Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Breht listens to, reflects on, and critically engages with a public lecture by the late philosopher Michael Sugrue titled Marcus Aurelius' Meditations: The Stoic Ideal. He discusses the philosophy of Stoicism, its insights as well as its limitations, its commodification and bastardization under late capitalism, the dialectical inversion of the philosophy of a Roman Emperor for proletarian revolutionaries, Virtue Ethics, Mahayana Buddhism and The Four Brahmaviharas, the importance of courage and discipline and responsibility, Momento Mori, the Cardinal Virtues, equipping ourselves mentally and emotionally for a lifetime of class struggle, seeking the balance of the Middle Path, Marxist Dialectics, and much more! 

Professor Sugrue passed away last year, and Breht has always found his free, public lectures on philosophy to be helpful and really well done. In the spirit of free and open access to education, Breht offers his knowledge of philosophy alongside this offering by Professor Sugrue. The use of this lecture series falls under the protections of the Fair Use doctrine. 

Outro Music: "Lilac Wine" by Nina Simone

SUPPORT SOCIALIST NIGHT SCHOOL HERE: https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-omahas-socialist-night-school?qid=4ba49bb6351ea7b8638e5d8ea3c4f851

Check out all our other Philosophy Series episodes HERE

Follow RLR on IG HERE

Files

Comments

Spiderdijo7

That was one of your best eps man. Really inspiring!

Traik Peltier

That introduction was just straight up heat 🔥

Chase

So sick dude I love it!!

Chase

The dialectical marriage of stoicism and revolutionary politics is something I’ve been wanting to

Rev Left Radio

Im so glad you found it worthwhile, i really appreciate that support so much.

DC

Hey Breht, or anyone, sorry off episode topic here, but could you direct me to anywhere you've discussed a domestic vanguard party at length? I know there was an ep with JMP a couple years back about the need for one... I know the US doesn't have one. Anyone even close? Do you just fuck with more local orgs? Any different, current thoughts on that? Would love to hear. Thanks!

Rev Left Radio

Definitely our eps with JMP (on economism and the communist necessity etc. ) will discuss the concepts, as well as Red Menace eps on various texts by Lenin in particular (what is to be done, etc.) I def do not just fuck with local orgs, as I wish we had and want to help develop a true vanguard. Its only in lieu of one that local organizing is necessary as a pre-requisite to build momentum and a base and to get active in general. A vanguard party necessitates a mass base of support and an organization operating at the national level. I think PSL has really good organization, I think Black Alliance for Peace has great leadership and ideological clarity, both strive for building internationalist connections. I think we will have to marry various orgs like that together, and then link them to aspects of the organized labor movement if we hope to really build a vanguard party in the proper leninist sense. But building the vanguarrd party should be THE overarching goal of all communists in the US. This requires base-building in communities, of which labor organizing, tenant organizing, serving the people programs, political education initiatives, etc. are essential aspects/ingredients. In the meantime, I urge people to get involved in the most principled or largest org in their area and contribute to it, for those looking for careers getting into unions and the trades is helpful, artists and intellectuals need to be working on raising class consciousness, tenant organizations should be popping up in every major city and pushing the struggle for affordable housing while raising the political education level of regular people who get involved, etc. There is also the question of the electoral terrain as a site of struggle and recognition. Since most Americans engage with politics at that level, we need a presence there, in defiance of both corporate parties. Such a party would need to overcome various barriers put up by the two parties, shun getting dragged into culture war ephemera that alienates people, would have to focus intently on multiracial class struggle and universalist economic populism, as well as anti-militarism and anti-war politics to build a broad base, and then use that as a funnel into more intense political education programs, more grassroots organizing, more militant labor formations and caucuses, BPP style community programs, etc. There is a tension here between the fact that this is a LOT of work, many working people are trained to hate and fear socialism, and it all seems almost overwhelming -while at the same time- realizing that the vast majority of Americans are working class, are struggling, are worried about their futures, are sick of the two parties, want real change, and would absolutely resonate with an anti-corporate, unapologetically working class movement and party that opposes all wars abroad and the military industrial complex... Bernie tapped into this very real need, but had more loyalty to the Dems than he did to the movement - a huge blow to the momentum he helped galvanize. Who knows how all this will all play out, but it seems obvious that what we can all do is to get organized as best we can. I am always looking for hopeful trends and organizational development that could build toward a true vanguard and will use every ounce of my platform and my energy to bring attention to such a formation if and when it arises, adn to assist its development in any and every way I can. I want nothing more than to see that begin to emerge, but it can only emerge if enough of us are working hard to make it happen, cuz no one is going to just swoop in and do it for us!

Rev Left Radio

Imagine, despite its many contradictions and obvious issues, if the Green Party, PSL, the DSA, the Black Alliance for Peace, radical indigenous organizations, and various local tenant orgs, indie media outlets, decided to come together to try and build a national level party that operated on the electoral terrain via the green parties ballot access, had already active grassroots organization in communities and on reservations via PSL, DSA, indigenous orgs, etc, combined with a national tenant organization rooted in teh various tenant orgs, had internationalist connections, brought in new media and political education voices and platforms like ours and others, and agreed that - as imperfect and contradictory and it would no doubt initially be - we will put our differences aside for a period of time (say 2 election cycles) and try to connect these disparate streams into a mass party (maybe with caucuses and degrees of autonomy for all orgs and outlets) that pointed all its energies to trying to build a fighting working class apparatus that could operate on the streets, on the internet, and on the national electoral stage, all geared toward achieving an admittedly limited set of goals we ALL share: 1) universal healthcare for everyone 2) corporate money out of politics 3) defunding the empire and investing that money at home 4) Increase the minimum wage to $25 an hour 5) strengthen labor rights and union protections 6) affordable housing for all and an end to homelessness 7) breaking up all monopolies 8) nationalizing the banking system 9) huge tax increases on the wealthy 10) Investing seriously in public education across the country including free community college. After two election cycles, if it fails, we can all turn on eachother and rip eachother to shreds lmao, but goddamn as farfetched as it sounds - and is - that would represent a huge jump-start toward what we are trying to build and make a generational impact on the consciousness of working people. In lieu of some sort of collaboration and coming together, I fail to see how a million tiny, disparate orgs will be able to challenge capitalism and imperialism on the national level, let alone the internationalist one. WE will continue to be relegated to REACTING to what happens instead of shaping it. Our only other option is to wait until this system slams into the brick wall, implodes, creates massive suffering and crisis, and try to build something out of the rubble (and that assumes they wont be successful at building a techno-feudalist fascist dictatorship that staves off such a collapse - for a while at least). Idk you asked my thoughts and here they are all haha.

Sean the worker

I should print out a transcript of this episode, and nail it to my door next to my mirror.

Brennan Aitken-Gantz

Very interesting. I would love to offer a critique but it comes completely from love and a yearning for mutual success. If it’s welcome let me know. Otherwise, so glad to be a supporter of your good works.

Brad Northcote

The way you tied in the struggle for recovery from OCD is incredibly helpful. We can take steps to help that process, but in a lot of ways that goes frustratingly at its own pace.

Rev Left Radio

YES! Please! This one was an interesting tight rope to walk for me, given the seeming NON-overlap between stoicism and marxism, but I felt it was worthwhile to try and a unique attempt to pull back stoicism from the jaws of neoliberal influencers and self-help emptiness at least haha. But i am ALWAYS open to critique, especially from those who support the show here.

Rev Left Radio

Definitely. Im thinking of doing an episode sometime soonish about my own attempt at recovery and the stuff Ive learned in hopes it could be useful to others going through it.

Rev Left Radio

Im so glad you found it inspirational in that way, my friend. Thank you for your continued support.

Mexican Stalin

I meditated on this episode a little and believe that class dynamics muddy Stoicism. I don't think a slave should accept being a slave and strive to become the best slave they can be. More than a slave, they are a human, and they should strive to be the best human they can be. A slave's only right is to break their chains, so they should, to the best of their ability, strive for liberty. Idk if it makes sense but even privileged people like Che strived to be better human beings by giving up there privileged lives to become revolutionaries and uplifted humanity. Communist stoicism

Dylan Thompson

Sankara was brilliant at bringing the revolution down to the individual level. Great example.

DC

Dude... yes! Unsurprisingly, this is brilliant. Thank you so much for the depth and care of reply. I’m thinking of Bevins’ When We Burn and why different mass movements have failed to achieve lasting change, and also what successful revolutions (almost always) have had in common — disciplined, organized leadership; mass mobilization (the people support it, even if they aren’t party members); parallel power structures; armed struggle; clear ideological vision; strong leadership figures; international support. Your vision of a vanguard checks so many boxes, as it would. I learned from Rev Left that William Z Foster said organize the unorganized, but this is more like organizing the organized (who are fragmented, and thus unorganized in a way). I completely agree with your vision. A grand vision, or shared strategic pathway —one that temporarily subjugates ideological differences, sectarianism, and leadership ego—seems foundational. You’ve laid out a strong argument. Cultivating it within the movement/s would be challenging… So what would petitioning leadership/decision-makers in these orgs/groups look like? In part it would require people with credibility across multiple sites of organization coming together to develop strategy, right? Then upon acceptance, prioritizing it and diverting already stretched-thin resources to this project. Practically speaking, how does this get momentum? Maybe this project — vanguardism via organizing the organized — is already being worked on? Maybe this is naive (and indicative of my own “over-consumption” of the medium), but communist podcasters honestly seem like an excellent site of influence here, not merely because of your platform/audience, but because of all the varied connections that you (all) have and make… all of these in-roads into a multitude of organizations, big and small, academic and grounded, local and national, domestic and international, etc. I have heard your humility and struggles, and I imagine that sometimes you must feel like an insignificant rando from NE (and maybe these aren’t mutually exclusive lol) but, brother, you sound like the vanguard. Not just your sharp as fuck materialist analysis and principles, but the way you marry it with hope and imagination, discovery, and mysticism… it’s all so crucial, imo.

xander

just aska luigi!!!! thanks for the good episode breht. I appreciate your ending notes in particular around egoism.

Jose Alvarez

Happy birthday Breht! This was a good episode, very timely for me in my personal life

Haazen

Loving this series. Please keep them coming!

Rev Left Radio

I love when these discussions resonate with people in this personal way! Thank you very much for the birthday wishes, 36 years old is CRAZY lol

Rev Left Radio

I read that first line in an obnoxiously italian accent - as intended! lol Thank you for listening, and Im glad those points about overcoming our own egoism hit home, my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. We can see how the ideology of stoicism was a superstructural product of the material base of slave society in the roman empire, it didnt challenge class relations, it reified them, and even justified them. Thats why I tried to reveal its limitations and invert it for our purposes! Communist Stoicism indeed! Spot on analysis!!!

Rev Left Radio

Friendly reminder to launch your critique if your still up for it. Im genuinely interested in it and want to wrestle with it! No pressure tho ofc. :)

Rev Left Radio

First off, thank you so much for the incredibly kind words. They mean a lot to me and keep me motivated to continue playing my small, humble role in this larger process and movement. Your insights and depth and critical thinking are rewarding in that you are the exact sort of listener and supporter that I would want to cultivate. Many of those organizational questions are essential, but would have to be worked out, well, organizationally and communally, but you are putting your finger directly on the immediate contradictions, concerns, and tensions of "organzing the organized" as you put it! Coming around a concrete set of shared values and setting aside other ideological differences for a period of time seems to gesture in the general direction of how to begin to address some of those concerns. Once all parties agree that THESE are the things we will focus on, and agree to set aside our other differences for the moment, momentum could happen. Your point about leadership ego (and the egoism of needing to be right, more correct, more principled, etc.) is why I am always banging on about our personal obligation to try and become aware of our own egos and humble them in service to something bigger because ive seen the ego problem ruin organization after organization, create meaningless splits, etc. You can see the egomania in any political formation and movement, and its a REAL danger, not just an abstract pet concern I have. I think the project is organically, if haphazardly, developing, but way too slowly. I certainly want to play any role I possibly can in helping the development of such a structure or movement. I can do very little alone ofc, aside from the show itself, but I would love to throw my weight behind the emergence of such a movement. Ive thought often and deeply about what I can do to maximize my contribution to such an effort, but always seem to slam into the limits that we all face. I dont have the organizational or administrative talent to start something myself, and I also dont think we need to keep creating new things/orgs. WE need to take what comrades have already spent generations building and bring them together - and I am nothing if not a synthesizer myself - bringing different strands of thought together to bolster them and explore their connections. This is also how I think of building such a movement - playing whatever role I can in bringing already existing formations together to multiply their power and effect. But that hinges ultimately on those forces and organizations wanting that in the first place. We shall see... But in the meantime, strengthening the forces we do have seems to be the right direction to head.

Brennan Aitken-Gantz

Yes! I will just juggling the kid/job/sleep as ever hehe. Appreciate your warm receptivity.

Brennan Aitken-Gantz

Thank you so much for creating both a body of work and a community aimed toward collective liberation. I want to share these thoughts hopefully to help increase the effectiveness of that project. If my intuitions are wrong or feel like they are coming from a place that is unusable please discard them and think nothing of it. When I am listening to this episode, I noticed that the interjections that you provide at first add so much context and clarity as they get longer and more impassioned, i start to follow your thread, and I lose track of the original content. When the original content snaps back in, I then have to re-allocate my awareness to that. Eventually, I am experiencing more the switching between two perspectives than one of the pools of content. I wonder if there is a way to shorten and or soften some of your interjections in general so that the original content maintains its consistency and primacy, but extend a few of them longer and more emphatically where appropriate to give the listener access to your perspective. To be sure, this is a refinement and should only be taken as applause with the warmest heart. You have a profoundly powerful voice, and it may be that you don’t fully realize how potent you are. I realize I am in some ways, giving advice to somebody much more accomplished than myself so I understand the possible value of that advice might be less than zero. Hopefully, I have been able to wrap a criticism in the truth, which is that I deeply appreciate you.

peachyf0x

Thank you as always for your thoughts, comrade. Happy birthday to you, I hope this year brings you adventure, rest, and time to do more of what brings you joy.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the support, truly! I appreciate the birthday wishes as well. <3

peachyf0x

If you need assistance with editing your project, I'm happy to assist! I did editorial and journalism in the past and am willing to share the workload.

Jihad

Fantastic episode, this mini series is quickly become something I’m looking forward to. For what it’s worth, I think these episodes in addition to the rest of what you’re doing really make rev left something special in comparison to similar work others are doing in the space of political education

SprocketMusic

This is positively electrifying.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Great episode, Bret. I really like this series. Question: with all that’s going on in domestic politics right now, is there any chance you and Alison will be doing a current events episode soon?

DC

Likewise, Breht, thank you for your kind words 🙏 I take them to heart. This dialogue gives me a lot to chew on; I will be ruminating on all of the insights and keeping my eye on the main principle -- organize the organized, form the vanguard. Thanks again for the thorough reply! Keep doing your thing! You're a real one ✊️ And happy birthday!

Nick

Great episode Breht, I've been really enjoying this philosophy series. This gave me a little bit more respect for and understanding of stoicism. My main critique (which you touched on) is that I'm not sure you can just intellectually understand virtues and align your behavior toward those virtues through willpower and intellectual understanding. Since you are a student of the Buddha (and I am as well), I want to share this sutra with you that is one of my favorites: (1)–(2) “Bhikkhus, for a virtuous person, one whose behavior is virtuous, no volition need be exerted: ‘Let non-regret arise in me.’ It is natural that non-regret arises in a virtuous person, one whose behavior is virtuous. (3) “For one without regret no volition need be exerted: ‘Let joy arise in me.’ It is natural that joy arises in one without regret. (4) “For one who is joyful no volition need be exerted: ‘Let rapture arise in me.’ It is natural that rapture arises in one who is joyful. (5) “For one with a rapturous mind no volition need be exerted: ‘Let my body be tranquil.’ It is natural that the body of one with a rapturous mind is tranquil. (6) “For one tranquil in body no volition need be exerted: ‘Let me feel pleasure.’ It is natural that one tranquil in body feels pleasure. (7) “For one feeling pleasure no volition need be exerted: ‘Let my mind be concentrated.’ It is natural that the mind of one feeling pleasure is concentrated..." this process continues all the way to full enlightenment. This sutra is AN 10.2 (read in full here if interested: https://suttacentral.net/an10.2/en/bodhi?lang=en&reference=none&highlight=false) When we behave virtuously, in a way that is compassionate, kind, generous, in line with the Brahmaviharas, it is like a natural law that we will feel happy, joyful, and naturally enter into meditation. This is the beauty and genius of the Buddha and his deep understanding of the nature of the mind and how it works. When we put the right causes in place, the rest flows naturally. The reason I mention all of this is because I think the Buddhist view is a more sustainable way to behave virtuously because we can actually feel the effects of our virtue rather than forcing ourselves to try to reach some "virtuous ideal" that I feel is common in some Western philosophy. It's a positive feedback loop because we feel more and more happy from our good acts and helping others so it's easy to continue doing good things. In this way we can continue our organizing and advocating without becoming disheartened or burnt out. I think that you know these things but I just wanted to share that sutra because I find it very informative and inspiring. Another thing that I want to mention is that I don't think any Buddhist teacher (or spiritual teacher in general) that has bad and unvirtuous behavior has any real wisdom. How could they be "enlightened" if they are abusing people and misbehaving when virtue is a prerequisite to deeper states of meditation and therefore wisdom? They are most likely just charismatic people that don't have much experiential wisdom in my opinion. I agree with the statement that even an enlightened person may have some personality quirks but I don't think that they would ever abuse or hurt people (or any being) purposely. Just wanted to share my thoughts. Thanks for all your work Breht! Take care ❤️

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! Yes, well, kinda. We have planned an episode on Trotsky's text on Fascism which may allow for us to get into current events AND I just did a guest spot on a show that will come out on our platform soon where we talk at some length about current issues. But a full on current events show will certainly be on the menu in the coming month at some point - ive just been swamped lately and working through already scheduled episodes and what not!

Rev Left Radio

I really appreciate that, and Im grateful to be able to carve out a unique space in the growing ecosystem of left wing and marxist voices! Always trying to connect the political to the philosophical and the existential! <3

Rev Left Radio

Beautifully stated, my friend, and I could not agree more! Buddhist practice has been the transformative thing for me ethically in a way that no mere philosophy could ever be. As for the guru point, you may very well be right. It never sat well with me and never aligned with my experiences that someone who had been genuinly spiritually developed could behave that way, but I do leave open space for the possibility that people can have unbalanced development, where pure insight is high, but ethical development is low. IDK if thats true, but I at least am open to the idea that it could be! But your point is very well taken and, again, aligns with my undertanding and experience in a way that unethical spiritual leaders do not! In any case, I really appreciate this thoughtful response to the episode and your support of the show! <3

Bill

Wow what a great episode! My own evolutionary path took me from Roman Catholicism to atheism to stoicism to Zen Buddhism while simultaneously moving leftward with my politics— so this episode really touched on a lot of important constructs for me- particularly your point in tying philosophical growth to revolutionary strength. Such great wisdom and advice- thank you for your compassion and generosity in sharing it. You are a true Bodhisatva 🙏…. And one last thing- throughout this episode this quote by Marx kept hitting me: “The philosophers have only interpreted the world, The point however is to change it”. It seems to me that was your point in this episode as well. Anyways, well done!

Rev Left Radio

Wow! Our paths certainly mirror one another's, Bill! I am so glad you enjoyed the episode, and I appreciate the incredibly kind words and your LONGSTANDING support - it means the world to me brother!

Ken S

First- love and solidarity, Breht, you're so much of what i wish i'd been ten years ago; second- how dare you, sir, do *not* come for Eeyore. Eeyore is not a complainer, Eeyore is a truth-teller, disposed to solitude so as not to burden his friends, and if it weren't cultural appropriation i would call him my spirit animal. Anger (from Inside Out) riding Eeyore is actually a tattoo i've considered getting, but that's neither here nor there. i dabbled in Stoicism when i was younger (also in an obnoxious New Atheist phase) but i think i got turned off when i felt like it was too... i don't know- idealistic maybe, or invoked "the gods" too much. Or it was just too much damned reading at the time. Then i ended up gravitating to Buddhism myself- and later Marxism too- and now you've got me thinking that i should take another shot at integrating some Aurelian stoicism because damn if this didn't present him as an admirable figure. But seriously, lay off Eeyore. That noble donkey deserves nothing but our compassion- look at the motley crew of embodied pathologies that pass for his friends. 😛

Lenny

An excellent episode that really resonated with me. One thing I wanted to push back on is I like your dialogue with the source. Cut in as many times as you need. If I want to listen to the source uninterrupted I'll do that on my own time.

Adriaanus Stephanus

Fcck, I can’t stand all the AI-generated videos about stoicism on YouTube. They’re so grossly culty. Thanks for posting this, Brent. I’ve been searching for better understanding of stoicism, but struggled to find something genuine.

Jo Vinova

I haven't listened to an episode from your philosophy series in a while. I almost forgot how moving they are. I'm in the middle of a realignment of focus and priorities so this was really great to hear. "Just ask-a Luigi" 💚

Monty O’Blivion

Listening to this episode after a particular hard couple of days involving multiple panic attacks, and it could not come at a better time, thanks for this Breht. And Happy birthday!

Nolan Alan Good

Fantastic episode! I know this is very off topic, but I’d love to hear your thoughts (perhaps in a future casual, Patreon episode) about some more non-revolutionary but sub-textually quite interesting pop media! Something similar to your Inside episode, but about the show Severance, which I think is full of intriguing things to discuss through a Marxist lens. Im not sure if you have had a chance to watch any of it yet, but I think you would really appreciate it.

SprocketMusic

I do want to push back a little at the idea that absolute power is the ultimate temptation. A tyrants' biggest vice is seldom food or sex or booze or even raw power. It's almost always fear. Usurpers, contenders, competitors. Rivals inside and out. Sword of Damacles shit. Domestically, Marcus Aurelius' power was unrivaled, so he did not weaponize terror. For this he is lionized by historians. But in his Northern military campaigns, where Rome's power was always struggling to expand, Marcus Aurelius was ruthless. The Pax Romana was only a "pax" for the imperial core. As for Fear as a vice, I harp on it because I think it's a useful framework for understanding our current conditions. The backbone of fascism is pretty much always the petite bourgeoisie. They're the ones with something to lose, and the most to fear. Precarity is what leads people to support the most heinous atrocities imaginable. I'd argue that the fear of ruin that the average middle class American faces everyday presents a far greater temptation to stray from virtue than Marcus Aurelius ever faced.

Rev Left Radio

Thats a great idea. I am actually just starting DUNE: Prophesy on HBO and have lots of thoughts about historical materialism and the feudal mode of production in the DUNE series, which takes place in the FUTURE, yet has retreated from capitalism and back into feudalism. this is not lazy writing, but actually interesting and fertile soil for analysis. I havent seen Severence yet, but I do know the basic idea and it seems fascinating. Ill try to see if I can put these thoughts together for the next patreon ep! :)

Rev Left Radio

Super interesting insight and feedback, and spot on with regards to fear and the role it plays in reactionary ideology and decay into fascism! An episode coming out next week with Pokepreet we explore that exact idea in some depth! Your analysis of Aurelius is also very good, I tried to gesture toward that in the episode, but you are 100% correct!

Rev Left Radio

Im sorry to hear you are dealing with anxiety my friend. I send you my love and am glad this episode was useful to you in that regards. Stay strong and refuse to run, my friend! Thank you for the birthday wishes >3

Rev Left Radio

Love hearing that, Jo. Thank you for your support and the kind words!

SprocketMusic

I keep coming back to this episode with new things to reflect on. I love what you said about talking through politics, and finding common ground. Over the course of about 2 years, I went from Bernie Bro to rad lib to Anarchist to Marxist to MLM. I was able to make that evolution entirely because of one friend who not only taught me about revolutionary politics, but who listened to my own perspective and experiences along the way, and took my critiques seriously.

Rev Left Radio

Thats beautiful to hear, my friend! Your development is a solid one, and one many have tread before you! And we all need good comrades and friends to help us along the way - god knows I did! Thank you for your support of the show, it means the world to me!