Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Go like and leave a positive comment on this video on YT to show Adnan some love from the Rev Left Audience please!!!

The Adnan Husain Show: What does spirituality on the left look like? In a Ramadan special, Adnan discusses Buddhism and Sufi Islam, the distinctions between mysticism and mystification, spiritual practices and ethics as well as the liberation of the soul w/Revolutionary Left Radio and former co-host of Guerrilla History, Breht O’Shea.

In a wide ranging and deep conversation about the inner life and the outer world, what it means to be truly human, and transformation socially and personally, Adnan and Breht explore the intersections of left politics and spirituality from the alienation of consumer corporate capitalism and the degradations of imperialism to the defiant dignity and faithful resilience of Gazan resistance.

@adnanahusain on X
adnanahusain.substack.com
    / adnanahusain786   
www.adnanhusain.org

Files

Spiritual Materialism? Left Politics and Marxian Mysticism w/Rev Left Radio’s Breht O’Shea

What does spirituality on the left look like? In a Ramadan special, Adnan discusses Buddhism and Sufi Islam, the distinctions between mysticism and mystification, spiritual practices and ethics as well as the liberation of the soul w/Revolutionary Left Radio and former co-host of Guerrilla History, Breht O’Shea. In a wide ranging and deep conversation about the inner life and the outer world, what it means to be truly human, and transformation socially and personally, Adnan and Breht explore the intersections of left politics and spirituality from the alienation of consumer corporate capitalism and the degradations of imperialism to the defiant dignity and faithful resilience of Gazan resistance. Like, subscribe, share and support (if you can!): www.patreon.com/adnanhusain @adnanahusain on X adnanahusain.substack.com www.youtube.com/adnanahusain786 www.adnanhusain.org Check out sister podcast w/Henry Hakamaki, https://guerrillahistory.libsyn.com Follow Breht’s work at www.revolutionaryleftradio.com and check out the two part series on Mysticism on RLR and Red Menace podcasts: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/on-mysticism-ego-suffering-love https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/on-mysticism-ii-enlightenment-non-duality-perennialism

Comments

Rev Left Radio

Apologies for my bedroom background lol, I dont have a sophisticated looking office in my small ass house XD

Melyss

Mashallah. Beautiful, thank you ❤️

Dylan S. Levi

Hey Rev Left! Random off topic question, but I stumbled into a bit of a rabbit hole on accelerationism and got a little curious as to its origins, its historical application, etc. I'm a little familiar with Nick Land, Curtis Yarvin field but I'm still a little lost. I was wondering if you could maybe do an episode as a general overview? Just a thought, but it would be cool. Edit: Also, as a young high schooler myself, just wanted to say thanks for all the great episodes you've had! They've been a very impactful part of my political education, and have helped inspire me to organize with my friends and fellow community members! On that note, some takes and thoughts on organizing under the context of the Trump administration would also be really cool, especially with regard to ICE raids, mutual aid, etc. but also given the support he's garnered from labor unions this last election. Anyways, take care! - DSL

HackerBoiTellEm

Fancy meeting you here comrade! Hope to see you at the study session with JMP for Wretched of the Earth next weekend! Also behind the bastards, while it's not my favorite podcast, but they have some Yarvin episodes. TrueAnon, which is one of my favorites, also a few episodes on dark enlightenment/technofeudalism bros as well.

louis stephens

Great episode! It’s just what I needed!

Jolene Bresney

Brett- this was beyond words impactful for me. Truly I needed this so much. I tend to sling back and forth with religion. Your perspective was nourishing.💫

Bill

Seriously that was pure gold. You have a real gift and it was nice to put a face to your voice! I used to look down on religion- it’s fantastical thinking, it’s blind faith, it’s dogmatism, it’s hierarchy, it’s divisiveness, it’s sordid history, it’s complacency etc - and yes all that can still be strongly criticized- but perhaps it is worth considering that these criticisms are the result of religion being usurped and exploited by those in power or seeking power (the same fuckers who exploit democratic/secular values). Strip away those grifters and the power structures that support them and what we are left with is simply an embodiment of spiritual yearning that seeks to sanctify and honor the values most humans share or aspire to: love, kindness, compassion, generosity, humility, and caring for others less fortunate. In this light, I can appreciate the value and beauty of religion. As revolutionaries we should aim to liberate spiritual and secular values from those who exploit, commodify, and use them to gain power.

GoldenComrade

Hi Breht I was wondering if you could do an episode with Adnan about an intro into Islam because I've been wanting to pursue both Buddhism and Islam because of your episodes. I am very curious and I want to learn more

Biggus Diccus

Omg pardon my user name I had no idea it was that 🤣🤣🤣

Biggus Diccus

I responded and said I think this person misunderstood your politics and that you would probably agree with most of what they said.

Nick

I'll let Breht answer for himself but one thing I will say is that the Buddha spoke out against the caste system which was present even in his time and said it was just a made up thing by humans which went against the belief that the Gods had set the caste system in place. Spirituality can free us or confine us. And we always have to remember that all religions (and perhaps philosophies and beliefs in general) will be used by the ruling class to consolidate power. Its up to us to be vigilant regarding this power and hold ourselves accountable for any dogmatic beliefs. That's the nature of living in a class society, and it won't really be until class society is done away with that religion and spirituality can really flourish without all the downsides.

Rev Left Radio

This is a great opportunity to explain my engagement with this stuff, and in fact I just submitted a book proposal to a publisher to see if I can write a whole book literally *using dialectical materialism* to bring together the outer liberation on offer from Marxist revolution and the inner revolution made possible by Buddhist practice (and other forms of spiritual and psychological practices), and synthesizing core concepts from both traditions into a dialectical and historical materialist framework and account of human development. In short, this person, while well-intentioned, is arguing in a way that is counter to dialectical materialism, which is about addressing the totality of a thing, including its contradictions, its kernels of truth, and its relationship to the whole. My argument is that if we want total transformation and genuine liberation we have to take the outer, political, and social transformation of revolution seriously *as well as* the inner, psychological transformation that allows us to transcend the subjectivity conditioned into us through thousands of years of class society. Che Guevara (and even Lenin's wife) talked of a new type of person to be developed under socialism... We cannot bring the same old conditioned egoic subjectivity of class society into a project meant to transcend class society -- we may be able to push into socialism, but will not be able to achieve and sustain full communism without an inner maturation beyond ego-identification. There is NOTHING idealist about this whatsoever. There are of course deep idealist strains in all forms of religion and spirituality, but critiquing, engaging, and incorporating their truths through the prism of dialectical materialism is better than writing them off entirely as hopelessly idealist and thus only worth discarding. Consciousness is shaped by the material base of society, and in turn helps maintain that base. If we want to advance the material base of socialism, and then achieve communism, that will absolutely come with a shift in human consciousness. The material reality is primary, but both are essential and feed into one another. Mao understood the importance of a revolution in the superstructure via the cultural revolution! I am merely attempting to take that core insight a bit further and offer a PRACTICAL and time-tested way of beginning to develop that consciousness alongside the political work or organizing and struggle. I have NEVER said that spiritual practices alone are causal, are without their own forms of error and co-optation, or that they should be prioritized over material struggle. To the contrary. So overall, this person fundamentally misunderstands what I am arguing for and what I am attempting to advance, again with good intention and genuine insight which i do not dismiss or denigrate. If my book gets approved, ill make these arguments in extreme detail and will be able to address in a deep, systematic way! :)

Rev Left Radio

"As revolutionaries we should aim to liberate spiritual and secular values from those who exploit, commodify, and use them to gain power." absolutely, my friend! well said!!! Thank you!

Rev Left Radio

I am so glad to hear that Jolene, thank you so much for your longstanding support!

Rev Left Radio

lmao the username and you forgetting you had it made me bust out laughing XD

Joe

I'm not Breht but I am a phd student in philosophy and studied some Buddhist philosophy during my master's degree so might be able to help you out (in addition to @Rev Left Radio 's own comment). The person offering this critique has a number of mistaken views about Buddhism which really just seems to stem from vast over generalisations about "spirituality". Lumping Buddhism and all other forms of spirituality together this way really just seems to betray an Orientalist attitude. Unless they're also including Western faiths like Christianity, Islam, etc in with "spirituality". If that's the case, the category of "spirituality" is essentially useless for the purposes of critique because of how radically, say, Christian theological and metaphysical ideas diverge from Buddhist ones. For example, Buddhists don't really believe in anything like God as a designer of the universe. So of course Buddhists are never going to think that the universe is "just how God designed it". Perhaps they *do* "naturalise" the conditions of human society in some other way but it's not clear to me that they do. And to be honest even modern Christians don't really do that. There are also, of course, more reformist tendencies within any religion which Breht has expressed sympathy with before (I recall Breht doing a reading of the article "Politics in the Dharma Hall" which argued essentially for a kind of political reformism of Buddhist Sanghas). There are of course strains of what look obviously like metaphysical idealism in the Buddhist tradition. And perhaps they are even the dominant strains. But then again there are very materialist-looking strains as well (e.g. the atomism of the Abhidharma). And then there are other strains which seemingly reject both materialism and idealism (the Madhyamika, followers of Nagarjuna). This is why I say that critiquing Buddhism in the way this person does risks Orientalism or oversimplification, where Eastern ideas are treated as monolithic and understood purely in terms of spooky, supernatural "woo woo". The Buddhist tradition spans huge swathes of land, many different cultures over many centuries. Of course you will find deep diversity of thought there just as you find very significant diversity of thought across European philosophy between, say, the ancient, medieval, and renaissance periods, and between Greece and Britain. And crucially, these Buddhist philosophers were very precise, systematic thinkers who are worth engaging with meaningfully in their own right rather than rejecting on their face on the basis of being "idealists". Also, a focus on metaphysical idealism vs metaphysical materialism is inevitably going to produce mistakes. I'm not actually sure much of being a good Marxist turns on being a metaphysical materialist in the style of early moderns like Hobbes. In fact, this kind of materialism is exactly what Marx called "vulgar" materialism, which he thought was a mistaken view. On the whole, I think Marx and other, later Marxists have expressed views which you could characterise as broadly "anti-metaphysical" or, to put things perhaps more weakly, are hostile to those who focus too much on "pure" metaphysical questions like the question of metaphysical materialism vs idealism rather than questions tied to the natural sciences and actual "practice". Just anecdotally, it seems to me that *very very many* contemporary Marxists make this mistake i.e. of understanding "dialectical materialism" as essentially some kind of unification of vulgar materialism with Marxism. This should be avoided. Couple this with the fact that, if you actually look at the intellectual history, Engels had high praises for the Buddhists, referring to Buddhism at one point as the "highest development of dialectics" in its day. Many commentators have also remarked on the similarities between the thought of various Buddhists and Spinoza who, through the German idealists, had a great influence on Marxism. And there is work being done now on the contact that German idealists had with eastern thought, including Buddhist and Hindu works (even if Hegel in particular, as a result of the more racist parts of his thought, adopted quite a hostile attitude towards Eastern ideas). Obviously these are German *idealists* I'm talking about, but they still had a massive influence on Marxism - Marx's project wasn't just one of outright rejection of all that came before him. The contemporary mathematician/logician/philosopher Graham Priest also has a lot to say about Marxism and Buddhism, so it's worth checking out his book "Capitalism - its Nature and its Replacement: Buddhist and Marxist Insights" for more. I've not read all of it but have looked at a few chapters and iirc he says a lot of agreeable stuff. Note that Priest is a controversial figure in analytic philosophy (which is mainly where I work) but most of what I've read/heard from him about the interaction between Marxism and Buddhism seems perfectly reasonable to me. And to be clear, when I say he's "controversial", it's not because he's viewed as a crank, but rather that he defends some very controversial views about formal logic, mathematics, and ontology. I hope that was helpful.

Trisha

Breht you are brilliant and inspiring. I wish I had a pinch of as much eloquence as you have, want to keep learning so I can one day share in more in depth discussions with people. Any recommendations for intro books to Buddhism? 🙏

Biggus Diccus

Thank you for such a detailed response. You’re awesome man keep on doing the things.

Max

@Joe: I can't respond to your comment directly because the OP got deleted, but you make a couple of interesting points. I think we may be mistaken to single out Buddhism as uniquely suited for materialism. It is a matter of spirituality and religion in general. Buddhism, historically and contemporarily, also appears as idealist. Conversely, I deem it very possible to articulate a kind of materialist spirituality in terms of Christianity and probably any other religion as well. That does not mean they do not differ. They constitute different perspective with their own blindspots and problematic tendencies. To approach it abstractly, I think Buddhism veers to a kind of “negative idealism” while Christianism has a more “positive idealism”. Buddhism may not suffer from the superstitions that come with a more personal conception of God - to which we may be more attuned to since we grew up with them - but it begets its own problems. Notions of “ego death”, “annihilation of the self” or anti-subjectivity can have very anti-social conequences if not sublated into a materialist base of collective identity. Oneself might commit sympathetic “orientalism” by looking for an answer in the Far East instead of within the troubled but rich history of religion in front of our own doors. I say this from a very European perspective. The American position may differ. And none of what I say should discourage any already established and thriving spiritual practice. Just food for thought. And as a sidenote: I think the conflation of Marxism with “vulgar materialism” stems from the fact that Marx’ and Engel’s materialism was themselves a tad vulgar. This may be forgiven as they were more concerned with liberating themselves from reactionary shackles (and did so with swinging fists) than to reach complete nuance and refinement. So some of their conceptions might not have been fully caught up by their dialectics. Specifically, concerning questions of metaphysics, which turned out to be not so obsolete after all.

Joe

I did mention in my original comment that Buddhism hasn't always been "idealist" and that, even so, the sense in which it is idealist doesn't obviously overlap with the kind of idealism that Marxists oppose. But I agree that religion and spirituality very broadly conceived can be made consistent with historical materialism and Marxism (though you would have to have a very unorthodox understanding of the life and legacy of Jesus to be a 100% committed historical materialist Christian). As for the orientalism thing, I have no idea why looking to eastern thought and cultures for interesting ideas and answers to philosophical questions would be "sympathetic orientalism"? So long as you're paying attention to the nuances and not making silly generalisations about those traditions of thought. It's seems really odd to me to suggest that we should look at the spiritual/religious ideas prevalent in our own culture over others. That strikes me as obviously wrong. And I may well agree with you about Marx and Engels' vulgar materialism, at least that I could be convinced that they (especially Engels) accidentally dip into a kind of vulgar materialism now and again. I'd have to do some rereading of the relevant texts and think more about it say definitively if you're right there. But regardless, that's not the only reason that contemporary Marxists fall into the trap of vulgar materialism. I think it's partly just because vulgar materialism is a much simpler set of doctrines than the doctrines contained within historical/dialectical materialism.

Max

I did not mean that we should look at ideas prevalent in our own culture over others. I was trying to say that one can romanticise cultures which are far away from us. With Buddhism in particular, its role as instrument of a ruling class tends to be downplayed, so that Buddhism appears as form of pure spirituality, unsullied by the corruption we spot in the Western traditions. Morevover, the flimsier the historical connection to a certain tradition, the more effort has to be spent in order to prospect for substantive meaning.

Joe

Well you say that you didn't mean to say that we should look at "our" ideas first but then you say this thing about how "the flimsier the historical connection to a certain tradition, the more effort has to be spent in order to prospect for substantive meaning". Seems like you're having your cake and eating it here - you clearly think that there's something more useful about one's "own" cultural tradition. I have no idea why you would think that. Do you just mean that it might take longer to read and understand? That being said, I do agree with you to some extent about the use of Buddhism in class domination. Absolutely it is not free from those sorts of historical connotations. However, I think it's still different in kind from Christianity in that respect. Though I also think it's obviously possible for a Christians or Muslims to disown all of that stuff and engage with their faith on an anti-imperial basis, for example. So that stuff doesn't *necessarily* count against any religious tradition imo.

Max

To read a book in your own language is a lot easier, than to have to learn a foreign language and pick up on other cultural nuances etc. This is similar to religious practices that require a lot of cultural intuiton in a sense. That does not make it unworthwile to engange with foreign ideas. Quite the opposite, bringing different perspectives into your inherited culture can be incredibly fruitful, not least to help bridge the gap between peoples. However, since it requires more effort it would really have to be your focus, therefore I dont see it as a feasible way for everyone. So if you dont have a spiritual journey in the centre of your life, it might be easier to stick to what reveals itself to you in your vincinity. Whereas, many leftists can have quite a negative attitude towards their own culture. In most cases, I perceive this as somewhat wasteful. And to open a can of worms in passing, I dont think it is neccessary or helpful to disown parts of your history. Similar to when Marxists try to disown Stalin et al. That is what can, for example, stunt the engangement with a religion to its mystical aspects and forego all the wonderful lessons of organised religion. The mystical wing of any religion, not coincidentally, being the "radical left deviation", the "anarchism of religion" so to speak.