Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht speaks with Robert E. Wilson, author of The Football Manifesto and The Supporters Trust League Manifesto. Together they explore what it means to socialize sports; to reclaim the Beautiful Game from billionaire owners, corrupt institutions, and imperial powers, and return it to the people as a democratic, community-owned, and liberatory project.

Together, they examine the ways professional sports in the imperial core normalize colonialism, militarism, racism, and capitalism, while grassroots football worldwide has long been a site of resistance, solidarity, and struggle.

From the NFL’s “plantation economics” to the vision of supporter-owned clubs, equal pay for women’s teams, and football as a hub of political education and mutual aid, this conversation makes clear that sports are never “just games.” They are battlefields for ideology and community -- as well as an expression of our nature as social beings -- and if reclaimed, they can become engines of solidarity,healthy communities, and socialist culture. Whether you are a sports fan or not, you will get a LOT out of this fascinating and surprisingly wide-ranging conversation!

Gaia Labs HERE

Behind the Shield documentary on the NFL by Dave Zirin HERE

Black Alliance for Peace petition to ban Israel and US HERE

Files

Comments

louis stephens

Is anyone able to list the books the guest mentioned towards the beginning of the episode?

louis stephens

This is truly an amazing episode as well

Curtis

I know this doesn't directly pertaining to this episode, but are you thinking of doing another fantasy football league in the future, depending on how your apprenticeship goes? I missed out on it last year and didn't hear you mention it this year.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I am. Am thinking about an NBA fantasy league for this year, I just had too many nfl ones last year tbh. Lots of people join but then give up or whatever cuz theres nothing on the line. So I decided to only join leagues with buy ins so everyone is invested. Thinking about doing the same for a RLR NBA fantasy league and if that goes well, do a fantasy football league next year w a buy in too!

Curtis

I completely agree. I'm definitely up for a buy in NBA league this year /NFL next year if you put one together. Also, props on the new apprenticeship 👊

Jolene Bresney

as someone not really interested in american rugby- i genuinely loved this. fascinating

Max

Very interesting episode. Although I think it may be a bit of an overdramatisation to call “soccer” the “slave name” of football. Refering to American football as “American rugby” within the United States also seems unnecessarily abrasive and moralising to people there who might just enjoy the sport. Shedding light on the historic roots and how they relate to class struggle is important, but we should also acknowledge the transformation that has taken place since then. To plead a different case in favour of European football however, I think it is a beautiful game for its philosophical properties especially. Unlike American football that deals a lot with pre-conceived plays and set pieces or baseball the rigidity and individual focus of which enables an almost complete mathematical description (like in “Moneyball”), football has a fluidity to it that naturally favours dialectical thinking. There is almost no other sport in which MVP is a less meaningful title, as it is practically impossible to evaluate a single player’s performance outside of his relation to his teammates and his opponents. Everything depends on context. Players cannot draw on set tactics out of a playbook, but instead they have to work with more abstract principles in order to continuously construct their system under changing circumstances. This poses some interesting tactical problems. Indivdiual performance or mathematical statistics are not rendered useless, but they can only be made sense of when taking into account the conditions that they arise in (to a larger degree than in most other sports). It can appear a bit boring at first and like in every sport not every match is excting. However, football’s low-scoring nature is at the same time the source of boredom as well as of ecstatic excitement. For an uninterest party, a 0-0 may be boring and not much of a spectacle. If you are rooting for a team however, the fact that while not many goals are scored overall, there could be a goal at any point, creates an incredible tension, that can erupt in an almost orgasmic release once a goal finally happens. The most exciting game of my life, lasted 113 minutes until its first goal, when Mario Götze finally brought salvation to a whole nation by securing the World Cup. With the scores being so low, a lead is rarely secure and even a weaker team can land a lucky punch and turn around a game suddenly. It is “unfair” enough, that the dominant team does not automatically win and is never completely safe, but not too unfair so as not to reward effort in the long run. Which is a good mix for a spectator sport. Also, for the initiated, in each game there is a lot that happens between the lines that can be interesting on its own, even if not a lot of goals are resulting from it. Though you need to know what to look for. Keeping track of 22 players can be daunting. But again, it is at the edge where it it is still possible to understand whats going on despite the complexity. It is possible to have an enjoyable superficial experience just casually rooting for your team, but you can also engage with it on a deep level if you’d like to. Therefore catering to many different people. Finally, football is probably one of the most universal team sports in the world. It can be played almost anywhere and does not require too much expensive equipment. A ball and two backpacks to delineate a goal line can be all you need to play in the park. It also has roles for a relatively large variety of body types (unlike e.g. Basketball). You can make use of your tallness, but being small gives you a lower certre of gravity and enables a better control of the ball (look at Messi’s physique). Bulk can be useful, but too much also slows you down. Of course, you have to be able bodied and fit enough to run a whole lot. But for a sport, it can bring many different people together as well as many different nations.

Monty Fuch

Breht, congrats with this one. It is almost 3 hours yet still as a listener I feel as if yourself and Robert only just scratched the surface. I could have listened intently for a lot longer, honestly. Sports are an essential terrain of struggle and a real way to get people plugged in to our worldview via the mechanism of a pastime that inspires raw human passion. For what’s it’s worth, I don’t think ‘American rugby’ as a term is gonna take off. It’s an American podcast with predominantly American listeners. ‘American football’ and ‘soccer’ is fine by me (a Scotsman, for transparency). The word soccer originates from the official term from the Victorian age ‘asSOCiation football’ anyway. But I digress. I would have liked more critique on why there is so much obscene wealth swirling around sports in the first place, and how sport might look under socialism. Football is by no means immune to this and I would not want listeners to be under the illusion that the model of fan ownership in some cases in Europe in any way exempts football from the deprivations of neoliberalism. Football has become an ‘enclosed commons’. Many supporters of the game in Britain continue to do so mainly out of the communities and relationships they have developed in their lifetimes and the nourishment for the soul they get from this, but not so much from the actual fortunes of following their team. Money corrupts. The beautiful game has become like the picture of Dorian Gray - aloof, detached, insulated players and managers that no longer represent the communities they came from, mass manufactured in elite level academies that only wealthy families can afford to send their kids to. There was outcry and indignation when Roy Keane signed a deal earning him £100,000/week around 2004/2005. Today Erling Haaland receives approximately £860,000/week and people have become accustomed to accept this as normal. Realise I’ve gone off on a tangent by now but the point being - great listen and there was a lot more to be covered, if time permitted. Sport under the Soviet Union, for instance? Clearly not organised under a profit-seeking model yet still achieved many successes and triumphs. Those interested in football/soccer try this Reddit thread for size (How could the imbalance of football financially be fixed?): https://www.reddit.com/r/football/comments/1jxgj5m/comment/n3tyv5b/?context=3

Rev Left Radio

haha I agree about the word football, its here to stay! Still fun to explore. thank you for the feedback, and Im so glad you enjoyed the ep. I had a great time having the convo, and hope even non-sports folks listen, cuz it really is worth it imho!

Rev Left Radio

I agree with you about the verbiage, though its still fun to explore the semantics of it. I def use "football" and "soccer" like a regular american outside of this convo haha. You make a STRONG and fascinating case for soccer, truly... Ive never gotten into it, but my wifes family are, so I play once in a while and watch some big games with them. Still, ill have to dive deeper! Your class point about futbol is pot on too! absolutely!

Monty Fuch

To your point about football’s fluidity and expressiveness compared to the rigid scientific nature of American sports, you will have noticed how football is unfortunately trending towards this end of the spectrum. At the top levels of the game, fewer and fewer ‘styles’ of play. 4-3-3 and a high press. Used to be certain body types and physiques would suit certain positions on the field. Now every player is an elite athlete who has to be able to run and run for up to 100 minutes a game with the absurd amount of added on time for VAR and up to 5 substitutions now instead of 3 as it was for so long. The increased prestige and prize money for winning in football engenders a win-at-all costs playing philosophy that trickles right down to schoolboy level and ultimately stifles creativity in the game. The wonderful thing about football throughout the 20th century was not necessarily the winning or losing but the moments that might happen that take your breath away. Bobby Moore’s perfectly-timed tackle on Jairzinho 1970, Gerd Müller scoring in the penalty box despite having almost no time to see the ball and no backlift in his shot, Maradona vs England, Messi vs Getafe, the Cruyff turn. Things that people will pay to go and watch and be glad they did, being able to say “I was there when..” Now it’s all just my system vs your system until someone make a mistake. Very few flair players anymore. P.S. I have watched some thrilling 0-0’s over the years! Arguably Wayne Rooney’s greatest performance for Everton came in a 0-0 draw at home to Bolton as a 17-year-old.

Wes Rich

Such an incredibly interesting episode. I learned a ton and think it’s such an important topic but also a really easy way to sneak some socialist ideals into a conversation with an otherwise not politically engaged person. Years ago I made a Change.org petition for the city of Houston to either expropriate or purchase the Houston Texans and just checked on it and noticed it’s been closed and had a whole 36 supporters lol. I’m so surprised I couldn’t dismantle the system using one of the the system’s release valves lol.

folfsystem

I'm curious where other sports play in this, ex bowling. Very insightful episode, love it <3

Rev Left Radio

haha just ONE more petition bro, I swear, just one more bro! Naw, but I love the idea! And I agree, its a great doorway into the politics. Almost everyone hates the ownership model of pro sports!

Max

I share your grief about the commercialisation. It is getting more and more ridiculous. With the result that going to the stadium or even watching in a stream becomes more and more inaffordable. To be able to watch all Bundesliga matches in Germany you need two different subscriptions of more than 30 EUR each. And then you won't even be able so see all of the Champion's League, because Amazon has snatched away some exclusive rights. I don't share your pessimism about the state of the game on the pitch though. There is always a football meta. I remember everyone playing 4-4-2, then 4-2-3-1 and then some variant 4-3-3. And nowadays more and more are playing with a back 3 (5-3-2 oder 5-2-3). There is always a dominant style and then some dogmatists (such as Barcelona). Also, I think the level of fitness and tactical discipline, has improved the aesthetic of the game. You still have moments of individual excellence but additional to that you can now admire incredible collective feats as well. A well timed pressing attack of the whole team or a combination that is made possible because everyone is in the right place are something I very much enjoy. Also the general level of technical proficiency has greatly increased. Nowadays you even have some Centre Backs with flair (Calafiori ❤). Lastly, the scientification of football has brought with it a lot interesting statistics and databases that enable a deep dive for nerds like me that was not possible back then. It poses the interesting question of how to work with mathematics and statistics in an way that combines analytics with intuition. Therefore it illuminates a couple of general characteristics in a controlled environment that I think transfer to the use of statistics with regards to society and politics.

Monty Fuch

Can’t remember the titles of works but the philosophers mentioned are: Deleuze Guattari Castaneda Sartre Descartes

Daewoo

Basketball players are definitely the most gifted athletes in the top flight of American sports. But Offensive (and some Defensive) Linemen in the NFL are tasked with so much responsibility at their weight, including moving other, similarly sized and powerful humans. The amount of speed, power, balance, agility, recall, improvisation required for the size they are asked to play at isn't anything to laugh at. Not that anyone did.

Daewoo

Also it should be "Gridiron football" and "association/club football"

Hana

Wondering what the evidence is to suggest whoever follows Trump's term would curtail Israeli colonisation? In the UK there is absolutely zero political will in the mainstream. Are there stirrings in the States? Seems unlikely what with the recent "50 states 1 Israel shit"... One other comment... Wall Street and US capital never stopped supporting Nazi Germany. See Prescott Bush, the Dulles brothers, Coca Cola, Ford... Robert Wilson is right to talk of reinstating historical accuracy and that is a huge part of what made the US what it is today. Plus Operation Paperclip etc

Bacchus

Some interesting ideas here. But some early premises are misconceived. Why is the USA number one in its major four sports? Because nobidy plays American rugby or baseball. Secondly, muscle men in the NFL are not unrealised world class footballers. The greatest footballlers have been mostly small, low centre of gravity men - Messi, Salah, Maradona etc. Likewise, 2 metres tall NBA stars would not have made world class footballers. A country being at the top of football, furthermore, has less to do with developed economy. Argentina, Brazil, Croatia, Portugal and France do not owe their footballing prowess on economy.

Bacchus

Excellent though. Love it.

HailZeus

An interesting video I was looking forward to, but could not get pas the first 40 minutes. Im going to ask a rhetorical question, How many times is the guest going to say "quote unquote" in a 140 minute long epispde? It really dragged down the listening experience for me as he says this phrase about 1 to 2 times per sentence. Why does he do this so much?

Rev Left Radio

haha I did not pick up on that, apologies that that was distracting or annoying!

Rev Left Radio

There is a growing contradiction between the majority of people and the government, so it remains to be seen how that will play out in the political and electoral areana, but only boomer republicans have a favorable view of Israel these days in the US according to most polls, so something is bound to give one way or the other. And yes, I agree wholeheartedly. The US didnt defeat the Nazis, they absorbed them, and the US-Israel are the closest thing to a Fourth Reich that exists today imo.

Rev Left Radio

Great point, the combo of grace, skill, Agility, and strength for pro linemen is truly unique in the sporting world.

HailZeus

You did an episode a long while back giving a very quick marxist point of view of the American revolution. Do you remember what episode that was? Or can you do thst as a future full length episode going into how the American revolution can be seen as an attempt to secure means of production for an emerging social class rather than for the idealistic notion of liberty and freedom as is taken as a truism in American history studies. P s. It may not have been a quick overview I just remembered a very distinct like 2 minute rant ( super fan of your rants) going into it.

HailZeus

Apologies for the length. I wanted to ask your permission about a proposal I had, this is inspired by something I used to watch back in the day (pre-covid). There is a a famous , not so famous anymore atheist (atheist experience) channel where the community had compiled a ton of shorter segments highlighting important points. What would you say if we can do that with the non-patreon episodes. My thinking is to find various short segments like 30 to 90 seconds that can be compiled and uploaded either on a channel you control or even just by the community as a way to bring greater awareness to the analysis and make it more accessible for ppl who watch shorter form videos. I know you are probably swamped wirh responsibility and work hence why I'm asking if you feel comfortable with the community volunteering to do this, there's a ton of episode segments between yourself and Socialism 4 All that i have in mind.

Memo Tan

The claim that “practically every basketball player that plays in the NBA can play in the NFL” is crazy. The skill sets and physical demands are vastly different for the NBA and NFL. The claim discredits the talent and physical toughness that it takes to even get to the combine. Great episode tho! Lots of interesting perspectives.

Rev Left Radio

haha I think the claim is more robust and safe when its phrased thusly: "NBA athletes on the whole would have a much easier time transitioning to the NFL than NFL athletes would transitioning into the NBA". The physicality of the NFL is different for sure, but these are world class athletes. Lebron James could take a hit, and the leanness of constant cardio that NBA players tend to have wouldnt be necessary in teh NFL and they could thus build the armor of muscle needed to take hits. But their height, speed, vertical movement, hand eye coordination, etc. would definitely translate very favorably to the NFL skill positions. Thank you tho for listening and the feedback and the support! <3

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

I grew up in Wisconsin and have been a GB Packers fan since I was 9. Whatever issues and disappointments the team has had and we’ve been through as fans, I am IMMENSELY proud of the club’s history as a publicly owned team. This is why everyone should root for them to win the Super Bowl every year, to show the superiority of a socialist sports model 🤣

rhubarb

haha, the story about nothingness reminds me of when i was about thirteen; i was in a state of mania late at night that came from a long period of insomnia, and i “discovered” on my own that truth is relative. i was texting a friend about it, just going crazy. i woke up the next morning sobered, and read back through the texts just thinking ‘this fucking idiot’ 😂