Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Movie Poll: Simone's "favourite" genre (Patreon)

Published:
2025-10-13 12:00:14
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:

Poll

Movie Poll: Simone's "favourite" genre

  • Weapons (2025) 935
  • Longlegs (2024) 257
  • Barbarian (2022) 492
  • Sinister (2012) 363
  • Us (2019) 411
  • Rosemary's Baby (1968) 540
  • Silent Hill (2006) - George has seen this a long time ago but remembers very little. 402
  • 2025-10-06
  • —2025-10-16
  • 3400 votes
{'title': 'Movie Poll: Simone\'s "favourite" genre', 'choices': [{'text': 'Weapons (2025)', 'votes': 935}, {'text': 'Longlegs (2024)', 'votes': 257}, {'text': 'Barbarian (2022)', 'votes': 492}, {'text': 'Sinister (2012)', 'votes': 363}, {'text': 'Us (2019)', 'votes': 411}, {'text': "Rosemary's Baby (1968)", 'votes': 540}, {'text': 'Silent Hill (2006) - George has seen this a long time ago but remembers very little.', 'votes': 402}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 16, 13, 48, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 6, 13, 44, 24, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 3400}

Content

The last weekly polls winner will be available this Saturday. Reminder: movies that don't win does not mean they will never be watched, it just means they will be watched later. Please be respectful to each others opinions, we're all just here to have fun and watch movies. :)

Comments

JoeE

Would also recommend one cut of the dead

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

Yes what a great poll! All outstanding choices but I’ve gotta go with Barbarian and Weapons. Zach Cregger is one of the best new voices in horror and they’re perfect for a Halloween season reaction!

Kevin Kerr

Ooo this is tough one, good choices on here!

James Kennedy

Aw man, I knew Weapons was gonna be winning. I found it super disappointing honestly

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Weapons is stellar and fabulously crafted. Mind you Barbarian is also fantastic. Some disturbing viewing ahead no matter what haha

Adam

Long legs is god awful. Please don’t vote for that 😂

newhastings

Weapons is obviously gonna win but man it’d be cool to do Barbarian to compare alongside it

daskeyzerlein

I agree. An absolute masterpiece and a movie you should not know anything about it beforehand

Carl Noraas

I think Weapons is gonna reign here. Happy about it :)

Some Guy Some Where

If you want a movie that will properly scare George, I’ve been hoping you’d watch Free Solo for a while. I admit I’ve mostly given up after seeing your Ghost Protocol reaction. It might be the hardest movie for his issue with heights, fair warning. That said, it’s a really good documentary and worth watching, unless it gives him a heart attack.

TomGas2025

How about the Conjuring 3 and the annabelle movies.

Bertrand Belisle

First time I watched all the movies in the poll, and I like them all. And is october, so watch them all.

Alexrandom

Rosemary's baby and longlegs are the most interesting movies on this list! But I'd watch any of them anyways 😊

Michael M.

Recency bias strikes again

Charles

I don't know if it would get a lot of votes but would like to see you guys react to Waiting...

Maniacalmouse

I haven’t actually seen any of these, so I am just going to list some others for future consideration in no particular order. 🙂 -The Woman in Black -1408 -The Haunting (1963) -The Legend of Hell House -Something Wicked This Way Comes -Stigmata

Chris

Wow, this was difficult. So many good ones. Do them all, please 😊

VeticalArtistry

Should watch Idle Hands. Is a horror comedy from 1999 and has some pretty terrifying moments but is also funny as hell

Michael Bauer

I'm in the minority here, but I found Weapons really disappointing and bland. I wondered whether I had just lost the taste for horror, but I then rewatched "The Descent" and a few other classics from the 70s to the 00s and still enjoyed them quite a lot. Guess this one just isn't for me.

paul rai

*Insert Patrick Starr rubbing his hands together with a gleefully evil- like smirk*

Ali D

It’s not necessarily a bias. It is new, it’s fresh in people’s minds but it’s actually a great movie. The other ones aren’t going anywhere, they will get to them.

Exeden

You should look at Dead End (2004).

Jaaahn

again? - last weeks poll the movie from 1991 won with newest being 2015 in second place. - poll before that Grosse Pointe Blank was from 97 and in that poll newest was a 2010 movie at last place. - before that the newest film on that poll lost. before that it was a movie from 1975, the oldest film on the list won. - and before that it was Devils Advocate from 97 when newest on that poll was from 2017 came 3rd. - going back further it was that 'rEcEnT fIlM' Monty Python Meaning of Life from 83. literally cant remember the last time the newest movie won. recency bias?? really??? are you high?

Haye Zeus

🎶Recency Bias is winning again🎶 Although this time it’s for a movie i am interested in

Michael M.

Might be. Might be. Thanks for the research and the rebuttal.

Spacedone

I agree that it's not anywhere near as scary as some people suggested it was. There's some horror in there but it's more mystery than horror. And I was roaring with laughing at the ending. Very odd tone-shifts. That's not a criticism of the film though, I still thought it was entertaining enough.

Jaaahn

what do you mean again. seriously, name the last poll where the newest movie won. see how far back you have to scroll because im scrolling well into August now and still havent found one. past poll winners have been Prisoners, Rocky Horror Picture Show, Devils Advocate, Monty Python, Book of Eli, Willy Wonka, Wedding Singer, Close Encounters of Third Kind, Hellraiser, Gangs of New York, Lost Boys. back to July now btw, then it was Brazil. every single one of those polls had multiple other films much newer into this decade. recency bias?? if anything it seems more like nostalgia bias. which is also a stupid claim. but calling the polls "recency bias is winning again" is insane. its like youre so eager to make this complain you dont actually care that reality has been the opposite.

Ronny Boss

If you fine folks want a good horror comedy this year, then I think you would enjoy Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon

darkmoobs

They should do Barbarian and then Weapons. Knock out both of Cregger’s films.

Ronny Boss

Oh that is a good one. I second that suggestion

paul rai

The thing about Weapons (which I’m so happy you’re getting to) is that I think Simone will find herself surprised at how much she will enjoy it because it’s equally terrifying and hilarious. Like I predict she’s gonna be on the verge of tears of laughter at some scenes (IYKYK). It’s got a wicked sense of humor. Sinister is the film I think she may loose her mind over and curse us all out for making her watch it lol. That’s a movie designed to scare you to your core. I was lucky enough to see it an early screening with the writer in attendance, and he used to be a former film critic, Robert Cargil, for Ain’t It Cool News, I was a huge fan his work and it influenced how I view genre films. He talked very heavily of what he wanted to avoid when writing a script for a horror film. Really cool guy.

FranciscoGios

I haven't seen Weapons but I've heard it is good!! So lucky Simone 😁

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Idle Hands is a treat. Great choice dude! Been a while since seeing that one but Devon Sawa was excellent in it

RSMJ

Silent Hill! Much like George, I saw it when it came out and vaguely remember it. I'd love to revisit

SmallWoodenDuck

Oh Lord, these are ALL great. Just do them all. Longlegs getting criminally overlooked so far.

Josip Buretić

Not my favorite genre,so I hope something good wins 😁

BzzBzzBzzBzzBzz

please refrain from calling other members stupid or insane.

Jaaahn

i said the claim is insane. i dont think he is, i dont know him. but his claim is stupid and insane.

Clipped

Rosemary's Baby is legit scary and really creepy. Not even to mention it's an excellent film that takes its time making you care so that when it finally gets to where it's been heading it — a bit like the Exorcist — rewards you for your patience. Mia Farrow's performance is pitch perfect. This film changed the way I thought about 1) that kind of building, 2) neighbors, 3) behbeh carriages, and 4) behbehs.

blerbaberpaterb

smart people can say stupid things and 'recency bias wins again' is stupid.

blerbaberpaterb

curious you didnt complain about nostalgia bias in the last what, 3 months?

Dane Winton

Holy frijole just watch all of these 😆 I loved Barbarian, Longlegs and Weapons! I haven’t seen the others but I’ve heard that Rosemary’s Baby is a classic and Us is good as well. And the other two look like they’d be fun at least 🎉

Jasbro

Us is really good, but i think we all know Weapons is going to win, i havent seen it yet but people have hyped it up so im excited to see it.

ShōNuff3K

I can't vote for Weapons because I haven't seen it, but I have seen Barbarian. 👀

DemNikoArt

Great list. I think Weapons definitely deserves the win! A few more for Simone ;) - drag me to hell - Hollowman - No One Will Save You - Mama -A few more "Saw" movies maybe? :D - Sinister - Midsommar - The Night House - The Gift (2015)

Cinebinge

Hi folks. Let's please keep things calm and civil towards eachother, and let's end it here now and move on. Thank you

Robinson vs. Parkinson's

This week's recommendations are two baseball movies to cleanse the pallette after spooky season. Both are actually feel good films with a lot of heart. 1: MAJOR LEAGUE, and 2: BULL DURHAM. Can't go wrong, either way.

beefjerkywizard

Barbarian & Weapons double feature...? Can't go wrong with any choice off this list.

Random Nevermind

Please watch some day 
The Ninth Gate The Others Thank you

Josh Cutmore

I love that you have Weapons and Barbarian on here!!!!! I would suggest starting with Barbarian, they both have the same director, but Barbarian was released first. Just my humble opinion! Thanks for being awesome, both of you!

Jaaahn

i agree with watching Barbarian but its not a prerequisite. its not like one is a sequel.

Haye Zeus

Thank you for saying i’m smart.

Josh Cutmore

Totally agree! I think a double feature would be awesome. I just think it would be neat to watch Creggers flicks in order 😊

Śéáń

Weapons is a great watch. Couldn't believe it was done by Zach from WKUK. The comedy to horror pipeline continues. edit: one of my favourite sketches https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPHc68RIYAo He got into writing horror to cope with the loss of Trevor, the other person in this clip. They were a great sketch group.

Cosmic Slice

Rosemary's Baby is a classic!

Jaaahn

you really mixed in some terrible actors and even terrible people in there huh. I mean Segal?? the Putin suck up with a history of sexual assaults on sets and is so out of shape and lazy he has to do fight scenes sitting down. yeah how about lets not promote that colossally terrible person.

Jaaahn

i apologize for my harsh wording, but this complain really does drive me nuts because it comes back time and time again, yet each time theyre like months apart which should actually tell you how there isnt a recency bias.

Haye Zeus

I was joking dude. I just thought it was funny that the new big movie won, like it’s obvious why. But It’s not a big deal. I also said that i’m interested in the movie so i’m actually excited they’re gonna watch the movie.

Jaaahn

okay then i am sorry. but you can see that im not the only one who thinks youre serious. because in the past, people have been serious with such complaints despite not having a new movie win for long stretches of time. i dont ever want S&G to be afraid to put newer movies on the poll because of non sense complaints.

Haye Zeus

I get that, but it’s gonna be a part of the channel whenever this thing happens. It’s inevitable. People are gonna complain. Even if it’s a movie that has 99% hype, that 1% is going to be the loudest and annoying. It happens and just gotta tune that shit out or realize when someone is just being a silly billy like me.

Jaaahn

how about dont spoil things and let them decide if they like it or not.

Jon Nelson

Rosemary’s Baby is an absolute masterpiece

Jon Nelson

Rosemary’s Baby is literally on the poll, Thankfully George and Simone are mature enough to separate art from the artists, you should try it…

Jaaahn

except Rosemarys Baby is actually a good movie and Polanski, despite being a rapist, is actually a good director. the hell does Segal have to offer? hes not a good actor, hes not a good or real martial artist, he cant do action scenes worth shit, AND hes a terrible person whos actively still doing terrible things. im on the side of separating artist and art, but there must be good art in the first place. Segal has none.

Jon Nelson

I would love some more classic horror like Frankenstein (1931) or The old Dark House (1932)

Jon Nelson

Great film, saw it on The Last Drive-In

Robert Finlay

Rosemary's Baby is a must-watch, regardless of whether it wins the poll or not.

Michael M.

Very curious indeed. I seem to have my own biases. So sue me.

blerbaberpaterb

right cause Under Siege is on the same level of Chinatown, or are you saying you think Beyond the Law is equal to The Pianist? no? which fat Segal movie are you claiming is worthy of artistic merit Jon? lol Chinatown is genuinely one of the greatest films and thats the requirement to separate artist from art. watching License to Kill or whatever while Ukraine war is actively going on is just in bad taste

DasBigUn

Simone's going to need a change of pants....maybe 2

Chris Graham

This is a really difficult poll, I love Horror and this list is great, Rosemary's Baby for me is a classic but its the slowest of slow burn with not much pay off, I would love a reaction to all of these movies

Collinson

Wow all of them are deserving of winning.

FWPJR.

Oh man, I’ve been waiting forever to watch you two react to Sinister. It’s one of my favorite horror movies, but judging by what the poll is looking like right now that definitely isn’t happening next week lol but hopefully it happens sometime soon.

Lycowolf

Since you guys have seen "The Fly" and "The Thing", you should finish the 80's extreme remake trilogy with "The Blob".

Jpsynergy

Haven't seen many of these. I hope the scariest one will be picked!

cincassette

Some good contemporary options here, with Weapons still fresh off its release. I was quite underwhelmed by Longlegs when I saw it in cinemas last year, but I think most of these picks will make for great first watches. Rosemary’s Baby is obviously a must-see. Another classic horror worth checking out is The Birds, and more broadly, there are still so many great Hitchcock thrillers to explore... North by Northwest and Vertigo would be great places to continue.

JoeE

Sinister one of the scariest horror movies I’ve seen recently

Tom Buckley

George mentioned previously you should react to the Hitch hikers guide to the galaxy.

RLYtoxic

Hope they get around to it, think it was on a poll couple years back.

Cinebinge

we've both seen the movie. it appeared in polls before because Simone forgot shes seen it, then once we started talking about it prior to recording, she realized shes actually seen it before.

ShittyShittyGameGang

This is a hard one, i want you to watch so many of them! I will say though since it looks like it's in the lead, it's not 100% necessary but I would watch Barbarian before watching Weapons. They're the same director and I just think if I was telling someone to watch both it'd be in that order for like one reason that I won't spoil.

FWPJR.

It’s definitely scary, it stuck with me for awhile after watching it.

ShittyShittyGameGang

No, but it feels right that way. Like their will be the tiniest of pay offs for doing it that way and I think it'd be great!

ShittyShittyGameGang

Just to maybe lower your expectations a little, the first time I watched I was like meh that's okay and then I watched a couple more times and I love it. I was the same way with Longlegs but Barbarian I loved immediately. Just so you can maybe gauge my taste & compare with yours.

ShittyShittyGameGang

Longlegs is my favorite for the year but I love so many on this list, so I get it. Sad that they still haven't watched Sinister yet too!

Logan Kerlee

The Birds!! That movie scared my mom quite a bit back in the day! I remember seeing it in our video collection and after pulling it out she jumped at it and immediately told me to put it back! xD

Jeff I.

Glad to see Weapons doing well, but I really would echo the other comments and suggest doing Barbarian as well. The order doesn't really matter. Also, I don't think it's a spoiler to say that having moments of dark comedy in a horror film is part of Zach Cregger's style (writer/director of both Barbarian and Weapons), so don't be thrown off by that.

Jon Burrows

On and off it’s been measured scariest movie of all time. I love watching reactions to Sinister.

maikeru

They never do actors poll for whatever reason. I suggested a Schwarzenegger poll probably at least twice last year and maybe once this year but nothing so far.

Mike FromOz

I was thinking "Why are we having such morose films of late??". Then I remembered what month it is 😄 So, whatever wins, wins. Be interesting to see how things end up, but it looks like Weapons has it in the bag.

Jon Burrows

Sinister definitely hasn’t been measured to be scariest of all time I think they should start with an easy one like that 🫣

Jeff I.

I could see someone unfamiliar with Zach Cregger's style/tone due to not having not seen Barbarian before Weapons being a bit thrown off, but to call the last 20 minutes of the movie "a fucking comedy" is a wild overstatement.

scott melton

Weapons or Barbarian first? I tried Barbarian when it was released, but bounced off it at the time. Went back after Weapons and loved it.

olly.enn

Happy about Rosemary doing so well. I think that one should go into some "mandatory classics list", regardless of season or the voice of the mob! :)

olly.enn

Sure, doesn't really matter but I think Barb first makes sense, just for the progression of Cregger's oeuvre... Would also make for a fun double! :) ButI DO think Weapons is the superior film, so Barbarian should serve as an encore to that one, not as a substitute because it can be only one winner.

olly.enn

Yeah it's funny to see how many viewers seem to be put off by the humor in it. I really appreciate it but when it comes to horror some people seem to be particularly anal regarding tonal ... "flexibility"

Red Freckle

Looks like Zach Cregger's two films are doing well. If you know nothing about Zach Cregger, he was part of one of the first youtube sketch comedy groups, Whitest Kids You Know (WKUK). His type of absurdist humour is evident even ~16 years later, a short I'd recommend featuring him is "WKUK - Gallon of PCP" (it's only like 3 minutes).

olly.enn

I know it's a SHOW and not eligible for being a spooky season feature - and flies a bit under the radar in general - but do we know if the HANNIBAL TV show is still being considered as a potential future series?

John

I would add The Natural and 42

Kaushik Sethunath

Not necessarily for this season.. but.. Here's requesting 2015 Best Picture winner and black comedy, Birdman! For the filmmaking, performances and general vibe, I think it'll be right up George and Simone's alley, and would make for a great reaction. Would love to atleast see it in a poll soon!

Michael L.

Better than the poor Silent Hill adaptation is going back to the source: Jacob's Ladder.

ShōNuff3K

Okay I just watched Weapons. Was some of it supposed to be THAT "dark" or do I have a crappy TV?

ShōNuff3K

Ahhhh, square footage, YES!

rictus grin

while i had more fun watching Weapons i have to go with the classic Rosemary's Baby

Paul Mix

I actually liked Silent Hill, but Jacob's Ladder is a masterpiece.

Robert Finlay

Have they done any Hitchcock yet? If not, they need to do North By Northwest, Vertigo, as well as the Birds.

Paul Mix

The Others is delightfully creepy.

Paul Mix

I'd love to see a reaction to Pumpkinhead (1988).

cincassette

They've only watched Psycho and Rear Window so far

Maeve1667

Should check out Woman in Black and An American Haunting

Daniel Smith

My weekly shout out for Never Let Me Go. For a horror film below the radar, American Mary. In the same vein, Promising Young Woman.

Brandon Meng

How about a non-horror Halloween movie like Hocus Pocus or The Witches?

sagesaria

They did Hocus Pocus last year.

Ari Ramirez

you've got the teeth of the hydra upon you

Dan Holmes

Man, weird list lol going Rosemarys baby I guess

Jay Davis

Since I find 'horror' movies boring (...unless of course that movie is The Omen (1976) ;), I'll let everyone else decide then watch whatever it is because George and Simone are not boring.

Ashton Lewis

Great list. Weapons deserves the win. You should do the 2013 Evil Dead film this month too :)

Saifu

WEAPONS LETS GOOOO!!

LeperMessiah117

Kinda surprised it's losing as bad as it is.

Patrick

*psst* Dog Soldiers is great.

Dustin Duvall

I've been asking for sinister for years :(

dansoddity

Weapons is such a good time and atm my favourite of the year! But would definitely recommend repolling Rosemary's Baby another time, that's an all timer right there.

BellaBlue

so many on this list I hope get done soon...I voted for Weapons for recency bias and I wanted a film I voted for to finally win (and I figured it would)...Longlegs is also a fun watch.. (I admittedly love it more than some)..and Barbarian was the Weapons director first film and it is also great... RB is a classic and def deserves a watch...the others are also good...although US is my least fav JP film...

BellaBlue

high praise..I loved it as well...it will probably be a contender in top 10 category for me...but there are already a few I'd prolly put over it at 1...but I've been pretty happy w the quality of films I've seen this year... as of yesterday 67 films at the theater so far this year

Andrew

It's probably an unpopular opinion but I thought Longlegs was very overrated. Glad to see it low in the poll. Barbarian is my choice because it would freak Simone out. 😂 It won't win but they will get to it eventually.

mayhem74

"You spelled 'favorite' wrong...."

Anders Sandum

Movie recommendations: The Man Who Would Be King(1975) The Mission(1986) The Last of the Mohicans(1992) Quiz Show(1994) Unstrung Heroes(1995) Cold Comfort Farm(1995) Hackers(1995) Rob Roy(1995) Swingers(1996) Beautiful Girls(1996) Kingpin(1996) Beavis and Butt-Head Do America(1996) Event Horizon(1997) Dangerous Beauty(1998) Enemy of the State(1998) Stigmata(1999) Deuce Bigalow: Male Gigolo(1999) Blast From The Past(1999) Almost Famous(2000) Gosford Park(2001) Bandits(2001) The Royal Tenenbaums(2001) Spy Game(2001) Joe Dirt(2001) Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back(2001) A Mighty Wind (2003) The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou(2004) I Love You, Man(2009) Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy(2011) Bridge of Spies(2015)

Thirty Year Old Mulberry Field

With you on that. Oz Perkins can provide great atmosphere but I’ve yet to see him top or significantly improve upon his debut, “The Blackcoat’s Daughter”. I’m glad “Longlegs” & “The Monkey” did well though, hopefully he can just hone his stories into something that can match what he brings as a director.

ShōNuff3K

Sleepy Hollow for Halloween?

Darren Boyle

None of the above 🤷‍♂️

Philipp Roensch

Weapons is great, already love it after 2 watches. Barbarian should be a contender. I personally like NOPE more than Us, but it is still the best kind of creepy.

Thirty Year Old Mulberry Field

Lots of good picks, though I do think this list leans pretty hard on post 2000s flicks. I only say that because my horror theme for this year’s October has been older horror, think pre-slasher stuff. So I’m hoping “Rosemary’s Baby” pulls through. For future consideration: “Carnival of Souls” “Eraserhead” “Suspiria” (1977 & 2018) “Eyes Without a Face” “Creepshow” “Phantasm” “The Exorcist 3” (not necessary to see Exorcist 2) “Peeping Tom”

Rooster Aleution

I would've preferred a poll for 2000's horror films and then another poll for pre-1990's horror films.

Tall Paul

Romcom of Simone's choice should be an option

Ashton Lewis

Massive respect for including the 2018 Suspiria alongside the original. Some remakes are very much worth the watch, and that is one of them for sure

Mykel

That's a lot bangers on one list. 👌

Kaushik Sethunath

@Thirty Year Old Mulberry Field Need more people to mention it in comments tho :( I feel like they've mentioned taking the number of people recommending something in the past as a factor to determine poll candidates. So please, my goodman, fight the good fight with me!

Royal83

Going in as blind as u guys normally are Weapons is gonna be a great reaction!

Dustin Duvall

I love Nope. I think its one of the most beautifully shot movies ❤️

maikeru

I watched it a couple days ago, the film is good and disgusting^^ I had to mute the audio during the scene with the teeth and the kitchen desk or table 😖

maikeru

They should watch French Kiss, my favorite romcom

Dwight Scarn

Any chance yall gonna react to INTERVIEW with a VAMPIRE amc?? Both seasons are on NETFLIX

maikeru

I'd like to see their react to Boy Soldiers (1991). not the best but interesting

maikeru

I enjoyed Men (2022) quite a bit, the camera work is great, the experiments with sound, the unexpected story and message. A film not for everybody but kinda unique and there are some WILD, intense "no way this is happening" scenes = a film perfect for reactions.

Fly Ωhms

Haven't watched Weapons yet. I'd watch it with you guys.

Chase Schleich

Why are people voting for Weapons when they really should watch Barbarian first? Not a huge deal, but you'd think people would want them to go in order.

Royal83

I mean I don’t think they went in order on Tarantino but once they do watch Barbarian they’ll recognize how good Zach Cregger is in this genre.

BellaBlue

I've fought that battle w other directors...other films...and it is a losing battle..so I've trained myself to just not worry about it...

BellaBlue

excellent film not talked about enough

BellaBlue

Requests for your consideration: Horror or Thriller - Heretic (2024) - Companion (2025) - Strange Darling (2023) - Black Phone (2021) - Bodies Bodies Bodies (2022) - Fear Street Part 1 1994 (2021) - Fear Street Part 2 1978 (2021) - Fear Street Part 3 1666 (2021) Note: Should be watched part 1 to 3, not chronologically

Thirty Year Old Mulberry Field

Sure homie, I think I’ve been seeing you in the polls comments for a little while and I always try to show support. But I think G&S have mentioned they go less off repetition (at some point it gets added to the backlog) and more off support. Maybe someone can clarify to be sure what’s best.

Andrew

I haven't seen his other movies. I will check them out.

Strict9

It Follows should also show up at some point...:)

blerbaberpaterb

what order? the films arent related, weapons isnt a sequel.

Jay

recency bias is a little strong with the fellow patrons this time.

Charles Clover

Marketing doesn't really help for many of the films, either.

BellaBlue

some peeps want a director's filmography to be watched in order....I can understand it and think it is interesting to see the progression of their art...but it isn't a battle worth fighting....zero chance S&G are gonna try to take that type of thing into account... I do think it is worthwhile in certain cases even in no sequels when there are still even loose ties in a story or world... but that isn't the case here

Robinson vs. Parkinson's

Agreed! I'm just trying to avoid suggesting a library of film every time, lol 😆. Both of those are great though.

zak

I loved Longlegs, but i also understand why a lot of people bounced off it, not only is it the kind of film where you can't be on your phone at the same time, which seems increasingly rare, but you also need to be the type of person that can get really sucked in to a film, let your imagination fill in what's in the dark corner, or notice that Satan is just in a reflection for 1 second...I also enjoyed The Monkey because Perkins makes people explode in to blood every 5 minutes :P

Jeff I.

The order doesn't really matter, as the film are unrelated in terms of plot and characters. That said, Zach Cregger has honed his skills more since Barbarian and Weapons is a better movie for it, so I'd rather they do Weapons first if it was a choice.

Jeff I.

Yeah, Men (2022) went under the radar sadly, but it's really, really good!

Aaron Stinson

Most under appreciated Tim Burton film. I watch it every year

Aaron Stinson

I know y’all don’t do gaming vids anymore, but Silent Hill 2 is a must play.

Joe

I said it before in a previous post and I'll say it again now...Barbarian and Weapons double feature.

Wrwemi

Hi! I know these aren't as high profile as Weapons and Barbarian, but Talk to Me and Bring Her Back are infinitely better and scarier recent horror movies, the kind that stays with you after the credits. Hope to see them on a poll one day, and in the meantime cheers !

Ashton Lewis

Excellent film - Hopefully they will just decide to watch it someday, as unfortunately I don't think it will fare very well in a poll

Mike FromOz

Since it is the month of spookiness, could we please have "Ravenous" sometime this month? It is an amazing film with a brilliant cast, and veers between scary and hilarious. An absolutely top tier watch for Halloween!

Stephen

barbarian is awesome , havent seen weapons

Brandon Meng

If we get a chance to get away from horror/spooky genres this month, I think it's absolutely insane you guys have only done a single Wes Anderson film. The Royal Tenenbaums Rushmore Moonrise Kingdom Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou Fantastic Mr. Fox Isle of Dogs I can't speak to his more recent stuff but just a fantastic overall catalog Also, because you just did Rocky Horror Picture Show, Perks of Being a Wallflower is a MUST Cheers!

Dazzler & Em

really good list. Us is a really good film alongside Weapons. I personally think Barbarian is slightly better but weapons is certainly going to cause a strong reaction from G & S Longlegs is okay as is Sinister. Rosemary's baby is a classic.

Jeff I.

Talk To Me was very average to me. Some good aspects, but too much badly written dialogue and it felt like a horror movie specifically made for the average 16 year old (hard to explain). But I thought Bring Her Back was really good, and I'd love to see them do a reaction to that one as well.

Brad Lowry

I love the Canadian way you spelled “favorite”! BTW, Happy Thanksgiving, (belatedly)

mayhem74

Have a happy one, as we're still over a month away from Thanksgiving here 😁

Mikebdrx

Any one else excited about Sam Raimi's new movie Send Help? Just me? ok lol but seriously?

Jeff I.

I don't understand these "recency bias" comments. It's a really well made movie that happened to come out recently, and I'd rather them watch the better movie, regardless of when something came out. Also, the runner up which will presumably get watched in a couple of weeks is the oldest movie on the poll.

dansoddity

I know right?! Definitely think something will surpass it for me soon (still haven't seen One Battle After Another among a few) and I'm sooo intrigued by future releases like Hamnet and Sentimental Value - which I have a feeling those two will overthrow the top spot but we'll just have to see! And 67!! I've gotta get my numbers up! Do you have any recommendations from the top of your list?

Lionbarber

Aaaaah you have to watch Us and Longlegs! They are masterpieces! Also please include "The Changeling" (1980)

Rune Kristensen

Only on Netflix in the US, I think. They're not in the US. I had to use a VPN to watch it.

Martin

Weapons will make Simone poop herself.

OldBeardedGuyReacts

DUDE...you're gonna put Weapons, Longlegs, AND Barbarian all in one poll? And you expect me to only pick one?

Matt Blanchette

Where's "The Monkey"? They filmed that in Vancouver, just like "Longlegs"!

BoredLittleLady

I’ve only seen Barbarian and Sinister but I’m looking forward to Weapons since I didn’t see it in theaters.

Hamesque

I've never seen any movie ever but Us has the shortest title

Matt Blanchette

I kinda love he immediately reunited with an actress who basically came into his previous franchise film at the last minute, whom he wasn't initially involved with casting at ALL, and yet who enjoyed working with him so much that now we get this. :-D

Brandon Meng

Not even a fan of the genre but I love Rachel McAdams and the trailer to this movie looks SIIIICK

Dazzler & Em

Next poll should include the new evil dead films. these would scare and disgust G&S in equal measure. 🤢🤣🤣

Dazzler & Em

Also the recent Alien Earth tv show is really good.👁👁👁

Strict9

No, it isn't related to Megan. It's a great, serious horror movie about a 'stalker'...or maybe 'walker' is a better word...

Ashton Lewis

I've been trying to will this reaction into existence for a while now. One day!

Mr.Crowwave

"The Monkey" is my absolute favorite. Perfect dark comedy/horror with gory final destination like kills

Mr.Crowwave

Agreed. I don't dislike Weapons but I thought Barbarian was a better horror movie, far more tense. I think I just butted against the non linear storytelling of Weapons. But I still can't wait to watch it again and hear their guesses of what it's about 😂

Panda Animation

Is spooky month! Guys! I really reccomend The Witch, Midsommar, Bring her Back, the Remake of Suspiria and Last Night in Soho

droodly

Happy 3 YEAR anniversary of the gremlins reaction release everyone! Gremlins 2: The new batch, must be coming any day now, right? RIGHT?!?

Kyle B

If you need a horror/comedy pallet cleanser. I recommend The Final Girls(2015). Really has fun with slasher movies, and has a surprising emotional gut punch.

Ashton Lewis

Great list - I haven't actually seen Last Night in Soho though for some reason, but I'm very much with you on the rest!

Blqbrd

So pissed I missed my chance to campaign for Silent Hill. It might be my favorite of the 2000’s horror films

maikeru

best game ever, best score, epic

maikeru

and the original voices of course 👌 not the remake voice actors

maikeru

@Paul I hate that I know the twist 😔

maikeru

1408 is quite scary (a bit less after I watched it 2-3 times over the years) but still.. it‘s shot in a way and all the sudden shit, noises, visuals, creepy old man etc the whole vibe, you get goosebumps here and there, the silence.. waiting for creepy shit to happen etc

BlindPanda

two john Cusack movies you guys should watch are Runaway Jury and the movie Identity. you guys wont be disappointed!

Guts

Sinister is great