Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Author and Scholar Marcello Musto joins the show to discuss his book "The Last Years of Karl Marx: An Intellectual Biography".

Together, Marcello and Breht explore the last couple years of Karl Marx's life, including his personal tragedies and illnesses as well as his continued study, travels, and theoretical development. They discuss and counter the criticisms that Marx was irredeemably euro-centric, didn't wrestle with the question of colonialism, or was a class reductionist, while also diving into his relationship with his wife and children, his best friend and colleague Engels, his analysis of Russia, and finally, his own death.

Marcello Musto is a Professor of Sociological Theory at York University, in Toronto – Canada, where he is the founding director of the Laboratory for Alternative Theories. He is acknowledged globally as one of the authors who has made significant contributions to the revival of Marx studies over the last decade and his research interests also include Socialist thought, the history of labour movement, and alternative socio-economic systems. His work has been translated worldwide in twenty-five languages and among his publications there are four single-authored books and twelve edited volumes.

Files

Comments

Lana

I so appreciate how well you articulated identity politics, Breht. I struggle to explain this to people in ways they will understand without taking offense, like I’m saying their identity and their experiences as “X identity” isn’t important. It is. But we can’t let that strangle the broader issue at hand, which is universalism, and how the ruling class uses identity against us in order to divide us. How do you straddle the line between identity reductionism and class reductionism? I see many on the left disparaging class reductionism as a major problem. I’m curious what others will have to say! I’m still learning!

Rev Left Radio

You say you struggle articulating it but you did it very well here! haha. But yea, I would say that reductionism, whether class or identity, occurs when one is emphasized to such a degree that the other becomes irrelevant. Having said that, they arent exactly equal either. I think class is the mechanism through which we come together despite our different identities, and is the only coalition able to wage class struggle as such, therefore it is primary. But in order to build and maintain healthy class solidarity, peoples identities must be fully respected. When you allow bigotry of any sort into such a class movement, it weakens it via alienating various segments of the working class, which is always multi-racial, of every different sexual orientation, multi-national, etc, etc. So class reductionism would say things like race, the colonial question, feminism, LGBTQ rights, etc arent important at all and "get in the way" of the class struggle, which is an error. Identity reductionism says individual identity markers are primary over class or, in some cases, just as important as class, and this is also an error because it dismantles or disregards the only plausible mechanism that would allow people of different identities to unite in a truly common struggle. Im sure there are even more nuances here to be explored, but thats the general idea IMO! So, in short, we strive to understand teh unique ways in which certain people have unique forms of struggle or oppression under capitalism-imperialism-colonialism, and take their struggles for autonomy and equality up as our own, while at the same time stressing that in order to build a better world for ALL of us, and avoid the trap of "my identity v. yours", we need to emphasize the international proletarian struggle as the vehicle of liberation for everyone. Liberals love identity reductionism cuz its hyper-individualist to the core where everyone is a unique intersection of identities (which makes class struggle impossible, since liberals in principle are not at all concerned with class struggle and see it as a communist threat). Chauvanists love class reductionism cuz it allows them to only focus on the class struggle without having to wrestle with or face the complexities offered up by race, gender, orientation, colonialism, labor aristocracy, etc. etc. keeping their idea of a white guy in a hard hat as the avatar of the "Working class". They also dont have to wrestle with teh ways theyve been socialized into racism, misogyny, and other forms of bigotry fostered in a society built on genocide and white supremacy.

Lana

Thank you for your clear and thorough response! I appreciate it.

Bill

Glad you mentioned Love and Capital. I really enjoyed that book and its portrayal of Marx’s humanity. It made me appreciate his ambition and the scope of what he accomplished- often under difficult circumstances.

Bill

Great question! I was thinking that if Marx’s philosophy of dialectical materialism and economic determinism lends itself to class reductionism and identity politics lends itself to identity reductionism, then wouldn’t the best way to straddle the two be through intersectionality? This article sheds some light on this idea but honestly it’s something I still have to work out. https://www.marxist.com/marxism-vs-intersectionality.htm

Adriaanus Stephanus

Please invite Marcello on again sometime! This was so interesting and insightful and I really enjoyed your conversation.

spinitch

banger after banger after banger 🔥🫡🧡