Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The two went on foot. Elder Rui, now Sect Master Rui, didn’t bother saying where it was or how long the trip would take. It didn’t really matter. Left unsaid was that if they didn’t go, they would only be guests in the Monastery from now on. It would no longer be their home. 

Tian wasn’t sure how he felt. He felt too many things to be only feeling the one thing- frustrated, furious, sad, curious, resentful, and perhaps above all irritated. At this point, his bowl was overflowing with more good things than he could realistically eat in a short time. He didn’t care about the Sky Treading Art. Maybe it was amazing. Maybe it was the best qi-and-shen art this side of the Celestial Court. It didn’t matter, because he didn’t have the damn time!

The root of it was that they were jamming him into a relationship he didn’t want by holding hostage all the relationships he did want. Rui was using soft methods, as soft as he could, and doing it as politely as he could, but it was still extortion and manipulation, and not very subtle at that. 

“Why now?” Liren asked seemingly out of the blue.

“Why what now?”

“Why is he forcing this now? Why not in a week, or a month, or a year? He doesn’t know about Voidcatcher’s deadline. As far as he knows, we are stuck on the mountain indefinitely with the rest of the Monastery. So why does it have to be practically as soon as we arrive?”

Tian mulled it over. “Did you see Brother Wang’s robe?”

“Eh?”

“Core disciple. Either he didn’t have a true revelation of the dao, or he refused to take a master, same as us. I don’t know how enlightened he is, but I know he’s careful and mistrusting of authority to the middle of his bones. Either way, that means the last three people who might have been direct disciples all disqualified themselves because they didn’t trust the sect to be responsible teachers. That’s not just a political problem. That’s the kind of thing that kills sects.”

“There is more to it, I’d bet. Resource shortage means we get elements of the siege mentality, though not nearly so bad of course. No new people to talk to, seeing the same faces over and over every day. That has to wear on you. All of this coming on top of how we left the sect in the first place.”

“When I ripped the face off the whole damn monastery.”

“I prefer to think of it as you having a Free and frank exchange of views in the Hall of Harmony,” Liren offered.

“The sect is running on a lot of rumors, and since none of our brothers and sisters are dumb, they are probably fairly accurate rumors.”

“He made us direct disciples as soon as we reached the Monastery.” Liren walked up the mountainside as though it were flat land, eyes forward, looking for their destination, or danger. She had stopped wearing the veil, but she kept the broad hat. She had come to prefer it.

“In name. He needs a win. Something to solidify his position in the sect, and mark a real change. More than that, he needs some tangible proof that what he is offering is worthwhile. If two big holdouts against the previous… regime? Administration?”

Liren just shrugged, not caring what Tian called it. “If we accept, we are saying we wouldn’t accept being taught by the former sect leader, but will accept being taught by his master, and by extension, him. We won’t be part of Starsieve’s lineage. We will be part of Cruel Treachery's lineage, with the added benefit of you bridging the gap thanks to your father being Starsieve’s disciple. We will help legitimize him, and stabilize his administration. It will be a big boost for morale too.” She put the rest of it together. Living in the City Lord’s palace had been an education on top of the one they had already gotten in the Monastery. It helped when you could snoop on all the parties to a conversation, and see the schemes they thought went unseen.

They let the conversation fall fallow. The mountain was no less beautiful than they remembered. Each leaf and branch of each tree seemed to seethe with life. The vibrancy of the water, the sweetness of the reeds in the morning sunlight, so different from the steppe grass and myrtle around Burning Flag City. The thought made Tian smile, then laugh.

“We are half way up a magic mountain, and still breathing mortal air. What fine reclusive daoists we are. What superb mountain ascetics!”

The two walked until late afternoon, not rushing, not going slow. The token led them to a half-hidden valley, more of a fold in the rock than anything else. They were slightly spooked when the token dissolved a concealing array on an unremarkable stretch of the rock face. They hadn’t even suspected it was there. 

“Juniors Tian Zihao and Hong Liren have come to greet Daoist Master Cruel Treachery." Tian announced, standing by the entrance to the cave.

There was a long silence, then a subtle beckoning. No words, just a feeling they should enter. Tian glanced at Liren, who glanced back. They went in, side by side.

The cave was shallow. They were only a dozen yards in, when they found Cruel Treachery. She was sitting on a worn and ragged prayer mat at the end of the shallow cave. The space around her was narrow, she could have touched both walls stretching out her arms, and she wasn’t a big woman. She was, to Tian’s quiet surprise, entirely bald. Her robes were the blue and white of the Monastery, but of a material so fine, Tian couldn’t even guess its name or nature. Some manner of celestial silk, perhaps. It carried no ornamentation. It didn’t need any. Simple quality of materials and perfection of craftsmanship said everything necessary. 

“Once you have achieved a certain degree of mastery over shen, the so-called silent communication used in the Heavenly realm is no different than shouting. I mention this so you will understand. Your thoughts are heard here. Your words to each other are heard. And yes, I heard you as you walked up the mountain.”

Her lips weren’t moving. Her eyes didn’t open either. She remained sitting in lotus, her breath slow and steady as the mountains’. 

“Your deductions were correct, as far as they went. You forgot the other question you should be asking. ‘Why send you to me?’”

Tian blinked. He thought the answer was quite obvious.

“Only partially obvious, Junior Tian. The part you are leaving out is that I trained disciple Rui. I’m the one who showed him the virtue of the thinking that led to your beloved West Town Outer Court. If the hell of your childhood can be traced directly to the policies of old Starsieve and… do you really think his name is Dog Nose? That’s hilarious.”

Her face didn’t so much as twitch. 

“I’m not telling you his real name.”

Tian struggled mightily to keep his mind empty.

“Anyway. If the worst things in your life can be traced back to them, your happiest childhood memories, the best part of your time in the Outer Court, the foundation of the rising strength in the sect, can all be traced back to me. It may be arrogant to say, but it is those who follow my teachings who are the hope of creating the sect as you wished it was. This is your opportunity to make it as you wish it to be.”

“Or else.” Tian didn’t let the words escape his lips, but the difference was nil.

“Or else, yes. We won’t be cruel about it, but you will be saying, very directly, that you do not wish to be associated with what truly makes us a sect. What would you do in our place?”

“What would your requirements of us be?” Liren asked. She spoke softly, but her words echoed off the narrow walls, filling the space with the weight of the question.

“Be filial.”

Tian controlled his snort. He really was trying to be polite, but his endless education on what ‘filial behavior’ meant left him unwilling to entertain the opinions of others on the subject. Nor was he willing to pledge it to a stranger.

“You know I can feel your neck stiffening. It’s usually a metaphor, but in your case, both your cases, I can feel it’s literally true. My disciple really didn’t exaggerate. You aren’t overawed by my cultivation either, because you have seen, and studied under, beings far more powerful than I. Nor are you particularly worried about punishment, given the circumstances and the notorious outcome of Junior Tian’s last public correction. What a day for laughs.”

Treachery’s face remained still and impassive. Perhaps she was laughing on the inside. 

Tian didn’t say anything. He was too old a hand at meditation to think he could silence his thoughts entirely, so he turned them to cultivation instead. Verdant Spring was an old friend. He could cultivate that while doing almost anything else, short of fighting. 

“What would you ask of a student? What would you demand from a disciple?” Treachery asked.

The memory of Han in the courtyard flashed into Tian’s mind. “Be true to yourself. Conduct yourself in the world in a way that won’t make me ashamed to acknowledge you as my student. Do your best to uphold the virtues of compassion, humility and frugality.”

The silence hung heavy on them again. He had the uncomfortable feeling that she was dissecting the fleeting memory he had revealed, picking it apart and trying to understand him.

“And you, Junior Hong?”

“The same.”

“Really the same?”

“More or less. I’d have skipped the three supreme virtues. I think they are implied by the previous sentence.”

“Heavens.” The thought sounded simultaneously indifferent and helpless. “You do understand that the practical difference between what you and I asked for is nothing, and the symbolic difference is everything.”

“Phrasing matters. I was told so repeatedly.” Tian’s voice was prim, though still polite.

“You left out the other part of what you told that mortal boy. The bit about consequences finding him quickly.”

“I did, Daoist Master, yes. It seems redundant at the moment.” Tian nodded.

“I suppose it is. How amusing. All these years of cultivation, of discarding vanities and trivialities, and now it’s my neck stiffening. The phrases “Junior, you dare,” and “Courting death” do keep leaping to mind.”

Tian nodded. He had long since accepted that he had that effect on people.

“Daoist Master-” Tian started, soft and gentle, trying to ease the tension without yielding ground.

“You can call me Elder for now.” 

“Elder Cruel Treachery, may I offer an observation? So long as we are part of the sect, we are subject to the laws of the sect which govern behavior. As to practical differences, what would be the difference between us following the sect’s rules and agreeing to be filial towards you specifically? I believe it would be very little. The symbolism of accepting you as a master should be enough to cover all political issues.”

“I am more concerned about the symbolic distinction to me. Your rejection of filial connection severs the lineage I represent.”

“How so? Would you not be our teacher, and we your students? Would we not receive your teachings, and carry them on to the next generation?”

Treachery fell back into silence, then said “Student Hong, you have let Student Tian speak for for the both of you. I want you to speak now. What do you want? What do you feel?”

“Fury. Utter fury, which I am only keeping leashed by practicing the meditation discipline taught to me by Venerable Merciless. Not because you have lied to us, you haven’t, but because of the sheer falsity of the situation. You want to teach, we are willing to learn, the sect wants us to be the standard bearers for the new generation, we don’t want to leave our people. We all want the sect to change for the better, yet this one thing, this one detail you argue is semantic and symbolic, is enough to derail the entire project and put the whole future of the Monastery at risk! If the difference is so irrelevant, why must we be the ones to bend our necks, when we are the ones being strong-armed into staying? And how dare anyone ask us to treat them as a parent, when they contributed to our families' extermination?”

The temperature of the cave dropped sharply. Tian noticed his breath was condensing into fog, something he could never remember having seen before. Quite interesting.

“You play a dangerous game, girl.” Treachery’s voice was colder than the cave. “Don’t mistake my calm for a tolerance of naked disrespect. Slandering a sect elder- you know the punishment.”

“Is that what you want from your disciples? That we live in fear of you? Do you think so little of us that only the threat of death or imprisonment would make us behave properly? If you think we would betray you, don’t teach us. Just send us away. If you think we would be a credit to the monastery, teach. I am entirely respectful and sincere in saying this.” Liren did just manage to keep her tone civil.

The coldness hovered a moment longer, then dispersed. 

“How amusing. How utterly absurd. Disciple Rui really didn’t exaggerate things. You really would leave the sect. You would pay the price in pain and just go. I can only imagine the sort of parents you will be. Your children are going to be an absolute nightmare for you, once they reach about ten or eleven years old. All your words will be thrown back into your teeth.”

Tian didn’t know how to answer that, so he opted for silence instead.

“The word ‘filial’ matters because it means you are part of a family. A family that originates with the Ancient Crane, and each subsequent generation choses, and is chosen by, the next. A created family, built on respect, tradition, and shared beliefs. You wish to move the relationship from family to something more impersonal, a sort of institutional lineage.”

“Respectfully, Elder, did you plan on being a teacher to me, or a mother?” Tiand cupped his fist and asked. Liren bowed with him. 

Tian had the feeling of standing on a razor’s edge. Not metaphorically, the literal sensation. He was thrown for a second, then recalled the Metal cavern in the Six Turns Cavern. He literally stood on razor’s edges and the tips of needles, to better understand the truth of metal. It was an element that demanded focus, precision, that tested you constantly and forced you to discard what did not survive. 

Cruel Treachery snorted, and opened her eyes. They were entirely sky blue, without a pupil or sclera. “I suppose you can call me Master, then. We will follow your terms. One day, I hope you can appreciate what you just lost.”

Comments

Robert Mullins

“I’m not telling you his real name.” Dog nose: I thought you said she wasn't deserving of her title?

Seth

God it’s crazy how good every chapter is.

Chrysos au

Thanks for the chapter. I don't really understand what cruel treachery means when she says "I hope you can appreciate what you just lost." What did they lose?

Teach

Ah. Yes, I think I agree with treachery here. Tian has chosen quite the lonely path.

EvilLittleThing

Everyone loves clowning on Dog Nose! I do wonder what it is the kids lost, though. Was Cruel Treachery actually intending to adopt them or something? Why would she assume they would accept that kind of relationship without actually building a relationship first? I am glad that they are going to learn how to fly without tools, though. Or rather, run through the air Edit: typo

Diarmuid McGinnity

A deeper relationship. Loyalty, a familial bond and everything that comes with it. We’ve seen how Voidcatcher treats (glazes and loves) his disciple, but I doubt there’s any chance of that here anymore. She will teach them and advise them well but she won’t love them

Rowdy

Pretentious. Every elder always follows the same line of pretence. The symbolic family that justifies the term filiality. Meanwhile, Tian hates metaphor and Liren can't let euphemism paper over contradiction. It's not that neither believe a loving relationship can't be built from a transactional one, it's that evey authority figure demands and screams that it has to be love before there can be a transaction. Or demands that they pretend there is no transaction, just magnanimity and gratitude.

PrepHorizon

This 100%. Love and care is not instant. We see it with FU, he provided both and Tian reciprocated. Why can't the Elders do the same.

Seadrake

They don't trust you Lady. Sure "everything good" did come from her lineage, but her lineage still had an entire hand in their pie of misery. Tian's birth family was exterminated with his father's help. Tian forgave his father, and only his father. You don't get to come in after everything that's been finished, say welp you're my family now (on threat of excomunication) to pick up the political win

Tabac Iberez

This too is part of the defiance of heaven that makes up what defines a true cultivator from a sect member. Nobody remembers the disciples, but the master remains immortal. Don't think I don't see the implied critique of Confusist thought there, Warby!

PrepHorizon

I disagree, Tian may look lonely but he has people. If he didn't why would they be trying so hard to bring him into the fold, because if they lose him, they lose others.

Andrew Goebel

"And how dare anyone ask us to treat them as a parent, when they contributed to our families' extermination?" - Are elder's too removed to see this? Tian grew up in a dump, only saved by an immense power. Liren watched dog's eat her family so that a displaced family could maintain appearances. The monastery wants change without any change. They will not get that with this generation.

porilaine

uuuuu, this book! I dont think that they will regret the things they just lost, but it may make things a little harder at some points in their journey

Johan Persson

An excellent outcome. She would only love them if they became like her, and she's an utter failure.

BaguaBrady

I don't think it's necessarily true in her case. They have no idea what the power politics of the sect are and maybe she's the only thing that stopped even worse offenses or a greater spread of that style of sect management. If she's been fighting "the good fight" for so long, holding against erosion from others at her level she cannot singularly contest - it would be intensely frustrating to here she is the cause of their pain. She still should have handled it much better but I can see where she might be coming from, if I fill in the blanks about sect politics at the top in a certain why.

Mobb

At least she got jokes lol

Seadrake

I think my biggest issue with that last statement is the impatience of it. She's supposed to be a wise and LONG LIVED master, and she's surprised that the poorly treated youths, who've effectively earned nearly all they have from their own efforts despite the sect, aren't excited to play political fuck fuck games or willing to trust someone they've just met?

BaguaBrady

I see both points of view here and really appreciate how it's written in such a way. Still, you don't bring a hurt and partially feral animal into your family with demands. The base premise makes sense, the strategy to get there is inherently flawed. And I think Cruel Treachery's greatest failing is to force the issue immediately. That's the part she has failed to adequately explain. What is being lost? What family that starts with coercion and demand is worth living in?

G&S Gaming

Something tells me they may actually regret this one.

Mobb

I’m not sure whether she actually thought that she could convince them like that or if she was just testing the waters. It really baffles me how the monastery is this stubborn on making the master-disciple relationship equal to a familial relationship. I know it’s a different world with different values and all, but to expect someone to see you as their parent from the very first lesson without teaching them beforehand and giving them time to accept you as part of their life seems utterly Alien to me. It’s as if a step parent demanded of their step-children to call them “dad” or “mom” from the very first day they met, when it usually takes years to build that kind of trust

Veridescent

Hm, perhaps it is my own ignorance but I do wonder what explicitly Cruel Treachery was defining in saying family. The Confucian terming of it is intrinsically hierarchical and without a equitable framing. It is to be owned for being born and to be led with a assumption of knowledge absolute being held by the leader. Learning as from a peer is possible and a thing of humility but it seems in part this definition relies on a framing of absolute rather than gradiated superiority. The difference between family and institution is unclear to me beyond direct reproduction perhaps. A thing very...complex, in the notions of cultivation vs Neo-Confucian framing of norms as immutable truths of reality. Makes me curious about her statement about children to Liren and Tian. Nominally at least if they act as proper role models and can manage to not be hypocrites their own words would not be thrown back at them. Though I suppose if they were authoritarian parents then indeed their words would be thrown back, like as not. 10 year olds tend to respect boundaries being kept, truths being told and transparency in the whys of reciprocity in modeled behavior.

Josiah Elliott

Exactly, the west town outer court monastery taught Tian to be a human before they asked anything more than civility, to assume you could waltz in with an unwanted technique for political caché and assume the title of "mother" is far beyond propriety. FU (which I now realise is F U kinda funny) gave his all to Tian and was his father before Tian even knew consciously that he thought of him that way.

Veridescent

Hm but how can she know she will not come to love them? In the infinite scope of time, can she know their relationship cannot become closer? What definition of love is so conditional? And if it is so limited what does it say that it would be her own decision to not love them? Fitting patterns I suppose given implications of a lack of care being the universal constant of the setting.

Jonathan

Interesting chapter! TBH thinking of Jin, Hong and Zihao did eventually become like Master/Disciple, though not as formal and not as close (since he's mortal). I'd think it would be fine to like...teach the couple for a while and build a relationship THEN offer to become part of "the family". I do agree that their distrust of Cruel Trechery over a technicality is (while naunced) irritating on both sides. I'd think both sides would learn to compromise--like I said if there's not enough trust, then build a relationship and then offer to be familial. I do like how their journey humanized their seniors a bit, making their actions understandable and reasonable from some perspective, though not entirely correct as evidenced by its outcomes/reforms. It makes this more than just Hong/Zihao as paragons of Xianxia, and more people navigating a relationship with a good-but-flawed institution, with their own problems.

Veridescent

Yeah its mostly unclear what the implications are for Family as she said it, since she more or less noted they are already stemming from her lineage of mentality. She cleaves closer in representation to other elders even when it seems she could easily accede to some of their perspective and then use her own. Liren and Tian both kind of acknowledged the Monastery as fine overall despite its externalities, it truly wouldnt be hard to "turn them" as it were.

Josiah Elliott

Exactly, he's so surrounded by friends and relatively important ones that they consider his loyalty to be of utmost importance, and he also literally cultivates a fire of human compassion based on his love for his fellow humans nourished by the days he spent as an orderly.

Boneco

Cruel treachery is a lousy daoist like most in the sect She was offended and threatened to use violence over juniors expressing their true toughts, and not even to offend her, but because she asked for it The filial relationship would never work, since Tian actually tries to follow the virtues and Liren cannot tolerate lies

BigBuckler

Feels like in spite of the fact Elder Cruel Treachery can quite literally read their minds, she didn't really understand how Tian and Liren felt about the ACM until the very end. And her insinuation that they would one day regret not wanting to be in the fold the way the Elders want them to be seems short sighted to me.

Mobb

On a positive note, I can’t wait to see what Grandpa will be cooking up with the sky treading art in combination with the Dark North Sea spell. I do wonder how Liren incorporate the sky treading art though. Her personal art should be better so there is no point in completely replacing it. Maybe the sky treading can easily be run alongside other cultivation arts. It would make sense thematically, because the sky holds everything below and is so broad that myriad paths can be walked on it.

Enzo Elacqua

Lonely sure, but never alone

Andrew Goebel

How would you respond when someone with immense power to change the world tells you, "at least I tried?" Does it make the loss any better? Does it make the instutions that lead to that loss look better? Or does it look worse knowing that part of the organization KNEW better? And while they may not know every in and out for the millennia the sect as existed, they know the outcome. By demanding filial loyalty minute one of knowing these children, she has purposefully closed the door on it.

Raffaele Di Bella

I think that the reason why Rui said that only one Daoist Master could be their master is that no one else would have accepted this condition. It’s not that the Sect Elders are unable to understand that a relationship has to be built gradually over time, but rather that for 10,000+ years the sect has been developed in this way. So, while Tian and Liren are essentially taking a teacher with extra steps, Treachery here still believes they are interrupting the millennia old “chain of filial piety” out of misguided and immature beliefs and, despite accepting this was the only way, still grieves for the lost tradition.

Andrew Goebel

Also, I'm only arguing because it's fun. It's a super intense moment in the arc of the story and I'm enjoying playing an advocate. Your through process is perfectly reasonable.

Andrew Goebel

I don't know if it's a typo or not but "fuck fuck games" is very funny.

Andrew W

I think Cruel Treachery is right here. We’ve seen everything from Tian’s perspective, we’re immersed in it, so we know that his entire persona is wrapped around a childhood of trauma, of viewing humans as either Rock Throwers or Heretics or the same Seniors who pushed him into the Wastes. He’s still able to connect with others but it must be earned. Some have earned it. Hong and Fu obviously, but plenty of mortals, plenty of his peers like Wang. The problem is that that’s fundamentally at odds with what their doaist virtues of ‘filial piety’ mean. It’s fundamentally at odds with what a sect is. If the sect were made of nothing but Tians, the sect would not exist. She wants more from him than the barest respect, she wants an actual chance, and Tian/Hong’s unwillingness or inability to give a chance *before* she walks on coals for penance is frankly kinda shit. It is 1000000% understandable from their perspective. Still shit.

Blackking👑

Yeah, but the whole premise is ridiculous because just like you can theoretically say that all of the good things in his life come from her teachings the bad things also are derived from her indifference

Roxanne Moore

That Zihao and Liren want to stay is already more filial than the Sect deserves.

Blackking👑

Yeah, like you can say that "all" the good things that happened to him are because of her lineage but at the same time you can also say that the bad things partly we're allowed to happen because of her indifference

João Vene

This story is so good, there's so much here. It's a really rocky start of the master-disciple relationship, with the Monastery taking their actual filial relationships hostage instead of growing theirs organically. It's understandable why they're doing it, since Tian and Liren walking away would damage the legitimacy of the Monastery when they're already very demoralized. And Treachery did accept a transactional relationship in the end, instead of just kicking them out. But when she says they lost something precious, it's so emblematic of everything wrong with the upper reaches of the Monastery. She assumes the filial relationship is the norm, the baseline of what they're supposed to be doing, but she doesn't actually put in any of the work, while also forcing them into a transaction. "Learn from me and you get to still live with your father and friends". That's a transaction, and what she and Rui are forcing on them. She gets offended when they ask if she would love them as a mother! And while she questions their demands as teachers to Han, of the transactional nature of the relationship they offered, she doesn't even question what Han actually felt for them. Han loved them as a son, because they actually treated him with filial care. They offered the lesser, transactional relationship while actually putting in the work for a filial one, while the Monastery keeps assuming their relationship must be of filial love while actually doing everything on a transactional nature

Chris Britt

I think Treachery is wrong here. She and by extension the sect aren't really offering anything of value here and STILL demanding unquestioning loyalty. You can definitely tell that she is still part of Starsieve's generation with the huge emphasis on filial piety at all costs. This is just a slightly different tactic. It reminds me of arguing with your parents and they say something along the lines of "I kept you fed and clothed"....like yes that is the legal minimum you are required to do. In this case Treachery's line about how everything good came from her lineage....well sure, but the fact that your lineage aren't incompetent murderous idiots in a sect that seems full of them isn't the win you think it is.

Blackking👑

Yeah, he's not lonely because he won't take a lady that he never met in his life who can only claim to have been a positive influence in his life through the actions of a student of hers as a mother when he's only now and is basically being told that he either accepts her as a teacher or leaves

PrepHorizon

She is a lousy daoist for sure, she was reading their minds and still fumbled. She could have said "I know you have been wronged, I will teach you, hopefully we all learn to be filial to one another" but no, she went straight to ultimatums and threats, where was the compassion, understanding etc? Maybe she forgot she was talking to children relative to her age?

Blackking👑

Yeah I mean the reason why he's so loyal to his brothers because all they asked him was his success. Meanwhile, all the people that would take him in as a disciple want him to see them as a second parent or some bullshit, ignoring the fact that there's nothing for that type of relationship to stand on at the beginning at least

Blackking👑

Yeah, the whole premise is weird cause no one who's negatively predisposed to you is going to immediately agree to see you as their parent when the only thing that you can claim is that someone who you influenced did something good for them in the past

Chad L.

lol. She is blinded by her own expectations, and doesn’t realize that they have not lost anything that they wanted or valued.

Ryan Naquin

The elder seems to believe that the appearance of sect unity is more important than the actual actions of the sect. Which is how she justified sitting on the mountain doing nothing. Elder Starsieve set the direction and a good junior like her isnt allowed to question that direction. At this point is she an independent person or just an extension of the sect. No wonder she cant break through the human realm.

Raffaele Di Bella

The last sentence sounds like a threat but really isn’t in my opinion. It’s just that she believes their stubbornness on this point derives from a narrowness of vision and lack of understanding about the chain of filial piety starting from Ancient Crane, as well as the concept in general. I read it like this “I hope you will one day realise what it is you are rejecting and its true value”. They are denying the importance of bonds of affection and love between master and disciple and the unquestioned hierarchy inherent to the relationship, without (in her opinion) really understanding what they truly mean for the past, present and future of the sect.

Blackking👑

It's so strange cause if you look at the start of the lineage, I doubt the ancient crane had all these stipulations what she was preaching

BaguaBrady

His brothers are a great example because he spent quite a lot of time hiding in shadows and they let him. If they demanded filial respect when he was doing that, dude would have had a very different reaction.

Chris Britt

There also seems to be this belief that there is a huge benefit to that filial relationship and I don't think we've seen it in the sect. Voidcatcher is proper filial with his disciple. Merciless is filial with his ultra distant descendant. In the sect though the relationship seems to be benefits for the master and obligations for the disciple. I know the benefit for the disciple is supposed to be learning, and that works for mid cultivators. However if you are receiving true revelations of the Dao, they you'll probably be able to work something out eventually like Tian and Liren did. The demand for unquestioning loyalty cultivates middling talents and pushes away the excellent

fruit dragon

I think the politics is what is pissing tian off. Rui could have talked with the in privet before declaring them directly disipeles but he didn't he used them for his own gain he might be right that will help more people in the end but it would piss me off to. He sent tian to Fu not only because he wants them to reconnect but also as a reminder of what he has to lose.

BaguaBrady

I mostly agree with you Andrew but I would seek to understand a person who stayed in a broken system and tried to reform it internally. I would buck against the immediate demands to loyalty as they are doing though. But I can understand why she might feel slandered though, regardless of my opinion on how she handles it

KarmaXY42

Any good relationship has to be built on trust, but neither Tian and Liren or the elders are willing to be first to extend that trust. The difference is that our protags have actual valid reasons not to trust the elders, while the elders have every reason to trust our protags but don’t because tradition says they shouldn’t.

FoolRegnant

I wonder if what they're giving up is that fundamental trust and connection the sect has in them. Maybe it means the Ancient Crane doesn't see them as true disciples. Maybe it's more basic, and it's about how the sect will treat them. If they accepted a master fully, then the sect would trust them absolutely, but since they haven't, it will always be at arms length. Obviously the sect broke trust first and this was a half hearted olive branch, but that's just how it is sometimes. The sect as an institution failed them, and it's totally reasonable to not trust the sect when it's the sect as a family, but that probably will close off some doors and open others. If you're treated poorly by an institution, you can really just leave. It's a lot harder when it's your family. Tian especially regards the people of the sect as his family, but while treating the sect itself as an institution instead of family, there will be an inevitable strain.

Zenopath (AEV)

Its not baffling to me. The key is that fillial means going above and beyond. What do you owe your master? A fillial student would say "everything". But Tian and Liren are only offering obediance. To be fair, the root problem is that they dont need a master, which is extremely rare. They are only accepting a master for political reasons and dont feel that they owe anything beyond obediance to sect rules.

Ano Ano

To the powerful, disagreement is so easy to see as disrespect.

Robert Mullins

I can only assume the elders and daoist masters fully expected this outcome and that the reason cruel treachery was selected as their master is that she is the only one that would have agreed to it.

Seadrake

It's a purposefully used phrase, I forget where I originally heard it and find it an extremely apt description of most political engagements.

João Vene

It really didn't, since everyone describes it as her spending some time on the mountain preaching the Dao and then flying away

EvilLittleThing

Hmm idk maybe? But they aren't denying them, just refusing to pretend they exist before they really do. Fu grew a deep relationship with Tian, and I don't understand why the elders don't look at that as evidence that Tian doesn't actually reject the bonds of affection and obligation. He just insists on reciprocal obligation.

Pharous

I think from the sect perspective Tian and Liren are two nukes that have no bridle. Even worse they are the best new nukes in the monastery, but no one knows their activation code lol.

Khanalas

At least try understanding her point of view before discarding it. In parent-child relations, you do not choose your family from people you love, you become a family first and love comes from that, maybe because you're family more than the behavior. If we take this as her view, then by refusing family you refuse real familial love, no matter affection you will feel afterward. Fu became Tian's father and Tian started loving him, not the other way around. The question isn't that expecting filialty commitment before it's earned is preposterous, it's that the pair aren't prepared to give the Monastery trust in this matter before it's earned, and the Monastery believes that what's lost by not accepting filiality first is more than what's risked if you do.

Brian P.

How is pledging undying loyalty towards her just giving her “a chance?” That’s the demand here, give themselves unto her and trust she will treat them well when all evidence they’ve seen points towards the opposite. Tian and Hong are the ones offering her a chance: Teach them and maybe things can change as the relationship grows. Cruel Treachery seems to be demanding immediate and complete supplication.

Josiah Elliott

Fu was not Tian's father first, he was a good person who was training a child and through being supportive and freely giving the love he could became Tian's father. And yeah if you were born to someone you are their child before you can concieve of love, but you grow that love by supporting and loving a defenseless child and giving them love.

Kain

I think one of my remaining gripes about this whole sect revitalization project is the lack of any people of significants being jettisoned from the mountain, that we are aware of. The Longs didn’t matter they were core disciples? I think and had connections to other core disciples. They were a symptom a product of the sects neglect and decline. We’ve not heard of or met any Direct disciples, let alone Elders or above, the people actually managing things, that got booted out of the mountain. I think right after they got to the mountain the first time it was mentioned some were but we never got names so the impact of that is muted to me. If it really comes down to none of the people managing the sect were actively malignant, but they were indifferent or incompetent, and therefore allowed to stay then I’d just write the Monastery off. In time once Tian and Lieren leave the same things gonna play out, CT is probably the chillest and most willing to change of the DM’s and even she entertained the thought of just killing these two for upsetting tradition. Rui is fucked even if he wants reform if the core of the monasteries power is as ingrained in their ways as they seem to be there’s literally no reform that will stick it will just revert to how these old monsters like it when he leaves or before if he doesn’t show immediate results and gets the boot.

William Johnson

"You wish to move the relationship from family to something more impersonal, a sort of institutional lineage.” That's rich coming from someone whose organization slaughtered both of their families because it was economically beneficial to some scumbags in the inner court. If that's the family on offer I'll take the transactional relationship thanks.

Trey

cruel treachery seems like the type to tell their kid because i said so when they ask why something has to happen one way or another. then gets pissed when you say that’s not a real answer. if you lose somebody’s familial love because you are unwilling to follow blindly, then it doesn’t seem like a love worth having. hell she pretty much hit them with a you’ll regret this way of acting at the end. some i brought you into this world i can take you out bullshit. hopefully rui was right in that she deserves a chance because boy this first talk was a huge fumble

David Blomeyer

That last sentence is poisoned waters. One side ("Cruel Treachery") reads thoughts, asserts the intent and capacity to "Dao Parent", and so far fails to demonstrate it. Tian - "This humble Daoist humbly suggests that we back up and begin again, as my shortcomings have left me more confused then when I arrived. I have experienced cruel treachery. It creates a burden of proof. Your name is not helping. I know barely more then nothing of who you are. Please help me understand." If you cannot trust a mind reader to acknowledge and address issues of trust, it is certainly not safe to learn the Dao from them. Alt - "This is Ancient Crane Monastery. Its legacy began with the Ancient Crane demonstrating, speaking, and living the Dao. It went first, without conditions or expectations; she chose to be filial first. Those who witnessed and experienced the Crane saw its Merit, were enlightened by its Dao, and wisely became filial in response, and those are the first roots of our legacy. Your position seems to be that we should choose to be filial first. Seeing how this differs from the Crane itself and its first disciplines experience, it seems the legacy you see is one part the Cranes teachings and Dao and one part a discipline of the Crane who became a Master in its absence who added hierarchy, submission, and blind faith as an additional Legacy along with the Cranes teachings. The cruel treachery we have lived, and are living, comes from abuse of that second legacy. You say that if we reject that second legacy that if we grow wise enough we will regret it and this confuses and worries me greatly. Maybe you are right; your love is beyond doubt a precious thing and even though I have never felt it now the thought of its absence feels like a hole in my heart. What is in question is what is greater; your love for us or the cost of that second legacy being passed along from here without significant reform starting in this moment. I suspect we will all regret either choice. Are you sure that it has to be a choice or can we do better?" Call it out, reach mutual understanding, or walk.

Andrew W

She's explicitly not asking for 'complete supplication.' She's not asking for 'undying loyalty.' Filial loyalty, yes. But exaggerating the concept of 'filial loyalty' into some extreme demand, when it's foundational to the entire existence of sects, is... well, it's an exaggeration. The fact that Tian bristles at the 'filial' thing, and so many readers echo that understanding, is exactly why she's right. They're saying they'll be compassionate, honorable, frugal, all those other Daoist virtues, they'll 'conduct themselves in a way that won't bring her shame,' but the one thing they *will not* bend on is loyalty. If she was the monster that they're implying she is – that the exaggerated understanding of 'complete supplication' implies – she wouldn't have acquiesced. But she did. Their worldview decrees that their Seniors are unworthy of filial respect, while simultaneously only being allowed to exist because at least some of their Seniors are. It's fundamentally incoherent. It's still great storytelling, mind. The inconsistency opens up paths for character growth, and the worldview tension opens up avenues for conflict between otherwise-aligned characters, which is some necessary fuel for the coming arc. Since Warby is a good writer, I'm hoping that Chekov's Gun at the end there does fire. Cruel Treachery will prove herself to be a genuinely worthy master, somebody who they'll end up deciding that they want to form a connection to... but because of their decisions in this chapter not to bend, they will have lost that chance, and it will cost them.

Robert Mullins

I do think it's funny that they hit cruel treachery with the exact same terms that tian gave the old sectmaster and which made everyone in the holy land laugh at dog nose. But now the sect is in a position where even someone of a higher level is forced to agree if they want to keep the sect healthy and functional.

JackassofAllTrades

"Cruel Treachery snorted, and opened her eyes. They were entirely sky blue, without a pupil or sclera." Warby likes to describe charaters as snorting often. I can never quite tell if he means they snort in the sense of a snicker or laugh or just making a forceful exhalation through the nose. Maybe both interchangeably? I feel like he uses it in situations where laughter would make some sense, like above, and other situations where the character laughing just doesn't make sense no matter how I think about it.

HyperJoJo

That last line is kind of a pet peeve of mine. She might as well have said "I am neither patient nor compassionate enough to try to work out our differences. I can neither force nor convince you to do things my way, but I'm not humble enough to entertain the possibility that I could be wrong, so we'll do it your way, while I imply that actually I'm right, you just don't see it yet."

Mobb

Tian and Liren have proven several times that they are willing to go above and beyond for the sect and those they consider they own and this would naturally include the Monastery and their master of they don’t betray their trust and stay respectful. Not seeing their master as their second parent, doesn’t mean that can’t get attached to or form a loving relationship. The thing is that the Monastery isn’t actually worried about Tian’s and Liren’s actions, but about the place they have in the duos heart. Tian is willing to die for their brothers and sisters yet he still only considers 3 people as part of his family, Liren should be very similar and unless the Daoist master are incompetent they can also see it. Also I don’t think that it’s only a necessity and strength thing. Tian was even willing to refuse Voidcatcher as a master and I doubt that the situation would change by much if tian and liren were in a much less privileged position.

Khanalas

Fu became Tian's father because he chose to be filial to utmost, and he acted like a father in this way, which grew their love. On the second point, yes, you can say that like Fu became a father first because he had more agency than a feral child, a parent becomes a parent before a child can conceive it and this makes the child their child. So Cruel Treachery has to become a filial Master first because she has higher agency and responsibility and this would make Tian and Liren her filial children-disciples. You create filiality before your junior learns that they are in such relationship, because the relationship itself teaches.

Baines

doubt it given gpa eclipses the whole mountain

Mikołaj

I think you guys ignore the fact that it is Cruel Treachery who bends her neck towards Tian and Liren at the end. It is filial to your juniors to abandon your pride, lineage and thousands years of tradition for their good. Perhaps she also hopes that they will grow their relationship in time. Tian and Liren are also about 20 years old which is not very many even by mortal standards and they may change their views in time.

Quivo

Guess I'm the opposite and hoping they don't regret it because to me, it feels completely understandable for Tian and Liren to want to keep things transactional at this point. You say their new master wasn't asking for complete supplication but I feel she was. If it's not complete supplication---unconditional trust and love of the one above you in the hierarchy---then what IS filial piety? The whole point is that you trust, you take a leap of faith because naturally your elder will also be filial to you and reward that trust. Unfortunately that doesn't account for how variable people are and the fact that assholes exist. It's an ideal. If the elders above you don't do their job in weeding out their asshole peers, everyone downstream will suffer. I feel like anyone who's ever seriously suffered from said downstream effects would have to be outright crazy or desperate as hell to sign up for a filial piety relationship with someone they don't know well.

MarchParabola

Though Cruel Treachery may yet be right, and our heroes may one day realize what they lost, or have their children throw their own words back at them, Tian is completely correct here. Tian has always treated his brothers and sisters as brothers and sisters... but he's never been asked to call any of his seniors or teachers or elders 'father or mother' - he only called Fu that because he grew that desire on his own. If the Daoist Masters and Elders would insist on this being a filial relationship, then they would have to accept that they've been either abusive or absentee parents not worthy of the name.

BurnNote

I wonder if they'd have gotten somewhere if she'd said "yes, I want to be your mother, that's what beim a teacher means". But the really curious thing is that they insist on ignoring the obvious alternative: Fu. Xian and him already have exactly the relationship the monastery wants.

Logrus

What they just lost? The thing you *literally just said* was purely symbolic/semantic?

Nyroe

I think a snort could also be interpreted as a scoff, a chuff, or a nose exhalation in most cases. Especially with how sensitive Cultivator senses are. A twitch can be read as easily as a face-splitting grin.

Andrew W

As I said in the original, it's absolutely understandable. It's a tragic situation. Tian and Hong were traumatized as children with the whole family destruction/feral child situation, retraumatized as teens with the Wastes, then as they became adults learned how much of these formative traumas were a result of their Seniors being either corrupt or complacent. Tian and Hong *should* be reflexively distrustful; anything else would be out of character for them given their lived experience. Abstracted from their lived experience, it's incomplete. There are people you can trust. The world isn't full of dirtbags. Given that they know that West Town was the direct result of Cruel Treachery's line (Rui/Fu at least, I don't remember where Bai fits in), they have reason to trust her specifically. The existence of organizations is predicated on the ability to trust, and they (and most of their loved ones) are members of the organization in question here. There's even room for their skepticism inside a framework of trust – 'trust but verify' is a saying for a reason. Reflexive distrust can be understandable, but if it's how you treat everyone in your life, everyone you ever meet, that's really really sad. "Understandable, relatable, but also fundamentally missing something" is one of the strongest hallmarks of a well-fleshed-out character/perspective. The world is chock full of that.

G&S Gaming

I'm not talking about an opportunity for power. She did agree to teach them. I'm saying if she was truly responsible for little moments like the food flinging or stuff like encouraging Fu to pursue tea, and that sort of thing is lost in a colder more business-like idea of what the monastery should be that Tian and Liren would regret that.

Diarmuid McGinnity

“Some time” meaning something different to an immortal crane, I assume. It could well have been centuries or millennia seeing as Starsieve remembers listening to the Crane in his youth and he was the 3rd generation sect master

Blackking👑

I mean the amount of times she spent on the mountain doesn't really matter because if she was focusing on their specific interpretation of the master and disciple relationship, she would've only taught people that she saw as her students and brought them with her when she left

Brian P.

The elder of the core disciples was left outside the barrier, as I recall, but we certainly haven’t seen them.

Brian P.

As I recall Tian’s opinion on Rui is “wants to help but is unreliable” due to his actions when they came back to camp with heretics attacking. Given that, and that he is an extension of Cruel Treachery, I would think she would give evidence to them of why she’s trustworthy, or take action to prove it, beyond “my student’s student was good to you.” But no, she demands it and only relents when she realizes they will leave the sect before they take her on as a true master, with all the undying loyalty and trust that includes, without acts in their favor.

Michael

It's what they call them in the military, usually with a dash though. Take everything out of your baracks and then put it back in, FOD-walkdown the motor pool parking lot, organize that pile of rocks by size, shape, and color. Marine Corps is famous for them.

Donmalurkin

You know I get the whole three Direct Disciples rejecting the offer thing. But it hasn't been that long since Fu accepted. And isn't Lirens Aunt Bai a Direct Disciple too now? Or did she not make the cut?

Robert Mullins

Great, so then only 3/5 of your direct disciple candidates were so disgusted with the sect that they refused to take a master. A 40% approval rate of the thing that would be considered the most valuable and enviable opportunity in the sect isn't exactly inspiring confidence. And that's ignoring the fact that Fu and Bai were from before the mountain was closed off.

ArtTheGreat

Somehow I doubt that Tian and Liren will ever feel that they just lost something here.

Wandering Scribe

This whole filial issue the sect keeps getting hung up on feels so corporate in the best, most infuriating way possible. I am reminded of an old manager that was annoyed I did not have sufficient “team spirit”. I completed my assignments, I treated everyone with respect, I was neither late nor early showing up or leaving… and still somehow it was not enough.

DT

Ugh, remember my old company used to say 'We're all family'. Meanwhile, they would play games with schedules and expected us to volunteer weekends etc.

CastorInvictus

I have a hypothesis about Cruel Treachery's name and it's applicability to Tian and Liren. It's about unintended consequences, good intentions repaid with disastrous results. The trechary not of a person, but of fate. I bet that in her youth Cruel Trechary intervened in mortal affairs similarly to Tian and Liren. Defended innocent mortals from an invasion or similar, inspiring zealous devotion. Then the mortals, or their descendants, took it too far and did a genocide or rebellion which left untold devestation in its wake. Like Burning Flag residents considering Yuu to be heretics when Tian and Liren do not, and not suffering a heretic to live. Her name is a reminder of the treachery consequence inflicts on your best intentions.

Blackking👑

Sure, but it's different fu decided to take tian in he didn't need to go as far as he did. Any potential master is in the position of power and is choosing to teach their apprentice ultimately they're the one that holds all the power if they have reasons not to teach then they just don't need to teach

Blackking👑

I feel like a bit much. Especially when you consider the fact that literally every action that the sect is normally supposed to do would affect the lives of mortals especially killing heretics

Blackking👑

Yeah, also like the whole reason why they're so adamant about not accepting them as like a new parent is specifically because they do not know them and claiming that someone random who they've never met before is apparent to them specifically because they taught them a technique would just be a lie

Blackking👑

Yeah, the thing is that even that's not true the sect is gonna depend on them like always do you only the situation where they don't end up being a depended on is if they decided to say fuck the ultimatum and left

Blackking👑

Also, like I'm pretty sure the main reason why they haven't accepted in the past it specifically because they're not gonna lie to the master in question and claim that they see them as a second father or first mother to quote Tian

CastorInvictus

It does seem like a bit of a stretch to call it "trechary" when "consequence" would be more accurate. But if the consequences are sufficiently ironic and painful, perhaps

Blackking👑

I don't know they're both plenty Fillal the concept of the questioning it is entirely ridiculous. The fact that they don't see people that have actively been shown to be unreliable as reliable it just means that they have eyes. Also, even if crew treachery hasn't been paying attention and didn't take the warnings of her student seriously hearing their thoughts, while they were walking, should've put exactly into perspective how they felt about the whole situation they were being put in

Blackking👑

Also, again the whole premise that like a student needs to declare their loyalty to their master before they can be allowed to teach is inherently contradictory to how that sect sack to receive the knowledge in the first place as far as we can tell, based on the little bits of nothing that we've heard. The crane came she preached and she stayed for a little bit and then she eventually left. acting like you as a teacher don't have all of the leverage in the relationship between you and your student is kind of ridiculous. She doesn't need to teach them until they've proven that they deserve it. She basically got told by her student that no one else can teach them because they don't trust the elders farther than they can throw them. And immediately starts on the bullshit about being Filial and Home teaching them would put it into her line or something like her teaching them would somehow take away from the fact that she already has a student presumably that she has the master student relationship with

Blackking👑

Also, I gotta be honest I think that it's inherently disingenuous to act like they're acting this way specifically to any new person they meet. There's like a whole lot of circumstance that causes them to act this way, specifically in relation to people higher up on the hierarchy of their sect and and their distorted concept of filial piety. Like they're immortals they're going to live very long, especially considering the people that they take us true disciples have to be in the heavenly person stage getting to know them before you immediately tell them that they need to see you as a parent and swear, undying loyalty just seems smart, especially when circumstance is very obvious that there's serious issues with the way that shit is going on at the moment

Forrest Venable

In familial terms they are being introduced to a grandmother whom they have never met but who was a deep influence on their parents. She is leaning on that relationship to try to build a more direct connection, to have Tian and Liren embrace the lineage that traces back to the Ancient Crane. That they would then embrace their great grandparent and great great grandparent simply on the basis that those ties exist (Specifically Cruel Treachery was offering a way to sever the ties of filial piety from the Starsieve line, reestablishing them from her instead) They are refusing. Cruel Treachery might eventually become a figure of respect for them but her master will once more have to start building the relationship from nothing (or, at least, from an introduction) The lineage that Cruel Treachery is trying to preserve is severed. No longer is this a family but rather a study group. I can't help but feel like the Ancient Crane would approve

Notanautomaton

I have to wonder how the Elders are internally squaring their desire for Tian to fully accept their conception of orthodox fillial piety with the fact that if he did so he'd be obligated to kill Fu and Rui.

FoolRegnant

That's fair. I do wonder if it would have an impact on how the rest of the mountain perceived them, though. A lot of this is probably transient in the long run - Grandpa doesn't really care either way it seems, but he is expecting Tian to outgrow the whole mountain. Even so, Tian is still young and he will have to experience to social/cultural side effects of this at least through the Heavenly Realm, if not longer. Maybe it does end up with a real revolution in how the sect treats master-disciple relationships, maybe they get to go on as exceptions, but narratively I feel like things are being led towards a major break between Tian/Liren and the sect

Baconwargod

What is the implied criticism? I’m only aware of confusinism on a very surface level so I’d love to learn more.

Merlin King

I think I can see her perspective here. Originally, it’s the appearance of family; you agree to be filial and they shall be filial back. Over time, genuine affection blossoms but because they already are considered family, there’s nothing stopping it. Keeping a more impersonal view means that if Zihao & Liren do gain affection, they will inevitably held at arm’s length, in accordance to the agreement made now. She severed her own lineage for them, but I think it’ll have consequences

Brian P.

Auntie Bai ascended but didn’t have any tribulation lightning like Fu, Tian and Hong. Neither did Wang, though. But as far as I’m aware we’ve never been told or seen if she was core or direct.

Raffaele Di Bella

The key difference is the premise: it’s not “you’ll be as a father/mother to me for guiding my cultivation journey in a crucial way and so I’ll be properly obedient to you”, but rather “you’ll be my teacher and I’ll follow your designs only as long as they fit my own morals and inclinations”. The result may be similar -we’ll see about this, it really depends on Cruel Treachery-, but the premise is very different. Her authority is institutional, not derived from familial bonds, and there is no guarantee that they will actually develop a lasting relationship, while the usual master-disciple is meant for life. I also think Warby does a good job in portraying multi-thousand year old characters who are used to be obeyed without question and cling to the traditions of their upbringing. Cruel Treachery is far younger and less powerful than either Voidcatcher or Merciless, yet from the start she uses the kind of invasive power plays that those “venerables” never displayed (mind and memory reading, her shen as a pressure tool and the threat of expelling them from the sect). Infact, here she behaves far more similarly to Mourning Cry, or at least the Dawnlight Lark, which is a sign of flawed character in line with her still being an “imperfect person”.

Ezidium

It's funny to demand devotion at first meeting, to set out the terms of a relationship transactionaly without allowing it to develop, as if to teach someone at all requires first loving them as your own child, and them loving you as a parent. Like, it's such an unnatural idea. Unnatural as in distant from the nature of the world and thus presumably the Dao.

EvilLittleThing

I kinda assumed she was testing their patience with those games

Veridescent

Mm a really good summation of sides

JackassofAllTrades

Fair enough, I wouldn't say no to Warby introducing a bit more variety/detail in the words he uses to describe those various twitches though, might help to paint a more vivid picture of things.

Merlin King

Leeching this comment. Anyone know if Sky Pride has a discord, unofficial or otherwise? And what’s the current theories on Jun?

Brian P.

It does not, not an official one anyway. It once existed but Warby hated managing it and in his hate neglected it until it was overrun by bots, at which point he just nuked it.

G&S Gaming

I do kinda get it though, since irl basically everyone IRL who tries to "change it from the inside" eventually just because a part of the "or" they're trying to change. Personal relationships and learned helplessness in the face of a grand institution are powerful tools that those in positions of authority can and will leverage to dissuade dissent. So the excuse of "I tried my best to change it from the inside" always falls a little bit flat for me. I can recognize the good intention behind it, but ultimately your actions and the consequences of them matter more imo.

Tabac Iberez

Confusism is the general heading most of the "filial thought" in this story would philosophically become, and it has massive core statements about family structure and filial piety that are- to most Western commentators- highly toxic and self-destructive. It's *also* the of the default Villain Positions in a lot of xianxia.

Baconwargod

Cool thank you! So it’s the enforced family structure of the philosophy that the elder is taking for granted and attempting to enforce on the protags while not being or at least showing filial behavior herself

Tabac Iberez

Exactly. She is making an extraordinary request while displaying a bare minimum of filial behavior. This is partially excused in a "standard" context by how she's in the Dao Reserves (read: closed door cultivation until you kick the bucket) but that partial excuse holds no water with how deeply the Sect rotted out. Did she try to correct things? Yeah. She did. Did she do nothing as the rot intensified? Yeah. She did. Balancing the scales is only the start for her, unfortunately.