blabbering about books: Wuthering Heights (Patreon)
Downloads
Content
new name, same old chaotic book reviews. in fact, i ended this one a bit dramatically cause i just had had enough of this book.
but hopefully you haven't :) cause we're yapping for a while today.
take this family tree, you'll need it. though it does not include Nelly, the main maid who is Hindley's agemate and our narrator.
also another thought I've had, as this is uploading, is the Saltburn as Wuthering Heights fanfiction (specifically the scene of Heathcliff digging up Cathy's grave to lie with her body made me think of this) to "Wuthering Heights" as Gone With The Wind fanfiction pipeline. But after reading this book I realized that, Catherine and Scarlett are racing in opposite directions. Catherine marries a rich man while still longing over a poor one. Scarlett is desperate to marry a rich man and ends up married to a scoundrel (who...also happens to be rich but through the dirty work of gambling instead of being good clean plantation owner 😒) who she grows to love too late.
okay wait i just read the wikipedia summary for the movie. (why is the hell is it over 2 hours long?) the comparison makes sense for the moment when Heathcliff leaves being similar to when Rhett leaves in GWTW -- main male character thinks female main character is not interested in him anymore but misses she saying that she actually deeply loves him and wants to keep trying. yawn.
also you know what? this book ain't sexy/romantic (minus maybe Cathy and Hareton's end but i find it very odd how flippant wealthy people are about marrying 1st cousins, anyway). the end of Cathy and Heathcliff's story (if you wanna stop there, which many adaptations do) is tragic, sure, but like there's a lot of fucked up and unfortunate stuff surrounding it that makes the love bit a lil hard to isolate. i think if i read this as a teen (mind you i had to read Breathing Underwater in the 9th grade so...maybe i got knocked out of the target audience to find this endearing mad early) i would've felt bad for Heathcliff (up to a certain point) but, similarly to Romeo & Juliet, more annoyed at the bad decisions than moved by the relationship.
i'm also so confused as to why there's a BDSM aspect in the film -- because of the controlling abuse? like i understand that we get Fifty Shades of Grey/Gabriel's Inferno from Twilight because the thread that's followed is "a couple with an extreme power imbalance that's amplified by wealth and emotional distance." how you read about a cycle of abuse and think "yeah that translates well into BDSM" is lost on me. and! according to the wikipedia article that aspect is introduced into the film via Joseph fucking on Zillah - which makes me wonder if there's a layer of classism painted onto certain sexual acts.
chile idk cause i still don't think i'll be watching it (136 minutes????) but i'm perplexed.