Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

ANIME POLL!!! Which One? 👀 🎥

  • Vinland Saga 295
  • Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 351
  • 2025-07-16
  • 646 votes
{'title': 'ANIME POLL!!! Which One? 👀 🎥 ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Vinland Saga', 'votes': 295}, {'text': 'Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ', 'votes': 351}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 7, 16, 14, 55, 34, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 646}

Content

Al my anime folks I need y'all to tap in!!! I've had several requests to get back to some anime content. Y’all have been asking for anime reactions to continue for a long time now — and I hear you loud and clear.

With the potential addition of a friend of mine wanting to dive into some anime content I feel like this would be a good point to kick one off with him.

Now don’t worry — all the other shows we’ve been watching are still rolling, but I wanted to open up this anime lane and bring y’all into the decision.

So my question is:Which anime should we start with?

🔹 Vinland Saga🔹 Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

P.S. I know I have other anime shows in the vault & I will either have a plan for my cohost to catch up and join me where I left off or I just may finish those solo. TBD!

These will mostly just be a 2 person reaction unless schedules are able to align a little better.

This poll may not be up long!

— Adison

Comments

Hamza

Vinland sagaaaaaaaaa

Olivia

AHHHH im so excited for thisssss

KCBC

I think y’all will love Vinland Saga!

Zack

Neither

SassyJ

FullMetal is amazing but ugh Vinland Saga was so good, ya’ll definitely enjoy it.

Xavier Chandler

VS for the dub over Full Metal is much respect 🙏🏾

SN

The possibility of him catching up to aot is fire! 🙏

Mikel Swart

FMAB! Please watch the dub

Brandon Nsaho

Full metal a good anime also a good anime to start with that’s not long would be my hero academia real talk 💯

Hamza

Vinland has one of the best character development in any anime. And also is about that get back

Tarot by Mokko

I voted for FMA but tbh there are better ones out there

Scienco

please vinland

Alysia Spells

I really like Vineland Saga and and waiting for the final season, BUT you have to start with one of the greatest animes of ALL TIME: FMAB! The story telling and pacing is too tier. You love some many characters and dynamics and everybody has their own favorites out of the villians. You would be highly remiss to not start with it. 😍

Alysia Spells

Yes but it's only about him. The other characters aren't nearly as important.

Brandon Nsaho

It really isn’t long compared to a lot of their anime but it’s a starter anime for new comers

Alysia Spells

I think Addison will like FMAB and Brandon will like VS

Quon

Exactly

Hamza

I would disagree ,Askeladd is a clever and unpredictable warrior who plays a big role in Thorfinn’s journey. Thors is a wise and respected man whose values deeply influence Thorfinn. Canute starts out quiet and reserved, but grows a lot over time. Leif Erikson is a warm-hearted explorer who supports Thorfinn and believes in him.

Ryùuzaki

at this point he needs to rewatch the entire thing. AOT is far too complicated for such a pause.

Vagabond_y

Guys, guys I say we go for Vinland since it's shorter and will give us more time for them to get into FMAB while having them standing completely ready for when they get into that series, besides i believe they'll connect so much from vinland, changed my life top 3 animes ever!!

SN

1 billion percent agree but you know gotta get what you can get

kingBD

Vinland koo but lets start them with something finished already

Mikel Swart

And then the bloopers afterwards

Jace Longoria

Why don’t they just get the two seasons out the way, then while they wait for season 3 they can watch fma

Tarot by Mokko

There's a plethora, they're just old. They would def love Cowboy Bebop, Samurai Champloo, Trigun, Monster, Psycho Pass, X, Blood + etc Basically, 90s to mid-2000s titles

Malcolm Xavier

Fullmetal hopefully wins but I heard Vinland Saga was good but never watched it yet

kingBD

I like both series so however they do it im ok with. Just think personally them starting with something finished is better than jumping into a story still going and having to wait for a next season.

Dan Schwartz

It might be a chore to get a hold of but if you do explore FMA; try to track down the older series for at least the first few arcs. Brotherhood pays lip service to those ones in order to have time to do their thing with the actual material that it covers.

Glen

They are not going to like FMAB. They will love Vinland Saga, more substance

Jace Longoria

Are they gonna watch sub or dub?

Vegas

I know its not anime. But does no one want him and adi to watch RICK AND MORTY??? That show is is legendary and would blow up on youtube

justbibi

I hope the vote changes over to VS. S1-2 are hype and FMA has too much lore especially for the new potential host joining on the journey.

Tyana1k

honestly not a fan of either choices i was hoping for something more mainstream or going back to finish demon slayer or like ATLA😭

Jace Longoria

Facts hopefully they finish both

Ayaulym🇰🇿

What about AOT? That’s the first MUST WATCH

Gypsysoul

I asked my son to watch GoT with me and in exchange I've been watching animes with him. One piece was my first but we are actually finishing up Vinland today!. I really enjoyed it! Id watch that with you guys

Ayaulym🇰🇿

Attack on titan PLEASSEE That’s where everyone who is new must start, no other way around

QueequegTheater

I know it'll never happen but just *imagine* their reaction to JJBA. Also, Addison, it might be a good idea to specify clearly whether you're watching the anime in English or Japanese; people definitely have their preferences (and some anime like Cowboy Bebop or FMA:B have famously beloved English dubs).

Jani

I know it’s not an option but really hope you guys do Attack on titan instead. WAY more enjoyable as people who don’t already watch anime and a great place to start reaction-wise. Loaded with action and a great storyline. I don’t think you’ll like either FMAB or VS nearly as much

Tasia

Omg, YESSS!!! As much as I’ve been wanting you and Brandon to react to “You”, I’m a HUGE anime nerd and this just makes me so happy. There’s so many to get into and I’m excited to see how you enjoy them 😊 One Piece is my all time favorite but baby steps lol. Very excited for this!

Drifts

Never even knew y’all watched anime, What are your favourite series or some of the anime’s you’ve watched??

Kyoshi Thee Stallion

Kinda unrelated, but are y'all going to go back and finish ATLA someday? 👀 I'm loving your channel.

Johann Andrews

I don't think you guys would enjoy FMAB as much as you would VS, but it is a classic. I think Vinland Saga is more modern and you guys would appreciate that storytelling more. But if you're soliciting opinions here, Attack on Titan should definitely take priority over any other anime LOL

Dan

would love to see tucker and dale vs evil, community, band of brothers

justbibi

I love your username.

Heavenly Demon

Full metal alchemist brotherhood is amazing

Ryùuzaki

Could've probably found better options. I wouldn't mind a rewatch of AOT with Bran ngl

gibbs gaming

Yes fma brotherhood is the best lets goo I'm hypeeee

Jcyn

Y’all gotta tap in with vindland

Felix Cabrera

Attack on Titan is one I think yall would be surprised by and have great reactions to. Fullmetal is also awesome and the English dub has some of our favorite Vox Machina voice actors in it.

Pinder

FMAB is amazing and definitely a must watch HOWEVER may be a bit too for a lack of a better word beginner anime.

Pinder

I don't know if you have Attack on Titan in the vault but if not that is a must! Very real world themes that apply nowadays

Ece

cann we vote attack on titan lol

Eric Koval

I cannot believe Vinland Saga is losing to FMA….smh you people have terrible taste

tha comingstorm

Are u fr?!?!? Over Vinland Saga guys? Nah that’s crazy

QueequegTheater

Man everyone is already fighting over FMAB and AOT like they're not both Baby's First Anime /j

E

Yall are crazy, im pretty sure vinland is way shorter too

Leon

Lmao

MattPalmer237

OR, much better idea...Cyberpunk:Edgerunners. 1 Season, won't take forever to get through and instant classic.

Mr. Every

FMA is a very well made show for younger audiences, Vinland is for more mature individuals. Choose whichever you’re leaning towards.

David James

Vinland is better but aren't you already doing Vikings

Derek

have y’all watched naruto. i’d legit kill for a DUB naruto reactions. gosh one of the best things that have touched this earth. love naruto, love the dub, its GOLDEN

Ryùuzaki

Doing vinland before vikings is kinda funny ngl

Zachary Berry

I know it’s not on the list but Naruto would be peak (but it’s really long), also cyberpunk edgerunners is amazing and fairly short

Sabrina Taylor

Never heard the same amount of praise about fma as much as aot all I hear about fma is the girl dog

f_1001

so hard to pick for me

Ashencrow77

You guys have to watch Naruto and attack on titan. Those are legit the best anime’s out there by a long shot

Donte

tho good animes there are better starter animes to choose from, but I'll be tuning in regardless

Cnz43

AINT WATCHED FULLMETAL YET SO.. BUT I WOULD LOVE TO SEE YOU ALL REACT TO HAJIME NO IPPO, ONE OF THE BEST ANIMES I EVER WATCHED PLUS ITS GOT THE HUMOUROUS MOMENTS. GOD (JESUS CHRIST) Bless and GOD rest the souls of the dead amen. Romans 10:9 - That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.

Crazy Taco

Aot or naruto shippuden would be better

Alyssa A

You all should go back to attack on titan. All of your personal takes would be priceless ❤️

Tiaaa_moon

Omg I came here hoping for attack on titan