Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Todd McGowan joins the show once again, this time to discuss his newest book "Pure Excess: Capitalism and the Commodity". Together, he and Breht discuss commodity fetishism, the tensions between Marxism and psychoanalysis, what a critique of the subjective aspects of capitalism offers anti-capitalist politics, the "superstructural malaise" of late capitalism, Desire and Lack, capitalism's death drive, how to resist becoming a neoliberal subject, and much more. 

"Drawing on psychoanalytic theory, McGowan shows how the production of commodities explains the role of excess in the workings of capitalism. Capitalism and the commodity ensnare us with the image of the constant fulfillment of our desires―the seductive but unattainable promise of satisfying a longing that has no end. To challenge this system, McGowan turns to art, arguing that it can expose the psychological mechanisms that perpetuate capitalist society and reveal the need for limits. Featuring lively writing and engaging examples from film, literature, and popular culture, Pure Excess uncovers the hidden logic of capitalism―and helps us envision a noncapitalist life in a noncapitalist society."

Check out all our other episodes with Todd HERE

Check out Todd's podcast Why Theory? on your preferred podcast app!

Outro Song: I Want to Work Less by Grand Commander

Files

Comments

Saya Clarke

Started my day listening to Shoeless which I have recently become a fan of. I gotta be honest it’s really grown on me even though originally I wasn’t into it. I found the narration of the meteor impact juxtaposed with the thoughtful and hopeful conversation about love and life, marriage and parenthood to be hauntingly sweet and entertaining. So tell Dave great fucking job to the both of you. This episode with Todd was great too. I always get so much out of his guest spots and I just want to say I am so grateful that you both expressed skepticism towards “Techno-Feudalism” as I share that same skepticism and having previously heard you use that term in a prior episode I thought maybe you understood something about it that I simply did not. I find Varakovis to be a bit hubristic in his aesthetic dressing up of what is straightforwardly still a capitalist mode of production. I also don’t like how he goes on about “All those other people aren’t actually communists, I’m a real communist like people used to be. I actually value freedom and they don’t.” He also calls himself like a libertarian communist or Marxist or something which is something that really gets my goat and makes me roll my eyes. One more thing, I just want to say thank you so much Breht for getting me connected to Alyson! We had such a fun time together and I got a flood of appreciative messages from DSA members in chapters all over the country. It was really a huge hit and I couldn’t have pulled that off without your help. Love and solidarity comrade!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for the kind words about Shoeless! Its def way different than anything else I do, more insular in some ways, and harder to get into it - and thats on purpose tbh. But its great to hear this sort of feedback. Im alwasy trying to experiment with stuff on that show too, so its def weirder than anything else I do too haha. I agree with your take on Varafoukis(?) too. I havent heard him explicitly say hes arguing its a new mode of production, but that is how it comes off when he talks about it. This is PURE capitalism through and through, and its letting capitalism off the hook to pretend otherwise. But yea, while he is useful and a good dude, he def has limitations and always has, but perhaps we all do in the end! Either way, I agree with your analysis 100%. So happy that event happened and went off well -- I had NO DOUBT that it would. Alyson is such a genuine, sweet, thoughtful, and sharply intellectual human being. One of the best people Ive ever known. You two hitting it off doesnt suprise me at all! :) Great work, Saya!

Ken S

Taking in the whole Rev Left back catalog since Oct 2023, plus sole's music (which you introduced me to, to my eternal gratitude), plus meditating with Buddhists for ~20 yrs myself... this whole episode feels spot on. You've *gotta'* un-fuck yourself, internally, before you can ever hope to be ready to live in the new world- much less contribute much to creating it; if you don't, you'll bring the monstrosity you're trying to transcend with you, in your baggage.

Bill

Great conversation! I kept thinking throughout the episode how pertinent and beneficial it might be to explore the ideas of the Frankfurt School- notably Theodore Adorno- critical theory - the critique of western pop culture from a Marxism/Freudian lens.

Rev Left Radio

Oh yea, Id say Todd is definitely in that tradition. Im sure Ive done an episode on the Frankfurt School at some point in the past, but always worth a revisit for sure!

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely. A few have criticized me on this account as an idealist, but thats from a mechanical materialist view. Dialectically, the inner and the outer develop together and both contribute to overall development, thus both need to be accounted for and pushed forward! This is our responsibility to ourselves and to the future!

Lana

I’m only 17 mins in right now but damn I’m hooked. I hope this one will be unlocked for the public at some point. I know so many people that need to hear this! 😅 As a side note I hope your surgery recovery is going well Breht! ❤️‍🩹

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Lana, im 5 days out from surgery and recovering well. Still pain and immobility, but getting better :) and yes, this episode drops on the public feed tomorrow!

Rosanna Fields

Breht, I need you to know i love you and your work before I say this, so you understand I'm good faith, comrade. But I am rubbed the entirely wrong way by what Todd said about "capitalists are the ones selling transition", "widely avaliable transition is the product of the development of capital", in the context of talking about how conservatives are mad about things related capital but dont know it. I'm gonna need some explanation, because when I take this proposal to it's logical conclusion, all I see is conservatives taking that, or people who distort marxism such as the ACP, saying that the scientific developments of gender affirming care is tied directly to capital and is inherently bad and trans people and trans Healthcare are a product of capitalism, so therefore trans Healthcare and people shouldnt exist and won't exist under socialism, and therefore trans Healthcare and trans people should be attacked under the guise of critiquing capitalism. If you can elborate if im getting this wrong or he isnt saying its a bad thing necesarily, I'd appreciate it.

Mike

Chris Hayes’s recent appearance on Know Your Enemy I think is relevant to this Rev Left episode and I thought I’d share: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/know-your-enemy/id1462703434?i=1000693629719&r=1051 They discuss Hayes’ new book called The Sirens’ Call: How Attention Became the World's Most Endangered Resource. Here’s an excerpt in The Atlantic from Jan 22 2025. https://archive.is/P78LS From the KYE episode: “The algorithmic feed is an assembly line of the mind. It's an incredibly awe-inspiring product of technological capitalism that rationalizes each moment to its maximum profit-making end, and in doing so, has stripped something profound out of us as human beings that exist outside of the market.” They also discuss the effects of the attention economy on religion, spirituality, their own relationship to Catholicism, and how “boredom and holiness that are inseparable from each other.”

Mike

The recent one-day Economic Blackout was briefly brought up, and Breht, I wanted to get your thoughts on that and its actual utility. No shade on anyone who participated/will keep participating in it, found value in it, and felt empowered by it. I think there is something there that raises consciousness about ethical consumption and living under this system we’re all in. And it also felt like another version of resistance lib virtue signaling. A few celebs who promoted it said, “We have the power!” Yet it’s framing ourselves as consumers and less as consequential political actors. It also exposes some tone-deaf class privilege amongst my friends and peers. A lot of people have to rely on Amazon and big box stores because they live in food desserts, don’t have access to other options, and can’t afford to just shop at one store, esp one with high prices. We live in a petit bourgeois shithole. It also seemed like a defense of companies getting rid of their DEI programs - which to be fair is absolutely two-faced bullshit - rather than a larger, more broad interrogation of labor politics and exploitation. For instance, Whole Foods and Trader Joe’s weren’t on any boycott lists I saw (please correct me if they were). WF is owned by Amazon and are a top-down shitty company, and TJ is in active litigation (along with Bezos and Musk) to dissolve the NLRB. Again, I’m not disregarding the boycott wholesale. Historically boycotts have worked and have been effective to varying degrees - but they were done concurrently with other actions and tactics. Mass activism shouldn’t begin and end with what’s essentially spectator politics.

Luke

Hi Breht, great ep. I was trying to find an episode about the civil war in Myanmar and can't locate it. May have been on Guerrilla History idk. Any help is appreciated. Thanks

Opal

Yeah, I want to give Todd the benefit of the doubt but it was... An eyebrow raising part for sure

Rev Left Radio

Totally agree with you wholeheartedly. I forgot he mentioned that, was only dimly aware of the thing in the first place. But yea, your analysis of it is spot on and resonates totally with me own, Mike!!

Rev Left Radio

I listened to that actually haha. Hayes can be interesting at times (hes actually read marx and references him fairly often), and I like Know Your Enemy overall as well! Definitely appreciate the analysis of the attention economy, and like many others am in a constant state of tension with my devices too. I resent it and struggle to find a balance, but I never stop trying!

Rev Left Radio

I went back and looked at the transcript to get the exact verbiage cuz i didnt remember that part until I read this comment, but the way I took it was simply one admittedly very clumsy extemporaneous example of how the technological advances wrought by capitalism bring about things that conservatives don't like but is in contradiction with their love and defense of Capitalism as a system. Reflecting back on that now, you are correct that its a weird and unwise example. I believe he was TRYING to find something the right is REALLY riled up about and then work backwards form there to make that point, but I def see how it came off in the wrong way. In my years of knowing and listening to Todd, there has never been anything he's ever said that would indicate in any way that he is transphobic or against medical transitions or trans people, so I think he was just trying to find a hot topic on the right and then tie it to capitalism and walked himself into a bad example that didn't hit the mark in the way he intended. But yea, your hesitation about that and your logical elaboration makes a lot of sense and is a totally valid criticism of him using that to make a point he could have made much better using almost any other example. Based on everything I know about Todd my deep instinct is to be charitable here wrt his intentions, while fairly pointing out and criticizing him for fumbling this point for sure. LMK if that sounds right to you, or if you think I am off the mark here!

Raquelle Jac

Random question - when getting organized, how do you deal with dumb petty interpersonal shit that arises? I feel like organizing has always felt out of reach for me due to social and mental health issues but recently I've felt more confident and jumped in head first with a local chapter of an org. But I'm crashed and burning rn. Weird social bullshit and weird competitiveness and defensiveness has overshadowed the solidarity I briefly found. I'm sensitive, I feel like a POS most of the time, so my tenacity during uncomfortable social situations can be variable .

Rosanna Fields

I agree with what you're saying, i listened to it a few times, and i see the point hes trying to make, and I definitely don't sense any ill will or anything like that. even if I wish he used a different example that doesn't have a history of being used by reactionaries who claim to be leftists who are upholding an anti-trans line. Definitely no ill will or anything like that, Todd is an amazing ally

Andrew Blake

At approximately 1:06:40 your guest makes a comment about how China being the only country not to give up on climate change is a scary prospect. I wish you had interrogated that, bc it left me pretty confused about how that would be scary. Is it scary in the sense that they're the only one doing anything, so there's not much hope? Or is it scary in the more liberal, reflexively sinophobic sense that we don't want China taking over as world leader in anything? I'm trying to give him the benefit of the doubt that it wasn't the latter, even though that's the immediate impression I had from his tone. And if he did mean it in that latter sense then it defintely required pushback.

Trisha

Great episode Breht. Took me down the rabbit hole listening to Grand Commander for the first time. 🙏❤️✨️

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate you pointing it out though, and your points still absolutely hold and are worth thinking deeply about. <3

Rev Left Radio

haha hell yea! My 17 year old niece actually introduced me to them a few weeks back, so shell be happy to hear it spreading!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, I think he has an unfortunate liberal line on China. It never comes up in our convos, but that point did squeak past. Its not scary at all, China is leading the way in so many areas including being a MUCH more responsible agent on the global stage than any western power, and its disheartening to hear a friend or comrade express that fear. In retrospect, I could have nailed him down on that, but I actually thought it might just generate more anti-china stuff which was irrelevant to the convo. Hard call to make in the moment tbh, but Im open to having made the wrong one. Apologies.

Rev Left Radio

This is the exact problem I try to address through advocating that organizers take inner work, spiritual practices meant to transcend the ego, cultivating virtues and maturity that make communication and problem-solving and conflict navigation better and productive, etc. This is what I mean that people who want to change the world but cant change themselves, cant grow up, cant push the limits of their own being, ultimately act as limitations and caps on building the world we want to build. Some orgs are better than others, for damn sure, but it is inevitable if one organizes long enough that youll run into such stuff. Finding a couple good comrades and working more closely with them can help, while staying out of petty, ego-driven nonsense as much as possible and setting an example of how to be better can be helpful. Sometimes orgs are rotted out by this behavior and exploring new orgs is the only path forward. Some good orgs do a lot of work addressing this stuff as people come in through political education that really help prevent this stuff from cropping up in the first place. Its a hard call, and very dependent on specific orgs and chapters -- but again, it goes to the very heart of why Im always emphasizing the necessity of inner growth and maturation, because this type of shit is exactly what we have to overcome if we want to move forward. Notice that the "dumb petty interpersonal shit" is all ego-driven. Its ALWAYS boils down to that! Plus people are conflict adverse or drama-addicted, and both are rooted in the ego and an inability to see things from outside of it.

Andrew Blake

It is a hard call and I don't blame you given the needs of the show/ topic at hand. Maybe just a quick joke like "not scary for me!" Before keeping it moving... but yeah much easier said now than done in the moment

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

I had never heard of this podcast and I’m listening to this episode right now so thanks for the recommendation! The harmful effects of social media and the attention economy seems to be one of the few things that transcends political ideology. I’ve never talked to someone who disputes that social media in general is bad for us. I remember in social media’s infancy you used to be able to filter your feed in such a way that you could avoid all the brain rot but you can’t even do that anymore. Instagram claims if you report posts and click “suggest less,” over time those posts will be removed from your feed but I’ve found they don’t even work. I’ve reported numerous inappropriate posts and Instagram always comes back after their “investigation” and say they found it doesn’t violate community standards. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Rev Left Radio

You are right. Its something I consciously want to get better at - to stop thinking of it as derailing or creating awkwardness and start thinking about it as a nice opportunity to deepen the convo, offer a friendly critique, and create space to showcase how uncomfortable disagreements can be had in real time and in a way that is productive. I appreciate the critical but comradely feedback on this!

Dave Miles

Great interview. And I’ll take the stance that the only reason that it’s “scary” that China is the only country still pushing against climate catastrophe is that it’s the ONLY country pushing against it in any meaningful way. If our mate thinks “China baaad, OK?”, that’s a cross for him to bear.😉

Benny Boy

Amazing introduction encapsulating why we can all feel so empty (the best intro Breht has done so far). Rest of the show was great too. He's a likeable guest

Eric Ripa

lol same here! Rev left has been a great source for finding some new music for me. It would be cool to have a combined list of all the exit music somewhere!

Derek

I was really interested in this convo and am now reading Todd's book, maybe a quarter to a third in. It's a little repetitive at times but otherwise super interesting and giving me lots to think about. Nothing slows me down reading like philosophy! But I can't help but feel there's something a bit off on his entire framing around utility vs uselessness. The useful is only that which directly reproduces the social order. All else is "useless" or "excess," but the way he repeatedly uses these terms and applies them to examples suggests that for him there is zero human utility in beauty or aesthetics. The end result comes off as a rather coldly rational appraisal of human life and society. One example that gets at this is his assertion that only sex without reproduction involved is pleasurable. Having experienced both, I take his point that our culture idolizes one more, that its very excessiveness and risk imbue it with a greater sublimity in our fetishized ideal of it, but I've also experienced sex within a reproductive intent as utterly sublime, spiritual, etc. I guess I feel like the whole book rests on somewhat shaky foundations in this respect, though I'm getting a ton of value out of thinking my way through it.

Trisha

Agree! Any other gems off the top of your head I should check out? I suck at finding new music so also am grateful for the extra nugget of awesomeness in the episodes.

Eric Ripa

I have really enjoyed AJJ that Breht has mentioned a few times. Bambu’s latest album has been on repeat for a bit too. It also helped me rediscover some of my favorites from my young adulthood, but those are mostly in Swedish so probably not very relevant! 😊

Trisha

Hey thanks! I will check both out and appreciate the reply. ✨️🙏

SprocketMusic

I've noticed that every time there's a crisis, a bunch of libs come in and try to reinvent organizing. Usually it's a call for a general strike, and spread via memes with no broader organization involved. When it fails, they inevitably say "it would have worked; you just gotta believe." The thing that struck me about the no purchase day is that it wasn't even bold enough to make a fake call for anything subsantial. It's exactly as you said: a misinterpretation of the dynamics of power. People view their consumption rather than their labor as the source of people's power.

Rev Left Radio

Those are really deep and thoughtful critiques Derek. WRT to the utility question is he talking about utility as a commodity under capitalism, or general utility? I cant remember that full section tbh. Your point about reproductive sex is definitely interesting and I agree with you. When my wife and I were trying for a baby, it added an insane amount of pleasure and thrill that non-reproductive sex never quite matches. It just felt like the sex was soooo much more consequential and had that element of literal life-creation that was astounding and created the spiritual sublimity you are talking about! Very interesting point, my friend! truly.

Derek

He seemed to be making larger claims about human utility/uselessness in that section, rather than just how it manifests in the commodity form, which is why I found it so objectionable. But like I said, doesn't invalidate many other valuable claims to chew on throughout. :)

Benny Boy

For me, the best intro you've done (and they've always been very good). Sums up the malaise of modern capitalist society perfectly.

PuebloCO Jenin

All that talk about good movies, especially anti-capitalist, leaning South Korean movies, would sure like a list. Any chance of that?