Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In 1917, Russia went from a centuries-old monarchy to the world’s first workers’ state in just eight months. From the February Revolution and the fall of the Tsar, to the July Days and the failed Kornilov coup, and finally to the decisive October insurrection, the Bolsheviks and the Soviets navigated setbacks, repression, reactionary coups, bourgeois opportunism, and unprecedented opportunities with remarkable clarity, unmatched strategy, and resolute discipline.

Breht is joined by Daniel, host of The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union, to walk through the year that shook the world. Together they trace the month-to-month developments from February to October 1917, bringing new depth and insight to a revolution that toppled an empire, established the world’s first socialist state, and still looms over our present and future.

Check out our episode on "What Is To Be Done" by Lenin HERE

----------------------------------------------------

Outro Beat Prod. by Spinitch 'Bitter Cocona'

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Rev Left Radio https://revleftradio.com/

Files

Comments

Ricky

Appreciate this. Gonna dive in. It's overdue for me. Thoughts on Mike Duncan's 100+ episode history of the Russian revolution on his Revolutions podcast?

Rev Left Radio

Its good, but this is from a Marxist-Leninist perspective, and limits its scope to the year 1917 exclusively. Id also ensure listeners that even if you listened to that whole series from Duncan, you will learn new things in this episode, and we reflect on it from a Marxist POV wrt to its ongoing and future relevance.

Brad Northcote

Going back to the roots! I've been reading comparative analysis of the French and Russian Revolutions. They really hammer home the inevitability of facing reaction even as we figure things out. Had a good discussion with comrades this week about how to cope with irrational heuristics in organizing. I'll be listening with that (apocryphal but in his spirit) Kierkegaard quote in mind: "History must be lived forwards but can only be understood backwards."

Lana

I'm only 45 minutes in but I can already say I'm SO appreciative of Daniel's manner of speaking--very accessible, very easy to follow. I'm locked in! Can't wait to listen to the rest.

Lana

LOL okay now I'm 51 minutes in and Breht literally said that exact same thing LMAO. Maybe I should wait to comment from now on 😂

Rev Left Radio

XD for real though! Hes very very good at weaving a detailed narrative that doesnt lose the listener and is continually accessible. A real skill!!!

Rev Left Radio

Love that Kierkegaard quote, and yea, those are two of my fav revs - endlessly fascinating and instructive. In both cases, the mobilized masses from teh bottom up were the best defense against the reaction.

Ricky

Thanks! I'll probably listen to Daniels podcast instead of Duncan's. I did like the Mars Revolution as a work of fiction from him. Seems like he was influenced by the Russian Revolution in writing that novel of a podcast.

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

It’s me! I’m so glad you are enjoying this interview, and thank you for the kind words! I am a big fan of Mike Duncan’s podcasts, but I think because of the sources he used, he fell very quickly into the anti communist trap of accepting that maybe the revolution itself wasn’t terrible, but what happened after was tragic and inherently anti-democratic. He goes through the Civil War and then kind of sprints to 1937 and the Stalin purges and, without any context or materialist analysis, argues they were the inevitable outcome of communist revolution. I mean no disrespect to Mike, but I vehemently disagree with this approach and line, so my show doesn’t and won’t do that. We will be covering everything Mike does and more, going all the way through 1991. And we will be doing it all from a dialectical materialist perspective, focusing on the lessons we can learn along the way. I hope folks come along for the journey, and enjoy the show!

folfsystem

I'm 1:51:31 in, in bed and shaking my fists and smiling with glee this is an amazing episode <3 thanks to the both of you for doing this <3 I will 100% share this.

Radiant Sun Warrior

The Revolutions podcast is great! I would echo the statements that it is not a solid Marxist-Leninist reading, but where it fails in that it makes up for it in clarity and approachability. The Russian revolution has so many characters and events leading up and through it, it's hard to keep track. I found Mike Duncan's work to be good at giving the outline of events and characters, in a way that further study will fill in details.

ComradeCam

I wrote my research paper for English 2 arguing against historians like Richard Pipes who say that the revolution had little to no support from the masses and that it was a coup orchestrated by a tiny minority against the will of the masses, and I even got a 100!

Jacob Bucci

It’s good, but I lost it when he culminates in “the western revolutions were much less bloody than Russia’s”. Like the worst thing is when white people kill each other, but if you export the bloodbath to brown people on the frontier then it’s like it never happened!

Rev Left Radio

Good for you! Yea that is a literally insane take, and egregiously ahistorical. Without the mass support, they never could have succeeded, nor solidified, the revolution. Anti-Communists are so lazy...

Rev Left Radio

Love that! Thank you for listening and for your support, my friend!!

Shane

This is great so far! Hoping to listen to the rest here soon

taylor

this was a FUN deep dive

Chaise

in a recent podcast on ideologies by Dr. Roy Casagranda he said that the USSR was mercantilist. I’d never heard this info from a communist perspective. Suppose he’s right, that could imply that there is a necessary transition from feudalism to mercantilism to capitalism to socialism. Challenging to me but I enjoy his talks on history and wanted to hear him out.

Chaise

he puts it simply that mercantilism is a state owned economy, but instead of a monarch it was the Soviets

Anton Pannekoek

Hey Breht, thanks for this episode, it was quite fascinating in the details. I would also like to take this comment as a chance to beg you to consider doing some housecleaning and preparation, because people like you or the SRA are in the crosshairs now. Getting you cut off of Patreon and "Buy Me a Coffee" will be childs play once they get going. So, please prepare and stay save.

Rev Left Radio

Appreciate that man, and yes, im actually listening to a report now on exactly that: the Trump admins crack down on the left thats coming! The threat is always there, and is ramping up for sure.

Rev Left Radio

Its an interesting claim that I am instinctually resistant to haha, but ill check it out and hear the arguement in full!

Chaise

I definitely flinched at it.. but I couldn’t have defined mercantilism this morning anyways. He’s been an interesting guy to watch. Recently did a history of Palestine from ancient time to the present

ethan

I listened to this episode near Joensuu, Finland which incidentally (didn't know before this episode) is where Lenin fled to in Finland. Needless to say it was a cool feeling to be listening to history retold where part of it took place. Thank you for this great episode!

Rev Left Radio

Wow, amazing. I love being in historical places while learning about the history, I once walked through Paris alone listening to a lecture on the French Revolution haha.

Bill

Daniel was great!