Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

What comes next...

  • The Moment of Truth - Blythe/Emerson's story (from The Whole Truth) 109
  • Long Story Short - Savannah/Marisa's story (from In the Long Run) 286
  • Against All Odds - Madelyn's story (Sutton and Charlotte's older daughter) 428
  • One Fine Day - 1960s story 54
  • Riley/Gianna AU 173
  • Hannah/Caroline AU 231
  • 2026-07-24
  • 1281 votes
{'title': 'What comes next...', 'choices': [{'text': "The Moment of Truth - Blythe/Emerson's story (from The Whole Truth)", 'votes': 109}, {'text': "Long Story Short - Savannah/Marisa's story (from In the Long Run)", 'votes': 286}, {'text': "Against All Odds - Madelyn's story (Sutton and Charlotte's older daughter)", 'votes': 428}, {'text': 'One Fine Day - 1960s story', 'votes': 54}, {'text': 'Riley/Gianna AU', 'votes': 173}, {'text': 'Hannah/Caroline AU', 'votes': 231}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 7, 24, 22, 8, 23, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1281}

Content

First, an update on The B Side - I mentioned it on the community chat the other day, but with the promotion having just really started for my trad pub book, my plan for The B Side is delayed. I'd planned to drop it as a release this week, and no longer can do that. I believe I should be able to in August, and if not, I'll release parts of it on here and then publish it sometime next year.

I will make a post here when I know, so you will know.

Second, I Knew You Were Trouble and The Game Changer are both nearing the end of their stories. Both are going to last throughout the remainder of 2026 for sure, but will be ending in 2027. So, I want to get an idea for what stories and characters we will be jumping into next.

An idea of what the stories entail -

The Moment of Truth - Blythe Kincaid and Emerson Merriweather from The Whole Truth - includes sharing a home, starting over in the wake of grief, exploring your sexuality, finding that someone who means everything to you already could - somehow - mean even more.

Long Story Short - As seen in ItLR, Marisa might have a little bit of a crush on Savannah Vandenberg. That's lasted for... a casual/chill 10+ years. Where is that sort of thing supposed to go, anyway? Except. Now Savannah is not married. And an 8 year age gap doesn't feel impossible when you're in your 30s.

Against All Odds - Madelyn Thompson has had to have it all figured out, at least as far as the public eye is concerned, since her early teen years, when her mother became the president. And, for the most part, she does have her shit together. In her humble opinion, having an enemy in Lydia Ward - the daughter of her mother's political rival in her last presidential campaign - is just the natural way of things. And... whatever might happen behind closed doors with Lydia is no one's business (it's not even something she will think about in the sane part of her mind)

One Fine Day - set in the backdrop of the 1960's. Alison Nowak is... making do, content with her life. Having dropped out of the final stretch of obtaining her journalism degree several years ago, she's not unhappy working as a secretary by day, spending her nights socializing regularly with her book club - a small, comfortable group of other like-minded women. But that's before she meets Victoria Keeton. Sharp-witted, confident, and enigmatic, Victoria works with Allie's boss, not only shaking up the status-quo at work, but completely up-ending her so-called contentedness.

You'll see that Hannah/Caroline au and the Riley/Gianna au don't have specifications - I have multiple ideas for both couples, so if either of them win and I go in that direction, there will be another poll in the future to decide which direction we'll go in

*please keep in mind that on a poll like this (ie not a single chapter/poll of the month poll, but one that I'll be writing a continuous story for, for at least a year or two), I do want to know what the vibe is and there's a good chance the winner will be the story I write next - but, it might not be (hey, I Knew You Were Trouble didn't win their poll back in the day, but I'd say it worked out!)

Whatever story is chosen will start to be posted in the beginning of 2027!

Also, this is all separate from The Iceberg Principle

Comments

Chance

I’m going to vote for Hannah and Caroline but my god I’m dying for Marisa and Savannah 😭😭😭

sarrah

Oh god it’s hard 😭😭😭

cammich

Your ideas are gorgeous and whichever one of these options win, we all win. Thank you for giving us the gift of your talent. That said, I would simply ADORE a period piece so One Fine Day has my vote.

Mtc

Omg. I honestly can’t vote 🤧 all sound incredible. How the f* do we choose

viviana

will you be choosing the top two of this poll since two stories will be ending?

Claire

Same here! I’d love another ITLR story but just can’t resist seeing H&C fall for each other again🥺

Shawna

Such great choices. I can’t help but say though, I know there was some talk about a full length Down to a Science story. If that ever becomes an option, it will be my vote every time! I feel like we never get enough Ellie and Mia. Their novella is too short! (Especially because I would also love the idea of a DTAS AU… because their story is way shorter, I feel like they need more spotlight to be in the running. Just think, high school Ellie and high school Mia and how they could have really needed each other back then)

Dianna Norman

This was so hard, I wanted to vote for three different stories. However, Caroline and Hannah are my true loves so I have to vote for them.

Jackie

Was not expecting this hard of a quiz on a Sunday afternoon 😅

reeg ✌️

choosing between the moment of truth and against all odds was very hard 😮‍💨

Quilt

Whatever happened to the Caroline/hannah au that won the poll from like over a year ago 🤔

Haley Cass

Unclear! I'm leaving myself a back door there, so it could be the top two options here, or it could be the top one and a random story I decide I want to write lol

viviana

makes sense, ty for the answer!

Gabi

Just a general “YES” to all. Though (and yess I recognize I’ll get flack for this! Totally fair) the Charlotte/Sutton world has so much coverage I gotta spread the love around. There are so many couples to explore in the HCLU and it just keeps growing 🥹.

Cleo M

I am preparing emotionally for In The Long Run to once again get dogwalked in a poll

Júllya

Everything sounds incredible, but I’ve been dying for Madelyn’s story ever since I found out it was going to be written.

Iris A.

Pulled every which way, Gianna my favorite character, Hannah Caroline my favorite couple, and Madelyn with that great premise and the continuation of the next generation’s turn (ultimately the deciding factor for me)

monika bjelcic

Haley would it be possible that there is ranked voting? Because as a split like this it can be misleading. Plus some people also don't know what are the AUs you also gave as the option which can affect that vote too.

p

Bro I wish I could rig this poll cause why are my top picks the least popular 💀 I need The Moment of Truth and OtSP AU !!

Lucie

Haley can you by chance let us know if Blythe has time to have a baby before the tragic passing of her husband? I felt like that could happen, but I wasn’t sure how far in the future that story would take place! I love a kid fic so it does impact my answer 😊

Liv 🧡

All sound amazing but I’ve been obsessed with Savannah since we met her! Praying this story wins 🙌

Ysialis

I’m dying to know something or everything about Marisa and Savannah. Although I do love everything Haley writes, so win-win every time. I hope we get to had a little or big story of Daniele and Norah ❤️

GS

I’ve been thinking about Madelyn’s story ever since I knew it was a future option but also am soo curious about how Blythe and Emerson got down and I can’t choose!!

Hannah Yaara

im not voting for one fine day, but i am very interested in seeing what you have for it, so consider this a vote for it being a novel in the near future

Haley Cass

I would give anything for patreon to allow for ranked voting, and I have some issues with third-party websites that I found. BUT i will be reading through every comment, and do take them into consideration (like not including C/S on general monthly polls sometimes because they always win, and I see that feedback in comments) - so feel free to comment your thoughts/preferences!

Haley Cass

you'll probably be very happy with Blythe's story, then!

monika bjelcic

Please please please continue Hannah and Caroline AU that you wrote from inspiration of a bad dream. That chapter was amazing and I would LOVE more.

Haley Cass

I'm actually very impressed that Long Story Short is hanging in the top choices right now!

Thea Krebs

Lol in a similar boat. I went "Oh the Savannah/Marisa story! Probably voting for tha- dammit I have to see whats going on with Madelyn." I'm still working through the patreon stories but I think 'The End' from the Those Who Wait bonus content is the furthest we've seen in the timeline so far and I'm interested in seeing if the events mentioned about Madelyn there tie into this story at all.

Cat H.

The blurb for One Fine Day is *really* compelling. I hope you will consider writing it, Haley. (eventually?)

Haley Cass

It's one of my favorite ideas to return to and play around in their outline. I've had their outline going for like 4 years at this point lol so it WILL be written at some point!

Haley Cass

even if they don't win, there's a VERY good chance I'll go back and write some more for that. Even if it's not always consistent/monthly - I really love that story, too :)

MK

I neeeeeeed to know how Marisa and savannah got together!!! Please Haley Cass. 🙏🏼 😄

Lisa Tillery

I need Hannah and Caroline in every universe.

Gabby

Could we do a spin the wheel 😂

Araz

I chose Marisa/Savannah (currently #2 in the poll) as I'd like to see stuff outside of the Charlotte/Sutton's world. Love them, but they get a lot of air time 😅 But I'd have actually picked One Fine Day, as a period piece with all the angst of that time would be incredible

Rachel

All of these will be amazing and I look forward to each, but Marisa and Savannah are probably the couple I’ve been interested in the longest — ever since I read the book and before I even knew about the Patreon — so it’s gotta be them for me!

Erica H.

Very invested the Whole Truth world. I didn’t expect to love them so quickly, but here I am ❤️❤️❤️

Vanessa

Super hard Haley! These all look wonderful. I thought Madelyn was a sure thing(!) and I’m keen for her story but IF I HAVE to pick one - I want to go back to Faircombe. Also to add - as much as I love H/C, they do get pretty good coverage imo. Also to add (again) - I also love the bonus scenes as they give us glimpses of all couples and less angst than the monthly drops so can I vote for keeping those too!!

sandrakb

^ this!! Dying for a Caroline&Hannah AU!

Haley Cass

thank you!!! I have a very deep love for Victoria and Alison, and will be writing it, at some point. Their outline is over 50 pages long with how often I've gone back to it over the years lol

a

I refuse to be denied Savannah and Marisa any longer

Cat H.

Hooray! I honestly know we will all enjoy it whenever you decide to give it to us. Loyalties to existing characters drawing us, the loyal readers, into some sort of almost!obligatory voting hierarchy creating a curve that doesn’t quite always align with author inspiration.

Grace

Madelyn has my vote! I love that you’re getting into the second generation! Like with the game plan, it’s great to see the ‘second generation’ and how their parent’s decisions and love impacts them.

Açucena

I'm voting for Madelyn's story, but I'd honestly give anything for a Blythe and Emerson story too 😭

sandrakb (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-14 21:00 Super unpopular opinion 🫣🫣: I think I’ve reached Charlotte & Sutton political story plot fatigue. Needing something outside of that dynamic (even their offspring) and cozy Faircombe sounds refreshing — or the always cozy lovers Caroline & Hannah
2026-07-26 22:17

Ayreal Harris

I want Savannah and Marisa so bad…. Love C/S au’s but guys we have sooo much content of them already, we gotta spread the love

Haley Cass

true - which is why I now make my comment like I did at the end lol. I'll do my best to dedicate myself to the poll winner, but I can't promise I'll have the motivation for it

Haley Cass

For the record, all of these stories are sure things! I'm just determining the order of operations :)

Alex L

I’ve been dying for Savannahs story

Vicky Church

Picked Madelyn, but would also love to see Marisa and Savannah's story too!

Sheila

COMPLETELY agree. I do love ALL things Sutton and Charlotte, but Marissa and Savannah needs to happen! Please!!! :-) lol But truly…whatever Haley writes is going to suck me in. Bahahaha ❤️

Ioanna

Agreed! I’d love to see some of these other worlds built out!

Sky

Nooo, I really love the TWW multiverse, but I think we've had enough of it for a while. There are so many other couples that deserve to have their stories expanded, like Savannah and Marisa (they've been waiting for so long 😭), Gianna and Riley, Hannah and Caroline or even a story that's completely disconnected from everything we know so far, like One Fine Day.

Sky

Though it breaks my heart to choose, I voted for Savannah and Marisa because we have so little ItLR content, and I think they're the couple that's been waiting the longest to have their story told. But I really wanted Hannah and Caroline or Riley and Gianna AUs too.

Dionna

Good news…these all sound amazing and I will devour whatever you write!

JJ

This was such a hard decision!

Gabriella

Will always vote for Gianna/Riley (and I did), but my GOD am I kicking my feet at the Blythe and Emerson reveal🥰🥰

Heather

Im conflicted. Im really curious about the Blythe/Emerson story but my heart belongs to the Thompsons!

Lisa

It’s literally so hard to just pick one of these! Picking against all odds but would love a Riley/gianna or Hannah/caroline AU at some point!

Emma

I had to vote for marissa/savannah on principle because i have wanted that since i first read about them, but GAHD HALEY! Could you do me a favour and perform mitosis? Have 6 of you each work on one of these???

Cate F.

This 🥹🥹🥹 I can’t seem to move on from them 🥹🥹🥹

heidstuff

Please make Savannah and Marisa a reality 🙏🏻 It's time for a revisit to Faircombe!

Jess

I know the Madelyn story will win but hopefully we get Marisa and Savannah too! Justice for in the long run 😂

Betts

I see Caroline/Hannah I vote Caroline/Hannah

Araz

Will we see a continuation of Rose's POV, Knowing The Score?

E

One Fine Day sounds so great! I wish it were getting more votes!

Ayreal Harris

Pretty please consider top 2 🤞🏾🤞🏾😭

Meghan

Would be very happy with either Blythe and Emerson or Savannah and Marisa. I need a tiny break from C/S (please don’t hate me!)

Lily

There’s just too many good options!! I’m in my feels about Emerson/Blythe since my reread of TWT, but I’d love some insight into Madelyn and her life as S/C’s kid. BUT ALSO I wanna see Savannah/Marisa’s story cause the prospect of that also got me hooked in ITLR

Heather

Which one is least likely to make Katherine Spencer disappointed again?? 😭😭😭

Robert Hedley

As someone who loves Caroline/Hannah and hasn't yet read TWW, I'm voting for Madelyb's story because it sounds the most interesting to me. But whatever series come next I know I'll love them

SJ

I can’t imagine not having Abbie and Rose and Autumn and Maya next year

emily

Ohhh this one was hard. I waffled between Savanah/Marisa, Madelyn, and Hannah/caroline au, but all sound great.

Bron

The top three all sound so good but I had to go with Marisa and Savannah. I’ve been waiting so long for their love story and I really want to go back to Faircombe.

Kay

Voted for Savannah/Marisa’s story as I’ve been looking forward to that since I read ITLR, but I’m not disappointed to see Madelyn’s story in the lead. Very much looking forward to getting some insight into Charlotte and Sutton’s parenting through getting to know their children!

charlie

I’m so intrigued about the 1960s story - I did vote for it initially but then changed my vote for madelyn’s story as it had so few other votes but would be so up for reading this in the future

Bailey

One Fine Day sounds so cool as someone that did their thesis on historical fiction, but I’m so sat for Against All Odds.

AO

It’ll be tough to say goodbye to Autumn&Maia 💔 but excited to see what comes next

Blue

I was really hoping to get “The B side” this week😭😭😭😭😭 still I’m excited for what’s coming next

Kat

While I am defs interested to see if Madelyn can claim her mum's title as queen of delulu, I've been looking forward to Marisa and Savannah's story ever since I read ITLR. Such a hard choice!

Lauren

I feel like if we had an idea of what Hannah/ Caroline and Riley/Gianna’s AUs were they’d get more votes

WaitWhat

I need everyone to go reread On The Same Page so that Riley+Gianna can get the attention they deserve!

Chance

I think about that all the time 😭😭😭

Chance

I went back and changed my mind. Marisa and Savannah have been plaguing my mind and I think I need more. Faircombe doesn’t get as much love as it deserves. Plus flustered Marisa is super endearing 🥰

Shani Atar

It’s funny how most of the comments are for Savannah & Marisa lol their story is long overdue and we are desperate for it 😭😭😭😭 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

Kayla B.

Save Colton! Poor guy!

Karo

Must have Savannah and Marisa! The wait has been immense!

Kim

Charlotte and Sutton are so compelling to read because the characters are multi-dimensional and it's interesting to see what they would do in different circumstances. I would read any number of their AUs.

Julianna Duso

I love Sean’s #returntoFaircombe

The Manic Bookworm

Haley, for the riley/Gianna AU, what ideas do you have for the plot? I was thinking it be interesting to either flip their positions where Riley has been pining for Gianna or an enemies to lovers story.

Mostly Amy

As soon as the audio book comes out. I’ll know all about Blythe and Emerson lol

Sue R.

I totally agree….

Hilde Eide

Marissa and Savannah, I would love to read their story☺️

Meg Helen

Marisa and Savannah have just been waiting and waiting and waiting to fall in love....

tinytransfem

I'm very late to this but having just finished The Whole Truth I cannot put into words how much I need The Moment of Truth! I loved Emerson so much in TWT and the moment it was revealed she's gay I was praying you'd be writing her story too!

Risa

Been waiting for the Marissa + Savannah story for a long time. I actually think it would be pretty amusing if they get together while Savannah is in her third trimester or so since being pregnant is less than ideal for a budding romance, I’m sure Haley will appreciate the writing challenge and surpass all expectations ;)

Noname Empty

omg this is so HARD! i've been wanting marisa and savannah since i read ITLR but Against All Odds and The Moment of Truth both sound SO interesting. what happened to blythe's fiance?!?

thisrogue

I'm new t this Patreon, but after binge-reading all of Haley's published books there was nowhere else to run... This post got me really excited for the future!! It's wild how every single one of these pairings in the poll is one I want to read about.

tt

When will the moment of truth come out ? Im really interested in those 2 and that storyline!🥰😍