Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

EARLY RELEASE: In this episode, Breht is joined by philosopher, author, and cultural critic Gabriel Rockhill to discuss his new book Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism? The Intellectual World War: Marxism vs. the Imperial Theory Industry.

Rockhill argues that the Cold War was not only fought with bombs, coups, and sanctions -- but with ideas, institutions and intellectuals. Drawing on extensive archival research, Rockhill shows how U.S. imperial power built a vast apparatus of foundations, universities, media outlets and cultural organizations to shape what kinds of Marxism were allowed to exist in the West.

Rather than simply repressing Marxism, empire promoted a “compatible left”; a version of critical theory and Western Marxism that rejected actually existing socialist struggles and experiments, detached theory from mass struggle, and helped neutralize anti-imperialist politics. Together, they explore the role of the Frankfurt School, Herbert Marcuse, Cold War cultural warfare, and the long shadow this history still casts over today’s left.

This episode was recorded in the immediate wake of the U.S.'s invasion of Venezuela and kidnapping of President Maduro and his wife, which they discuss at the beginning of the conversation. 

Check out Critical Theory Workshop HERE

Follow Rockhill's work on his Substack HERE

Files

Comments

Brad Northcote

Sweet! Been following Dr. Rockhill's work since the publication of Domenico Losurdo's "Western Marxism". It's a useful reference while reading seminal/otherwise Western Marxist texts and engaging with that "school"'s positioning relative to current needs for anti-imperialist action. Figured this interview was a long time coming!

Seamus Keane

Looking forward to listening to this episode. I'm reading Gabriel's book atm and it is such a liberating experience for me, having spent way too much time trying to understand Western Marxist texts by Deleuze & Guattari, Derrida etc. All that time wasted that could have been spent studying dialectical and historical materialism. All thanks to you Breht & Rev Left Radio for opening my eyes and introducing me to Guerrilla History and my journey eventually led to Monthly Review, Iskra books and Gabriel.

Finn 415

Oh hell yeah! I got this book otw on special order from my bookstore!

Nick

YES!!!

Real Progressives

Fantastic discussion. Gabriel will be joining us soon on our podcast Macro n Cheese!

EdLam

This was great! glad you have them on!

CM

‘My beautiful soul’ LOL that is so spot on how western leftists sees themselves 🤣

Monty O’Blivion

This was SUCH a great discussion, very timely with all the imperialist lapdogs coming out of the woodwork, hogging the microphone about Iran and VZ. And now with Mamdani showing his full ass about Hamas, this is a much needed listen. I can’t wait until you have Gabriel back on!

CM

‘We are on the side that feeds the children’ 👏

Luis Rosa

Great episode, i immediately thought about Yanis Varoufakis's position on the soviet union

Lana

This episode made my head spin but also gave me much clarity at the same time, if that makes sense Lol! The deep nefariousness of western counter-revolutionary operatives is next level, god it fills me with rage. Evil evil evil. Much of what he talked about reminded me of the chapter in Blackshirts & Reds on Left Anti-communism and I was happy to hear Parenti mentioned in the ep. Overall, this is such a critical conversation, and important to be actively aware of the red flags for counter-revolutionary messaging that are dressed up as legitimate. Especially for all the budding Marxists who are just coming up, who may have the best of intentions and may unknowingly be trapped by it. The closing conversation around the last 5 mins or so had me nodding along profusely with every word you both said. I have recently noticed a faction of the Marxist Left, especially on social media, that are increasingly hostile and bitter. On the one hand, I understand the frustration that comes with interacting with liberalism, but SO many on the Marxist left assume the worst of intent from people asking questions and tend to forget they were probably Libs at one point too. The arrogance they show sometimes is kinda gross. Shouting STFU on your caption or in your comments, is NOT doing us any favors in terms of bringing people in. Truly a GREAT episode!! Can't wait to share it with people when it goes public!

Asia Meana

Vital listen/ book for anyone getting a PhD in the humanities (like me 😩). Inoculation! Looking forward to Rockhill’s visit to UGA this year. ❤️❤️✊🏼✊🏼

redlove

Amazing, timely episode.

B8ttyH

Just listened to Red Nations episode on this and I loved this episode as well

Ben

just got this one in the mail 😤😤 pumped to listen

Amy Erickson

Great episode! Do you have any recommendations on sources we can use to find alternative narratives to the ones we are fed about Venezuela, Cuba, China, etc. Are there any news outlets? I know there are plenty of books, and I do love reading, but I don’t want to read historical nonfiction all the time. Thanks so much for all of your work.

Ben

FIRE!!!! im pumped. brilliant point at the end breht about not automatically giving in to the hegemonic narrative out of fear that we don’t know everything or will be “gotcha’d.” being well-read and well-spoken is powerful and we should strive for both, but our mission is so urgent we can’t miss opportunities for the sake of protecting our egos

Anton Pannekoek

Sure, attack "western marxism" where there are actual trails of imperialist meddling (for sure in the Frankfurt school and France), but also consider that "eastern" or maybe "third-worldist" marxisms include situations in which the vanguard of the revolution is at the same time a one-party heavily centralized system that EXCLUDES the soviets and the "Räte" (councils) and the majority of proletarians and peasants from power in favor of an intelligencia that was quite close in social structure to the bourgeois revolutionaries of the past. Where did class rule end when the petit-bourgeois intellectuals took over as the "vanguard" and destroyed the workers opposition (Alexandra Kollontai, Rosa Luxemburg, Anton Pannekoek etc.) in their respective revolutionary situations? One can always claim to "stand for the working class revolution" while enforcing the working and peaseant classes oppression. That this was happening in a sitiuation in which much more leeway might have produced general historic defeat does not mean that the centralized one party state form under a new functionary class was actually the correct way to produce the emancipation of humanity.

Lana

I follow BreakThrough News, Drop Site news, and Mondoweiss. Chris Hedges is another one. For geopolitical analyses Elina Xenophontos is spectacular

Rev Left Radio

I appreciate your counter-view and your perspective, and yes, I think what you say is absolutely critical. Its a contradiction within revolutionary movements that has not been totally resolved yet. The vanguard party has been and can be many things, and I agree soviets/councils/collectivos/communes are an ESSENTIAL part of it and must remain at the heart of the vanguard; and its true that that has not always been the case. I do think MLs have a critical point though when they talk about supporting even imperfect proletarian movements as they try to survive, let alone experiment, in the face of brutal imperialist pressure.

Rev Left Radio

I am glad that point resonated with you! Many people are hesitant to go hard in the paint, but we must indeed go hard af in the paint as out and out partisans. And when you are even somewhat well equipped with knolwedge youll quickly realize MOST people who seem to be super smart and intimidating to debate do not know much at all, or think within a small bubble. We should understand our own POV and the POV of those who disagree with us, ideally better than they do! Which is why we must read and study widely, not stay within our own ideological bubble.

Rev Left Radio

Lana's recs are all great and I second them! Breaking Points on YT is a sort of "dissident" daily news show, with one democratic socialist (either Krystal Ball or Ryan Grim) and one new rightist (Saagar or Emily). Its great for daily news, even though I often disagree strongly with Saagar and Emily, but its balanced and has great guests and questions mainstream narratives on the economy and on war. It shouldnt be your whole media diet, but it has a good role if you wanna stay up on the big political stories in a NON-corporate media way.

Rev Left Radio

Absolutely! This speaks directly to you haha. Best of luck in your academic career!!!

Rev Left Radio

Great feedback and so glad you got so much out of the episode. I agree with you wholeheartedly my friend!

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I was listening to him today. As I was, I thought "I can see the visceral appeal of having a marxism that remains pure, unpolluted by actual reality, but its a sort of intellectual retreat into idealism and undermines socialism in practice, cuz if every socialist experiement fails to live up to your purity test, we aint ever getting out of capitalism!". We must pick and side, embrace the errors and mistakes, and be partisans nonetheless. There is no ideal version of marxism to retreat into, there is only the real world struggle and its consequences.

Rev Left Radio

Thanks Seamus! I appreciate the support so much! Im working on a book for Iskra too, should come out this year! :) On a side note, Id still recommend wrestling with and trying to understand western marxist texts, just bring the critical eye to it! We have to read widely and I would not consider your time with those thinkers as a waste, everything is grist for the mill of ones intellectual development!

JK

This was an excellent talk and I enjoyed your guest very much Brett. However, I wanted to voice my frustration that in the wrap up, he didn't want to/couldn't atleast mention one real Marxist organization he supported. Especially after you two even spoke briefly on the urgent necessity for such an organization to come to fruition. In lieu of that, I will yet again mention the work being done by the Revolutionary Communist International. Perhaps a fellow patreon member who isn't organized reads this and finally takes that first step in getting out there and meeting other communists. I know you've already seen me plug the RCI Brett, but I'm stubborn and will continue to do so, especially because I'd love nothing more than to hear you have a discussion with some of our cadres one day. 2025 was our best year yet, and the dedication to theory is proving itself in the quantitative growth of the organization, which seems to be accelerating year after year. That growth is also feeding back into the quality of veteran comrades who are increasingly becoming more effective at training up new communists. If you can make time to host a cadre, or join on one of our podcasts, I think it would set a benchmark for revolutionary optimism and be a powerful inspiration to your audience. Joseph Attard, Jorge Martin, or Hamid Alizadeh are who you would want to get in touch with from the "Specter of Communism" and "Against the Stream" podcasts. Always wishing you the best Brett, keep up the brilliant work comrade. For those who want to learn more about the RCI, reach out to one of our national sections and someone will quickly schedule a 1 on 1 with a fellow comrade to get you organized. https://communistusa.org/ (USA) https://communist.red/ (EU+International) https://www.marxist.ca/ (Canada)

Aaron Hyman

This discussion fits in very well with the discussion had on the most recent episode of The Wreckage, discussing Chomsky and why he was “safe” as opposed to Parenti Et al.

Larry

Thank you

Daewoo

His point about Parenti never having a permanent teaching job made me think of Chomsky. Chomsky, who you interviewed with Vijay Prashad (I think with Guerrilla History), not only had a teaching job, but it was at MIT, one of the most prestigious! Not to disqualify Chomsky's important contributions, but it interesting to see how culturally and institutionally accepted Chomsky was and is compared to Parenti. Manufacturing Consent is even used in Good Will Hunting to show how wicked smaht Matt Damon is! And Chomsky's recently revealed deep ties and I guess friendship with Epstein....totally not related to this episode but the Parenti comment made me think about his, idk, rival? But a wonderful episode as always and I hope the guest is brought back soon!

Daewoo

https://youtu.be/lLcpcytUnWU?si=PoxJ9Ci5ab4Hb2Io Listening further about how "left" intellectuals and, as you pointed out, "left" politicians are accepted in capitalist/imperialist bourgeois society, it's because they either serve or abide the empire. All the while Chomsky speaks about the ideological apparatuses that shapes and molds journalists, such as the one interviewing Chomsky, he also is talking about himself as an intellectual, though I'm not sure he's self-aware, at least in this clip, about that. He says that "filtering system that starts in kindergarten...selects for obedience and subordination." That goes for all of bourgeois society, doesn't it? The journalist he's speaking with as well as himself! Even as critical of ZioAmerikkkan capitalism-imperialism as he often is.

4Liberation

Also check out The Grayzone especially for Iran / Palestine/ Syria / US imperialism/ the Zionist entity aka Israel, and the Epstein files -- also great coverage of what the CIA is doing globally

Lindberg

This conversation reminded me of Tony Judt. His book Postwar really hit me but he was very clearly anti-communist.

Rev Left Radio

Yes! Always torn on Chomsky cuz he was essential to my development (first anti-imperialist / anti-capitalist book I ever read as a teen was a Chomsky book), and I can always accept political difference (I dont get worked up about the fact that hes a critic of Leninism, etc.). But his epstein ties are so weird, taking pics with Bannon, hobnobbing with the elite, etc. Im still proud that I intereviewed him, and I think he will go down as an essential intellectual of the 20th century, but its complicated to say the least. His comparison to Parenti though makes Rockhills point for damn sure.

Rev Left Radio

I will look up more about RCI. I sadly know almost nothing about them! Ill check out those pods asap. I am always down to come on one of your pods as a guest to chop it up and make connections! LMK if your interested or can make it happen.

Nico

I started listening to your show summer of 2023, when I became a hand engraving apprentice at one of amerikkkas oldest jewelry companies. 8 hours a day of listening to my headphones and drawing letters, numbers, doing monogram layouts, drowning out the sexist men in my department (who ultimately pushed me out of the job) and listening to RevLeft among other audiobooks and podcasts. I listened to Wretched of the Earth because of your show. Then that October the Palestine Genocide kicked into high gear. I've been radicalized little by little since childhood. I've had a class consciousness since childhood, then 9-11 happened...But 2023 year was the nail in the coffin for me. RevLeft has always been eye opening, informative, cathartic. Hearing your voice and all these guest speakers morning after morning - IDK how I'd get through this fascist regime without your show. I know that sounds dramatic. But I just want to say THANK YOU for putting in the time, and taking out a loan, and taking time away from your family, so we can have this information. I considered myself closer to anarchist. I was a freegan bike punk that did Food Not Bombs, slept in abandoned buildings and community spaces, and went to demonstrations during the Obama era and Financial crisis of 2008. I hit a personal rock bottom with drinking and nihilism, went back to college and compartmentalized during the Obama years until I became reradicalized under the Trump regime, and getting a little visit. Learning about Marxism, through your show, theory and philosophy, and witnessing a Genocide. Radicalized me for life. Thank you comrade. 🌹✊ Love + Solidarity.

MS

This was a great conversation. I think Rockhill provides an important anti-imperialist corrective on the Global North Left, and he's also very easy and enjoyable to listen to. One thing that bothers me a little bit, approaching this from a Maoist angle: Rockhill rightfully spends most of his attention on Western Marxism where he can struggle against it. However, his framing is that there's a contradiction between Western and Eastern Marxism, the fake one and the real one basically. To me, he makes them seem as two monoliths. That overlooks the many conflicts and contradictions we've had in the Eastern or ML tradition itself, where arguably some positions were correct and others were just as wrong as the Western Marxism criticized by Rockhill. What I mean for example: Bolsheviks vs. Mensheviks, Stalin's USSR vs. Tito's Yugoslavia, Khrushchev's reforms vs. anti-revisionists, the Sino-Soviet Split, CPC Right vs. the Gang of Four; or even within a single MLM movement, the Rectification between the peasantry-first Reaffirmists and the urban-first Rejectionists in the Philippines. What I mean is, struggle over correct ideas is inherent to socialism. If we overlook that and simplify all opposition, even to ruling Communist parties, as "wrong" Marxism, we risk being stuck with wrong ideas. So I guess, kudos for the criticism in the West. Would appreciate the same amount of scrutiny in the East, too. Although I understand why Rockhill's focus is this way.