Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

To live is to suffer. How we respond to that suffering determines who we are.

Files

Comments

Lana

Appreciate you opening up to us here, Breht! I get extremely severe anxiety that pops up seemingly out of nowhere, and also struggled with OCD as a kid so this episode resonated with me deeply and it feels validating to know we are not alone in our struggles. There is no shame in asking for help, either for yourself or your loved ones. My heart was so full when I donated to your sister's GoFundMe and saw that her goal was met and exceeded!! Mutual aid means creating networks of community care and about our fellow humans helping each other in the struggle. You've done so much for all of us, sharing your experiences and your wealth of knowledge on Rev Left. If you ever need help yourself, please know you can always always lean on your comrades. Sending love to you and your family!

Bill

You certainly are one noble human being and I am grateful for the inspiration and wisdom you provide. If there is any redeeming benefit to the hardships you have and are currently enduring it is that somehow they provided you fodder to shape yourself into the remarkable person you are- and that is a monumentally huge accomplishment. Many, as you know, are completely broken by their hardships. A willingness to bear your own suffering AND, despite it all, remain willing to help others is equally worthy of applause. My only words of advice are to rest easy on yourself and to take care of yourself. The world will gravitate toward empathetic people like you- and if you don’t protect yourself the weight of that it will break you. Put you, your family, (and your Patreon lol) first- and never, ever feel shame or guilt for that. People who truly love you will understand. Peace and Solidarity.

Jo Vinova

100% agree that there is no shame in asking for help. That's what the community is for, whether it's family, friends, or Patreon comrades. Don't be too hard on yourself Breht!

Jo Vinova

Being a pillar/leader in your family is something I can resonate with. You gotta let them be there for you like you are there for them. And if you really feel like you venting to your wife is too much, you can always vent to us dude. You could even tie it into how the system contributes to the issues you might be dealing with.

Alex C

Keep that self esteem up. You're always good at speaking. You carve good questions as well, and present organic audio products. Keep that self esteem up.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Bret, you mean a lot to the patreon community you’ve cultivated over the years. Your authenticity is unmatched in the podcast world. At the same time, I don’t think you can say that you shouldn’t lean on your family, such as your wife like you mentioned, in times of struggle. That is what family is for. Also, give my condolences to David as he goes thru this tough period. I look forward to hearing from him and you on Shoeless again. Stay strong, brother. ✊🏻❤️

Daewoo

I was uncomfortable listening to this episode. I mean this with all the love and respect one can have for someone I'm in a parasocial relationship with: you need to get real, Breht. You need to look up narcissism and see if you have that in conjunction with OCD. As snarky as this next bit will be, I think it's needed. Really, Breht? You are the only one in your family and social circle that can handle not only your own physical and emotional burdens, but also everyone else's? If I was someone of consequence in your life, I would be very upset at how incapable you think I am. You think so little of me and my ability that you hurt yourself (denying catharsis) keeping all this bottled up in you? That is hurtful. It is noble, on the one hand, to step up and take on the hardships of not only your life, but others. On the other hand, it is ignoble to deny that same capacity in others. It is noble to not put more on other people's plate. It is ignoble to say you are unique among all others in how you are able to handle all that is on your plate. Your desire to help your loved ones does the opposite. You hurt yourself when you deny yourself these outlets and catharsis and just deep, meaningful, personal discussion. You hurt yourself, which hurts them. This may seem a personal attack or whatever, but this is just me engaging with what has been said in this episode and I hope it is taken that way. I'm glad I listened til the end. Is this your pity party for yourself? You put this to us to have us recognize your ability to shoulder the burdens of yourself and family and friends. Your family doesn't need to change, you do. Again, I mean this with all the love and respect I have for you through this and other podcasts. You yourself said this might be unhealthy. It is. I have struggled with the same thinking but it hurt my friends and family while I tried to be the superman for all of them. I'm not superman. Neither are you. Love and solidarity.

Cynthia Jeffries

Your stream of consciousness ramblings are the best. You artfully cover topics that are deeply meaningful and impactful. Thanks. 🙏🏼

Hunterchuck

I appreciate these kind of real talk episodes. For some of us, we are completely alone and it's brutal both economically and emotionally.

Ryan Smith

That's harsh. I found the episode inspiring. Don't overthink it.

Ryan Smith

Nice episode. I found it meaningful.

Radiant Sun Warrior

I had a similar sentiment which drove me to make a comment. In lue of restating what you already put well, I'll add another idea to this. In activist and revolutionary left circles I have found a major theme regarding "shouldering the burdens of others". You cannot, in a direct and permanent way at least. Our revolutionary task is to give people the tools and confidence to liberate themselves. When we start talking like we, as strong powerful defending men of history, have to take upon ourselves and carry the burden of our weaker members, we rob them of agency and we burn ourselves out. Even within your family where you are a strong provider and they rely on you, there are ways to rely on them as well, to the mutual benefit of all. It's important that we support each other, but we have to do it with the right kind of mindset. The kind to uplift people in suffering, by empowering them, not thinking you have to save them. They will save themselves if given the tools, and given they want to. Bret, I know you're going through it right now. I am in awe of your bravery and transparency across this and your other public works. Like you said, suffering is the stimulus to growth. We are all in this together, one struggle, one fight. Love and solidarity comrade

Rev Left Radio

Thank you both so much for the kind words and unending support! And thank you Lana for supporting my sisters gofundme! Exceeding the goal brought everyone to tears and now gives them real breathing room while she keeps searching for a job. They literally went from pure panic to full relief within 24 hours <3

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Bill, I take your wisdom to heart and it means a lot to me.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Jo. I def vented a bit in this episode haha, it wasnt my intention actually. I meant to briefly talk about it and then move on to political stuff but kinda just fell into a full episode of venting. It was chathartic and seeing the responses helps too. Thank you for your support my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Im really sorry it came off this way. That was not my intention. It was not that people CANT shoulder the burdens but that I dont want them to have to and I demand a lot of myself in that regards. I would be dead without my family and friends and of course they help me. My immediate family (not my wife and kids but my parents, siblings, etc.) are in a place of real chaos and interpersonal rage and hate. I didnt indulge the details cuz its too personal but thats the center of gravity around which I was talking. Within my family (again specifically my parents, siblings, and not my wife, in laws, etc.) there is a LOT of trauma and pain and suffering and conflict. Lots of genuinely broken people. In THAT context I have to rise to the challenge and lead the family, mediate ALL disputes, etc. I do not think I am a narcissist, and It sucks it came off that way. I was just venting and speaking off the cuff in a state of pain. I wasnt trying to present myself as some stoic badass uniquely capable of bearing suffering, only to work through my own thoughts and feelings. Maybe I shouldnt have shared this as it was perhaps too personal. I used this as therapy, and I wasnt even meaning for it to be. I had a whole thing I was going to talk about but that fell to the wayside once i started talking; it all just kinda came out. But to be clear: my wife, my in laws, my friends, my grandparents, etc. all have my back, all support me immensely, are all strong and capable and competent people who I lean on often and couldnt get by without. Its just that after my dad died, that part of my family really went downhill and left me in the position of trying to lead and help them as they spiraled. I could have been more clear about that.

Rev Left Radio

P.S. Daewoo, while I think your quip about narcissism is genuinely off-base (and admittedly hurtful), I do take your point overall. Particularly about the denying of that capacity within others. Even the people I was specifically referring to (which I did no make clear) do have the capacity to bear pain and suffering and still help others. Even in their pain and suffering they help me, have my back, etc. And I take your words to heart and will think about that in the coming days and weeks. I appreciate you.

Daewoo

Reading my comment back, I definitely think I was too abrasive in stating what I was thinking as I was listening. And I am actually regretting the 'pity party' paragraph. And I thank you for reading my comment charitably while I wasn't so charitable with my listen.

Rev Left Radio

Naw, its all good. I interpret it as a friendly dose of tough love and I see clearly that the intent of your comment was not to tear down but to offer totally honest, constructive criticism which I genuinely appreciate and take to heart. Thank you.

Daewoo

And also, I do like to hear these episodes, even if I get uncomfortable. I recognize things that I've done and have been been told are narcissistic, so spew that forward on anything I recognize, even if misguided. Again, I don't know shit really, but ye.

Breakerofchains

There’s a comment in this thread that I won’t reply to directly for non escalatory reasons but Breht just make sure you know that the majority of us are a lot more compassionate. Yes you are just a random person that we never met and by default of the structure of Patreon, we will know things about you meanwhile you don’t even know we exist individually. But that doesn’t mean we can come on here and attempt to psychoanalyze, posture and hurl random labels at you just because we give you a few bucks every month. As the rest of us are, you’re just a working class person trying your best and is using your platform of supporters to discuss how your material conditions are causing you and your loved ones to suffer. This was a very insightful episode. It was a raw look into the reality of trying to survive this human condition as a working class person. This episode wasn’t any form of trauma dumping or oversharing. This was a dialectical primary resource from a regular person that many of us can empathize with and relate to. Solidarity.

Gaige

Dog I relate to you so hard. Thank you for sharing, I needed to hear the part about not making others suffer by grieving to them. They don’t deserve it. I have done the same thing to my SO.

Dave Miles

Mate… I’m 64yo - and I wish that at 35 yo I had half the wisdom you have. There’s really nothing I can tell you other than that we have the greatest love and respect for you and what you do. Offloading in this platform is perhaps a kind of “journaling”; probably better than dumping on our greatest supports 😁 And I believe that what you spoke of today IS political; Capitalism has placed unprecedented pressure on our psyches, without any meaningful tools (Amazon’s “mindfulness sessions” and screaming cubicles aren’t any kind of answer to what we are experiencing) TL:DR - we love ya. And send our love to Dave.

Ben

Breht, I love you man! With “who’s your role model?” being a classic icebreaker or tell-me-about-yourself question growing up, I never felt particularly confident in an answer. I can say that since listening to you regularly, you’ve filled that “role” for me. You inspire me with every episode, and learning recently that you also suffer from OCD meant so much to me and probably contributes to why I find your way of thinking about things so easy to relate to. So grateful for your existence and thank you for all you do

Nick

Hey Breht, sorry to hear that you're struggling right now. I hope that things get better for you and your family 💚. While I was listening to the episode I had this advice from the Buddha come in my mind: "Even if low-down bandits were to sever you limb from limb with a two-handled saw, anyone who had a malevolent thought on that account would not be following my instructions. If that happens, you should train like this: ‘Our minds will remain unaffected. We will blurt out no bad words. We will remain full of compassion, with a heart of love and no secret hate. We will meditate spreading a heart of love to that person. And with them as a basis, we will meditate spreading a heart full of love to everyone in the world—abundant, expansive, limitless, free of enmity and ill will.’ That’s how you should train." (MN 21) It struck me when you described life as a battle that you would keep fighting through. I understand its just a simile for determination but sometimes I think we really feel this way about life. Like we're trying to exert our control over it and somehow beat it. If we can learn instead to open our heart up to it in a genuine way and accept the out of control nature of life we can find a lot more peace and understanding. Coincidentally we also empower ourselves and end up being of greater service to others. I dont want to preach to much and I know you've already gotten a lot of responses but just wanted to share my 2 cents. Its a lot easier said than done but reflecting on this has helped me in my life and helped me turn my difficult times into times of growth. Please don't be afraid to talk about your problems because no one can make it through this life alone and we respect the political education you're helping give us 🙏🏼

Rev Left Radio

I really and truly appreciate your kinds words and your support. I put it out there and I am okay with everyones honest responses, thats part of the trade-off and I accept that. I appreciate your interpretation though, and thats definitely what I was AIMING to do with this episode: to be honest and vulnerable, make others not feel alone in their struggles, and try to work through some shit that im dealing with in a - hopefully - constructive way that could resonate or even inspire others. I hate the one-way nature of having a platform and genuinely feel connected with those of you who respond to these posts and who directly support us and our families. In a perfect world I would be able to meet and genuinely befriend folks like you, but its the pros and cons of the internet I guess. In any case, thank you again for your kindness and support my friend. <3

Rev Left Radio

Im glad it resonated with you. THere is a fine line to walk between open and healthy communication about your feelings and struggles with those you love and share your life with AND putting too much on them in a way that is not productive or helpful for either side. Im not sure If i made that distinction clear enough, but thats what I was trying to say. I send you and yours my love.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you man, I really appreciate that and having someone with your life experience find value in what I do is high praise! Idk if its journaling, oversharing, or using you guys as my therapist lmao but Im glad some people found it worthwhile. I totally agree with your deeper critique of our system. Our fear and precarity and struggles and suffering are, in significant part, to the alienation and economic mechanisms of our violently capitalist culture, absolutely. The love is mutual, thank you for the support, my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Ben! I love you too man. It means a LOT to hear that I fill some part of that role for you, and I wouldn't be doing that responsibility justice if I didnt also show the side of me that suffers and worries and struggles. Im glad that resonates with you so much. I send you and yours my love and solidarity!

Rev Left Radio

Hey Nick, what a gorgeous quote! Thank you for that, its hits hard and is genuinely inspiring and helpful. Your point about framing life as a battle is also very insightful. Those metaphores and similes of battle and war can be useful at times, but overall I agree they are limited ultimately. Ill continue pondering both of those things going forward. I really appreciate your wise words and compassion. <3

Gaige

I think everyone other than an annoying vocal minority understood exactly what you were trying to say. Sharing is good, but burdening your closest partner with your worst thoughts just because they will listen is not fair, especially when they are powerless to help change the circumstances that lead to those thoughts. I think you expressed your situation beautifully. You bring up things that you struggle with on the inside and even within this small community some would rather judge and tell you that it might not be the absolute healthiest rather than try to understand where you are coming from and take off their analysis lens for two fucking seconds. I know you take it as comradely conversation but I find it fucking ridiculous. Anyways man, I know you’ll get through it. I’ll see you on the other side of this period of acute stress.

Pablo

Thanks for your reflections Breht, I have been struggling with the hedonistic treadmill and squaring knowing how fortunate I am from a global perspective, while at the same time experiencing the alienation and frustration of our times. It helps to hear you share your thoughts about this, not a topic we often discuss on our day to day lives

Jose Alvarez

If you want to draw more people to the Patreon, you should start releasing HALF of an episode on the public feed, and then at the very end remind listeners that the rest of the episode can be found behind a paywall

Mike

💯

Jon Self

Thank you so much for this Breht. I also struggle with OCD and while my specific struggles are different, the wisdom and perspective you bring has helped me feel like I’m not alone. I have reached deeper levels of philosophical peace as a result of your podcasts. Thank you. I would also like to mention that you don’t need to bear the brunt of everything without support. You won’t be the support you want to be if you don’t give yourself the support you need. That’s just being a human.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for listening and im so glad these sorts of episodes are useful and helpful to you! I also totally agree that I do not need to, nor do I in reality, bear suffering without support! Im so grateful for my family and friends who do support me and have my back no matter what. I think in this episode I was trying to convey my struggles in a way that came off as if I dont have any support network, and I feel bad for that. I was just wrestling with the role I play in my family and how sometimes the people who should be able to be there for me, like my parents in particular, have their own issues that prevent them from fully understanding mine or being able to help in an ideal way. But they still love and support me and did what they could and can for me. IN any case, I really appreciate the support and I send you my love and solidarity.

Autumn Williams

I'm sorry to hear your sister and everything else going on. We'll always being listening to your story. Thank you for sharing! You're doing great things!

Mike

As a 42yo still grappling with the after-shocks of crippling OCD as a teenager, your thoughts and insight are extremely helpful and healthy to hear. Thank you, Breht. (In fact, if you’re ever up to discussing it further off-thread, I’d love that). If we’re to survive as humans, we should rely on our built-in faculties of communal coping and cooperative understanding. Narcissism disempowers us, where love is power and praxis, an ethics or service; digging deeper into these spaces that aren’t easy to understand and deal with, and we need each other to do that (I’m paraphrasing Maira Olivias-Rios on the Red Nation podcast here). A community of love is a revolutionary struggle in and of itself. In order for us to find love in ourselves, we need to be willing to take it in from the people around us so we can extend it back out regeneratively in the observable nature of the universe. All we really have, as living things with a limited time being alive, is the unique capacity to relate to each other. We need each other to survive, and we need to rely on collective energies to allow us to do so.

Derek

I relate! Been going through it w mental health the last 6 months (a bit better last couple weeks), and also found I was letting that spill over into snappy comments and uncharitable thoughts w my SO. Decided to make this the "summer of sweetness" cuz I needed a reset. We've both really enjoyed it! I know sweetness can be a blechy word but I used it as shorthand for erring on the side of a smile rather than a sass, not engaging in every opportunity for back n forth, etc. Game changer!

Eduardo Zaragoza

Bret I have been going through a crisis. I'm listening to this episode at work. And you reminded me I'm fighting to be a kind human everyday. I can't believe I was throwing myself a little pitty party when I can use that energy to be kind to others no matter what.

Rev Left Radio

I send you my love and solidarity, truly. Remember what you have to be grateful for, try to be of service to others, and be kind, patient, and compassionate with yourself as well! <3

Rev Left Radio

I love that and think it is very wise. When we are stressed or sad or anxious - when we are in our heads all day - we do tend to be less patient and forgiving w those we love the most. Focusing on correcting that is great. Im reading a book called "You Are Not a Rock" by Mark Freeman and I highly recommend it for any and all mental health issues and just for living a more balanced and healthy mental and emotional life in general. I send my love to you and your family.

Wes Rich

I’ve listened to this episode a few times now as life continues to pile it on and take from me and I’ve found it to be very comforting and cathartic, that I’m not alone in all this suffering. I completely agree with the sentiment that suffering is unifying. We all love you Brett and are so thankful for you. Your contribution is so much more than a raindrop in the ocean.

Ken S

Almost caught up after i started listening ~2 1/2 yrs ago, and glad to see i've got more ahead clear up to the present- that you've been able to stay in it, comrade- because i've grown to feel like you're a dear friend and mentor i've never met. The voice of the commie in my head is very much like yours- but also incorporates everyone i've listened to you talk to over the years, and the didacts before you who led me to you (the Deprogram boys, and Philosophytube)- and going through a bit of shit myself right now (underemployed & financially stressed because the Feds found out how i feel about fascists and revoked my security clearance, womp womp), i deeply empathize with what i'm hearing. Especially when it feels like your troubles *correspond* to your struggle to live properly- that unfucking yourself has provoked the ire of the fuckers in power- the choice presented, back down or push forward, shut up or expand further... is no kind of choice at all. We *have to* push on, we *must* grow bolder- once you've finally really *felt* courage, cowardice is anathema. There is no going back, starving to death in the cold would be more dignified than self-re-subordination.