makes funny noises Aiden

Justin Marevka

the timestamps fuckin murdering me dude

Jack

Aiden is smoking so much butt on this argument.

Nicholas Keung

53:40 I think Nick sums it up extremely well here, and the question becomes "how accessible is melee to the general audience." And speaking as a non-melee head (and barely even a gamer), I think 80+% of Robert Pattinson's fans are pretty similar. Personally, I've seen "Greatest Melee Moments of All Time" clips dozens of times and absolutely no idea what was going on. This is despite me listening to The Yard for years, having multiple friends who play, growing up playing casually, and being genuinely interested in learning. So the likelihood that a Robert Pattinson fan watches a set, stays for more than 5 minutes, understands what's happening, manages to learn the basics of the game, and sticks with it for more than a month just seems insanely small to me. But current melee players can probably speak better about retention and bringing in new players.

Mason

Never played a day of melee and this is the most out of touch I’ve ever felt and I’m still absolutely loving the friend dynamic of the length of an argument that is in every single way silly to even bring up lol