Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chris Cutrone re-evaluates his time as a Marxist pedagogue and wonders what went wrong. He's still reeling from the death of the Millennial left.

Comments

Tom Edwards

nearly finnished bash bash revolution Doug, really enjoying it.

Tom Edwards

Started reading Determinate Being again (The actual text not secondary) with a fairly different perspective now, so fascinating and things are falling into place a bit better for me now. Since I talked to you about it last Doug my perspective has shifted. It seems not as important to me as I made out before, its not essential in terms of spitritually or for socialism or something and at the same time even more worth doing on its own terms. I hope the reading group does start up again one day soon. I watched myself back in a couple of the group videos and Ive changed quite a bit I think, I was pretty grating and bluffing at times. I said the right things on occasion but I didnt even understand what I was saying! I think I know better what the point is now.

Will

Fuck

Will

Sorry, Tom. I thought about it and realized that can be taken in too many different ways. I didn't mean to dig at you though. Just you wait- one day we're gonna take over the workshop.

Tom Edwards

Haha it’s fine, I thought it was funny.

Will

Get to work. The Buddha attained enlightenment at 35

Tom Edwards

That seems pretty late in life

Will

Look it up! I'm at the temple right now.

GWJones

I was reminded of a character in a novel and asked AI for a synopsis ; "In Haruki Murakami’s Kafka on the Shore, the philosophy graduate student working as a sex worker is an unnamed young woman encountered by the truck driver Hoshino. Arranged via a surreal meeting with a pimp avatar of Colonel Sanders, their encounter transcends a typical transaction. Instead, the sex worker engages Hoshino in deep intellectual and existential dialogue, casually discussing abstract concepts like Hegel, epistemology, and the nature of consciousness. This bizarre blend of high philosophy and commercial sex acts as a catalyst for Hoshino’s spiritual awakening, helping him unlock a broader understanding of reality necessary to aid Nakata on his quest."

Steve Roberts

This post from @teo11teo11teo11 in the youtube version needs reading and understanding . Teo here: when I read Marcuse's interview on Adorno's death I immediately thought of Chris and his various "Marxist-Leninist" critics. Marcuse with extreme clarity recognizes that Adorno kept the show running in ways that most "Marxists" of his time couldn't recognize or couldn't help but perceive as anti-Marxism even. Marcuse was a titan of Marxism compared to the army of Third-Worldists and nationalists who claim poor Marx these days. But he also often expressed a frustrating ultra-leftist deviation from orthodox Marxism, and it was very encouraging that despite all that he was able to recognize and speak truth about the peculiar efforts of Adorno to sustain orthodoxy by advancing it critically in regressed conditions. Contra Gillian Rose, I have to say that Adorno, as a proper Rottweiler, resisted his disheartening milieu and kept biting and barking, even with Negative Dialectics and Aesthetic Theory. These books are models still, not desperate explicatory attempts to conform to the demands of the audience. All this is of course linked to Danny and his tragic loss. He was living in the unfortunate conditions you thematize often here in Cutrone Zone. And one cannot but welcome the bad new days. He so often took on the thankless role of bringing the receipts to Chris' pedagogy, because that's what people prefer: Safety of dead data, more than ability to think. In this way he was still a tireless, invaluable student of Chris who was also a fellow traveler in pedagogy. He had to stall the growth of his own thought to help in this manner. But he was in parallel doing his own attempts to form his own thinking, as his writings and contributions which should be published show clearly. To honor Danny's memory, Chris and Platypus will keep biting and barking instead of conforming to the already obsolete fashions of the day.

Steve Roberts

And today, Saturday uk timeline, it has been announced that Greenland and Denmark have agreed to cede all " security" to the umbrella of the USA !! CC wrote /spoke "..approaching the quarter millenium of the American Revolution perhaps the borders of the empire of liberty are set to be revised again" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZY4YFuSCl0

garett hill

I don't know whose making the subtitles, but 1:05:45 made my day!

Mathieu Dube

lol, there's already a split in your front cadre group?!? You truly are like every Troskyist cult since 1971. We used to have a joke in the 90s: 2 Trots enter an elevator on the ground floor, what do you get when they get out on the 3rd floor: 3 tendencies, 1 for each Trot and another one for both of them. Maybe Marxist exegesis doesn't equate good political analysis after all, who would have thought?!?

Michael

Is the campaign a front group? What's this about Marxist exegesis? ?!?11111!

Eddie Valentine

Do you really want to change society? Can you change society? What do you want to change society into? Are you willing to accept the possibility or probability that you will make things worse? These are questions that the expansive realists should be asking.

Eddie Valentine

My second novel is a picaresque satire that poses such questions and puts under the knife the pomposity and downright stupidity of much of the leftwing project.

Will

No. They want to reject theory. Activists want to do go out and do good in the world because they are good earnest people. Unfortunately it is true that most of the time, those whole wield theory use it as a cudgel to boost their own egos. The activists want to reject CC because they think he is that and therefore an obstacle to just doing good in the world.

Steve Roberts

Mathieu Dube, the tone, generalisations , non contextual and obvious lack of knowledge of the full circumstances ooze from your cynical post. I am in no position to appropriately discuss the specifics of the KSP , although i have some knowledge i will not revert to cynical knee jerk judgements to satisfy ones obvious agenda . There really is no pleasing the cynic, if there are no disputes/splits searching for clarity etc then one is accused of been part of a dogmatic cult, the opposite then also applies. And who are the "we" you refer to, what were /are you a part of ?

Steve Roberts

Too much ambiguity there Eddie. What do you consider the "left wing project" to be that makes you consider it pompous and stupid ? Do you consider the main protagonists in Sublation to be part of that pomposity and stupidity, lets narrow it down for ease of reference, Doug and CC. Who are the " you" that are referenced in your initial post ?

Eddie Valentine

It's the DSA, the Democratic Party, the third worldists, and the new Jacobins that are poisonous and they despise the Platypus/Sublation folks i.e., the reasonable ones and I'm not so sure there's any rational element left after that.

Grawlix

Ben says you lose brain plasticity, so you might as well just keel over and give up the ghost. Reality is set in stone. Once a pleb, always a pleb. Accept your lot in life. Don't bother.

Grawlix

I've had 3 kinds of managers who thought this way: 1. Ivy league white guy biz bros who want to repopulate the planet with cookie cutter ivy league biz bros 2. Some insecure asshole who is worried you are better than them 3. Indians who want to hire a bunch of other Indians and get rid of you

Grawlix

4. Womyn who want to hire a bunch of other womyn who ally with PoC and act like allying with random PoC is the same thing as feminism or whatever, then they become shocked when PoC dudes can be "conservative" and lash out extra lashings because they were betrayed by the menz and that's your fault too (even tho the real problem was their original world model was fundamentally flawed because idpol thinking is for basic bitch simpletons)

Tom Edwards

I don’t know if you have to be that intelligent to read it, maybe just perseverance is needed.

Grawlix

I don't get the weird Platypus insistence that people refrain from disliking Capitalism, being dissatisfied with it, etc. Don't focus on the notion that you are being robbed by the people at the top. Constant "We know best" snark that everyone is just rebelling against mommy and daddy, etc. If everyone is supposed to like Capitalism, what would motivate them to adopt Marxism? I just don't understand your argument or position at all.

Grawlix

Additionally, if people aren't supposed to focus on economics or material concerns, how do they know any of the principles actually match reality? And if you aren't focusing on material concerns, what are you supposed to focus on? A bunch of philosophers making claims that can't be verified or substantiated? Doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. Seems more like hiding behind intellectual obscurantism

Grawlix

And one of the things I like about philosophy over literature is in some schools of philosophy they manage to write documents that are, say, 5-25 pages long. When people try to do philosophy that love literature they write these obscenely long and tedious narratives, like fucking Ayn Rand. I am never going to sit down and read a 1,168 page story about some steel mogul. There's no fucking way Ayn Rand needs 1,168 pages to explain Objectivism. I feel the same way about post modernist shit, etc. Cut to the fucking chase lady. Spit it out.

Grawlix

The problem with perseverance is there is no way to know what's actually worth putting effort into until you already have. And at that point, does one start justifying it to themselves via sunk cost fallacy thinking?

Grawlix

I lost all interest in the Matrix once it became transmuted into this trans allegory thing about blabbedy blah I wanna be an anime pretty princess whilst yammering on non stop about JK Rowling's tweets

Tom Edwards

Hmm generally I don’t agree with that, especially in this case though I’m confident. The more I understand about the science of logic the more I find it self evidently true which is the entire point, it’s supposed to be undeniably proven at every step, in other words necessary. I’m like an ant at the bottom of a mountain at this point though but I feel like I have some rudimentary map now.

Grawlix

I was thinking about this more and maybe it's a teacher thing. Maybe if my job was to deal with other peoples dumb-assed kids all day long I'd grasp this

Grawlix

In other words I have my own disgruntled attitude which would match "the kids" almost immediately, but if my job was to actually guide them and deal with all of these annoying issues perhaps I'd fold right away and be like "god damned these dumbass fuckers" maybe i'd instantly fold and rage quit But at the same time I find this confusing because it seems like "Gen X" has some kind of odd "worship 'Gen Z'" thing going on I fundamentally cannot grasp. For me it's like: "yeah of course you love your stupid fucking kids" (not my problem!) I've always hated teenagers and people in their early 20s as long as I can think of as a non parent, by default. To me someone in that age group = know it all cocky dipshit. But these days I'm trying to appreciate the fact in some ways (especially in my industry) I need to figure out how to work with these guys and maybe even rally them a bit. Because I'm no "senior". I'm in the same boat as them. Plus I kinda like "Gen Z" so far based on vague notions I've built up watching some of their videos

Grawlix

I also think "Gen X" is kinda full of shit. I know you assholes were trash talking 20 year olds at some point and now you are doing this fake disingenuous bullshit where you think this new generation is some kind of savior or whatever. Give me a break, man. You're irrationally attached to your own spawn

Grawlix

The Gen X people I've known in my personal life have always had the opposite opinion. They were always like "yeah IDK about this new generation, this seems dire" I can't think of a single time my elder Gen X siblings though people in my specific age bracket were total fuckups

Grawlix

Except on the job where they were total assholes and remind me a lot of sublation / platypus. So I guess its an academic Gen X thing ; )

Grawlix

Except a huge number of gen x people in tech aren't even credentialed and are like making serious bank as software engineers with like english degrees and random shit while gate-keeping endlessly about this shit while Indians kiss ass to those in power and then visciously attack anyone who doesn't have a degree who doesn't have power over them and magically omit attacking the gen x degreeless with power over them and the gen x tech people do some weird liberal idpol crap to justify it all

Steve Roberts

Grawlix, regards the like/dislike capitalism situation. I think you have, perhaps inadvertently, stumbled upon a very important distinction and problem of the " left". The political battle for Socialism/Freedom among the proletarianised in society ( most of us) will not be won by a simplistic " anti capitalism" that is vague, politically unconscious and no basis for building a social force that can overcome the obstacles of going beyond where society is presently, unfree, and indeed the necessity for all of society to do so. Few today, even among many capitalists would defend "capitalism" positively,indeed the disgruntled of its effects are even now the vast majority of society. But despite the antagonisms, the exploitation etc etc etc survival within present society and indeed the level of immiseration that can and must be endured does not transfer to a demand for something else. That is a huge task and it will not be achieved by a shallow anti capitalism, society is in effect already there anyway. No, the task for freedom is what we face as a society , and a left,or we will remain where we are in capitalism, anti it or not. The reality is we exist and have to in capitalism, that is extremely variable as to how billions of us do so on a daily basis all our adult lives. It is perfectly posssible to accept this ( we have little choice) the best we can and at the same time task ourselves with the goal of socialism beyond it, in that situation " anti capitalism" becomes an empty phrase full of emotionalising and moral claims but little else except " state socialism/democratic socialism blah blah blah which have nothing to do with freedom.

Grawlix

Yes but if we're not supposed to dislike capitalism, why would we seek to overcome it? I get that people can simply walk around saying "capitalism sucks" all the time and then nothing actually happens to change it or perhaps your "potential energy" becomes discharged (recuperation), but if you are satisfied with capitalism to begin with, there is no motivation to change anything. And I don't really see a difference between this abstract freedom you guys are talking about and having one's basic needs being met. I mean, you kinda need your basics covered (perhaps a necessary but not sufficient condition) before you can go chasing after anything higher level (Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, etc)

Steve Roberts

You are introducing factors here that are really not particularly clarifying but are unhelpful, they are uncontextual and muddy the waters. " dislike capitalism" " satisfied with capitalism" neither of which considers temporary or indeed relatively permanent precarity for all the proletarianised in society. It also disavows the ability to convince masses of people of the necessity of Socialism etc. It is a form of presentism "..folks will only response to the dislike /satisfied criteria they are situated in .." that "nothing can be done etc.Freedom is abstract in the sense we do not have it, unfreedom is concrete because we live it. It does not mean Freedom it is unachievable As to basics covered, what is the criteria for that ? The level of immiseration that allows basics to be covered can be extremely severe. The task before us is to operate in all conditions good, bad and ugly with the exact same understanding of necessity for all. That is the task.

Grawlix

Looks like the order is hosed on the web again. I had to look at this thread on my phone. I am not sure if you guys have noticed that, but threads get scrambled on the web at least in some browsers on Patreon. But then eventually they will revert. One of the reasons why I brought up so many topics was I was talking about all the various random ass opinions presented in a pretty long video.

Grawlix

Mathieu is my favorite wiley francophone canuck anarchist on here

Grawlix

The idea that capitalism is a necessary step towards developing communism is not the same thing as "and you have to like capitalism" If we were in a feudal or perhaps mercantilist society I could get the trollish baiting but we've had capitalism for quite some time now. Long enough for people to have developed a laundry list of grudges and discontents