Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

EARLY RELEASE: In this Christmas special, Alyson and Breht reinterpret Jesus through Jewish mysticism, Christian contemplative traditions, and Buddhist conceptions of Enlightenment, offering an understanding of his teachings and words as attempts to articulate the ineffable and non-dual, rather than metaphysical propositions to be believed. Drawing heavily on the Gospels, the Gospel of Thomas, and early Christian scholarship, they explore the possibility of a Christianity beyond fear, hell, and belief -- one rooted in a radical transformation of consciousness, a revolutionary confrontation with injustice everywhere, and an embodied love for all creation.

Files

Comments

Matt

Hell yea can’t wait to give this one a listen! Such a radical figure that is all too often bastardized and stripped of anything actual meaningful by our culture. I always appreciate these type of episodes.

Andrea Bolt

This was beautiful. If only Catholicism was taught this way to me, I’d still be in the faith. I’ve indeed been looking at Jesus’ teachings from a different angle these last few years especially after Oct. 7th. The Palestinians have a certain way with humanity and it makes it even more special that Jesus was a Palestinian. Also, what is the name of the artist featured at the end of the episode?

Ricky

Appreciate this one. Jesus was probably one of the most amazing humans to have lived. To say his love for others is legendary, is perhaps cliche but true from my view. I also reject in contemporary reactionary Christianity the concept of eternal hell and especially insisting the colonized, internally and externally, turn the other check and seek Peace in the after life rather than move with compassion like Jesus did, to challenge and change the reality on the ground where we suffer today. Peace to all. ❤️‍🩹🖤🤍💚

Louie

Where do the religious apathetics land? I also grew up in the West so I know a thing or two about Christianity. As a kid I spedrun (speedran?) the 10 Commandments in one night so I could get prizes the next day at Sunday School. As a teenager I became agnostic then as an early 20s something I was a born again Atheist. “There is no God and I am his prophet.” type of stuff Now I’m nearing my 40th year and I’ve mellowed out on a lot of stuff as we tend to do. I still find no place for me in religion, though Side note that might contradict my last statement: I no longer live in the West. I live in an Orthodox Christian country. Some churches here are older than the town I grew up in. I don’t attend them often but when I do, I feel a deep connection to history. Back to main point: I no longer deny religion as I did in the war days. I see it’s there. But I still don’t see its value for me personally. Am I being smug? Spiritually lazy? tl;dr: my ultimate personal goal is to be OK and I haven’t found a way for religion to fit into to that yet. Feel like I’m mostly talking to myself in this comment but thanks for making the space for it 😂

Anton Pannekoek

Before listening, but you guys should really get a cooperation with the "The Regretable Century" guys going on catholicism, it might be fruitful. And put a challenge to your thinly vailed ML mainline.

Rev Left Radio

Ive never heard of them! Ill check their work out. What do you mean by "thinly vailed ML mainline"? curious!

Rev Left Radio

I do NOT think you are smug or spiritually lazy. I get it, it doesnt resonate with many people, and people find meaning or purpose in other places. I am still very atheistic/Naturalistic in how I think about Life and Death, tbh. I just rediscovered a fascination and curiosity toward religion as I left my "there is no god, and I am his prophet" phase (lol!). I also think the pursuit of the transformation of ones consciousness IS worth it, even if it is more or less totally stripped of any religious connontations - though I do think religions are uniquely good vessels for that transformation for many reasons. Ultimately, I see religion as evolving alongside society and human consciousness, and I see it as our attempt as self-conscious, thinking beings to grapple with the majesty and mystery of our own being. On that level, it does take priority in my life.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely agree! We have to cultivate and express the liberatory function of christianity and Jesus' message in contrast to the strains you mention! Letting them have a monopoly on Jesus is unacceptable IMHO.

Rev Left Radio

The song at the end is "Time to Wake Up" by Pat the Bunny! And yes, if Jesus returned, he would be in the rubble of Gaza. Truly. His message was for us to love others as ourselves! <3

Anton Pannekoek

I mean that you are sometimes too close to an unreflected Stalinism, like in the last Dengist episode on "socialism with chinese characteristics". It is one thing to accept that material conditions produce imperfect socialist state projects, it is another to affirm them without critical perspective on how the capitalist world system deforms even the best attempts of overcoming it. The "The Regretable Century" guys are post-Trotskyists who have an interesting affirmative philosophical take on catholicism while staying away from an ML perspective that endangers actual revolution in the name of ossified nation state systems.

Louie

Thanks. I agree that the pursuit of transforming one’s consciousness is worthy. I’ve yet to find a better solution than what David Foster Wallace lays out in his This Is Water commencement speech: be aware that there is a default way of thinking. Keeping this in mind usually helps me avoid knee jerk reactions to most anything. In turn, I am usually available to have my awareness risen by a smidge. As I listen more to the episode and gather more of the knowledge that you and Alyson bring, my initial fantasies are using a higher proficiency in Christianity to better “argue” with my more religious family and friends. So there’s a red flag right there. I’ll need to wait and see if a more filling motivation comes around.

Rev Left Radio

Interesting. My view on China is actually more nuanced and subtle than that episode conveys (it was the guests essay which formed the topic and approach to that episode). I responded to another comment posted on that episode (the next post down), in which I articulated that view a bit better if you are interested. As I said there, it is without a doubt true that Mao would have seen Deng and his reforms as the victory of the capitalist roaders within the party, and all marxists have to contend with that fact. I understand the mainline ML argument that this is the primary stage of socialist development, and that a communist party overseeing the development of the productive forces and subordinating capital to the nations interests is a sufficient standard for calling a state socialist, and I am sympathetic to those who are want to stay critical of such a state, raise a higher standard to meet for it to be properly socialist (revolutionizing social relations, etc.), and want to emphasize the continuing class struggle and exploitation that exists within China.

Rev Left Radio

I love that speech, and it was no doubt influenced heavily by Wallace's at least cursory engagement with Buddhism, as well as his own life experience, suffering, etc. But yes, I agree, its great. haha, hey, if such arguments allow you to better struggle on the terrain of religion, so be it! Such struggle is necessary! Just lead with love ;)

Lana

What a fascinating conversation! I'm not up on Buddhism and Mysticism so I think a lot of the terms and ideas went slightly over my head but what I did glean from it, I found very insightful. Might have to do a little more research on some of the terms and come back to this one in the future. I was raised in Christianity--the particular flavor that took the Bible literally (yikes). I appreciate the notion you put forward that Jesus was an enlightened figure, and that his teachings come from that elevated consciousness. It shines quite a different light on the gospels when you consider it that way. In my mid 20s through fairly recently, I went through an atheist phase, citing the absence of physical, material evidence as the basis for my disbelief in a god and I cringed at anything spiritual. I am emerging from it in terms of spirituality and discovering ways to connect to myself, others, the earth, and the known universe. But grounding myself in material reality, I still struggle with the notion of there being a god and a creator. Do you ever struggle with that?? I would love to hear from people who feel challenged by this.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Your spirituality-based episodes are always great. They always reignite a desire of spiritualism within myself too. Happy Holidays to the RevLeft Family!

Julian Delphiki

I love these conversations so much - very needed. thank you both :)

Brad Northcote

Loving this discussion! I was raised in, and have had something of a dialectically-matured return (after flirting with New Atheism as a teen) to, the United Church. It's been heartening to see the Church's openly self-critical engagement with past practices (notably a colonial legacy in the form of residential schools)---and even occasional space-making for activists. I don't want to overstate any progress, but even religious institutions don't have to be inflexible. As you've said, religion reflects the spectrum from reactionary to liberatory! I'd encourage anyone to look past skepticism about certain aspects of faith (belief in heaven, literalist interpretations of the biblical timeline, etc.) and save your constructive critical engagement for what the Church centers about Christ's teachings. If it's shared experiences of compassion and grief (as it has been for me), then there's value in that worth setting your ego aside.

Brad Northcote

Palestinian Pastor (of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Bethlehem) Munther Isaac's sermon "Christ in the Rubble" is still incredibly moving. This reminds me to watch for a Christmas sermon from him this year!

Andrea Bolt

Oh yes, the priest who set up the display of baby Jesus wrapped in a Kuffiya in the rubble? Very powerful.

alli

This is the kind of stuff I come to Rev Left for. Just a one of a kind analysis, I really enjoyed this one. I’ve been wrestling a lot with Christian mysticism, but as someone raised in an atheist household it was difficult for me to overcome metaphysical understandings of Christianity. I wanted to dig deeper, knew there was something deeper there, but was unsure how to approach it. This really cleared through the muck for me, excited to read the gospels!

Hamish Bradley

Holy shit! A 2+ hour episode on revolutionary mysticism and nonduality?!? With a mention of Pat the bunny then wrapped up with a Pat song I don’t know yet???? Christmas came earl-… oh I guess it was right on time lol. Fucking amazing episode thank you guys. I love you all as of you were me:)

Hamish Bradley

As always I connected so deeply with this episode and everything you’ve said. It’s refreshing to find other communists that aren’t militant atheists or antitheists. I too used to be one, after deconstructing my literalist baptist upbringing. It’s also so exciting to hear in depth thoughts from people with a nondual view of the universe, who don’t outright reject the belief in a god (especially like the god of Spinoza) or something more than the physical, materialists who believe in more than the material, who understand it as TRULY dialectical.

Hamish Bradley

I want to share another step in the evolution of consciousness and love that I think most people here still need to take. That is to stop using and eating non-human animals as things to be owned and used for our own pleasure. We do not need them for food. We can be completely healthy without taking the lives of other conscious beings. Without imprisoning them and breeding them over and over only to be killed and used. With the understanding that we are just instances of the universe becoming aware of itself, how can we not see that any sentient being is the same? When we talk of loving others as ourselves why do we exclude those who may not look or think like use, but who we KNOW are able to feel pain, fear, and suffering, as well as live and joy? Breht when you have talked about that time in a Safeway parking lot I remember you specifically saying you felt complete love for all “sentient beings” as if they were your own children. How can you go from feeling that back to enslaving and eating non-humans?

Hamish Bradley

If we are all one then contributing to animal enslavement is hurting us as well. Just by sheer scale it is the single greatest cause of suffering that we know of in the universe. Over 90 billion land animals and around a TRILLION sea animals are killed per year for the crime of being useful and profitable to humans. The universe screams in agony through the voices of pigs and cows and chickens. The animals scream and beg for mercy for mercy. Why can’t the most progressive, loving, and conscious humans listen? There is a major contradiction between the values of a leftist who wants to fight against oppression, but who participates every single day into explicit and intentional oppression. When you talk of the revolutionary bodhi-satva this is part of the internal revolution. This revolutionary must stop their own participation in oppressive violent practices. How can we decry violence with the corpses of enslaved beings making their way through our own bodies?? I urge anyone who read this to watch dominion at watch dominion.com. See what YOU are paying to have happen. And remember these individuals all have the capacity to live and to love as well as to feel pain and fear. Remember that every single one of them is someone’s child. That these individuals want to live. That these individuals are a part of the same universe that you are. That these individuals are YOU. Love and solidarity with all life💚🩷

Amy Erickson

I really appreciated this episode and your analysis, I don’t engage with much Christian material or discussion. I wanted to offer a small reflection from my own experience. As a firm atheist, I sometimes feel a bit isolated by rhetoric that frames atheism as cold materialism or total rejection of anything resembling awe or meaning. Despite my atheism, I feel deeply moved by interconnectedness, shared humanity, and our place in the cosmic universe. Those things feel grounding and meaningful to me, and they deepen my commitment to leftist politics. All without any mysticism or supernatural framework. Just offering this as another way some atheists experience the world. Thanks for creating space for these conversations!

Bill

Fantastic episode as always! Thank you! I am another firm atheist here however. A healthy skepticism rooted in the expectation that beliefs are guided by scientific evidence and not mystical conjecture does not preclude me from appreciating, respecting, and partaking in the ethical or contemplative practices of religions or philosophies. I do not believe in virgin births, miracles, resurrections etc but I value the lessons garnered from the myths and stories that they embellish. Jesus as a revolutionary human being is quite inspiring to me. His ethical teachings I stand by. Similarly, the Buddhist philosophy and the practice of Zazen has had a profound influence on my life. There are no gods in Buddhism but there is a blind faith in it that I am careful to step around. Again, I protect my demand for scientific credibility but I understand that while some practices may not have scientific backing they are nonetheless personally helpful. I also enjoy the community of humans collectively coming together to honor and sanctify virtues such as love, compassion, generosity. Another concern I have is that while blind faith may feel liberating, it is a dangerous premise in any walk of life, not just religion. I believe that true growth that fosters enduring change must be centered around skepticism, debate, research, analysis, evidence based practices. Easier said than done as humans are intuitive, emotional, and reactive by nature but nonetheless that should be the standard. Encouraging blind faith, starting in childhood- as many religions do- can potentially undermine our ability and our commitment to a scientific process/approach. I think it can also truly impact the ability to achieve revolutionary change.

Lana

Wow I appreciate this comment so much. It is really helpful for me in articulating my own atheistic inclinations. Sometimes I don’t know how to explain my beliefs.

Lana

Beautifully said!!

Rev Left Radio

I agree with you, and when it comes to the question of god, I am literally an agnostic, but practically an atheist. If someone called me an atheist, I wouldn't bat an eye, but I do like to critique and separate my approach from the caricature of militant, aggressive, dismissive atheism that most people think of when they hear that term, (aka reddit atheism, or New Atheism). The approach to spirituality we are offering I think is totally conducive to atheism and naturalism, as well as to various religious traditions, because it is not about belief-claims or conceptual propositions, but about radical experiential transformation - such transformation is open to everyone *regardless of what they believe about the universe and its creation*. To go beyond conceptual thought is to go beyond the limitations of beliefs about the world and enter into direct, undivided relationship with it. Post-Atheism transcends and includes - meaning it transcends the mere reductionist materialism of scientific atheism while including its very real and important insights. Dialectical evolution always transcends and includes! So I would wager that your and I's worldview and outlook are very, very similar, and I wouldnt dream of assuming that everyones atheism means the same thing or manifests in the same way! Thank you so much for your support, and for your thoughtful feedback!

Rev Left Radio

P.S. I think it would be fair to say that Zen Buddhism is an atheistic religion. It makes no claims about metaphysics, it is interested only in radical, natural immanence. The perfect form of a post-atheist spirituality, and its "post" atheist in the sense that it does not concern itself with the conceptual arguments for or against atheism or theism!

Amy Erickson

Totally makes sense! Thank you for the very thoughtful response :) and I definitely agree on Zen Buddhism, I’ve read a ton of Thich Nhat Hanh and always find peace and comfort in his writing (and like you described experiencing with Christian iconography, I do often find myself moved to tears with his words). Thanks again for hearing me and taking the time to respond! Happy holidays to you and yours!

Lorenzo Personne

Thank you for an excellent insightful conversation. Just one point I want to challenge, regarding the commonalities among all the religions when you approach them from a spiritual, mystical or immanent perspective. At a couple points you seem to generalize these deeper religious perspectives and the motives or desires behind them to all of humanity or the human species in essence. I entertain a different view, to see all these human longings and their religious manifestations as arising within and in response to cultures of hierarchy and violent domination. Of course, that's where the ancestors of these religions have been living for several thousands of years, so such longings are understandable, but they don't account for all of humanity. I'm thinking of indigenous societies in the Western Hemisphere, Africa, Australia & the Pacific prior to the arrival of European colonialism, prior to the imposition of hierarchies of domination and extraction. Sure, there were empires like Inca and Mexica, but there were also non-hierarchical, non-dominating forms of social organization like the Haudenosaunee (Iriquois), Wendat, Anishinaabe and others. From the writings of their contemporary voices, they had metaphysics combined with political-economic-social structures that emphasized dependence on the land for life and entanglement with the waters, the trees, and all living things that comprised the "community" whose care for which they were and are responsible. I doubt whether the religious perspectives and motives you discussed would have had any relevance for these and other indigenous peoples whose traditions and ways of life were not products of hierarchies of domination and violence. To extend the speculation even further, I doubt whether any of the celebrated works of art, philosophy, music, literature, architecture, etc. we call Western Civilization would have been produced but for the spirit's response against violent hierarchical structures and practices of domination.

Eli 🇵🇸

This comes at such a hard, critical, fertile time in my life. Thank you so much.

Eli 🇵🇸

My background is Southern Baptist Christianity until my early twenties, then a few years of militant angry atheism, then a return to some sort of spirituality at a higher level like the homies describe in this episode. And now, learning things from these two specifically and trying them on for size. 😂 I say that so you know where I come from. It sounds like we have a pretty similar journey! I wouldn’t say that I STRUGGLE with the notion of a god / a creator, so much as I find myself putting up psychological guard rails when I hear somebody mention one. I feel comfortable at this point in my absence of belief in a god being, but I instinctually begin to run anything someone says through a filter once they mention that they DO believe in one. It’s a “won’t get fooled again” defense mechanism left over from my exodus from the christo-fascist gutter of Christianity I was brought up in. But the more I mature as a communist organizer and as a person, the more I see it as a roadblock to engaging and connecting with others. A crudely-made tool that was once useful but has now outlived its purpose.

Eli 🇵🇸

Sorry for the novel! I hope that’s helpful. I’d love to hear more about your thoughts on that subject.

Lana

Yes this is SO helpful!! It does sound like we have a similar journey and I’m so appreciative of your comment. Psychological guardrails is the perfect way to describe it and it becomes somewhat of a barrier in my ability to connect with people who DO believe in a god/creator. I can connect on a historical/tangible level, for example, acknowledging that Jesus was a real historical figure and his teachings have value, but the moment someone mentions a higher power, creator, all seeing all knowing god, I recoil. Do you feel that you are getting better at removing those roadblocks you experience or do you feel stuck, as I do?

LumpinLinecook

this episode triggerd the hell out of me, no pun intended. I can't seem to understand why you would, & have been putting so much time into the white washing of dominant religious, spiritual, & divine philosophical characters. Is this an attempt to tail the masses in a potential "christian/ socialist" endeavor in the belly of the beast. I would like to reiterate the works on religion by comrade V.I. Lenin in hopes to combat this religious-revisionist effort to lie to the people. if your feeling conflicted I also recommend the organization "www.recoveringfromreligion.org". along with the ever growing aithiest community online, and in most major cities & large towns. that being said I am according to Brett & Alison an infantile, & angry atheist so feel free to refute me based on that alone. #jeebuspeebus ain't real, & I can get the same morality from Sesame Street.

Liz Mooney

One of the things I love most about this podcast is the way it integrates spirituality. This conversation resonated with me on many levels. My mom has been on a similar spiritual journey my whole life, and much of her learnings (and recently teachings) about the ego and compassion and oneness have been passed on to me. I have been trying to gain momentum to integrate these exact types of spiritual acts and habits into my life. In the last year, I’ve done a lot of internal healing around my strained relationship with my father through working with a spiritual therapist. It has been tremendously healing for me to practice seeing his offensive and dismissive behavior with compassion while also learning to establish and stick to healthy boundaries and realistic expectations in regards to our relationship. I know that my brain is constantly looking for something to latch on to and that it is incredibly challenging for me to quiet my mind and separate from my ego (although I am grateful that I am able to do it in fleeting moments here and there). I acknowledge that meditation is an excellent way to generate a greater capacity to do this, and so I appreciate the invitation to integrate that more into my day-to-day in the new year and plan to accept that challenge! So, thank you both for an excellent conversation and for all that you’ve researched and shared and done to bolster this metamorphosis that humanity is working through! Many blessings in the new year!

Chase

These eps are my favorite! Been about a year into embracing the Christian tradition and these interpretations definitely have helped have a deeper and much more meaningful religion. Also, one of the Patreon eps you released a bit ago you talked about the venn diagram between religion, philosophy, and science. I found a YouTube channel called Where Faith Leads and he does a great job connecting Islamic faith with modern and quantum physics. Super interesting! “God became man so that man can become God” gives me chills every time. Just got diagnosed with OCD as well last week and holy shit I’m in the middle of it and it fucking sucks. It’s like playing chess with my own mind. Heaven and Hell being mind sets is a super helpful way to frame it!

Hunterchuck

As an Athiest myself, I don't see any value the Abrahamic religious doctrines give a person. I understand some Marxist here want to see if we can tap into these doctrines and through them connect with people. I don't see this working since these doctrines already have established a certain interpretation that you are attempting to reinterpret. I'm not interested in yucking anyone's yum either though so Godspeed.

Hunterchuck

I finished this episode and wanted to add that the discussion here was very fun to listen to. Both Breht and Alyson always have a way to make something I have zero interest in hearing about interesting.

Benny Boy

As an aside, Marxism itself emerges from 'Christendom' and therefore must have been influenced by it in certain ways.

Christian Holmes

How do we feel about Alex O’Conner? Seems like you all could have a very interesting collab podcast on religion and philosophy. He focuses mostly on Christianity, could be interesting to hear you offer him some eastern ideas too!

Rev Left Radio

Ive always liked and respected what I have seen from him! Seems like an interesting, genuine, deeply thoughtful guy! Not sure of his politics, but would def be very interested. Though I think his platform is quite a bit larger than mine, so unsure if he would be interested!

Eli 🇵🇸

Sorry for the late reply. Thank you so much for sharing your experience! It sounds like you’re doing great from over here. I wouldn’t say stuck, but challenged and sometimes frustrated yes. For myself, a big part of the remedy has involved increasing my own confidence and security in my ability to discern what is true and untrue. I don’t need to have the guard up all the time anymore because I’ve proven that I can trust myself in the moment. And when the guard comes down, the compassion flows out. But everything takes practice. You get better by just doing it, which probably feels uncomfortable. I’m going out of my way right now to talk to Christians of all stripes every chance I get to practice finding common ground and hopefully seeding relationships. What do you feel the pivotal moment or moments are that make you reach that “stuck” place? Like when does it go south and hit a wall for you?

Lana

Hmm, in terms of going south and hitting a wall, the first thing that comes to mind is anything that involves the metaphysical when addressing material concerns. For example, let's say someone is saying they got laid off and need money so they don't get evicted in 2 weeks and the Christian response is to say "I'll pray for you" and leave it at that. Like, what?? It really really irks me when people turn to prayer alone to address material concerns.

Max

What does it mean you "speedran the 10 commandments"? You broke them all in one night? How? 😮

Louie

Haha! That’s a better interpretation. I just memorized them in one night

Max

Hello friend, I don’t want to challenge your belief on sparing animals from your consumption, however I would like to dwell on why the experience of unity or “non-duality” does not induce compassion in a way that may or may not be implicit in your conviction (because it is philosophically interesting). I posit: Unity itself does not already contain its moral conclusion. If one understands oneself as truly and absolutely one with the living world, you lose the ground for suffering, grief and therefore compassion. Compassion is not only rooted in sameness, but in the irreducible otherness of another life: in the fact that something is lost that cannot be substituted, continued, or integrated without the remainder. Grief presupposes that this loss matters as this loss. Unity dissolves precisely this condition. This is why I think there is a genuine tension in certain non-dual frameworks, especially when they are mobilised ethically. By dissolving desire, ego, and attachment, they aim to dissolve suffering. But in doing so, they also risk emptying the affective structure in which love and compassion have their weight. This negativity is both their greatest strength and their greatest weakness. It can break the hold of inner compulsions, but it cannot, by itself, generate commitment to concrete others. That requires something else: a binding to singularity. When we feel compassion for an animal facing its end, we do not grieve because we are “the same”. We grieve because this particular life, with its inaccessible inner world, is disappearing forever. That inaccessible interiority is precisely what we recognise in the other – and what separates us. It is shared only abstractly, never concretely. If we were truly one, nothing would be lost. The animal would merely change form, continue in us, in the whole. Transience would lose its horror by being subordinated to a higher continuity. Taken seriously, unity does not just ground universal kindness; it also neutralises violence. If nothing is ever lost, then everything can be sacrificed. This is why genuine selflessness is the precondition for both the greatest acts of care and the most appalling crimes. Once the singular is no longer ultimate, once no being is irreplaceable, moral restraint has no natural anchor. So yes, connection is necessary for compassion – but so is separation. Duality is not an ethical failure to be overcome, but a condition of responsibility. There is a distance we cannot abolish, a competition that never fully disappears: life lives through other life. Decay and death are not accidents of bad organisation; they are structural. For that reason, “ending all suffering” cannot function as a philosophical justification for veganism. That does not mean there are no good reasons for it. It means only that unity by itself, cannot do this work. Ethics cannot be outsourced to metaphysics. Violence and hierarchy do not disappear because we declare ourselves one. They have to be confronted within a world that remains divided, finite, and irreducibly plural.

Max

Hey Hunter, If you're interested in why a Marxist could see value in religion in general and the Abrahamic doctrines in particular, I'd like to share a (translated) text that I wrote to a friend of mine some time ago. However, don't feel obliged to read it, as it is pretty wordy. It's just an offer for discussion. "For a long time I grappled with the question of how one could justify the necessity of religiosity without appealing to private revelation or mere sentimentality. The difficulty is obvious: religion is not primarily a set of propositions, but a mode of orientation toward the world. It involves feeling, imagination, and practice. This makes it easy to dismiss for those who do not already share the experience. Yet the fact that something is mediated by feeling does not make it irrational in a nonsensical way. It only means that it concerns objects too complex, too comprehensive, or too fundamental to be fully grasped in explicit concepts. The question, then, is whether there are dimensions of human rational life that require such intuitive forms of orientation. Consider the following: every human being, skeptic included, necessarily relates to the world not only in fragments but also as a whole. We act, judge, and commit ourselves within a horizon that exceeds any finite description. We speak of “the world,” “history,” “humanity,” “nature,” or “the meaning of life” as if these were unities, even though no complete empirical or theoretical account of them is available. This orientation toward totality is unavoidable. The question is not whether we have it, but how it is structured. What I will call “God,” in a minimal sense, is precisely this: the imagined and intuited form of our relation to the Absolute—that is, to the world as a meaningful whole. This is not yet a doctrinal claim. It is an anthropological and epistemic one. We cannot relate to totality purely through articulated concepts. Any explicit theory is necessarily partial. What remains is a kind of holistic representation: a “picture” rather than a definition, a unity of memories, values, expectations, fears, and hopes. This is what feeling and intuition are for. They are not opposed to reason; they are reason operating under conditions of excess complexity. A familiar analogy can help. Knowing the explicit rules and tactics of football is not the same as having a sense for the game. The latter allows a player to integrate countless variables in real time. It is fallible and bias-prone, but indispensable. Something similar holds for our orientation toward life as a whole. The meaning of our existence is not a problem that can be solved once and for all; it is something that must be continuously lived into. For this, we need an intuition of the whole. At this point, one could object: why religion? Why not construct such an orientation individually, or rely on secular moral and philosophical frameworks? The answer is not that individuals are incapable of reflection, but that the task itself exceeds individual life spans. Any worldview that aims at totality implicitly claims to say something about humanity as such, across generations. It would therefore be epistemically reckless to ignore the accumulated attempts of countless human lives to articulate this relation. Religions are not authorities of truth, but long-running collective experiments in meaning. They have been tested, corrected, distorted, and reformed under existential pressure for millennia. To dismiss them wholesale is not critical humility, but a peculiar form of historical arrogance. This brings us to the metaphysical core. Religious representations typically combine two moments that also appear outside religion, but only in fragmented or unstable forms. First, there is the idea of a universal interconnectedness: the sense that all humans, and indeed all beings, participate in a shared world that is not merely external but internally related. This underlies moral universalism, human rights, and solidarity with strangers. Even in secular form, such commitments presuppose a unifying principle that makes different individuals comparable and mutually accountable. Historically and structurally, this principle originates in religious conceptions of a shared ground of being. Second, there is the idea of subjectivity at the level of the whole: the thought that the world is not merely a neutral background but has a direction, a normative pull, or a meaningful development. In religious language, this appears as divine will or purpose. In purely secular forms, it often collapses either into blind progress or into arbitrary individual preference. Without some representation of purposiveness at the level of the whole, universal norms lose motivational force and degenerate into empty formalism. Religion unifies these two moments: unity and direction, substance and subject. Outside religion they tend to split apart—either into a cold universalism without purpose, or into a voluntaristic subjectivism without real universality. This unity is not merely something to be understood conceptually; it must be felt and enacted. Human self-consciousness is not sustained by abstract insight alone. We are beings of desire, recognition, and expression. We hunger not only for physical sustenance, but for confirmation that our thinking, loving, and creating matter within a meaningful world. Love, beauty, and truth are not accidental pleasures; they are the highest forms in which we recognize ourselves in the world and the world in ourselves. Through them, we experience that our rational capacities are not alien to reality, but belong to it. Religious myths give symbolic expression to this structure. The narrative of the Fall, for instance, can be read not as a primitive moral tale, but as an image of a necessary separation: consciousness emerges only through distance, negation, and struggle. The loss of immediate unity with nature is the condition for freedom, knowledge, and reconciliation at a higher level. What appears as punishment from a naïve perspective is, in fact, the precondition of all genuinely human fulfillment. Finally, religion persists because it is practiced, not merely believed. Rituals, communal gatherings, music, architecture, and symbolic acts cultivate and stabilize the intuition of meaning that no argument can permanently secure. Even modest practices—pausing before a meal, marking transitions like birth or death—can transform how the world is experienced. They slow us down, bind us to others, and remind us that our lives participate in something larger than individual utility or pleasure. One may reject the literal doctrines of any particular religion. But to reject religion as such is to assume that human beings can indefinitely sustain a meaningful relation to the whole of reality without shared symbols, practices, or metaphysical orientation. That assumption, at the very least, is far from self-evident."

Hunterchuck

Oh I'm not really saying there isn't a good thing to do or learn in the doctrines. A person can read Jordan Peterson's works and find something good in it for example. My point is that the Abrahamic religion have too much hatred and bigotry baked into it for the average person that undermines anything good in it. The Abrahamic religions should wholly be rejected and we need to reimagine our idea of God. There isn't anything wrong with believing in a God after all because the cosmos is too vast and great, with too many unknowns to not think that some powerful being could have created it.

Max

I wouldn’t necessarily agree to equate the teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ - who died for our sins on the cross - with the ramblings of one Jordan Peterson - who reminded us to tidy our room. I do, of course, understand the frustration with hate and bigotry but - and here I do agree with the more militant atheists - you cannot defend religious worship in general and then just ignore centuries of real existing practice when it becomes inconvenient. If you argue that the Abrahamic religions should be wholly rejected, you are not making a modest correction - you are implying a clean historical rupture. You are claiming that two thousand years of symbolic language, metaphysical concepts, moral frameworks, and lived practice can be discarded and replaced with something fundamentally different. That is an extremely strong claim, and in almost all historical cases, it turns out to be a false one. So the problem is not just that it would be wasteful to throw away millennia of human experience, thought, and struggle. It is that the idea of a “sterilized,” harmless, freshly reimagined religion is not credible. There is no easy way out. Any concerns about hatred, power, or exclusion have to be confronted within the historical and cultural material that actually produced our concepts of God, morality, and universality in the first place. If you think there is something in Christianity that is genuinely irredeemable - something that cannot be reinterpreted or transformed without reproducing harm - then that should be argued concretely. I think that discussion is possible. But a wholesale rejection avoids the hard work rather than doing it.