Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

because we like you

I originally had a different dorky headline, but Wack'd supplied a better one.

Files

Comments

Quantum

BEG PARDON LMAO

Minzoku Bokumetsu

"I have no objections to you continuing to smooch Dorothy while dating me :D"

Logibear

YES JOE!!! THATS MY BOY!!!

el

POLY SICKO WIN??!?!

hollyollybeetee

Wait did he... did he just already assume this was a polycule situation?

Andrea Andrew

Wow, Joe’s the perfect boyfriend for poly girls like Joyce, I guess.

AE Gonzalez

Polyamory Alarm going off

C

"Oh, you didn't know? Dorothy has to fight your Seven Evil Exes before she can date you...although, there's not that many of us yet. I guess we can put that off until later."

The25th

Complete sicko victory.

Grimeagle

"This is my girlfriend. And that is my girlfriend's girlfriend. She is not my girlfriend though, we're just good friends."

Jeremy AR

Ooooh the comments are gonna be fun tomorrow.

Megh

Welp, it seems the Disaster Polycule is imminent I for one welcome our new chaotic non-monogamous overlords!

Railway Series Book Club

okay well i guess its not total yet bc dorothy and joe aren't having bitter rival sex yet but we're like 2/3rds of the way there so THE SENTIMENT REMAINS

Quantum

I don’t know if I should take this as a win for polyamory or if Joe doesn’t think Joyce is serious about Dorothy or…?

Nicholas A. Jalowick

:banging on table while chanting 'Throuple!, THROUPLE!' intensifies:

AE Gonzalez

“Who’s that guy?” “Oh, he’s happy so long as he has McNuggets.”

Harold

@Jeremy AR: That's their secret, Jer - the comments are fun every day

Jeremy AR

Cue the "fanfare

AE Gonzalez

*Making an assumption for the sake of a pun. Perfect.

MrShoggoth

I’m relieved this isn’t going as disaster as I feared for ages. Hooray for communication!

Bronxden

Bruh, Joe is a damn champ \

tifani

It’s polyamory!

Arlo C-J

The Bulletin of the Fuckpile Shippers have just adjusted their Doomsday Clock to a minute before midnight.

Jeremy AR

First time i ever been called that. Can't say I am a fan

Harold

@Quantum: It's a valid question, but I don't think Joe doubts Joyce's seriousness about Dorothy.

Logibear

"Joyce, I spent time finding out what and who I like and making mistakes along the way. Who am I to get in the way of you finding out about yourself too? Just give me a heads up next time"

tifani

Yes! YES! POLYAMORY!

shoutytrack | issa maspro

considering the cast, I think Joe is the likliest person to know how to successfully steer this ship towards group sex with minimal casualties - I think the biggest obstacle here will actually be Dorothy, since she's the one insisting that she and Joyce be exclusive. very glad that Joe is showing those communication skills

tifani

FOR ONCE!

Mariah

its been a ride

Johanne

Yes yes, polyam for the win! But fyi for folks saying throuple, that's when three are all dating each other. This is more likely to be V or N formation (depending on Walky)

Mariah

this is like when the kiss happened and everyone congratulated Andrea lol.

Smoochie

Sickos, I, a drama goblin have a proposition for you. You can have your Joyce-centric polycule. Fine. Just give me Dorothy dumping Walky thinking it was going to be a just her and Joyce thing—and as a result the Walky crash out I wanted. THE WALKY CRASHOUT I NEEDED! …What say you?

Kelly (they-them)

I'm doing the triangle smile right now Edit: triangle smile at your own risk. My face hurts now

ScrimpArt

T-the sickos and paladins . . . Won?

Harold

@Arlo C-J: Somewhere, Charles Walkerton is smiling, and Linda is giving him a side-eye and wondering why.

Logibear

Willis, I beseech you. Hear my prayer.

Johanne

If he already knew how much Dorothy loves Joyce, he probably also knows how much Joyce loves Dorothy. She's not quiet about it, and he was just saying how he reads her comic strip.

Tsa

BLESS YOU WILLIS I BREATHED SUCH A SIGH OF RELIEF

AE Gonzalez

Joyce: “Let’s test our ability to handle this, Joe. I’ll make out with you in front Dorothy, then me and Dorothy will ma- . . . We’re not gonna need to the second one, are we?” Joe: “Nope, already hard just thinking about it.”

SmartAlec105

No, this is not Sicko stuff. A Sicko victory would be Joe being devastated and Sickos rejoicing over the emotional outpouring.

Megh

So what was that original dorky headline?

Katrina Marie Paton

Oh wait, you meant hitting it didn't you? Hitting the table...actually the more I think about it the less I think that's what you meant.

The25th

Amendment to my previous comment. It will not be complete victory (in my personal opinion) until walky and amber/amazi girl is added

Megh

I mean, as has been well established, Sickos *always* win. But the Paladins can win sometimes too, as a treat

Harold

For anyone who can't see the newspaper front page clearly, AE is referencing the text at the bottom of that page explaining why the headline uses "bi" instead of referring to the couple as lesbians.

shoutytrack | issa maspro

also, for any potential naysayers who think that 18/19 is too young to successfully navigate a threesome at minimum, I've been the Joe in this situation. Sometimes you have to jump in the deep end and not be surprised when someone ends up wet.

Kelly (they-them)

As much as I loved Dorothy and Walky together during their first rodeo, I think it would be best if they broke up, polycule or no polycule

Harold

@Jeremy AR: I needed a single syllable for the reference to fully work. Sorry!

The Mayor of Christmas

Or he could be saying he wants her to stay with him. That’s also a possibility. If my girlfriend who clearly has strong feelings for me and recently instigated a major advancement in our relationship said she had to break up with me after kissing her friend, I would make a case for myself. I feel like most people would.

KittyKai

LET'S FUCKING ***GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO***

Nicholas A. Jalowick

In retrospect, I should have stopped to consider the double meaning there. Time makes fools of us all XD

Railway Series Book Club

100% agree with this. now that the Joyce/Joe conversation is seemingly going extremely well, i need the Dorothy/Walky breakup to be even bloodier to contrast.

KaylaZX

*EXACTLY* WHAT I WAS ABOUT TO COMMENT. PRETEND I LIKED IT TWICE

GundamBradley

I am not super surprised by this, but I am curious what Dorothy will think of it. Walky, too, for that matter.

Kelly (they-them)

I thought of Sajuuk-Khar, too! I'm in the middle of scrolling through looking for his comment right now

Heatth

Yeah, not a fan myself. It seems a set up to just take the wind away from the drama. Polycule as a way to make things easier is not very interesting to me. Also, not sure I like how this reflects on Joe or Joyce. Like, it doesn't make her evil and I am willing to give a lot more leeway for queer people discovering themself but, Joyce *did* cheat on Joe. Not just the kiss, but her failure to communicate with him in the after match. Honestly, to me the BJ was the most messed up thing Joyce did in this story line, specifically because she was fully intending on breaking up with Joe after. It is a form of leading him on and it is dishonest. For it to be swept under the rug feels unsatisfying to me, specially because I thought cheating was a big deal for Joe, in particular. I want to make clear though, because I know folks are sensitive about that, that I have no interest on seeing characters being "punished" for "bad behavior" or any nonsense like that. But I do want actions to have consequences. If the result of cheating is a shrug, it is just kinda lame as a story.

Harold

Not to mention Becky

Lia

people who really love joe dont seem to understand him very well

AE Gonzalez

One word: Becky Also the others. Even if Joe forgives, many friends simply won’t be able to trust Joyce. Then there’s Walky, he could easily handle this terribly.

Maude Reads Things

I'm a little conflicted on this one. On the one hand I might actually get to keep at least one of my ships and I'm always happy to see canon polyamory. On the other...my drama loving goblin half is put out. With Willis saying things like he blew up his comic doing Joyce/Dorothy now and the 'sorry Joe's and the reminder about Joe's trauma with infidelity last night AND what happened with Sarah this just...isn't dramatically satisfying. I feel like we got a lot of build up to a rocky ride (with potential to eventually end up with everyone in an okay place) and then someone let the air out of the balloon before it was about to pop. On the other other hand....a) There's no guarantee polyamory will go well and b) we do still have Becky and Walky to find out (and I've kinda wondered if Walky's going to be the one to be pissed off and I did think Joe might be the one who took it well so. What do I know, really? Guess I'll just have to keep reading and see where it goes.

tifani

Calling it now: Joyce’s first time having full blown sex with Joe and Dorothy is gonna be a threesome.

Packy Anderson

Triangle smile for a love triangle? Well, more of a love angle, since the Dorothy-Joe side isn't there...

ScrimpArt

Dorothy breaks up with Walky Walky crashes out and hurts Dorothy's feelings in the fallout. Dorothy, hurt, goes to Joyce to share solace in them breaking up with their boyfriends. Joyce comes back not broken up with joe (their relationship possibly strengthened as well) and suggests dorothy (hates joes guts) be in a relationship with her and joe at the same time. This is the messiest shit ever. ABSOLUTE CINEMA

Harold

@Kelly (they-them): I think he might have fainted from sheer joy.

Kelly (they-them)

Half of the appeal of the "see the comic early" tier for me has become the Patreon comment section

Anna Phylaxis

If this goes poly, that is the biggest mess and the most potential for drama that could possibly happen to these goobers and I AM HERE FOR IT.

Lia

joyce's immediate snap from overly apologetic to intense unemotional "wait really" in the last panel is so good lol

tifani

If? It’s happening!!!

Anna Phylaxis

There is NO WAY these three dorks are prepared to navigate polyamory, if Dorothy is even interested in that. Absolutely NO WAY. No, it's going to be a huge mess of simmering tension and drama.

Grace Serenity

The comments have been fun for the last couple months! Unhinged, even!

ScrimpArt

Every dorm room got the walkerton stool 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Steven Herzog

I'd like to think about it in a more charitable sense and guess that Joe is ready to accept the idea of a kiss in the middle of an extremely intense moment that was a mistake and can be talked through, instead of a dealbreaking degree of cheating. There can still be consequences but they don't have to include absolutely broken bonds.

Logibear

and sit in that chair over there

Heatth

I would love to see that, because I do want to see more of Walky. But honestly, this recent relationship with Dorothy felt so weak overall I am not sure a crash-out would be very convincing, at least to me. Like, obviously he likes Dorothy and it sucks to be dumped. But their relationship this time around seems a lot more casual than it used to be. Maybe because he actually dated someone else for a while but Walky doesn't seem quite as devoted to Dorothy as in the past. So I am not sure I can quite see he being effected quite that much,

Ilana Feldman

"*Making an assumption for the sake of a pun" LMAO

5099 5618 v2.0

(/The Shipstream sparks, throws crew to the left) Hold together! Hold together, damn you! (/Small explosions at nearby panels)

Grace Serenity

"His girlfriend is a drama goblin, and his roommate just likes to watch..."

Justin Seifert

This is how Joe fully understands Joyce... He understands she's navigating a lot of changes in her life and is willing to be a supportive partner in any role he can be including not breaking up with her because she found love additionally in another

Megh

I have a feeling that a polycule will prove cleaner in the short term yes, but much messier in the long term than a break up ever could be I definitely understand your concerns tho, I hope Joe at least as some strong opinions about the Failed Break Up Turned Blowjob to talk about soon Even then this does kinda feel like getting off lightly if poly is really where things are headed On the other hand I do think this shows growth from Joe that he's NOT crashing out over this, which genuinely I love to see

Harold

Danny: "Just keep that goddamn camera away from my foot"

Logibear

Imagine if the "why?" was actually in response to the "I had to come over here" and Joe just goes sicko mode saying that he presumed they had already broken up

Heatth

@Gonzalez, the thing is, if Joe forgives the other friends will have no business on any of this? Like, at all. Sarah can't really be mad at Joyce if she is still dating Joe after this. I mean, she could, it is just not interesting for me as a reader because she would be unambiguously in the wrong. As for Becky, that is its own thing that is mostly unrelated to the cheating. I do want to see how she reacts because I can see it going many different ways. But it is not really a narrative consequence to cheating because that is not what is important to her.

Ignolian Thorne

"You like kissing girls, I like kissing girls... As far as I see it, this is an absolute win."

Railway Series Book Club

i mean Dorothy's been treating him pretty poorly during their whole rebound, so for me this mindset comes from a place of compassion for Walky. i'm sure Amber would appreciate his company while she recovers from her stab wounds!

C.T. Phipps

I predict with 100% certainty that Joe will be okay with non-exclusive dating (versus polyamory) and Dorothy WILL.NOT.BE.

Heatth

@Megh Oh, yeah, I can definitivelly see how the polycule can be dramatically interesting in the long term. Like, I don't hate the development in principle, I think there can be good stories out of it. I just think it weakens *this* story.

Calder Johnson

Aside from figuring Sajuuk hasn't commented yet because they're passed out on their keyboard from sudden and total dopamine overdose... There's certainly a way this makes sense - while a number of folks (including myself) were concerned that Joe would be triggered and hurt by this, I had been recently considering a second option - that Joe would...kinda feel a sense of relief? Like, much of his fear has always been centered on that HE would be the one to cheat. That HE would screw up and hurt Joyce, or somehow 'corrupt' her. Taking her off a pedestal might actually be quite GOOD for their relationship.

tifani

I want it with Walky but eventually, not yet.

Jayne Lindgren

Oof. Disappointing for me, but it's nice that a lot of other people are happy! For the moment, at least. I'm not convinced this is going to go as cleanly as a lot of folks seem to believe.

Andrea Andrew

Definitely better than Joyce and Ethan’s arrangement. That was bad for both of them. I wonder how Ethan feels about Joyce kissing Dorothy.

Calder Johnson

Yeah, I'm all for the Sextagon (eventually), but I agree with QueenOfSodor that Dorothy really needs to work on being a better partner, especially in regards to Walky. And I have a hunch that her four-quadrant break-up speech is uh, not going to be reviewed well...

Smoochie

There was a time I originally did—but I kept seeing so many people reasoning out that Joyce-Dorothy-Joe made the most sense and completely leaving him out of the topic. For me this circled around into just wanting him to have a crash out about it. Whether it’s because his own opinion of Joe has yet to go beyond ‘guy who wants to fuck’ and he sees this, or seeing Dorothy dump him just to be part of that (from Walky’s perspective) Or maybe realizing that long ago his comic lost out to what was essentially Joyce prophetically laying out her and Dorothy being together who knows—but I want the Big Bang to ensue.

Smoochie

10000000000/10

Heatth

Yeah, Walky's relationship with Dorothy is just not that great nowadays.

Heatth

I hope it doesn't, because a clean resolution would be the most disappointing thing.

Calder Johnson

I mean, I don't think a lot of folks think this is going to go 'cleanly'... That's gonna be more than half the fun as readers! I just think it's cool that Joe is handling this as about as well as a human could in the moment, while also managing to stay true to character. That's pretty neat.

ScrimpArt

I wanna say walky is better witth amber but like, its amber . . .

Ilana Feldman

I think most of us who want to see the polycule also want to see it being an absolute mess anyway.

Jonathan Bland

"Polycule as a way to make things easier is not very interesting to me" None of these people are Poly, so their engaging in poly activities will only lead to dramatic social explosions. I'm sure Dorothy would start reading all of the books and quoting all kinds of communication and attachment types. Joe will get burned, as he was the one suggesting it. Joyce would maybe get way too into it way too quickly and leave a trail of broken hearts and maybe an STD, probably nothing tooooo spicy.

tifani

So does that scene asking Asher if he was in a polycule with Jennifer and Ethan count as foreshadowing? Joyce you have to think of a response for it being the polycule thing now. You’re in a polycule thing!

benjie

Devout Christian to polyamorous as an 18 year old over 5 months is crazy

voyager-ngc5195

I know everyone's on about the intriguing notion of a new polyship, but given the byline about the arrests... where's Jocelyne? (Seperately, I'd ask where Robin and Leslie are but given one of the last things Leslie said was "We're going to be arrested", well, I'm thinking Robin got to try the Barbie meme...)

Calder Johnson

I really think this could have gone either way and it would still have been true (to an aspect) of Joe's character. Which is pretty nifty as far as storytelling, really. I think, as Anna said, this is also just the beginning of the drama... But it's a sweet moment in the middle of it all.

Logibear

Possibly answering the call from Hank saying "Yup, that was me kissing that Girl. Joyce was never there"

tifani

It’s been a wild three days.

AE Gonzalez

Having your first orgasm will do that.

Ria

I think if this comment section had a "it's so joever" / "we're so back" meter its oscillations could power a small city

Kelly (they-them)

Jocelyn is fine. In the July 28th, 2025 strip she had texted Joyce that she safely made it back to her friend's place

voyager-ngc5195

It might work if Jocelyne wasn't directly in the background under "Pro Kiss"

tifani

I don’t think Dorothy is someone on Ethan’s radar at all. Have they ever had an actual conversation?

Calder Johnson

I mean, an overly-large tire fire would be better than Joyce and Ethan's 'arrangement'... That bar is somewhere around the molten core.

Logibear

Damn, good catch

Heatth

Amber was the shortest lived of all Walky's relationship (and not even official, if I remember right), but I do agree it was the best for him. They broke up for a honestly good reason, but I do hope they try again at some point. It would be very funny if Amber ends up catching strays in a possible Walky crash-out if he realizes she helped Dorothy, though.

Kelly (they-them)

So, professors, teach me the math of... ~Love Open-Angles~~~

Smoochie

@Heatth I don’t think it will be the breakup that would do it—but the potential polycule. Walky likes being liked. That much we have gotten. So imagine him seeing that he is literally left out of this supposed polycule. More so, let him see that for all intents and purposes, he’s sort of being punished (I speak only from his perspective) for Dorothy and Joyce’s moment of realization/infidelity. (All a misunderstanding but Dorothy goes with it because now instead of Walky and Joyce fighting over HER attention, it’s Dorothy and Joe clashing over Joyce’s. Things rhyming nicely.) Because now Dorothy gets to be with Joyce, Joe gets to be with Joyce, and Joyce gets everything. I dare say that we could even get ANOTHER brilliant rhyme/callback to Joe/Dorothy’s conversation about Joyce but between Walky and Joyce this time, possibly the most antagonistic convo yet. “You do absolutely nothing and get everything.” Joyce got the boy, the girl, the comic, living her best whole life as a bisexual campus icon (Again, only from Walky’s perspective).

AE Gonzalez

My sister’s husband cheated on her a while ago. A few months after kicking him out, and promising a divorce, she let him move back in, eventually saying she forgave him. Those of us hating on him for cheating on her continued hating on him. We saw hurt, we saw a break of trust; can easily see the same here.

Calder Johnson

This is like the Christmas Truce of 1914

Crunchos cereal

YES... HA HA HA... YES! Talk, people, talk! Communication is the key! Yeah, I think it won't go smooth but this is good.

tifani

@packy No Dorothy/Joe YET

Calder Johnson

@Smoochie I dunno, I've just never really clocked Walky as the bitter type, and he already seems like a combo of sad/annoyed/clocked out during this latest fling with Dorothy. I would predict more of a simple but emphatic "I am so done with your bullshit. Have a nice life" rather than a full-on personal doom spiral.

T Campbell

Every so often in journalism, there is a perfect match between writer and content. Daisy has found her moment.

Ilana Feldman

I know that the singular word "Why?" from Joe implies awesome messy polyamorous drama coming up, but I have to wonder why Joe's asking that. He knows why. He literally mentioned the infidelity ~12 hours ago to Joyce and knows that she is still relying on a very traditional view of relationships, having not much experience yet. Or I could be reading too much into it and this is just the best way to lead into the next page and it'll make sense in 24 hours.

Girlycore

THE POLYCULE LIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Tom @ Magic Chopstick Games

I mean, I’m hearing * Dorothy really needs to work on becoming a better romantic partner and * Dorothy should enter into a poly relationship with Joyce and Joe …and these two concepts *really* aren’t playing well together in my head

Calder Johnson

@Magic Chopstick Games - That's why it would be an absolute mess! But probably in a hilarious way, not in the kind of sad and awful way of just continuing to watch Dorothy be terrible for Walky.

Maude Reads Things

I mean, knocking her off the pedestal in his mind can't HURT.

Jesse

So, someone just guessed they were bi for the sake of a pun, and like a stopped clock they happened to be right.

Sajuuk-Khar

I had a whole manifesto about this and I gotta go dig up the dang thing now razzle frazzle I’ve been sick the week of major plot developments in my potential favor and my schedule is off the fuckin WALL. Here’s bullet points on WHY NOT WALKY? 1.) I love Walky and I love Dorothy and I thought Walky and Dotty were cute first semester and very good, but I do not think that they’re healthy now or good for obvious reasons lol. They need time apart to sort that shit out at the very least. 2.) Walky and Joyce have a Problem that is not like Dorothy and Joe. Dorothy and Joe have a problem you can solve with talking and maybe kissing and then maybe—anyway the point is if you do that with Joyce and Walky it’s like throwing sodium in water. It won’t work the same way. It shouldn’t. 3.) Walky has the demon ADHD, like I do, real bad, and he desperately needs someone he doesn’t have to mask with. Amber is that person.

Sajuuk-Khar

STATUS REPORT, MR. CRUSHER

Maude Reads Things

@ Anna - My drama loving goblin side is banking on that! We want mess! :D @ Calder - Yeah, like I said, I did think that Joe could possibly take it well and it's not exactly UNfitting just...not where my goblin side was hoping it'd land. XD

Sajuuk-Khar

I SLEPT THROUGH THE DROP AND NOW I FEEL LIKE YOSHIKAGE FUCKING KIRA AFTER BITES THE DUST FIRST TRIGGERS LMAO

Smoochie

@Calder I mean that’s all fair—take my predictions with a grain of salt. I’m just going on his reaction to losing the comic spot to Joyce way back when, the (possible) knowledge that Dorothy broke up with him for Yale but skipped Yale for Joyce (well, if you ask Joyce at least), and so on. It all has to be building up.

Sajuuk-Khar

Did I really do it? Did I beat them all, Killer Queen? Or am I in the ghost alleyway???

Sajuuk-Khar

Hello! I’m Sajuuk-Khar’s totally fucked sleep schedule and THIS SECTOR IS NOW UNDER VAYGR OCCUPATION

Gale Tazzin

he openly encouraged Dorothy to accept her feelings for Joyce. he might actually be understanding here

Heatth

Clearly it worked. You need to sleep through the next few updates as well to make sure the polyamory plan sticks.

Gale Tazzin

ok, terrible thing that just occurred to me: if Joe and Dorothy somehow both agree to a polycule... Becky might also try to join it, and that's possibly the most awkward alternative

Sajuuk-Khar

I gotta show up as late as possible all David Glover with five pizzas to every update

Inquiring Raven

Honestly; I’ve kinda been team polycule, or team “Joe just takes it like a champ and is a shining example of healthy masculinity afterwards” ever since we saw him confront Dotty about having feelings for Joyce. He knows. And by encouraging Dotty, he showed some hidden potential. Only time will show how it plays out… ~but I certainly would love to see a threesome slipshine~

Sajuuk-Khar

@Magic Chopstick Games: also, what Calder said. Dorothy working on trying to service top Joe and Joyce, badly, and ending up exposing her goofy poindexter sub underbelly, is sitcom gold. Watching her continue to do this thing with Walky that hurts them both is more like if Darren Aronofsky wrote a sitcom.

Heatth

@Sajuuk I strongly disagree with 2). I think the hatred between Joyce and Walky is greatly exaggerated. Joyce is possessive of Dorothy, but otherwise she hangs around with Walky just fine. They aren't the closest friends but they aren't as explosive as you are describing. Meanwhile, Dorothy actively avoided Joe an pretty much only interact with him because of Joyce or class. I totally agree with the other 2 points though.

Terra Bruder

🎶Every time I see you falling🎶

Sajuuk-Khar

THREESOME SEX VID DANNY’S SHOE CAMERA STAND FINAL DESTINATION

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Shields at 69% and dropping! (/Crash) ENM modulator's online, but there's no telling if it can take the strain!

Sajuuk-Khar

Honestly like, yes, I will take this bargain, Smoochie Dormammu, even though it will make squishing Dotty between Joyce and Joe in the way that turns her into overwhelmed Dorothy gelatin is much harder and not in the fun way heyoooooo

Sajuuk-Khar

I am happy for a V but I believe a triangle is truly possible. It can happen. Maybe it shouldn’t happen and it seems messy BUT THAT’S WHY IT’S GOOD

Sajuuk-Khar

Instructions unclear, table covered in “sexual kindness”

Sajuuk-Khar

She’s not your girlfriend… YET

Calder Johnson

Spiraling off that brilliant manifesto, Dorothy and Joe interacting not only has the potential for hilarity, but actual real character growth. The current mess that Walky and Dorothy are in is trapping them both.

Sajuuk-Khar

I have switched my unrealistic stretch goal to “a heated moment in any emotional direction leads to an unauthorized Joe/Dorothy kiss and them both going ‘what?!? WHAT?!?!?’”

Sajuuk-Khar

Who will love, and who will hate? And who will form disaster polycules? The spirit, not the mind or body, has already experienced and memorized those facts! And that is cultural victory! Not just for one person, but everyone will be able to face their destiny! (…) You might think that knowing the ill fortunes of the future is despair... but it’s the opposite! Even if you knew you were going to die tomorrow, it is that very resolution that makes one happy! Humanity will change! This is what I strived for! THIS IS …MADE IN HEAVEN!

Rae Farnsworth

Interested to see where this goes. On the one hand, Joe’s been traumatised by his father’s infidelity, even if unconsciously. On the other hand, perhaps because of this he has a pretty…open and flexible view of relationships and hanky-panky privileges.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Gala Tazzin I suspect Dina would not support that.

Sajuuk-Khar

Also like as has been pointed out we need spice in this polyshape, and Dorothy to have guilt sauce and bitterness mayo get on her fries is vital to this

Mariah

We have all been waiting for your victory lap.

5099 5618 v2.0

(/squints) "Making an assumption for the sake of a pun" No words... Should have sent a poet...

Sajuuk-Khar

@Heatth: I may be exaggerating for effect, but I really don’t think they’re that *close*, it’s more they kind of have such an intense shared interest in some thing that they can tolerate proximity and be normal so long as they’re just kind of surface interacting. When they try to co-op at all though it becomes a mess, like the comics debacle. But , honestly, Joyce and Walky *could* definitely work on an enemies to lovers trajectory in the toxic zone! If Willis wanted to give the wife a poisoned apple gift that would be the funniest possible way to have the Joyce and Walky pairing repeat at all! I just don’t think it’s as easily *worked on* as Joe and Dorothy both recognizing that Joe is changing and growing and burying the hatchet. Although, like, watch Dorothy bury that hatchet and cut herself on it and start growing a new hatchet, because Joyce is all “oops I polyamory’d our cheating, Dorothy my new gf, uwu” and Dorothy is unwilling to blame the beautiful Joyce lmao

Sajuuk-Khar

Yessssssssss (said like Grace Jones)

Morgan Byrd

My gut says this is bait

Jeremy AR

@Jonathan how would you know they aren't poly? You are not writing them snd they haven't even discussed the possibility yet. It's a kind of weird thing to say.

Sajuuk-Khar

I have come to claim what is mine, return the Second Core, et cetera, give me the big special laser ship from the nebula, bla bla bla, I need to play Homeworld 3, etc etc, several thousand Jojo and Achewood references in motion, and finally Willis will give me a threesome Slipshine within thirty days and I will spare your Homeworld. Thank you, Children of Hiigara.

Sajuuk-Khar

YE BEST START BELIEVIN’ IN DISASTER POLYCULES, MISS BROWN

5099 5618 v2.0

@voyagwr-ngc5195 "Polyship" sounds like one of the leviathans from Farscape, to me. Like if Moya had a more well-adjusted kid after the main storyline wrapped up.

Sajuuk-Khar

If this is bait it was literally made for me. This is me-shaped bait. Did you do that to me, Willis? What have I ever done to make you treat me so—oh, it’s all the comments. Okay. Fair.

5099 5618 v2.0

@AE Gonzalez Sometimes you just gotta keep rolling the dice and see how many 20s you can get in a row.

Sajuuk-Khar

@Mariah: then I have arrived and I shall begin cackling madly

Shane Wegner

So, one of the themes I’ve been feeling regarding Dorothy is… she kind of thinks she’s more special and important than everyone? Supporting evidence- 1, her goal of being president does imply she believes she’s uniquely qualified in all the earth to rule and solve difficult problems. 2,“I’ve spent my whole life not getting what I want”, when her very supportive parents helped her get into college and surely would have been supportive of her kissing girls, if that’s the missing thing she thinks was denied to her. (The missing thing denied to her probably isn’t “a just world”, since she basically admitted a tendency of not rocking the boat because of how comfortable things were for her personally.) And Evidence 3, her assumption that she and Joyce have found their Specialest Important Feelings for each other, obviously they’ll both go quickly and easily dump their Unspecial Other Feelings boyfriends like the meaningless dead weight they are. Those guys are just meaningless NPC side quests to the Dorothy/Joyce main character arc! So I’m curious what happens if Joyce stands up for herself and says “Ho-hold on. My feelings for Joe are important too. I’m not ready to just drop them.” Does Dorothy say “But ours for each other are More Important! Aren’t they?” If Dorothy doesn’t understand and appreciate this aspect of Joyce (as Joe appears to already), and navigate it successfully, then maybe they’re aren’t as mystically compatible as might first appear. Maybe Dorothy tries to play along while resenting Joe the whole time (good drama source, also polycule poison). Does Dorothy spiral more if this doesn’t work out? And I want to explicitly point out that characters having character flaws isn’t a bad thing, on the contrary it’s an interesting thing.

Smoochie

Part of why I *think* Dorothy might get talked into a polyshape she is in it to ultimately win Joyce’s heart—and the same for Joe.

Railway Series Book Club

see i feel like Becky probably wouldn't try to do that unless Joyce like, actually reassessed her feelings for Becky and came up positive this time, which feels unlikely... which is a real shame bc i've been developing a hankering for Becky/Dorothy? like, THATS the real avenue Becky should go down if she wants in on the mess! i wanna see sub-on-sub violence gone sexual!!!

Calder Johnson

I mean, possible. But itd be pretty brutal queerbaiting to go this far with the possibility only to drop it.

Sajuuk-Khar

The real secret is I slept through the upd8 like a chump and I’m gonna spell it that way because this is a level of webcomic and shipper hype I haven’t felt since the old-school HS halcyon days

Sajuuk-Khar

Queen you have spoken a dark and terrible idea into existence and I think I kind of love it

Lapin

Yes! Yes! YES! You people didn’t believe me, but here is it, polycule! My boi, Joe, the goat!

Railway Series Book Club

i should probably write a post about becky/dorothy for tumblr at some point, it'll be a nice bit of variety after all the theocracyposting

ArdieBea

Ii think, like many others, the main obstacle to a poly solution here is Dorothy's distaste for Joe - and her desire to have exclusive rights to Joyce. Joe has shown all along that he can share; Dorothy's found it triggers her trauma! She's the one repeatedly saying that they need to break up with their boyfriends. But then... she had very little in the way of a reaction to Joyce giving Joe a bj last night instead of breaking up with him. Overtly she rationalized it as, "well, he's officially still your boyfriend, isn't he? - So you didn't cheat on me." But still. I would have thought she'd... react even a little? So I think we need to recognize how much has changed for her. She's not only acknowledged that she's horny for Joyce, but also that she's more broadly attracted to women. And the one woman whom she really, truly, deeply desires came running to her through clouds of teargas to tell her she loved her and to hell with propriety. And kissed her. And asked her to stay the night. I think she's coming at things from a new and better place, and might now be able to see Joe differently; see him for a guy who also helped her girlfriend be more happy and open in her sexuality. The guy who urged her to be open about her own feelings towards HIS girlfriend. I agree with Sarah, a polycule is not an easy way out of relationship drama, but on reflection I CAN see how all three of these fools might now be open to it. If Dorothy is really willing to share.

Sajuuk-Khar

Also Kelly thank you so much for the Crazy Ex-Girlfriend rep in this hour of dire need

Mohmi

"Why don't we do the civilized thing and just all sleep together?" -David Bowie

UVS

Sonofabitch...he really loves her

Anne Romines

The second I saw Joe talking to Dorothy about how he knew she liked Joyce, I knew this was possible. Glad to see it come to fruition!

Sarah

Polycule!!!

Sajuuk-Khar

Willis canonizes polycule on the same day that a crowd of people in the DC metro tell JD Vance the Veep to go fuck a couch in no uncertain terms, nature is healing

Sajuuk-Khar

“Maybe an STD” Gross projection, motherfucker, can you get it out of here? That’s just creepy.

Lea

I don't know Dorothy's mind, of course. But my assumption on reading Dorothy's "I don't get what I want" was that it referred to the many "classic" experiences that she's been foregoing in order to be "president material": Underaged drinking, ill-advised relationships, wacky hijinks that could actually be a threat to the powers that be. All that said: Dorothy has actually be increasingly (in little, mostly "safe" increments) partaking in those activities. The blowing off a class, or hitting a bar, or not studying non-stop for an exam, or showing up at a major protest. So it kinda feels a little odd to hear it from Dorothy at that moment, at the protest... ...unless she sees those things as "not my own," but rather, "The things I peripherally partake in as part of being with Joyce." If she doesn't see these activities as things she's really free to do, but only gets to experience in a sort of tangential vicarious way through/with Joyce, then Joyce doesn't just hold the keys to Dorothy's heart: she also holds the keys to her life, to the opportunity to just be a young adult, figuring things out the messy way, without having to be perfect, without having to meet all the standards. Joyce is just...potentially meaningful to Dorothy in a lot of different ways, which I find fascinating.

AE Gonzalez

Twist: it’s Joyce who’ll object to the polycule. Even as an atheist, she’s a huge fan of monogamy; she let out an ultra sonic squeal when Becky said she planned to marry Dina. Joe’s all in with his girlfriend making out with another girl, it’ll be funny seeing Dorothy trying to convince Joyce to do it. She did seem more accepting of the Sierra/Mandy/Agatha polycule in a recent bonus comic.

Logibear

Man, imagine how this is for Joyce. Like you build yourself up and know that you are going to break the heart of someone you care a lot about. But then its just haymaker after haymaker.

DiDi-chan

"Why?" Oh... so that reference to his mom cheating was a red herring... are the open relationship people actually on the money?

ArdieBea

Plus actually suggested it for Lucy/Jacob/Sarah - with qualifiers.

Kelly (they-them)

Picture this, my fellow sickos Joe in the middle Dorothy on top Joyce at the bottom achieving a level of squish she had never before dreamed possible To be clear, I'm suggesting they all just lay flat on top of each other. Or do that stack thing the bears in We Bare Bears do

Tessea

So the cliffhanger question is now what his take is. i see three possibilities. 1 - He's fine with sharing Joyce with Dorothy (that was easy) 2 - He's been expecting it to happen for a while now (acceptance) 3 - He thinks it wasn't as big a deal as Joyce and Dorothy do. (broken heart in-progress)

NinjaZaku

On one hand Polycule? Lets fucking go? On the other hand Shit, Jocelyne is absolutely in that picture.

Jay

/tableflip Aight we going with this line of logic. Pets see how it goes

Pangab

I think it was more, imagine you’re a gay man and during a dark time you use a fundamentalist Christian woman as a beard who is trying to turn you straight, or at least convince you to abstain from gay sex. Months after your breakup she’s in the local newspaper for a big gay kiss in the middle of a protest. You might have some thoughts. Even if just, ‘huh?’

Jasmijn Wellner

Everyone is like "polycule confirmed" and while that is definitely a possibility, I feel like the more likely outcome (at least at this point) is for Joe to be like "listen, you made a mistake. And then you came clean. I can forgive you. Let's be together for the rest of time, and by that I do mean monogamously." and for Joyce to be like "oh no, wasn't I clear? I chose Dotty over you, I'm just sad having to hurt you to be with my one true love" I'm still team polycule, I'm just sure we're there yet. Maybe if Joe has been making out with Walky in the time between The Kiss and now? Then again, I was wrong about the picture so who knows.

Jay

Dorothy doesn't deserve Walky she's been kinda terrible to him

Jay

Or is it simply Joe is a very well written character who could have several believable reactions to things?

Naff

Is there another, even deeper, Patreon so I don’t have to hold my breath until tomorrow?

Matt McKenzie

After Joe was the one to go to Dorothy and ask her straight up if she was attracted to Joyce, an event which really got the ball rolling for Dorothy to acknowledge those feelings, it would seem strange for Joe to be acting this way in this moment and in the next breath ask Joyce to pour water on that fire and stay exclusive with him. I’m team polycule.

Acebender

come on throuple!

I Know Why the Mowed Lawn Screams

stuck btw being really happy for the polyshippers (esp after the weeks of insane dismissive behavior towards poly/non-mono dynamics being hurled in the main comments section the last few weeks) and wanting the punchline for tomorrow’s strip to be “we can just put this behind us Joyce I won’t hold it against you

Rob McBobson

Hey, one question: How's this gonna work, exactly, if they go poly? Like... Joyce is assuming that she has to choose. So she chose Dorothy, and not Joe. How are they gonna have a healthy poly relationship if Joyce is clearly more into Dorothy than into Joe? I know different things work out well for different people, but I'm not sure how you'd make it work with three people, romantically, if one is explicitly less important than the other. I fully understand that I might have missed something or gotten it wrong, but what?

Rob McBobson

(Oh, and full disclosure: I'm definitely colored by my own experience here, since my first open relationship fell apart when it became clear that I was less important to my partner than her other guy was. Though again, I realize that different things work out well for different people.)

etherealDesign

I'm not sure the goal here IS for Willis to write a healthy relationship, rather than exactly the kind of trash fire you're describing.

Em

@AE Gonzalez, sorry about your sister’s situation. I dealt with something similar in my family. And I agree with you — Joyce staying with Joe isn’t going to necessarily make Sarah not think the things about Joyce she mentioned the last time she was on panel. This actually might lead to a fracture in their friendship. I could see Sarah opting to spend more time with Tony.

Nikki H.

I think it feels in character for Joe to be cool with Joyce dating both him and Dorothy. I think the rub is Dorothy not being okay with Joyce dating both her and Joe, and I'm not sure Joyce is quite ready for that either. I mean, I am also team polycule, but I also need to predict how my dreams will be shattered.

Rob McBobson

That's an EXTREMELY fair point, but I guess what I'm saying is: What's Joe's plan? Does he understand that Joyce explicitly chose Dorothy over him? Is he planning to have a romantic relationship where he's clearly less important? Or does he think that Joyce regrets kissing Dorothy, and is gonna tell Joyce "Of COURSE I forgive you, since you clearly regret doing it"?

Harold

@Pangab: I’m picturing Ethan walking up to Joyce like in the HANDMAID’S TALE scene where Commander Lawrence approaches June after realizing she didn’t escape when she had the chance, and simply saying “THOUGHTS?!?!?”

Shane Wegner

It is interesting to think of Dorothy wrapping herself up in chains even tighter than Joyce’s fundamentalist ones, because she thought it was necessary. Dorothy could just ask though: “Professor DeSanto, can I drink an alcohol yet still become a politician?” “BAHAHA good one! Oh, you were serious.”

tifani

Yeah I feel like the people thinking Joe is going to turn around and suddenly demand monogamy are being kind of ridiculous. He has never stated that he expected exclusivity. He has never expressed anti poly sentiment. Honestly I think he was letting Joyce set the tone. He thought she was monogamous so he was willing to do that for her. Turns out she’s not so he can roll with that too. He just loves her and wants to be with her however he can.

Shane Wegner

I’ll give Dorothy this- although the forceful nudge towards the first Laundry Time was risky, it unlocked a lot of repression for Joyce.

Shane Wegner

As I remember it, Dorothy was spiraling on a snow pile, Walky magnanimously asked if some sex would help, Dorothy “YES” and they also decided they were a committed thing again? (As if “we bone down sometimes if we’re both feeling it” isn’t a valid arrangement.) Like the whole arrangement and Walky himself seem pretty easygoing to have a whole crash out over it. The whole Lucy thing imploding over one parent visit and one church visit, then the Dorothy thing imploding next might be combo annoying, but I don’t think Walky had towering dreams for this Dorothy relationship that can come crashing down.

Matt McKenzie

That’s the impression I get from Joe. Turns out he’s just such a ridiculous sweetheart that he knows that the person that he loves is made a fuller person by Dorothy. I think that the real drama is going to come from Wally and Becky. Walky I think isn’t dedicated enough to any of this to not just Walky away (lol). Becky is going to be complicated. Lot of weird feelings there.

Shane Wegner

To literally answer the question, it might look something like this: Joyce does things with Joe that make her happy, (wall smooshing, orgasms for whoever, however.) Then, with Joe’s knowledge and enthusiastic agreement, she goes and does thing with Dorothy that make her happy. (Weighted blanket movies, smelling necks, orgasms for whoever however.) (Also with a Dorothy’s knowledge and knowing Joe knows.) At the moment I only see the hinge arrangement. For Joyce, it’s going to class and a dopamine high time after the work day. For Joe, it’s being happy in person with Joyce sometimes, knowing she’s happy with Dorothy other times. In theory, Dorothy accepts similar from her side. No idea how possessive Dorothy is.

Brian Danger Hicks

Well hopefully he's saying that for polycule reasons and not bisexual erasure reasons.

Daniel S

Mmm yeah inject that awkwardness into my veins.

Daniel S

While we're all distracted by poly questions (not a fan personally) we're letting the fact that Joyce's parents are probably holding this newspaper just pass us by.

The Mayor of Christmas

“How are they gonna have a healthy poly relationship if Joyce is clearly more into Dorothy than into Joe” That’s begging the question. I don’t believe she is clearly anything of the sort. If anything, she’s much more into Joe. She had no problem restricting herself to clandestine kissing and cuddling with Dorothy, but when she’s around Joe, she doesn’t think she’ll be able to physically control herself.

Mark

Maybe coming as an unused strip post?

Harold

It's always fuck o'clock *somewhere*

Harold

In the midst of all this joy / relief / poly-speculation / Walky-worry (all 100% warranted!), I don't think anyone here has yet mentioned Willis's offhandedly scathing commentary on journalistic priorities and possibly-institutionally-mandated burying-the-lede (at least, I *hope* this isn't all on Daisy): near the bottom of the front page you can see the following: TROOPERS CLEAR DUNN MEADOW DOZENS ARRESTED - PAGE 18

Rob McBobson

Mayor: That is indeed begging the question (and also, THANK YOU for using the term correctly), but since Joyce came here specifically to break up with Joe, I'm assuming she's choosing the one she wants the most.

Derek Benson

Poor Joyce. Genuine remorse.

Smoochie

I’ve made this point in a previous response but I think Dorothy might be up to the challenge of a polycule—only in that her endgame is ultimately being to one to end up in something monogamous with Joyce. We’ve seen two people fight over Dorothy’s time and attention before, and that was just with Dorothy and Joyce being as close as possible without intimacy. Now there’s intimacy and the person challenging for Joyce’s attention is Joe. How does Dorothy now deal with wearing the shoes that Joyce and Walky wore before treading on each other over her?

Sajuuk-Khar

I would be genuinely shocked if all the corruption of the IDS is on Daisy’s personal hand in her pants style of journalism

Sajuuk-Khar

My anxiety: I’ve analyzed their attack, sir, and there is a danger. Shall I have your shuttle standing by? My Sacred Polycule-loving heart: EVACUATE?! In our moment of TRIUMPH?? I think— Me: WAIT, NO NO NO, I’VE SEEN THIS MOVIE. D: YEAH KEEP THE SHUTTLE RUNNING

Girlycore

I think she was choosing the one she hadn't cheated on, because she expected the cheating to be a dealbreaker. Which is pretty fair given the way comments have reacted. I doubt she's taken any amount of time toward deciding who she wants the most. She's been on autopilot.

tifani

Ok people really need to understand that it genuinely does not matter if Joyce appears on a surface level to be more into Joe or Dorothy. That’s really not how this works. The only thing that matters is that Joyce is into them both and wants to be with them both. They’re not in competition with each other. Yeah some poly couples do the primary thing where one person is the main partner with secondary’s (that doesn’t mean the secondary has to be on some kind of lower rung or whatever) and if Joyce was married to Joe or Dorothy that would be a discussion but based on how Joyce tends to love people I don’t think that kind of designation would appeal to her.

tifani

No she was choosing the one she loved most recently. Joyce was operating under the monogamy pilled delusion that falling for one person means you have to make a choice and that with Joe not around and in the euphoria of the love bubble and the euphoria of new attraction she wasn’t really thinking about Joe. But the second Joe was there and in her presence she couldn’t go through with it and the second she finds out she doesn’t have to she’s going to realize she doesn’t want to. That’ll be inconvenient for Dorothy but if Joe can compromise so can she. She’s not entitled to Joyce.

Girlycore

It isn't queerbaiting if they are both queer. They've kissed, they've discussed wanting to be together, this is just normal relationship stuff (amped up for drama) but not queerbaiting.

tifani

Yeah I really think you guys are counting on Joe being not the guy he is if you really think a reaction like that is plausible. At this point I’m confident enough to say this. It’s poly. You’re getting poly. Whether you like it or not.

tifani

I think any hurt feelings Becky might have originally had about this are going to be altered by the outing. Becky is way more mature than her persona implies and at the end of the day Joyce was a childhood crush and she’s in a healthy long term relationship. The fact that Joyce and Dorothy have been outed in this way is also going to enrage and disgust her. Walky on the other hand has every reason to be pissed af.

tifani

I’m not going to let anyone take this victory from me. Polycule is happening. I believe it. No room for doubt in my heart filled with joy! I am captain of the good ship Joe/Joyce/Dorothy. (JoeDorothy is inevitable. They have enemies to lovers written all over them.)

razboy

this is pretty drama free so far, which means the drama will either be A) joyces papa seeing this or B) dorothy not wanting to share joyce with joe.

Matt McKenzie

I don’t think it’s that Becky wants to be with Joyce. I think that Becky will have a hard time reconciling the feeling she might have that Dorothy was “good enough” to “switch teams” for but that Becky wasn’t.

Inquiring Raven

Isn’t that just the college newspaper? I didn’t think that was supposed to be the city paper… even if it’s the city paper Joyce’s folks live 3 hours away… do we think it would reach them at home? Or do you suspect they read the college newspaper’s website? It’s entirely possible, but I think that might be a stretch to assume it’s breached local containment just yet.

Railway Series Book Club

yeah the sentiment that Joyce's feelings for Joe and her feelings for Dorothy being unequal would spell disaster for the polycule feels weird to me. like, i'm in a polycule in real life, and that hasn't really been a problem for any of us. like as an example, one of my girlfriends is dating a girl who's planning on marrying her other girlfriend, and all three of them are perfectly fine with their relationship arrangement, and even goad each other on sickos-style. it's really not that big of a deal, so long as everybody's on the same page! (i'd say 'now watch as Dorothy failing to be on the same page makes things a big deal' but like, i need to see more of Dorothy being possessive of Joyce under the current status quo before feeling confident in that lol)

Daniel S

Good questions. Guess we'll see!

KittyKai

Or C) BECKY 😨😨😨

tifani

I think people who aren’t poly really have a hard time wrapping their minds around the fact that love is not some finite thing. There’s plenty to go around. We do it all the time with friends and pets and our children. You just have to realize it can also be the same for romantic relationships. I’m not saying it has to be that way if you prefer monogamy but that is how it is if you’re don’t. And I genuinely feel like none of these three (Joe, Joyce, or Dorothy) are monogamous. It’s just the default expectation. Like heterosexuality.

I Know Why the Mowed Lawn Screams

@Tifani I really need to emphasize that i’m 100% OK with poly, i’m just bummed because it looks like the biggest thing i was looking forward to with the whole cheating thing (Joe getting his heart broken) doesn’t seem very likely to happen anymore 😩

razboy

in my head i had already considered that inevitable lmaooo but the other 2 are tossups

tifani

It’s gonna happen! If we believe in it/peer pressure Willis enough anything is possible!

tifani

I think she’s matured beyond that for romantic jealousy but there is her whole anxiety about sexuality switching. If anything I could see this giving her more anxiety about that. If Joyce suddenly stops being 100% hetero could that mean theoretically Becky could not be 100% lesbian and what does that mean about her entire identity that she’s built etc.

Harold

Becky's the wild card here, no question. On the one hand, she loves Joyce and wants her to be happy, and she's also now thankfully on record as having directly assured Dorothy that she genuinely considers her a ride-or-die as well. On the other hand, she is absolutely going to have certain feelings about recent developments, and - as Willis has ominously written on Tumblr - "Becky doesn't really do anything by halves." Fasten your seatbelts!

Matt McKenzie

That would certainly reflect some of the anxieties she’s already shown.

Logibear

Yeah, as long as everyone is communicating clearly about what they want and how they're feeling then they have a pretty good shot. Joe has shown time and time again that he's all about being clear with intentions and consent since the timeskip too. I think that Joyce and Dorothy have just been too caught up in the moment to even consider what options are really available to them. I have faith in all these goobers, however drama is always on the horizon.

tifani

I think drama is definitely coming but I don’t think it’s going to come from where everybody was worried about. I think once the poly situation is decided on between Joe/Dorothy/Joyce it’s going to actually be more comfortable than they ever expected which is why full throuple feels possible. But the extended social circle is going to suffer. Becky will likely have to deal with more anxiety about fluid sexuality. Danny is probably going to be pissed on Joe’s behalf even if Joe is fine with it. Walky I think is going to have the blow up reaction everyone thought Joe would. Sal is going to be stuck between Danny and Walky. Amber has her own feelings for Walky and the fact that she did push for this to happen. Sarah is going to need time to get over her disappointment with Joyce. Billie already was barely friends with Dorothy and I think betraying Walky is going to make her an active antagonist for Dorothy for awhile and affect her friendship with Joyce.

tifani

Oh man I just thought about Danny having second hand jealousy when it comes to Dorothy because he opted not to give into his desire for Ethan out of loyalty to Amber only to lose both of them in the end and then Dorothy does the “bad thing” and gets (from his pov) rewarded? Like I don’t think Danny is at all over Ethan I think it just ended so badly before it even got to really begin (and I think Danny has so much guilt about it like I don’t think he would have said what he said about Mike if he thought for even a second Mike would actually die) and so he put it in a mental box labeled “don’t think about it” and Dorothy is going to make him THINK.

MiqoRems

I think that says 1B, not 18

Teh Moose

There's the $10,000 tier where you can view the entire buffer. Or so I'm told.

tifani

@i know Well if it helps I think you’ll get that with Walky. Maybe try to look at it like a there’s no coke but here’s some pepsi kind of thing?

tifani

I swear to you I read my comment in that pirates of the Caribbean zombie voice as I was typing it. Get out of my brain!

Paul's VHS Recordings

I think honestly what will happen is not Poly but more “you messed up, but you were going to tell me immediately so this is just a blip and we move on together.” That honestly sounds pretty realistic and reasonable

Kelly (they-them)

Yes, but only one person is allowed to be at that tier. Maggie snatched that one up early by being married to Willis.

tifani

That sounds boring.

Naff

Damn, I’m always too little too late.

Ilana Feldman

Honestly sounds terrible for Joe. He knows there's an incredibly strong bond between Joyce/Dorothy that they have discovered is also romantic/sexual. What, is he going to have to be on guard for as long as the two remain in contact with each other? Chaperone whenever they meet up? Ask them to not communicate?

Ilana Feldman

It would be so funny if the biggest crashout came from specifically Danny, and not anyone actually directly involved in this mess.

tifani

Elaborating on my sounds boring opinion: All the people rooting for them to break up or for Joe to insist on monogamy…why? Seriously why? Not only does it not fit the vibe of everything being put out in front of us but there are literally THOUSANDS of stories like that. I really think people are so afraid of a story trying to zig when you expect it to zag that they are just being willfully blind to the actual interesting thing happening because the same old same old is comfortable for them or because the whole idea of polyamory makes them uncomfortable and isn’t something they would do so they can’t conceive of these characters doing that?

Ilana Feldman

I think Dorothy is monogamous, but I might just be saying that because of how possessive she's been of Joyce. And to be fair, in the giant insane polycule I'm building in my head, Dorothy gets all four of walky/joyce/amazigirl/jennifer.

Inquiring Raven

Okay, so I’ve been thinking about this all day (off and on): Joe says that’s the college paper (because it’s the one that publishes Joyce’s comic) do we suspect that Joyce’s parents are reading the college newspaper’s website? That they have it delivered to them? That they drive in the 3 hours to pick it up? I think we can discount Joyce’s parents learning from *that* source.

tifani

I really think he might take it the hardest of the extended social circle. This whole situation deals specifically with a lot of things potentially triggering for Danny. He strikes me as someone who compartmentalizes but look at all the stuff he’s had to move past in less than a year: Dorothy breaks up with him to be free of relationship burdens, immediately starts dating Walky. Danny moves on with Amber/Amazi-girl then gets dumped because of his friendship with Sal. Then Sal and Amazi-girl become friends. Around this time he’s realizing he’s bi but decides to not act out on his attraction to Ethan because he thinks it will hurt Amber. Turns out Amber would have been totally fine with it but now it’s too late because he torpedoed his chances with Ethan by allowing himself two seconds of being a petty bitch. And the one time he does that the guy he was an asshole about who had been nothing but a dick to him and everyone around him before that DIES HEROICALLY. Also Walky keeps dating his exes. Also he’s dating Walky’s sister. And honestly there’s a whole psychosexual vibe going on between Walky and Danny that NEEDS to be dealt with (they wanna fuck each other they don’t know they want to fuck each other but they keep doing it by proxy) Anyway amongst all this his ex who he has done his best to have a grown up break up with comes to him for advice. He gives it. He advises her against cheating on the guy she started up with two seconds after dumping him. She does it anyway with his best friend and then potentially his best friend decides to open up that relationship to include her. And by doing that he is back to being presented with how his own bisexual awakening went so bad.

5099 5618 v2.0

Headcannon: CPT Julia Grey's adventures with President Doris will start to look more and more like Farscape fanfic, but ~35% hornier.

tifani

Oh and also his girlfriend clearly wants to fuck his ex situationship’s new boyfriend. That is just BLATANT. And he can’t say anything because he still wants to fuck Ethan. The four of them need to fuck it out but will they? WILL THEY??? (God I hope so).

5099 5618 v2.0

(I have no idea if Joyce has seen Farscape, but I enjoy the idea of her and the crew watching it, together) (Mind you, I'm not sure she'd be able to get through a full episode of Lexx)

Mariah

Im not a paladin but the general concensus is that because joyce and dorothy cheated they don't deserve to be in a poly relationship and that poly should of been negotiated before the kiss happend. I don't agree with this but that is the general paladin stance.

tifani

That’s boooooring af.

Jayne Lindgren

Because I don't like Joe and Joyce being together, never have, and want them to break up. That's pretty much it.

tifani

@jayne Ok but ignoring your personal dislike do you really think the story as it is being laid out before you is actually leading to a breakup because that’s what I’m actually asking. Not if you root for it. (Okay I know I did originally ask why people root for it I’m asking something else now) but now I’m more curious about story structure. Does a break up RIGHT NOW make sense for the overall story as is? After all the time spent building them up? Or from the pov of the person writing it why not explore both relationships and not kill an entire plot line?

tifani

For example like remember how in the later seasons of the office they had this horrible habit of trying to introduce Jim and Pam substitutes and they tried with multiple couples then they spent all that time and effort on Erin and Andy just to break them up and have Erin end up with a random last minute add on? Or the himym finale bullshit? My point is if you are going to spend all this time building up a relationship maybe you don’t have to just kill it for the sake of drama? Maybe there are more interesting ways to explore a story? Maybe Ted/Robin/Barney could have just FUCKED? Maybe Grey’s Anatomy should have not gotten rid of Erika Hahn out of nowhere??? Maybe Schmidt/Cece/Elizabeth could have been a thing? (I have a lot of tv grievances). It’s why I only watch like three shows now and one of them is iwtv.

Calder Johnson

Respectfully disagree. I know this is a sticky subject, but I say this as a queer person, that I feel uncomfortable with the erasure or misrepresentation of poly relationships in mainstream media. We can see in this in the comment section here, there are a lot of people incredibly hungry for some legitimate (if messy) representation of a sexual orientation that doesn't get much of it. Dangling this possibility this clearly than yanking it would be a pretty harsh rug pull.

Railway Series Book Club

ngl i hope Punished Danny arc happens bc i kinda wanna see Danny and Ethan have a Problematic Homoerotic Suicide Pact a-la BillieRuth

tifani

Oh yeah, Danny has sooo much to make up for. On his knees.

Jayne Lindgren

I mean...yeah, sure. Joyce and Dorothy's relationship has been built up for even longer than Joyce and Joe's. It was a huge, watershed moment, when they both admitted something about themselves they'd kept buried, and in the midst of a crisis they affirmed their desire - their need - to be together, damn the consequences. The fact that they already are in relationships is part of those consequences. So they love each other and want to be together? Great! Now you have to face giving up something you've already got. Especially since they clearly felt like that was what they wanted to do. Joyce has only been wavering when Joe's literally in the room. She may not like breaking up with him, but to cast it as her not being willing to is just not correct.

Jayne Lindgren

Hang on, I hit enter before I finished.

Maybeeus

There has also, been an outstanding amount of foreshadowing towards a Joyce/Joe/Dorothy polycule and i cannot bring up every example but people thinking Joe would be really upset over the cheating miss the point that his answer to his dads infidelity isn't to become strictly monogamous but to deconstruct the concepts that caused so much hurt for his family to begin with. See the open relationship bit with his dad awhile back.

Jayne Lindgren

I really dislike the idea that everyone should be poly. I frankly don't see it any different from believing everyone should be monogamous. So I've been disappointed with a lot of the commentary here that has assumed that polyamory in this situation is 1) obvious, and 2) the only moral option. "Joyce can't decide, and it's wrong to make her!" Well, she can if she wants to. This idea that Joe or Joyce or Dorothy not being comfortable with it is basically being dismissed as a moral failing, rather than just a personal thing. As if any of them wanting anything other than free love forever is selfish and cruel, and not a completely reasonable reaction for a lot of people who can't stop being mono anymore than poly people can help being poly. So, frankly, I think at this point what I'd like to see IS the idea of poly brought up, and some of them being fine with it...but some of them not. And then they have to deal with the idea that none of them are villains, but they really can't have it all with no problems or heartbreak. Sucks, but that's how it is. But knowing how a lot of commenters are, I'm sure no matter what happens, it'll all be Dorothy's fault. Especially if she's the one who's not comfortable with "sharing" Joyce. That's definitely going to go over well, I'm sure.

tifani

She doesn’t want to choose. You want her to choose. Dorothy might want her to choose. Joe knows she doesn’t have to choose. And there is beauty in that. I don’t think everyone needs to be poly. No one is saying everyone needs to be poly. But there is no shortage of monogamous relationship representation in media. An actual poly love story has rarely been told and despite what anti poly people are saying I think that all the signs point towards that being the story we are being told with these three characters in particular. Joyce is not done with Joe yet. I think it’s being made very clear that she is split in her devotion and that is part of the conflict. I also think there’s something to be said about telling two different versions of how the story moves forward. Two different love stories (Joe and Joyce with Joe and Dorothy) and Dorothy having to deal with getting the person that she wants but having to share her with someone she only thinks she knows. She can grow from this.

Jayne Lindgren

Oh, and also, I am annoyed because I think there is a very real trend for people to take man/woman relationships far more seriously than woman/woman relationships. So even though Dorothy and Joyce has been such a long theme, and they are shown to be feel so deeply about each other both romantically and sexually, there are STILL a lot of people who are giving Joyce's very young relationship with Joe more "weight" and importance than what she has with Dorothy. I feel like Joyce and Dorothy's relationship is deeper and stronger (at least at the moment), so I feel like it naturally should get the narrative priority. And, I mean this in a non-hostile way, but it's something you yourself has done. The other day you argued that because Joe is a man, it's "harder" for Joyce to express her feelings and sexuality with him than with Dorothy, a woman, because she was raised fundie. The idea that a fundamentalist Christian would have a harder time with a straight-passing relationship than a queer one is....not something I agree with.

tifani

Well we’re going to have to agree to disagree. I have my reasons for why I feel like Joyce has held back with Joe and I stand by them. I also don’t think Joyce remaining with Joe takes anything away from what she has with Dorothy and I think maybe because of the trend of queer relationships not being given the respect they deserve in other areas people might be minimizing Joyce and Joe. I think both relationships deserve respect. If it helps you to accept these opinions coming from me I am bisexual. And maybe that is also apart of this for me.

Jayne Lindgren

Look, you asked me why and I said so. It's extremely clear you feel very strongly about this. There's nothing wrong with that! But I don't really thing this is a thing that we're going to agree on, and I'm not really interested in having to justify all my feelings about this. I am trying very hard *not* to obsess over this and let it bother me, like I did when Joe and Joyce initially got together. So I replied because I wanted to offer a point of view that I think isn't very common in this comment section, but I don't really want to debate this stuff. We're going to find out in about 20 minutes how accurate some of this stuff is, anyway.

tifani

Hey I did say agree to disagree in my last comment.

The Mayor of Christmas

It’s really weird that you don’t think “trust Joyce“ is an option.

Jayne Lindgren

To be fair, that one got popped out while I was writing that! I basically didn't see most of your responses until I'd typed everything up, sorry.

Ilana Feldman

My point is that it shoves the issue under the rug without addressing it at all. Joe was already trusting Joyce before this.

I Know Why the Mowed Lawn Screams

ok ok ok I was writing this very long and sincere response to at least a handful of my personal reasons as to why I wanted JoJo to break up first bc I don’t think I really see ANYONE else with the same thoughts I have (tl;dr wanna see what Joe is like when he can’t be the boyfriend™ anymore, at least for a storyline or two), but then the comic updated and I’m just like fuck it dawg I can either keep holding on to this pipe dream or learn to love the DoJoJo, and I’m not going anywhere committing to the former at this point 😩

Beck Chonigman

*me in my little corner flailing around with my poly flags in hand and excitedly screaming*

Maude Reads Things

Sure, but he and Joyce were (ostensibly) monogamous so I don't think it was that out there to think he might be upset that once he does decide to give the monogamy thing the ole college try (pun intended) it ends up being cheated on. Maybe something about how Joe was so worried about ending up like his dad he didn't anticipate being in his mom's position. Like I said, I don't think this is out of character for Joe (I mean, the guy LITERALLY made up threesomes to boost his cred), but I don't think that it would've been if he had been upset either. That said, I definitely thought polyamory was a possibility. I thought it might be a bumpier road to get there but this was definitely an endpoint I thought was possible

I Know Why the Mowed Lawn Screams

You will never catch me with a Pepsi in my hand but I do appreciate the analogy, praying that we get some classic walkyverse levels crashout from him lol