Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 747671452.mp4

Downloads

Content

In this parrot room Chris and Doug discuss Adorno and Marcuse and end up evaluating the contemporary Marxist left.

Files

Comments

Anthony Teso

Abstract. This essay challenges Chris Cutrone’s claim that Marxism died in the revolutionary crisis of 1914–1919. It argues that the recurring “crisis of Marxism” is best understood as an obituary genre in which the collapse of parties, doctrines, and political institutions is mistaken for the death of Marx’s critique of political economy. Tracing this genre from Masaryk and the revisionist controversy through Luxemburg, Lenin, Korsch, Althusser, and the Platypus Affiliated Society, the essay shows how successive writers identify Marxism with particular organizational bodies and then treat those bodies’ failures as evidence of theoretical exhaustion. Cutrone radicalizes this pattern by transforming historical defeat into a philosophy of regression and an institutional program of mourning. Drawing on Hal Draper’s account of the micro-sect, the essay interprets Platypus as a retrospective sect that preserves a defeated party-form in miniature. It concludes that Marx’s critique has no institutional biography and therefore no historical death date: the unresolved problem is not Marxism’s demise, but the failure to build durable political mediation between critique and class self-emancipation. https://1drv.ms/w/c/c3598b38f68269be/IQD6xy7wsNR7QY9BuWrbfmkbAZNIq7FkuDGmT5WygFo2nkA?e=BzH8sI

Dave

“Marx’s critique remains what it has always been: neither living nor dead in any biographical sense, but open like an indictment that has never been served.” In your essay you’re saying that Marxism was preserved through the 20th century for the working class by ever-shrinking groups of staunch defenders of Kapital and Marxist states. And this proves that Marxism can’t be killed; or that it’s some kind of vampire, or zombie? That it’s an objective world view? I think the point of Chris’ work is to criticize precisely that proposition. That comes through clearly for me in his essays. This feels one sided Tony - Chris (unlike Rockhill) has The Campaign. He is interested in building up the capacity of intellectuals and the working class. One more thing à la Chris, Chris said in this very episode in which we are commenting that Kapital 1 - 3 was not meant to be a theory of what was or is (as much as we might want it to be). I think that claim is reductive and serves only to help you make your point. It is a theory that is imminent to the working classes’ self conception as working for a fair days pay, as well as their politics being enunciated in the language of political economy. Outside of that movement its usefulness is questionable.

Steve Roberts

While you are here Anthony could i ask why you deleted - by whatever method- my comments to your series you publish on Substack ?

Anthony Teso

Steve, Remind me. What comments?

Steve Roberts

I posted two fairly , what i considered challenging but innocuous comments which disappeared as you apparently reposted your original post, I believe more than once. You want a screenshot as proof, or was it a Substack glitch ?

Dave

Wait. Marcuse = CIA. Adorno = CIA. Marcuse killed Adorno. Doug would Marcuse fan fics be acceptable as €xpansivd Realism?

SuppleMeme

Chess for some people is work.

Eddie Valentine

When Tucker Carlson and Hasan Piker are effectively on the same side, something real rotten is going on.

Grawlix

Now this is the high quality kind of discourse I'm here for. Enough with the crap where they paid off some stock millennial hipster character to throw the match

Grawlix

I'll have to watch this to see what exactly you are referring to, but "don't be a nazi" is never that simple. I mean literally today I had to hear about how communists and fascists are the same thing. "Oh that person is just a moron" you will say. OK, but explain to me how the definition of nazi / fascist isn't always being abused...

Grawlix

Office 365... bold

Otto Caulle

Question. How does someone come to think it is easy to be a nazi unconsciously

C

Is the campaign organizing to help protect American Jews from all this anti semitism they face down all day everyday? Hope so

C

On a more serious note, there of course are lots of Jews experiencing serious discrimination, repression and worse by both state and civil society, the ones protesting Israel and Zionism, which is the actual problem.

Will

You talk about death but I think you forgot the second part of the Platypus slogan: the left is dead......... long live the left. I won't pretend to be knowledgeable enough to debate the thinkers you cite but I think this is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what Platypus is. Your rendering of how Platypus thinks of the death of Marxism is accurate enough and I guess the obituary is a fine enough metaphor, as exaggerated as it may be, but again, you forgot the other side. In Platypus we read about where the lifeblood of Marxism comes from in radical bourgeois thought through to the Frankfurt school and the New Left so that it becomes clear how thin it has become in the present day as shown in the panels. This points to the question: how can it be revived? To be clear, Platypus is an explicitly intellectual organization so it makes no claims to being the thing that will actually do the reviving in the world. It exists to clear ideological obstacles. I suppose this is why Chris Cutrone felt the need to help found the Campaign for a Socialist Party. Did you forget about that too? Sure Marxist theory will always be there floating around in the aether regardless of its organizational form but that's just a truism. The organization is what makes it real and a force in the world.

Grawlix

Who is this question for?

Anthony Teso

You're right that I quoted half the slogan. "The Left is dead! Long live the Left!" is the whole thing, and leaving off the second half made the essay's job easier than it should have been. I'll grant the genealogy point too. Reading from the radical bourgeois tradition through the Frankfurt School and the New Left to see how thin the present has become is the best thing Platypus does. I've said so elsewhere, and I learned from it. And the Campaign for a Socialist Party. No, I didn't forget it, but I didn't deal with it, which in an essay about whether Platypus's position can be tested amounts to the same thing. That's a fair hit. Here is where I still disagree, and the CSP is part of it. Take the second half of the slogan seriously. "Long live the Left" is a claim that the Left can live again, so it ought to come with some idea of what that would look like when it happened. What would count? When I read Cutrone, every existing tendency turns out to be downstream of the death. DSA, the Trotskyists, the anarchists, and the unions all get measured against 1919, and all come up short in ways that are said to confirm the death. I don't see what could come up and not be read that way. If nothing could, then "long live" doesn't name a revival. It names a hope that has been placed out of reach of any evidence. That was the argument of the essay, and quoting the full slogan sharpens it. Now the CSP. Cutrone himself calls it a pre-political project and talks about a proto-party. I don't say that to score a point. The words are telling. The organization that is supposed to answer the charge of endless deferral describes itself as not yet political. Maybe that's just honesty about where things stand. But it means the CSP hasn't yet become the test of the Platypus position. I'd like it to become one. I'd want to know who is in it, how it relates to people who work for a living and have never heard of Adorno, and whether its program comes from their struggles or gets delivered to them. Those are Hal Draper's questions, and he asked them of every small group that decided it was the party in waiting. I haven't seen enough of the CSP to answer them, and I'd rather say that than pretend. Your last point is the one where I think we agree more than you expect. You say Marxist theory floating in the aether is a truism, and that organization is what makes it real. Yes. I wasn't claiming the theory survives no matter what. My claim was narrower. Marx's critique of the forms capital imposes on social life didn't die in 1919, because it was never the kind of thing that could die. What did die, or never fully arrived, was a working class organized to act on it. I called that a political problem, and I meant an organizational one. So we agree on the stakes. But notice what your sentence does to Platypus. If Platypus is explicitly intellectual and only clears obstacles, and organization is what makes theory real, then Platypus by its own account makes nothing real. That's fine as a division of labor, but then everything rides on the CSP, and the CSP has to answer the question Platypus never had to: what is its relation to an actual class here, now? I'm genuinely open to the answer. I just don't think it can be given in advance by reading 1919 correctly.

Anthony Teso

The indictment line I'll defend, though I think you've read something into it I didn't put there. I'm not claiming the sects kept Marxism alive for the working class. Most of what I've written about those groups is about how badly they kept it and how the keeping became the point. If anything carried the critique through the century, it wasn't them. It was the wage relation itself, which went on producing what Marx described whether or not anyone read Capital. That's the only sense in which I'd call it objective, and the word is Marx's. In chapter one he calls the categories of political economy "socially valid, and therefore objective" forms of thought. They're objective the way a price is objective. Nobody has to hold them as a world view for them to be operating on us. On Capital being immanent to the workers' own self-conception as earning a fair day's pay, I think Chris is closer to right than my essay allowed. That movement is where the critique had purchase, and that movement is gone. I don't have a good answer for who carries it now. Where I get off is the step from there to "its usefulness is questionable." Marx wasn't just handing that movement's language back to it. In 1865 he told the General Council to take "a fair day's wage for a fair day's work" off the banner and put "abolition of the wages system" in its place. He was working from inside their self-understanding in order to break it open. The audience for that argument went away. The wages system didn't, and I can't see how the second fact stops mattering because of the first. What I'd actually like to know is whether Chris sees the campaign as an answer to that problem of who carries the critique or as a way of holding the space until someone does.

Grawlix

Yeah you gotta bring Erin on here to scold us

Grawlix

Not trying to be weird or anything but if I'm gonna get scolded either way, ya know, there's different means, and the means justify the ends, eh?

Otto Caulle

Oh well it is for me of course

Otto Caulle

I took a quiz on quora and discovered I have hypochondriacal intellectuality.

C

When Spencer Leonard went on the swoletariat podcast he fucking trounced that guy by power of superior intellect, it was impressive. But the key moment was his assertion that Netanyahu was going so often to the White House to see his master and not the other way around. It’s exactly half true, Trump is in fact calling the shots, but the power of aipac and the Israel lobby is very real and not at all some anti semitic conspiracy theory which is the broad implication of your politics on this matter.

Grawlix

Naw, Platypus Erin

Grawlix

The lady with the dog and the window air conditioner still installed in the dead of winter ; )

C

And maybe rhetorically defeating the swoleteriate isn’t so impressive really

Otto Caulle

I haven’t read that yet

Dave

Thanks for the thoughtful replies Tony. I guess I’ll begin by saying that the freedom of Chris is the precondition for the freedom of the CSP. And I’ll also say that I don’t want to get into a Marxist history battle. I’ve been studying along with Chris and Sublation for a few years now and I have found their “red thread” from 1776 to 1917 quite useful in simplifying and clarifying my own political endeavours and helping clear up old arguments - so I am Cutrone pulled in that sense, but I think all that means is that I have a basic education in politics and American history. Two points: 1. (Below) I don’t think Marx survives because life sucks. I think he survives on his own intellectual merit. 2. I don’t think Chris is interested in creating a new sect of Marxists that study Marx but don’t have a political bone in their body. 1 - I think we do have to take the closed book of Marxism seriously. As every Marxist on the earth has experienced, their only exposure to Marxism was via a sect, party, or party state of some kind, and what Marxism originally was doesn’t exactly line up with The Erfurt Program. You quoted Marx and said that the categories of political economy are as objective as the air we breathe, and I assume that their contradictory or maybe oppressive nature is what motivates people to read Das Kapital. That’s probably true of University students, but as a leftist activist and a working class guy he was irrelevant to me until after my 5th failed campaign for justice some Marxist whispered in my ear and gave me a few texts by Engels and then showed me The Manifesto. Marx was useful to me not because he showed me why my life sucked, but instead as a way to critique my former comrades. With that in mind I would put pressure on the political in political economy which makes Marx’s statement correct. We can’t really say that any movement for the workers is conditioning the belief in political economy today. If anything critical race theory or science is what’s objectively correct today. The workers become activists and weirdos and don’t see themselves and their actions in society as political, and that’s probably why I had never heard of Marx. 2 - We want Chris to succeed in carrying the torch forward for Marxism and Socialism, but paradoxically that means he will selflessly have to reproduce himself 500 times so that there’s a proper motor force behind the socialist movement - not some glorified social justice campaign that’s fraught with oughts, or blindly following the canon of Marxism. This is the task that Chris has taken on by setting up a structureless structure for CSPers that allows them to figure out for themselves if they want to be socialist organizers. The CSP, unlike Platypus, is interested in theorizing practice. Our writings and meetings are about getting to know one another and learning from each other’s experiences out in the world as faithful servants to the working class. But I understand the confusion about the CSP. The CSP is an odd duck and simultaneously not an odd duck. Here we have Chris Cutrone - one of America’s leading, and most original Marxist organizers and theorists - as the thought leader of an ambitious campaign for a mass socialist party imploring the participants not to move from theory to practice. And the Platypus critique is never brought up in conversation in the CSP - in fact most participants that I know are quite happy to have distance from it. That would strike 99% of Marxists as odd or anti-Marxist. But this phase of centering practice will most likely last a few years until the major networks in the US and Germany grow in size and can be depended on as consistent cadre and organizers. At that point - when size and politics necessitates it - our conversations will need to become sharper and will most likely be about how to move from practice to theory and back to practice; or how to read history and theory as a process of freedom unfolding. When that happens I think your essay may garner a larger and more engaged audience. As a CSP member in a town in Canada of 1 million+ people, I can say that starting fresh with activism again has felt like new territory since I’m used to operating in an activist group or Marxist cadre. I first had to kick the habit of trying to herd and organize people into a project of my own creation, and start trying to get more involved in the working classes’ own projects in order to relearn how to learn from them. I failed at organizing my own thing a few times which proved Chris definitively right: my mind had been warped by the left and I had forgotten how to move “at the speed of trust,” with the class (such as it is), and I never learned how to begin. This experience showed me the strength of Chris and the CSP: that the structure of the CSP relies on the already existing structures of organization within the working classes. Conversely, The Left’s political trajectory tends toward historical images of anarchism, social justice, or Leninism/Stalinism today: they begin from ideology and draw people toward it. And so, the first task for CSP members is just to try out some activism that they might like and assess if that activism is still fun or meaningful for them. If they like working with the working or poorer classes then we encourage them to keep it up and write us about their experiences. If not then they’re free to leave with no judgement. Either way both outcomes are useful to us. The second task is to take an active role in your activist circle, find the leaders in the class and help them out as much as possible without putting yourself or anyone else at risk, or making their lives harder. Simultaneously they should write about their experiences or work with a writer, attend meetings, and learn from other organizers. We’ve seen a huge leap in confidence and understanding in our members as a result of this, and the field in which we operate in is wide open for us to develop into something political. There is so much already going on that no one is paying attention to. Furthermore very few organizations are taking the training of their members as seriously as we do. It’s rare to see a group communicating about organizing as effectively as we are (so far - scale will test this). All of this is to say that we want our members to learn how to become a Marx or Lenin or Cutrone. We want our people to see how society produces and necessitates the creation of Cutroneish people, and we want them (and everyone else in the world for that matter) to feel like they can become someone like Chris isn’t afraid or put off by the task going beyond capitalism without a map (ie useful theory) which is where we are. This is where the paradox - “we” vs “I” - of the socialist party lies for me. And this is where I think Chris is right to point out that there is no “we” in socialism. P.S., I enjoyed thinking about the obituary genre. Was it your creation or is that a known quantity to Marxists? Never heard of it before.

Will

Thanks Tony and Dave. This is helpful

Steve Roberts

I don't have one, I won't make that mistake again. Shouldn't have to but c' est la vie.