Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

a bold strategy, cotton

Files

Comments

Jozan

YEESSSSS YESS YES YESSSSS

Minzoku Bokumetsu

"Dating TWO people at the SAME TIME? Is there even a WORD for that?!?"

Jozan

Thank you Willis!

Ze Myna

he’s so sweet. holy shit.

Populuxe

This is a conversation Dorothy should be a part of.

Chloe Wiley

HOLY SHIT IS IT HAPPENING IT CANT BE HAPPENING THIS IS NOT A DRILL

Jay's Journey

Yes! A healthy, even if Joyce tried to screw it up, polycule!

Logibear

Joe stocks soaring right now.

C

"YES! HA-HA...YES!"

el

this poor man...

Andrea Andrew

Damn it, Joe! You’re an amazing dude. So insightful and understanding. Definitely someone I’d have picked for a boyfriend.

Ragtime

Now to see if Dorothy and Joyce are cool with this.......please don't sink this ship so close to port Willis!

WT Harmon

I want good things for Joe. I don't think this will work, but what the hell do I know.

ArchineerLock

Joe is maybe the single most mature chatacter in the entire comic.

Templeton

It’s Joyce and I believe she has the room in her heart for both of them, but what will Dorothy think?

Jessica

Let's goooooooooo! (However this resolves, so wonderful to see healthy polyamory even PROPOSED)

Anna Phylaxis

AND THE POLY SICKOS HAVE IT, AN AMAZING COMEBACK, COTTON, LET'S SEE WHAT THE COMMENTS THINK (oh god)

tifani

Beautiful! Beautiful boy!

ArchineerLock

Also, but have yall considered: will Dorothy be okay with this arrangement?

C.T. Phipps

Dorothy: NOOOOOOOOOOOoooooo!

C.T. Phipps

I really think she'll hate it.

Andrea Andrew

So Joyce now has a boyfriend and a girlfriend. I knew that bonus strip where Joyce talks to the poly girls would pay off. It makes sense. Joyce didn’t stop liking Joe. She just realized she’s in love with Dorothy. I hope Dorothy is okay with this. She’s probably feeling grateful to Joe for helping her realize her love.

tifani

Also: VINDICATION!!!!

AE Gonzalez

Joe’s officially in, let’s see what Joyce and Dorothy say.

Megh

Poor Joe looks so conflicted here He saw this coming a mile away and it still hurts I think poly is a bad idea for him, I think it will hurt him so so much more than just breaking up right now... But I am a sicko at heart so I will keep watching ofc Also really like the "have/know what you want" callback

Smoochie

It’s a beautiful sentiment. A healthy suggestion though I…am not entirely sure if there are healthy reasons behind it. To be loved by Joyce is like being a Kryptonian in front of a yellow sun.

The Mayor of Christmas

If the question is “will Dorothy be a considerate romantic partner”, I think we all know what the answer is.

ATD

I'm so giddy right now!!! I don't think I've ever had a polyam ship I like become canon before...

tifani

Hahaha people are gonna be piiiiiised!

The25th

I wonder how walky would react. Does he have the same capacity.

Acebender

damn Joyce how come Willis lets you have two partners

Kelly (they-them)

Joe realized Joyce and Dorothy were on a date the night of dranks before they did

Kelly (they-them)

I have so much to say about this strip. I love this strip. This is my favorite strip for at least the next hour

tifani

Let’s hug each other and jump up and down in spirit!

Em

So … this is the first time since it was clear where the arc was going that I’ve felt uneasy. Joe’s attitude is super super unhealthy. He talking about Joyce’s needs and happiness without considering his own. It’s very possible that he is and will be fine with this, but he’s leading with how this is benefitting Joyce and that Joyce’s happiness is paramount. Which is … troubling. To me. We’ll see what happens, I suppose.

Ilana Feldman

Maybe we'll get a redux of "The boyfriend is gone and I am reclaiming my time" but with Dorothy saying it about Joe instead, given that she has seemed pretty possessive of Joyce specifically.

Harold

Dorothy: "OK, just pretend that people are McNuggets. You can't stop at just one, right?" Walky: "I'm listening..."

Jeremy AR

I know i love it. All these people are emotional messes ,😃

tifani

Oh my god “troubling”? No the fuck it’s not. It’s beautiful!

AE Gonzalez

Points to Joyce for being honest and upfront with “. . . and I plan on doing it again.”

Crunchos cereal

Also, for some reason my brain said ’fuck Rachel’, though I hope she can change, too.

Quantum

Okay thank you, you put what I was feeling into words

Harold

Now BOOONNNEEE!!!

Jeremy AR

And you know what happens when you try to fuck the sun.

Crunchos cereal

Though, hey, first-year college kids. Many, if not most, people do not figure these things out ever. I’d give them some slack.

5099 5618 v2.0

Cap'n @Sajuuk-Khar, the ENM modulator's holding steady! (/The Shipstream rumbles) (/wobbly sounds resonate through the hull)

Harold

@Tifani: Never will the word "cuck" be used with such feeling, and in so many different ways

Tim Mitchell

Yeah, Joe is very aware of what has been going on with Joyce and Dorothy. But is this him accepting that, or him trying to salvage something.

Heatth

I, uh, don't think this is a good outcome for Joe? I see some folks celebrating and calling it healthy but I am having a very different reaction. It is the second to last panel. That reads as genuine pain. He knows doesn't occupy the same space as Dorothy does *and that hurts him*. He wants to be that but is forcing himself to compromise and resignate himself to a lower position. I am not familiar with polyamory, but I feel that is not how it is supposed to go, to have a throuple where one person is a secondary relationship. And ultimately I don't think this seem very healthy for him. I think it likely derives from his low self esteem. I think he should be able to want more of a relationship

Wednesday Sophia

Joyce: "w-wait... so i can kiss...Everyone???"

tifani

I’ve been holding back but I am over the rampant mononormative bullshit and won’t even be pretending to entertain it. If you thought I was annoying before see how bad I can be when I’m proven right. I feel like I could punch the sun right now! (Smashes a bottle waves the pointy end around menacingly) Fight me!

Aubrey Bryn

Honestly, I kind of felt he might be fine with it. He didn't seem even remotely threatened by Dorothy when he figured it out

voyager-ngc5195

Gotta be honest that I'm not seeing this as the same win that a lot of people seem to? I guess, it's mostly putting the ball in Dorothy's court as to whether she wants an exclusive relationship with Joyce or is fine sharing her; if she's not then Joe's still dumped. I can see how it's still a step towards a poly relationship, just seems way too early to celebrate now.

Smoochie

It’s hard because it’s like—all respect to him for going above and beyond emotional maturity here. However—we’ll see if he’s built for this. Dorothy and Joe both, I dunno if they’re necessarily built for poly but then again WHAT DO I KNOW. People surprise themselves.

Mariah

Joe doesn't value himself! he deserves better than that hussy! "cries in paladin" thats what the comments are goin to think on the main site anyway.

Tim Mitchell

Yep. I’m not seeing her being the sharing type with this.

Harold

Panel 4 Joyce: "Wait, what? This is a thing that can actually happen? I mean, I know it *happens,* I know people who have it. But to *me*? After all *this*?!?"

Aubrey Bryn

I dunno; I feel her only concern with Joe was that she wanted what they had, and now she has that.

ArdieBea

Joe's been preparing for this for a while, now. Dorothy (and Joyce) have been overwhelmed by developments. I can see Joyce grabbing onto this, but Dorothy... has years of misogynistic Joe in her immediate past that will make this a very hard sell.

Lia

AW

Uniquitous

Oh shit. And hell yes!

Calder Johnson

Another turn in The Wheel of Prophecy...

Morgan Byrd

Fuck it’s actually happening

AE Gonzalez

Side note: Is Joe gonna ask Joyce why she sucked his dick last night? Joyce had just made out with Dorothy, he has to wonder if the two are connected.

Morgan Byrd

He planned on this. He knew this was going to happen. That makes sense.

Railway Series Book Club

i'm a sicko doing my sicko dance bc the polyamory storyline is gonna be awesome to see unfold

Harold

@ArdieBea: But without Joe's prodding, Dorothy might never have acknowledged her true feelings for Joyce. That should count for a lot. It doesn't necessarily mean she's up for *this,* but hopefully she has a warmer regard for him now.

tifani

Kindness is her kink and he just gave her everything. Joyce is going to ride him so hard he’s going to need to be hospitalized for dehydration.

5099 5618 v2.0

(/clicks and beeps) Emotional compensators are taking a beating, but we should be able to get out of this rift before it closes if we jump through sub-space. (/Small panel explosion) Your orders?

Uniquitous

And also, please Joyce. Please. Have the space in your heart and your brain to accommodate this

Ilana Feldman

Joyce already answered that. It's because of his powerful sexual kindness.

Heatth

I mean, does *Dorothy*? Or Joyce for that matter. That was always one of the biggest obstacles to me, they both have shown to be incredibly jealous of each other.

Maude Reads Things

There are polyamorous relationships where they sort people into primary/secondary/tertiary partners based on how much time and/or commitment they have for each one, but uh. Yeah. From what I know there's lots of potential for hurt feelings in those if you're not careful

MrShoggoth

Positively or negatively?

Maude Reads Things

Okay, Harold, if it goes like that I'm gonna cackle. Best way to let me keep both my ships

tifani

They’ll start a group chat

Calder Johnson

I would consider it healthy in the sense that Joe has clearly considered this, knew this was a possibility, and is making a decision of his own free will. Whether or not the decision is healthy in the long term is something we just don't know yet.

Quantum

It's not even about being mono-normative. It just feels like the way he's approaching it is more "I don't wanna lose Joyce so I'll take what I can get" and not "yeah I've been cool with sharing you this whole time actually"

5099 5618 v2.0

@Harold Ah, yes. One's first polycule. It does tend to feel that way.

tifani

Because he’s not like a regular webcomic creator. He’s a cool webcomic creator.

Bronxden

Ah so where going down a potential line where this is about to be unhealthy for Joe and how he’s ignoring his own feelings and not able to break apart from this “ok” I think Joyce will try to give a try or a second thought but I think someone will talk to him on how he has to let her go because if she was open to the idea for extended love it would have been brought up.

Harold

@Tifani: Is that what the kids are calling it these days?

Heatth

The biggest thing to me is Joe's face in panel 5. To me that is not the face of someone who wants what he is proposing.

Doki

This is what I'm wondering. Joe outright called Dorothy a friend in that conversation and didn't talk down to her, and I know that's gotta count for something?

Beck Chonigman

*me launching out of my little corner with my little poly flags proudly flapping through the breeze as I am on my collision course for the moon*

5099 5618 v2.0

@Leander Tupper Oh, probably. It's not a guarantee, but there are many ways to do so. (/Eats popcorn) (/Crunch crunch)

William Lewis

Oh damn. Been there, done that and had my heart ripped to tinier pieces than any other bad romance. Willis, I refuse to say "damn you" because of truth, but it's still a fu*king bit*h of a moment for me. And for the poly people? This is _not_ a good place to start that from. Trust me and some real fucking bi pain. They could end up there, though I don't expect them to. I think it will be Joyce and Dorothy with Joe having grown stronger for this. May what ever good that is beyond us bless them, eh?

Harold

@Uniquitous: Her heart, absolutely. Joyce has an unlimited capacity for love. It will almost certainly take longer for her brain to catch up.

Ekelemchi Okemgbo

literally, minus the "here's a photo of you kissing somebody else on the front page of the paper" part

Railway Series Book Club

i posted on yesterday's preview about personal experiences with this in my own polycule and like, when people are on the same page about everything, it hasn't really been that problematic in our experience? that said our 'cule is a lot larger than this is shaping up to be so like, maybe it's something that's a more severe problem at smaller scale, idk. i'd be interested in hearing what fellow polyam folks have to say about this.

Doki

I'm not necessarily sure that's true? Those last two panels are basically what a lot of polyamorous people say/feel about their partners. (Source: I am poly, though I'm not just talking about myself here.)

Harold

[Insert image of Alice avidly sipping soda]

DiDi-chan

Oh... Joseph. This is more heartbreaking than him being angry...

Calder Johnson

There are sticky and complicated spaces between those two states. And sometimes loving people means loving and accepting all of who they are, if thats the choice you make. And that is the choice he's made.

Grace Serenity

I'm not sure this is a healthy response. Joe, buddy, you don't need to cuck yourself (I mean, unless you really want that)! His expression says "I don't want to lose you, even if that means I get hurt" which is not a healthy dynamic! Sure it'll make for good fiction, but Joe doesn't need to get hurt in the process!

5099 5618 v2.0

@Minzoku Bokumetsu No words. Should have sent a poet.

Albi

Dsng it the poly paladin sickos were probably right! XD

Heatth

@Mayor, I really don't think it works like that. Not everyone is up to polyamory and they shouldn't feel pressured to be. I think equating accepting entering in a polyamorous relationship with “will Dorothy be a considerate romantic partner” is very troubling. Also, to be perfectly honest I think Dorothy was never really a very considerate romantic partner, lol. Like, she tries, she is not an asshole, but she did kinda push Walky around during both their relationships.

Calder Johnson

I mean, I think he's being extraordinarily clear about his feelings. And I extend some grace to Joyce in this situation because mononormativity runs DEEP

Doki

So, I'm poly. And I can tell you that some people absolutely do have primary partners and secondary/tertiary/etc. ones. I'm in a triad where we're all equally into each other, so it doesn't really have that dynamic, and even THEN I've had moments similar to the second to last panel here. Hell, I've had that with platonic friendships too. Acknowledging that pain openly like Joe is doing here is actually a GOOD thing - better to put it out there than let it fester!

Heatth

Yeah. To be perfectly honest I am very confused by people celebrating polyamory here. This seems a painful page to me! I really having trouble seeing what other people are seeing.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Leander Tupper Perhaps. Such things are all but cannon events, from what I've seen.

Albi

Ya know what, you earned it. Have a ginger beer on me! 🥂

Lia

girl dont incorporate cuck into your vocabulary like that. like ik ur joking but u wanna talk about an unhealthy framework for understanding these situations, like...

5099 5618 v2.0

@Heatth Some hope, some cope, some raw amazement, I think.

voyager-ngc5195

"I still wanted to compare if I liked hot dogs or tacos equally, jury's still out though because Dorothy didn't want to save any time!"

I Know Why the Mowed Lawn Screams

I can’t even be mad this is almost the exact set up I have with my Partner IRL. “I want you to have what you want” is such a legitimately sweet line I can’t help but melt a little.

Calder Johnson

Yeah, I don't think it's really possible to love multiple people 'equally'. There's always differences, otherwise the result would be monogamy! (Because why wouldn't you do that if there was no difference?) The issues tend to crop in the more problematic nuts and bolts of things like communication or power dynamics.

Heatth

@Queen, The thing to me is that it seems Joe wants to be Joyce's primary partner and it is just resigning himself to be the secondary one. And that unmet yearning just seems painful to me. I guess if he himself had another partner it might not feel so unbalanced? I don't know. @Doki, so you think this might work?

GundamBradley

I am deciding how I feel about this, but in the moment, god, Joe really wound up being one of the most emotionally intelligent dudes on the cast, huh.

Lia

i feel like all the comments saying this is actually heartbreaking and bad for joe stopped reading at the second to last panel. Like this is polyamory, sorry if it looks wrong to you. Actually I bet Joyce reassures him pretty soon that Dorothy's space in her heart isnt greater than his, she just didn't think it was an option to have both

Harold

Meanwhile, I'm picturing Dorothy's conversation with Walky being like a scene from an old Preston Sturges comedy where a woman walks up to her current boyfriend with her new would-be love interest in tow and simply says, "From now on I'm going to be seeing a lot more of him and a lot less of you."

Albi

Jokes aside, as a poly person I am... Kinda worried. Because this is Dumbing of Age and there are bound to be really hurtful mistakes. I am hoping it works out. But I've had to break up with two monogamous people because they were genuinely unhappy with the arrangement. We'll see how this plays out!

Jayne Lindgren

If she was consulted first, then how could she be cast as the villain if she's anything other than 100% enthusiastic about this getting dumped on her?

Doki

Yeah, that's actually something I hadn't seen anyone put into words yet, but I agree: Joe IS healthier for Joyce in some ways. But, of course, Dorothy has helped her in others. That... honestly feels incredibly true to life when it comes to poly relationships?

Anna Phylaxis

Cuck yourself? Friend, that's some rough language you're tossing around here, and I don't think it's gonna help you be understood.

Andrea Andrew

And Joe admits that while she does like him, she loves Dorothy. He also does admit he finds Joyce and Dorothy hot.

Corronchilejano

Resist the urge to communicate your feelings through his weenus Joyce.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Wednesday Sophia "You can, but that's the neat part: you don't." --Omni-Man, probably

tifani

No Joyce give in!

taekwondogirl

We don't actually know if Joyce (and Dorothy) are monogamous. THEY don't know if they're monogamous! Hell, Joyce's only relationship before Joe that isn't her pretending to date Jacob was less than a month. That's the bigger problem, IMO.

taekwondogirl

Powerful Sexual Kindness is the name of my next band.

5099 5618 v2.0

Wait... Are *we* Joyce's intrusive thoughts?

Morgan Byrd

Oh god yes she can fuck it up. I think Dorothy is going to be the bigger obstacle though (say nothing of Walky)

William Lewis

She's human; of course she _can_ That does not mean that she inherently must. The one overwhelming virtue Joyce has is love. And even as an atheist, the whole 1st Corinthians Chapter 13 sermon on love still rings in the mind... (ask me how I know 😉 ) I am a photographer. I live in the light - I view the light as inherently good. I believe she will walk out of this in the light. I am probably wrong but that's my bias and I'll lay my money on it 🥰

Jayne Lindgren

I just want to say to all the triumphant people who are understandably taking a victory lap right now: Other people are allowed to not be super excited about this development. Try and be as kind now as you'd like people to be to you. It's OK for people to not agree on things.

Ernie O'Dell

I'm confused on the definition of polycule, I see maybe an "open relationship" but yeah I don't know how Dorothy and Joe will get along, they don't hate each other but I don't see them i a relationship with each other either. But I my be wrong...

tifani

People who are determined to see tragedy here will twist themselves into pretzels making it so. Me I’m walking on sunshine. But mononormativity is a hell of a drug.

Sydney Ashcraft

I am poly, and stumbled into it... pretty much at their age, actually. Hanging out with my boyfriend and best friend turned into cuddling, turned into more, and when we all compared notes later all three of us were wondering when someone would pull the plug. And I'm still with one of them. But this feels like Joe settling for scraps. Joe ASKING to settle for scraps. Not saying it can't work, but. Not exactly an auspicious beginning.

Calder Johnson

I think one thing I would say in response to those expressing worry in in the comments - I hear you, many of the concerns over whether or not this is a healthy beginning to a polycule are legitimate. But it's also REALLY hard to do this 'perfect' your first time out of the gate! This is all incredibly new to all of them in so many different dimensions! And for the few out there who managed to navigate these new experiences without hurting others or yourself - I'm legitimately impressed, sincerely. But in most cases, there's a lot of mess that goes along with the learning.

Tessea

Awwww.... I kinda figured this was going to be the route Joe was going to take, whether he tried to stay with Joyce or not. Even he could see how close those two were. This is officially the point where I've come to actually like Joe. He's definitely matured.

Uniquitous

If I've learned anything in nearly fifty years of life, it's that what I make of any situation is worth fuck-all.

Tessea

I don't feel he's getting hurt by this idea. I think he'd be more hurt if Joyce actually did leave him. I think if Joyce is happy, Joe will be willing to share. He could already see how close she is with Dorothy and he never acted threatened by it. It looks to me like he feels that as long as he still makes her happy as well, that would be enough.

William Lewis

Ding ding ding Winner winner Chicken Dinner! Been there done that and it's not pretty if everyone isn't on the same sheet of music. IF everyone is, it can be just fine, but it's still an odd dynamic but if people aren't? Oy!

Uniquitous

Or... y'know, just go with it

voyager-ngc5195

To me, it's not polyamory *yet* and my concern is that we're jumping the gun in that no one in this scenario has stated that they are polyamorous . Joe's not said he's poly. Dorothy's not said she's poly. Joyce hasn't said she's poly. Moreover, Joe's not saying that he wants to become poly himself; what he's asking for is for Joyce to make the decision to become poly, so that he can stay in her life. It's an option that both Joyce and then, Dorothy would have to consider; probably their first decision *as an official couple* because Joyce has already stated she wants to be with Dorothy *over* Joe. Even if Joyce wants to enter in a poly relationship, if Dorothy's not on board with it then it's not going to happen. Joyce has made clear that she's going with Dorothy regardless. This is all very new to everyone involved so everyone's still learning preferences and limits, but I'll be honest; the ideal time to have discussed this was when they were still together as a couple, not on the verge of breaking up. I'm absolutely not disagreeing that this poly relationship could still work out, just saying that the scenario here is nowhere near ideal, especially for Joe.

shoutytrack | issa maspro

We love Joe so much in this house I am. Fist pumping. Like i'm genuinely glad that he's just. Putting himself out there and trying to do this in a way that honors Joyce's desires before like, the sexpot persona he's slowly been shedding. It's nice to see that nuance. Also, let bi people have what they want forever 🌟

5099 5618 v2.0

@Jeremy AR You find out you can breathe in space? (Or is that just Batman?)

Harold

@taekwondogirl: And, of course, there were, um, other issues with that first relationship.

eightand17

He's called her "dude" twice in this scene, has he ever called her that before? Or any other woman he's into?

Tessea

To me it feels like all Joe wants to know is if he still makes her happy _as well_. He looks hopeful that she'll accept (check in with Dorothy first, you dork!!) and maybe that will be enough for him.

tifani

He called Rachel dude which could mean nothing

Tessea

Joyce looks so lost. 'But I screwed up. Badly! I'm not supposed to get everything I want as a result!'

Ria

Wow okay king legend slay poly god????? This is a level of good practice that like, it's awesome to see him display, but it's also quite shocking from anyone who's 18????????? In any case, I'm deeply thrilled that this is the kind of drama we're about to get!!!!!!!!! Dorothy is gonna be a fucking WRECK LMFAO

Ria

No literally this is electric

5099 5618 v2.0

@Tessea Getting what you want is one thing. *Keeping* it is another thing, entirely.

Ada

In this thread: a disturbing quantity of people who are, evidently, polyamorous and bad at it

5099 5618 v2.0

@Ada I'm hoping it's more they remember being bad at it at 18-19 yrs old, myself.

Calder Johnson

Time till the Poly Crowd separated into Paladin and Sicko camps: less than one hour.

Berry

Oh thank GOD

Ada

I mean don't get me wrong, I am a sicko, in that I think this is delicious drama, I'm just perturbed by people thinking the events being described are... good. Rather than an oncoming train wreck that I look forward to watching.

darklion

JOOOOOOOOOOOOOOE

Wednesday Sophia

"... So anyways Dorothy!!! now you can be there when i have sex with Joe! so i can do it right!"

shiftdruid

this might piss some folks off more than Any Other Possible Outcome. fortunately it made me cry like a baby so

Chloe Goodchild

As a very poly person I understand the folks in here worrying but I also see a lot of what does make the relationships I'm in work. We understand that there is love beyond what we can feel for each individual and through that we thrive. "I can't occupy that space in your heart" is a self detrimental take on this imo, not nessecarily a bad mindset, but an unlearned perspective. My partners all bring different parts of my needs and my expressions of love out, and I for them. I think of anyone, Joe with lots of experience knowing what he doesn't want, is well placed to understand what he does here. And he's definitely thought about this a while already. Dotty tho. She worries me. She screams jealous and controlling and while Joyce might melt that somewhat, it might not mesh with Joe. I'd say she needs to mellow. Perhaps Joyce might be her path there. Not that they have to be 'kitchen table' about it, but I'd bet Joyce would like if they were. All said, I fully see the both of Dorothy and Joe being able to feel the full effects of compersion, which in my experience has been the key which releases the jealousy demon from existence. Arguably Dorothy already did this by helping point Joe in some directions and seeming happy that things worked for them and Joe seems to be understanding the benefit that Dorothy brings to Joyce too... There's a lot that can work here. The starting point is messy, but figuring out you are actually truly into another girl while in the middle of a protest being gassed out is a big system shock. It isn't the same as intentionally cheating and maliciously seeking things without communication... Maybe some folks have forgotten what it's like to first realise this stuff properly and how electric it all is, let alone how spontaneous it can be. It's not planned out, so being able to pivot swiftly is a big deal. Joe was ahead of the curve here and yet again ready to catch Joyce when she worked out something new about herself. Anyway I do big talk. Me stop now. Hoping this is either cute as hell or an entertaining tragedy.

NinjaZaku

I feel similarly. I think there is potential for a solid polycule based on the various personalities. That said, Joe undervaluing himself as a partner is not a good place for him to be mentally. Where the rest of this conversation goes is gonna be really important.

Packy Anderson

Right now, I respect Joe more than I ever have before.

Chloe Goodchild

100% To be fair to him too, he's been put down a lot for his past. That sticks around. Joyce is as much an escape from that as anything else too. Hopefully in a good way. He genuinely seems to like that he can give her what she wants but has to know that, if this does continue, he is also what she wants and that he's more than just a vessel for pleasing her.

Jack Atherton

As an ambiamorous person — I see Joe using language in this strip that means he **THINKS** his spot in Joyce’s heart is something to compare to Dorothy’s. Like of those spots is measurably larger, and it isn’t his. I think that’s something that happens so often in polyamory — especially in the beginning. I think it’s common to compare what you think your worth is to what you perceive others’ to be — both in and out of polyamory. Especially in the context of thinking how much love you deserve from those that you love dearly. It reads to me as Joe being ahead of himself on maturity for polyamory when it comes to understanding that having someone’s love in this way isn’t a fight against all others who might also. But also as reflecting some of his own beliefs about himself and his worth. So his actions show a comfort in sharing, and his language shows him comparing himself to Dorothy and thinking he is less worthy. Is the secrecy of how all this started okay? *No.* Since these boundaries were not explicitly defined beforehand, is this poor decision making at best and cheating at worst? *Yes.* It sounds like Joe tried to softly, indirectly define this boundary a while ago, however. As the person potentially cheated on, JOE gets to decide how HE feels about this. He already decided how he feels about it. — I say this as someone who has literally been in Joe’s shoes. This isn’t a black and white / either all good or all bad situation. It’s messy. Willis isn’t naive and he’s very skilled at carefully painting complexities like this. The whole comic is about how messy figuring this shit out is when you are coming of age. I feel like folx who are isolating focus (emphasis on ISOLATING) to the messy/“wrong” things about how this is unfolding are missing the nuance. Making it out like Joyce and Dorothy are being horrible oversimplifies both what’s happening in the comic, and the human experience of learning/growth. Being excited about the budding romance/polycule isn’t the same as saying everything happened just right and is entirely justifiable. Or that the ends justify the means. I, for one, am really excited because I love Joyce/Joe AND Joyce/Dorothy. I’m glad it doesn’t necessarily have to be just one or the other — that there’s a chance they’ll try to work through the inherently messy process of figuring out what a polyamorous relationship even looks like for them and how to navigate it more successfully. EDITED: to include 2 accidentally skipped sentences

Cyberfossil

Wholesome Joe is best Joe.

Justin Seifert

I really appreciate the way you framed this… it hits on something I’ve seen play out in real life. What you said about different people filling different spaces in the heart is exactly why polyamory works when it’s done with honesty and care. One person doesn’t have to be everything for you… and in fact, expecting that can create resentment or exhaustion. I’ve seen relationships struggle when physical needs don’t line up, or when one partner thrives on adventure and the other isn’t wired that way. That mismatch doesn’t mean the love isn’t real… it just means one person can’t be every answer. Poly dynamics give room for each connection to stand on its own value. A partner who brings stability and love doesn’t take away from another who brings creativity and adventure. Those bonds don’t have to compete… they can coexist, and when partners practice compersion it becomes less about jealousy and more about appreciating how each person enriches the life of someone you love. For me, that’s the beauty of it… love becomes less about holding every space and more about honoring the spaces we do hold in someone’s life. I’ll open up a bit of personal here… because I empathize with Joe a little too much. There is a woman in my life who I love deeply… her creative spark unlocks places in my heart I didn’t even know were there. She already has partners who bring their own forms of love and fulfillment into her life, and I don’t want to take that away or compete with it. I only want to be whatever role I may be for her… whether that is adventure-planner, confidant, or simply a steady presence she can rely on. She is irreplaceable… and through her I’ve had to face my own past mistakes in how I’ve handled love. I’ve learned that love is not about clinging, or measuring worth by exclusivity, but about honoring the bond that exists and doing right by it. I want what is best for her, whatever that may be… even when it isn’t me. My heart still aches at the space I cannot enter, but that ache is softened by gratitude. Gratitude that I have a place in her life at all… gratitude that I can show my love not by claiming but by giving. I would do just about anything for her... whether that means planning trips that light her up, making her laugh when she needs it, or sitting with her in quiet when words aren’t enough. Polyamory has shown me that love doesn’t lose its worth just because it isn’t exclusive. My bond with her may not look like anyone else’s… but it is still real, still vital, still its own kind of irreplaceable. And maybe that’s the truest form of love… not demanding to fill every corner of someone’s life, but honoring the part you are trusted with and giving it everything you can.

Simon Magid

@Jack Alberton: I never had this particular issue myself. But my SO and I had plenty of other problems. We were both abuse survivors and had no idea of what an actual functional relationship looked like. We got so many things wrong. But the thing is: It is possible to start at wrong and work your way to right. My SO and I managed that. It was long, hard and often painful work and at times we hurt one another badly. But now we have a stable, happy and strong relationship. We still screw up at times but at the end of the day we make things work. (Edit: I suddenly realized that this may sound like I am objecting to your post somehow. This is by no means my intent; I mean to be a voice of support. My thought is that hard work, honesty and trust combine to make a good relationship possible, be it vanilla, polyamory or any other relationship form.)

tifani

@justin: Beautifully put.

Tessea

Absolutely!

Logibear

Even if this ends in heartbreak. Joe is being as honest as he can possibly be here. He isn't deflecting or hiding anything. My boy is shining and I am so happy that Willis let him.

Sajuuk-Khar

Stay on course, Mr. Crusher! Aim for the rift and make all preparations to jump! Jettison the rationality subsectors if we must, the core is what matters!!

Sajuuk-Khar

Black turtlenecks for all! Jojo poses for some!

Logibear

Also calling it now, this either ends with her jump-kissing him, or with her breaking down in tears saying no.

Sajuuk-Khar

WILLIS IF NEXT STRIP FUCKS THIS UP I’M GONNA MAKE A GLADYS STICK WITH YOUR HAIR ON IT

Lonk

I was like 30% sure that it was gonna go in this direction when Joe first approached Dorothy about liking joyce with seemingly zero jealousy

ArdieBea

I think that conversation highlighted both Joe's development ('Be more honest Dorothy," "Joyce is everything, isn't she?") and Dorothy's resentments ("You've been calling me a lesbian since we were 15!", "I've given it all up for nothing and you sacrificed nothing and got everything!") And afterwards, it was still actively triggering her trauma to see Joyce going off with Joe - because she associates him so strongly with abusive masculinity - despite all she said to Joyce about how Joe would always treat her well and be happy just to be with her (which I think was, at least in part, projecting). So I don't think it'll be easy for her. And I think that her consistently crumbling persona through the last 15 years has left her with massively diminished emotional resources. My take on it is that she really needs some space to learn how to love Joyce well and be loved by her before she'd even contemplate doing the hard work of sharing. Especially with Joe. BUT on the other hand, Joe is currently an established part of Joyce's life. If a polycule is going to be possible, it may stand it's best chance starting now, without forcing Joyce through the grief of losing one partner to satisfy the needs of another.

5099 5618 v2.0

Aye, Cap'n! Course set, and jettisoning RS 1&2 in preparation to jump...now! (/THUD THUD) (/Pre-jump klaxon sounds) (/Sparks) Captain, we just lost the moral navigation array to a surge in orgone energy from the rift! The core's intact but there's no telling where we'll stop if we jump, now!

AE Gonzalez

Dorothy: “I don’t fully agree with this, but if it makes you happy, it makes me happy. That said: if you get to keep Joe, I get to keep Walky. Does that work for you, Joyce?” Joyce through clenched teeth: “If it makes you happy Dorothy, of course!”

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar "Yes! Yes! Yes! Oh my God..." -Joseph Joestar, probably

Logibear

Imagine if she breaks up with Walky just to float this back to him an hour later.

Jack Atherton

@Simon Magid Thank you for your kind reply! I just noticed a sentence went missing somewhere in the writing/editing I did of my post. I just added it back in I meant to communicate in the above that I feel like folx who are focusing on all the messy/“wrong” things about how this is unfolding are missing the nuance. I’m happily still with my partner that I went through a Joe-ish experience with. Same as you said — it was messy and many mistakes are made. But we stable, happy, and strong as it sounds like you are with your partner, of which I’m very glad! So yeah, people making it out like Joyce and Dorothy are being horrible are oversimplifying both what’s happening, and the human experience of learning and growth. (My intended tone is 1000% genuine! With autism I can’t always tell if I’m hitting my intended tone in text)

Rob McBobson

BBCC: It's true that there's lots of potential for hurt feelings in those if you're not careful, but that's, well, every relation ship ever.

SomeKindaNerd

Joe? My respect for you has skyrocketed once again. Your commitment to changing already made it peak, but now it's astronomical. He's being a bigger man than he already is physically and that's huge.

Gale Tazzin

i think Joyce's feelings for Walky are actually quite similar to Dorothy's feelings for Joe

Gale Tazzin

i voiced a similar sentiment to my partner and was proud of myself for being emotionally mature and unselfish and then a few weeks later i got dumped lmao

Gale Tazzin

joe is going to mysteriously turn up dead

AE Gonzalez

Another possibility: before she has a chance to say anything, he breaks up with her. He already saw the newspaper, he’s already made his decision.

Maude Reads Things

Of course! There's potential in any kind of relationship for hurt feelings.

AE Gonzalez

Continuing: Joyce: “How dare you dump Dorothy?! She’s the most awesome girlfriend in the world!!” Walky: “You . . . want me back together with her?” Joyce through clenched teeth: “If it makes her ha-“ Walky: “Smooching me, fondling me, sucking my weenus . . .” Joyce: “You’re making this much har-“ Walky: “. . . putting her finger up my butt . . .” Joyce: “Goddamn it Walky!!!”

Smoochie

@Gale The parallels of Dorothy/Joe’s relationship to Walky/Joyce are actually genuinely terrifying.

Smoochie

@AE maybe we don’t get a blow up, but Walky makes it clear in no certain terms that that he’s not even sure he and Dorothy are still friends

aran

I think Walky will either utterly shut down or possibly actively crash out. Joe's buoyed by his recent self-improvement streak and has a secure foundation of self-worth. Walky... has none of that

Terra Bruder

I mean if it works out great that's sweet no shade but if they develop polyculitis 😢

Smoochie

Drama goblins: you guys get camps?

ScrimpArt

this stuff RARELY ever works out so while I love joes maturity (andenjoy the drama) he needs to get out of here.

Rob McBobson

Panel 5 worries me. Long story short: Joe looks unhappy. It's always a warning sign that somebody agreeing to be poly is looking unhappy. How large a warning sign it is varies, but it's never a good sign.

Sajuuk-Khar

THEN WE JUMP BLIND, MR. CRUSHER, AND DAMN THE COSTS! SIPHON POWER FROM ENDGAME SUPPORT AND THE GOOD POLY CHOICES DECKS IF WE HAVE TO!

KittyKai

GODS, Joe is exceeding all of my expectations. But really in retrospect, this makes perfect sense. Of all the characters I've seen in Dumbing of Age, Joe post-Joyce-date has consistently shown a level of emotional maturity that much of the rest of the cast can only hope to achieve. I do feel kind of bad for him when he says he'll never match Dorthy's love for Joyce, and there is a part of me that worries that's gonna be a bigger issue in the future. But I get the feeling that no matter what happens, no matter if this polycule stays or is doomed to fail... No matter what happens, I think Joe will be okay. And even if they break up, I don't think Joe or Joyce will ever stop being there for each other. I'm proud of the boy it's what I'm saying. ... and while I acknowledge the possibility that this poly may crash and burn, MY POLY SHIPPER HEART IS HOPING IT DOESN'T BWEEEHHHH

Sajuuk-Khar

Jack, as the person this arc is for, per at least the wonderful Kelly, your viewpoint here is good and you should feel good

T Campbell

Silly me, I thought Joe's reaction might at least tamp down the controversy. Instead, we're probably gonna get the pro-poly camp going "HURRAY, THIS IS THE BEST THING EVER, JOE ACCEPTS THE FACTS LIKE A FULLY ENLIGHTENED DUDE" and the "this is cheating" crew going "Oh geez, Joe's lashing INWARD instead of lashing out, this is painful to watch." Put me more in that second camp, I s'pose. I mean, I answered "They're horny idiots" in the poll, and I'm forgiving of Joyce and Dorothy...they're trying hard to handle this right. But trying ain't succeeding, and sometimes you can do your best and still fail. (Sarah would argue with the idea that a night of snuggletime without telling anyone doesn't constitute "doing one's best," but hormones gonna hormone.) I 've written multiple polycules in my own career, so despite not really being part of one that lasted or fully qualified, I feel like I've done a lot of thinking about the dynamics involved. All participants need a few key attitudes in place for it to work, and the EXTREMELY VARIABLE attitudes that Dorothy's shown about Joe over the course of the strip make me...doubt that she'd be ready to do her part there. What's more, Joe seems to be coming at this with the attitude of "I'm not good enough to be #1 in her heart," and a poly relationship with competition at its core isn't likely to be stable, even if one of the parties expects to lose. Frankly, any relationship that has low self-esteem as a basis is unlikely to have a healthy outcome. I still have certain doubts about Joyce and Dorothy's long-term viability as a couple--which proves nothing, if I didn't have doubts, it wouldn't be a David Willis romance*--but right now, they sure look a lot more like a stable configuration to me than Joe-Joyce-Dorothy. Though either of those arrangements would look more stable than any grouping that includes Joyce and Walky. Say, Becky reads the student paper, doesn't she? *Seriously, I think the only DoA pairing that I never really doubted would go the distance, that actually HAS gone the distance, is Sal and Danny. So far, anyway! (And they were David's *original* broken-up couple in his old continuity, so...)

Riley

POLY SICKOS STAY WINNING

Jay

I still think this is the lazy solution to all the tension thats been built up over the past montj but I also sss this blowong up even harder in a year or two so im just gonna sit here and enjoy the cute whole waiting for that nuke in the corner to go off

MrShoggoth

I know people who have done exactly what Joe’s doing here, and it’s ended badly every time. I’m worried even though the discussion started off well.

Sajuuk-Khar

I feel like… UNLESS Willis proves it was all a bait and switch next strip, we are locked into this *disastrous* version of the Sacred Polycule for at least Book 15. Is it healthy? No. Is it founded on good decisions? Not at all. But we left those the fuck behind in Dunn Meadow, baybee!!! We’re on a voyage into unknown and dumb-ass waters!! I don’t…really see Dorothy laying down an ultimatum about No Joe?? 🤔 Like, she’s…Dorothy. It feels very out of character for her! It’d be weird! Not to mention I would be kind of concerned about Joyce/Dorothy’s stability then? Like, it’s a valid boundary for sure, but it’s also setting an ultimatum about monogamy down for the partner you cheated with. In the words of Luke Skywalker, “[that’s] not going to go the way you think”. I don’t think this is the most enlightened thing ever and I’m worried/goblining about Joe’s self esteem as well as Dorothy’s, but I do think that it’s way too early to be calling doom and gloom. I think these three (four??? Walky *could* hang in there even if he really shouldn’t, I do not WANT him to for his and Dorothy and Joe and Joyce’s sakes) are going to be great in some ways, cringe as fuck in others, I can’t WAIT to see which.

Riley

i definitely think it's at least been on Joyce's mind considering her fawning curiosity at the poly folks on her floor in the past

Heatth

"Frankly, any relationship that has low self-esteem as a basis is unlikely to have a healthy outcome." That is one aspect of Joyce/Joe and Dorothy/Walky that never sit entirely right with me. I don't think it is necessarily mean those pairings are doomed but it is still something that needs to be addressed and so far hadn't.

Harold

@NAtAyAZAInAk: She already did last ni-- oh, wait. I didn't see the "-pats"

Sajuuk-Khar

(Let me pause for a moment and note that if Dorothy is unhappy about this and swallows it and burbles with resentment she is not a villain. If Dorothy does an ultimatum she is not a villain. If Dorothy accepts this and is good giving and game but really wishes she was consulted beforehand she is not a villain. We love our bony poindexter in this house, as much as we love our goofy ex-fundie Crazy Ex Girlfriend in the making and our hunk shedding the bad chrysalis of toxic masculinity. I am not here for shidding on Dotty or to be made to appear to be shidding on Dotty.)

Populuxe

I don’t see how this is a polycule? Joe wants to continue to be Joyce’s boyfriend while accepting Dorothy as her girlfriend. But the third side of that triangle doesn’t exist. I just don’t see Dorothy and Joe together in any capacity. Not romantically. Not for Joyce’s sake. Just no.

Spartacus

Oh yeah. As a poly sicko myself, this is like... Being a 5 year old with an extra-large soft serve. It's going to end with the mother of all tummy aches. Cause like, Joe can't even muster up the self-esteem to call Joyce on her cheating? Not only is Joyce not getting the chew-out she deserves, but Joe's boundaries have been totally ignored and without proper reconciliation he's not going to be able to set up new ones soJoyce and Dorothy are going to keep crossing his. What was originally a car crash just became a train wreck.

Spartacus

Yep, I agree. Relationships can go poly, but how the monogamy cracks defines the whole course into the future. And this relationship is being opened by Joyce and Dorothy ignoring Joe's boundaries and Joe being unable to enforce them.

voyager-ngc5195

It's a common misconception, but a polyamorous relationship doesn't need to be entirely reciprocal for all parties involved. Sometimes it's just one person who has relationships with multiple partners at once, while the partners involved are just friends with one another.

Spartacus

Yeah absolutely. This is a classic poly blunder, and I'm here to watch the explosions from a safe distance. Sometimes relationships are like rocket propellant

Jonathan Moore

It might be that he's trying to head off her breaking up with him and slow the conversation down. He's had some time to process his initial reactions without Joyce there. If I had my way, he'd level with her about his feelings and reiterate (or explicitly state where he hadn't before) his boundaries, and give Joyce an opportunity to make those right, *first*. Then everyone's stuck in limbo until Joyce can talk to Dorothy and whatever happens with Walky. It hinges on whether Joyce and Dorothy can own their mistakes and reconcile them, without assuming that means they have to go nuclear. We shall see.

Jonathan Moore

I am hoping he's able to transform "I'll never be able to match" into "What we have is special and precious".

Sajuuk-Khar

1.) Voyager is absolutely right. Hinge or N-shaped polycules are just as valid as triads or squares! They’re just as likely and deserve respect and consideration. :) 2.) Every time I hear people talk about how Joe and Dorothy just cannot be together ever ever ever I become more obsessed with them doing so. My spite-fueled Dorothy/Joe idea centers are through the roof. You are making me too powerful to be expressed in words or numbers.

Jonathan Moore

I'm with you on all points. Sometimes we learn by making big mistakes, or mistakes that are made out to be big. But honestly, young people may not really know what it means to commit until they hit the lines, or even color over them some. That it usually ends the relationship doesn't change the fact that it's part of learning. Making mistakes doesn't have to end the relationship; many relationships have to hit some type of trust break to validate that they can survive the break and build a new, stronger trust. It's my hope that we get to watch this with the characters here, even if they don't maintain the same romantic relationships. They all have their traumatic backgrounds, and I'd really love to see them grow from the experience without new, lasting injuries.

Sajuuk-Khar

Also I know we all note that the main site comments are bad pretty regularly but whooo doggy they really aren’t doing good today! Good God! This one’s gonna cause some FLOUNCES when it drops. (The subreddit doesn’t count, they count even less than that bullshit constant /co/ hateread thread on 4chan where all the chuds wanted to lick Mary’s toes years back. I bet they’re the same dudes.)

Sajuuk-Khar

also everyone should go see Weapons

Sajuuk-Khar

Jesus the oof size on that image lmao

Astariel

This isn't what I wanted, which was all Joyrothy all the time, but I'm happy for all the poly shippers who are seeing their dreams come true. That said, I'm a bit concerned about Joe here. It reminds me a lot of my first (and only) relationship where I was decidedly second place to another partner. It worked out for me in the long run, but only because the other relationship collapsed and the two of us settled into a monogamous relationship. In the short-term it was frequently very painful. Now granted, we were all in high school, it was 1999, and none of us knew jack about polyamory, so hopefully these guys will do better. But I see a lot of how I was then in Joe, and it concerns me.

Jay

There’s so many exciting ways this could shake out and it’s far too early to make predictions either way, but I’m a simple theorizer and I must put down one humble bet: Joyce and Joe will break up despite neither party really wanting to. But after processing with Joyce, some recognition of Joe’s character growth and positive effect on Joyce, and some serious soul-searching, it’s gonna be *Dorothy*, in a symbolic act of burying the hatchet with Joe, getting them back together. And thus the polyship will sail~

Jay

It would also be a lovely parallel to Joe’s earlier conversation with Dorothy about loving Joyce.

zee

....would be a hilarious parallel to Joyce getting dot and Walky back together ages ago

Kelly (they-them)

I've never been to the DoA subreddit, but do people act at all like they do in r/questionablecontent? Cuz if so, woof

Jay

Yes, you see ✨ the vision ✨

KittyKai

I'm in the awkward position where I REALLY want this to work but also I am seeing the many signs that this could very much go downhill fast, and how Joe's current mindset can lead to more problems down the line I'm holding out cautious hope ✊️

Unknown

It may be kind of deserved due to past behavior (and I get that, he really used to project 'pig' intentionally and no one should be forced to deal with that), but one of the biggest thing's that's bothering me about this possible polycule now is actually how much it feels like both Joyce and Dorothy are dismissing Joe as a person. I logically get why that's happening, but between Dorothy having SUCH a chip on her shoulder (again likely deserved) about Joe during their talk when he did actually have a valid reason to engage there, and Joyce jumping straight to the reason the current evolved Joe would encourage this is because 'hot lesbians', it just feels like maybe he's not really being seen or appreciated. Again, I get why this is happening, and hopefully they'll get to a great place! This has all been so fast and they're so young! But I'm just seeing Joyce and Dorothy be very casually dismissive about him, and it feels a lot like he's being treated as a nuisance and an obstacle rather than a person. Especially when he's showing up in the way he is, and being so open and vulnerable (even if a little self sacrificing/deprecating, but ultimately the phrase 'I want you to have what you want' is just so pure and sweet). This is college, so there's absolutely an understandable level of self involvement here with all of them, they're not all awful people or anything for this. Just feel a little bad to see someone who is growing so much be kind of dismissed like this, even if the people who are sidelining him don't automatically owe him acknowledgement of that growth (which they don't if we're being real).

Rob McBobson

I think you were going to write more. Feels like you got cut off.

tifani

Dorothy doesn’t actually KNOW Joe. She knows the guy he was pretending to be in high school. She’s adjusted her opinion on him a bit since then with new information and evidence but it’s really hard to let go of the idea of the version of him she used to know. I think once she actually finds out who he really is she’ll love him as much as we (and Joyce I believe it I think she just isn’t ready to say it YET) does.

Unknown

Yeah, I'm on a phone and can't seem to figure out how to paragraph, just keeps sending instead when I try. Sorry for that and also the lack of paragraph breaks, this hurts even my eyes to look at 😅

tifani

@sajuuk: Give it time. DorothyJoe is gonna happen. I FEEL IT. The throuple will…throuple.

tifani

@smoochie and I think THAT’LL shock Dorothy more than anything

Unknown

I hope so, and you're totally right! To be honest though I also think it would be ok and maybe fair if she never comes around or adjusts. He HAS been kind of a sexist dick to Dorothy for a long time, and it would be really great if they could work through that, but I also think it's fair if she's just done now and has decided she doesn't want to engage with him. I would be sad about that, I want everyone to get along, but I would understand. I'm just really more surprised at Joyce, because she seemed to like and respect him as his partner and this reduction of him is surprising.

tifani

People worried this whole thing is resolving too neatly I really REALLY (pro polycule though I may be) do NOT think Walky is going to react like Joe. I think he’s going to be blindsided and hurt and feel deeply fucked with because HE WAS. I don’t think he’s going to laugh this off. I think he’s going to react to this in a way we’ve never seen him react. It’s been a long time in the real world and they’ve cooled a bit but we have to remember it hasn’t even been a year ago that Walky LOVED Dorothy. Joe levels of Joyce loved Dorothy. The first girl/person he EVER loved. It was NOT his idea to end their relationship the first time. And it’s not going to be his idea to end it this time (even if he dumps her first he was forced into this). And his humiliation is going to be right there for the whole campus to see. The drama is coming.

tifani

How is this the lazy solution? It requires significantly more work from a relationship and writing perspective than just breaking them up. Breaking them up to me is the lazy solution. (In the case of Joyce and Joe at least). It’s what most stories would have done. It’s the expectation. Willis is daring to try something new. He deserves props for that.

Eli Sheep

Huh, I didn't get this perspective at all and it's so interesting to see how everyone is interpreting this page o: Honestly, I don't see what Joe is saying as an inherent negative or as something that's a hit to himself. He literally can't be Dorothy for Joyce, and he knows how important she is to her. To me, he's acknowledging that Dorothy has been building a solid foundation of love and trust with Joyce for quite some time now, and he knows that she provides Joyce a unique and wonderful experience that only Joyce's Dorothy can provide. The last panel reads to me that he hopes that Joyce will also like to continue building together the unique and wonderful relationship that they've been enjoying with each other thus far. Because of Joyce, Joe was genuinely inspired to become a better person, and he sees how much passion and care Joyce has, not only outwardly wanting her to have what she wants, but actively encouraging and supporting her in it. He's so far has shown to be thoughtful, noting what Joyce needs when it comes to her sensory icks, dietary preferences, and safety. He has also shown that he has seen within himself the capacity to change and become someone better and he seems to becoming more assured of himself and the value he is bringing. (I suspect it'll always be a Work In Progress, of course. As these things tend to be, haha) So yeah, I see this entire page as a positive and I'm absolutely delighted by it and am feasting haha

Eli Sheep

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Joe's face in the last panel is killing me. My lil poly heart is melting. I love how he is encouraging Joyce to be with Dorothy while also challenging the notion that she HAS to break up with him in order to do it. They've been building such a wonderful relationship together!!!! There's no need to toss it because she finally came to terms with her love for Dorothy!!!!! (The cheating makes me feel >:C but also, they're young, dumb, and are going through this life for the first time so I guess I can cut them SOME slack) I am very excited and anxious to see how Joyce responds hahaha

Eli Sheep

If you told me that Joe would become my favourite character in DOA I would've been like No Fucking Way. Here we are, though, and my heart is truly full of pride for him!!!! He's come so far. They both have! I really hope they can make it work ultimately, but maaaaan, i know it's gonna be a ride

5099 5618 v2.0

Aye, Captain! Re-routing power from all non-essential functions on GPC decks 7-13! (/Metal straining sounds) EGS reports narrative continuity stabilizers are holding; Shipstream has the core integrity needed to jump! (/Whooshing and thrumming) (/Bee-beep). Captain, Mx. Gurathin in Engineering says the temporal capacitors prematurely discharged after the Orgone surge. We're at 34%, and we need another 35% or we won't clear the rift when we jump! (/Gurathin appears onscreen, sparks and explosions in the background) Gurathin: "Captain, we might be able to jump halfway and slide the rest of the way through if we route the ENM modulator through the communication array and sync the shields in phase-lock with the local narrative waveform! If we get it just right, that should generate a poly-spatial psuedo-surface capable of deflecting and channeling Orgone energies! The Orgone surge coming from the rift would propel the surface through sub-space and carry the ship with it! We're sending coordinates for the next wave to your console, now!" (/Dramatic beat) G: "Captain, I know we've had our differences since the incident with the Paladin ambassador. I should have listened to you, then. I should have *trusted* you. But I need *you* to trust *me*, now! It's going to be a rough ride, but Shipstream *can* do this!" (/Rumbling throughout the ship) Captain @Sajuuk-Khar ? Your orders?

Rob McBobson

Okay, so I get that Joyce's dismissive "Ugh, why. Because it's hot?" is a sincere misunderstanding, but it's still really tragicomic. She's been cheating on him, and he found out in a way that's less than great, and his response? "I want you to have the happiness of kissing the woman you love. I won't deny you that joy." And her response is basically "That's because you're an objectifying PIG, right? UGH." Poor guy. XD

Sajuuk-Khar

Also, like, we’re going to get the bad poly mistakes along with the good poly love *in the future*, Willis is *cooking*.

Sajuuk-Khar

(Hella zooming in, dramatic non-diegetic music, poundy Galactica drums for effect…) …lock us in! (TO BE CONTINUED…!)

tifani

Everyone makes the worst assumptions about him before they really see him and he doesn’t deserve it. Hasn’t for a long time now. He had every right to get pissed at that and he didn’t because he is GOOD. Sarah was right. And I think Joyce’s face in that middle panel is that realization fully sinking in. Whatever was holding her back when it comes to him before this it’s gone now. She’s not throwing him away.

5099 5618 v2.0

In case anyone else also remembers Voyager somewhat fondly [1], here's some of Tuvok's thoughts on writing from that time the crew found Tuvok's training simulator [2]. I keep coming back to the idea of decisions needing to make logical sense from the character's perspective, even if they are *bad* decisions, in the reader's mind. https://youtu.be/VeHZBSXjET4?si=byNyyMvK7CebjLLz _______ [1] - Bonus points to those who remember the time one of the cast of Roomies! was both deep into online backlash to Voyager and somehow wound up in bed with Kate Mulgrew around the time Danny graduated from college. [2] - Training simulator / holo-novel. Also his real-life friend-fiction, but he'd never admit to that. Rumors of the other contents of Tuvok's 24th-century AO3 account have never been canonically confirmed.

David Pipes

Quite simply, I love how Joe has grown.

Amal El-Mohtar

I don’t know if I’ve ever commented here but this strip made me cry & I love it & I love Joe & I just want them to be happy

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Learning usually looks like making different and better mistakes over time, IMHEX. Good mistakes, ideally, and occasionally costly ones, but still. Here's to good mistakes.

Sajuuk-Khar

It seems to be the case, yeah

tifani

….Did you co write this is how you lose the time war?

KittyKai

I have not been on the questionable content subreddit, but I did get curious and read the reddit comments to the main site page today. And...... HOOOOO BOOOOYYYYY 😂😂😂

Ilana Feldman

Personally I stick to /r/QContent. Much nicer comments.

Astariel

Minor quibble, it was Walky's idea to end the relationship the first time, because he felt like he was holding Dorothy back. She just came to the same conclusion before he had a chance to bring up. That said, I agree that not many people, either in-universe or in the comments, seem to care much about what happens to Walky. The only thing that makes me think he might not take it too badly, at least on the surface, is a few of the preview panels, and of course, those can be misleading.

tifani

@rob He looks hopeful but bracing himself for disappointment in case Joyce says no. Not unhappy. I really think people need to just accept that Joe is NOT being forced into this. He’s NOT monogamous and being forced into a poly situation against his will in a desperate attempt to stay with Joyce. He’s not a victim. He WANTS her to have EVERYTHING she WANTS. He wants to be INCLUDED in those wants. He could not have been clearer about how he is actively choosing this if Joyce is game. He doesn’t need or want pity.

tifani

I was thinking about the post pause break up where Walky thought they were back together and Dorothy said no. To be fair I haven’t reread the archive since it happened. So the whole backstory kind of blurs together. Also where are people seeing these preview panels I keep hearing about?

Wednesday Sophia

Dorothy, looking tired as hell: I... ok, i-i did I, i-- Joyce: Hey!! Great news! I didn't have to break up with Joe!!

tifani

@wednesday yeah I don’t think Joyce is going to think for even a second Dorothy will be happy about this. I think she’s going to approach it with the same energy she went to about breaking up with Joe. Unhinged too wide smile “Heeeeeeeeey Dorothy…”

Rob McBobson

@Tifani: Are you sure you're looking at the same panel I'm talking about? Panel 5? Because the description "hopeful but bracing himself for disappointment" sounds more like panel 6 than panel 5.

tifani

@rob Ha! I was talking about panel 6, mea culpa. But my overall opinion remains the same. I don’t think he’s sad. Worried definitely but not sad.

tifani

Well you’ve convinced me!

Ilana Feldman

The update from 2 days ago has suddenly taken on a whole new meaning in my eyes. With more context, 8/22 panel 4 Joe goes from "don't BS me Joyce, you knew what you were doing" to "Give yourself a little more credit, you did a great job of kissing dorothy"

Harold

@Tifani: Willis occasionally posts preview panels (images only, no dialogue or anything else spoiler-y) to the DoA Tumblr page, or to his Bluesky account.

Em

I hear you on that, but I think some of the concern is that people will denigrate polyamory — which would not be cool. I think people can largely disagree but I don’t think it’s okay for people to down poly.

Mariah

every day I find out authors I respect read this strip through the patreon lol.

Rob McBobson

Hey, friend, you might wanna edit your comment above because the title's wrong. It's "this is how you lose the time war" , except you wrote "we". (I'm saying it here because this is one of those situations where I'd wanna be corrected but discreetly.)

tifani

@amal you co wrote my favorite book so thank you for that. Sincerely. I agree with your opinions on this webcomic we apparently both read. Oh my god. Hi 👋

tifani

@rob GOD DAMN IT

tifani

@rob Thanks.

tifani

So would the throuple name be Joeyorthy?

Harold

Or DorJoJoy

tifani

Counterpoint: If we go dorjoyjo it kind of sounds like dorito

Avian

Joecothy, or Jo²rothy

tifani

That does sound mathy and Joyce does like math. Also polyamory = sexy numbers.

Donny K

Joe I swear to the gods I want to kiss you on your sweet sweet forehead you precious man

Amal El-Mohtar

I think I started reading Shortpacked in … 2012??

Amal El-Mohtar

Aw thank you so much, that really means a lot! Also I love the Severance pic!

tifani

@amal and of course you would have perfect taste in tv too.

tifani

God this patreon subscription keeps paying off.

tifani

I am having a GREAT two days

zee

DoJoJo, it's too easy

zee

People are sleeping on the Walky crashout. This is the next step in a long pattern of fuckassery from dot in their relationship and I think he's gonna snap. That pedestal is coming down hard

zee

"you want me, then you don't want me, then you want me but you push me to Lucy, then you want me back from Lucy, and now want Joyce instead?!" This man's gonna develop relationship anxiety with his track record.

zee

I am :3ing irl so hard rn

William Lewis

Still not sure where Willis is going to go with this, but the dumpster fire at the main site (and even more hilariously at reddit) is, I have to say, making me get beer and popcorn ready ;)

5099 5618 v2.0

@zee I suspect he is going to at least have a few heated things to say, yeah

5099 5618 v2.0

JoJoDo[1], maybe? Regardless, what would their Stand(s) be? [1] - Jo(yce, )Jo(e, )Do(rothy)

Sajuuk-Khar

SO NO CHI NO SADAMEEEE DORJOOOOOOOJO

David M Willis

there's a person responding to the bluesky post for today's strip very very very convinced that everyone who thinks joe would suggest poly is an idiot, and i'm just, like, staring at those comments and then back to tomorrow's strip and, uh, you are being very confident about this thing about which you are wrong, like, in my face, and that's an audacity that's kind of admirable, really

KittyKai

Oooooo BOY pop all the popcorn for Reddit xD

Logibear

Some people like the feel of egg on their face I guess

KittyKai

Placing bets on how much they're gonna friggen McLose it when this strip gets published xD

Sajuuk-Khar

「MISERY BUSINESS」 STAND MASTER: Joyce Brown Destructive Power: B Speed: A Range: D Stamina: D Precision: A Developmental Potential: A Stand Ability: Pinpoint teleportation to any loved one, inhuman dexterity, rush attacks — 「WOMANIZER」 STAND MASTER: Joseph Rosenthal Destructive Power: C Speed: D Range: A Stamina: A Precision: E Developmental Potential: B Stand Ability: Powerful sexual kindness and aura; originally used for evil, but has become a tool of good like Hierophant Green or Diver Down — 「THE COUP」 STAND MASTER: Dorothy Keener Destructive Power: A Speed: C Range: E Stamina: A Precision: B Developmental Potential: ∞ Stand Ability: Allows the user to stop time as long as she Blair Witches in the corner consumed with guilt and trauma

Calder Johnson

Like this reminds me of a discussion I had I while back about modern media literacy - namely that modern audiences have become so used to treating every piece of ongoing media (TV, webcomics, etc) as puzzleboxes where the game is to predict the 'big twist' before everyone else, or to endlessly debate and dissect via comment sections, subreddits, etc, that audiences are losing the ability to actually see, understand, and trust what an author/creator is blatantly showing them. And in that conditioned blindness to authorial intent, people can rationalize into existence whatever the fuck headcanon makes the most sense to them according to their internal biases, as opposed to, like, just absorbing and digesting an ongoing story as the author is telling it.

Calder Johnson

That is a defiled land diseased beyond all healing

zee

Powerpuff theme

Jeremy AR

Can i quote this in the main cite when people inevitable say that he stilk isn't doing that?

Mariah

there is another person on the mainsite saying "I hope joe does not let me down and does the right thing (breaking up with joyce) and im like oh buddy....

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Does that make Joe Kakyoin? Have we figured out who Dio would be?

5099 5618 v2.0

Sometimes people are wrong, and sometimes they're the last to realize it.

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Mrs. 5099 is impressed with "Misery Business" and "Womanizer" got an actual LOL, but she's not sure what "The Coup" is named for.

William Lewis

Oh, I am so waiting to see it...

Doki

"Honestly, I don't see what Joe is saying as an inherent negative or as something that's a hit to himself. He literally can't be Dorothy for Joyce, and he knows how important she is to her. To me, he's acknowledging that Dorothy has been building a solid foundation of love and trust with Joyce for quite some time now, and he knows that she provides Joyce a unique and wonderful experience that only Joyce's Dorothy can provide." Yeah, what Eli Sheep said. This is more how I'm interpreting it, as a poly person myself? I CAN'T be my other partners for my partners, and that's sometimes a little sad but also fine (that grammar might be confusing but hopefully everyone understands what I'm saying here haha).

Doki

Yeah, what Em said. Liking or not liking a ship is whatever, fiction is entertainment and we all have our own tastes! But polyamory is still SO incredibly rare in both media and real life that I'm not sure I trust that all of the concerns people have about this are... fair? Not based on their own monogamous bias? (I wish there was a -phobia/-ist word for polyamory, but alas, there is not.)

Ilana Feldman

There's probably still someone out there insisting joyce is straight

Doki

@Heatth IMO it theoretically could? Buuut obviously there's a lot of assumptions about romance that both Dorothy and Joyce have that could really get in the way even if Joe is coming at this from a clear-headed perspective. (Dorothy's jealousy and hangups on not feeling like she's ever been able to let loose and also only just realizing she's bi, and Joyce's... well, literally every romantic thing she's done and learned this ENTIRE comic LOL.)

C.T. Phipps

Your evil plan is genius, Willis. You set this entire thing up to trap them!

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Wait, it's Mary, right? Mary's Dio, isn't she?

Daniel S

Willis used the word poly themself, but is that what this is? I mean it kinda sounds like letting Joyce have a harem more than an equivalent situation...?

Jay

I actually dont think its harder to write personally but 🤷‍♀️ I'm not the writer and I'm not gonna tell Willis how he should write his story. It's just not a direction im satisfied with because it makes the build up feel like its gotten 0 pay off. Yay the status quo did not change!

Sajuuk-Khar

-Joe probably is in fact the Jobro of this part! Although I’d say he’s more of a Caesar/Hermes hybrid with the occasional touch of Okuyasu than Kakky. -Hahahaha yesssss, but also, INFO: the Coup is a long-standing hip-hop project of Boots Riley, the guy who made “Sorry To Bother You. A lot of their tracks deal with openly leftist ideals and coming to terms with radicalization—in particular the absolute bop “The Guillotine”—and so I thought for Dorothy now there’s probably no better metaphor unless I straight up call her Stand 「RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE」. -Fuck! Oh no! If Joyce is the Jojo she probably is Dio! BUT DIO’S COOL. D: WAY COOLER THAN HER. I’m sorry, DIO!

5099 5618 v2.0

@Sajuuk-Khar Joe's Caesar??? We have to make sure he stays far away from big stone crosses. The dissonance of him getting crushed by one might cause Joyce to catch fire

Sajuuk-Khar

「WALK THE DINOSAUR」 STAND MASTER: Dina Saruyama Destructive Power: A Speed: A Range: ∅ Stamina: A Precision: ∅ Developmental Potential: D Stand Ability: Dina’s inner Utahraptor comes out, like a cooler and more scientifically accurate 「SCARY MONSTERS」 from Part 7. — 「RASPBERRY SWIRL」 STAND MASTER: Rebecca McIntyre Destructive Power: C Speed: A Range: B Stamina: A Precision: B Developmental Potential: C Stand Ability: 20m radius Lesbian Garnet Splash — 「FINE ART」 STAND MASTER: Amazi-Girl Justice O’Malley Destructive Power: A Speed: A Range: D Stamina: A Precision: D Developmental Potential: B Stand Ability: Irish fury, the power to take out a platoon if riot cops in full gear — 「JAGGED LITTLE PILL」 STAND MASTER: Ruth Lessick Destructive Power: ∞ Speed: A Range: ∅ Stamina: ∅ Precision: A Developmental Potential: D Stand Ability: Removes and destroys your femurs

David M Willis

yes, this is absolutely one of several ways people can be poly