Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/5Fvi3fXAQ5 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/uVY7hR2mg3 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Joseph Kelley

Can’t wait for the inner light react, such a good episode.

Mike FromOz

If you're reading this Simone, thinking of you on the news of Dolly's passing. It's been a rough, rough day 😥

ChiefKC

Happy Star Trek Day!

Captain Kermit

George, without future knowledge, Hugh is a beloved Borg Character from this one episode. Star Trek is not the show to have horror space zombies, and never ever attempt to humanize them. Nonetheless, the Borg have been around since season 2, 4 years in real life. You and Simone have been binging, hence your name, so it feels quicker than it did in real world release.

Adam Morgan

The fact that you can refer to the Borg as "The Borg" makes them a race. A race is ultimately just an identifiable, defined group of things. Once it's classified and has a name/designation, it is a race. It doesn't even need to be humans or sapient beings: you can refer to types of sausage as races of sausage, or varieties of cabbage as races of cabbage. Regarding cosmic horror: it's hard to write new stories for cosmic horrors. Not impossible but difficult. There are only so many ways to incorporate a remorseless, faceless entity into a plot.

Matrim

They send Hugh back because he chooses to go back. He’d rather stay, but knowing that it would likely result in the Borg attacking his friends he chose to sacrifice what he wants.

gfixler

Goodbye, Geordie. I will try to remem–𝙿𝚁𝙾𝙶𝚁𝙰𝙼 𝙳𝙴𝙻𝙴𝚃𝙴𝙳

gfixler

My mom works at Dollywood. She was glad she didn't have work today. She said it's going to be really sad at the park, lots of crying.

R. Chang

George, your opinion about the Borg is present in the fandom, though I'd say that it's a minority opinion. And I hate to break this to you, but my experience is that it generally comes from the "Star Trek is too woke now" crowd. I think that most TNG fans were pretty on board with exploring this idea that even a cosmic horror could be humanized. When it aired, I loved I, Borg and I still think it's a great episode. The scene between Hugh and "Locutus" is top notch.

Matt O'Keefe

Not too long until George sees DS9.

Kat

I guess you could say they're not "falling" through the floor because falling requires gravity, and there's no gravity in space. There's no reason for them to fall "down" because there's no down in space. They could just as well fall "up". Of course this opens up a whole other can of worms, but my personal technobabble head canon is that the artificial gravity of the ship (in each floor?) keeps them in place and makes them able to move around. I think it's a fun episode anyway, if you suspend disbelief a bit. 😆

Matrim

Regarding Ro buying into being dead so fast. Something that you haven’t really seen much of yet is that the Bajorans are an intensely spiritual people, it’s part of what sustained them during the Cardassian occupation. You’ll get a much more thorough understanding when you get to DS9.

Tangerra

I feel like “I, Borg” is a very Star Trek answer to a cosmic horror. Regardless of the complexities involved, the Borg is a collective species and destroying them would be considered genocide. It is worth an argument that a lack of viable alternatives to self defense could potentially justify it, per example killing a single being powerful enough to destroy your civilization, but also being the last of its kind would be justifiable defense. However, the ethical problem here is that they proved that the individual components could be rehabilitated, which then makes the genocide unethical. The thing Picard says about individuality I never read as a plan or a wrap up, but more of a hope. And sending back, though not what Hugh preferred, was still his choice and if they made the decision for him that would conflict with the entire argument for individuality they made during the entire episode.

Andrew

For someone who is critical of the characterizations of the Ferengi and Romulans as being one note bad guys, I find it interesting that George is critical of this episode for adding some depth to the Borg. I thought that was what he wanted for the other species.

Jaaahn

i dont think he was being critical, i mean he specifically said that since nearly all the plots of star trek so far has been about humanizing aliens, a cosmic horror space zombie is actually the one thats out of the norm and he was excited about that. how you derived being critical from his excitement of what the show had presented to him prior to this so far is weird.

Dioskur

I *think* the problem with sending him back to kill his whole collective comes from it being a sneaky act. If it was just a super magic space laser weapon and the enterprise would fly into borg space, tell them to leave them alone and then would be attacked and had to use the super mega laser to defend itself and that way eradicated the borg it would feel ok. Because it would be active defence, not a collective knife in the back of 100 billion individuals edit: oh and it would have been a cool idea to ask the rest of humanity... seems a little egomanical to decide alone

Alan Pownall

If you watch TNG first there will be characters and locations you get introduced to in TNG rather than DS9 which would be a little weird, they also mention a few plot points from the first two episodes of DS9 in TNG. There is also something that happens in the 2nd season of DS9 that would get spoiled by something towards the end of season 7 of TNG. The films need to be watched in the correct place as there are spoilers there, although I imagine that is less of an issue. There is an easy to follow google doc which has all the episodes listed in release order but I don't think it would be the end of the world to finish TNG first; although breaking TNG up a bit might not be the worst idea.

Jaaahn

also, preferring a characterization while disliking the same when applied to something else is not as bizarre as you seem to think... everyone loves Picard as badass no non sense leader characterization but it doenst mean i will love it equally if the same traits are applied to any character. so him not liking the way Ferengi is written up to this point, which by the way is not some rare opinion, doesnt automatically mean he must also hate other singular purpose characterizations...

Bill

George is a victim of binge pacing with his questioning the Borg plot. His comment about there only being 4 episodes before they give them humanity is the tell. For most of us, it was 4 years marinating on the Borg and what they are, by the time we meet Hugh, and even 2 seasons since the Best of Both Worlds double episode where Picard is abducted. It didn't feel rushed in that context. EDIT: Also, in the Next Phase, there are all kind of issues with moving through walls. I mean, galaxies are moving, and objects within the galaxy are moving, so even a stationary Enterprise would be flying around the galactic core. I take this to mean that starships can actually come to a complete stop, and space is so large, that this doesn't make any noticeable difference in the hours or days they might be in the same spot. For the floors, I was thinking the artificial gravity is an exotic technology in every floor structure throughout the ship, and would work on phased objects, possibly on accident. But then I think about the walls holding in breathable air, and wonder how Geordi and Ro could breath non-phased oxygen - how would the alveoli in their lungs be able to interact with non-phased oxygen molecules to get into their blood stream? So it all falls apart upon further scrutiny, but nonetheless a fun episode!

SnabbKassa

I think the Federation should have had the debate on whether the HIppocratic oath applies to injured Borg and set a policy on it BEFORE beaming down into this situation.

ChiefKC

If I recall correctly, there is only one or two episodes of TNG that includes characters from DS9 and they occur late in the final season of TNG so it should't be any issue finishing of TNG then going to DS9.

dasgrove

The borg is much more like a cult that race. The members are indoctrinated and the hive mind reinforces the beliefs. Separated from the hive mind allows the personality of the individual to resurface. They are not zombies, they are not dead, they are controlled. They are victims. They don’t need to be killed, they need to be freed.

Jaaahn

what assumptions are those?

xeve

It's a culture not a race. It's culture forsably integrates parts of many other cultures and races. Edit, tbh even using the term race doesn't fit given its psuedo science history. Imo, species would be better.

Guts

I don't think Simone got that Paragon/Renegade joke. Simone must be reminded to play Mass Effect. NODDERS

Jaaahn

oh i did. and i didnt find anything he said to match your accusation. genuinely curious what he said that made you think so. edit: his original comment was that George is making false assumptions the show didnt present, became unhappy that the show isnt following his assumptions. so i asked him what assumptions he was referring to, he then told me to watch it myself and figure it out. thus my reply. im assuming as he was writing out the examples he realizes he didnt have a lot to go on and so deleted the comment in an attempt to make me the unreasonable one for asking what he meant.

Robert Gendron

Trying to avoid spoilers here, so being vague. There is nothing in TNG that relies on knowing what is going on in DS9, so you can put it off if you want to. I'd recommend interweaving DS9 when it started airing. There is a character from DS9 that crosses over in an episode of TNG and a small cameo from another. It will obviously reveal the basic setup of DS9 and the character that crosses over, but nothing beyond what's in the DS9 premiere. So it might be a good idea to watch the premiere when it would've aired. Its airdate was between episodes 11 and 12 of TNG, but your 2 episodes per week will have 11 & 12 in one week, so I'd recommend doing the two part DS9 premier after 6x12 if you want to see it's intro as fresh as possible. If you do watch it then, I'd recommend alternating 2 DS9 one week and 2 TNG the next until TNG finishes season 6, then finish season 1 of DS9. S2 DS9 and S7 TNG ran at the same time with the same episode count, so it's easy to keep altering from that point. It's a ways off, but Voyager premiered in the middle of DS9 season 3 so you may want to consider doing the same when that happens.

John Rose

I was 12, and the fact that the walked on the floors drove me nuts!!!.....at 12!!!

John Rose

I also use this as my head canon

Polecat21

love Geordi's debunking of Ro's ghost theory - are you saying my clothes and visor have an afterlife?

iFixSAN

So while, yes, you could just finish TNG, since the actual per-episode plot overlap between TNG/DS9 is minimial, The overarching ST-Universe has some thematic/geo-political (for lack of a better term) events that will play better watching them in air-order. I fear going 2 years deep then going back to the beginning, the connections will get lost or forgotten. Also, the timeline overlap of DS9 and VOY is much greater, (Basically DS9 only had 7 months where it was the only ST show) so if it were me, I would take the first 2 seasons of interleaving TNG+DS9 and see if you can make it work. If you find it's more trouble than it's worth, then just finish DS9 completely before hitting VOY. Aside from the series interweaving there's also the TNG movies which also touch on subjects pulled from DS9 (from an in-universe status perspective) and VOY (less-so, but still somewhat spoiler-y) so you need to track that watch-order as-well.

Thall

Should've killed Picard if all Borg are irredeemable evil! That's the dilemma isn't it? There are still people in there, under the technology that controls them. "Just kill them all" is an easy solution, for sure, and it might be the right one, but it HAS to be asked if you can't at least revert some of the tech-cancer in many of them.

TalynOne

Switching between DS9 and TNG is not that hard, because you only have to do it for two seasons. Also TNG is mostly episodic so it's not really required either way. You will get a few minor spoilers for DS9 eventually in TNG, but again they're really not that big of a deal. It is important you don't watch the TNG movies until they fit in chronological order during DS9's run because they mention/spoil DS9 story beats. As for Simone's questions we already saw the Enterprise "C", it's the one in Yesterday's Enterprise. And only the "D" is galaxy class.

gfixler

I did the overlapping episodes thing for all the Chicago shows. Hang on, I have to look this up... Okay, it started in 2012 with Chicago Fire, a drama about the adventures of Chicago firehouse. Part of the way through season 2, they spun up Chicago P.D., which included officers who had been on Fire many times, because fire and police deal with each other often. So then all of a sudden you have to start ping-ponging between those two shows every episode, and characters end up back and forth on both shows. Then, in the middle of Fire season 4, and P.D. season 3, just after Fire 04-05, and P.D. 03-07, they spooled up Chicago Med 01-01, with nurses and doctors you saw all through the other two shows all the time. Then, for reasons I don't recall, it doesn't just rotate all 3, but it's like P.D., Med, Fire, Fire, Med, P.D., Med, Fire, Fire, Fire, Med... Then, in the middle of that craziness, they did a crossover with Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, because it's in that universe, too, so it's P.D. 03-13, Fire 04-14, then SVU 17-14, and I think SVU people showed up in the other shows (or maybe just P.D.?), in the episodes leading up to the full crossover. Then, after Med 02-14, Fire 05-15, and P.D. 04-16, you had yet another show in the universe, Chicago Justice, and I gave up before that point, but it's probably full of people from the other 3 shows, too. There were more SVU crossovers, too. It was hard to watch it all. I had to create a giant text file of the 828 episodes, and consult the scrolls after every episode to see what I had to watch next. And then there was this spin-off, I guess? https://youtu.be/ehLQAshHRcs?t=8 Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUBYnswJUks Very related: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/skzjE83WT70

Guts

They never asked Hugh if he would want to destroy the Borg to protect Geordi. They did not want to force an individual to become a suicide bomber to wipe out a gigantic consciousness consisting of assimilated individuals (or to force a free individual to anything for that matter), which is different from destroying a deadly sickness. But what if the individual was willing? They never went there. There is also the question if Hugh was in a state where he could give informed consent or make any informed decision whatsoever. They ultimately also dodged the question of if the Borg are a race and if their genocide is morally acceptable even though the Borg collective is essentially just a hive mind parasite that controls individuals of other races, as this moral dilemma was usurped by the question of using an individual as a weapon. Are the Borg a race or a group of mind-controlled individuals and is the collective in itself a life form, and how would that change our moral stance? Are assimilated individuals not individual lifeforms anymore? Is a wasp taken over by a parasite still a wasp while under its control even if it could theoretically be freed of said control? And at what point do we just say "to hell with morals" in a last ditch effort to save ourselves and our civilization? Are we willing to ride our moral high ground straight into extinction? And what if we consider that it might be too late at that point? Cool episode but it leaves us hanging, although for good reason. They didn't want to destroy the Borg or ruin Picard's moral superiority for future episodes.

xeve

They aren't a singular species, there is no such thing as a colliective species unless one completely redefines species meaning. They are themselves a genocidal culture. That individuals maybe rehabilitated does make for interesting discussions, the Borg themselves are an example of the emergant property principal where the whole is greater than the some of its parts (at this point in the story).

R_Van_S

As for the Enterprise registry number, the TOS Enterprise was "NCC-1701; no bloody A, B, C, or D."

Mastervodo

What did Simone do to piss off some pirates? IYKYK.

Pearl Jam

I rationalize the ‘not phasing through the floor’ with gravity. Gravity still has an effect on them when phased, so I attribute it to them just being pulled toward the ships gravity plating as normal. Perfect rational, no, but enough to give it a pass in my mind.

PJ

I came here just to look for this comment :) I've waited five season, I can wait one more week.

mpd

Tempted to subscribe to the shout out tier with the name "Incorporeal"

xeve

I don't agree with imprinting today's conflicts onto people's opinions rooted 30 plus years ago. To get into more details would get into spoilers So I'll avoid that. I will say there's a difference in retconning and world building and for me, this episode falls into world building the Borg.

John Miller

You started talking about DS9. First, no spoilers here. DS9 and TNG exist at the same time. There are direct crossover episodes, including to a certain extent, the very first episode. And then after some time, there's a pretty significant crossover. What you could do is, rather than watching 2 episodes of TNG each week, watch one TNG and one DS9.

DesolationEntertained

There's quite a bit of rudimentary science that makes trouble in the plot. Phase ghosts can see each other, meaning light is being reflected, but light reflected by phase ghosts is visible only to other phase ghosts, and non-phase ghosts would see that light go unreflected? Otherwise they would cast a visible shadow. They can hear each other, which means their vocal chords are vibrating air, and that vibrating air affects other air, and ultimately each other's eardrums, but that same vibrating air doesn't affect other eardrums. Edit to add: I just had to mention, these same kinds of issues come up whenever someone is talking about ghosts.

Paul Peavler

I agree with this. It’s not even really two full seasons, DS9 doesn’t start until almost halfway through season 6 of TNG and season 1 is only 20 episodes. And you really should delay the viewing of the TNG movies until they’re in the proper air date order with DS9 because they do spoil several DS9 plot points and character beats. Jen Murray did TNG and DS9 concurrently and it was a really cool experience IMO and wasn’t too difficult to manage. She decided not to watch Voyager concurrently and I think that works out just fine considering there’s even less overlap between DS9 and Voyager and the TNG movies. But I really think watching DS9 and TNG together makes sense, more for the impacts on DS9 than the other way around. Like there are a few times where a story line is started in TNG and then DS9 picks it up and expands on it the next week, so if you delay watching DS9, it’s not that anything is going to get spoiled or be confusing, but it won’t have the same impact as if you watch them back-to-back as they happened in real life.

funky weapon

Finish TNG and then go to DS9. The two shows aren't really as connected as you're thinking. Yes they're happening at the same time but they cover different quadrants of the galaxy. It's not like a comic book event where a story begins in TNG and wraps up in DS9. it's hard to describe without spoilers so I'll just say DS9 is going for its own unique vibe separate from TNG. Also if I woke up and no one could see or hear me and I could walk through walls, I'm not sure "holy shit I'm a ghost" isnt a logical conclusion. And theres an arthouse indie movie called a ghost story that answers your question about whether or not a ghost can become homeless if their haunt is destroyed. It's a Casey Affleck movie and it's pretty good.

Monica Alarcon

Well since you insisted on release order and experience it as we experienced it then yes, follow release order... Maybe not episode by episode. Ds9 started mid season when TNG was in its 6th season. I vote for finishing season 6 of TNG then watch the first season of DS9. Then alternate between the two and keep doing that for Voyager as well. Voyager started mid season through DS9's 3rd season...

John Miller

I never had an issue with that. I chalked it up to how gravity is generated on the ships. Remember, each deck would have it's own artificial gravity generation. so the floor is not the same as a wall.

Sven Ketelhut

USS Enterprise NCC-1701 Constitution / Constitution II class: TOS & Star Trek movies I, II, III, launched 2245, destroyed 2285) USS Enterprise NCC-1701-A,Constitution II class: Movies V & VI (retired 2294) USS Enterprise NCC-1701-B: not seen (yet?) USS Enterprise NCC-1701-C, Ambassador class: Seen in TNG (The ship that came through time and Tasha went with them, destroyed 2344) USS Enterprise NCC-1701-D, Galaxy class: TNG (obviously, launched 2363) I would watch TNG and DS9 parallel, mostly because the first two seasons of DS9 are a bit hard to get through (although in the end it is the best TV-show out of all the Star Trek shows, not the best Star Trek, but the best TV)

Adam Morgan

Culture, species etc are all synonyms for race. Race is an amazingly flexible word that just means "type of thing". Take Worf, for example: his race is Klingon, and Belarusian, and Federation, and Starfleet officer, and Security officer, etc. All viable uses of the word race. (For the sake of completeness, he's also of the race of Mogh and the race of Rozhenko, but that's a slightly different definition of race.)

Tangerra

I agree the term species isn’t accurate with the definition we currently use, but we don’t specifically have a term for it because it doesn’t exist. They possess a single mind, making them part of a single organism, they’ve even used the idea that they can’t voluntarily disconnect any individual member from the collective. The Borg is actually somewhat analogous to Data, being a race of 1, or 2 depending on if Lore is alive at the time. We don’t count Data as being a collection of parts and programming, which to the Borg thats all an individual would count for. I was just using the best language I’ve got to describe the context. Apologies for being confusing.

xeve

I disagree there is a scientific definition for species rooted in lifeforms being able to produce viable offspring with one another. That is distinct from what cultures a species produce. Race is psuedo science rooted in racism.

REDR58

🎵

REDR58

George says *finally* a Borg episode. TNG has a nice balance of Borg episodes. Just enough to keep them interesting.

Opti_Frog

Watching in release order would fix that automatically. Most weeks it would be one TNG and one DS9, and sometimes two TNG or DS9.

Craig Brennan

Simone and George. The way to do the franchise going forward once DS9 starts is in release date order between both shows including the movies. But this is also because once TNG is finished Star Trek: Voyager does Launch and then DS9 overlap in Universe.

Thall

I'd also vote TNG finished, then DS9, aside from movies maybe. There is overlap, but it's better to actually be focused on DS9 VeERY MINOR SPOILER because it is ... it's less week per week storyline if that makes sense?

Michael Daw

It's a good thing George didn't read the title in advance: "They bring a borg on the ship and do a whole bunch of stuff and have moral quandaries and let it go". Would have been big spoilers. One thing a person watching a show like this has to remember is that there are only a certain number of characters that can be used to express ideas. Crusher may sound naive here, but SOMEONE has to play that part.

fforw

I think what gets lost in "I, Borg" a lot, both on screen and off screen, is that it is not just about the concern for Hughs life, which is of course Beverly's primary concern. She swore an oath about that. The bigger issue is the prime directive and general attitude of the Federation. Of course, the Borg are dangerous and there has to be some care for that danger, but they are not very different to very smart lions. Of course we would protect us from them, but that most certainly does not include eradicating them.

xeve

It's hard to discuss without getting into spoilers, but I'll try it this way. I've heard the portuguese man-o-war in a science class described as a colony who's cellular members sacrifice procreation for specialization and the greater good of the colony. I've also heard of interconnected Aspen trees being a singular organism and in the same vain a largly underground fungus is the largest organism. So, what are the Borg is an interesting discussion at this point.

Tangerra

Agreed, from an actual biological standpoint, describing the Borg is complicated at best. And yeah, I know the future stuff does change the conversation a bit, but I’m trying to stick to what the characters (and George) know about them for now.

Tangerra

Yeah, they just wanted to do a “what if our characters were ghosts” episode.

Tangerra

If I had an opinion, it would be to at least watch DS9 season 1 before TNG season 7. I think that would resolve a lot of the interconnectedness nicely without being TOO confusing.

Kev Longley

I'm not going to argue that the decision to destroy the Borg is wrong, but Beverly wanting it to be clear that what they were talking about is genocide/destroying them all is an important point, not naivety. If our heroes are to carry out this plan, they better be damn sure they know exactly what it is they're doing and why they're doing it. They owe it to themselves to consider all the implications of what they're doing before they make the decision. And its important to note that this seems to be a unilateral decision by Picard, rather than something that the Federation has considered and ruled on. And Picard, being someone hurt by the Borg, is the last person who should be making that decision. We wouldn't even consider wiping out mosquitoes if we could without carefully considering all the relevancies. Whether they are truly a race or not isn't relevant, we're talking about exterminating billions or trillions of humanoid beings. We can't just boil it down to "curing space cancer".

WastedPo

Sigh. I can already tell by the comments that two of the best episodes of TNG are going to be nitpicked to death.

Michael Daw

That dude walks by Ensign Ro's body and is like "Oh that's just Ro passed out on the floor again. No big deal." Pretty great ep. Great Sci-Fi stuff. Having effectively ubiquitous knowledge of Star Trek, it's quite jarring to hear George postulate about DS9 from a place of total inexperience.

funky weapon

you're conveniently sweeping aside the fact that the Borg is not just some foreign culture who have disagreements with the Federation about trade. the Borg is actively attempting to assimilate all life in the galaxy. if they succeed they will have committed atrocities on a scale beyond human comprehension. weighing life itself against one alleged culture is not fair to the culture. Hugh is a nice boy, sure, but that doesn't change what the Borg is and what they're trying to do. they're an existential threat to life itself.

funky weapon

I think the real problem is the writing. she doesn't sound naive, she sounds sanctimonious.

Blackbaldrik

First episode: I am a HUGE fan of The Borg, specifically because they are a terrifying cosmic horror. But I also don't think that's at all diminishing it by humanizing them. In a way, it makes it worse. Zombies are easy, they're already dead. Mow them down left and right, wipe them all out, who cares. But The Borg are still living breathing sentient beings forever trapped in the collective. It is "Eldritch" in almost as true a sense as you can get. An apathetic intelligence beyond imagining is twisting everything it touches, turning normal people to its purpose. And this episode is easily one of my top-3 in no small part because of that new understanding. (Also, Hugh is adorable.) The Federation and its deeply ingrained ideals, is now faced with the moral issue that this unimaginable horror that wants to absorb them, is actually billions, maybe trillions, maybe even tens or hundreds of trillions of people, that all could potentially be saved under the right circumstances. And it's no longer so easy to strap a bomb to one of them and say, "Off you go, to blow up literally countless living people, and who knows how many last remnants of assimilated species and cultures!"

Drew Acheson

I feel like George is going to love Voyager...eventurally.

REDR58

Crap, just accidentally deleted my comment but anyway… I’m going to assume that all Starfleet personnel have standing orders to disable or destroy any Borg they encounter if it is reasonably safe to do so. But *YES* Picard making a decision as he initially did without consulting Starfleet and by extension the Federation seems odd to say the least.

REDR58

I agree with this.

REDR58

Yes “A Ghost Story” (2017) with Affleck and Rooney Mara is *excellent* and should be watched here.

REDR58

Part of the problem is that the story is introducing a *lot* of interesting questions in a very short amount of time. This is something I think would be better addressed over several episodes.

REDR58

The best answer to that is “magic” or “a wizard did it.”

Thall

I was just waiting for someone to do that, considering season 6 is on the horizon

Alexander Whitehill

You have already seen something of Klingon "funerals" (I know that's not right... but definitely in regards to their views on death). Season 1 Episonde 9 Heart of Glory Korris: It is only an empty shell now. Please treat it as such.

Opti_Frog

Okay, so, I, Borg. I completely understand what George is talking about. There is something nice about a villain that is pure hostility, pure evil (from our perspective) and unredeemable. But at the same time, i'm not convinced that this episode takes that away from the Borg as an enemy. What is does is provides us with the information that despite being a collective hive mind, every Borg has had their individuality suppressed rather than removed.

Geoff Richards

Note that just as he's beaming up, Hugh turns to look at Geordi. It's clear that he hasn't entirely lost his new individuality, at least not instantly.

REDR58

I, Borg Once again, using force fields as the sole barrier to a prisoner’s cell is beyond absurd. Why are there access panels of any kind in these cells? And they just let a *Borg* plug into it??? Crusher says Hugh’s cybernetic eye “is like some kind of holographic imaging system.” Hugh’s eyepiece prop is not a visual effect but rather a physical, flat holoGRAM inside of the eyepiece prop. It’s just like this: https://youtu.be/0ics3RVSn9w?is=LD4v-9gjipSMhLsq So Picard justifies animal experimentation then! Savage.

John

Simone's eyes when George was talking about Ro and Geordi being fused... 🤣🤣🤣

REDR58

I wish I liked Voyager. I was so excited when it premiered back in the day. All the actors are great. But the show is just… I couldn’t even finish the series.

Michael Daw

It does go pretty far, yeah.

Drew Acheson

It does get better in the later seasons. It’s a little cringy at first. But worth seeing through.

Lessiarty

I can think of another beloved Borg character... If 'beloved' is the right word...

Lessiarty

In TOS, in the 1960s, the Klingons were basically an allegory of the Russians and the Romulans were the Chinese.

REDR58

TCL, George? In my day it was /idclip or /noclip (depending on the game).

John

In my head canon, each deck has a "gravity" plate on the floor and on the ceiling. Since they can't create actual gravity without a corresponding amount of mass, they use artificial "gravitons" that flow from the upper plating to the lower plating, moving all mass between the plates (phased or not) along with them.

Lessiarty

Boomer here: Today's opinions aren't as different or evolved as you might think. 30+ years ago there were people who called TOS "hippie" or "peacenik" rather than "woke," but the rationale (?) was pretty much the same. Tomayto, tomahto.

John

Geordi and Ro should have gone to their own respective quarters to make the chroniton fields. SOMEBODY would have figured out that it was them doing it.

Brandon

Personally, I see no benefit in adhering to a strict "release order" policy. Do what you think is best, guys. There are, I think, 3 episodes of TNG that have DS9 cast members in them, but they are not full cross-overs with that series. You will definitely not be lost if you haven't seen DS9 when you get to those episodes of TNG. Just think of it like when some random Starfleet character appears as a guest star in a single episode. The writers discovered a problem with the Borg being a nearly unstoppable enemy. It's extremely difficult to write for them. 'I, Borg' is such an important episode because it starts to make them more than that, even though they are an enemy. If Picard can be freed from the collective, anyone can. He was only Borg for a few days so he hadn't yet come to fully rely on his cybernetic implants. A long-time Borg can be freed, but the implants can't be removed without killing them, so their biology has been forever changed regardless. Frankly, I think it's weird to be debating the ethics of genocide in 2026, even in relation to fiction.

eZTarg8

There's zero major narrative storylines crossing over from TNG and DS9 back and forth. Like one episode needing to be directly followed by an episode in the other show... at least in any ways that spoil any of either show's storylines. There's world building that crosses over, or is mentioned, but not in any stories that require seeing the other show to follow what's happening. Watching all of TNG and then moving to DS9 shouldn't affect your experience beyond a few "oh, that's so and so character from TNG, and they're here now" and retroactively lining up the timelines, and going "oh, cool, now, moving on with the current story" lol

erosennin

George, just imagine you have billions of voices in your head every second of every day of your life forever... then someone pulls the plug and you hear nothing. You don't think that would have a pretty immediate effect?

dc

Agreed -- TNG Season 7 is a little rough since a lot of the better writers went off to work on DS9, and they were kind of out of ideas. I would love if they went in true broadcast order; it gets us to DS9 a bit sooner, and there really is a fair bit of overlap that broadcast order will enhance. I definitely understand if it's too much trouble though.

REDR58

I vote you start DS9 at the conclusion of season 6 of TNG, then wrap up season 1 of DS9, move onto season 7 of TNG, then season 2 of DS9.

Michael Kemmet

For Simone: Appearances: 1701 - TOS, TAS, refitted for ST 1,2, destroyed in 3 1701-A - ST 4,5,6 (copy of 1701 refit) 1701-B - ??? so far 1701-C - the time-traveling one that Tasha went on in TNG 1701-D - TNG Class names: 1701 - Constitution and Constitution-refit 1701-A - Constitution-refit 1701-B - ??? so far 1701-C - Ambassador 1701-D - Galaxy

Opti_Frog

The actors, yes. The characters? Zzz.... 😐

erosennin

"The borg just fly around in cubes assimilating unconsenting individuals." Yes.. so did the vikings. That's why they're all tall and relateively beautiful for the standards of the region. That doesn't make them NOT a species. What we know so far of the borg is very little, I think the show hasn't revealed anything about their origin. Maybe Q has when he introduced them, I'm not a 100% sure, but if so, Q can not be trusted anyway.

TechJJ

I have a bone to pick with Simone's displeasure of Beverly at the beginning. First of all, there is no need to bring in future Borg encounters to make Beverly's actions believable. Recall from the two-parter "Best of Both Worlds": 1. Beverly is the first to want to save Picard after being assimilated. She sense Picard inside Locutus 2. When Picard got disconnected from the collective, his individuality was returning At some point, it's established that Borg assimilates from beings from other worlds. So definition of "race" is probably incorrect, but like a "nation of (forced) immigrants". I'm a bit surprised that this did not dawn on Simone - that most Borgs are forced into doing things they DON'T want to do (Remember the "Family" episode?). So the "Borg is Evil" really should not mean all the individual soldiers forced, but the "erase of individuality" and taking order from the "collective" involuntarily to assimilate others AGAINST THEIR WILL. Now to this "I, Borg" episode: 1. Beverly was the first to examine an d look at "3 of 5" in the face. She sees through the Borg armor an assimilated boy. This is NO different than seeing "Picard still in there" with Locutus. 2. Beverly also know the boy is disconnected from the collective, so Picard is already a proof that the boy can be saved to us the audience who followed the Borg encounters up to now. Somehow, the writers conveniently "forgot" about this \and have all characters starts\ out against against saving the disconnected Borg. 3. Picard is definitely the biggest hypocrite at the beginning, since he was SAVED by disconnecting from collective. The boy could've too. But writers did put in a line for Picard to express he didn't want to talk to the Borg because... In summary, Beverly's view is consistent whether trying to save Picard or Hugh. Her character portrays genuine and relentless caring of living regardless of political affiliations, consistent of those that bravely participate in "Doctors without Borders".

TechJJ

Yep! I just post my piece to counter Simone's judgement on Beverly's at the beginning.

REDR58

The “Constitution-refit” are also called “Constitution II” class. The TOS TV series Constitution class (Enterprise and others) were called “cruisers” which in comparable modern naval terms is the largest ship in a fleet other than aircraft carriers. The TOS movie Constitution-refit/Constitution II are called “heavy cruisers” and I assume the difference between “cruisers” and “heavy cruisers” is something like a lesser or greater mass or the sorts of weapons it carries. Real naval cruisers are meant to operate independently which is exactly how we see the various USS Enterprise and similar other ships in TOS and TNG used. They rarely operate with other ships (other than wartime). The NCC-1701-C Enterprise/Ambassador Class vessel that we see in “Yesterday’s Enterprise” with Tasha going back in time was also designated a “heavy cruiser.” The NCC-1701-D Enterprise/Galaxy class vessels also seem to be designated “heavy cruisers” but I cannot recall a reference to that as such in TNG?

Michael Kemmet

At the rate you guys are going, you're going to have to figure out how you're going to do the TNG/DS9 overlap in the next month. DS9 101-102 aired between TNG 611 and 612. So October 14 will be the day your decision takes effect for us viewers. To sum up your options assuming 2 episodes per week: 1. One episode of TNG + one episode of DS9 per week starting with TNG 611 + DS9 101. 2. Two episodes of TNG one week and two episodes of DS9 the following week. TNG 611/612, DS9 101/102, TNG 613/614, etc. 3. Finish all of TNG season 6, then DS9 season 1, then TNG season 7, etc, 4. Finish all of TNG, then start DS9, then start Voy. I don't have much in the way of suggestions. There are positives and negatives to every option. The only one I probably wouldn't suggest is option 4 for reasons down the road. Option 1 is the most accurate to the way we watched it in 1993-94, but it will make the last 1.5 seasons of TNG drag out twice as long. Same with option 2. And option 1 is the most complicated for you guys to film. Also remember that you'll be facing the same decision with DS9 and Voyager almost immediately. There was only a 6 month downtime between the end of TNG and the start of Voy. And all three series progress in the same timeline. The events of one series are happening at the same time as the events in the other series in real time. This may or may not have ramifications at times. (The TNG 6 / DS9 1 and DS9 3 / Voy 1 overlaps are a little more complicated than the other seasons as DS9 1 and Voy 1 started halfway through the year and have fewer episodes than the other seasons. But it's better to set your plan based on all the other seasons and then adapt the two atypical overlaps to whatever pattern you've decided on.) Good luck with your choice. :)

REDR58

Oh and in “Yesterday’s Enterprise” Yar described the then-alternate timeline USS Enterprise NCC-1701D as a “Galaxy-class battleship” which is a little odd because “battleships” did not really operate alone historically and almost always have escorting vessels. The only time I can think of a US battleship operating somewhat on its own was the Battleship New Jersey during the Vietnam War when it was used to shell North Vietnam and it faced no real opposition of any kind in terms of enemy naval forces.

StonyD

I, Borg is probably my least favorite TNG episode of the entire franchise. I have no sympathy for the Borg, and I think Hugh does more to hurt the Borg concept overall than anything else. When you create an amazing enemy like that, you don't turn around and try to make them touchy-feely or "humanize" them. It ruins the concept the same as the current modern deconstruction of western cultural heroes hurts them.

Jeffrey Mitchell

I am also going to vote for interleaving TNG and DS9. That matches the experience many of us had 30 years ago and there are a few crossover things as others have mentioned. But, also as others have mentioned, there aren't any episodes where it starts in one show and ends in the other, so if you don't interleave, it isn't the end of the world. But you will be jumping back a year and a half. There are some political situations that you'll be introduced to in TNG before they were originally introduced in DS9. Some people have mentioned interleaving one season and not the other and other some what more convoluted options, but air date order is easiest and if you mess up a week here or there it won't matter much and you can just get back on track. Doing the movies in the right places, like you did with the TOS movies, is definitely more important. Though being a bit off shouldn't matter there either. Just not a whole season early or late.

DanTurismo

There is actual crossover in when TNG was airing and when DS9 first aired. DS9 started around the middle of season 6 of TNG (between episodes 11 and 12). In fact there's a crossover two-parter episode of TNG (season 6, episodes 16 and 17). I think it'd be a shame if that's your first introduction to DS9 sets, cast, etc. You might want to skip those episodes, or at least watch the DS9 pilot before those episodes.

DanTurismo

Agree with this. Unfortunately no way to explain how they breathe without the air being phased.

DanTurismo

I never minded the Hugh stuff because it can be explained away by him being cut off from the collective, but (hopefully without spoiling anything), I always hated how they dealt with the Borg after this. The Borg are interesting and scary because they're unlike any other threat the crew has faced. Like George says, it leans into cosmic horror. The way they took them after this, felt like they were willing to undercut what made them interesting or unique, to try to make it more accessible or understandable to a general audience.

Hammond of Texas

George, people might not attend your funeral not because they don't like you - but - maybe they are having a hard time dealing with a death and can't face it head-on.

Runes N Raccoons

I love Hugh, but like George, I was annoyed with Beverly. Claiming that the Federation wasn't at war with the Borg after they attacked Earth was kind of ridiculous. Especially after all of the species that the Borg was directly responsible for wiping out, including Guinan's species (which is the entire reason why she appeared in this episode).

Ryan Alexander

Don't finish TNG first, after season 5 go to DS9 season 1, then TNG S6, DS9 S2, TNG S7. Otherwise when you get to DS9 it'll feel like you're jumping back in time, and not in a good way

REDR58

It’s just simpler to watch DS9 season 1 after TNG season 6 instead of skipping or bouncing around.

REDR58

While I find the overall usage of the Borg in TNG perfectly fine, they are less interesting the more of them we see in later series.

Ian Tellam

This is how I presumed they would do it, and makes most sense to me.

Jimazoid

I would highly suggest speaking with Jen Murray about how she dealt with TNG/DS9 overlapping. She did it well: watching them in release date order. It worked out well I thought.

REDR58

The Next Phase Yeah, Ro being fused with Geordi would be an absurd, stupid idea that I would never want to see on screen. Joycelyn Robinson who plays “Gates” (uncredited) who is usually seen at the helm on the bridge (she was there in “I, Borg”) is eating dinner in her quarters with a male companion when Ro and the Romulan run through. She looks a little annoyed when her guy friend gets up to answer the door when Data shows up. George, regarding the Romulans, you saw the two episodes with Spock where a number of Romulan civilians wanted to have friendlier relations with Vulcan (and presumably the Federation). So it’s mostly civilians, but there was also the Romulan who came around to assist Geordi when they were both stranded alone and then the defector Romulan Admiral. Geordi said he and Ro hadn’t eaten in 2 days. I presume they continued to make use of their normal restroom facilities but didn’t “dephrase” their waste after coming back to normal.

Patrick - Excelsior

Hugh had to return because if he didn't the borg would keep going deeper into Federation space to find him. Whereas if he returned they would just turn around and leave. You were discusing something when this was explained. Its why Hugh in the end said while he wanted to stay, he couldn't because in doing so, he would endanger his friends.

Mike FromOz

And today Tim Curry was taken away 😥 I'm not ok 😢💔

Cory Garron

It's probably trillions, if not hundreds of trillions.

Cory Garron

I vote release order as well, for what it's worth.

Simone's Coconut Squire

Exactly. There really is no Borg “species”. Every Borg is a former individual of some other race who has been assimilated. And at this point in the timeline, you’ve “UnBorged” Picard, so why not others?

Angzarr

Belusted? But seriously, I think that character is actually beloved, for many qualities other than the obvious.

Peter K

George, you got to be patient about the Borg, they take their time dishing out what they are and one series that is far away for you guys now really delves deep into them...I think in the long run, and I'm talking several years (yikes), you will get plenty of answers. Personally, until this episode the Borg were pretty black and white, this brought in a gray area...because the collective is bad, but maybe not the actual captured entities that comprise them. Are you due for another film soon? You got to get past Generations and get to First Contact...one of the best, up there with Khan.

Michael M.

That would be my recommendation, if not for the season-bridging two-parters of TNG

Michael M.

I think you can watch the series sequentially. Movie-wise, I would hold off on Star Trek VIII, until you've watched some episodes of Voyager. and Star Trek X, until you've finished Voyager

MacGuffinStuff

"Abandon All Physics, Ye Who Enter This Episode", but it was still a fun episode "The Next Phase", of course I'm always happy to see Michelle Forbes. I also saw the downsides of being incorporeal, and gravity wasn't even one of them, I just accept that most SciFi movies and shows NEVER bother to explain how there's gravity, maybe Star Trek has, I just don't know (edit: gravity plating and gravitron fields, okay now I know), but it's standard suspension of disbelief. "I Borg" I thought should have a comma (edi: maybe add a period every now and again with these run on sentences), like "I, Robot" (Asimov book not Will Smith movie that done Tudyk a little dirty in the marketing), assumed it was a cool reference by the show. Simone handled George's questions about DS9 with grease and a plum, I mean grace and aplomb, shut up about that George till you watch it. SPOILER (ISH): I would've said something like "I'll tell you what Deep Space 9 isn't, it's no moon." Sorry, had to.

Thall

I don't agree with that. The Borg, to me, are absolutely their own species, although a parasitic one. That goes back to Measure of a Man and Data. "Borg" might well be its own conciousness that is unable to interact without bodies to assimilate, that doesn't make it not a species. So far it hasn't been proven conclusively that Borg has the same level of conciousness as Data, yea, but lack of knowledge is not proof of anything. To be the Borg are somewhat closer to the Goa'uld from Stargate.

Marcus Hicks

My vote, for what it is worth, would be one of two approaches-once you catch up to DS9. Option 1 is to do 1 epsiode of TNG & 1 episode of DS9 per week. Option 2 is that, as soon as another current TV series you are watching comes to an end, set that day aside for 2 episodes of DS9. I know Jen Murray was watching TNG & DS9 concurrently when they overlapped, so maybe you could ask her how she managed it 😉.

Robert Mendoza

I love Borg so much! i realized I don't love it when Star Trek focuses a lot on action but thoughtful, cozy episodes that give you something to think about are my jam. It's just a series of conversations between different characters. It must have been an interesting acting challenge to play Hugh as alien and other but also innocent and uncertain. Geordi, able to be best friends with an android and a cyborg but he can't talk to women. I love it that even though friendship is so new to Hugh he is very loyal right away. The tragedy and the horror is that even though Hugh wanted to stay on The Enterprise he essentially sacrificed himself by going back to the collective to keep The Enterprise safe. George asked why is Hugh so quick to become an individual. So the episode can happen. More seriously I would think Hugh hasn't been assimilated for very long or maybe he had a very individualistic personality pre assimilation and some part of him was only too happy to respond and become an individual again. If you watch all of TNG before DS9 there are no spoilers unless you count seeing a couple of DS9 characters briefly a spoiler. Thestories should all make perfect sense however you choose to watch them.

Cc Decc

George, i got your back on the Borg thing. Its omnipresent in genre writing, especially among Johnny come lately hack writers, to take each and every pure and terrifying thing out there and try to make it banal and humanized. They have feelings too (even now, orcs in Rings of Failure. Ick.). And no...sometimes its better when they do not. That is why we fear them. When you give them human traits, they just become humans in makeup (although in a future Star Trek series there is one "human in makeup Borg" that absolutely is...a pleasure to watch. :) But do not fear, despite them already wavering and starting to erode their own monster, the Borg will have one more memorable glorious cosmic horror appearance in one of the best remaining moments in the entire Star Trek franchise.

Blackbaldrik

When it comes to phasing in pretty much any show ever, you kinda gotta just not think about it too hard. xD

Cc Decc

Technically true...but that's a lot of years. That's the thing about watching Star Trek in this sort of format, rather than monster weekend binges or whatnot. There were 176 episodes of DS9, 172 episodes of Voyager, 98 more of Enterprise. Just to get to the end of Voyager at 2 episodes a week would take 176+172 = 348 /2 weeks = 174 weeks, or roughly 3 1/4 years. So they'd be scheduling the later Star Trek movies for 2030 or so.

punterjoe

You've already seen the TOS crew films. The A came along at the end of 4, the Enterprise C you saw in Yesterday's Enterprise. I don't want to spoil anything, but you will encounter the Enterprise B in the TNG films. I don't think that really spills any beans. Hope you're enjoying season 5. They've come a long way from that awkward first season, eh?

punterjoe

Maybe we can take a lesson from The Next Phase and treat this as a celebration of an extraordinary life.

punterjoe

Trek isn't too dogmatic about alien cultures. If you recall from TOS, the Romulans were treated as rather noble and dutiful. Later Trek rebranded them as duplicitous. Kind of the way the Klingons transformed far more than physically from TOS to later Trek. TOS Klingons felt more like Jack Sparrow type pirates. At least to me.

punterjoe

Yeah, someone in the writer's room was a big Patrick Swayze fan. I think they missed a golden opportunity not making Guinan the only one who could see them. 😏

punterjoe

Sure, why not? Any story like this calls for major suspension of disbelief. If they can't interact with the "in phase" world, and Geordi complains that he hasn't eaten in days, how do their lungs process in-phase oxygen? Story lines like this just require the viewer to "go with it" and leave their rational brain aside. Which is fine. It was an enjoyable storyline.

Elvenwitch

Before I begin, I fully understand the HUGE difference between the Borg and the story I am about to relate. I am also not making an excuse for my grandfather's bigotry. This comment is to point out why I had the reaction I did the first time I saw this episode. When I was a young man, growing up in the early 80s, my grandfather was like most of his generation, a bit bigoted. For him, he had an issue with those of asian decent. It was never loud or even direct to anyone, but while driving or watching a movie, he would use a slur. As a child, I didn't know that what this man I loved was saying was bad, but as I grew, it became more evident. I wondered how this grouchy but loving man who took me fishing and made me feel better than most in my family could lump entire groups of people together for hate. A few years after I started to feel uncomfortable every time he would say something, I learned in greater depth about his service during WWII. He served in the Pacific in the Navy and was present at the Battle of Okinawa and others. I began to see that his bigotry was tied to his PTSD and was exacerbated by the extreme Pacific propaganda and the instilled fear of others. A few more years later, I saw this episode at 15; it felt like I was watching something related to this part of my life. Picard's anger felt like my grandfather's, and that also colored my view of this episode and later First Contact. While I never got a Picardesque turnaround before his death, I did get one moment of openness from him that forever made my memories of him so much brighter. At 18, I joined the Air Force, and after basic and tech training, I was stationed on the island of Okinawa. On leave, I brought pictures (yes, physical pictures) and showed him the island that we both had ties to. To my astonishment, he had a tear in his eye. Later, he told me that during the battle, so much white phosphorus was used that the entirety of the island was on fire- people, trees, bushes, even the water was on fire- and it looked like what he thought hell would look like. He thought that nothing would ever grow there again. By the end of the story, I realized that somehow his brain used his bigotry as a messed-up coping mechanism against the horrors he had helped to perpetrate. This does not make up for his behavior or beliefs, but as a grandchild looking to love his grandfather, this was as close I would get to understanding his closed and grouchy mind. He died a few years later, and so this episode will always remind me of him.

The Real Andrew Kim

Simone with the IYKYK look was really funny. It would be crazy if 2 crew members with differing personalities were forced to become 1 individual, its almost like it would make a good Star Trek episode....maybe taking place in the Delta quadrant.... 😜

Jomero

My best friend whose love for TNG rubbed off onto me in high school, passed away some years ago. He really helped me through a very dark and rough period of my life. He befriended me during that period and liked me for me. In my mourning, I decided to watch a TNG episode. I sort of picked one at random. I landed on "The Next Phase." I am surprised I didn't watch one that was more memorable. I barely remembered the episode, other than my friend and I joking that there's this Romulan forever phased, floating in space, never to be found; a permanent hell for him. But then Data gave the line about Geordi, when he thought Geordi had passed away. "He accepted me for what I am. And that, I have learned, is friendship." That line hit me really hard and was something I really needed to hear and be reminded of.

The Real Andrew Kim

I believe the point of this story is to highlight how easy it was for "enlightened people" to so quickly justify Genocide which I think didn't get discussed enough in the reaction. This obviously is prescient to our current times if you have been paying attention to the Palestinian situation IRL. It surprised me at how enthusiastically George was advocating for just killing the Borg without any compassion for their way of life. If you "dehumanize" a species as just a cancer or plague it easy to justify this perspective, but even if you view the assimilated as having a disease to be eradicated, it's best to remember the assimilated were innocent victims that could be potentially rescued or saved. The direct jump to Borg Genocide without even attempting other solutions was the point of ultimately sending Hugh back. They found an alternate solution that didn't need to involve Genocide which i think is very relevant to today IMO. I understand George's POV of wanting the Borg to be more like Force of Nature rather than a civilization of beings, but as I have mentioned in previous comments, you have to look at Trek as telling stories coming from an idealized (and to some extent, Naive) perspective, because the whole point of Trek at least early on was to present humanity as evolved and enlightened and that includes trying to highlight the ugliness that even people who we idolize like Picard, can have bigoted opinions mainly due to his past experiences and trauma and Trek always tries to highlight how we can overcome those blind spots to be better as people with principles and understanding. This is a recurring theme in the entire franchise, for example in Star Trek VI The Undiscovered Country starts with Kirk showing his justified hatred for Klingons and blaming an entire race for the death of his son which was the result of 1 individual rogue Klingon captain, but by the end of the movie he realized how he judged the entire race on the actions of 1 person and instead fought to overcome his prejudice and look toward the future with hope and prosperity. I, Borg has the same arch for Picard and his hatred with what the Borg did to him which he will still struggle with in future episodes/movies.

The Real Andrew Kim

There is also an argument to be made that the Borg was an allegory about Communism vs Democracies coming from a very 80s/90s Cold War perspective with the whole Collective vs Individual discussion that Geordi and Hugh have which I think needed to be highlighted more. Personally I don't think its a very good comparison since clearly we are propagandizing the idea of a collective culture as being dehumanizing while propagandizing and overstating the need for individualism.

The Real Andrew Kim

Ideally it would be nice if they watched them in actual release order including the overlapping seasons of TNG and DS9 and then later the overlapping Seasons of DS9 and Voyager. That would help give context to some episodes accross the spinoffs.

The Real Andrew Kim

I get this perspective, but I try to ask people to try to isolate the incredible character growth that Picard and Guinen had to go through to break their bigoted perspective and admit when they are wrong for condemning an individual for the actions of a system that they were not a willing participant but a forced victim and the immense self-reflection that is required to overcome their hatred. That is the lesson that needs to be promoted especially in modern political times, but I feel this message always gets lost due to opinions like yours that minimize the more important message IMO. Now could the same story be told without messing up the Borg lore by using a different alien species, probably, but this is what we got because the writers felt by taking the universally hated and feared Borg and be able to humanize them more fully highlights how hard it is to overcome your own bigotry which i think your comment emphasizes this point.

The Real Andrew Kim

It's probably too much to try to do individual episodes in actual release order, i think the most practical would be option 3, staggering the seasons.

The Real Andrew Kim

Yeah staggering the seasons is the most practical i think.

The Real Andrew Kim

If anything this just proves context means everything, Beverly reads the context of the situation that it does not need to be this one individual who has to be held accountable nor should he be the weapon to destroy a completely different alien life form. What does it say about humanity or the federation if they throw away their principles about respecting and preserving life if they throw it out the minute it becomes inconvenient.? What does it mean to argue for individuality when you deny the individuality of your enemy when they present it to you? Beverly is pointing out the hypocrisy. There is a difference between self-defense and preservation vs outright annihilation and genocide. Hugh showed for the first time the the Borg are more complicated than Picard and Guinan would like to believe and that there is a solution to defending themselves without direct annihilation.

The Real Andrew Kim

My opinion exactly. I'm sorry that people want the borg to stay what they wanted, but at least understand the point of the episode and not get distracted by personal desires of what they wish the borg to be.

Jomero

Romulans are essentially xenophobic and believe themselves to be superior to all other alien species. It's hard to get a "non-asshole" episode with a group of people like that.

StonyD

I understand the overall message, and it's a basic one. Trek has dealt with those exact same issues since its inception many times over and in many different ways. Nothing new here I didn't see with more subtlety and nuance in Star Trek VI. But I am not talking about Picard or Guinan's character reactions and more about how the Borg becomes less entertaining and interesting the more you make them frail or relatable or understood. You shouldn't be able to "get to know" a hurricane. It needlessly detracts from the mystique and their place in Trek lore imo. It's the entertainment factor, not the moral or ethical implications that bother me. That's all.

The Real Andrew Kim

Ensign Ro's quick acceptance of death was probably written to show how the Bajorans have a deep spiritual and religious culture, which was mentioned when she was first introduced and will be expanded and explored greatly in DS9 which the writers might have already been thinking about establishing since this would have been around the time they started developing that show. Remember the Bajorans are not technically part of the Federation at this point.

Z Simons

That's my friend John doing s lot of Picard's fencing! He was Patrick Stewart's stunt double for all of the TNG era.

Kev Longley

Im not conveniently sweeping anything aside. My first sentence said Im not arguing the decision to destroy them is right or wrong. I am arguing that before we make that choice we should examine it thoroughly. We dont just get to wipe out a race, a species, because they are bad. We should fully explore such a decision before we make it. Writing Beverly off as naive because after two encounters we have decided its just a disease that needs to be eliminated is short sighted and a huge disservice to ourselves.

Guts

I think the second to last episode of season 7 is better if you have seen some of DS9

DemNikoArt

It probably has been said already, but I think "I Borg" makes the concept of the Borg even more terrifying and doesn't really demistifies the threat. Hugh doesn't speak for all the borg. And he doesn't represent them as a whole. He won't convince them and they won't be softened by his experience. They are still the cancer of the universe. This episode just wanted to show us the tragedy of all the assimilated species. That there are still some remnants of them trapped. But they as a collective won't be phased by these events at all.

Ian J

After watching you two watch the second episode in this video, I think you might find the film "A Ghost Story" (2017) very interesting.

Joe Concepts

But I think here, this is the show adding some depth to their own characters, and I don't see it as going against what we know. I sometimes will get annoyed when writers want to humanize some long time evil cartoon character or something. So we "understand" why they are bad. But this is Star Trek after all. Having an entire, mindless murdering race to easily justify killing them doesn't really fit the franchise. Once they introduce the idea of them assimilated unwilling people, it's harder to dismiss them all.

Joe Concepts

Interesting to watch this reaction, because many others have seen immediately feel like Picard is acting unusually harsh for his character. Understandable, given his extreme experience with the Borg, but he stops being the thoughtful Picard at first.

Joe Concepts

To me, when you come up with these technical questions about science that don't seem to make sense, part of the fun is making up your own explanation. Since Ro and Geordi obviously ARE walking on the desk and breathing, you figure there is enough of them there for gravity to affect them, and for I guess oxygen, etc to still work for them. Since their walking through walls and sticking their hands through objects is leaving some marker behind, they do have SOME substance.

Beddoe

Simone from restroom: "Victory"

This Justin

Even the zombies in George A. Romero’s old Living Dead movies aren’t that black and white.

Angela D. Mitchell

George, interesting arguments. But even if the Borg were mindless killing "space zombies," even zombies were once human beings and deserve mercy, right? For me, the most interesting monsters are those we feel something for. So I wasn't angry at Beverly like Simone was, because Beverly wasn't just seeing Wesley in Hugh, she was seeing a human being who had been abused, enslaved, and damaged without choice. I absolutely understood Picard and Guinan's points of view, but the human being beneath the Borg deserved their help. But I loved the conundrum, and loved Picard's ruthlessness in just seeing a hated enemy who had almost destroyed him -- not a fellow victim! That scene where he slipped back into Locutus with Hugh was incredible -- it opened up so many questions for me. Is "Locutus" still there within Picard? I tend to think yes, after this episode. And superb acting from both Patrick Stewart and Hugh's actor, Jonathan Del Arco (who I recognized from "The Closer" and "Major Crimes"). As far as Hugh's biology -- they didn't remove the Borg implants because until very late in the story, they were planning to send him back as the "bomb." So there was deliberately no attempt to turn him back. I still struggle with them sending him back. He said he didn't want to go. Picard's reasoning of, "Maybe he will 'infect' them with individuality" was weak to me. So I feel like this was another deeply tragic ending. Hugh's final, fleeting glance to Geordie was so well done! He's so stoic, he's a Borg again, staring ahead -- but nope, at the very last second... he looks back. And it felt like regret or like one last memory of personhood before it was all taken away from him again. And of course it was too late. It just gutted me. That last look is what will stay with me. Now I have to go cry and hug my cat.

Angzarr

If you're wondering how they eat and breathe and other science facts (la la la) , then repeat to yourself "It's just a show, I should really just relax."