Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

i'm reporting live from my bed, having recently hopped in this bitch after an Oscar's watch party and i've got some thoughts. (bb we spat this out and queued it up, we sure did)

  • when i was reflecting on the NAACP awards, i said that awards season is a moment for industry peers to applaud each other. and i stand by that. but it's also a series of subjective choices made by humans who sometimes have, most famously in the Academy, not watched all the options and/or vote based on bias/relationship (personal or otherwise)/popularity and not on craft.

    • which is to say: i find career sympathy awards to be really annoying and (what feels like) most often awarded in years where there are breakthrough nominees that are great exemplars of the craft but who are put aside in favor of "finally" giving someone an Oscar (see also, the 2023 Oscars with Jamie Lee Curtis vs Stephanie Hsu).

    • i think both familiarity bias and "well he's been here enough to finally get it" was happening with One Battle After Another -- and, you know, i shouldn't undermine someone's win even if i think OBAA has some reckless and uninspiring narrative choices. but the director this award season has been particularly feckless and apolitical whilst being acclaimed for a film that is anchored by political signaling as set dressing - so fuck it.

      • i'm sure there's a better, more comprehensive reflection i could have about the praise of a film that uses a cardboard cutout of political thought as the background on which to explore an interpersonal story of a hapless white man directed by a shallow "auteur" who, in one of his many award speeches tonight, says this film is an apology to his children "for the housekeeping mess that we left in this world we're handing off to them" and then during a post-ceremony interview responds to a question about where society is heading by saying "aren't we supposed to be partying?" as a reflection of the industry - and perhaps country - as a whole that more interested in aesthetics than action, critical thought or genuine engagement with anything beyond that which brings immediate comfort with the least amount of mental pushback, especially in consideration to how their privileges may be challenged. but it's 11:36pm and i ate homemade ice cream at this party so my tummy hurts and 30% of my brain power is being diverted to processing that. (the ice cream was great but i'm intolerant-adjacent to lactose.)

  • The Sinners of it all. i was gonna say i don't have anything to add but i have three things actually

    • if this film wasn't up against The Career Sympathy Option of The Decade, i think the film would've raked in more awards. the secret ballot articles are always really interesting (read: frustrating) to gain insight to the thought processes and how, again, they can often not be based in just a consideration of the craft.

    • on the carpet for the Vanity Fair After-Party the hosts were asking folks their personal pick for best picture - and the rhetorical hoops white people were jumping through on the spot to defend why they didn't pick Sinners was irky as fuck. you're not racist if you liked Hamnet or Sentimental Value more! but your thinly veiled concern over being called "racist" being more pressing than an actual examination of behaviors and beliefs is annoying, destructive, useless and not, in any way, cute nor funny.

      • i saw a tweet that said "why were those people cheering extra loud for Sinners when they didn't vote for it?" and like yeah, that part - but also there's a lot of seat fillers it's not all academy members but like i get it! point made and felt.

    • when Michael B. Jordan won, a person at the party I was attending immediately said "oh he's never gonna have an opportunity like this again. He's a shitty actor." then quickly followed up with "he's a commercial actor."

      • actors in more "commercial" films do have a harder time getting Academy, or general award, recognition, yes. MBJ has not historically been in the best films or played the most dynamic roles, sure. for that to be the first words out of this person's mouth was a harsh and uncomfortable reminder that we are all not watching, attending or voting in these shows for the same reason or with the same perspective of what a vote or a win could mean. ironically in the kind of inverse of me ripping into PTA, i think it's deeply important for racialized creatives to be anchored in pride and excitement and a sense of accomplishment beyond The Academy - not because these accolades don't matter, because they do have their place and their weight - but because our independent sense of worth has to be stronger than shallow-minded, short-sighted perspectives of filmmaking and storytelling and art if we are to find the desire to wake up the next day and make the next thing again and again and again, which is ultimately the most important part.

  • shitty producers/cutting off people's speeches: idk who is producing (as in the physical production of deciding when to move to different camera angles or fade the lights) but ... The Academy should re-evaluate the decisions made.

    • i realized i don't like awards shows because of the bits inbetween each set of awards. i can't recall them being this bad two years ago when i last watched but i don't understand the decision to spend more times on bits that were either blatant ads for upcoming projects (why are Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans and his new wig giving out the screenplay awards?) or uncomfortably long attempts at pop culture references (the subway surfers joke was...so dumb and a waste of time). especially in light of many speeches getting cut off. i'm here to listen to the creatives express appreciation and surprise! the way the awardees from K-Pop Demon Hunters were cut off while receiving the Oscar for Original Song was really fucking disgusting (and on par with how the ceremony treats international, specifically non-European, speakers I've noticed) and i'm really glad a reporter asked for the whole speech later.

  • Jessie Buckley's speech made me tear up. i will always have a soft spot for when someone gets to talking about motherhood. shout out to Ireland, all my niggas and Ayo Edebiri love Ireland.

well, that's it divas. fresh from my kitchen to yours. did you watch the Oscars (live or through social media)? Do you have any thoughts on the awardees? Do you have any thoughts on the looks? lemme know.

Comments

No comments found for this post.