Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht is joined by Kristen R. Ghodsee to dig into her provocative essay on the political economy of love under capitalism. Using Marx’s distinction between use value and exchange value, Ghodsee argues that love is not just a private feeling but a material necessity for human flourishing — and that our economic system systematically depletes the time, energy, and security required to sustain it. Together, they explore how capitalism commodifies two core components of love, attention and affection, turning them into scarce resources bought and sold in everything from therapy and childcare to the attention economy and the market for professionalized intimacy.

But the heart of the conversation is the one thing capitalism can’t truly monetize: reciprocal flow — the non-transactional rhythm of giving and receiving that emerges in long relationships, cooperative play, music, community, and solidarity itself. Breht and Ghodsee discuss how inequality and insecurity train people into suspicion and “ledger thinking,” why loneliness is not an individual failure but a structural outcome, and what a genuine politics of love might look like beyond mere self-help or lifestyle fixes.

Check out more Rev Left episodes with Kristen: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/size/5/?search=ghodsee 

Check out AK-47, Kristen's podcast dedicated to Alexandra Kollontai here: https://kristenghodsee.com/podcast

Files

Comments

Dog In Hot Car

I just finished my morning stretches & see the notification for this episode pop up! I've taken your advice about establishing a sober baseline and you were right about everything Brett. My emotions are way less volatile; my energy + motivation are hella improved, and I just have to think you for sharing your personal struggle with cannabis. It helped me deal with my worries about (nearly) quitting. I felt seen and heard last episode when you talked to mr. Rockhill about being a communist leaning youth in the middle of nowhere amerika. Anyway, I'm about to head to work and listen to this episode. Your show is the best 5 bucks I spend in a month. Have a good one man!

Saya Clarke

This episode gave me so much hope and its sorely needed with the ever increasing insanity of day-to-day existence in the heart of the dying empire. Grateful for her wisdom and brilliance. Sometimes I feel like I’m fighting for a world that I’ll never get to see, and as I type that it chokes me up and brings tears to my eyes. But today I think maybe, just maybe it’s not as far off as I think.

KK

Kirsten mentioned The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World by Robin Wall Kimmerer in case anyone wondered....

Brad Northcote

Looking forward to this one! LOVE Kristen Ghodsee’s work (Red Valkyries, most recently from my list). I feel deeply everything she said lamenting the transactional view of relationships. Healthy emotional boundaries do matter (i.e. when dealing with narcissists who don't respect them). But systematized trauma warps our perception of appropriate boundaries by playing into social withdrawal over cultivating respectful relationships as a solution. That's even prior to the tech dopamine factor.

KK

Be nice if Brett eve read my DMs - really looking to find out what happened to an old socialist comrade and can’t track them down. Brett mate, any chance?

Ricky

I swear the hive mind of leftists and mystics is incredible in its synchronicities. I've been seeing a lot of people taking a hard look at religion and spirituality in this dark times. Very poignant and powerful grist for the mill of the soul of humanity. I've enjoyed the calling for a deeper and more authentic understanding of love and God and religion as nourishment for action to defend the collective good bc what good is religion or God if it doesn't move you towards helping others. I'm looking forward to this episode. Thanks. Peace to you ❤️🖤🤍💚✌️

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

This conversation with Kristen was incredibly engaging and really resonated with me. I unfortunately had a lot of experience using dating apps in my mid-20s in an attempt to find a romantic partner because I hadn’t found success in pursuit of romantic love through personal connections. The experience was thoroughly defeating, with periods of weeks or months at a time of fussing over my own dating profile, deliberating over the interests of the women presented to me through the apps (I was never one to simply swipe left or right because I genuinely was seeking connection and partnership), followed by weeks or months where I wouldn’t touch the apps at all and wrote off romantic pursuits entirely. In my last attempt to use them, I ended up matching with a woman who later became my partner and who I’ve now been with for two and a half years. I feel fortunate to have found someone with whom I share an intimate connection after repeatedly feeling isolated from the experience. Looking back on that experience after joining organizations in my local community, I realize that the isolation I was feeling was because I had allowed myself to believe that the only way to find love was to engage with it in a commodified and socially acceptable way. If I didn’t have strong friendships and a loving family during that period, that experience could easily have led to me leaning into reactionary and misogynistic thoughts about women like many young men who are involuntarily celibate. Thank you always for the thoughtful and insightful work you do through Rev Left Radio, Breht! I am proud to be a supporter and regular listener of your show. ❤️

Liz Mooney

I love Kristen Ghodsee, and this is such a great conversation. I was just telling a couple of friends about this podcast last night and how it’s helped reshape/nurture how I view the world and how I appreciate and respect you, Breht, for bringing a spiritual perspective into the conversation. They were interested in learning more, and I just feel like this is a really good episode to recommend that they listen to as a way of introducing them RevLeft. Can’t wait for it to be available for them, and thank you for not hiding it behind a paywall so they can listen!

Rev Left Radio

Such kind words that I appreciate so so much Liz. Yes, this is just an early release, but the full episdoe will drop publicly on Monday morning! I never put interviews behind paywalls! Thanks again for the incredibly kind words and your support of the show!

Rev Left Radio

Please ask it here! I have a full time job, classes all week, a family of three kids, and honestly cannot commit to reading all my DMs or the various emails and messages I get across all platforms unfortunately. BUT I have commited to reading and responding to every comment on my patreon page. So if you dont mind asking here, I will respond! Apologies for not being able to get to my DMs! <3

Rev Left Radio

Wow, that is so amazing to hear. I am so happy for you getting to a sober baseline and the fact that I played any role in that at all is deeply gratifying. Morning stretches are also a great part of a morning routine!!! Thank you so much for your support of the show, my friend. Truly means the world to me.

Rev Left Radio

And even if we never get to see it, still, we must fight. We must do what is right regardless of outcomes, and if that world does come, we will have played our role nobly and contributed to its dawn! Keep up all your amazing work, Saya!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for that backstory, I am so happy you found someone, and your point about the possibility of being susceptible to the reactionary misogyny of the manosphere is very real, and shows how easy it is for people to be drawn in by it. There is wisdom and compassion in that realization that we ourselves, had our lives went in slightly different directions, could find ourselves in totally different shoes. If we have young men like that in our lives, we have to intervene! Thank you so much for your support of the show.

Jackson Duke

What she’s talking about at 48 minutes has been true since antiquity. Not exactly a new or increasing phenomenon.

CM

1:09 ‘We don't know how to help, only know how to hound’ - Emily Haines

Jamie Sims

Great conversation! I agree with so much of what Kristen Ghodsee is saying here. The reciprocal flow stuff is great. On the question of ‘purchasing affection’ and wellness and service industries, I agree but think it starts to get much more complex when we ask what we want instead. The transactional nature of 'purchasing affection' is problematic in a lot of ways - I think its good that it got framed this way, to not just reduce it to the sex work debate (I support decrim, fwiw, I don't want to get drawn into debate on that but rather to make a wider point) but recognising that something similar is happening with all kinds of service work, care, and therapy. I agree that 1. the demand for these services is in part driven by the atrophying of interpersonal care and affection in late capitalism 2. that clearly how these industries work under capitalism is exploitative 3. that access to such services is deeply classed by virtue of the fact that they cost money. However, I also want to make some space for the positive potentials of services like these, including under socialism and even communism. For example, I'd say two things are true about psychoanalysis and psychotherapy - one, you'd be a lot better off psychologically if you had a rich network of friends and comrades to talk to and draw on for support and this would mitigate a whole load of mental illness and harm, and two, you still might need to see a therapist. Let's think in terms of a transition that goes capitalism > socialism > communism, i.e. production for profit > production for need but retaining elements of wage labour and ownership > complete abolition of the state, property, and exchange ('to each according to...etc'). I recognise that model is open to critique, so imagine it as a rough heuristic - the stages to an extent overlap and interpenetrate one another, its transitional and process-based, and not linear. In that model, I'd say it still makes sense to have professional therapists, masseuses, coaches, and so on under socialism - with the ownership of those industries collectivised and democratised and conditions made way better all round. And funding to massively widen access to these services. After all, Kollontai's vision for reproductive work wasn't to de-commodify it back into the 'private' sphere, but to build canteens, nurseries, laundries, etc. There is potentially then a further contradiction, as we move towards communism - if we want to break down the division of labour, the difference between work and leisure. We might say why should there be the division of labour that professionalises this work - maybe we should all be taught massage and wellness skills, for example, and we can share that affection with each other (in the way Marx said you could be fisherman, a farmer, and critic all in the same day without any of those roles defining you). But I think even then having people who specialise in those skills is good (taking the positive aspects of guilds or professional bodies as repositories of expertise and transmitters of skills). Like, I think socialism and communism do make more room for the amateur and the ad hoc, but there's probably still a role for formal, professional, expert, collective provision - not least because it means you can access those things even if you - for whatever reason - don't manage to cultivate a deep friendship network or community.

Jordan Sandvig

Are you going to say anything about Minneapolis? I haven't seen any titles or conversations on your shows about it. Do people not know how bad it is here?

Dylan

I think we all feel that same maddening frustration you voiced toward the end of the episode regarding how the intensive anti-communist indoctrination of American workers prevents us from considering actually confronting capitalism. As you said, we’ll try literally anything but that. It’s sad seeing my union friends, vaguely progressive but staunchly anti-Trump, celebrating the IBEW statement condemning (firstly) communism along with the actual right wing grotesqueries of nazism, fascism, etc.

Dylan

Seems ripe for a Red Menace episode. American on Fire was a great one from the George Floyd uprisings summer.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, its sad that the IBEW has that in their core documents. Its a testament to how subordinated the unions have been. The ruling class knows that militant organized labor is the only REAL lever a working class movement has, and so they deradicalized and co-opted the number one vehicle for working class power in the US. Theyve done so successfully. Most union workers are vaguely populist, thats about it. Lots of Trump supporters (sickening), lots of social reactionary views, and then a left economic populism mixed in. Its sad.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, so much is happening, trying to keep my families head above water with work and keeping up on my classes, so I dont have the time I used to have. But I will address it as soon as I get a day off.

Rev Left Radio

Also, please follow me on IG. When I cant put out full or real time episodes, I am pumping out analysis on our IG, including on Minneapolis. Dozens and dozens of stories, often writing out multi-paragraph posts on the stories.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I think that feedback is very insightful and thorough and I agree with it wholeheartedly. I often think of Marx's "From Each, To Each" line here, and in that context, even more than his more utopian ideal of being different things throughout the day, it speaks to whats practical: we need expertise, we need specialization, we need people to get really really fucking good at one thing - not everyone, but some people. Overall, our vision of what communism will be is, by definition, vague and obscure and light on details. Like trying to predict the internet in the 1500s. But, again, yes, I agree with you totally.

Sarah

Absolutely agree thank you for sharing! On the point of therapy and mental health though I think it would be really beneficial to look into psychiatry hegemony and the political economy of the mental health system (good books by Cohen and Moncrieff), the current way we conceptualise ‘mental illness’ is so directly tied to capitalism I think these services in themselves would need a revolutionary overhaul not just to be de-privatised

Sarah

Thank you for a great conversation! I locked onto the point of the contradictions between the birth rate fear, anti immigration, AI etc and I am perhaps more cynical of the right wing agenda, but I think they do have a clear plan: heightened imperialism, border control, resource monopoly and anti-immigration has a clear ideological white supremacist component but could also be read as the right wing response to the impending climate crisis… no immigrants poses more worry for birth rates to continue production of workers, so anti-abortion, anti-women’s rights restricting access to contraception, restricting access to education, pushing for more ‘trad’ values… they want a less educated population easier to control, education is more expensive less accessible and the kind of “middle” jobs that are typically taken up by new grads are increasingly being used by AI… with AI they’re training it as a language and computing model and rolling it out more into roles that typically required some sort of college certification, making education less valuable in the job market but they aren’t using it (from what I’ve seen) to decrease the work load of physical labour, or roles that the elite consider as “unskilled” (obvs a bullshit term) Hopefully that made some sense, but basically all of this right wing policy has an answer within itself and is intertwined, it’s fucking terrible but I’d say we need to be careful not to underestimate the answers they do have and write it off as chaotic or completely contradictory on the surface level

Jamie Sims

Agreed. Definitely there needs to be a revolutionary overhaul. I've not read those books but last year I read The Man Who Closed the Asylums, which was absolutely fascinating. About the abolition of asylums in Italy, which was a really remarkable confluence of psychiatrists working in and against their institutions (often influenced by Foucault, the New Left, as well as postwar anti-fascist ideology), outside social movements, and elected Communist Party regional governments. I need to read and think about these questions more, but I'll admit to a scepticism of some of the more absolute anti-psychiatry or psych abolition perspectives. Seeing psychiatric medicine solely as a mechanism of control is sometimes reductive imo, and there can be an unwillingness to reckon with the really hard cases where some violation of autonomy or coercion might save lives and prevent harm.

Jamie Sims

Agree on the specialisation point, and there'll probably always be people who specialise in a vocation or even are completely obsessed with excellence in some particular field - and that's to me one of the beautiful things about humanity, not something we'd look to abolish. When you see people who have that drive its genuinely awe-inspiring (even if its often expressed in pretty distorted and exploitative contexts in capitalism). Reflecting on your point about 'from each, to each' I wonder if maybe the way to reconcile vocation and highly developed skill with that utopian ideal of being free-floating between different professions throughout the day is to see the critique of the division of labour as fundamentally about power and politics. Its about the constriction of people to only do menial or manual work and be denied opportunities for learning and culture. But its also about power, its about having some people who get to do the thinking and tell others what to do, and others who execute those orders. Like, blue collar/white collar doesn't even quite get to what its about - you might be an engineer or an independent tradesman of some kind and have way more autonomy and intellectual stimulation through your work than many 'white collar' office workers.

SprocketMusic

Just the other day I was making friends with someone, and they opened up to me about their trauma. We talked all night. The next day, when I opened up about my financial troubles, she offered to help me out, which was sweet, until she said she felt "in my debt" for having offering a listening ear. It broke my heart into a thousand pieces to have to explain that she wasn't in my debt - that I was honored to receive her trust - that our friendship isn't transactional - that she has inherent worth that can't be bought or sold.

Rev Left Radio

That beautiful that you made that explicit, and of course it speaks directly to what we discussed in this episode too!

Rev Left Radio

You are definitely onto something, and I am positive there are elements on the right that are thinking that way. Other elements are lost in the delusion that climate change isnt even real and nothing is going to happen, so many different factions probably have different interests and reasons, and when they all converge we get the psychotic, cruel chaos we are seeing today. In any case, we both know they must be defeated politically if we want a livable future!

Hoàng Nguyễn

As a young Vietnamese, I can certainly feel the shift in perception in love between my grandparents' generation and the youth nowadays. My grandma, who fought for the Viet Minh, aka the National Liberation Front, met my grandpa while he was a university student in the North. After their first meeting, my grandpa went to the Soviet Union to study engineering for 6 years and came back. Throughout those 6 years, they sent each other letters from thousands of miles away and kept their promise to have a proper marriage when my grandpa came back. My grandma was always telling me how pure their love is, how they did not expect each other to stay in the relationship, and most beautifully, how the love was just a natural reciprocal flow, as said in the podcast. Looking to the present, I am pretty sad that the Vietnamese youth have such transactional high standards when it comes to dating. They are always saying that they need to find someone who is on their level aka having prestigious education, wealthy family connections, having a high-paying salary, etc It is just incredibly sad to see how the pure comradeship that is not built on any kind of exchange value is being lost in the culture.

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

I’m getting caught up on episodes, and wow, I felt this one deeply. Love Prof. Ghodsee, and I will read her article asap. It definitely feels like the strains of capitalist commodification are breaking and a line has been overstepped with the commodification of love, sex, affection, and attention. I completely agree that if we don’t pull back, we risk losing something important - maybe the last thing we have that makes us human - our capacity for selflessness.