Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/liO2LyGLk8 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/i4sZig6uJ0 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

The Whale | Canadian First Time Watching | Movie Reaction | Movie Review | Movie Commentary

Full length/Unedited: https://www.patreon.com/Cinebinge https://www.instagram.com/cinebingechannel/ Merch: https://www.cinebinge.ca BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/cinebinge.bsky.social Simone & George are reacting to The Whale for the first time! Canadians React! Subscribe | Like | Share | Comment Early Access & Full Reaction available on Patreon! #moviereaction #moviereview #thewhale Instagram: @cinebingechannel

Comments

Ashton Lewis

This film breaks me every single time

22 WOLVES

I love crying at 8 AM, shout out to Brendan Fraser 😢

Josh Minke

I didn't feel like crying today, but I guess I no choice. "Clicks play"

Life in the cave of Garanoga

Pretty sure I have said this here before somewhere but finally seeing him get the credit he deserves when he was praised for this film is one of the most joyous things I have seen in my life. I've recommended his other films before, but the range he has is just crazy. He makes any movie worth watching.

Jeff Smith

Love Brendan Fraser but this movie ruins me every time I’ve watched it. Especially the last 30 minutes or so. He definitely deserved the award for this.

TheLeftPecOfTheLord

Throwing in the obligatory: I Love Brendan Fraser so much and it makes me unreasonably happy that he’s finally been recognized and won an Oscar. He deserves every success

Lloyd Franklin (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-13 17:00 I went through a similar situation when my mum died of terminal cancer at 62. I turned to food as a way to cope and ended up weighing 350 lbs. Now I’m down to 280 lbs and still losing it. I came to terms with losing my mum after seeing a therapist.
2026-08-30 13:26

MrGustavevil

The word George was looking for is apostate.

Jeff K.

Would love for you guys to watch School Ties, which was Brendan's big breakout role (and features multiple future big time stars in some of their earliest roles, as well).

Jeff K.

I love Brendan Fraser. Do I have a tshirt in my closet that says "I really hope Brendan Fraser is having a good day"? You bet I do.

Matt O'Keefe

The most I have ever weighed is about 368 lbs or so which was about 15-20 years ago. I am about 275 lbs now. My blood pressure was 300/150 when I went to the ER when I had an aneurysm about 9 years ago. It was caused by amphetamine addiction. Losing weight has nothing to do with working out. It's all diet. My being fat started when I was about 11.

Lloyd Franklin (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-13 17:00 Brendan Fraser did nothing wrong; the blame lies entirely with the person who molested him. He also dealt with severe back problems following his work on The Mummy.
2026-08-30 14:45

funky weapon

Well that was depressing! Thanks guys! I will say that I like that during Charlie's DMT dump while dying his idea of heaven was the memory of taking his family to the beach. As for the trivia on prosthetics: people who get morbidly obese like Charlie move a certain way that a normal sized person in a fat suit can't emulate properly. It makes sense that they'd want as natural looking movement from Brendan Fraser as possible and so opted for heavy prosthetics. It paid off too because you really feel every grunt and every struggle Charlie has in the film.

Ashton Lewis

I see her breaking the bird plate as her being angry that he was taking care of that bird, but never took care of her in the way she wanted. He takes the time and (considerable, in his case) effort to make sure that bird is fed every day, which in her mind is more than he ever did for her, after leaving

REDR58

Saw it in the theater when it first came out. Wonderful film.

Mastervodo

I don't think I've seen a reaction from Cinebinge that was so quiet. Youtube edit will be 7 minutes and 39 seconds. And will still be copyright claimed from A24.

Der heilige Stuhl

Dude legit had a nuke the Whales poster for "The Whale"..that is LEGIT

Raven Dark

George, I couldn't tell whether you were being serious or not, but you asked what we thought Charlie's white wale was. Charlie's white wale was himself.

REDR58

I’d never heard the phrase “food noise” before, so I just looked it up. Interesting. While I don’t have the most healthy of diets, I also don’t think about food unless I’m hungry.

Brandon

First time seeing this one. I can see why it's one of those Oscar movies that was nominated for acting awards, but not Best Picture, Director, Screenwriting etc. Darren Aronofsky shot a bad movie incredibly well and I think it's easily his worst film. The way it's filmed makes it feel like the movie wants us to be disgusted with Charlie above trying to humanize him. The dark music that belongs in a horror movie every time it focuses on him eating etc. The problem here is that decent people don't need to do all the work this movie wants us to do to feel empathy for an overweight man that's close to dying. I haven't seen the play this movie was based on, but I don't think Aronofsky was the director for this material.

Jeff K.

Yep. He got blackballed for speaking out about being groped by someone in a position of power, which unfortunately is often par for the course in Hollywood.

Jeff K.

As someone who does an hour of cardio every day and lifts three times per week, you're spot on: it's about diet. Whenever I'm actually intentional about what I eat, the pounds come off and the definition improves. When I go back to eating junk food and imbibing in some adult beverages, it's reversed, even with the level of gym effort staying exactly the same.

Thall

The US could've done a war on crime right at home in Hollywood, but nooooo, had to get other countries involved.

Senec

I feel unwell after this movie.

Tricky Smitles

Y'all gotta watch The Wrestler (2008). My favorite Aronofsky film.

Luke

This movie is terribleeeee

Carlos H

Brendan Fraser. Holy fuck. What a performance .

doe555

When I was seeing this movie i did not think about him dying when she opened the door, but I think you are right. Everything after is the last moment in his head.

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

I came here to also name drop this movie, so I 2nd that recommendation. They're not connected in any way, but I feel like the wrestler and the whale complement each other in a lot of ways. I also used to be a huge wrestling fan growin up, which lead to seeing a few of those behind the scenes wrestling documentaries, with some showing what it's like for wrestlers whose glory days are behind them. The movie does a great job showing that world to people who don't really know much about that business, but makes them care about it. Even if only for the runtime of the movie.

ThetaSigmaTheOriginal

I remember when I first watched this. I had no idea what it was about, or what the message the movie was trying to convey was. I was worried for a while that they were going to go the whole religiously "saved" route with Brandon's character, with the confusion going around with the Thomas character. Which I would have hated with a passion. He needed help, not saving.

Mesme Rize

Kinda just started watching your reaction, but speaking of Aronofsky, you guys should watch the Wrestler. Its my favorite Aronofsky movie and Rourke has such a brilliant performance and it's a really disturbing look at the dark side of the Pro Wrestling business.

REDR58

Sadie Sink was about 20 years old when this movie was filmed. George, Mormon missionaries and others definitely do their proselytizing within the US. They periodically come around to my house. I don’t answer the door to them (or anyone else I don’t know or am not expecting) or if I see them when I’m outside I let them know they are not welcome on my property. Getting into conversations with them is a waste of time and I have no patience for it in the slightest. Samantha Morton who played Mary was in Minority Report. Thomas, (played by Ty Simpkins from War of the Worlds, Iron Man 3 and Avengers Endgame) the New Life kid was completely insufferable but I’m sure I partly feel that way because I find those people personally offensive and manipulative of vulnerable people.

Frank

George, you brought back some nightmarish memories of you talking about food being tasteless and bitter. I had the version of covid where you lose taste and it was one of the most miserable times of my life.

Frank

I can't figure out if I've seen that movie or not. Gonna add it to my list, though, and try to check it out soon

Jeff K.

It’s an excellent movie. I highly recommend it.

TurnerK

Thank you

Thomas Young

I used to be 397 and I'm 6'3", My highest BP was 188/112, still really bad. I lost down to about 265, but unfortunately I've gained back up to about 325 now. I need to get back on it, but you're right, its all diet. Gym absolutely helps, as well as just having more muscle, but it like 80% diet, 20% gym. Unless you do something crazy for work, or are lifting/working out for competitive reasons.

Matt O'Keefe

I have plateaued in weight loss currently and sometimes gained back before but I know I can just restart. And of course so can you. And I am 5'11" and 3/4 of an inch, so I just say 6".

Kyle B

Needed to watch the episode of 'This Aged Great!' for The Whale as a palate cleanser.

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

And I felt saddest of all when I read the boring chapters that were only descriptions of leaves, because I knew that the author was just trying to save us from his own sad story, of the hobbits not getting second breakfast, just for a little while.

Robinson vs. Parkinson's

Lloyd, I spent a good part of the last decade coaching some pretty amazing people in my gym. Two of them came to me AFTER losing over 100lbs each. They are beautiful people living happy and fulfilling lives. You. can. too.

Saifu

Please add Brendan Fraser's Rental Family to the list too!

Hammond of Texas

I had never seen this movie but I'd heard it was good and was Brandon's re-emergence. What I didn't know is how heartfelt and important it is. Thank you.

ArcadeAndy

I don't think it's about getting people to feel empathy. I think the point IS getting people to feel disgust, which decent people wouldn't feel from just seeing an overweight person eat. Charlie could not get his partner to eat while he wasted away. Charlie therefore chooses food as the method of his own demise. Food is not benign in this story, and I think it was right to portray it as sinister or disgusting.

FranciscoGios

Coming in I knew this movie won some Oscar's specially Fraser's Oscar. And I knew this movie would be a shit show of crying myself a river. This was my first time watching it. Great movie.

Jamie

Whilst I liked this movie, you can totally Tropic Thunder it into a Sandler film at the points it is heart felt. There is a hilarity to it.

Brandon

But I don't agree that it portrays food as disgusting. It comes across as portraying Charlie as disgusting. The sounds of him eating paired with the music creates at best, a mixed message. Ellie is also downright cruel, way past the point of a teenager who has a right to be angry with her father. Her dialogue is filled with fat-shaming and homophobia and the movie never addresses the latter. When she tries to get him to walk without the walker and he falls over, the movie cuts back to her and she's suddenly covered by shadows. I couldn't help but roll my eyes. Sadie Sink is far more villainous here than in a certain summer blockbuster that recently came out.

ArcadeAndy

"No one chooses evil because it is evil. One only mistakes it for happiness." Charlie is too smart to believe monsters are real, so he chooses to believe Ellie's motives were to help and not harm. He cherishes the honesty in her Moby Dick essay and, in the end, comes to appreciate her honesty in life (which I think is why he tells his students at the end that nothing else matters but the honest things they say). I think that's what leads him to being honest with Ellie (and himself) about why he left his family (and how he regrets it) and, by doing so, earns him the same reconciliation that Thomas got when he did the same with his family. Ellie is no saint and probably does what she does because her father left her with a heavy allergy to other people's bullshit, but she's not evil either. She simply holds up a mirror to people and forces them to acknowledge who they really are, and Charlie chooses to focus on the virtuous side of that.

Bstan45

...with no explanation. What a waste of a comment.

Jay Johnson

"The Whale" and "The Menu" both came out in 2022 and both had Hong Chau in a supporting role (as George pointed out). Fun tangent fact for me is that they both mention "Waterloo, Iowa" in passing (Thomas mentions being from there in Whale, and Chef mentions being from there in Menu), which stands out to me because I live near there (was actually born there and lived in that town as a kid before we moved to a neighboring town). It isn't a town that gets mentioned in movies all that often, so it was funny to hear it in two films in the same year.

Grinznmore

"I think that we're all in our private traps, clamped in them, and none of us can ever get out." Norman Bates

Stephen Morris

Can’t watch this movie, I don’t want to cry that much.

Jay Johnson

Hollywood, Wall Street, Washington DC, all rife with crime.

Jay Johnson

I don't think this is a bad movie at all. but everyone is free to form their own opinions

Jay Johnson

Another film where it just feels like Simone could use a good hug afterward. (from someone she knows and feels comfortable with, obviously. not weird internet strangers like myself, as that would be creepy)

Cc Decc

And again with this one: get The Wrestler (2008) into a poll at the very least. if anything, this movie cribbed some beats from it. It too represented a reemergnce for a former A-lister (Mickey Rourke), and may have even benefitted from Rourke's self-destructive nature informing his character. 7.9 IMDB 99% RT, nominated for 2 Oscars, and frankly Rourke should have won his.

Jon

Twilight of the Golds (1997) was a great early effort of Brendan's.

Shawn B

I love that George has a big "Nuke the Whales" poster in the back of him while we're watching this movie.

ArcadeAndy

@Bstan45 let people express an opinion, even if you don't agree with it. We're patrons not comment police.

FryLord

I saw this in an empty theatre. There was only myself and a couple. After the movie ended I had to stay in place collecting myself because I was crying. I've seen this maybe 5 times before this post. I wrote an essay on it at the behest of my friend. To preface, by profession I'm a licensed therapist and I specialized in child & adolescent therapy, trauma, and substance use/addiction. Ellie isn't evil. She was a child who's anchor left and she was left alone with a distant mother who abused drugs. She was not properly socialized and anger became her security blanket. Look at Sadie's microexpressions. She cares deeply for Charlie and she doesn't know how to express herself so she lashes out because she doesn't know what love feels like. Every single time I hear "Daddy please" I cry. It's her most honest moment of the film because she finally revealed herself. She could've taken the money and ran if she was so evil. She always asked permission for things and even offered to make him a sandwich but tried to make it as healthy as possible. She wanted Charlie in her life more than anything and can't understand why he left which is why she interrogates him and lashes out at his attempts to connect despite a 7 year absence. Evil is such a limited surface level view of a child who never learned to walk so she crawls through the world angry that she can't walk along side others. I'm going to stop myself. I have way more about Ellie and broke down all the characters at length even noting that Liz was an enabler and only 'helped' Charlie because she was stuffing her own guilt from a savior complex "I'm the only one who can help him". Hmmm she could've called 911 and at least done an involuntary stay temporarily but she didnt because Charlie was her crutch. But I'll stop there. This is one of my favorite movies hands down

FryLord

This is a very narrow view of the film. It's not about evoking disgust. If you are disgusting that's your reaction. This movie is human. It shows a person in the throws of suicidal depression and how that radiated to all the other people in his life. This movie is a beautiful character piece. I'm not going to dissect everything you wrote unless you want to engage in such a way but even noting in your second comment the moment when Ellie wants him to walk she's trying to get her father to come to her to come closer to the door instead of just rotting on the couch. She struggles to look at him and feels sad. The shadows are reflective of her hiding her emotions because she can't express herself. She's a child abandoned by her anchor and raised by a drug abusing mother. She doens't know how to communicate so she lashes out. She's not a villain. She's the only living victim in the film

FryLord

I'd say yea everyone is entitled, but the question comes "What's the point". It takes more effort to load the page and comment than to simply ignore and attend to the literal thousands of other posts. Makes no sense to pay money just to be vitriolic for the sake of being vitriolic so I think policing here is valid.

Luke

Am i not allowed an opinion on this ‘in my opinion’ terrible movie? I enjoy their reactions to the movies i like.

Brandon

I wasn't disgusted, I was aware of the movie trying to make me feel that way. There's a difference. I'm sorry, but this movie wasn't a deep portrayal of human loneliness and people with a failure to communicate. Ellie is a terrible person who uses a traumatic event as an excuse to be downright horrible to other people. The filmmaking treats the audience like voyeurs. IMO it's a bad film that's been elevated by having some excellent acting from its cast. To me, Aronofsky has always been hit-or-miss and this is his biggest miss.

Psyclopath

It's been 4 years since I have left my house. Agoraphobia is getting worse but I lost over 130 pounds down from 320 lbs (6ft tall), yay. This movie was one big motivator, it's a hard watch as i'm practically looking at myself. No kids, at least.

Craig Motbey

For more of Brendan Fraser doing serious acting, see 1998's Gods and Monsters. Fantastic work from Ian McKellen in that one, too.

ShittyShittyGameGang

I'm not sure if anyone's answered this but when you start to question your faith/leave it completely it's called deconstruction. I think that's what you were looking for, i don't think it's the opposite of converting because you can deconstruct and still believe. Also, is that the kid from the Insidious franchise (Dalton) the one who was also in one of the Iron Man movies and Endgame?

Daniasaurus

I liked this movie, but I felt it was a little too much in my opinion. For some reason, it really felt like they were just adding so much stuff to make this as sad as possible, and it felt too melodramatic. That being said, I still enjoy this film! And Brendan is the reason for that! He is so good in this role. This movie feels very similar to The Wrestler by the same director. A lot of the same themes, but I just feel that movie does it a little better.

Jimi Hart

You guys gotta do Vanilla Sky

NuggzyBogues1

This was my first time watching this movie. This was the best movie I've seen in 13 years. I'm not obese but I'm disabled and spend most of my time at home. At one point a church organization would come and visit me because they thought I was dieing. As soon as they realized I wasn't dieing they stopped coming lol

gfixler

I never heard the term "food noise," but I literally had a compass. Like at the office, someone would send out an email that they brought donuts, and they're in the kitchen, and I would suddenly feel a feeling I can't quite explain, but like a mental indicator of where the donuts were, like a quest marker. Like if you asked "where are the donuts," I would point immediately behind and to the left of me, directly at where the donuts were, without needing to look. I never knew where north was, and I was always lost driving around, but I could be anywhere in the building, even on other floors, and reliably point directly to where the donuts sat in the kitchen. My brain automatically focused on keeping that map up-to-date on a second-by-second basis. As I walked all around the huge office floor, I would constantly feel their pull. They're over there... now they're over there. It made staying on my diets really, really difficult.