Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

for sexy reasons

Files

Comments

The25th

Stop making me feel bad for Joe, I’m supposed to be a sicko

Girlycore

Still a Sicko here, hoping Joe and Joyce cheat at the same time and end up realising they are polyamorous.

Hirst

That feels like it would undo a ton of Joe's personal progress

The25th

It all cancels out right?

Vivian

Oh Joe, you're trying so hard — I worry what will happen if things don't work out with this girl you've put on a pedestal.

Dan Rabin

1. Does Rachel's face in panel 4 show maybe just a hint of actually *listening* to Joe? 2. Joe is going to need another shower after this, and a hernia will make it difficult.

Ria

This strip to me makes it very clear that no matter where he and Joyce end up – and tbh, I don't feel like he'll be too well off with it :'( – he's going to be strong enough to maintain his course from here on out

tifani

You’ve still done the things you’ve done and guilt isn’t change. Jesus fucking Christ what do you WANT from humanity Rachel? Having guilt over past behavior is an evolutionary benefit that ensures change! What is a good person as defined by you? Someone who never makes mistakes to begin with? Someone who never fucks up or re-evaluates? That standard is impossible to live up to! You have to LET people learn and make mistakes and decide to be better. Otherwise what’s the fucking point?

Harold

I realize she may have valid, specific reasons for feeling the way she does, and being so unbendingly rigid about it, but right now, at this moment: Fuck ALL the way off, Rachel.

Ria

He is *really* trying. He got launched into trying, into being his best possible self, by way of Joyce believing in him. But it's bigger than that now: first piece of evidence is that Rachel can't pop his bubble so quickly anymore; and then narratively, given his direct involvement in telling Dorothy to be honest with herself + the fact that it would be Joyce fucking up (and not him) that ruins the relationship, it really feels like his central issue – total lack of faith in himself to stay loyal to a partner – is already meaningfully healed or at least moving towards being so.

darklion

Change Takes Time

C

It absolutely matters if someone changes. Holy shit, how does one even get to the point of having a worldview like that? I hope Rachel does, indeed, change from such a view...

C

I have to believe no matter how it ends, Joe has grown as a person, and for more than just Joyce, that he's also grown for himself to some degree.

Girlycore

That's how human beings work. Sometimes they backslide on their journey forward. I'm hoping Joe backslides into Rachel in this particular case.

T Campbell

"Here, allow me to set the bar so high that you can't possibly meet my standards unless you literally Quantum Leap into your past self to erase your own past sins, wiping yourself from existence in the process." Never have I wanted so much to get into a pointless time-sucking debate with a wildly unreasonable fictional character, except for the last time RAIDAH went on a rant, so good job, David, you have engineered the desired outcome 😆

Genevieve

Seeing her disbelief in the potential of people to change is really interesting - it would be very easy for her to give him the slightest of polite outs here and she's clearly taking another path. I hope we see enough more of her that we get to learn more about where she's coming from

Alison Berry

Man remember being 19 and being like this is who I am forever and also all the people I know are like this forever and then 20 years later half of you aren't even the same gender let alone the same personality

berryquiche

Remembering she used to be Ruth's roommate...

Railway Series Book Club

Kinda getting the feeling this cutaway is build-up to Joe eventually blaming whatever happens re: Joyce/Dorothy/Maytag Round 2 on himself. He's put Joyce on a pedestal and probably is still at least a little bit unsure about how good of a job he's done at changing himself, even if he is trying his best. He could easily blame his influence on Joyce becoming such a wildly different person that she'd cheat on him, or perhaps take the alternate route of thinking this is the natural result of Joyce needing a sexual outlet that isn't quite so intimidating. (Which, given previous words from Joyce to Dorothy, would be slightly more on the money...) Either way, he'd see himself as the root cause. Of course, he'd be wrong if that were his assessment, since Joyce's hormone-driven mistakes are purely her own and are well within her own agency. But we all have our own Demons Anxiety, and these could be what Joe's would whisper to him in that moment.

Maude Reads Things

These two are having a really interesting conversation and I want deeper in both their heads

Beck Chonigman

You're right Racel, guilt isn't change. Behavior is. And my glob this man has already changed so much of his behavior thus far. He is actively trying not to say a lewd thing in public. And even if he slips up, he still continues to dedicate his efforts to being better. By that definition, he has changed. Unless actions don't matter and only intent does, then his intent to change, whether it is guilt or not, is also genuine. So by that definition, he has also changed. So I guess you don't know what change is, is what I'm saying.

Donny K

Proud of my boy and doin' the little 'git 'm! Git' 'm!' thing from Gravity Falls

SkittleE

[Grandpa Simpson voice] And it'll happen to you!!!

Shane Wegner

I say this as technically an internet minister: Few people want sermons, unsolicited sermons even less so.

Lisa

Jeez, Rachel's like a secular Mary.

Grace Serenity

She's a college student who is so far up her own ass is how one gets like that. I'm sure she'll mellow with time, but probably not before the comic ends

Grace Serenity

I was SEVERELY burned by the church. But I will say that forgiveness and change were a couple of the few things I kept and they have served me well!

Maybeeus

Lots of hate for Rachel, i feel like most folks get the wrong read on her whole deal, she's not a Raidah or Mary she's the asshole anti hero who acts outside of the rest of the casts jurisdiction but always shows up to help when it really counts. Every bit of venom she speaks comes from a place of experience here and judging by her face i get the feeling she's not even fully convinced herself. I feel like she's a few steps of self actualization from becoming a widely beloved character in contrast to someone like Mary who has surrendered to the idea of ever changing as a person in any meaningful way. edit tldr ver: Basically she wants to fuck Joe but she doesn't want to admit to it because she knows he's an asshole and doesn't know how to process the idea that he's actually positively changing because of what that means of her own inability to overcome grief.

MrShoggoth

Both those options are terrible for Joe because his father repeatedly cheated on his mother, and it's why he was the way he was at the start of the strip. Do you realise the levels of hatred and self-loathing that would unlock?

Sajuuk-Khar

Doing some self-examination, I think one of the reasons I just want to like tune out whenever Rachel appears on a page is that her relationship with Joe in the Walkyverse always felt kind of…I dunno, like a marker that that Joe didn’t actually need to change, that he couldn’t help being the horndog, boys will be boys and here’s a girl who is down for it, etc. And so it’s been so nice and so refreshing to see Dumbiverse Joe go all in on Working On Himself, and I’m just like, stay away from him and his beautiful little anxiety for Joyce Also like she shit in my girl Ruth’s mouth when Ruth was super vulnerable, so get fucked, Rach. I know she was a bad roommate and all, but get fucked.

Alexandra Falk

If we didn't have insight into these characters' lives, I don't think we'd disagree with Rachel. If we only knew what she knew, then we might think the same things. This is good writing.

Sajuuk-Khar

Oh yeah, the writing is top-notch here. A lot of times conversations like this feel contrived but this is natural as heck.

NinjaZaku

I think the thing I really loathe about Rachel's rhetoric here is there is no room for growth. Even if people (like Joe and Ruth both) have changed their behavior, taken accountability for their wrongdoings, it doesn't matter. They are just a bad person forever. There's no room for nuance or sympathy. Just tossing them aside. And that just sounds so...deeply lonely and cynical.

Smoochie

I think he has at least given Rachel something to think about. That yes, guilt isn’t change, feeling bad isn’t change but that doesn’t mean it can’t be a VEHICLE for change. Does whatever the details in the fine print really matter when we got the course correct we were looking for? Not all the time. Life is much more complex than that.

Mohmi

Rachel is like every insufferable leftist I know who is convinced that you can't have progressive politics if you haven't disowned your slightly conservative parents or w/e

Ste Saunders

"Celebrity A made a questionable tweet 15 years ago, we all need to hate them now!"

Ste Saunders

Truth and Beauty are wonderful words but shrapnel is shrapnel and at the end of the day I am alone with the things I have done. - A Softer World, #227

Jeremy AR

Not even remotely in the same ball park.

Jeremy AR

If only we could stop yelling at Rachel long enough to do it.

Katrina Marie Paton

Hey, I'll give anyone a chance. But if you abuse that, then screw you. Can totally relate to Rachael here. Her saying Joe's "changed" clearly shows she doesn't believe a word of it and simply avoiding her, if anything, doesn't show any willingness on Joe's part to make amends. Tossing aside people who have messed you up sounds like a healthy thing to do in my opinion, and we have no reason to believe Rachael is in the slightest bit lonely. Cynical, sure, but a certain level of cynicism when it comes to people like Ruth and Joe were is actually a good thing. Hurt me once, shame on you. Hurt me twice, shame on me.

Harry Adams

"No it's not possible to have personal growth or change of view and opinion in those 15 years, they said it once and they are clearly evil."

Giant Speck

Are we going to get more flashbacks from the time when Rachel and Ruth were roommates? Because it would be interesting to see what incident caused Rachel to adopt this mentality; surely it couldn't have just been Ruth being rude upon them meeting for the first time.

Ryan Malcolm

I'd be sympathetic towards Rachel, except she's the instigator of this wee confrontation. Joe is minding his business, and is working at bettering himself, and Rachel comes in and flat out makes it clear she still thinks he's a terrible person, because he was the last time he encountered her. If she wasn't full of herself, she would either hae left the gym on seeing him or just started working out without speaking tae him. Whatever her reasons

joe mcguire

Rachel seems to be repeatedly guilty of something I hate to see in people: the mindset that people are just one thing. People are never just one thing, they are ugly AND beautiful AND cruel AND kind AND stupid AND brilliant. And no, that doesn’t mean instant forgiveness for the bad things just because there are also good things, but in that same way it shouldn’t mean total and blanket dismissal of a person because there are bad things about them. And if a person is working actively to give more power to their good attributes than their bad, and all you can do is judge them and say “they’ll never be good enough” well you’ve instantly become lower in my eyes than the person trying to change. But everyone is capable of being small minded and shallow temporarily, so I hope that Rachel will break out of this circle of self righteousness and learn that forgiveness isn’t a cop out, but actually something that takes extreme courage and strength.

Astariel

Exactly. They both believe they are the only righteous person, and everyone else is irrevocably damned.

Mariah

the issue is rachel goes out of her way to put people down and say they can't change. No one is saying the rachel needs to befriend ruth or joe but its totally fair to not want to be around someone who is going to put you down and dismiss your progress. Ruth was suicidal and mentally unwell when rachel said she was irredemable. There is no excuse for that.

Anna Phylaxis

Oh Joe and Rachel could be a VERY fun couple, some day in the future.

Joe360

It could simply be Ruth promising she would stop drinking and not following her words again, and again, and again, and again, and...

tifani

@mariah: Exactly this. I agree and this is important to remember. Rachel doesn’t seem to be willing to even consider the larger context of what causes behavior and that would be fine for her IF she didn’t make a point of continuing to point out wrongdoings to guilt trip people. She told Ruth redemption was a myth. She’s telling Joe his change is just guilt and “guilt doesn’t count”. Someone more sensitive taking this to heart could absolutely relapse hearing words like this. She’s potentially a danger because of this and she’s either ignoring that or she doesn’t care.

Mariah

like think about the ruth situation what if ruth attempted suicide even if you believe ruth was a evil person billie was also at risk rachel took a very dangerous situation and made all about herself. Joe one could argue had a sex addiction imagine telling a addict oh you have not really changed its just guilt and then they go back to drugs or alcohol. By all means cut toxic people out of your life and believe they can't change but do not try to guilt and shame them every chance you get especially someone with addiction/mental health issues. I have delt with toxic people in my life but you do not instigate with them like this its bad for everyone involved.

Girlycore

I realize. I'm just happy to read that particular flavor of drama!

Ph

Do you have an example of when she's shown up to help?

Lisa

This feels deeper to me than issues with a freshman year roommate. I think someone important must have failed Rachel when she was a kid.

NinjaZaku

@Mariah You nailed the point i was trying to make exactly. Thank you.

joe mcguire

I don’t recall….any time she’s been helpful? I mean, Walkyverse Rachel is super helpful, but I don’t remember this Rachel doing much of anything

Maybeeus

Rachel is a pretty minor character overall but when she called out Ruth and Joe respectively it felt like she was wholly justified and sticking up for people who otherwise wouldn't have it just happens both have made leaps and bounds to become better people. She's gotten very little time in the comic because she doesn't have an "In" and she's several years older than most of the cast and every interaction has been with folks she hates for whatever reason.