Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht speaks with professor of history Dr. Afshin Matin-Asgari to discuss his book Axis of Empire: A History of Iran–US Relations, about the long arc of Iranian–American relations from the nineteenth century to the present. Matin-Asgari argues that U.S. policy toward Iran has been structured by enduring “imperial priorities,” a framework that reframes familiar episodes such as the 1953 coup, the consolidation of the Shah (Pahlavi) client state, the revolutionary rupture of 1978–79, the hostage crisis, and the sanctions-and-war paradigm of the twenty-first century . Together, they discuss how state power, oil, militarization, the Israel lobby, imperialist aggression, American arrogance, and transnational political movements shaped this relationship. Finally, they analyze the current war in Iran through the lens of the history discussed.

Note: Dr. Matin-Asgari is an Iranian and uses the term "regime" to describe the Iranian government, as an Iranian left critic of said government. That is not a term I use, as an American, to describe the governments that the US is trying to destroy. I may even take those parts out before I release it to the public for that reason. In any case, it is worth being aware of that up front and, as I say in the intro, engage critically with everything!

----------------------------------------------------

Check out our NEW REV LEFT MERCH with Goods For The People HERE

Follow, Subscribe, & Learn more about Rev Left Radio https://revleftradio.com/

Files

Comments

Melyss

I had the pleasure of editing very drafts of Dr. Matin-Asgari’s manuscript so it will be exciting to hear from him here. Please consider having Dr. David Yaghoubian on soon to discuss Iran and teaching US Iran relations. They have very different approaches and perspectives regarding Iran and it might be nice to juxtapose the two (esp regarding the “regime” issue)

Rev Left Radio

Wow, amazing, Melissa. That is very cool. Yes its a small semantic issue, but overall I really enjoyed my convo with Afshin and his book is very useful as an important history of relations between Iran and the US. I will absolutely see if I can get ahold of Dr. Yaghoubian. Would you by chance have a way to get ahold of him? Do you know him personally?

Melyss

Yes, I sure do. Let me know the best way to get you two in contact with each other.

Rev Left Radio

my email is: andersonbrett2011@gmail.com If you could connect us that way, I would greatly appreciate it! :)

Melyss

Ok, I will let him know! Hope it works out!

Rev Left Radio

That is very interesting. I did see the viral interview w Marc Lamont Hill, but wasnt aware that Bad Faith did an episode on it! Ill check it out and see if we might be able to intervene meaningfully in the discourse around the concept/arguments.

Powell Pressburger

Stunning account. It reminds of the old Moderate Rebels Grayzone show hosted by Ben Norton, or, of course, Guerrilla History.

Wes Rich

Really great episode. I thought I had a decent grasp of this history but so many huge gaps were filled in during this conversation. Really appreciate this

Powell Pressburger

I bought Dr. Afshin Matin-Asgari’s book, Axis of Empire: A History of Iran-US Relations, and am excited about getting to discover his work in detail.

Guydude

Interesting note is the similarities and contrasts between the Tudeh Party and the Iraqi communists from the same era. In Iraq, the Iraqi Communist Party was popular among the masses as was the case in lots of places, so the government at the time actually had them in cabinents and what not while not being a communist government only southern Yemen would have anything along those lines. In contrast with the Tudeh Party and Mossadegh as discussed. Another contrasts being the Iraqi communists retained a presence in Iraq even after the '63 Ba'athist coup to this day. A funny aside, Ayatollah Khomeinei invited the Americans to try again after the failure of Operation Eagle Claw to retrieve the embassy captives and fast forward a few decades later and what happened with that aircraft during that "rescue" operation?

Rachel MacDavid

Wow this was posted the same day I finished reading the book! Great timing! And great episode- hearing the author give an oral overview of the major points of the book helped solidify it all more in my mind. I am only recently getting into Marxism, and my knowledge base of history and geopolitics is minimal at this point, thus why I bought the book in the first place, and episodes like this are wonderful.

Rev Left Radio

That is really cool timing, so happy it worked out for you that way! We have LOTS of stuff in our back catalogue and in our Red Menace back catalogue to help you learn more about Marxism, history, philosophy, etc! Hope you continue to find it all useful. Thank you for your support!

Rev Left Radio

haha absolutely. and great feedback/insight too! Thank you!

Rev Left Radio

So happy to hear that! More on this general topic coming ;)

Powell Pressburger

I hope Dr. Matin-Asgari can come back and cover 1980 onwards as carefully as he had time to cover 1941 to 1979. That was wonderful, but the account after that was necessarily rushed, it seems.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, we went over his time available so I was trying to be courteous of his time, but I am lining up another interview (with another scholar) on this history to fill in that period!

Powell Pressburger

This particular scholar is who inspired me to buy his book, because of his take, his telling. I, personally, would like HIM to continue and cover the period. Why switch him out?

SaSeigneurie

I almost had an accident while driving & listening to this interview due to some outrageous lies spewed by your guest. Before going into a couple of examples, a more general criticism of westoid trying to understand "others": there is this tendency in the western "left" to assume that just because someone is from a place, that person is "expert" even though that person has been living in the west for decades. It is kind of a response to the more mainstream orientalism of the western academic. However, it is not a marxist/dialectical understanding since people being shaped by the "ruling ideas of their societies", these "indegenised" expert are conditioned by the western cultures they live in. To this you also have to add the excellent analysis by Gabriel Rockhill in "Who Paid the Pipers of Western Marxism?" which would make you ask why that professor managed to land a position in such a prestigious university. Maybe because he promoted the same main ideas about the Islamic Republic that you find within the pages of the NYT or WP & such. In a sense, he sounded just like Tritta Parsi, though maybe very a slight anarcho-trotskyite after-tone. To give a couple of specific examples: he consistently referred to the government of Iran as "regime", an unmistakable sign of where his allegiance stand. He mentioned the dismantling of the 'Toudeh' party in the 1960's, something my now-dead great uncle (my dad's uncle) would have frowned upon as a relatively high-ranking toudeh member who died peacefully in his home in Iran. Then there is the issue of the various attempts at colour revolutions (2009, 2022, last January) which were documented to be just that but that he called "popular uprisings". The worst up all was his very short description of the January terroristic event that resulted in the death of 3017 people, hundreds of them being police officers & basij volunteers. And what about his description of Iran as "non-democratic" while a few years back, some western "democracy-promoting" NGO called the most democratic election system in West Asia? Funny enough, he called the Iranian "supreme" leader (in Iran, he is not "supreme", he is just the leader in the same way Stalin was a leader of the Russian Revolution or Mao that of the Chinese One) except that the leader is elected by a council (Council of Experts) that is itself elected. And neither the leader nor the council are life-long positions since they can be recalled at any time, countrary to the supreme court in the USoA for example. The role of the leader is also not as ominous as he says: leaders has important roles on issues of national security, but the executive branch has many times bypassed the leader's opinions on many issues regarding the country, as long as they do not threaten the national security. There are many more erroneous claims the guest made I could get into but I suggest you bring over someone like Ali Alizadeh if you want to speak to an iranian leftist leaving abroad or even better get someone living inside Iran now to ask them. One last comment: the guest reminds me of my own dad who also helped with the Iranian revolution but then decided to fight it with weapons (unlike you guest who run away to settle in the USoA). Now my dad is a crazy right-winger who prefers a king to a republic out of hate for the Islamic Republic. Note also that following the second revolution when the Islamic Republic was created, two groups of Iranians settled in western countries: leftists mainly went to western europe whereas libs & right-wingers (and trots elements) went to the USoA. I let you consider the political affiliation of your guest, regardless of what he claims to be.

StinkLord

Curious , what was your dad’s trajectory that led him to become a crazy right winger after participating in the revolution? Is this a common thing amongst Iranians settling in the U.S. ?

SaSeigneurie

My dad lives in France as many ex & current MEK members. He wrote his autobiography that is being translated in English & French. Long story but the turn to the right is typical of left-libertarians (from anarchists to trostskyists & sometime maoists as well) of all sorts in many ex-revolutionary movements. But the point is not my family's history, but the issue of giving voice to "black skin white mask" speeches, reproducing the liberal wing of the imperial agenda. I do not dispute the fact that such scholarship is worth studying. But on a such a small channel with a self-professed revolutionary ideology, one should focus on anti-imperialist thinkers, of which there are plenty already.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I agree with you, I have another guest coming on to discuss much of this from a perspective more aligned with our own. Still, I truly believe that I can and should have guests on that dont always align 100% with my or my audiences view. There is still stuff of value to extract from books and authors and thinkers even when they diverge from us on various points. Everything I put out is meant to be engaged with critically by independent thinking people (as you are doing here!), and ideally taken in within the context of the rest of our show. So I will continue to have on guests who I think can still provide value to my audience, despite their ideological deviations from my particular line. That's always been my ethos on this show, as frustrating as it can be sometimes. I also made a note in this post, pointing out the use of the word regime and how I fervently disagreed with it fwiw. I almost erased those parts of the episode, but felt that that wasnt fair to the author and his sincere views. People can disagree with this approach ofc, but ive been consistent about it for the entirety of the show's existence. I trust my audience, and I always have - and you prove my faith in my audience with your critical feedback! :)

Rev Left Radio

Also, and this is underestimated: there are times I have on an author or person for the first time and am not sure where they land on every issue/question, or what their exact ideological line is. A book can tell me a lot of course, but often I will have a guest on and truly not know how they will handle every question, what they will emphasize, how they will feel about this or that, etc. That does happen quite a bit actually!

SaSeigneurie

My main comment was that whatever that author says has also been said by others in part or in full. As a scientist, I know that one cannot attribute a theory or a discovery to a single person, since knowledge is built upon the accumulation of previous ones. Hence, why then promote someone with definitely imperial views (a cursory look at the author's work is enough to realise it) while there are similar or better authors with the same level of analysis or better but who will help the development of the revolutionary thinking, which I assume is the ultimate goal of your work?