Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/pwdx6Opct9 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/5ItitY9pC4 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Comments

Shibby

Yay :D

Leon Hickson

I have been tapping my foot impatiently for like 40 minutes now... can't wait to see the reaction

Paul T Hewes

For someone who said they went deep in the Dunk and Egg lore, George really doesn’t know anything. Aerion is so far down the line of succession, it would take a horrible event to even get close to the crown.

NOTTHELASTONEMANNN

i don't think he ever said that i only remembering him mentioning he read over one of the books once

newhastings

It’s an amazing feeling knowing Season 2 is coming out early next year, it’s this, The Pitt, and the Gary Oldman Apple TV show that are the only streaming shows somehow maintaining a yearly release schedule

Jaaahn

when did he ever said he went 'deep in dunk and egg lore'? he literally said he read the book, not even books, once, years ago.... I swear the favorite thing for a lot of people in this community to do isnt watching reaction, its to hear what they want to hear so they can dispute it and feel superior about it.

Patrick Waldeck

Dunk is definitely NOT a knight. It's why he hesitated to knight Raymun: he felt guilty about making a false knight, because he himself is one.

Shibby

Ok so I was not interested in this thanks to GOT ending but im glad I watched it with you guys it was incredible. Might be one of my favourite short series ever. Thank you for introducing me to this :D

Victor Fiegel

I feel like George is really in his spoiler bag lately, or just obvious foreshadowing. 🤔 much love!

Twiska Brand

You talked about hints of magic. The fortune teller wasn't in the books, but Daeron's dream was. The one where he saw Dunk lying under a dead dragon. That was him dreaming of Baelor's death, with Dunk as the primary cause. The Targaryens have a history of dragon dreamers—people who can see the future. Aegon the Conqueror seeing the Long Night (which was confirmed by GRRM as canon); Daenys the Dreamer seeing the Doom; Daenerys dreaming of hatching dragons during Book 1, which I think was cut from the show. Edit: Helaena being a dreamer may or may not be canon. GRRM never directly confirmed that.

Shibby

Also Sweetfoot has the best ending in all of GOT universe :)

Twiska Brand

While giving Dunk an almost-girlfriend adds to his backstory, part of me doesn't like it, as a big part of his character is that he doesn't know how to talk to women. He grew up with a gang of boys and was squired with Arlan till his death. He is only supposed to be 17 to 18 in this part of the story. He doesn't know for sure how old he is. So he is really awkward around women. I feel like him having a close friendship bordering on romance (that's how I took the love confession and her advice to make his own family) as making it a bit unbelievable for him to be so hopeless around women.

Twiska Brand

His not being knighted has been a common theory ever since the books were published. There are many times in the book when he hints that he is living a lie and that all his misfortune is divine punishment.

Jeff K.

I don't recall it being mentioned in any of your reactions, but just as a reminder for George and Simone, Jon Snow's true name is Aegon, as well.

James W.

The thing is, even if Ser Arlan knighted him, Arlan wasn't a storied knight, and certainly not of noble birth so noone respected him anyway, except Baelor. At no point did anyone really seem to believe or care if Dunk was knighted because if we was playing it false he'll die in the melee and even the more cynical folks eventually were rooting for him because Dunk carried himself more by knightly virtues than almost every knight we have met. I agree 100% though, from the context clues, I don't think he was knighted and that is why he hesitated. Its even why Maekar basically offers for him to complete proper training, because even that grumpy fucker sees how good a person Dunk is and even though he hasn't embraced it yet, it is why he lets Egg be with Duncan even though it hurts to let go of his last good boy. His last chance to get it right.

Jessica Jarvis

Maekar starts irritated and stays irritated and I love that for him.

Simon

Hopefully we'll see HotD season 2 & 3 in the next short show poll - would suck if they only did S1 and quit.

Spacedone

This is a wonderful series full of great actors but the one scene that gets me every time I see it is Maekar rejecting Dunk's offer to make Egg his squire by saying "He's my last son." There's so much unspoken meaning in those words. He's not saying that Egg is his youngest, he's saying that Egg is his last chance to raise a son who is worthy in his eyes. He feels that he's failed as a father to his eldest sons. Daeron turned into a drunk, maybe haunted by his true dreams. Aemon was sent away while young to become a maester, on the orders of the King. Aerion turned cruel and is maybe showing signs of the Targaryan curse of madness. Aegon is maybe his last chance to raise a son to be a good man like his brother Baelor.

Josh Minke

dammit egg. always getting Duncan in trouble. definitely deserves a clout in the ear

Jay Johnson

it has been a while since I've delved into ASoIaF lore, so perhaps I'm mis-remembering. But I thought I remembered the presence of magic more or less being tied to the presence of dragons. This series is set about years after the dragons died off following the Targaryen civil war, and well before Daenerys hatched hers. And I think the presence of magical effects had also dwindled during that time (with it being rekindled when Dany's dragons re=emerged)

Josh Minke

or he didn't want to put Raymuns life in danger

Patrick Waldeck

It is ironic that Dunk, a man who wasn't knighted, goes does in history as one of the few "True Knights," becoming a paragon of chivalric virtue.

James W. (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 05:00 I think this show nailed the tone of GRRM better than the main GoT show or HOTD. I love those as well, but I love every choice they made for this, from story, to pacing, to cast, music, all of it. Baelor's death is heartbreaking. The implication for the Targaryen's and their continued decline after loosing such a pivotal figure is a bummer. In a show with great performances in every slot, Sam Spruell's scenes as Maekar in Ep6 are beautiful and layered and I love him. Stoked to see him more going into season 2 and beyond. The "Art of Gary Gianni for George R. R. Martin’s Seven Kingdoms". is a collection of art that GRRM commissioned for a deluxe edition of his novel, some of the scenes in this feel directly taken from his work, in the very best sense. Its just a great book, and you can see how Gary an George collaborated to realize what was in his imagination. Its out of print but you can still find copies for a reasonable price on Ebay. Its a solid coffee table book Or if you have disposable income you can try and find the illustrated deluxe printing of the novel that was done in 2015 but thing can be very pricey as it was a limited run. Books like these hold their value very well and appreciate on top of them just being cool to have a nerd. If you are that flavor of fan I highly recommend them.
2026-08-25 15:14 I think this show nailed the tone of GRRM better than the main GoT show or HOTD. I love those as well, but I love every choice they made for this, from story, to pacing, to cast, music, all of it. Baelor's death is heartbreaking. The implication for the Targaryen's and their continued decline after loosing such a pivotal figure is a bummer. In a show with great performances in every slot, Sam Spruell's scenes as Maekar in Ep6 are beautiful and layered and I love him. Stoked to see him more going into season 2 and beyond. The "Art of Gary Gianni for George R. R. Martin’s Seven Kingdoms". is a collection of art that GRRM commissioned for a deluxe edition of his novel, some of the scenes in this feel directly taken from his work, in the very best sense. Its just a great book, and you can see how Gary an George collaborated to realize what was in his imagination. Its out of print but you can still find copies for a reasonable price on Ebay. Its a solid coffee table book Or if you have disposable income you can try and find the illustrated deluxe printing of the novel that was done in 2015 but thing can be very pricey as it was a limited run. Books like these hold their value very well and appreciate on top of them just being cool to have as a nerd. If you are that flavor of fan I highly recommend them.

I think this show nailed the tone of GRRM better than the main GoT show or HOTD. I love those as well, but I love every choice they made for this, from story, to pacing, to cast, music, all of it. Baelor's death is heartbreaking. The implication for the Targaryen's and their continued decline after loosing such a pivotal figure is a bummer. In a show with great performances in every slot, Sam Spruell's scenes as Maekar in Ep6 are beautiful and layered and I love him. Stoked to see him more going into season 2 and beyond. The "Art of Gary Gianni for George R. R. Martin’s Seven Kingdoms". is a collection of art that GRRM commissioned for a deluxe edition of his novel, some of the scenes in this feel directly taken from his work, in the very best sense. Its just a great book, and you can see how Gary an George collaborated to realize what was in his imagination. Its out of print but you can still find copies for a reasonable price on Ebay. Its a solid coffee table book Or if you have disposable income you can try and find the illustrated deluxe printing of the novel that was done in 2015 but thing can be very pricey as it was a limited run. Books like these hold their value very well and appreciate on top of them just being cool to have as a nerd. If you are that flavor of fan I highly recommend them.

Roaring Mouse

I believe that he was knighted because its too obvious that he wasnt and GRRM is never that obvious. I suspect that a near death, weak and feeble Ser Arlan just said, your a knight and didn't do the words correctly and Dunk feels like it didn't really count. Im curious to see it revealed, GRRM may not exactly have decided yet

Shibby

Lots of people have read LOTR but don't have an in depth knowledge of the lore, it's no big deal.

Stephen Stone

Current lineup for succession for king as of the end of episode 6... Daeron II (current king and Maekars dad) Valarr (Baelor's oldest son; Baelor was the oldest of 4 brothers) Valarr's younger brother Baelor's oldest brother Baelor's oldest brothers son Baelor's 2nd brother Maekar Daeron III (Maekars oldest son) Aerion (evil cunt) Aemon (revoked right to throne to become Maester of the wall) Egg (10 people have to die before Egg gets the throne) Egg was called "Aegon the Unlikely" because he was 11th in line if you included Baelor and the likelihood of everyone dying before him was very unlikely. In the books, Egg is the Mad Kings grandpa, but in the show universe, Egg is the Mad Kings dad.

funky weapon

seems you guys missed the joke Lyonel made: "we'll be gone after the roast." Smash cut to the funeral pyre for Baelor. Lyonel Baratheon is easily my favorite non-Dunk and Egg character. guy stole the show and I loved his comment about who really risked their lives for Duncan. It's interesting to get the kingdom's view of the Targs, since in the original show all we knew were basically lords and ladies acting prim and proper, putting words in the mouths of the common people. this show is actually showing us what they think. Maekar is exactly what I meant when I talked about how the characters in this show feel like real people. they're layered and rich in a way that most characters in the original show just aren't. not for fault of the writing but more due to the fact that GoT was an epic fantasy saga and this is just the adventures of two dorks in the woods. I also really like that it's ambiguous as to whether Dunk was knighted. dramatic irony would demand that the truest knight of the seven kingdoms is actually no knight at all, but on the other hand I like the idea that it was like an Army of Darkness thing where Ser Arlan may not have said the exact words down to every little syllable but he got the gist. I choose to believe that Arlan knighted Dunk. I really can't wait for season 2.

Brandon

I'm convinced that Maekar actually did grant Egg permission to travel as Dunk's squire. His freak out at the end is about saving face in public so it doesn't look like he made such a reckless decision about his youngest son. It wouldn't be too hard to have a group of men find him and bring him back. IMO he's actually okay with Egg having that life experience on the road.

Brandon

I hope they retcon the mistake of Aerys II being Egg's son and not his grandson. I don't know when or how, but I hope they do it anyway. 😆

Jay Willis

one could argue that he simply didn't know how to, the right words to say. Also recall we see that shot of him kneeling in front of Arlan, who shrugs. Arlan may not known how to properly knight someone, or maybe Arlan thought it was a silly tradition and he made a mockery of it in knighting Duncan, who then doesn't know if his knighting was legitimate. I know in the books there's even more clues and contextual things that Dunk may have been lying. But again, I wonder if it's so far Arlan never did anything, or if it's something more silly like Arlan made him kneel, said some nonsensical words that mock the tradition/ceremony entirely, and Dunk has no clue whether he's legit it or not, but eventually decides it doesn't matter (edit: or maybe Arlan revealed to Duncan that HE wasn't legitimate, and thus Duncan also questions the knighting). Either way, I think the point, for me anyway, is it doesn't matter. Whether he was knighted or not, he follows the way of the Knight and lives up to the ideals better than most, if not all, others. I won't be surprised if we find out one way or the other one day, or if it winds up being something that never has a clear answer (i would lean this is the far likelier solution).

Brandon

Bealor's fate is one of George RR Martin's big "what ifs" in the history of Westeros. All signs suggest that Baelor would have been one of the best Targaryen Kings had he actually lived to take the throne. My favourite of those big "what ifs" is the fart that changed the fate of Elia Martell. Basically, Elia was likely to marry Baelor Hightower, but he farted in front of her. Her brother Oberyn jokingly called him Baelor Breakwind. After that she couldn't take him seriously and she ended up marrying Rhaegar Targaryen instead. I really wish they would have included that story from the books in Game of Thrones. It's not like the showrunners were above toilet humour. 😂

G P

Don't forget Silo

Kevin

In reality season 1 of AKOTSK finished filming in September of 2024 and simply did not release for over a year. So it was actually quite a lot of time they have had to work on season 2. It remains to be seen if season 3 will actually come out in 2028.

newhastings

well there goes that dream 💔

REDR58

In the Name of the Mother I'm happy that the episode at least sort of hand-waved away how Dunk could possibly survive all of those stabbings by the blacksmith saying the mail was pushed in (and apparently not all pierced).

Michael Rawson

Line of Succession: Daron II "The Good" - current King 1. Valarr - Baylor's oldest 2. Malys - Baylor's youngest (Not sure about that name - started wth an M 3. Rhagel - Baylors brother (childless) 4. Arys I (childless) 5. Maekar "the Anvil" 6. Daron (Maekar's drunken son) 7. Aurien "Brightflame" (douchebag who fought Dunk) Ammond - not in the line of succession - becomes Maestor of Castleblack 8. Aegon V "the Unlikely" (4th son of a 4th son - crazy shit has to happen before Aegon can sit on the throne

Michael Rawson

Oh - when you mentioned the Stark's had evil ancestors - Ned Stark and his kids were kind a an aberration in the Stark family. Ned was fostered by Jon Arryn so a lot of his more honorable traits came from there which he passed to his children. The pre-Ned Starks were known for keeping oaths but were more ruthless, cold... I think Ned and sons were legal-good whereas most Starks in the past would be legal-neutral

REDR58

I really like how the show ended with “A Knight of the NINE Kingdoms.”

xeve

While they cared for each other their relationship was depicted as a bit uneven and awkward with her driving their actions and him often gobsmacked.

SlothSteve

He's only ever said he read the first novella once which only covers the events of this season.

Saifu

Or maybe time it around season 4/final season drops in 2028...

Christina Bee

lol I love that George basically fancast Peter Claffey for Henry of Skalitz. so many fandoms were fancasting him in stuff this year - Heated Rivalry, Dungeon Crawler Carl, X-Men.

Christina Bee

they had balls putting that flashback there but I felt it didn't linger too long and they didn't cheap out on the fight. this was so stressful to watch.

Sean Hennessy

Where was that place that Lyonel asked Dunk if he had ever been again?

dys

Even though I'd read the stories I wasn't prepared for how brutal episode 5 would be. I'd read the mainline books too so I was fully prepared for things like the Red Wedding or Tyrion's trial by combat but I didn't remember Dunk's trial being this brutal. As amazingly as the battle is filmed and as realistic as it is in other aspects relative to medieval combat scenes in other media, I do share the gripes that the amount of injury Dunk takes does seem too unrealistic. I'm not a doctor but I would bet just the multiple stabs through the hand alone with that big dagger would make it probably impossible to ever regain useful function in that hand without a top modern hand surgeon and years of physical therapy. You want your audience to be worried that the character is going to survive, but if you injure him SO much that IRL he would never recover from it can actually lessen the stakes. Maybe I'd like it better if I hadn't read the story and was actually worried he would die, I dunno.

MacGuffinStuff

I was looking into the bloodlines etc. after the last set of episodes, couldn't help it. But one bit of trivia is so cool, I don't think it's a spoiler but if there's going to be more Dunk and Eg, it could be, a bit? So don't read if you don't want it, I don't think it's a spoiler just a really cool connection, but I won't specifically say it... Confirmed by George RR Martin, at least one character in Game of Thrones is a descendant of Dunk I won't name them but here's a big hint. That was it, the hint is "BIG". There's speculation about at least one other character but I don't think it's true. And, Eg has the four brothers, Darron the Drunk is actually the oldest not A Aron, (btw Darron is a Dragon Dreamer, he showed it in episode 3 or 4, hia dreams are prophetic, hence the alcoholism), but Eg also has sisters, and I think that was one of them at the end, and she was very much cheering for Dunk.

SlothSteve

Describing past events for a little extra context. On the conditions in Fleabottom during Dunk's flashback. The Battle of the Redgrass Field, which was the final battle of the Blackfyre Rebellion was just fought not far outside of Kingslanding, we see Dunk scavenging in the battlefield when he finds that dying Frey. Many of the wounded and dying of the battle were brought to Kingslanding, hence the especially awful conditions at the time. This battle is also what Egg is singing about while he's sitting in the tree.

CommanderBrownCoat

Now that AKOTSK is done and I know there are some more short shows ahead, I thought it was still worth bringing up Reacher! I would love to see Simone's reaction to some of those fight scenes! lol

Andreas Buehler

The one talking about her name day? That's the daughter of the tournament's host, Lord Ashford. She's mentioned a few times.

Sean Hennessy

I am very much on the team that believes the truth. Several hints dropped.

Conzi

Maybe the reason Ser Arlan never knighted him is that he also was not a knight.

MacGuffinStuff

Fuckin NEVERMIND, I sound stupid, I looked up more of the lore and it's kind of that but WAY MORE COMPLICATED.. Imagine my surprise George RR you fuckin with me Martin.

Rando Estorn

I think you mixed Aerys and Rhaegel there, Aerys is older but does not have any sons himself, Rhaegel has twins and a daughter who marries Aerion.

Conzi

Apparently the creator said they threw that in there because they thought it was funny, but it wasn't part of the original script. My guess is we'll get a flashback sometime in season 2 of Maekar tracking them down & finally accepting it/giving him the Targ ring that is important a couple times in the novellas.

Bill B.

This is such a perfect season!!!

Stephen Stone

Yeah, you're right. I was going based on memory.

VirtuallyVeronicka

Ep. 5 was ROUGH! I don’t think I could have watched a longer version of that battle. Dunk took so many injuries. I truly think despite Dunk freezing in panic, Thunder finally jumped to start because of his training with Egg and hearing him yell the command. I was happy to see Baelor was standing in the end and then immediate horror as the helmet was removed, so many tears. 😭😩😭 If you rewatch the battle you can see others fighting in the background and you can see the moment Maekar hits Baelor as he fights off two guys to try to get to his son; it was all in the heat of battle which is heartbreaking.

VirtuallyVeronicka

Give me more adventures with Dunk and Egg!!!! I love this end to S1; ending on a return to sorta chill with our two leads. But yikes!!! 😳 Egg lying to Dunk again and sneaking off is adding another wedge in between his family and Ser Dunk. Apparently in the book Maekar gives Egg permission to go. So I’m curious what this twist means for the show. I was happy they gave Maekar more time on screen. The actor did a great job expressing the pain of being the one that dealt the fatal blow to his brother. I felt his loss. His request to Dunk to accept Egg as his squire was a surprise, and somewhat shows that he cares for his son’s happiness, but I think Dunk made the right choice. IMO the “lightning in a bottle” they caught boils down to the leads, the humor, the friendships, the music, the sweet moments and that it all walks in hand with the potential of danger in the GOT universe. I’m very much looking forward to S2, which was already in production!!!

Not Batman

yooo george how bout not telling her dunk doesnt die in the books at the damn climax of suspense next time

OddThomas

After watching Knight of the Seven Kingdoms I reluctantly returned to House of the Dragon and while season 2 is frustrating early on (like many people, I bailed the first time), if you stick with it, the latter half of S2 and all of S3 is GREAT.