Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“Disciple Tian Zihao greets Master Cruel Treachery.”

Hong clasped her hands and echoed Tian. 

“No genuflection? No, I suppose not, after having said all that. Well, if you wouldn’t kneel before ancient monsters like Voidcatcher or Merciless, why should I be special?”

The words felt bitter to Tian. He wondered if she had intended them to be ironic. Had he been a bad teacher for Han? Tian thought he had done his very best for him, but had he somehow wronged the boy by not creating a master-disciple relationship? It seemed absurd, but none of the elders were stupid. Presumably there was something he was still not understanding.

“So much, Disciple Tian. So much. What’s worse is that you have led Disciple Hong around to your way of thinking. Two years ago, she would have understood. And no, you didn’t wrong that Han child. You raised him well.”

Right. Mind reading. He didn’t have that useful amulet anymore. The Myriad Colors Holy Land didn’t let them outside. He did have a thought-isolating spell, but had completely fallen out of the habit of using it after leaving the Mountain. He could feel Cruel Treachery snorting, even if it wasn’t audible. 

She still hadn’t opened her mouth. Tian found it a pretty mild quirk, given the absolute blue of her eyes. He had the growing feeling that they weren’t simply blue colored. It felt like he was looking into a blue sky. He half wondered if he would see a cloud crossing them.

“The Sky Treading Art, at its core, places the human in the heavens, and gives them agency. That is a crucial word- agency. The power to make choices. This is the ‘treading’ part of the title, you can walk where you will, not driven hither and thither by the winds of fate or circumstance. In theory.”

The two disciples nodded. 

“What does it mean to place the human in the heavens? Both the literal meaning of the words, and the metaphorical meaning. Flying without a tool is the signature ability of the basic mastery level of the Sky Treading Art, though even at the Human Realm, it is considerably slower and more tiring than using a sword or, yes, a boat, or flying on the back of a bird.”

That made sense to Tian. Swimming was more tiring than riding on a boat. Or so he imagined, anyway.

“The cultivator must, wait, you can’t float? Not being able to swim I understand, most people can’t swim, but you don’t float at all? That’s… neither here nor there. And Disciple Hong is in increasing danger of blowing away in a high breeze. I suppose that is a sort of help in learning the Sky Treading Art.” She was sounding rather tired now. 

“The metaphorical meaning of the name of the art, the actually important meaning, is to situate the divine thought in the world of heavenly qi.”

Tian felt Grandpa suddenly grip his shoulder. He could feel the old ghost giving Cruel Treachery his full attention.

“The human bridges the heavens and the earth, but it is ultimately rooted in the earth. What transcends this limitation? Qi and Shen. What is qi and shen? The energetic origin of the universe, and the divine thought that transcends the immediate and material. The Sky Treading Art teaches you to separate your qi and shen from their earthly confines, filling them with the vastness of heavens. When you are ready, when your energy bodies are sufficiently full, you bring the illumination of shen. The divine thought that transforms a void into the heavens, and reveals all it shines upon. At the end of the imperfect mortal realm, you condense it all back again, and are reborn as something greater. Something free of the shackles of mortality.”

She closed her eyes, the lids drifting down like clouds shrouding the sky. “I’ll let you know the details of that step once I manage it for myself.”

Tian and Hong bowed deeply. 

“You still have a copy of the philosophical teachings of the Ancient Crane? Good. You memorized them, in fact. Hah. How filial. Well, lend your copy to your dao companion. She will need to study it to fully grasp the meaning within the chant of the Sky Treading Art. It’s rather long, so we will begin by memorizing it in sections. Sit. This will take some time.”

The sun was setting by the time they had the chant memorized. Understanding would take years, and even the initial breathing and energy circulation pattern was considerably tricky. They were to come back the day after tomorrow at dawn, for Treachery to guide them through their first cultivation session.

“It will be easier for you than for most, as you already cultivate high quality Heavenly cultivation spells. You can cultivate both, incidentally, the spells are of sufficiently high quality. It’s only the low quality stuff that you need to worry about crippling you.”

She sighed. “I can’t help but feel that some of your stubbornness comes from the fact you already have a clear path forward. You have your own reliance in those spells you cultivate, and so don’t need your elders in the sect for your progression. It’s part of the deal, to put it in depraved terms. It’s the bargain. We have seen further. We have delved deeper. We have inherited a legacy, a heritage older than kingdoms, propagated by affection, interests and ideals. We offer immortality. We offer power enough to reshape the world, at least locally. We offer freedom from want. Freedom from anxiety. Asking that you treat us as family doesn’t seem like too terrible a requirement.”

They both had the sense of being waved away, though she still hadn’t stirred a muscle bigger than her eyelids.

“Go. When you see your friend Wang, tell him that you have taken me as your master. I don’t want our terms made public, but you can tell him,” The bitterness was inescapable now, he could feel it boring towards his marrow, “That what I have accepted from two people, I can accept from three. Tell him that there is at least one person on this mountain who doesn’t cross his bottom line.”

Brother Wang had broken through with a true revelation? That was fabulous news! Though that made it even more surprising that he didn’t have a master yet. Tian would have thought the elders would be fighting tooth and nail to recruit such a lucrative student.

Cruel Treachery’s eyes snapped open, the blue suddenly very cold. For the first time she opened her mouth. “Scram!”

The two kept their thoughts to themselves until they had returned to their cave home. There was a lot to think about, but Tian kept returning to the immense bitterness that Cruel Treachery didn’t bother to hide. Ultimately, he could only sigh and let it go for now. 

“Want me to treat you like a mother? Did you ever treat me like a son? Grandpa, am I wrong about all this?”

In the sense of local mores and customs? Absolutely. In terms of harming your future prospects? Absolutely not. The piece, or one of the pieces anyway, that you aren’t remembering is that this is her home. The sect is her family and it has been for thousands of years. Thousands. The faces change, but the legacies and disciple-descendants of her contemporaries remain. In a sense, she may lose people, but she has kept the extended family.

Seeing someone who should be an emblem of that extended family actively despising and mistrusting it, insisting on the family being an institution, that the family lower itself to meet him on his terms, not theirs, hurts. And what hurts worse is that she knows doing it is necessary for her home to survive. Where you two lead, the next generation will follow. Wang first, then probably that librarian girl, then likely Little Treasure. The older generation, if more of them break through, will fall in line easily enough, but they won’t be pillars of the sect the way Fu and you kids will be. And Fu… keeps his own council. He’s burnt too, and is exactly the kind of person who can bend a flow in the direction he prefers, not where others would have it go.

An old, boney hand patted Tian’s shoulder. She didn’t do you wrong, though. I didn’t give the Monastery enough credit. There is some real depth to this art. I’m not going to be able to adjust it with everyone breathing down your neck, but what it is, is already surprisingly good. Peak third tier, I’d say. I’m deducting points for the absurdly picky energy body filling method, the qi refining speed is at a fine-not-great level, ditto the circulation complexity, honestly it would be at the bottom of the third tier except for the shen component. That is quite good, and is setting you up beautifully for your breakthrough to the perfected human realm. In that regard, and only that regard, it actually exceeds the Darknorth Sea Spell. 

If it was only slightly better, it'd be a second tier spell. I could make it peak second tier… ah, never mind. Your teacher must have some troubles if she isn’t able to break through after studying this art for so long. It should be an absolute doddle for her.

Tian and Liren made a simple dinner, rediscovering the old rhythms of life in their cave. Tian took a few moments to admire their new tea tree. It must be admitted that tea trees are not the most lovely in the forest. The silvery bark was covered in brown, rough patches. Not a disease, it was just how the bark looked, quite normal for a tea tree. The branches were twisty things, tending towards the spindly. It was early days, of course. The tree was barely a few years old. 

“Should we set up that qi condensing formation in our cave? It takes a few crystals to run, but it’s not too expensive. Frankly, we can afford it, and it would probably do all the plants and things a lot of good.” Liren suggested. 

Tian nodded, still lost in memories of the day. “Yes, that sounds good. I’m going to stay up tonight. I need to meditate.”

“I’ll keep you company. I’m not as mad as I was, but every now and then it sneaks up on me. I’ll have to head over to the Disciplinary Squad and start that going. I have… so many ideas. So many plans. It sounds like no one will argue too much with me about them either. Lucky them. How are you feeling?”

“Sad. Frustrated, confused, overwhelmed, and sad.”

She smiled, understanding. “A good time to meditate, then.”

The two meditated through the night, not cultivating just thinking through things. Occasionally one would stand and slowly run through a weapon drill or practice some boxing. Tian spent ten minutes making a single cup of tea, and stared into the second cup for a half hour before discarding it and fixing himself a fresh one. Liren declined his silent offer, pouring over the slip containing the spear art she received from Merciless. 

When dawn came, he greeted it with staff in hand. He gathered the feeling of righteousness around him and slowly ran through a simple drill. He was still drawn to the image of the tree over the water, but he could feel what Grandpa meant by the limitations of the arts he used as the inspiration for his nameless staff art. Moon Crossing the Lake was a movement art, but it was rooted in illusion and deception, being untouchable. The tree was an adaptation of the Verdant Spring, which wasn’t a combat art in the first place. The actual staff arts at the core were all unmentionable dreck, only learned for their few good ideas and a dearth of better options. 

His hands spun the smooth wood, grasping and releasing, raising and lowering. The core of it must be the righteousness. All the other imagery, the other inspiration, could be changed or dispensed with. What was at the core could not change. He was someone who would fight the pain. He would fight the corruption and sickness, in people and the world. He was someone who would slay a mad god. He didn’t need some precious tool to do it, and that’s all a weapon was- a tool. It was the hands moving the tool, and the will moving the hands, that truly mattered.

Liren knelt near him, her spear planted on the ground in front of her. She didn’t touch it. She just watched it, as the sun rose above it. Watched as it cast the first shadows of the day on the ground before it. Saw the hole it left in the world. She drew in a long breath, then exploded forward. Liren snatched up the spear and thrust. It was much slower than Tian was used to seeing. Not at all fitting with the speed she was moving when she grabbed it. But from what he observed out of the corner of his eye, the spear had a monstrous weight to it now. It no longer just pierced, it crushed. This required different qi and a different way of thinking about both spears and the elements as she used them. The first step of her broadening path.

The two silently refined their arts, discarding what wasn’t useful, constantly searching for the right balance and the essential core. Their moves were sometimes rough, sometimes smooth, always exploring, never sentimental. There was a humility to it, an appreciation of how they fell short of their own standards. There was an arrogance to it too.

They didn’t see the two elders watching them, nor the bitter expressions they didn’t bother hiding. The arts the two practiced, within but apart from the sect, were things that were not of the sect. They were things they had found outside, things that were no worse than the best the sect could offer. The sect could still help guide them. Stop them from taking a wrong turn in their studies. Speed up their mastery by years. But those were things the youths could dispense with. An ascetic and a revolutionary, they could dispense with most things, or find them themselves. The sect had taught them to be self-reliant.

Comments

Seadrake

Yeah, the consequences of your own actions are typically bitter like that.

Zenopath (AEV)

The sect needs to get outof their way. Its clear that the only way to keep these birds is to let them be free. If they choose to stay then reward them. Trying to cage them in a master student relation will only breed resentment.

Blackking👑

Thats what happens when you repeatedly reinforce that the people that they're supposed to depend on are unreliable. They were taught to be self-reliant so they became self-reliant.

FoolRegnant

I think Grandpa's point is right on the money - in terms of power and progression, not taking a master is fine, but the social and cultural repercussions will come. It waits to be seen how this impacts the sect going forward - are they able to fix the problems which caused the sect's failures in the first place without losing what made the sect special, and familial, in the first place. Tian and Liren can be loyal to the sect's principles without a master, but can everyone? Can they replace a system which has been imperfect but sustainable for thousands of years with something that is different but can last as long?

Thomas Buckley

Tftc! I have noticed that you refer to Tians cultivation art as Verdant Spring, not Advent of Spring. Is this change permanent?

porilaine

Is it Rui and Fu or someone else? But grandpa really is a great parent

Robert Mullins

It is the basic fundamental goal of any parent to raise a child that is capable of taking care of themselves and their own needs. ACM: wait, not like that...

s476

dreck? -> dirt?

David

I think it's finally sunk in just how badly the sect must feel like they messed up. The very best of the new generation - likely to be the very best of them, current elders included, do not need them and aren't really a part of the sect. Tian and Hong staying is to the benefit of the sect... and the sect has very little benefit to offer them.

Jackson Albert

It's probably Rui and Cruel Treachery.

Johan Persson

I think we're moving towards a resolution of some kind. Either the sect accepts that it needs to change, and lets go of the ego, or the heroes are letting go of the sect. I think our friends are going to be leaving.

João Vene

Probably Rui and Treachery

Kain

Eh I feel like they’re taking too much credit personally. I would say Fu and Bai and their individual monasteries/convents made them self sufficient. With a little help from Grandpa and Spear.

porilaine

I thought she was something more or diffrent than an elder, but it does make sense

Asheric

Dreck is like useless garbage

Jackson Albert

No, the use of dreck here is correct.

DrSubterfuge

It means trash, refuse. It comes to English through Yiddish.

Seadrake

Oh definitely, but I was referring to the consequences of not policing the sect properly and allowing for more than dickish behavior. I'm not saying that would have been easy to do, or if whatever they would have tried would have been successful. There are just consequences of not succeeding. Disciples that don't really give damn about the sect is one of those.

Woodsy

They are in many ways too talented, it gives them a freedom from constraints both good and bad.

Deus Ex Minima

Makes me wonder if White Peacock is still live streaming all of this, full production with reaction shots from the White Crane elders, Voidcatcher and Merciless snarking in chat like Statler and Waldorf in the Muppet Theatre.

David

I suppose a slightly unpopular opinion: I completely understand some bitterness. These are people who have not wronged Tian, and have actively worked to make the monastery a place that would not perpetuate these wrongs. In many ways, they have met the demands he stated before he left. And he's not budging an inch. I don't blame him for not budging, but they're not being absurd here, either.

Pharous

Oooh the tension on the mountain is high! I wonder what these elders are thinking of doing…

Deus Ex Minima

Yeah, that’s how I read that last line, too. Your kids are always, always learning from you, even when you don’t want them to.

Blackking👑

I mean if the sect was managed matter, even if they were self-reliant, they would've still depended on the sect like there's a very clear divide between who in the sect then trust and it happens to be the people that could've done. Something are the people that they don't trust and the people that couldn't have done anything and we're in the same position as them are the people that they still trust

Diarmuid McGinnity

Well tbh, I can’t see them spending thousands of years in the Heavenly and Human realms, after which people leave the monastery altogether. Maybe Warby is planning to do that but my hunch is this secret realm will accelerate them to nearly the peak of the heavenly realm in a year’s time. This tension is temporary, and they will be gone far far faster than any of the elders expect. I’d be annoyed if I thought i’d have to deal with this situation for millennia too.

Blackking👑

I mean, yeah, but they were never going to have the type of relationships with the elders/higher members of the sect that they they seem to expect

Teach

In defense of the sect, this level of progression isn’t normal. Of course a backwards wasteland sect wouldn’t build a system that would maximize the growth of two world protagonists. For a normie cultivator this sect system is better than literally any I’ve heard of

Seadrake

Yeah, they're seeing the best attempts to save their family that they've had for hundreds of years fail. It's rough letting down family when they're worth damn.

Boneco

Thanks for the chapter! I think one of the reasons a lot of the people in the sect fail to break through the higher realms is that they aren't true to thenselves, they dont follow a dao like Tian and Liren. When they need to make choices they choose the most logical one instead of the one that is true to their path or dao If Tian finds an herectic he will try to kill him, if he dies because the herectic is stronger, that was his fate. I think this kind of atitude might be necessary to raise through the realms I think Tian's dao has something to do with diminishing suffering and that was why he burned the herectic medicine book without reading Liren is something related to justice or justice itself

Grant Prater

Cruel Treachery reminds me of the trial skeleton, forget their name. Hope her story gets resolved

Mobb

I feel like I finally understand why the sect has an obsession with filial piety, it all comes down to fear like tian already realized at least to a degree. Not the fear of betrayal, at least not in itself, but the fear that both will become like them. No rather they are convinced of it. Starsieve is the perfect example. Old and strong Daoist have a strong tendency to become apathetic and only very strong relationships matter to them after a few millennia. Thats why Starsieve didn’t blink an eye at killing thousands of sect members and millions of mortals, but the fact that he disappointed his predecessor and sect family drove him to suicide. They hope that creating a familial relationship will prevent them from becoming monsters, because even if they don’t care about anything else they will at least try their best a honoring the monasteries core values and their masters teachings. The thing is that even this boils down to a lack of trust and belief, but you can’t really blame them if they themselves failed.

Robert Mullins

I mean, they already have accepted it. Or at least one of the daoist masters has. That's exactly why they are accepting tian and Liren now.

Master Program

It really is kind of ironic how badly the sects final gambit of sending them up to the holy land backfired. It was supposed to open their eyes to how big the world was, how old monsters would be far more demanding while rewarding only a fraction of what the monastery would. Instead the trip gave them all the tools they needed to grow independently and cemented the fact that the monastery needed them more than they needed it.

David

It's very clear in the story that West Town, including Fu and Bai, are the way they are in large part due to Rui.

Chris Britt

Almost certainly. This is probably the best entertainment theyve had in years

JackassofAllTrades

"but they won’t be pillars of the sect the way Fu and you kids will be. And Fu… keeps his own council. He’s burnt too, and is exactly the kind of person who can bend a flow in the direction he prefers, not where others would have it go." Poor Skull Crusher Bai, even Grandpa seems to have forgotten about her. It's still crazy to me that we've not seen her and Tian even speak, I think the last time we saw her was back in west town temple during Tian and Liren's second duel. She practices the staff right? Tian should ask her to trade pointers.

JTP

What a damning final line.

Island Relics

I wholeheartedly agree with you on the reason those in the sect tend to fail break throughs is because of the lack of following ones called (chosen) dao. This is exemplified in the stated rarity of tribulations during ascension in the sect. Though I will disagree on what I think Tian’s dao is. I believe that it falls closer to the dao of morality itself. If it fell into diminishing suffering then the choice to burn the book could be seen as going against it. With the slightest possibility of something in the book being able to help in diminishing said suffering. While morality as a consequence diminishes suffering through the simple act of walking it out, while not at all tolerating what is immoral.

Donmalurkin

I always like it when you use the word doddle. Learned it the first time ring grandpa said it and it's been fun to see since. Lol

Donmalurkin

Guessing Rui and Cruel Treachery. Edit: Xianxia equivalent of Ninjad

vaelentinus0526

he does that randomly. he had done it in one of the earlier volumes i believe 1 or 2

Kain

I concede Rui might have some claim, though I think him saying “everything” they find appealing about the sect stems from him and his master is more than a bit of an exaggeration. But we don’t even know that Rui is one of these elders. I think we can rule Fu and Bai out because of the bitter expressions both of them would just be proud of their kids, the fact we can’t rule Rui out for the same reason I think speaks to his having an inflated sense of his branch’s impact Fu and Bai personally did a TON of work effortlessly that the others just refuse to do or are incapable of doing. But it might not even be him. CT is an extra step removed from Rui and so has even less of a claim and anyone else basically has no claim.

Brian P.

They didn’t directly harm Tian or Hong themselves, but they were invested in, and actively upheld the institution that: caused the heretic problem through inaction, allowed the Long clan and their like to flourish, encouraged the mentality of the Long clan and the like through secrecy and pride, and ordered two thirteen year old kids to fight a war. They wanted to fix things but their incrementalism allowed evil to flourish, with Starsieve being the one to force drastic change by filtering the membership and locking the mountain. If they had their way it would have been decades to centuries before real change was managed, with most of the terrible actions continuing for that time.

Deus Ex Minima

Hadn’t thought of it this way, but this is really solid framing, I’m glad you brought it up!

FoolRegnant

Not right now, but look at Cruel Treachery. She's been a member of the sect for thousands of years. Tian and Liren are twenty. Will they still feel the same in a hundred years? In a thousand? Maybe. Are the elders right in what this means for the sect? I feel like that is a more certain thing. Tian and Liren will change how the sect works, and maybe it's for the best, but I don't think there's a clear right choice for either side here.

Donmalurkin

Lack of story presence unfortunately. Makes me wonder if we will get a chapter or two with her eventually while Tian develops his staff art and spell.

FoolRegnant

Yeah, I feel for everyone involved. Tian is certain in his certainty and unwilling to bend, which is admirable and totally reasonable, but I think that the elders have also tried to be as flexible as possible without fully breaking with the traditions they hold most dear, and they just can't bridge that gap.

Fuyge

Maybe but if the relationship moves from family to institution it’s not just the relationship with the elders that will change. In the outer court tian was treated truly as a little brother by the other disciples. It’s a relationship that’s much closer to family than that of a pure institution. In a way it’s exactly this familial part of the sect that tian fell in love with. If the sect now moves away from the idea of the sect as family it will affect the new outer court as well. Most likely new disciples will never develop the relationship tian had with his senior brothers. I do think tian is not fully aware of all the consequences of this change.

G&S Gaming

I love that last line. And, as a parent who has a kid who wants to join the American military *now* of all times.... A competent and smart kid, Eagle Scout, amazing and kind kid.... I get it.

David

Their school of thought has had power in the instition for none of the events you are discussing.

G&S Gaming

I think, probably one of the smartest things I ever said to my son, was that even if something I do only teaches you how you *don't want to be as a person,* that's still a valuable lesson. I just hope I'll keep those teaching moments to a bare minimum xD

G&S Gaming

Yeah that's exactly what I was trying to say last chapter. The stuff like the friendly fight over food bowls, and to fill a juniors bowl, and stuff like Fu learning tea after a very mercenary life, who knows what will remain of those things if the sect becomes a purely business-like place.

Mqrius

And yet, being treated as a brother didn't come with an upfront requirement of vowing them to be his brothers, or his father. That happened naturally after a time of being treated right.

EvilLittleThing

Righteousness, not morality. And kindness. Tian is very kind, even when merking heretics.

G&S Gaming

Just as a side note on the discussion of morality, I am quite fond of Joshua Greene's takes on the subject. If anyone here is interested in 300-400ish page theoretical discussions about the nature of reality do an internet search for his thesis or books imo. The thesis paper was particularly good. It's basically a dissection of why Kantian morality doesn't work, only consequentialist morality makes sense, linguistically speaking. Tl;dr version is whenever we base morality on something *other than* the consequences of an action it becomes linguistic nonsense. Like "Whatever God wants is good" is a form of circular reasoning because God and good are synonymous, you're basically defining the term using itself. So while you might believe in such a system you can't ever effectively communicate what it means to anyone else. You might personally believe that morality is based upon God with the capital G, but in order to communicate it you have to describe a consequence. (Please note how other people feel about your actions *is* one of those consequences. You could justify killing one person to save five, in a certain sense, but you'll have to live with the consequences and the close friends and family of the one may *strongly* disagree. Or, you know, if the one was a saint and the five were heretics that is also a factor. It gets complicated and messy, absolute morality like "it's always wrong to tell a lie or kill" is nonsense at the end of the day. You can only really talk about morality by acknowledging consequences)

Island Relics

Yes, I agree with you, though I will say that it has been emphasized that a good daoist nudges things in a direction they desire while only stepping in when absolutely necessary. In this I would say that Rui has a large impact on the good things in the sect. If given a few more centuries of him pushing for influence to be put on people like Fu I can see there being a positive impact on the sect. Maybe after half a millennium the sect could be wildly different from what we see today, but with all the chaos he had to actively step in. Especially with the harsh realities of what the coming generation face, and see in the leadership of the sect. Also, in my opinion, it’s quite unfilial to take such a long view with something so bad being allowed to propagate in the sect. And only waiting till someone like Fu or Bai to pop up to start really doing anything about it. At least this is how I understand it.

erfan ashkan

Yeah also cruel treachery with her long life knows that she is staring at the barrel of her sect disbanding. If the new generation follows the thinking of Tian and Liren in a generation or two there wont be a crane monastary any more. Or at least there wont be a familly for her.

Noroh

🎵"Careful the things you say, Children will listen. Careful the things you do, Children will see, and learn..."🎵

Chris Britt

The more I learn and think about this, the more I think the Monastery have misunderstood the teachings of the Ancient Crane. Would a being who preached you should exit this life like you were taking off a robe really demand unflinching loyalty from those beneath it? I doubt it. I think rather The Crane demonstrated filial piety but did not properly elaborate on it. A parent should act in the best interest of their child even if they child does not understand, and a child should trust that the parent acts in its best interest even if they don't understand. The trap lies in that you can justify any action with this line of reasoning, but once the child realizes that you have been abusing their trust then the bonds of filial piety are severed forever.

zero

our heroes bout to learn to be agentic 👊

Chris Britt

Thats the thing though....these once in a generation talents are who is supposed to be leading the sect. The sect bungled its future leaders. Sure you can stick some middling talent who plodded along as the sect master, but that will spell the end of the institution eventually.

Joshua Flowers

How many sect elders are they watching? Rui, Cruel Treachery, Fu(?), Bai(?)

Zephyr

I keep hoping he goes back to the cave at some point too.

Tabac Iberez

The sect will be seen as an institution until they stop sending disciples to war as an institution, restrict access to critical resources like an institution, and operate branch outposts that work with minimal oversight towards institutional goals. Or more prosaicly: Cruel Treachery must realize her sect destroyed both students' families. If they were filial, then there would be a great vengeance underway. Does she, and by extension Rui and the rest, really want to open that door?

William Johnson

These last couple chapters have been amazing. Just seeing the elders who love the sect but let it become the mess it was confronted with the consequences of their inaction is possibly the greatest face slapping arc I've seen. Cruel Treachery is truly coming to appreciate what she lost through passivity and disinterest.

Noroh

Interesting, I will have to take a look. I do find consequentialism to be the perfect example of why morality itself is circular, not that I believe morality doesn't exist more that it is inherently ineffable. For example, consequentialism will say what matters is not so much the intent, but the effects. How do we judge the effects? Even if you say "what materially benefits the greatest number of people" as a standard of good, the choice for that to be the standard is just as arbitrary as saying "the Law of God" is the standard. Baked into most consequentialist definitions I have seen are the same issues Kant was having, that is in the absence of a unified religious framwork how do you justify morality? It is that last bit of the sentence that is telling, as it shows there is already a cultural element of morality that the indivitual making their definition is trying to reach. It is inescapable, we are mired in our cultural millieu and even when we seek to change it for the better we recreate the parts we find comforting, hence it being called reform lol.

Noroh

This is almost certainly part of it, and I hadn't considered it either, but they basically said something similar when they tested Tian for sociopathy back in book 1.

William Johnson

It's an interesting framing, but it makes revolutionaries like Liren and Tian vitally important. You need people to shake things up from time to time and reset the sect, otherwise you get too up your own butt about elders and tradition and stop doing anything. So you know, maybe working as intended?

William Johnson

Kids are learning the most when you don't want them to.

Noroh

Sweet Lord, have you tried telling them that there are better ways to serve their country? Politics perhaps, we could use more smart and kind polititians, and it would be just as bloody a fight too 😅

Noroh

I think part of it is time as well. Rui clawed his way up the hierarchy trying to change things, to prove that they could be better, he knows where Tian and Hong are coming from. The Dao reserves don't though, from their perspective they closed their eyes for a few moments and suddenly everything went to shit. For a group of people who spend hundreds of years like we spend an hour Tian and Hong seem like they are coming out of left field, because the Daoist Masters are still imagining the Monastary of their youth, not the one that is here now.

FoolRegnant

That's true, and that really is Tian's fundamental point - his brothers made him into family informally first, the elders haven't done the same, but maybe the sect can pivot into that kind of position before things really fall apart. The elders should act more like parents to the Heavenly disciples, the Heavenly disciples should act more like parents to the Earthly disciples, and that can build that naturally. The only problem is making that work across thousands and tens of thousands of people. It's hard to scale natural affection to the institutional level, which is what the master-disciple relationship is trying to do, cutting down in that institutionality in exchange for a more awkward, more forced initial relationship.

G&S Gaming

I highly recommended the Coast Guard instead of the Navy if he really really wants to serve right now, since it's far more rescue oriented generally. He has his heart set on being a nuclear engineer or communications officer aboard an aircraft carrier and seeing the world. I tried to say the Coast Guard gets to see the world too, and if he doesn't get enough of that in the Coast Guard he could always use the training he gets to try and get a better position than usual working for a cruise ship or something. He is very convinced that he knows what he is getting into. The best compromise I could make is he is going to read a few books on military and Navy history and discuss them with me before I sign the paperwork letting him join after he graduates (he is graduating early and will still be 17). Among them is Fiasco (about Iraq/Afghanistan) and War Is A Racket by Smedley Butler, as well as 3 books about different incidents/operations in the Persian Gulf. Fingers crossed that some of that dissuades him, or he changes his mind if the war in Iran right now spirals into something much larger

G&S Gaming

Iirc, and keep in mind it's been *years* since I read the thesis paper, Greene doesn't dismiss intent or say faith is worthless. Only that discussions of morality that are entirely divorced from real world consequences are inherently meaningless. Personally I do believe intent matters, it's just that consequence matters *more.* Like if you're intent is to defraud or harm me but what you do ends up helping me instead I can't even be all that mad about it. It doesn't mean I will trust you afterwards, if that makes sense? But also regardless of your intentions if I end up hurt by something you do you need to be able to acknowledge that. IDGAF about your intentions if your actions cause harm. One saying I always try to keep in mind when thinking about morality though is "what is good for the fox is evil for the chicken, what is good for the chicken is evil for the fox." Because foxes eat chickens. Without eating stuff like chickens a fox's kits will starve. But the world needs both foxes and chickens. Most of what we consider to be "good" is just good for *us.* Most of what we consider evil is just that which harms us. I think the only true Good with the capital G is that which helps the entire community of life thrive, especially if you need to make *some* level of sacrifice to achieve it. That which is truly Evil is that which harms the greater community of life overall, especially if you did it solely for personal gain. But there are countless shades in between and most people/living things are, at the end of the day, just okay. Not truly Good or Evil even if they're a nice/shitty person to *you.* Just okay.

s476

Funnily circles back to German, but fair enough

Venerable Ro

Another angle on this filial relationship business occurs to me, the intimate degree of trust inherent in passing on this kind of teaching. The Sky Treading Art is a paradigm-defining insight, a series of principles that can bestow a far-reaching perspective sufficient to inform a cultivator's, everything, really. Moon Crossing The Lake is far more than "just" a movement art in terms of what it's done for Tian's comprehension, The Sky Treading Art is the same kind of conceptual insight. Therefore, understanding the Art in its entirety would give a substantial advantage towards understanding a cultivator who uses it as their foundation. Just like an enemy who recognized the nature of Moon Crossing The Lake would have a much easier time catching Tian That's why they're so reticent to hand it out, as much as it's a priceless boon to their disciples it would also be a deadly weapon in the hands of an enemy. One student breaking the chain of filiality and misusing it or the teaching falling into the hands of someone like Black Iron could very easily create a bane tailored to their lineage. It's probably a whole discipline akin to Gu, something something "Foundation Severing Technique". Tian's, irreverence, signals very strongly that he doesn't hold the Art or its practitioners in any particular esteem, which means/implies that he wouldn't go to especial lengths to keep it safe *when* he takes off into the blue as he so very clearly means to. Thus Elder Rui has to consider the very real chance that giving Tian the Art results in someone else turning up in a century or so with a technique tailored to him, Elder Cruel Treachery, and so on. Filial bonds. Protect your family by protecting your secrets. Tian would sooner cut out his tongue than speak a single word that could harm Fu, that's the framing that should have been used.

Argivian

It's pretty direct, I'd say--Rui was in charge of West Town when Tian's family was murdered and he ended up in the dump. Tian may have forgiven Fu, but he certainly hasn't forgotten.

erfan ashkan

I never thought about it like that but most power fantasy mcs in the xienxia genre that i know seem to be kind of against filial piety. They often dont want to be beholden to an organisation since it can stiffle their growth. Its kind of like our dominant libertarian / neoliberal individualist ideologie surfaces in that moment. They dont owe any one anything since they are self made men and grinded for everything they got.

Lady Merlin

The thing that frustrates me is that Tian/Liren/Wang can't be the first 'rebellious' types in ACM to have arisen in those thousand years. They just 'matter' now to their high cultivation/fortuitous circumstances. We know how Wang was treated prior to us meeting him in the story (jailed, for being an idealist), which I assume was on the harsher side of the norm. Put a different way, it's like imagining all the queer folks in history who had to live in the closet (suppressed/repressed) vs living in more progressive communities today - Tian, Liren, and Wang are the tip of the Spear that is pushing through the barrier, but I'm sad for those who came before that likely had to either go with the flow or lose their community (and a chance at immortality/greater ability to defend themselves in this harsh xianxia world) that came before.

Golden monkey

I think it's worth noting that in every other cultivation story nobody really cares about the sect unless you're some kinda young master related to an elder. I'm sure almost every outer sect disciple while feeling prideful about wearing the colors knows they aren't really disciples. And every inner court realizes that core and direct disciples are actually "part of the sect. Its kinda why I've felt weird about this conflict because that includes the elders, they don't care that nobody cares because they don't care either. And I don't think I've ever read a story where a side or main character actually loves the sect they are apart of and feels tied down emotionally to it. And the same goes to the elders in this story. They were mad that Tian didn't care about some bird's teachings. They don't even teach it on the grounds that everyone under them aren't worthy until they prove they are. And until you are you have to fight and kill and almost die and at that point who cares. The last scene especially, what are they sad about? They don't give or teach techniques, they give out scraps and expect you to pick stuff out and make something of it. Heck I felt like the way Hong and Tian grew was by design because they just kinda threw problems and stuff at them and told to not die. I just think its weird they suddenly care about this "family" they've been actively ignoring.

Golden monkey

Here's what I think if they want a sect that'll survive they're on the right track just keep compromising until the gap gets close enough. If they want a "family" with connections and lines and lineage, they're going to have to keep bending. Because true fillial relationships have to start from the master either wanting a son or daughter (ie disciple) or them being someone a person would want as a parent not just because they hace good techniques. Otherwise you get transactional relationships pretending not to be and those almost always end in betrayal of some kind.

Zenopath (AEV)

I would feel sorry for the ACM if they didnt use child soldiers. Would'va thunk them child soldiers are not particularly "fial" to the people who sent them off to a war that was only started because of the sheer greed and incompetence of those same people.

CastorInvictus

Maybe Cruel Trechary's name is referring to driving child soldiers to kill on a hellish battlefield then demanding their affection and loyalty.

Rhyx

I feel like its gonna take Tian having a full PTSD attack next to Cruel Treachery so she can mind read THAT to understand just how badly the Sect failed them..

Jonathan Grant

How many sect members actually thought of the sect as family? Only the ones who reach her level or have the potential to. Everyone else has been treated like a disposable. “The faces change”. Such a mild way of talking about people you aren’t going to meet twice because you met them between meditation sessions. Do they think of this old monster as family? Do they dare?

Christopher

I would love to hear the POV of the mountain beast elders as they watch the sect elders watch Tien and Liren. It would be good comedy that could also help shape the filial narrative from a hopefully different perspective. I feel like the way of this sect is not the only way and that the world view of the sect elders is extremely limited.

Fayhem

Well, there's a reason that literally everyone was always saying that Dog Nose was not cut out to be a good sect leader lol

Chris Fey

Your name is familiar

SomeGuy

I mean it didn't help that the Masters they were sent too ended up not being who the sect wanted them to train under. It seems like they were sent to master with the polar opposite aspects then the sect wanted them to train under.

Veridescent

Shen is interesting as a concept, because its another one of those super syncretic ones that gets folded into the Neo-confucian framework while technically being multiple concepts from other sources. Shen is a bunch of things but one could note that it actually fits really well into a couple of different concepts brought up. The least institutional is the comment Jun made on dragons. They arent Yin or Yang, not really, thats just mortals being unable to grasp their whole selves due to a lack of perspective and consequently they conceptualize them as if them being both/all is contradictory. Its the awe of a thing that has achieved wholeness and so is seemingly constituted of contradictory elements. So that ties fairly easily into energy bodies and holding a aspect of perfection so total in scope it supercedes the binary illusions of before while also kind of defining a linked cycle of binaries. Neo-confucianism is always messy, with some of Shen kind of existing in legitimizing the ideation of the celestial bureaucracy and the celestial emperor having been around forever. Its also focused on those celestial eminences affecting and pervading the spritial aspect of humanity and radiating that down to the mortal world. To have Shen both defines and notes the state of being one of those celestial beings who in turn define the world. Its amusing to consider the heavenly demons celestial focus do this very literally. And how closely this matches into Slumrats cosmology. Its a fun if contradictory thing given how anthropocentric Neo-confucianism is. Ie. Humans are the prime form of cultivation and while Qi is both ancient and all pervading its also a direct result of the interactions of gods and mortality. If Tian ever said he wanted to kill the mad god out loud, it would get some fun reactions from the Daoist I am sure I do feel a pair of key kind of collories to note on the Sect as a instiution framing is that the Sect is already a insitution. Its ideation of family is very much a instiutional framework. Cruel Treacheries true note is more or less a refutation and struggle with identity. The people may change but the pattern of values and interactions do not, allowing her to maintain a sense of self tied to the Sect. This is however for her the same core trap as that "hero of the sect" focused Cultivator that Tian felt he ruined earlier on. It is a focus on a aspect of humanly attachment at the cost of ignoring the nature of that identity and the wider world. Which you can say is a general pattern of the Sect, facilitated by it being a big fish in a tiny pond for a long time. .The sects focus on its own knowledge base from a position of assumed hiearchal and total primacy for better methods blinds it on multiple fronts. Because that assumption both counters the Dao being all pervading and encloses the identity of being a sect member a lack of openness to learning. They arent the only beings of knowledge in the wasteland, nor are they the only people to have ever cultivated. Its a assumption of being a objective source of superiority rather than simply one of infinite peers in the Dao, aided by the resource scarcity of the wasteland. It is the arrogance of one who hasn't admittted in humility, there is nothing wrong with acknowledging how much you dont know if you want to attain mastery.

King Eater

At what age does it become acceptable to be sent to die for the economy?