2. Lift A Glass And Don't Look Down (Patreon)
Content
At some point around 1980 or 1981 the BBC used a snatch of music on its Christmas idents that bewitched me - a long melodic phrase that seemed full of wonder and the promise of school holidays, sugared almonds, decorating our starkly artificial but beloved tree…
The melody is older - it dates from the 30s - but years later I found out who had recorded the snatch of music, and when, and I was deeply surprised. The recording was younger than me - the repeated Prokofiev borrowing in Greg Lake’s “I Believe In Father Christmas”. What had seemed timeless and full of mystery was just a pop single.
This is one of the curious properties of Christmas songs. Because we hear them when we are little, often as part of a whole concatenation of minor ritual, they feel like they’ve always been there. But at the same time, new Christmas songs are released, some becoming parts of the ritual themselves. A question of legitimacy arises: which songs are part of the fabric of your season, which belong to some other Christmas?
I’m a British man in his 40s. This bracket contains the heart of my Christmasses - the bloom of festive songs from 1973, the year I was born, and plenty of examples from the decade or so of vaguely competitive merriment they kicked off.
Why the UK and why the early 70s? Slade, Wizzard and (absent in its original) Elton all released their Christmas bangers independently in 1973, which doesn’t feel like a coincidence, and surely isn’t one. Go back to 1971 and there are no Christmas songs in the Top 40 at the end of December. But check 1972 and we find our patient zero - “Happy Xmas (War Is Over)”, Lennon and Ono’s “spoonful of sugar” ploy for getting an anti-war message into the charts. Sonically there’s no direct line between John, Yoko, Roy and Noddy, but the song was a massive hit, proving the existence of a market for modern Christmas material by big names.
If that was the instigating factor, the actual shape the Christmas song boom took was down ro TV - colour TV had transformed British pop, giving bands a reason to dress up and look after the visual side of their act, and it’s no surprise that the big glam rock acts who’d made the most of that potential were the first to dive into Christmas.
The astonishing success of the resulting hits - EMI had to draft in its French pressing plant to meet demand for Slade - set off an era where doing a Christmas song became a respectable (and lucrative) challenge for British musicians. In Christmas 1985, the Now That’s What I Call Music series released its first Christmas LP: only two of its 18 tracks predate the 1970s, and only 3 weren’t by UK acts.
One of the 18 was Greg Lake. He’d written “I Believe…” as a protest against the commercialisation of Christmas, and found his song settling firmly into the season’s profitable B-List, where it more or less remains.
A lot of today’s bracket takes place in the world of Now - The Christmas LP. But not all. American musicians were still releasing Christmas records, but in the far more stratified world of US radio, more of it was aimed specifically at MOR or childrens’ audiences. That’s not a bad thing - John Denver’s own country Christmas single is an oddity, but his team-up with the Muppets is a joyfully wholesome bit of 70s fun. The strangest inclusion here might be Joni Mitchell’s fantastic “River”, which is barely a Christmas song (it just happens at Christmas) but isn’t here out of perversity - its sparse, sad, beauty has become a seasonal song by accretion over the years.
One reason “River” has come to fit is the continued rise of alternative Christmas songs. The a-word here isn’t necessarily a marker of popularity, more of worldview - these are songs which explore the lonely, difficult, or double-edged aspects of Christmas, in a subtly different way from heartbreak Christmas songs. Those tend to assume Christmas would be just fine if only your baby came back. Alternative Christmas songs often see the lonesomeness in Christmas itself.
The Kinks’ acidic “Father Christmas” is an early example. Greg Lake flirts with it. But the most striking example here is The Waitresses’ “Christmas Wrapping”, in which the form (higgledy-piggledy rap) matches the content (the guilty stress of an exhausting Christmas) perfectly. Released in 1982, “Christmas Wrapping” doesn’t show up on a mainstream Christmas compilation CD until 1993, by which point the appeal of an alternative take on Christmas had been proved in the most emphatic way possible...
Files
Previews only