Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

you can't change because they stopped making pennies

Files

Comments

Minzoku Bokumetsu

CHANGE IS IMPOSSIBLE SARAH WHY BOTHER TO EXERCISE - somebody

Giant Speck

Of all the people to show up to this conversation, Sarah is honestly the funniest option.

Ria

I hope Rachel learns better about the world before she graduates and becomes a tech ultra-girlboss

MrShoggoth

Yeah, take that, character so devoid of personality I don't remember their name!!

Jeremy AR

Honestly i wanna see what happened to Rachel to left her with such fucked up belief. It kinda reminded me of the flawed system of the afther life in the good place where you ended up dammed even if you did a lot of good if you didn't do it for entirely selfless reasons or caused harm to others unintentionally due to your personality flaws while being otherwise a good person.

Lia

sarah training arc... cant wait for the tournament arc

Maybeeus

You'd best start believing in redemption arcs Miss Jackson. You're in one.

Simon Magid

A while ago I decided that the point to changing was to do better. Not to 'redeem' yourself but simply and plainly to do better in the future, avoiding hurting others where you once would have and helping out where you wouldn't. No matter the opinions of others, nothing could take that away from you. And maybe that isn't redemption, but it still matters.

Packy Anderson

- somebody tomorrow in the main site comments

C

"PEOPLE DON'T CHANGE! SO STOP CHANGING IN FRONT OF ME IN RAPID SUCCESSION!"

Paul McCubbrey

Oh god. That’s “there’s no such thing as altruism because it makes you feel good”. That’s what that is.

Harold

[Rachel clocks Joe upside the head with a weight] Sarah: "What the FUCK?!?" Rachel: "You can thank me later - just get out of here before he wakes up!"

Dan Rabin

A previous station wipe-off from Joe: https://www.dumbingofage.com/2020/comic/book-10/02-to-remind-you-of-my-love/towel/ The strip before that gives some context re: long-term goals. I'm finding it a challenge to analyze Rachel's side of this interaction because we've seen very little of Rachel's character outside of her arguments with Joe and Ruth. There's another tiny hint from Booster: https://www.dumbingofage.com/2020/comic/book-11/01-this-bright-millennium/sobstory/

Sajuuk-Khar

Ohhhh she’s a philosophy major and she’s Like That

Harold

Maybe we can upgrade Other Rachel to Rachel and start calling *this* one Other Rachel instead

TobyTura

yay sarah and joe interaction!!! i love them so

E

I thought she was CS? I forget

Fart Captor

Rachel's scepticism is well-earned but she's making some really shakey leaps in logic

Mariah

someone said rachel didnt seem lonely I sure think she is now.

Megh

Between all the Paramore stuff last chapter and Rachel saying people never change, I now have Misery Business stuck in my head At least it's a good song

Sajuuk-Khar

She might be a CS major who reads hella dumb philo texts, which makes this anxiety that she’s now inflicting on others as a worldview worse, if anything, lmao I’m not saying it’s causation but damn if the correlation doesn’t look a certain way

taekwondogirl

I find Rachel more exhausting than Malaya. :|

HenryVolt

Well, if not wanting to be just another dick head in a world that doesn't need any more of them is being selfish then, I guess some people should be allowed to be a little selfish from time to time.

Andrea Andrew

Ironically, she’s barely been in the comic.

Andrea Andrew

I’m glad Sarah and Joe seem to be developing an actual friendship. Joe may (or maybe not) be losing Joyce, but he’ll soon be gaining a lot of friends.

Kelly (they-them)

I'm gonna search the archive to see how many times Joy s and Rachel of spoken on panel if any. Like, fuck, dog Joyce is the same in many ways but she has changed so much in just half a year

Uniquitous

Are we not all in pursuit of things we want? Wouldn't it be more illuminating to examine the why behind the want?

Uniquitous

And thank Cheese for that. I'd almost rather put up with more Carla.

Kelly (they-them)

Rachel was born at exactly the size and weight she is now. She lifts weights because she finds it fun - she doesn't believe her body will strengthen or atrophy in anyway

Sajuuk-Khar

Malaya’s just an egoist who hasn’t read Stirner yet

Kelly (they-them)

Rachel taking Psychology 101 and learning about fixed mindsets: Yes, exactly, this is what I'm talking about Rachel taking Psychology 101 and refusing to learn about growth mindsets: How asinine! What bullshit

Railway Series Book Club

i hope next time rachel shows up she can have something to talk about other than whether or not people are capable of truly changing. like, i dunno girl, what's your opinion on the military-industrial complex? that feels worth asking right now

Megh

But of course that would require her to change into someone who talks about something else I commented this before you edited the part about the MIC in, and now my snarky comment feels less appropriate...not that I'm gonna remove it, just edit in this addendum

Kelly (they-them)

They've appeared in 22 of the same stripes and have had 1 conversation in the bathroom. They were both waiting for a shower stall to free up and Ruth was audibly bawling in one of them

Railway Series Book Club

yeah sorry for undercutting your comment, i was hoping i'd be able to edit in that better punchline before anybody saw the first version lol

Kelly (they-them)

But Malaya HAS read Catcher in the Rye and she loved it

Megh

Eh, no need to be sorry, all's good

Maybeeus

I do hope that even if Joe and Joyce as a relationship fails that they do remain very good friends. It's wild to think back in the Walkyverse Joe was probably Joyce's best friend. Their dynamic has always worked in whatever form it takes and Joe really has become her confidant and someone she can escape to. I do believe Joyce and Dorothy as a couple are inevitable at this point with all the imminent disaster (and attempts at mitigation) that will bring but it is still also my hearts wish that Joe and Joyce do remain close. They are important to each other...

Jesse

There’s pessimism, and then there’s being a judgmental asshole.

Jesse

@Megh You just blew my mind, maan…

Grace Serenity

Not all self serving things are bad! I want to pay taxes so I can enjoy public goods like parks. The fact it ALSO helps other people is a bonus, but according to her I should feel ashamed?

Mohmi

Now Joe USED to be a piece of shit, but people can change! Slicked back hair, sloppy steaks at Galasso's, absolutely! But people can change!

Andrew

*cues rocky theme song*

NinjaZaku

I could be reading too much into things but that look in the second panel reads like she's doubting this belief she has about people changing. I feel like she's saying these things to convince herself just as much as she's trying to hurt Joe with them. I'd imagine her (perhaps subconscious) idea here is something along the lines of "If Joe, one of the worst people I know, can change and form meaningful relationships, then who/what else am I wrong about?" And confronting that possibility is harder than just being awful to him so she just keeps reaffirming her thoughts.

Simon Magid

I am afraid she gives the impression that no-one should ever feel good about doing anything at all. It makes me feel terribly sorry for her. :/

Sajuuk-Khar

Rachel: That can’t be Ruth, Ruth is an abusive monster with no feelings. Imposter. Pod person.

Jasmijn Wellner

She believes her belief that her body will strengthen from exercise is just a self-serving belief she has

joe mcguire

So by her logic, there’s no way to do anything good because there’s always some way you benefit, even if the benefit is the satisfaction one gets from helping people. What an unpleasant person. What’s the point of life if you’re denied even the pleasure of helping others? Or if theres no way to improve one’s personal or spiritual lot in life? There might not be any way to truly change, but what good comes from choosing to never try? A person who refuses to try to improve themselves and denies others the opportunity is, in my opinion, way worse than someone who tries but still makes mistakes.

The Deliberate Myth

Accidentally posted this on the main site. Reposting here because i loke being notified if anyone responds! I think it is important to remember this part of the equation: WE, the audience, have seen Joe’s attempts at changing, and we have seen him be largely successful. So we are really rooting for his redemption story to happen/keep happening. But Rachel hasn’t seen any of that. If we had been following Rachel all this time, if we knew her story and understood her better as a person… if all we knew of Joe was that he did that awful thing, then says he is trying to be better… I wonder how many people would take Rachel’s side in this. These last couple strips have been some of my favorite strips that Willis has done, tbh, and I think they do a great job of reminding me that other people are people, and many of them are worthy of the benefit of the doubt if you can give it to them. It takes effort to see their humanity sometimes, and for some, they will understandably never be willing to extend that empathy. Rachel, for example, gets a free pass to never forgive Joe’s behavior if she chooses. I don’t think less of her because, from her perspective, she hasn’t seen nearly enough from Joe to justify the olive branch. And she might never see enough. But both things can be true – Joe may never convince Rachel that he deserves forgiveness despite genuine change (both potential and actual). It just reminds me that, while some things are clearly going to be too much for me to get past, I will still try every chance I get to extend the benefit of the doubt to someone whose full story I don’t fully know.

Shane Wegner

“Change is impossible” she said, while doing reps she hoped would change her into a slightly stronger version of herself.

Shane Wegner

I agree with your take, I’ve also met people who claim altruism is impossible because it feels nice to be helpful so it’s somewhat self serving. Rebuttal: um, ok good?

Shane Wegner

Thank you for succinctly summarizing why I’m scowling in her her general direction this comic.

TobyTura

This... joejoyce are so precious to me. They've been built up for such a long time- even across continuities and it kills me that it might end badly

Mariah

I mean I was willing to give her the benefit of the doubt but she believes this about all people not just joe or ruth an ideology she has created to protect herself but makes her extremely toxic in her own right.

MiqoRems

I think you might be missing out on the fact that Rachel isn't like this with *just* Joe; she takes the first impression of *everyone she meets* as their true, immutable, completely fixed personality.

The Deliberate Myth

Not missing that - it's definitely a character flaw on her part. But if Rachel had been as big a character as Joe, I assume we would know way, way more about why she acts like that. It wouldn't change the fact that she is acting like an asshole, but I imagine that a good number of us audience members might be a little more sympathetic to her if we knew more about why she acts this way.

Gale Tazzin

turns out you don't have to be the thing you were before

Rachel Baker

How about instead of "change" we call it "growth" - people grow all the time, unless they make the active decision not to anymore.

taekwondogirl

It's a great point reminding us that she hasn't been privy to seeing Joe's growth. As pointed out, she thinks change isn't possible, but to me the real thing is she goes around telling everyone that. Like what is your goal, for everyone to just not even try and to just be outright assholes?

Astariel

But no one is asking her to forgive his behavior. Joe didn't even talk to her. She came in and immediately started antagonizing him, without provocation. That's why I think less of her, not because she won't forgive him.

monica segura

Honestly, I just kinda love the Sarah + Joe interaction. It’s sweet and friendly - and demonstrates how much both are changing.