Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Patreon Exclusive: Breht ties up loose ends about the election, responds to criticism of his downplaying of identity in the election, talks about why the Democrats cannot pivot back to the working class even if they wanted to (they dont), confronts four myths that the establishment want us to believe about Kamala's loss, and much more.

Files

Comments

Bill

Thank you for pulling my head out of the sand that I buried it in over the last few months in order to salvage whatever is left of my mental health. While I entirely agree with all your talking points and find them inspiring as usual, I’m exhausted by American electoral politics at this point. In fact, I’ve taken to reading fiction which suits my escapist, existential mood- The Book of Disquiet by Fernando Pessoa and The Idiot by Dostoyevsky has topped the list. I’m also reading The Railway Children by E.Nesbit who was a British socialist. She and her first husband were the founders of the Fabian Society (largely reformist). What I’ve entirely stayed clear of is listening to or reading anything from Democratic Party apologists. It’s just so egregiously pathetic and manipulative. Thank you for flushing the finer points of this out.

Lana

Appreciate this follow up episode from the first election episode and enjoyed the your response to Sugrue’s Marx lecture very much. I can’t express how much I love this podcast and your patreon. Since you are planning to do more of those philosophy episodes, I’d love to hear you break down Guy Debord Society of the Spectacle!! Feels so relevant to our time.

John Sheridan

I love your show and I deeply value your thoughts. One additional point in support of your position is that the Republican runner-up was an Indian woman. There were enough people on the right to at least consider her as a potential president, so I agree misogyny and racism were not decisive.

Irene

I’m hollering at “shoot him to the moon” and that whole moment, amen

Lefty In Training

ETA: lol thats what i get for not waiting to the end of the video I find a lot of the idpol rationales for the election result really wanting. The best argument I saw was from FD Signifier because he was using the voting numbers to make various points. Ultimately, I thought those numbers only told part of the story. Additionally, if we accept that there's no way a black woman can win, then it's still the DNC's fault for running her and still running her on a Biden campaign they knew wouldn't win.

she's all rat

In Canada we have federal elections in 2025 and sad as it is, this episode applies completely to what's happening here. Thanks for another banger, helps me brace myself for the year ahead.

Rev Left Radio

Solidarity! Canada - like the US and UK - is really going through it. Impossible for working people to flourish in these decaying societies.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Lana, and I deeply appreciate your long-standing support of the show. Means the world to me, truly. and YES, I have a Guy Debord solo ep in my To Do notes app lol. So hopefully I can get to that soon!

Rev Left Radio

Love it. Thank you. I find the Concept of the Political interesting, but def have no love for Schmitt. The friend/enemy distinction is a valuable one but certainly not one unique to or solely advanced by Schmitt, so I appreciate that!

Rev Left Radio

Hey bill, glad you are taking care of yourself. I, too, have been wanting to retreat into fiction lately and have LOTS of books on my To Read list. I think its important to engage with literature and to take breaks from the political spectacle for our own wellbeing. The books you are reading seems great! Simon Critchley has a new book out on Mysticism that I am super excited about, but also got Zen and Stoic stuff on deck. Been wanting to dive back into Franz Kafka's work lately though, even Vonnegut has been calling me back haha.

Wes Rich

I watched FD’s breakdown when it came out and I think both of your critiques work really well in tandem. I didn’t take away from his video that he was saying it was the only factor or even the most decisive factor (it was a few days ago so I may be wrong on that) but just used data to show how it was an important factor that requires unpacking, which I think you’re saying as well. I do think he puts too much stock in her identity so if I’m being honest I think your analysis of the material conditions and the Dems complete ignorance of the current economic realities of every day working people and that being the decisive factor is more accurate. Either way though I love his channel and love that you shouted it out and whole heartedly second your insistence that people check it out because his analysis of everything from music and sports to working class and marginalized rights is spot on and a wonderfully necessary voice in leftist critique of capital and class.

atesah

Hey Breht, I love these patreon episodes very much. They are more casual and therefore more intimate, it feels like you are our earnest communist coach keeping us engaged and motivated for the long protracted struggle in our communities. You do this with love and I’m sure I’m not the only one that feels it <3 Could you please do another New Year’s resolution episode and share with us your goals for 2025 and reflections on 2024 - politically, emotionally, spiritually, physically - hope that’s not asking for too much haha!! I’m growing politically and psychologically through my parasocial relationship with you and want to feel in solidarity with you and everyone here coming into the new year. (Hope it’s not weird saying I have a parasocial relationship with you lol I just watched Elliot Sang on YouTube’s video about parasocial relationships and feel less shame about feeling connected to people online that I admire and learn from) Love and solidarity xx

Rev Left Radio

THank you so much for those kind words, my friend, as well as your support of the show! A new years episode would be a great idea!! Ill absolutely do it and itll be because of this comment! Love and Solidarity!!! P.S. There is nothing wrong with feeling connected to others. Its an honor to hear that you find what I do so worthwhile that you could develop such a relationship with me! I only wish I could meet listeners like you IRL becuase I am sure wed get along and be friends! :)

Rev Left Radio

Hell yea, love hearing this! Yes his argument was nuanced and not the run of the mill Liberal cope at all. He def put more emphasis on identity in the final analysis than I do, but I am very glad to hear you listened to both and got the full spectrum of the argument. NOthing but love for FD

Ava

Literally sitting alone in my apartment laughing out loud at your use of the word freaks to describe these ppl/ your gulag comment. Just so true

RAB

Have you ever done a listener Q&A episode? Think it would be cool… love these types of rant episodes. Complete 180 from the “professionalism” interview eps which are also great. Best

Jessica Beasley

Sorry for the late comment. Sometimes it takes a while to finish listening to podcasts. Preface: I’m generally aligned with what you’re saying here and rationally agree with you the ridiculousness of cutting people out of your life. The following is an emotional reaction. A doubled edged sword of being trans is that the only people that REALLY care about us are a small set of weirdos. Running a campaign on hurting trans people isn’t going to win you an election… but as we have seen, it won’t stop you from winning. When I think about all the people that did not consider anti-trans bigotry to be a complete deal breaker, I don’t feel solidarity with them, I don’t want to engage with them, I want them to go immediately to hell. Which would have the added bonus of making me and my spouse considerably safer. I know rationally that we need these people but I would never trust anyone whose moral compass is so broken.