Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The above playlist is 1/4 of THE TREE, one of the two World Cups Of Christmas.


Christmas, like no other moment, exposes the geology of pop: The Tree consists of brackets laid down as generational strata, from the early festive canon of the 40s and 50s to the holiday hits of the 2010s.

The earliest layer - “White Christmas”, “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”, “The Christmas Song”, and others - is both the most familiar and the strangest. It’s likely that nobody voting in these polls remembers when Meet Me In St Louis was first in movie theatres, and “Have Yourself...” (the oldest record here) was a new idea in the world. And the songs themselves feel pre-aged, wartime or post-war remembrances of an ideal the singers hope haven’t been lost.

These are pop’s equivalent of the shark or the crocodile - survivors of an earlier evolutionary order, who have maintained a seasonal niche long after almost all the rest of pre-Elvis pop (and much of post-Elvis pop) has died off. Modern artists doing music in a similar style to this are doing it as a pastiche of this. And it quickly becomes a pastiche of itself - Andy Williams and Burl Ives’ tracks here take the early formula of “things that happen at Christmas” and drain it of all its more haunting or hopeful elements, creating a parade of brash cheerfulness.

Everything since, though, is reacting to these early songs - paying them tribute, subverting or inverting them, or modernising them. (It’s not until we get to The Stocking that we reach back before the 40s)

There’s one big missing ingredient from the proto-canon, and that’s romance (or heartbreak), something the 50s and 60s Christmas songs quickly put right. Eartha Kitt’s “Santa Baby” is a delicious rebuke to the wholesome visions of the 40s, an atom age Christmas song asking “what’s in it for me?”. Ella’s “Christmas Island” is flirtatiously silly; Elvis’ “Blue Christmas” plays the King’s brooding sultriness tongue half in cheek, but is no less alive for that.

The rock’n’roll era is the first to ask the question every pop age has since - how can we make our new music say something about Christmas? I’m glad we have The Drifters’ magnificent doo-wop “White Christmas” here even if we don’t have Bing’s - a radical claim-staking to the ultimate Christmas song which keeps its joys intact.

The Drifters and Darlene Love are the pivot in this section of the poll - “Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)” commits to the emotion “Blue Christmas” keeps a mistletoe twig away, and it’s the soul men and women who make the best Christmas music of the mid-to-late 60s, a pudding of sex (Clarence Carter) and sentiment (Stevie Wonder) flambeed in politics thanks to James Brown’s astonishing Christmas funk tracks.

What’s true of this whole phase, though, is that Christmas music is a subset of American music, a canon born from the stress of war and separation, and mirroring the 50s consumer boom and the 60s civil rights era. But then, in one of pop’s weird historical coincidences, American Christmas music loses a lot of its force just as the UK works out what it wants to do with it….

Files

Previews only

THE TREE Day 1

We and our partners use cookies to personalize your experience, to show you ads based on your interests, and for measurement and analytics purposes. By using our website and our services, you agree to our use of cookies as described in our Cookie Policy.