Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Pop - at the level of the face on the record sleeve - renews itself constantly. Even so it’s striking how much early work there is in 2008 by people - Gaga, Miley, Katy, Taylor - who would go on to define early-10s pop. You can throw in Rihanna, already a superstar but not at the level she’d reach when the decade turned. The thing that would define this pop generation against the class of ‘98 - its autonomy, or at least its performance of autonomy - isn’t obvious yet. But the cluster of fresh faces makes the pop brackets highly competitive. Especially as the previous tranche of stars - Beyonce, Britney, Girls Aloud - is far from done.

In the 2001 poll, one of the big stories was the commingling of R&B and pop. In 2008, it’s the boundaries between indie and pop (and dance and R&B sometimes) that are blurriest. As well as big-name pop stars, what we’ll also see in these groups are a gaggle of indie acts whose weapon of choice is the hook - mostly the big, whooshy synth hook. M83, Cut Copy, MGMT, Hot Chip and plenty of smaller names are here making pop music which combines a dancefloor-ready push with the kind of diffident, pretty melancholy the Strokes spun into gold. We also take in synthpop revivalism from the likes of Little Boots, La Roux and by-now-veterans Ladytron; cult R&B acts like Cassie and Jazmine Sullivan; blog-friendly Europop from Annie and Alphabeat; and Fever Ray, Santogold and even Portishead at the darker, spikier end of electronic pop. It all adds up to brackets full of pop at one of its most theatrical, bohemian moments.

There are 16 tracks per bracket - here are four highlights from each.

Day 1: Hype Machine

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0IVYe0ps8Zmfxf2DlJfMYJ?si=ff58ca387fa84148 

MGMT - “Time To Pretend”: One of the contenders to win the whole thing - even though (whisper it) it’s a 2007 track. 2008 was the year it became a colossal student, blog, hipster and advert soundtrack smash, though, one of those songs whose chart position belies its cultural clout - well, somewhat. Is it good? It’s got that great wheezy riff, and it does the prematurely world-weary millennial thing as well as anyone has. Which may not be saying too much.

BLACK KIDS - “I’m Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How To Dance With You”: At the time this (annoying but intensely catchy) track became a kind of dire warning of the perils of blog hype - the band were rushed into the spotlight having barely formed, their debut LP was savaged by the sites that lauded their debut single and overnight they were the blogpop Menswe@r. I’m interested to see how well this does.

HERCULES AND LOVE AFFAIR - “Blind”: The bracket’s other heavyweight - which sounds, thanks to ANOHNI’s unique vocals and the band’s commitment to a hard, simple dance groove, a thousand times classier and less frantic than almost anything else here. I can’t see it going out early, but I can’t see it dominating either - if I’m wrong, we’ll know very quickly.

DRUMS OF DEATH - “DODFUCKSUPANESCORTTUNE”: One of the few tracks here I didn’t know, and it turns out to be a ramshackle big beat number, the lively, shabby opposite number to “Blind” - Hercules And Drunken Shag. I’m into it.

Day 2: Idolator

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7eHnKqrntqpDIVxsWjNdYY?si=1aa8d10e5ae84d3a 

NE-YO - “Closer”: I showed this bracket to Idolator’s former editor, who pointed out (rightly) there wasn’t enough of the alt music they also covered. But what there is - and something the site was always good on compared to some other pop outlets - is a lot of Black pop. It’s easy to forget R&B smoothie Ne-Yo, whose elegant Year Of The Gentleman is one of 2008’s best LPs, but I hope one of his two tracks goes deep into the poll.

DANITY KANE - “Bad Girl”: Pop deep-divers on certain internet fora loved Danity Kane, whose “Bad Girl” is one of the (sadly) few pop tracks of 2008 to pick up the gauntlet of Britney’s mecha-pop masterpiece Blackout. Cascades of robo-harmonies and a Missy Elliott guest spot too!

BEYONCE - “Single Ladies (Put A Ring On It)”: This bracket’s heavyweight, though how well it’ll do is open to question - it’s a more iconic song than it is a great one, in my opinion. (The more obscure Bey track here, “Why Don’t You Love Me?”, is a beast though.) The song’s hammering post-Diwali rhythm is hard to deny, though.

LLOYD - “Girls Around The World”: There’s no real discoveries for me in this bracket but I’d forgotten how great this is - the best of many Lil Wayne guest spots in the poll, as he riffs on Eric B And Rakim’s classic “Paid In Full” verse and acts as madcap wingman to the unflappable Lloyd.

Day 3: Stylus

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/0fchwDWZzcPxNwYwqQ3UoC?si=75aa31c53cf94651 

FEVER RAY - “If I Had A Heart”: I think of Karin Dreijer’s moody, electronic pop in her various guises as quintessential ‘Stylus music’, even though the site had actually closed down by the time Fever Ray’s darkly minimal debut single came out. Voters have given The Knife a chillier reception than I’ve expected, and the same might be true of Fever Ray - I hope not, though: “If I Had A Heart” is as harsh and lovely as any of the Portishead tracks we’ll be judging.

FRIENDLY FIRES - “Paris (Aeroplane Remix)”: One of the year’s great cult hits, the dreamy remix of “Paris” brings out the hope and sadness in the song and then flies into cloudbanks of gorgeously thick, layered electronica. A dark horse to go a long way in, I reckon.

SANTIGOLD - “L.E.S. Artistes”: Possibly the bracket’s biggest gun, and Santigold’s nasal bark is one of the things that’s a powerful madeleine for “2008”. There’s an immediacy to “LES Artistes” which sums up the best things about the year’s alternative pop, and a brittleness and reserve which maybe hints at why these people didn’t become a new establishment.

LATE OF THE PIER - “Focker”: The nearest thing to a “discovery” here (I knew most stuff in these brackets very well), and as with Drums Of Death its the scuzziness that’s enticing. Will likely get swamped by better known tracks but well worth a go.

Day 4: Popjustice

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/5AwSnthdQTG0MEbEonMiLE?si=a4c24921d64f4b75 

ESTELLE ft KANYE WEST - “American Boy”: Topped the polls we ran at the time (on LiveJournal, aww) and surely a heavyweight here - but one with an Achilles Heel in the form of Kanye, who voters seem to delight in giving the bum rush to. If his enjoyably goofy idiot-abroad verse here (“Ribena, I know what you’re drinking”) can’t push him into the last week, nothing can.

GIRLS ALOUD - “Live In The Country”: There are three Girls Aloud tracks in the poll - this album cut is the most obscure but a very pleasant surprise to rediscover: the purest drum’n’bass backing the band ever used with a typically slick pop song on top. I hope it sneaks its way out of a difficult bracket.

KATY PERRY - “I Kissed A Girl”: Katy Perry is one of the big pop names we’ve not seen a lot from in the polls. “Kissed” is one of those tracks which has to be in a 2008 competition but which carries a hell of a lot of baggage too, and its reception will be… interesting. (See also Britney’s “Womanizer” in this bracket - how will the spotlight on Britney’s current struggles impact a post-conservatorship hit?)

LADY GAGA - “Paparazzi”: It feels like Gaga dominated 2009 more than 2008 so it was a slight shock to remember her debut LP was all eligible. “Paparazzi” and “Just Dance” are her picks - I think I agree with whoever said “Poker Face” would have been stronger (maybe even a favourite) but of the two this is the more interesting, the Gaga persona and approach starting to come together and her first strong ballad.

Comments

Arron Wright

Ouch, you weren't kidding about "difficult bracket". I make that: my bonus; the other two tracks I considered; the obvious ante-post bracket favourite; two more Xenomania tracks; PLUS Katy, Rihanna and Britney. Re GA, I'm obviously going to mourn the missing bunny, but I'm glad that one of Out Of Control's few concessions to bonkers-pop is here. I had 'Live In The Country' as a fourth-tier track, and definitely would have picked 'Miss You Bow Wow' as the resident Great Lost Single. However I did a lot of re-listening in Feb while compiling the #FaveArtistTop40 on Twitter and it's definitely grown on me. After all, only their bottom tier is almost uniformly terrible. Thanks as ever; looking forward to re-discovering 2008.