A Salvage Year (Patreon)
Content
(On The Possibility Of Lists In Capitalist Ruins)
1.
This strange year put every relationship to the test, and that included relationships with art and music. Some people have reported that music was more important to them than ever, others felt cut off, with music’s link to physicality and community suddenly severed. For many, I think, 2020’s pervasive sense of dislocation meant comfort listening became important - rediscovering old favourites, with emergent communities like Tim Burgess’ Twitter Listening Parties* bringing nightly relief and connection.
All the while though, people kept making music, oceans of it, and people who enjoy thinking and writing about music tried to make sense of that. The final weeks of 2020 have seen the usual list-making and summarising. Which feels, honestly, stranger than ever, and not entirely because of the pandemic.
I’ve felt like there’s been a cargo-cult aspect to year-end round-ups for a while now - going through the rituals of the monoculture, ushering new records into the canon, building a narrative, casking a year and rolling it into the cellar of history, all half in the hope that something like the old ways will return. The hollowed-out, hibernatory lives some of us have been leading in 2020 make that need for normalcy more poignant, but it isn’t new.
For me, the weirdness of 2020 has thrown into relief how inadequate these old critical structures are for describing music in an age of unprecedented access. It’s been 20 years since Napster, and writers are still floundering for ways to deal with the biggest change in ways of listening since radio. People rightly criticised the initial “global jukebox” optimism, but what’s replaced it? There’s been excellent work done on the iniquitous economics of streaming, but it’s tended to become entwined with a bleak take on 21st century listening and taste. This take is one of the oldest stories in the critical book - one of vanishing authenticity (scenes, stores, intense listening, the commitment of ownership) pitted against homogenising modernity (music consumed in passive obedience to “the algorithm” and made to fit its hidden rules).
My problem with this perspective isn’t just that it’s completely useless as a way of describing my experience. It also does something a lot of critiques of tech companies do. To add urgency to justified criticisms of business practices, goals, or dangerous policies, the critic also paints ordinary users as highly manipulable dupes. There’s no need to do this - for instance, a critique of online advertising based on its motives (selling stuff) and methods (misleading people, abusing personal data, gobbling visual real estate) can be valid without having to inflate its actual effectiveness by assuming people will act as the advertiser wants.
Especially as how people do act is often more interesting. The Spotify algorithm, for instance, is a set of dynamic rules which determines the information you’re shown when you explore the app. It doesn’t decide what you do with that information - eg, what you listen to - though it makes some options a lot more accessible than others.
So the concept of “the algorithm” as a gatekeeper or main driver of what people listen to on Spotify is simplistic. The algorithm’s role is way more like a GM (Game Master) in a tabletop Role-Playing Game, like Dungeons And Dragons. (Lists And Listeners, perhaps)
The algorithm-as-GM’s job is to create the environment in which you act, and then determine the results of those actions. The ways in which it’s nothing like a GM are important - it’s not accountable, for instance - but the metaphor gets at something about people’s relationship with algorithms. The first thing you learn about RPGs is that they’re a collaboration between the players and the GM. And your experience of any social platform, Spotify included, is the result of a collaboration between you and the algorithm.
It’s not a collaboration you invited, and it’s not one that always leads to a positive experience (though I think Spotify is a far better GM than, say, Twitter!). But it changes the conception of the algorithm from a kind of mysterious astrological force that drives actions to a thing you’re in constant, if uneasy, negotiation with.
Spotify’s own ways of talking about music play this negotiation down. With their highly-popular Spotify Wrapped feature, and other more gimmicky bits of content, they present you as the one with every bit of the agency. Their tone of voice is breezy and peppy, a mere collector of data whose pleasure it is to reflect your unique taste. Except Spotify’s own high-level translation of a year to a playlist and a handful of sharable stats is as poor an aggregator in its way as the year-end lists and their annual attempt to carve a Rushmore from sand. Spotify can tell you what you listened to, but not why, or who helped you find it, or what importance you might have attached to it. The pleasure of its summaries is at least partly in their non-recognition - my track of the year was that? New ways of seeing the year, and its experiences, are still required.
2.
The image I’ve found most useful for understanding how I personally use Spotify is one of foraging. The app is an immense forest of music, in which you are a single woodsman. On a day’s listening you might take the broadly trodden paths, or you might strike off into the forest’s depths, in search of something unknown, growing among the roots and mulch. Or you might return to the things you found on previous explorations, which might lead (via chainings of “Appears On” or “Similar To”) to new paths into the always-growing wilderness.
The image isn’t quite mine. In the grand tradition of the British music critic, I found it in a book of theory, half understood it, and lifted it. The book is The Mushroom At The End Of The World, by the anthropologist Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, though what attracted me to it was its subtitle: On The Possibility Of Life In Capitalist Ruins.
Mushroom is a book set partly in physical forests - the human-planted pine woods that remain after resource exploitation of older-growth ecosystems. In these woods grow matsutake mushrooms, a particular delicacy which has proved impossible to domesticate, and is farmed by individual foragers, who roam the woods before coming together to sell their finds to mushroom brokers in highly febrile, semi-informal marketplaces, at the beginning of a supply chain which leads to high-end Tokyo or Bay Area restaurants.
Tsing is interested in two things: the emergent ecologies of these human-altered landscapes, and the precarious ways of working and living developed by the foragers. The locations and quality of the mushrooms are inconsistent, and demand and prices in continuous flux, so the work is done alone, a mix of instinct, experience and luck, creating an economic subsystem made up of hundreds of constant individual negotiations with the market, like a fungal prediction of the gig economy.
The ideas of streaming services as capitalist ruins in which emergent behaviour might appear, and listeners as forager-scavengers attuned to their environment appealed to me.** They fitted with the very genuine feeling of wandering that a late night session hopping from artist to artist, track to track can instill. The disorientation you feel, for instance, when you realise you can’t remember the trail you followed to reach a particular artist, whose biography is empty or whose monthly listeners number in the dozens.
There were hunts for new sounds in the physical-media world too, of course, but the metaphor was different. Back then the record hunter was a miner, digging in the crates in search of gems their knowledge allowed them to recognise as worthwhile. This delving had more continuity to it - you knew where to look each visit and what to look for: the question was would you find it?
Foraging on Spotify doesn’t feel like that, at least for me. It’s more of a drift, setting a direction of travel, then following chains until you find something that might be worth the hunt. The crate-digger is looking for permanent value, but exploring Spotify means leaning into its expectations of ephemerality, treating a first listen as an only listen (as, statistically, it very likely is) and being alive to the possibility that each of those chance encounters might be meaningful.***
Do these ideas feel more personally important to me at the end of a year which finds me mandated to stay at home, forbidden from real life encounters? Of course. Even music can’t fill every gap, but it remains the best way to try.
All of this was meant to be a brief prologue to a kind of year-end list which is more of a naturalist’s journal, a record of meetings with music whose value I’m not always sure of but which left an impression. Brevity has failed me, so the list will be the next post.
**FOOTNOTE 1: The metaphor falls apart at the point in Tsing’s story at which the mushroom-hunting meets the market. It’s not the listener whose labour is being exploited here, after all - it’s the mushroom-musicians themselves, as there’s no direct mechanism for the fruits of discovery to become part of a marketplace and for musicians to be rewarded. (Bandcamp solves this by putting the marketplace at the centre, but relies heavily on curation for discovery - it lacks the lonesome serendipity of the Spotify hunt.)
*FOOTNOTE 2: As should be pretty obvious if you’ve got this far, the Peoples Pop Twitter polls are an example of this, and of the more general thinking in this piece. To be very pompous about it, they’re an attempt to see whether a mix of quite simple systems - Twitter threads and polls; Spotify playlists - can create collective behaviour which actually helps people discover new music, something these platforms on their own are generally bad at. The results so far have been highly satisfactory.
***FOOTNOTE 3: Another word for this might be “poptimism”.