Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht listens to, reflects on, and critically engages with a public lecture by the late philosopher Michael Sugrue entititled "Marx on Alienation and Ideology". Professor Sugrue passed away recently, and Breht has always found his free, public lectures on philosophy to be helpful and really well done. In the spirit of free and open access to education, Breht offers his knowledge of Marxist philosophy alongside this offering by Professor Sugrue. 

The use of this lecture series falls under the protections of the Fair Use doctrine. 

Outro Music: "Steal for a Meal" by Bambu  

Files

Comments

Jihad

Always thought I was alone in the wilderness listening to Sugrue’s lectures as a lefty, looking forward to this

Eduardo Zaragoza

Your solo philosophy episodes are my favorite

Haazen

Loved this episode. Please do more!

Derek

I think I get a bit of his critique, in terms of the mixing of materialist oil with metaphysical water. I know Lasurdo was talking in one of his books about the teleological flavor to Marx, both in terms of the unfolding of history in general through stages, but also a bit of a Messianic inflection on the imminent arrival of communism. But some of the scholars in The Marx Revival edited by Musto were pointing out that there really is an evolution in Marx's thinking on both points as he matures and gathers more experience. He and Engels clearly begin toying w the possibility of a socialist revolution happening in Russia rather than an advanced capitalist economy. And it's also important to stress the propagandistic nature of The Communist Manifesto, which in some parts is pretty drenched w telos but is also intended to inspire people to action and thus gins them up a bit towards an "inevitable" near future (that doubtless felt much closer to that moment in history than it does in 2024). In short, Marx is a complicated thinker and of course you can point out some contradictions across his vast body of work. But he never intended to be the end point of the struggle.

Lana

Here for these episodes as a sub-series! 👏

Jo Vinova

New Bambu for the outro was a nice surprise 🙏🏽 I'm not at all familiar with Sugrue, but his bias was definitely showing with that jab at Stalin. Critiques that socialist revolutions are too authoritarian come from a lack of understanding the amount of consent that is required from the masses to carry them out and then maintain them. They also usually lack the context of external capitalist forces constantly interfering to claim, or reclaim, the access to resources within the new socialist state. I wouldn't mind hearing some more of Breht and Sugrue.

Payton M

Great episode! Professor Sugrue is certainly an excellent thinker and I appreciate his voice. The episode on Alvin Gouldner with Sugrues assistant is pretty interesting. I'd also recommend his hegel episode. All his stuff is good but I like those two the best.

Jose Alvarez

Wow this is great 👍🏼 thank you

GolfBaller

"What's Left of Philosophy?" and "Plastic Pills" are other good lefty philosophy pods yall might like.

capn_snooze

How good is the new Bambu album?

BammEs

Very neat episode! What's missing from Sugrue's discussion is dialectics and him not grappling with that is why he thinks Marx is incoherent. He's stuck in what we'd call a vulgar materialism. Also: is that a new Bambu? Awesome. Cool to see those lines from DOOM sampled, I had them noted down too to use once. Nice.

Rosanna Fields

Thank you for your hard work comrade, this is the highlight of my day 🫶🏻

HackerBoiTellEm

This is great Breht! I hope to hear more. I also hope you and Alyson will be able to come back around to the analyses of right wing, or "third position", thinkers that you mentioned in the beginning of the episode.

Wage Slave

Just started listening but also noticed Bambu being used again!! New album is 🔥

Brian Rowe

Is there a playlist for all the music used the outro in various episodes? This one was 🔥, I want more

apaintingchicken

I'll never get tired of hearing Breht break down marxism to it's most basic components. Also mad impressed he just did this off the cuff. Keep it coming!

JK

Comrade, I will forever be grateful for the part you played in radicalizing me into a Marxist. I've been listening for a long time and I think this is one of the best episodes of yours I've ever heard. I haven't even finished it, yet I felt the need to comment here. You do a brilliant job of clearly, concisely, and emotionally conveying these core tenants of Marxism. Your anger towards this parasitic capitalist class is contagious and has helped re-ignite my vigor for bringing about their downfall. I seriously believe that if this episode was beamed into the head of every worker out there, we would have revolution tomorrow. It makes me want to sharpen myself even more in hopes that I can convey these ideas so expertly in order to help build our party and bring about revolution IN OUR LIFETIME. I think I'll likely use this episode as an introduction to new contacts our party makes cause I think you do such a great job in your delivery. Keep it up comrade.

Lefty In Training

I always find it so interesting when someone can actually do a pretty good job at explaining Marxism in a mostly correct and understandable manner, but then completely falter when applying it in an real-life context. They then fall back on shallow anti-communist propaganda and poor understandings of history that any history teacher at the same level as he is in philosophy would tear apart. Like how could you go into great detail into how Marx correctly pointed out that thinkers of any age will be shaped by the mode of production of their day, but then not apply it to yourself just 20 minutes later? I guess I'm just attracted to that point when people forget that their expertise in one area doesn't mean they are any better than a random undergrad student in another area. Oh and speaking of history teachers and your progress toward becoming one yourself, a history teacher Youtuber has gotten a bit of exposure in commie Youtube after reacting to some of Hakim's videos. Wondering if you have seen any of Mr. Terry History's videos. He's...actually not bad? Most of the time he's either agreeing with Hakim, adding some nuance to Hakim's points, bringing up potential critiques for the sake of engaging with the content that he may or may not actually hold, or admitting when he doesn't know something. About as balanced as I've seen from a history Youtuber, particularly an actual history teacher.

Adrian borja

Would love a series like this. Never knew how cool and interesting philosophy was until I listened to your episodes on it.

Grant Wynn

Love to see this! I initially found rev left via the owls at dawn podcast with Austin Hayden Schmidt. I was on a philosophy deep dive with them that let me to substantial political education with you. Incredible how much the two fall hand in hand

Allie S-M

I like this. More please

Michael Xin

I think the issue is that philosophers treat Marx and Marxism as a discipline of "Philosophy", when in reality it is an entirely different beast - I contend that Marxism (or Historical materialism) is the true successor to the discipline of "Political Economy". the proof of this lies in the fact that The final arbiter of All these divergent theories of Marxism isn't logic or metaphysics; it's their veracity during the process of class struggle. There is a scientific (i.e. material) core element of Marxism that makes it quite fundamentally different from other schools of philosophy, and I always get the impression that some of the criticisms levelled at Marx seem to be completely missing the point. Anyways loved the ep. Would like to see more.

melloncollic

I definitely enjoyed this one and would like hear more like this!

d

An amazing episode, thanks for doing this

Alex Kowalewski

Love philosophy and would love to hear more eps. like this. Thinking I should share this one with some people because it really has some important discussion here.

Mirazh

This episode is really great. I think when you bring in these other perspectives and engage with them, its some of your best work. Works especially well when the other source has its own audio like this one. Really really good and I hope you do more like this (either from further Sugrue lectures or other sources that pique your interest).

Jason

I can’t believe Sugrue claims that idealistic teleology is inherently part of Marxism, and hence a flaw because it contradicts Marxist materialism / scientific basis. He then uses this false idea to extrapolate that Marxism is inherently authoritarian because Marxists could allegedly go to any extreme in the present to help achieve some far off utopia (communism). As Sugrue describes it, Liberation Theology exists and mixes Christian idealism with Marxist materialism, but so what? How is that a criticism of Marxism? Also, for every example of real or imagined authoritarianism in Marxism, you can find 100 examples in capitalism, so why does he save his criticism for Marxism?

Monty Fuch

I must say; when Professor Sugrue, having laid good, solid foundations for the basis of Marxist thought, to then do a complete about-face and argue against its real-world applicability was jaw-dropping and sore to take. How can one engage with this tradition and then decide yeah that's as far as I'll go, throw your hands up in the air and cry 'who knows what the answer is'?! It's disingenuous.

Monty Fuch

Also Breht I'm struggling to keep up with all the great post-podcast music. Any chance of a wee Spotify playlist or something so they're all in one place?