4. No Place For The Old (Patreon)
Content
It’s odd to say, given that the most successful modern Christmas song of all comes smack in mid-decade, but the late 80s and 90s were a weird time for Christmas pop music - one of its lowest tides, with only a smattering of additions to the by-now established Christmas canon.
I don’t know much about American Christmas music at this point, but in the UK it’s easy to see what had done the damage. The Christmas glut of the 70s and early 80s was unsustainable, but nobody told the biz. The peak of 1984 - with Band Aid joined by Wham! (the highest-selling No.2 ever) - was followed by the horror of 1989 - when Band Aid II vied with Jive Bunny’s Christmas megamix “Let’s Party”. The year before, the leathery hands of Cliff Richard seized back the Christmas number one for baby Jesus, with “Mistletoe And Wine”, whose title promised fun but whose chorus offered “Children singing Christian rhymes”.
Of these songs, only Wham! feature on this playlist, which cherry-picks the era and reveals it as one of a steady expansion of the Christmas remit. The link between Christmas music and charity forged by Band Aid was picked up by the A Very Special Christmas series, raising money for the then ‘Special Olympics’. It shows up here with Run DMC’s “Christmas In Hollis” (donated rather than created for the comp) and The Pretenders’ weighty tilt at “Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas”. Amy Grant, meanwhile, offers a purer take on a religious Christmas pop song than Sir Cliff’s awkward hybrids.
This is also an era of songs which flirt with being Christmas records but don’t entirely commit - East 17 and the Spice Girls aren’t included, but Freiheit’s Beatley “Keeping The Dream Alive” is. Roxette’s “It Must Have Been Love” and They Might Be Giants’ “Santa’s Beard” take place at Christmas but don’t really depend on it.
More than anything, it’s a time for records which take a slightly oblique angle on Christmas, trying to find something new to do with it. Chris Rea and Saint Etienne look at Christmas as a time for heading home and seeing old friends. Fountains Of Wayne goof around. Low feel Christmassy on the road. Paul Kelly writes the great Australian Christmas song. Eels, Flaming Lips and (later on) Julian Casablancas write exactly the kind of Christmas-adjacent records you’d expect from them. All of them exist in the shadow of The Pogues and Kirsty MacColl, whose “Fairytale Of New York” was the ultimate idiosyncratic Christmas song before it became a culture war hostage.
Some of these records join Fairytale as perennials - others fade from view. The bracket includes the other great survivors of this era - Shakin’ Stevens generic but jolly “Merry Christmas Everyone”, Wham!’s soft-focus “Last Christmas” (perhaps the ultimate ‘set at Christmas’ tune), and Springsteen’s raucous Spector tribute.
It’s Bruce who points the way most clearly to Mariah Carey. There are no great Britpop Christmas records, because there was no 60s UK Christmas tradition for them to pilfer from. But there was a US Christmas tradition, and “All I Want For Christmas Is You” carries out the same impulses as Britpop vastly more successfully - what if then, but now?
By the end of the 90s, though, it wasn’t at all clear that “All I Want For Christmas Is You” was anything more than a glorious piece of tribute, a full stop on the age of the Christmas song rather than its seed of revival. Things would get a lot stranger first.
Files
Previews only