Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

2008 was a strange year for me. It’s the first year we’ve polled where I was getting paid to have opinions about music, in the form of writing the Poptimist column for Pitchfork every month. A lot of my online friends (and foes) were part of the critical apparatus too, writing or editing across a range of publications - newspapers, monthlies, alt-weeklies, review sites, blogs….

So I decided to name the brackets in this poll after those publications and others. In order of appearance: The Hype Machine. Q Magazine. Idolator. NME. Stylus. Mojo. Popjustice. Blender. The Source. Uncut. Songlines. Stereogum. Decibel. Mixmag. The Wire. Pitchfork.

(As we go through them it’ll become apparent how closely, or not, the content matches what these places actually wrote about.)

There’s two reasons for doing this. The first - this fertile soil for music writing has become a dust bowl. All the websites I was dissing, some are here and some are missing in the 2020s. The late 00s were a moment when the spaces between amateur and professional, web and print, upstarts and trusted names, were in flux. It was a vibrant time to be writing and thinking about music, and if the factors that ended it - streaming, YouTube, Facebook, the financial crisis - were all already present, few people were joining those dots.

The second reason - this array of media, or the online parts of it at least, was approaching the peak of its critical influence in 2008. Blog and website favourites might not have been making a huge impact on the charts yet but the sites had shifted critical priorities.

Take, for instance, the impact of Pitchfork on the venerable Pazz And Jop critical round-up. In 2001, the most recent pre-2008 year we’ve polled, only one of Pitchfork’s Top 5 albums of the year made it into the P&J Top 20 (The Avalanches) - to find even a second Pitchfork favourite you had to go all the way down to The Microphones at =172nd.

In 2008 the lowest Pazz And Jop placing for a Pitchfork Top 5 album is #23, for Cut Copy, with Portishead, Fleet Foxes, Deerhunter and No Age all finishing even higher. Of those five acts, only Portishead had existed in the 20th Century: all the others had achieved some or most of their fame via exposure on blogs or music websites. And the Pazz And Jop Top 10 also includes Vampire Weekend, TV On The Radio, Santogold, Bon Iver… all new, all darlings of the blogosphere (and of Pitchfork, which ‘broke’ some bands and picked up a few others via smaller sites.)

This rapid installation of a new set of favourites wasn’t associated with a scene or a movement, but with a shift in media alignment. Pitchfork’s increased influence wasn’t just because the site had got better at picking winners (though Fleet Foxes and Vampire Weekend were a lot more listener-friendly than, say, Fennesz). It was because most of the older publications had begun to take their cues from the blogs and sites. NME, Q, Spin… not just all praising the same acts, but the same new acts. And with streaming and social media still in their infancy, there wasn’t much room for counter-narratives to emerge (though there were some, and we’ll get to them).

What this means for these polls is that we’re dealing with both a lot of acts we’ve never looked at before, but also a faintly homogenous ‘feel’ to the year, with a spongy middle of kinda-alternative acts who could be - and have been - spread across multiple brackets. What’s interesting to me is how this stuff all looks now, at a distance. The blog-driven media landscape didn’t really last: has the music it promoted fared any better? We’ll see.

I’m doing my usual previews, but rather than look at each individual bracket (as I did for 2001 and 1980), I’m considering the macro-groupings we’ll be using after the qualifiers - which fall out into quite familiar patterns.

POP: From Gaga to Girl Talk. Big mainstream hits. Pop-as-subgenre. Blog hypes and student dancefloor fillers. “I heard you sold your guitars to buy synthesisers”. Includes the Hype Machine, Stylus, Popjustice and Idolator brackets.

ROCK: And roots and retro and respectability. Includes what used to be the “veterans” category, an unflinching look at post-landfill Britain, and even some token pop, because hey, it’s OK to like that now. Includes the Q, Mojo, NME and Blender brackets.

CLUB: ‘Critical beats’ from the Dirty South to the Niche North of England, via an extremely extended stopover in South America. Hip-hop, bassline, minimal techno, and the legendary global groups which this time include tracks that might actually do well. Includes the Source, Songlines, Mixmag and Wire brackets.

ALTERNATIVE: From bands on the brink of making it big to inveterate scuzzballs and freaks, all noisy, punky, folky, metallic life is here. Includes the Decibel, Uncut, Stereogum and - taking us back to the beginning - Pitchfork brackets.

Comments

Frank Kogan

Astonishing to me that I was <i>very</i> much part of the MusicWrite world you describe - read every P-fork column of yours - yet have little sense of the mags & blogs & sensibilities you're describing. Wonder if you're underestimating the impact (not on the world but on your nominators) of the Greater Tom Ewing Metropolitan Area (Freaky Trigger, the LJ poptimists community, parts of ILM, was Tumblr starting to happen?) as opposed to Popjustice..