Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

What does it really mean to speak of “socialism with Chinese characteristics”? Is it simply a matter of policy and political economy, or does it require grappling with thousands of years of civilizational history, philosophy, and culture?

In this episode, Breht is joined by Zhao, the mind behind Goods for the People and author of Chinese Characteristics of Socialism: Civilizational Factors in CPC Governance to explore a bold and provocative argument: that while class struggle and material conditions must remain primary, China’s socialist path cannot be understood without its deep Confucian, Daoist, and Buddhist inheritance. From Yu the Great’s flood control and the origins of infrastructural legitimacy, to the Mandate of Heaven, Da Tong, and the tributary system, we examine how ancient ideas of harmony, moral legitimacy, and collective responsibility continue to shape contemporary Chinese governance and foreign policy.

This is a wide-ranging conversation for Marxists, socialists, and anti-imperialists interested in China beyond caricature, reductionism, and Cold War myths -- one that asks how history, philosophy, and material struggle converge in the making of a socialist future, and what China’s trajectory might mean for the global path toward communism.

Other episodes mentioned in this episode:

Check out our 7 hour episode on the last 250 years of Chinese History HERE

Check out our episode on Italy's Years of Lead HERE

Check out our episode on the German Revolution HERE

Check out our episode on the Spanish Civil War HERE

Files

Comments

Ricky

Ben Norton just did an episode with a similar title.

Brad Northcote

About 16 minutes in and will eagerly listen to the rest. Cards on the table: My thinking has been strongly influenced by the likes of Mobo Gao ("Battle for China's Past" in particular), or Guerrilla History guest Zhun Xu, who go to great lengths to center ongoing class struggle and critical voices within Chinese civil society. I recognize the delicate nature of the dialectical push-pull between the internal integrity of a revolution and its need for staying power under pressures of a capitalist-imperialist world system. I would suggest that at the very least being in the skeptical camp with regard to China's post-Mao market reforms reflects a necessary, healthy impulse (recognizing tensions, not uniformity, in Chinese workers' perspective!). There's a reason figures as wide-ranging as Enver Hoxha and Jose Maria Sison have been scathingly critical of the Communist Party of China's direction since the late 70s. That said, it's for China's revolutionary workers to determine their direction, with any well-meaning international influence being firmly in *anti-imperialist* solidarity.

Anon

Great breakdown. As a UI designer I am just itching to find an out into a more egalitarian workplace, devoid of profit driven short-term thinking. Picking up the shirt to support the cause, and if we're going to die in the water wars and fight capitalism in the imperial core, we might as well look dope doing it. I say as I in the heart of black block territory lol.

Ricky

It's interesting to me to see how various channels within the left sphere often seem to psychically build off each other, with overlap in topics in close timing of each other.

Derek B Local Man

Regarding your question about how Chinese people view Trump around the 49 minute mark, I went to China earlier this year (as a tourist) and the few people (like 3) I did talk to about politics all told me they thought Trump was funny. Like both clownish/boorish but also genuinely a funny guy. Thought there would be some negative, vitriolic sentiment about him but nah just "oh yeah haha that guy is hilarious!"

Rev Left Radio

Yea, kinda weird tbh. Id definitely think there would be more vitriol too! But mostly a detached amusement cuz its us over here getting fucked by him, while China stacks Ws and laughs.

Rev Left Radio

I actually am in the camp you describe, tbh. In fact, the stuff I cover in the show and the guests I have on wrt this topic are probably a tad more pro-china than my deepest views. I think Mao FWIW would consider Deng as a capitalist roader and see his reforms as the victory of capitalism. I think hed be more sympathetic to Xi than Deng, but still very critical. What Mao thought isnt the end all be all, but I think its worth noting. What you emphasized though, of course, are the ongoing contradictions and class struggle taking place. I should emphasize this aspect more when I discuss China. Ultimately though, I think China has lifted an unprecedented amount of its people out of poverty, have paved the way toward a healthier form of international relations than the West has ever done, shows what the State commanding the economy can achieve, etc. And ultimately, I am willing to accept that this is the primary stage of socialism, what China does in the next few decades will determine if that was the truth or a cynical deceit... I hope its the former.

Rev Left Radio

Word, I like Ben a lot. Ill have to check that out. The title comes from the title of the essay we explored though, word for word.

Julian Delphiki

I live in the Central Valley in CA and trump dumped a massive amount of our reservoir water out earlier in the year to *help the LA fires*, but no mechanism exists to transport that water to the LA region. It essentially flowed out and soaked back into the water table (farmers that have had trump billboards on their farms for the last 10 years were very much freaking out). The bright side to all of that is that our ground water has been so over-drafted that it actually gave some parts of the basin a small opportunity to recharge. trump, the Inadvertent Ecologist was something we would joke about at the time (at least myself and my better half). All of that is to say, when the reference to "trump the Nation Builder" was made, I fucking chuckled.

JK

I'm glad to see in your other comments Brett that you still are a holdout when it comes to claiming China is "socialist". Although your guest was well spoken, and im assuming a genuinely amicable guy, Socialism with Chinese characteristics is still highly suspicious. I sensed a bit of underlying chauvinism, and it seemed your guest has great difficulty seeing past the era of nation-states. When he hints there may be a "Socialism with German characteristics", or "Socialism with xyz characteristics", it raises the question, well, what is the contradictions between these so called different kinds of socialisms? Are they not based on workers power? Do classes still exist? Its a very strange stance and I feel like the guest confuses cultural nuances for something else. Yeah his family members might fight over a dinner bill.....but that doesnt mean you live in socialism. Thats just how the working class treats one another. Would have liked to hear his stance on Israel. He makes a point to mention china doesnt like interfering in other nations shit..... but how does he feel about being Israels largest trade partner? Any truly marxist state would sternly oppose the genocidal Zionist regime. My final issue with this whole concept of China just doing socialism by themselves in their own little corner is: Why haven't we seen massive worker-lead, globally recognized, immensely powerful industrial unions arising out of China? If they really wanted to spread Marxism and eliminate capitalism, why arn't they showing the worlds working class what a militantly organized Union of workers is capable of? Why arn't there china lead marxist circles popping up around the globe trying to help propagandize and sway class consciousness? I guess the answer to my question lies in whether or not workers are actually in charge and democratically lead the work place in China. Anyway, ill maintain my suspicions and im sure the future will prove what is really going on in China. Either they will monumentally change the world, or will slide back into capitalism and crisis. Keep up the good work Brett and I hope you enjoy your holidays. <3

Liz Mooney

Wow, just love the whole latter part of this conversation linking all the way back to early humans and all religions and shining a light on what humanity really is all about. It’s so easy to forget at this point in time, but recalling how our cooperative nature is what makes us human is so inspiring. Also love the point that even reluctant socialism works. So funny, it’s like any time this stupidly wealthy country (US) does anything remotely socialist, it has huge positive impacts on the many. Obviously, the vast majority of the wealth that exists is stolen, so it’s not like the solution is to take that stolen wealth and distribute it, but it’s just mind blowing to use those instances as a way to realize how much wealth there is and how much it’s just being hoarded and used for destructive ends.

Mackenzie parvin

A question I have after the first 20 minutes is how is Leninism any different from a robust welfare state with strong unions? Genuinely curious

David Duba

This feels like a really complicated and long answer is needed. But off the top of my head (probably oversimplified and with some inaccuracy) - Leninism is revolutionary and insists that the bourgeoisie will not willingly give up power through elections. So a violent revolution is needed in which a small vanguard of the people lead a socialist movement to win power. Once in power, they restructure all of government, the economy, and society to achieve socialism. This would be much more significant than just a robust welfare state with strong unions. The government and economy would be controlled by the people (or a community party representing the people) and the bourgeois would be destroyed as a class.

Mackenzie parvin

Yea that’s the method of achieving socialism I’m asking about the difference in day to day living. China still has sweatshops owned by western companies where there are suicide nets .

Chaise

love this episode Inspired by a guest who is not part of academia. I come from a neuroscience education and always wanted that legitimacy of getting a doctoral degree but I’ve really needed a fire under my ass to just start putting all this political education into writing and researching on my own terms. Have a good christmas! peace and health

Mikey Mullins

1. Socialism is the stage with countries still. There can be socialism with x characteristics, (to put it another way... socialism in one country) but obviously beyond the nation state we would call that communism. And obviously socialist countries are not ready to move past the nation state at this point. There are like six of them. 2. Why isn't china showing the world what workers unions can do? Um I think it is. If you accept that works unions like exist in China and are involved in the government then it's logical to attribute the many successes of china to its workers. Maybe you just haven't heard about it in the western media.

JK

1. China has over 800+ Billionaires. I believe thats more than the United States. Is that one of the "characteristics" of socialism you endorse? How about the multi-billion dollar corporations in said countries you mentioned. Is that socialism? I find it highly suspect and fortunately more and more people are accepting "socialism in one country" as a totally dead experiment. Communism and socialism must be international, or it is nothing. I recommend returning to Marx. 2. I find it quite revealing you say that unions are "involved" in government. I got the the Department of Labor in my country too..... thats not socialism. Why is the government not in the hands of these workers? Why is it not being planned and run by them? I think you and I both already know the answer to that. Same goes for Chinas new hobby of exporting Capital and trapping smaller countries in predatory loans. Think Lenin had a name for something like that...... Honestly your comment lacks substance in general and any real Marxist is going to prod deeper than you "Trust me bro" explanations and hand waving. I suggest you take a more critical lens to theory and what you perceive as "socialism", cause there are real repercussions for getting it wrong.

Tobs

I am skeptical of the guests explanation for why early Chinese society has always had egalitarian/ socialist roots. He goes far back in our evolutionary history, all of which I agree with. But most Marxists would say that our ancestors practiced “primitive communism” out of bare material necessity. I don’t dispute that. It’s just that the critique Brett seems to be leveling is that the guest seems to be saying that CLASS society in China stayed more socialist/ egalitarian than in other parts of the world/ other cultures. This is what I’m skeptical of and this was not at all addressed by talking about our deep evolutionary roots.

J Hill

Such a rich conversation - thank you comrades. Will be reflecting on these non-western ideas of harmony and supremacy, of state building as a fundamentally cooperative process, of the revolutionary aspects of religion and of the need to de-capitalise fashion and the arts. Blessed to have heard this thank you.

J Hill

Had a very similar experience listening to this - I come from a healthcare background and have used my lack of formal education as an excuse not to delve so deeply into my own theorising and research. Good luck with your future projects comrade.

Cuba Libre

Nice convo to listen to and learned many things about China. Yet I’m sorry to say but the episode delivers NO proof, in the Marxist sense with a focus of political economy, of why China is socialist. The beginning mentions a little theoretical quoting, which in the case of Lenin seems to be related to the NEP and not a socialist mode of production with central planning. More importantly after this bit of theory there is no proof provided that this is the reality in China AND the rest of the episode lacks any kind of class analysis. Especially when things like ‘empire’ and ‘harmonious society’ are discussed. Meaning the latter term could also just imply class collaboration, theoretically thereby even fascism. For a deep analysis using political economy it would be good to interview Pao-You Ching of ‘From victory to defeat’ released by Foreign Languages Press. Looking forward to the next episode.