Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go to this site: Cinebingers.ca for the unedited versions of all our content.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/KUs1DF1nm1 👈 for the full reaction where you do not need your own copy.

👉 https://cinebingers.ca/J5MGlE9vL8 👈for the full reaction where you need your own copy.

If you are on a phone/tablet, hold down the link above and press "open in browser", or go straight to Cinebingers.ca on your browser app.

Files

Law Abiding Citizen | Canadian First Time Watching | Movie Reaction | Review | Movie Commentary

Full length/Unedited: https://www.patreon.com/Cinebinge https://www.instagram.com/cinebingechannel/ Merch: https://www.cinebinge.ca BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/cinebinge.bsky.social Simone & George are reacting to Law Abiding Citizen for the first time! Canadians React! Subscribe | Like | Share | Comment Early Access & Full Reaction available on Patreon! #moviereaction #moviereview #lawabidingcitizen Instagram: @cinebingechannel

Comments

WanderingDroidd

Seeing this notification made my morning

funky weapon

I haven't seen this since it released but I remember the ending infuriating me and everyone in my family. It's been 15 years so maybe I'll feel differently now.

Mark Messer

That scene at the beginning is so hard to watch

Matt Dellarosa

Simone, I'm gonna need you to do me a huge favor and stop injuring your shoulder. You said the same thing when you watched Event Horizon. I hope you haven't still been struggling with it for all this time. If so that stinks. I wish you a speedy recovery. Try to take it easy, hopefully I will pass.

PunchNJewelee

Recommending Death Sentence with Kevin Bacon. Similar plot, but much more grounded.

Alex

One of my favourite movies growing up. Please consider adding subtitles, we can’t hear the movie when you talk over in the uncut version.

Morion Williams

Queen of the damned (Ann Rice Vampire) Repo the Genetic Opera (Gothic Musical) Knights of Badassdom (Awesome Fucking Movie) God Bless America (funny thought provoking, better than falling down) School of Life (Awesome, Ryan Reynolds) Fanboys (Hilarious nerd comedy) 10 Thing I hate about you (Obvious, said you guys where going to) Sex Drive (Very funny, Seth green) the three musketeers 1993 (Swashbuckling comedy) Jurassic World (Dinos) AVP ( Alicen Vs Predator ) the Voices 2014 (Funny Ryan Reynolds) Free Willy (90's kids grew up on this classic tale) Homeward Bound (Cute animals, great story, Michael J Fox) I now pronounce you chuck and Larry (death by laughter) Animatrix (Really cool animated sci-fi) A.I. Artificial Intelligence (Cool and sad Sci-fi) IQ (Awesome Romcom) Mighty Ducks (Feel good sports comedy) Bill & Ted Bogus Journey/face the music Real Steel (Feel good family action comedy) cant hardly Wait (Good graduation comedy) Spectral 2016 (cool little action movie) Van Wilder (Hilarous, young Ryan Reynolds) Amazing Spiderman 1/2 (No way home hits different, you'd love it) A score to settle (Good Nicolas Cage Action) rubber face (Jim Carrey is Rubbe face) Stewart Little (Jonathon Lipnicki, Michael J Fox) The Little Vampire (Jonathon Lipnicki)

Lloyd Franklin

I can read, but when it comes to books, I just can't. When I try, everything plays in a monotone voice in my head, and I can't tell if someone is shouting, whispering, upset, or happy. It makes reading books boring. I use Audible instead.

Śéáń

I encourage anyone who has now seen this film to go and watch the trailer, just to show *how much of the film* it gave away from beginning to end.

Cartoons ReAct

Well...you guys should watch the tv show Hell on Wheels if you want more of Colm Meaney

Keith Jones

Foxy is sneaky, not sexy? Someone clearly needs to watch Disney's Robin Hood.

Lessiarty

For the hypothetical, I'd pick DUI. Just get plastered and go cruising. I wouldn't have to actually hit anybody or cause an accident, just the act of driving drunk would be eliminated. That alone would save thousands of lives.

MeetMountain

I agree about the end but chalk it up to, “they did it because it’s cool.” I also heard that Fox made them change the ending. But that’s just something I heard. It was already so bombastic that it just ended with him dying by his own bomb.

OddThomas

Of all the films I've seen, this is one of them.

Cartoons ReAct

George mentioned his subtitles were delayed, might be why he removed them

Cartoons ReAct

Yes, literally everyone also thought the ending f4cked it all up. Also, seems the ending was supposed to be different but they didn't want for the "evil" person win at the end

Cinebinge

unfortunately the amazon prime subtitles were delayed and not uniformly that can be fixed with a single offset, it was delayed gradually and accumulatively across the whole movie as if .001% per line until by the end it was several seconds delayed while at the start it was barely noticeable.

JonBjSig

I think the word you were looking for George is sly. As in "sly as a fox". Btw great answers to my question. Bribery is probably what I'd pick as well. Don't think I could stomach committing anything actually harmful to another human being.

thomas king

I hope u give it a 2nd watch. You spoke over some important dialogue. Per example Colm Meaney's character mentions Clyde had tunneled into all the solitary cells. U missed that and George later mentioned "That Clyde knowing which cell he would be in made no sense. Well the explaination was given but u 2 talked over it and missed it. For the most part I enjoyed the reaction. But counted 9 times I got frustrated and shouted STFU at the screen cause you talked over important dialogue.

Brandon

I don't remember the exact wording of Ebert's review, but he said it's a movie you can enjoy while you're watching it. As soon as it's over, you realize how absurd it all really is. That ending is really dumb, though. F. Gary Gray also made 'Friday'. I think his best movie is probably 'Set It Off'. A really underrated heist flick from the late 90s.

Zen Reacts

Movie would have been perfect if Jamie Fox wasnt such a drama queen about the ending

Com1xguy

I have the same issue as Simone with some shows and movies when enjoying gummies.

Ville Nurmi

Only bad thing about this movie is the wrong guy won

Morion Williams

They not only showed the holes into each of the cells they even said he tunneled into each of the cells. so it didnt matter which cell he got as long as he was in solitary.

Ashton Lewis

The most unsatisfying bad guy wins film ever made

Lloyd Franklin

If you were paying attention, George, the film says he tunneled under every cell.

Stoodles

This is one of my favorite movies (except the ending). I would also love to see you watch the movie Fracture with Anthony Hopkins and Ryan Gosling. Its a similar style move, but different. Another severely underrated amazing movie.

Tinfoilnation

You both missed an element, granted it goes by pretty fast, but they showed that Clyde didn't know which solitary cell he was going to end up in... so he tunneled into *ALL* of them.

The Audio-Technica 2035 Microphone

There was an original ending to this that had Clyde successfully executing his plan and getting away so the ending has always felt like well how do we spin this to me.

Jonathan Eaton

After reading the comments, I have a question? When are you holding the public flogging of George for his crimes committed during the watching of this film, and will it be streamed live? 😂

Joseph salazar

The ending yeah it’s always gets people

ChiefKC

Your reaction to the judge's killing was priceless.

Luca Spurgeon

"Competent people doing things competently..." Please, please, PLEASE add 'Blackberry' to your lists or find a way to just mix it in. A pretty incredible movie surrounding a Canadian company regarding the story about their rise due to their competency - the very thing you continue to stress you love watching - and that movie has it all. lol So please add. Its like 'The Social Network' meets the smart phone. You wont regret it :)

Shibby

They have to talk or it doesn't count as a reaction and will get taken down.

Jaaahn

why would they know when important dialogue would happen if theyve never seen it before. also, shouting at the screen over a pre-recorded video and getting mad at something as trivial as reaction videos is weird af.

OddThomas

Other good twisty thrillers: Sinister, Predestination, Malignant, The Village, eXistenZ, Vanilla Sky, The Strangers, Longlegs, Odd Thomas

djKENTO

About the audiobook for DCC and Simone talking about Jeff Hays and how he sounds like Patrick Warburton... yeah he's admitted it started as an impression of Patrick Warburton. here's the thing... Patrick Warburton's son, Talon Warburton is very likely going to play Carl in the live action series they're making. Also Simone... listen to the audio book. Jeff Hays who reads them is playing Princess Donut in the live action series. Oh as for George, When you're done with them, check out the IMMERSIVE AUDIO TUNNEL version that Jeff remastered. They sell it on Jeff's site SoundBoothTheater.com It's a fully redone version with more voice actors than just Jeff (though he covers all the parts you'd want him to) and it has music and special effects. It's also paced differently, more like a tv show and it's not just reading the lines, it's breathing and sighs and more natural sounding. It's great for your second go through.

Nathan Jasper

Well, Simone, you wanted gore. You got it 😆😆😆 of course animated gore is different but still lol

Chad Laurence

Damn stop talking over the dialogue guys lol.

Chad Laurence

No Larb, I said the same thing, like stop talking over the dialogue.

thomas king

I didn't say they should be quiet.

DeAndrew Greene

The way I took the ending was that they couldn't kill him outright, they couldn't outsmart him, so they gave him the tools to kill himself while offering him the chance to take a different path and he chose the path of vengeance. He killed all the people involved and a bunch of innocent people and it still wasn't enough. I would have done the ending a little different but him dying by his own hand essentially doesn't bother me.

thomas king

No one said don't talk. But sometimes they get so wrapped into their own dialogue that they miss important parts of the plot not paying attention. It is common with other reactors too. Angelina comes to mind immediately.

Michael Rawson

I was fine with the ending. This way the city gets to cover up what the people would view as unbelievable incompetence, having a prisoner enter and leave solitary at will. Letting him blow up part of the prison accomplishes two things - a, it makes Butler's character kill himself - he had every opportunity to not detonate the bomb, allowing the lawyer and cop be able to pass lie detectors that they didn't kill him - or at least they can tell themselves at night they are not murders. b, they can just say there was gas explosion or something, and the repairs would let them hide the tunnels. They'd have to still come up with how people were assassinated but the most egregious embarrassing factors could be hidden. As for Chester - they said many times she was dating him, and I'm pretty sure Chester was just forwarding an email that showed up when he went through her stuff after she died. So it was her and her contact in Panama that solved it,. What I think most people miss about this movie is Butler's character was very bad person who happened to have a cute kid and a wife who survived a tramatic event. He was already a sociopath and had no problem killing people. The ex-cia guy makes it clear Butler's character viewed the whole thing as a chess match - killing the cell mate was just taking out a pawn - also an my impression was that that was the one act that seemed to disturb him briefly - in his career he would kill people from a crazy distance and the only other person we know he killed directly with his own hands was the killer of his family, he seemed disgusted and kind of shocked for like two seconds after he kills the cellmate before he laid on his bed.

Logan Nelson

Killing is not inherently the highest moral wrong, but neither do I believe that a desirable outcome automatically justifies any means used to achieve it. The means still matter. Intent, necessity, certainty, proportionality, and the availability of alternatives all matter. My position is that in an extraordinary circumstance where it is genuinely certain that taking one life is the only available way to prevent vastly greater unjust loss of life, refusing to act simply to preserve the principle that “killing is always wrong” could itself become the less moral choice. That is not an argument that the ends justify the means; it is an argument that, in rare cases, morality requires us to weigh the consequences of both acting and refusing to act.

Jobbe Smit

Yeah it did not stick the ending but it's still a really interesting movie.

REDR58

Or “cunning”

Sporty Taco

In my mind, Clive was the hero to the end while Jamie Foxx transitions from villain to tyrant (not quite to the extent of the tyranny of Viola Davis' character. Ironically, the movie is set in Philadelphia, long time home of Benjamin Franklin who once said, "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." Throughout the movie, Clive is (by all accounts that can be proven) a law abiding citizen. The viewer knows otherwise because we see the magic behind the curtain. He is only caught when those sworn to uphold the law violate the law themselves (gleefully, I might add). Clive's intent was to expose the criminal justice system for the dog and pony show it had become. Elimination of the tyrannical mayor would have been the grand finale. In the end, the corrupt system is the victor.

Sporty Taco

Would have been better without Foxx period. He plays the same character in every single movie. The same mannerisms, the same inflection, etc.

Thall

I feel like there are humane and reliable methods to lethal inject someone, but as the US loves their cruelty and extra punishment on top of being imprisoned they don't use 'em.

Sporty Taco

He didn't get everyone. Foxx still needed to go and the mayor earned a spot on the list by trampling on the liberty of every person in the city.

Maxi_Rad

I love how one of the biggest mysteries in the movie for y'all was Chester lmao I only saw that character as a way to show that Sarah was adopting the same lack of Home-Work balance as Nick, using her boyfriend as a source for her job.

Anthony.Smith

I know you guys get an email for every comment and I hope you read this. First off, i want to just say Clyde is NOT crazy. He is not insane. He didnt experience one bad day and then lost his mind. His mind is fully intact. We as people are often quick to assume someone who does something like this must have lost their mind and gone crazy. It is a mistake to do so. The overwhelming majority of violent crime, including that which is most horrific, are not done by crazy or insane people. Even the overwhelming majority of serial killers are not "insane" from a legal standpoint. The second thing I want to say, which is the main thing, is that this film is not about senseless violence and thus Clyde's senseless violence does not undermine the point he is trying to make. His attitude isnt in regards to the senseless violence that killed his family; it is in regards to a concept in political science and sociology called "The State of Exception," as well as a broader critique of the Western Liberal justice system. The state of exception is a concept that should, for the most part, be self explanatory. The state doesnt just have a structure of laws that citizens must abide by, it has a structure of laws that itself must abide by. A state of exception is just that, it is a moment in which the law itself feels that in order to solve a problematic situation, it must circumvent its own rules in order to bring society back into order, and this is ultimately, the problem with the state of exception. It is about maintaining order, not creating peace. It is about maintaining power, not actually solving problems. It is about a system that already has a monopoly on violence violating itself to enact more violence. It is about a system that cares more about perceived fairness than about actual justice. Let's start from the top and work our way down. When a state of exception arises, or rather, when a situation occurs that the state decides to categorize as an exception, it does so under the pretense of establishing some kind of peace that was disturbed, namely a peace associated with a maintained order, when in fact categorizing it as an exception so that it can deal with it the way it wants to or needs to, is only about maintaing order. Furthermore, keeping the order or reestablishing it is the mechanism by which the system maintains its power over us, and if you haven't noticed, the system only declares a state of exception when its power is threatened, aka when order, not peace, is disrupted. This brings us to the more general criticism of the western liberal justice system, but we will come back to the list. There are so many instances, especially under capitalism, which is why it is a critique of western liberal justice systems in particular, all of which are capitalist, where it would be to the benefit of the people for the state apparatus to declare a state of exception and just doesnt. This also illustrates how it is inherently about holding on to its structural power, not about solving problems that need to be solved. Take for instance the rich and powerful men that do terrible unethical things, like when corporations dump chemicals into fresh water sources or pollute the environment and lie to the public about it. What they are doing under current guidelines is not illegal, but it is objectively and undeniably unethical. Because of that, and because of situations where it's like "well we cant PROVE that this particular company dumped chemicals there even though it is the only company close enough to do so and with the financial capabilities to have access to the amount of chemicals they are dumping." Clearly, in situations like these, it would be to the benefit of all of society for the state apparatus to circumvent its own rules about rights that it grants people, and violate the civil liberties of capitalist owners and their companies in order to hold them accountable for what we know they are doing but cant outright prove, or hold them accountable to acting unethically despite not being illegal. It is very obvious that the state apparatus doesnt do this, because these actions are not of a violent nature, and thus, do not threaten order and by extension, do not threaten its power. Now depending who you ask, they might define these actions by corporations as inherently violent in nature, but unfortunately, it is not how the state defines violence. When a corporation like DuPont gets found guilty and held liable for deaths as a result of dumping chemicals, they arent charged with murder, just gross negligence. The most important point is how this is a critique on perceived fairness as opposed to actual justice. The main thematic point of the film, the lesson that is learned by our, let's say, reluctant hero Jamie Foxx, is that you dont make deals with murderers. There is no such thing as a littlw bit of justice. There either is or there isnt, and as Clyde pointed out, while the system might be broken, so long as you FIGHT for justice, even if you fail to achieve it, you can still hold your head high. If you have a system where you lay the foundation of categorizing criminal activity and punishment, that is what the justice system has decided is justice. You kill someone, you get so many years. That, and only that, is justice. When you start doing things like making deals or letting criminal out for good behavior, that isnt sacrificing some justice so that you get a little as opposed to risking getting none; that is itself no justice. If the son of a mother is murdered in the first degree and the system says as a baseline says the killer deserves 25 to life, and you drop that 25 years to anything lower, for any reason, including they have agreed to testify against some all powerful murdering kingpin or something, you didnt give that mother "a little bit" of justice; you robbed her of it completely, because 25 years was the baseline defined by the justice system for what justice is. To go a little deeper into the perceived fairness aspect of it, this has to do with adherence to the golden rule that everyone is equal under the law. Unfortunately, I am sorry to say, this is bullshit, and not everyone is equal under the law and not everyone should be. This is because crimes are not people, and the law doesnt treat people, it treats crimes. Someone who is accused of stealing a TV from a department store does not deserve to be treated the same way as someone who is accused of murder, because these crimes are completely different. Someone who committed murder deserves to be held to a higher standard of scrutiny than someone who didnt. It also doesnt recognize that wealth creates inherent inequality, and that needs to be addressed in the process of finding justice. If Elon Musk is accused of murder and average Joe Nobody is accused of murder, the literal financial, social, and political power that Musk has needs to be taken into account in how his case is scrutinized. We are talking about people who have the means to kill people by having them killed rather then doing it themselves, and paying exorbitant amounts of money to the people they get to do it, or to their families so that they are taken care of while they are in jail. We are talking about people who have the means to bribe law enforcement and judges, to have evidence planted or erased, while we sit around, twiddling our thumbs pretending like that sort of thing doesnt happen or cant happen or won't ever happen. To go a bit further, we also treat different crimes of varying degrees as similar or worse. The notion that someone who sells drugs can be tried for murder and sentenced to life because they sold drugs to 3 people who then OD'd is quite literally insane. That is not the same thing as going out and randomly just stabbing a passing stranger on the sidewalk in the middle of the night, and yet, if you do that, you'd be lucky to spend 10 years in prison. Like, you dealt drugs, and you should be punished accordingly. The indirect outcomes of your crimes are irrelevant to justice. We all make choices, even addicts, and while you may have given them the drugs, you didnt force them to take it. We have a system that is based too much on the notion of "legality" and not centered around the concepts of morality and ethics. Society likes to talk a whole lot about both, but when it comes to the places where they are needed the most, like in the justice system, they are virtually nonexistent. Clyde says to the judge "Apparently i just killed two people, and you were about to let me walk right out that door." He presents us with confronting the fact that while his guilt may not have been proven, he already presented the system with a situation that it should have deemed a state of exception, and given the horrific nature of the crime itself, demands that his civil liberties be violated temporarily regardless of some, in his words, legal precedent that seeks to establish some base of "fairness". However, because it was two criminals that Clyde killed, his crime only vaguely disrupted peace, not order. It isnt until he goes above and beyond and starts killing government officials that order, and thus the power and control that belongs to the structure, is threatened, and then and only then is our reluctant hero given permission to circumvent the laws own rules to solve the problem. Before all those people were killed, if the law did that, well, the law would have only succeeded at benefiting the public, protecting anyone else from getting killed. It wasnt until solving the problem directly benefited the state apparatus, waiting until its power and control was threatened, that it took the required action. In our society, so many innocent people are imprisoned or worse, put to death because of this misguided adherence to some golden rule of fairness that isnt even real. Worse, so many guilty people go free or arent even held accountable because of the same attitude, this adherence to golden rules that dont exist.

Denis Yugov

Chester was Sarah's boyfriend. He just emailed Nick something that Sarah got from her source in Panama(because that's the information they were looking for out there) but couldn't relay to Nick as she was already dead.

fadyq1326y1

Saw a few people comment on talking, i personally dont mind that as long as the uploads have subs. Please do uploads with subs in the future, noticed on some of your other uploads from the past too

Ari Ramirez

This would make for a great one off miniseries if it were to be remade today

Robinson vs. Parkinson's

I've got the perfect answer for the crime that I would commit to make sure it would never happen again: Ponzy scheme!

DeAndrew Greene

I mean he killed numerous innocent people who just happened to show up to work on the wrong day. He's not the hero of the story and neither is Foxx. Foxx just sort of learned his lesson while Butler didn't. Mayor did a lot but he was a domestic terrorist blowing up people for his own sense of "justice" which in itself was hypocritical considering he worked for the CIA. How many innocent people did he help kill while just "doing his job".

Logan Nelson

I mean... Airplane mode would solve the whole cell problem lol

Deco

Never thought about the tax payers, blowing up the prison was a bit stupid

Zoe Hart

That has been American cinema in a nutshell since Vietnam. It was literally a decree from the Government.

Eversharpe

War declarations are not a crime. The one crime that would change the world would be wage theft.

funky weapon

The biggest issue with this movie is that Jamie Foxx is completely unlikeable. He's a complete asshole who only cares about his ambition and his ego. Having him also act like the moral authority of the film puts him at odds with the audience who ultimately agree with Clyde. Clyde is so sympathetic and Gerard Butler is so compelling that it completely turns the entire morality of the film on its head. The fact is that the justice system failed him and his family. Everyone involved from Foxx to the judge to the assistant prosecutor were treating the entire situation like a game where the goal was padding their stats to look good for an eventual run at the mayorship. None of them actually cared about Clyde or getting justice for his family. The biggest example of this is when Foxx actually looks at the crime scene photos from the case and says something like "okay, I get it." Clyde should've "won" in the end. The entire film was about exposing how corrupt and self-serving the justice system was and the people involved were shown to be completely at fault for it. Even the supposed "innocents" were just as responsible because they sat back and allowed this corruption to fester, uninterested in the pursuit of truth and justice and instead about playing their silly political games. Seriously. Not one person tried to empathize with Clyde. No one asked what he wanted. They just did what they thought was best for their careers and told the silly little victim to shut up and accept that this is an imperfect system. Anyway I'm rambling but that's why the ending is so unsatisfying to me. The whole film supports one character and one side of the argument and then pulls the rug instead. Jamie Foxx's redemption is completely unearned and so was his victory.

Frank

Sadly, that seems to be the case with all trailers, now. Studios do a great job of making 30 second teasers. I try my best now to avoid trailers because they feel the need to spoil the main parts (I still have no idea why bc everyone seems to unanimously agree and hate it)

Frank

I hadn't seen this in a while and was looking forward to the t-bone kill and completely forgot about the judge being taken out

Ashton Lewis

Exactly this. Jamie Foxx's character is an immoral cesspit from start to finish, who's obsession with winning meant that the man who commited the worst crimes and ruined Clyde's life only got a slap on the wrist and he basically told Clyde to get over it, pretending he cares about at least some justice being done when really he only cared about his prosecution stats. Rewarding that character with the "win" has always been baffling to me. And as George mentioned, the fact that Foxx's character won by committing the same crime everyone is so angry with Clyde for, and somehow framing this as the moral high ground is laughable. Im fine with Clyde dying, and I'm sure his character wouldn't mind it so much either, but Nick should have either have died too or at least taken some responsibility. Nick sucks ass

Rachiebubbles

Highly Highly recommend A Time to kill (1996). Law, court room drama. I wont say any more or whos in it. But would make a really good reaction plus a good film. Amazing stacked cast as well.

Śéáń

I'll the same, sometimes I'll watch about half abs if it seems like something I'm interested in, I'll turn it off. I even tried to avoid casting news if I can. Helps a lot to preserve twists in a story.

Gratch... just Gratch

Personally I've always found this a bit of a silly movie. Butler's "revenge" is unfocused and hard to pin down. They act like Foxx is a scumbag but his reasons for doing the trial the way he did are valid. There was a reasonable chance that a jury trial could have ended in an acquittal. Do we really believe that if his family's killer had been acquitted Gerard Butler wouldn't be angry at Foxx? And why is he just mad at the lawyers and the judge? Why not the cops? It's because Butler's character ordered the DA to do what he wanted and he's butt hurt that Jamie Foxx didn't give him what he wanted. He's just a deadly Karen demanding to talk to the manager and having a tantrum. But that being said, I'd never tell anyone they're wrong for liking this movie. If you enjoyed it than that's great.

Dan

Re the "crime" question... Declaring war isn't inherently a crime, and it also it's not a necessary part of conflict. In fact, it's kinda out of style now and war is rarely declared in modern conflicts. Here's my idea: bicycle theft. Because I could steal a cheap bike and it's a minor enough crime, but if bicycle theft went away with all the attendant costs and inconveniences of security I think it have disproportionate benefit and would be a significant factor in encouraging cycling.

Duncan

After the way they both coped with the first 2 minutes of this movie, nobody needs to be recommending ''The Accused (1988)'' Jodie Foster

REDR58

Based on John Grisham's 1989 novel of the same name. Most of the movies made from his books are great.

REDR58

If you want to watch reactors silently watching the movie, how is that interesting?

REDR58

And then people complain when scenes in a trailer do not appear in the finished movie.

Chad Laurence

Did I say that? The point is, they miss important dialogue because they're talking at the wrong times. That's all. They're usually good, but this time it was excessive lol.

Chad Laurence

@Shibby, Nah. They were silent for periods of time not saying anything so I dont buy that.

Chad Laurence

@thomas, that guy is trying to gaslight you lol. They have no argument so they need to go to the other side of the spectrum with "so you don't want them to speak ever!?" Lol. It's ridiculous.

REDR58

Yes it is!

Ken

Move over Jack, here comes Simone Handey - Stoned Thoughts...... We are here for it Simone, publish the videos!!

REDR58

2009 movie... For me everything between 2001 and 2016 or so was pretty much a blur. Never answer the door to somebody you don’t know or are not expecting. Ever. Yay! A movie set in and filmed in and around Philadelphia! The large statue first seen is of William Penn on the top of City Hall. You saw Bruce McGill (Jonas Cantrell, District Attorney) in “Collateral” with Jamie Foxx where he played FBI Agent Frank Pedrosa. Carrying out sentence in death penalty cases can go for on for *years* due to appeals and such. A former acquaintance/person I was friendly with in Boy Scouts in the 1980s is a serial killer has been on death row for almost 20 years and was incarcerated at a prison that borders the land of a house I used to live at from 1998-2000. When that prison was shut down and replaced with a new one on the same property, he was moved there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Eichinger There has been a moratorium on executions in Pennsylvania since 2023. Holmesburg Prison, as seen in the movie, has been shut down since 1995: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holmesburg_Prison The Who song Clyde listens to, "Eminence Front" is a great song: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BfrUQA2tb6M Leslie Bibb (Sarah) was in Iron Man and Iron Man 2 and Tag. As she says in the movie, she really was 35 years old. The guy they meet in the tunnel with the black cap, Bray, played by Michael Kelly, who you recognized from Dawn of the Dead was also in Man of Steel, Unbreakable and The Penguin. The scene with the robot with the caterpillar tracks and .50 caliber heavy machine gun/rocket launcher was filmed at Laurel Hill Cemetery, where Rocky‘s wife Adrian and Paulie were also (eventually) buried: https://laurelhillphl.com The real mayor of Philadelphia, Michael Nutter, is holding the bible when Nick is sworn in after the attack at the cemetery. He was mayor of the city from 2008 to 2016. The email address Nick receives in the mail from Chester after the attack mentions "Philadelphia City Hall Procurement Department Philadelphia PA 19102–1685" That department is real and the address is correct! Likewise, the Fax number 215-686-4716 was a real fax number, but doesn't seem to be active anymore. I just tried calling it and got no answer or fax tones. None of the civilian vehicles seen throughout the movie seem to have front license plate, which is correct for Pennsylvania. Too many times with movies set in Philadelphia but filmed elsewhere have license plates on the front of civilian cars, which is wrong. F Gary Gray also directed “The Italian Job” (2003) which is inspired by the original 1969 movie of the same name with Michael Caine and you should watch both movies. Del Frisco’s Double Eagle Steakhouse was opened in 1981 and is still in business. www.delfriscos.com

Duncan

Not true, Clyde achieved his end goal, which was to re correct Nick's mindset on the law and true justice, he moved all the pawn pieces so that Nick was placed in to the highest place of power, as the acting DA, where he can now ensure proper true justice is served moving forward. Clyde was never just going to carry on with his life and live happily ever after, his life ended the night his wife and daughter were murdered. Clyde achieved exactly what he set out to.

Dauerempoerungskommentarspaltenkrachmacher

The screenplay, and especially the ending, was apparently rewritten several times. In my opinion, they somehow managed to arrive at the dumbest ending imaginable. !!!Spoiler warning!!! Throughout the film, we are carefully led to believe that one character (Clyde) is exceptionally intelligent, has virtually unlimited resources at his disposal (money, connections, and other assets) and is always several steps ahead of everyone else. The film spends roughly 80 percent of its runtime reinforcing this image through a series of gradual revelations, only to turn around at the end and essentially say: Actually, Clyde is too stupid to figure out an obvious chain of events. Even worse, being present at his daughter's concert is used to suggest that Nick is actually the hero of the story and has undergone some kind of positive transformation. In reality, the only way he can defeat Clyde is by breaking the law himself (conducting an illegal search) and then taking the law into his own hands, ultimately becoming a murderer by deliberately locking the "villain" up and leaving him to die. And yet, the film gives us absolutely no indication that Nick will face any consequences for what he has done. Quite the opposite: the way the ending is presented seems to endorse or at least legitimize his actions. That completely undermines the film's entire premise. As a viewer, I feel quite cheated. It's a great example of how to take a really well-made, gripping film and completely drop the ball in the home stretch. This also applies, incidentally, to the anonymous source, who can certainly be used in a story, but once the anonymous source becomes an active participant in the story, the screenplay needs to provide a satisfying reason for maintaining that anonymity. Details like this, as well as other smaller inconsistencies and quite a few loose ends, naturally add to the disappointment.

Dauerempoerungskommentarspaltenkrachmacher

By the way, I want subtitles!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Or in Canadian: I would be very grateful if you would consider adding subtitles to the movies where feasible. At least for me, when you're talking over the dialogue, it's impossible to follow both you and the movie if I can't read along. I haven't seen every movie, and even with the ones I have seen, I definitely haven't watched every single one so many times that I know the dialogue by heart. Just wanted to kindly mention that!

MacGuffinStuff

I had never actually seen this but it's been recommended to me so many times, well it was better than I expected, a lot, up untill, yeah the end. Also it gave me big Seven (or Se7en, whatever) vibes with the planning and the sort of dark revenge against the world aspect. Although obviously this character's justifications were relatable, if not his methods. But that mirror torture murder I have heard is or was a Mexican cartel thing, they duct tape you to a chair, put a mirror in front of you, cut off your eyelids, pump you full of drugs to keep you alive and conscious, then proceed to remove the rest of your face, and then you get to see what you look like underneath. It's supposedly for snitches I heard. But then again I don't even remember where I heard that and if anything maybe the cartels got the idea from this movie, also I heard they pumped you full of cocaine but that doesn't make sense because Cocaine can kill you and it has a numbing effect, but maybe that's part of it, so when you come down and the pain kicks in... Gruesome. Ever wonder how many messed up torture things that movies or books have actually inspired?

MacGuffinStuff

Also Simone you're still saying Colm Meaney's name wrong lol, those Irish names will get ya, it sounds more like a LOTR character than a grooming tool.

Matrim

Funny Simone would mention the VO for Kronk…

Joe D

Random fact the bridge that can be seen in the background when Gerard Butler is poisoning Darby is called the Girard Point Bridge. Not sure if it was coincidence or an Easter egg like the coordinates being the hotel they stayed at.

Matrim

Clyde absolutely won. So many people just breeze past most of the final confrontation because they’re pissed at the culmination. The moment he refuses to make any more deals, Clyde got what he wanted.

D Gyre

No one won. Clyde became what he hated, became just like the men who killed his family.

D Gyre

How did so many people vote for this movie... it's morally indefensible and unnecessary graphic. It's vigilante torture porn.

D Gyre

Yes, multiple murders is very law abiding. Ben Franklin belived in rule of law and having a government still, which requires surrendering some liberty for safety. You literally cannot have a society with out that. He certainly didnt mean anyone can be a vigilante if they feel like it. You don't get to go outside the law and you don't get to override every other citizens will just because you don't like something the system did.

D Gyre

Yes he is insane. The movie doesn't show that rule by law is gone (what you're trying to say with a state of exception). The system is created by the people, which means its full of imperfections and compromise between opposing views. One person doesn't get to go outside the system based on their own judgment. Your argument would end up with more people like the TV thief treated harshly while more murders would go free. You would end up with even more innocents or unfair sentences and less justice, the very thing you claim thus movie must "really" be about. You want to actually do something about the injustice you claim to care about, go vote in local and state elections, go advocate for reform, change the system through the democratic levers that exist instead of glorifying vigilantism.

D Gyre

Way better film than thus one.

D Gyre

People can enjoy bad movies for lots of reasons, it's people acting like Clyde is a hero and not a sympathetic villain in a horror film that has me shocked. Agreed everyone can enjoy what they want, he'll I LOVE boondocks saints, but let's not act like this is behavior to praise.

D Gyre

🤣 same

sb

Directed by F. Gary Gray who's 1st movie was "Friday" starring Ice Cube and Chris Tucker.

Cc Decc

Absolutely. So SO much smarter a treatment of this sort of thing. But I will say this channel seems to have almost intentionally sidestepped the Grisham movies thus far.

Cc Decc

Also BTW, The Next three Days (2010) shares some themes and setup, but is a much better movie overall with a stellar cast. Its a true thriller.

Sporty Taco

Vigilantism and eye-for-an-eye retribution was still very much a thing in Mr Franklin's day. As was tarring and feathering public officials that strayed from their sworn duties and exceeded their authority. Clive was fighting a corrupt system. No one that was killed was innocent. As Jefferson once put it, "The tree of liberty must be refreshed, from time to time, with the blood of patriots and tyrants." Yes, he believed government was necessary but deemed it a necessary evil. This is personified by Foxx' character swearing an oath to uphold the constitution and then immediately violating the 4th amendment with an illegal search. The true definition of liberty is being free to do whatever you want as long as you do not deliberately deprive another of life, liberty, or property by fraud or by force. I state this unironically as 1) justice should have been served with the conviction (and swift execution) of both perpetrators of the original crime, and 2) the judicial system and those sworn to serve it in this depiction had become criminally negligible and corrupted.

sb

Director F. Gary Gray makes a cameo as the detective that hands in the poison that corrupted Aames's lethal injection.

Scott CineRam

Please share more of those stoned thoughts, Simone. Here, I'll give you one of mine. I was watching The Matrix while very high, and I get to the scene with the kid and the spoon. The kid says, "It is not the spoon that moves, it is only yourself." And I went, Oh! In the Matrix, if the spoon is no more real than his finger, that he should be able to bend the spoon as easily as he bends his finger.

Anthony.Smith

No, he is most definitely not insane. Insane is a legal term, which he would not fit. Insane means he is incapable of understanding the difference between right and wrong. He knows what he is doing is wrong. Again, he literally said "apparently, i just killed two people, and you were gonna let me walk right out that door." This illustrates objectively that he knew what he did was wrong as he points out the absurdity of the court getting ready to let him leave even though he apparently killed two prople, meaning he knows the court shouldnt let him leave, meaning he knows what he did was wrong. Did i simplify that enough for you? What I argued would not result in what you say, if the general actions of society itself were more ethical and moral. The idea that we would end up with more harsh sentences and more innocent people being punished, if morality and ethics were just as important as legality in a courtroom, really illustrates that you dont know what you are talking about. Also, please do not tell me to do those other things "instead of glorifying vigilantism." In absolutely no way, shape, or form am I doing that. I find your comment absurd and gross. Did I once say, in all I said, that i agreed with his actions? That is thought they were okay? No, i did not. In fact, I literally said that after he killed Ames and Darby, before he started killing anyone else, what he did was so bad that it already justified declaring a state of exception, to keep him locked up without a confession, in order to protect the public. "One person doesnt get to go outside the system based on their own judgement." You seems to not understand that this film is not about that, it is not about vigilantism. It is about THE STATE going outside the system, based on THEIR own judgement, a judgement that is only concerned to do so when its power is threatened, and refuses to so on the basis of simply protecting the public. Lastly I dont think you understood anything of what I was saying about the concept of the state of exception. I think political science and sociology is a little too complicated for your brain to understand, considering what you have said to me, especially saying something as asinine as I am glorifying vigilantism.

Billy T.

The ending of this movie is ass cheeks

akaTheBAY-AY-RON

This thumbnail makes me want to channel my inner Seinfeld and say ".......she had MAN hands..."

Mike MacColin

If you clip anything, clip your reaction to the judge's phone call! 😂

Mike MacColin

F Gray Gray also directed "The Negotiator" which is also a great thriller with a stacked cast.

Mike MacColin

The issue was not that Foxx didn't take it to court, but the reason why he didn't do it. He made a deal with Darby simply to further his own career - this whole thing was a political gambit that had nothing to do with justice at all.

BT

They are going to cover up Cylde's murder, from what I assume. Also, he's the DA now, so they'll cover it up. The other police guy is okay with it. lol Still a great film for 90% of it.

AnthemUnknown

The ending stumbles, but not for the reasons most people claim. People get mad because they wanted Clyde to blow up City Hall and ride off into the sunset, but the movie explicitly shows that Clyde won the ideological argument. He forced Nick to stop hiding behind plea deals and step outside the law to put down a monster. The real issue is that the third act feels completely rushed. They spend the whole movie building this elaborate chess match, only to slide all the pieces off the table in five minutes, which buries the actual thematic resolution under a hasty climax.

Nemo-the-Red

Literally came here to say this, the movie was so great, and then we got that ending. *Blows raspberry*

Nemo-the-Red

I really like that movie, just rewatched it a couple months ago, more melodramatic than I remember, but maybe im just more cynical than i used to be (there isnt a maybe there)

Nemo-the-Red

The Negotiator is a classic!

Jon

Pffft. The ending wishes it was ass cheeks.

Jon

Por que?

Jon

Are we just going to ignore the part where Simone said George hasn't seen The Emperor's New Groove??? I paused the video to comment this! That said, @Simone and @George, though this may make sense only to Simone, I have the silliest idea of a best friends Halloween costume pair for you two. Is Halloween a thing in Canadia?

Matrim

Have you listened to the Dungeon Crawler Carl audiobooks?

D Gyre

Your issue is not needing to over simplify but being too simple. The world is not that simple. Knowing what he is doing is wrong does not make it less insane/crazy to still do it. Don't dodge the point by claiming you only meant a legal definition. "If society was just better then everything would work!" Of course, but society isn't better nor will it be. That's the whole reason we have a justice system that presumes innocence first, why there are more protections against putting an innocent person in jail than letting a guilty one go free. Which you even mentioned as a problem, yet you propose a system that would only make that problem worse. Ah yes, I disagree with you so I must not know what I'm talking about. Morality and ethics are subjective. The spirit of them should be in the courtroom sure, but the law must be as objective as possible, which is why objective legality is more important in practice in the courtroom. What you're talking about only works if everyone has the same view of Morality. You are defending the idea of mass murder because it exposes what you see as problems in the system. You absolutely are glorifying it. You say you don't agree but everything else you proposes supported his actions. No that's what they wanted the film to be about, but the execution just makes Clyde look like a good guy. Sure, I know nothing about my own career field. Sure son. You think what you want, and I'll be grateful people like you aren't making the law. Then again looking around today maybe people like you are. Hopefully they can be stopped.

PunchNJewelee

Agreed, the music drops were a tad overdramatic. Very sad movie though.

D Gyre

Yes, he surely supported everything that existed in his time when applied to today and none of his views evolved over his lifetime. If you want to "tar and feather" public officials for failing at their jobs, demonstrate they failed and get them fired through the system, don't re-elect them, or work to change what you think is the loophole in the law. That's how you democratically fix the system. Don't go on a murder spree because you think your righteous and can go outside the will the of the people. Sure, its a catchy quote. Sounds cool. Not so much when you think about it in practice. Who decides who the tyrants are? The patriots? Who gets to choose to spill blood? People like Clyde (and apparently you) would use this as some kind of legitimacy for murder of people you deem corrupt, you deem deserving of death. But that's not how a democracy works, especially in the modern world. Fix the system by....fixing the system, through policy, through advocacy, through elections, through debate, you know through a *democratic* process that reflects the will of the people and ensures justice, not vengeance. Your definition of liberty, in the real world, requires a system to enable it. In reality, liberty requires tradeoffs, some group of people is always losing a little bit of liberty for a gain of liberty in another area, or for another group of people. It's a balancing act, and an imperfect one because people are imperfect (and that will never change). What you want isn't liberty for all, its liberty for you, regardless of others. 1) You don't get to decide this as an individual. Any given case, you could find some member of the public who would say this, while others feel justice is served. To have the liberty you defined, you have to accept the judgement of the system (which you get to vote and participate in to change if needed). You can have your own opinion, yes, I'm not saying that, I'm saying you don't get to take action/condone another taking action illegally against the system like Clyde did because you personally felt in this instance justice wasn't served. 2) There's the key phrase here, "criminally," There are different levels of the law, appeals courts, and state and federal legislatures that also are oversight on the system. If someone within the system has behaved criminally, then advocate for them to be charged and convicted. Deal with them through the system, have them exposed in the press. Again, one person doesn't get to deem the system forfeit and start killing people. And if you think the system is so broken it can't be fixed without completely replacing it, you think going on a murder spree is the answer, you better hope the VAST majority of people agree with you. Otherwise, you're just another murderer.

Sporty Taco

First and foremost - it's a movie. Settle down. Second - grammar. Learn it, use it. Third - if you think the US is a democracy, you aren't qualified to participate in its electoral process. The US never has been and was never intended to be a democracy. The only federal positions that were intended to be elected democratically are members of the House of Representatives. Period.

Crap Bag - first name Crap last name Bag

Apparently, Chester was supposed to be a plot twist where it turns out it was Gerard Butler, feeding them false information to execute his plan and win in the end. But of course they chickened out and gave us that shit ending. Love you both you make my commutes worth living.🤗

D Gyre

Yes it is a democracy. No one who actually studies democracy or works in political science limits democracy to only a pure direct democracy. Polity scores Freedom house, V-Dem project, and the US government all view the US as a democracy and use a definition that includes indirect/representative democracy. Arguing democracy only applies to a direct philosophical democracy is useless in a world where that won't exist. Regardless of what word games you want to play with the label, the legal system is created by laws passed by elected state legislatures and state officials, also elected or appointed by elected officials. The system is meant to reflect the will of the people(who often disagree significantly with each other). You can argue against that certainly but that's an entirely different justice system then, and not on reflecting the people.

MacGuffinStuff

George, you know what's fucked up about choosing BRIBERY? "Plata O Plomo" Silver or Lead. Without Silver there's only one other form of influence, the Stick. Bribery was considered the compromise to avoid violence, it's a sad fact of living in a predatory universe, could be worse, could be the Mist. Speaking of bribes, how much would it take for you to react to Defending Your Life?

Tyler Foster

The crime I'd commit to prevent it from happening again is close to what George says: political corruption.

Ben from Tenn

Cinebinge is the only way I make it through movies like this. And I voted for it 😑