Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alyson and Breht apply dialectical and historical materialist analysis to the current war of aggression in Iran. Together they break down the Marxist methodology into its three main parts - dialectics, materialism, and history - and showcase how they apply to the US and Israeli war on Iran, before bringing them back together into a coherent whole. Then they compare and contrast dialectical and historical materialism as a mode of analysis to other forms of analysis: from academic modes like liberal internationalism and Realism to common popular modes like conspiracy theories and moralism.

Throughout the process, they aim to show the superior clarity and demystification offered by Marxism in understanding our world, as it unfolds in real time. 

Files

Comments

Eli 🇵🇸

Yooooooo I’m coming right off Danny Haiphong’s latest video and the homie Breht drops a 5 AM banger

Lana

Aaah!! not me fan-girling at getting a shout out on Rev Left 🤣 I’m so hyped for this episode. I have my notebook ready to take an obscene amount of notes. So much gratitude to you and Alyson for doing this episode!

Andrea Bolt

30 minutes in and I feel like I should be taking notes! I would love to teach others in my community about dialectics to better understand our world. It really is the key to combatting the war on knowledge.

AL

My brain literally got bigger while listening to this shit, I had to go buy a new, bigger skull on the way home from work.

Rev Left Radio

hahaha nice. hopefully you found one at a decent price!

AL

Sadly, I paid the Iran premium price.

Rev Left Radio

Truly you were the sole impetus for this one! It exists cuz you asked a question - a question you were initially hesitant to ask too! :) Appreciate your long standing support of the show so much!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for your support and for listening, Andrea!!

Ben

do you guys ever feel like what makes Marxism such an effective way of viewing how the world works is partially what makes it so difficult to spread, at least under the current material conditions in the United States? how many people really have the desire for political understanding to pursue this? this election cycle has predictably brought a lot of DNC funded anti-communist rhetoric to the media-sphere. i’ve seen a lot of “proud liberals” (how many of these people actually believe what they’re saying, i don’t know) making the silly “do a revolution yourself, we don’t want one” take. do things just need to get to a bad enough point here materially for us to have any shot at a mass movement? and then how do we beat out these other worldviews this podcast discusses, which have a much more easily digestible (although, as a function of that, limited) and seemingly intoxicating (smugness with no work!) way of viewing things. i’ve seen so much self-flagellation from the left and not many discussing how our tactics should be adopted to the realities of today. would people even bother to open a little red book in the age of short-form content? can we “dumb down” marxism in a way that doesn’t produce revisionism? even some of the people that seem most keen to learn about dialectical materialism will not give a red menace episode a good faith listen. “it’s kinda heady!” i’ve been really hung up on this lately and would love input!

Rev Left Radio

This is a profound set of questions that we all ask ourselves at some point. Yes, the world is complex, to try and apprehend it requires deep, multi-domain knowledge and analysis. Add to that already existing difficulty the fact that we then have to combat the dominant ideology as well as the human preference for simplicity and ease, and you can begin to appreciate just how much we have to overcome. Yet, the Russians and Chinese were able to do it in similarly HUGE countries with similar or worse literacy levels. At the same time, the full spectrum anti-communist ideological apparatus that we contend with didnt exist either. Is there a way to "dumb down" marxism without producing revisionism? Probably but its very hard. Certainly dumbing it down can and has been done, but its also almost always required some warping too. Basic ideas like boss v workers, alienation, commodification of everything, ecological externalizations, etc. are explainable and graspable. Combatting the visceral emotional appeal of nationalism and fascism has ALWAYS been difficult - its difficult right now! I think the Vanguard Party goes further than any competing theory of organization to address this, because at the end of the day, not everyone in the mass movement need understand dialectical and historical materialism, the organic leadership and core cadre do. This simplifies the task a bit, and while political education is and always remains a must even and especially in a vanguard party, significant chunks of the masses not grasping the nuances and complexities of the theory doesn't prevent meaningful praxis as a movement nor necessarily result in revisionism, as the leadership covers that aspect of things. Do things have to get worse? Probably, sadly, yea. They will. They are. Our job is to help people understand by educating ourselves and others as much as we possibly can. Ive dedicated a big part of my adult life to trying to do just that, and for that reason. Most realistically, in the near term, we will probably have to exist as a hardcore faction within a broader, more watered down "democratic socialist" formation. Theres a reason Hasan Piker has much more widespread appeal than Alyson or I or others like us: he operates at the level of analyzing events without going too deep. This clearly rallies enormous amounts of people, but also allows for much confusion, idealism, and theoretical ecclecticism to flourish, leading to AOC type left liberal electoralism in many instances, as defaulting to that is the least demanding avenue for that energy to funnel itself through. In lieu of an actual vanguard, we will have to operate within that milieu, increasing education, agitating, pushing our line, winning people over into deeper dives into this stuff, etc. without alienating ourselves from it. IF that makes sense... Perhaps Ill talk more about this on an upcoming show. But as always, there are no easy answers here. We have a world historical task and lack much of what we need to accomplish it atm. Our options are to give up, water ourselves down, or keep struggling despite not knowing or controlling the outcome. For me, theres only one viable option here, so what else can I do? Nothing. I will struggle, my whole life if I have to.

Lana

Right!? Let this be a lesson to everyone! Ask your questions! Don't be shy! :)

Ben

thank you for taking the time to respond so thoroughly. i know you’re a busy man! your words are deeply centering and inspiring. i have yet a lot to learn and growing to do. seasoned, principled, patient comrades such as alyson and yourself are indispensable to the movement and i can’t thank yall enough! i would love to hear you expand on that point in your second to last paragraph, but i do think i know what you’re getting at.

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

This was such a helpful conversation, I’m definitely going to need to listen multiple times and take the lead of others in this comment section by pausing regularly to take notes as I listen. Thank you for providing this analysis in real-time and breaking it down in its dialectical, historical, and materialist components!

Monte-Cristo

Fantastic episode as usual I always learn and reaffirm my understanding of dialectics every time I you guys talk about it. But pease start engaging in understanding MMT as a lense to understand sovereign monetary regimes. It will deepen your understanding of the current us economy and stop me from cringing everytime debt or taxpayer dollars are mentioned.

B8ttyH

Thank you Breht! I have a revolutionary book club and right now reading Mao on Contradiction so this was like extra education😁

Rev Left Radio

Perfect Combo! We have an episode on On Contradiction too if your interested! :) But yea, that text goes very very well with this ep and covers stuff we didnt have time to get into

Rev Left Radio

Thats fair, its a topic Ive wanted to tackle and understand more deeply for while!!! So your point is well noted, my friend!

Rev Left Radio

Thank YOU for supporting the show. With you all I could not spend the time and energy I do on these episodes. Truly!

B8ttyH

Yes I’ve listened to it! I’m giving it a re-listen once I finish the book. I also did that with your Lenin WITB ep. Great work:)

Monte-Cristo

The podcast Marco n Cheese is where I started to really learn about it

Nik

Jeffrey Sachs is my personal favorite liberal analyst, even if he was the architect behind shock therapy lol

Andrea Bolt

You’re welcome! It’s the least I could do. I learn so much from you and Alison. 💕

HackerBoiTellEm

Yall absolutely knocked this one tf out. Breht I've been listening since the very beginning, you and I were in a "Libertarian Marxist" fb group and you shared one of your very first episodes in that group. I've been with you ever since. And yall are just so clean, and concise, and thorough, and accessible. All of your work is incredibly authentic and earnest, and this episode is really a testament to that authenticity and how far you've come over the years. Thank you both so much, for all the thankless work you've put into this project.

Jackson Duke

Good episode but you skipped the part where the US and Israel sold weapons to Iran in the 80s

rhubarb

really great book called ‘the nights are quiet in tehran’ follows the islamic revolution from the perspective of a young muslim communist revolutionary, then his wife, and later their three children as they grow up in germany and travel back to iran

StinkLord

A “Joe Rogan of the Marxists”, if you will 🤣

SaSeigneurie

I was skeptical of this episode at first (thinking it would be another brain masturbation) but it turned out to be quite nice, at least the first 1/2 I had time to listen to. Two important comments regarding errors though: the shah (king) was in power when the 1953 coup happened, though he was "exiled" at the time; the MEK (mujahedin khald) were NOT communist but socialist-inspired, loosely based on Ali Shariati's works. I will comment more as I hear more of it. Stay tunned.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, yes, great points. But im curious: why were you skeptical at first and what do you mean by "another brain masturbation"?

Rev Left Radio

I really want to read more on this topic, so thank you for the rec!

Rev Left Radio

True, we talk about it in the Reagan to Trump episode we did last year tho fwiw!

Rev Left Radio

WOW, a TRUE OG haha. Thats so cool. I also deeply appreciate your incredibly kind words... Genuinely, it means so much to me, thank you. I just want to be useful to comrades and contribute what I can to the movement. I am grateful for your longstanding support, my friend.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, he is definitely useful. I actually did not know about the shock therapy thing until I just looked it up right now. Damn!

Rev Left Radio

Just found them and subbed to their show! Thank you

Daughters of Delos

Thanks for work you both put in for us to share with others. Comrade Across the River

SaSeigneurie

I have been following RevLeftRadio for a long while and it has taught me a lot. At the same time, reading more of the history of the non-western world, I have come to realise that some of the "deep dives" you guys do are counter to the materialist reality of how change appears: namely that it is through praxis that a correct understanding of the world is borne, as well the ability to change it. Sadly, I feel like too much effort is spent on theoretical work, particularly with your co-host, while more historical understanding would be needed. I may be wrong but it seems to me that the lessons of F Fanon's work have not been correctly translated into amurikan left circles, particularly regarding the the psychology of rebellion. Is that due to a mis-translation? Maybe, though I could be the one who is not understanding correctly. I also want to point out 3 important issues regarding the second half of the show: 1) It is important to realise that however much exploited the working class is in the USoA, it still represents the "aristocratic working class" since it benefits from the dividends of imperial exploitation. It is therefore important to start by teaching your fellow workers in the imperial core that they need to tighten their belts & accept at least some level of suffering if they hope to receive sympathy for the rest of the world. This also means breaking the "class collaborationist" behaviour endemic to these societies, where poorer people here are "forgiven" for working for the imperial military & co "for a good wage or access to higher education". I recently had an exchange with Dr G Horne, who is eager to criticise "his friends on the left" as long as these are "white people" but rushed to justify black people participating in imperial endeavour. 2) It is inaccurate to talk about "anti-semitism" when talking about the nazionist control of USoA politics. For one, those nazionists in the illegal entity called "israel" are NOT semites, but germanic, franc, anlgo, & slave in their very large majority. On the other hand, the largest group of of semitic people are arabs, with their best representatives being our brave warriors of Ansar Allah, Hezbollah (Lebanon), PMU (Iraq) & of course our Palestinian brothers & sisters. If the goal is to increase the knowledge & understanding of your audience, you might want to make sure to correctly use terms & definitions. More broadly, it is important not to racialise a religion (judaism), since that racialism has its roots in the early proto-fascistic trends of 19th century Europe, which culminated in the nazi party & its affiliates. 3) It is arrogant to even try and criticise the Iranian Revolution from a western perspective, however left it claims to be. Here the work of E Said in 'Orientalism' should be a guide to any westoid who aspires to revolutionary change: it is not your place to judge how other societies evolve. You can study them but you are not allowed to judge anything, since you have not achieved 1/10th of the advances those societies have achieved regarding the progress & advancements of their people. I say that as someone whose family was involved with the MEK and tried to destroy the Islamic Revolution, but who is so happy to see that it failed to do so. Sorry for the long reply but these have been on my mind for a long while. I still do appreciate your work, however naive it sounds to me sometimes, but I cannot expect someone with a good heart like yourself who has never experienced war from the other side, to be as bitter and demanding of westoids.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you for your continued support, my friend. Its longstanding and deeply appreciated.

Rev Left Radio

Okay, thank you for this fully fleshed out feedback. 1) Your point about our Dialectics Deep Dives are fair. they are ABSOLUTELY theory-heavy, almost by their nature. To be fair, they are not dialectical materialist deep dives for a reason, we really hone in on the dialectics part and run afield with that. As for Fanon, We did a three-part series on Wretched, in which the last installment was almost totally the psychoanalysis part of his book. They might not be what you are referring to, but I think doing another Fanon Text is long overdue so stay tuned. 2) Your point about the american working class is well taken, and I think I have said publicly that it is only fair that we suffer here in the core, and that we should be willing to accept a depression if it means Iran can more efficiently and effectively decolonize West Asia. I can say that more for sure, but ive said it publicly on several platforms and its my honest opinion. Do I think every single working American is a labor aristocrat in the Marxist definition of that word, no. I dont think poor black mothers in impoverished neighborhoods qualify for that. I dont think indigenous people on reservations qualify for that. IS the broader american economy the way it is because of resource extraction? of course, so by virtue of living in and engaging with that economy, your point is well taken. Still, id argue there are oppressed nationalities within the US that benefit very little from imperialism, purposefully. So I may be sympathetic to Horne's point there, but not for all black americans, as many middle, upper and rich black people certainly benefit. In any case, in broad strokes, your argument is correct, and I largely accept it. 3) Fair point on Semites. We are using the term colloquially as it used in popular speech, while arguing that Jewish people are not materially oppressed in the US. Still, point taken. 4) Our point was not to criticize it at all, but to study it, to excavate that period of our history as socialists, to deepen our understanding of it, and to honor those who sacrificed for it. That is not standing in judgement of them. I do not engage in that on this show for precisely the reasons you stated. I do think, though, that there are principled ways of wrestling with these periods of history and I do believe in a shared humanity which allows respectful and sincere study of different cultures, practices and histories, while not falling into chauvanism, western superiority, Orientalism, etc. I think there is a way in which people like Alyson and I could engage with that history that strikes the right balance, is generative, is informative, but doesnt collapse into judgement or the errors described above. IDK if you disagree with that, but just wanted to advance that idea. I appreciate your thoughtful engagement and constructive criticism of me and the show. It is comradely without being overly-gentle or soft. I appreciate straight shooters and serious criticism, as it helps me reflect and grow. I take your point to heart, truly, and not just because I am speaking to you and here and want to be nice or whatever, but because they are actually good, important points that demand serious attention. I am sure, as you imply, that my life experiences can shape certain approaches to these questions which can be frustrating to comrades like you. I apologize for that, and strive to always deepen my understanding and stay as principled as I can especially when engaging with movements and histories in the global south which my government - in my name and with my tax dollars - terrorizes and brutalizes. Thank you for your support, despite your criticisms, and taking time out to articulate your positions clearly to me.

Luis Rosa

Great work! Alyson’s analysis on liberal internacionalism immediatelly made me think about EU leaders such as Von der Leyen. They looked so pathetic preaching that world view on Venezuela and Iran when the US had clearly stated it’s imperialist interests. They live in an alternate universe where the liberal order isn’t dead.

Bill

This was such a superb presentation. Thank you. I’m wondering though if dialectics could ultimately become highly predictable through artificial intelligence- and then be used to guide socialist policy. Just a thought.

Peter Erian

Love y’all. So grateful for this. Would be so stoked to hear y’all take this topic to debate with a couple of serious realists or libs etc. just to hear how y’all negotiate the arguments.

StinkLord

I am maybe overthinking it, but how is negation of the negation different from dialectics? They have seemed interchangeable to me but maybe I’m missing something! As a side note, stuff has made a lot more sense to me when it compared to a scientific concept, like the quantitative accumulation resulting in qualitative changes (heating up water molecules, accumulating energy until it reaches its boiling point and qualitatively transforms into vapor). I did poorly in philosophy and loved chemistry but recently saw a meme about materialism being the missing puzzle piece that brings all these disciplines together (trying to find that meme again!)

StinkLord

Just listened further and I have another comment I want to make: While I do agree with the discussion re: rightwing antisemitic conspiracy theories being incorrect, i think it is worth taking a sober look at the support for Israel within the Jewish community. It is not antisemitic to point out that the majority of Jewish people either actively support the zionist entity or passively identify as non-zionist (which is basically liberal Zionism). I personally found this piece by a Jewish antizionist writer to be full of insight and moral clarity on this issue https://agelender.substack.com/p/yes-all-jews

Rev Left Radio

Negation of the negation would be one of the laws of motion of dialectics. Like Quantity-into-Quality, Unity of Opposites. These are aspects of dialectics, all propelled forward by contradiction. So its not different from dialectics, its just one aspect of dialectics if that makes sense.

Rev Left Radio

The love is always mutual, my friend. Thanks for your support, and I would def be open to friendly OR mediated debates. Ive never come across anyone who wanted to debate Alyson and I lol, though Im sure there are people out there who would!

Rev Left Radio

It is an interesting thought for sure. Depends on how advanced AI actually becomes tbh.

SaSeigneurie

Something that journalist Laith Marouf accurately pointed out: why is it that no John Brown has come out of western "jews"? During WWII, many germans died fighting the nazi regime. But somehow, we have yet to see a single western "jew" do it "to save their religion". This is something no westerner has been able to answer.

StinkLord

Oh I see, these all fall under the umbrella of dialectics! Thanks

StinkLord

I think part of it comes from the Holocaust education we got at school (which Gianni alluded to during the 9/11 episode). It’s the only genocide we are taught about, and it is taught as the Singular Worst One, and even chastising people for using the word holocaust to describe other genocides because it can only be used to describe the Shoah. I think it has caused many western leftists to have knee-jerk defensive responses when someone mentions Jewish supremacy as a core contributor to the violence done to Palestinians. It is the reason Palestinian people get tone-policed for using harsh language against Israelis (see the way writer Susan Abulhawa is demonized for her “inflammatory” tweets when all she is doing is rightly calling out aspects of Jewish supremacy). In short I think there is a large component of Jewish supremacy that we haven’t begun to dismantle within ourselves. I too had a knee jerk negative reaction to seeing posts about Jewish supremacy, but if white supremacy and Christian supremacy exist, then a Jewish version can definitely exist. It is something I am only now learning to dismantle in my brain. Something I try to remind myself is “Jewish feelings do not matter more than Palestinian lives” - this sentence is objectively true. But it may feel uncomfortable or controversial to say if we have internalized Jewish supremacy which I think many in the West have.

SaSeigneurie

I am not in the business to talk for others (the concept of Orientalism is based on this). I can only point out the blinders I have been witnessing both through a western (French) education system and now even more living in the USoA. More generally, journalist V Prashad perfectly summarised the issue with the "middle" (bourgeois) class that can be extended even to the aristocratic working class (note that does NOT mean all the working class of the west, but mainly the better off one) of the west: it is a class mainly concerned with its comfort (e.g., the speed of deliveries, the lines in groceries & gas stations, access to personal vehicles, the way they are addressed, etc...).

mimi

I think that each time I listen to y’all break down dialectical materialism, either by way of other subjects or directly, I understand the concepts a bit better. hope to understand well enough to pass this knowledge along, eventually. I appreciate y’all deeply, thanks for this

Michael Gregoire

Thank you both so much for this 🙏 You do a great job of breaking down complicated concepts

Rev Left Radio

That is high praise and means a lot to us! Thank you for your kind words and your direct support of the show, my friend!

.

https://youtu.be/C_n_qtgUKnY?si=hSdjSQHZMfUQhhT8 Just remember this. It is not ideologically different than white working class Americans supporting Trump against their actual interests. The biggest thing is to not get too bogged down in sectarianism/race/any other form of the ruling class trying to separate us from each other… the vast vast majority being working class people. Coming from a Jew the Jewish Holocaust is beaten over our collective heads as something extraordinary as if there haven’t been other holocausts that capital has done to other ethnicities/races. US empire has weaponized this for their own goals and Jewish people have latched onto the atrocity as an individual thing instead of seeking out solidarity with other peoples who have been subjected to genocide. Which again is just a product of neoliberal capitalism. My husband is Armenian. They don’t even get recognition. And you don’t even want to read the horror stories that generations of his family had to endure. Because the Armenian genocide is not productive for western capital.

Lindberg

Listening to the podcast series THAWRA: a history of Arab political radicalism. Goes deeeeeeeep deep on adjacent topics/histories. Highly recommend for anyone who was intrigued by this episode.

Zane Suhadolnik

As someone who is just reading Lenin's Imperialism the highest stage of capitalism, and how you were able to use that analysis to show how much things have not changed and how Lenin was right over 100 years ago is just insane to me. Great episode as always, the only Patreon I support and the only subscription I have and never feel bad about giving money to. Love and solidarity.

Inea Lehner

cannot overstate the importance of the public service you guys are providing. incredible work 💓🫡

Rev Left Radio

Thank you so so much, Zane. Those kind words truly mean so much to me, as does your support. I am so happy you found this useful and that it served as a good companion piece to Lenins amazing work on Imperialism! <3

Tony Evanko

Today I finished listening to the podcast The Iran War: A Dialectical and Historical Materialist Analysis. I think using the war in Iran as a way to explain dialectical processes was a very good idea. First, I will admit that I am really just beginning to study Marxism, Leninism, and their derivatives. Based on my general understanding, I am very much aligned with the foundational concepts, and I always learn an incredible amount from Alyson Escalante and Breht O'Shea wherever I hear them. This comment is directed specifically toward the last part of the podcast, in which the alternative methods of analysis are discussed. As I listened to the explanations, along with the strengths and weaknesses of each analytical approach, I was struck by what I perceived as a kind of denial—or perhaps underestimation—of the role these approaches themselves play within the contradictions that dialectical analysis is supposed to examine. Perhaps “denial” is too strong a word. But much more time seemed to be dedicated to pointing out the weaknesses of these methods than to explaining how they actively shape the strategies, assumptions, and material realities surrounding the conflict with Iran, realities that Marxist strategy itself must confront and address. Earlier in the podcast, Breht identifies dialectical materialism as being superior to other forms of analysis. While I do not necessarily disagree with that, the tone of the final section seemed more focused on asserting that superiority than on considering other analytical frameworks as active components of the social, political, and economic landscape that dialectical analysis must engage with. Earlier in the episode there was discussion of the unity and interpenetration of opposites, and of how opposing forces shape one another. My question is: if this principle is so central to dialectical analysis, why was it not applied more fully to the discussion of these competing analytical methods, especially given the tremendous influence they exert on the material conditions within the United States and other parts of the world that affect decisions related to war with Iran? To be fair, some of these effects were mentioned, but in what felt to me like a somewhat dismissive or superficial way, especially compared to the depth given to other influencing factors. While imperialism is certainly one of the central dynamics behind the war, the popularity and influence of these competing analytical frameworks also help shape—and in many cases determine—the decisions that are made. A deeper discussion of this would have been an opportunity to demonstrate more clearly the complexity involved in dialectical analysis and in the practical implementation of strategies meant to address these conditions. During the last part of the podcast, I was also struck by what I perceived as contradictions in the way Breht, and to a lesser degree Alyson, described Marxism’s projection for the future in contrast with alternative systems of analysis. Even though the idea that change is constant was mentioned several times in the closing comments, it seemed ironic that the concept of transition—as an integral aspect of change—was not explored more directly and, at times, even appeared to be disparaged in discussions of alternative methods. To me, this seems to weaken the material aspect of dialectical analysis itself, because those analytical methods are also part of material reality. Just as Zionism and antisemitism were discussed as beliefs and forces that shape political, social, and economic dynamics, so too do the analytical methods that people adopt and use to interpret the world. As I continue to study Marxism and the history of Marxist and socialist movements, I increasingly see experimentation as an integral part of their development. Even after dialectically analyzing a given situation or condition, the complexity of historical development is often difficult—if not impossible—to fully comprehend. As a result, any decision that is made, while grounded in theory and analysis, still remains an attempt to address conditions whose totality cannot be perfectly understood in advance. This brings me to my final observation, which concerns praxis. My understanding is that Marxist theory is fundamentally centered on praxis—the combination of theory and action. In many socialist or Marxist podcasts and lectures that I listen to, the need for organizing is frequently emphasized, as are the divisions within Marxist and socialist movements and the difficulty of aligning them in ways that produce meaningful advances. However, there seems to be much less discussion about how to develop alliances, how to strategically engage with existing political movements and analytical frameworks, and how to align with them in ways that advance long-term goals without abandoning core principles and the final objectives. I think a discussion along those lines would have been a stronger way to bring together the themes of the episode and conclude the conversation.