Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon episode, Breht discusses the current state of the Iran War, the most recent Iran Lego song (you read that right), the limits, history, and relevance of trade union consciousness in the United States, Breht's book, countering sloppy Zionist propaganda, and more!

https://goodsforthepeople.com/

Files

Comments

Eli 🇵🇸

Rev Left is my goddamn fuel while I’m salting my workplace at 2 AM. Can’t wait to get my hands on your book!

Bobby

Communism is a hammer of love

Comrade Strauss

would definitely love to read any of three ideas you have, my interest is definitely leaning towards ready about communism is love/a hammer and has actually been something ive been thinking about a lot recently. im not sure if it would be the best follow up to your current project tho. regardless, love what you are doing, keep it up comrade :)

Clint Blakely

almost literally between Iraq and a hard place

Lana

Always love your solo eps and I’m super excited for your first book! As for your second book, my vote is for your first idea, A Defense of Communism. They all sound interesting though, that one just spoke to me a bit more and I think that would be the most useful in terms educating people. I LOVED that whole section on trade union consciousness. To be a fly on the wall while you interact with your union peeps on the job would be amazing lol. As a former teacher and former member of a teacher’s union, I definitely saw some of the same limitations but with liberal individualism much more present. There seemed to be an awareness of “the bosses” but it was much less about hostility towards them in my experience and more of a “we’re all on the same team” collaborationist type of thing. Care work, (like teachers and nurses), tend to put the populations they serve above their own wants and needs, and bosses are SO quick to exploit that. So in my experience, the teacher's union was much more likely to bend to the whims of the bosses in negotiations rather than outright fight, which was really frustrating. I always love to daydream about what a nationally organized, socialist teacher's union could actually do to enact change in society lol. The collective power that teachers have is enormous, and the bosses know that, which is why what unions we DO have in the US are state or district organized (and not even every state I don't think). And bringing it around to what you said about organizing around chokepoints in the economy, just look at what happened during 2020 at the start of the pandemic! Bosses and politicians everywhere were shaking in their boots trying to get people to go back to work. It was "the economy this, the economy that" meanwhile, people are dying left and right. That last clip of Dershowitz and your commentary had me cracking up. From the jump, is this his attempt to corral angry everyday liberals over to the Right? What’s so frustrating is that people still believe that if you’re fed up with Democrats, your only choice is to be Republican. I'm constantly telling people to abandon both lol. Like, no, there’s another option here, people. Join us!!! ☭

Clint Blakely

I’m a theater actor and I really wish we had the same stigma towards non union “rats” vs dignified union actors that you have in the IBEW. Non-union gigs are ridiculously low paying… we’re talking sometimes $500/week for a Broadway national tour, which means 8+ shows per week and rough bus travel from city to city every day at times. No workman’s comp, laughable sick leave, no benefits. And yet these jobs get filled by wildly talented non-union actors because people are “following their dreams” and want the prestige that comes with a show, so they agree to abysmal conditions. On top of that, the union Actor’s Equity Association has basically no pay floor, and there are way more non-union jobs available than union ones. I’d really love for theater industry workers to develop class consciousness and solidarity

ahoch16

Unions get a bad rap in right to work states as they can hire workers that don't belong to union and pay them less. At least in Michigan we were a right to work state. This changed in 2024. I have been told stories of before that time where union shops would tell employees they were in a union but never fill out their paperwork and continue paying them less.

Jonathan Vassar

Personally, I'm most interested in the Spinoza/Zen Buddhism book. But I think A Defense of Communism might be a better follow-up, and more timely.

Haazen

On your book ideas: The book put out by PSL orbit called Socialist Reconstruction makes me think about the communist vision. If I understand your idea properly I think I would rather have the spiritual marxist outlook first since I dont think there's anything that synthesizes communism with spirituality. Should go without mention that any book you put out is worth a read for me.

Lana

Socialist Reconstruction is on my reading list. Have you read it? Would love to hear your thoughts.

Wes Rich

I love all three book options. If I had to choose I may lean more towards option 3 or maybe option 1. Chronologically I think option 3 makes sense to come after A Letter to Young Revolutionaries because it shows both sides of communism, not just the countering force it necessitates to defend itself from the capitalist global order but also the beautiful heart and love it offers as a juxtaposition to the brutality of capitalism.  I bet it would be attractive to young people sitting on the fence to see how much beauty Marxism offers, that it’s not just all bloodshed and uphill struggle. I write a lot and record a lot of music and one thing I’ll do when I have multiple projects I’m mulling over I’ll just start more than one and pursue them at the same time. More often than not one of them will just flow a little bit better and just feel like the right thing for me to dive headfirst into at that point in my life so maybe you could try that approach if you don’t know which direction to take.

Breakerofchains

I’m going to read tf out those books. All three ideas for the second book would be phenomenal but I think the Defense of communism book would be really amazing but I think also adding in just a bit of historical context would be great, like not going too deep into it but definitely getting into some detail because many anti communist stances and conversations always mention the historical stuff and even though that stuff has been discussed in previous books, it would be amazing to see the historical and philosophical defense of communism in one place. I think it would just be more comprehensive And also im thinking communism is Love/Hammer and defense of communism combined into one book could Be super fire like that flow of (defense then hammer then love) in one book could work really well

Andrew Blake

I think the 1st and 3rd ideas could be two halves of the same book... 2nd idea is the most singular contribution to the field, but there may not be a huge audience for it

.

From NC. Look up Ella May Wiggins.

Brad Northcote

I'll read either of them, but the "Communism is love, Communism is a hammer" idea reminds me of a line from Bertolt Brecht: "We who wished to lay the foundation for gentleness could not ourselves be gentle." So there's a lot there in terms of voices from history that speak to the present. It also ties in well with a Defense of Communism, which is simultaneously accused of being brutal and murderous, yet also naively optimistic about "human nature". Last little note: I've seen spirituality in my day-to-day circles acting as a bulwark against divisive reactionary rhetoric, building community, and I can honestly say that your work exploring everything from Dostoevsky to St. Francis of Assisi to Spinoza has opened conversational doors where starting out of the gate with, say, quoting Capital, probably wouldn't have worked, haha. Looking forward to reading it!

Haazen

I think its a book that is useful for conversations with people who are not familiar with the socialist vision for the US. It comes with thr warning that things shouldn't be prescribed because material conditions dictate how things are done, but it provides solutions to a lot of societal problems from a socialist POV. Tldr - Its a good read for organizing.

Curtis

Communism is a hammer of love, please. This integration youve been talking about for years has been extremely influential in my own understanding as well as helpful toward bridging the gap between idealism, material conditions, and what action looks like now

Sovin

Regarding what you’re talking about with social media and the lack of support for military aggression against Iran: I’m not the first person to say this, but the entire industry of FPV drone snuff film compilations is going to come as a massive shock to Americans if this war escalates. Not only will Americans be horrified to see US soldiers cowering in fear in the moments before their deaths as a drone flies into them, just imagine the possible propaganda videos Iran could make of pictures of a soldier and their family and friends from their social media accounts compiled together with drone footage of them getting blown up in the mountains of Iran.

Rev Left Radio

Yea, thats a great point. A new era of warfare and new abilities to see the horror of it in more or less real time. Americans havent faced that yet... Certainly the big tech platforms will work w the government to try and put a lid on it, like they are already lying about the amount of damage and casualties America suffered against Iran, but its impossible to keep it all hidden.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you, Curtis! Noted!!! I appreciate your support so much.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Brad! Love hearing that comment about our episodes being useful in conversations around spirituality - more of that to come! But yea, I appreciate the feedback overall, maybe ill have to eventually just write all of them if Iskra will allow me! XD Though, writing a book is super demanding and quite difficult. Im always revising it in my head, anticipating criticisms, adding passages, etc. Hard to know when to stop and just send it! In any case, your support means a lot, as always.

Rev Left Radio

Very good point.... I could integrate 1 and 3 into a single book. The 2nd idea might be better down the road if I can build a readership who would be willing to engage in that less directly political stuff.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you and I agree: I wont be able to (nor would I want) to avoid history totally. Dealing with anti-communist arguments in general demands it at some point, but yea def! Integrating the two ideas was suggested by a few others too, I think you are right!!

Rev Left Radio

Great recommendation on the approach, Wesley. I like that idea a lot! Thank you. And yes, I agree with your general feedback too, thank you!

Rev Left Radio

yes, I can totally see how people chasing their dreams makes them more susceptible to settling for shitty pay and condititons. I truly believe that, under capitalism, *every worker deserves a union*. It should be common sense that every working person should have the dignity and protection of union representation, and having such a policy would also increase class consciousness from normal american consciousness into union consciousness, which would be an upgrade, despite its ultimate limitations!

Rev Left Radio

That insight about teachers unions is really interesting. I have a public teacher friend who is in a union, and a slogan he told me about was "our working conditions are your childs learning conditions" and I really thought that was a potent message. But yes, having a job where you take care of children or patients attracts good hearted people who are willing to put others ahead of themselves, and bosses will prey on that goodheartedness in the way you say. Still, some radicalism persists in those unions for sure. The Red for Ed strike wave of teachers in red states from several years ago is a good example of that. Great point about the Pandemic, and exactly right. They are terrified of us waking up, uniting in solidarity, and applying pressure to their economy. And yes Dershowitz is just a total freak. Its not even about bringing liberals over to the right for him, its ALL about Israel. All his other "democratic beliefs" go out the window for one single issue: his beloved israel. He's delusional about where the american people are at, and you can tell he lives in a very insular world where nobody seriously challenges him and his opinions-- which is true of most of the ruling class: the rich business people, the media pundits, the politicians, the lobbyists.

Rev Left Radio

Damn, thank you so much. Means the world to me, Eli! Appreciate you!!

GoldenComrade

Hi Breht loved this whole episode! Are there more videos about your experience in the union I'm really curious in case I join one

Eli 🇵🇸

I knew Bobby was a communist. Fruit pies for all! ✊

J O E & R U E

That propaganda track is a bop! I’m not savvy enough to hear if the performance is Ai or not, but based on the structure I would say it probably is Ai. The way a verse will just oddly extend by like 3 bars, or an extra odd beat will be added to the bridge, tells me that the arrangement was likely generated after the lyrics had been written, making sure to squeeze in every word even if the bounce feels “off”

Benny Boy

Excellent episode as always. How you riff for that period of time and always remain coherent, articulate and insightful is always incredibly impressive. All the book ideas are intriguing. The second is my preference. I think an issue for many people re: believing that a Marxist project could potentially work is the very real danger of any group, organisation or progressive social movement being hijacked or accosted by a few persons who merely wish to control others as an end in itself (or as some kind of psychological protection mechanism) and thereby just create another 'elite'. A book (or chapter within a book) that addresses this issue seriously and provides a possible practical and ideological pathway to prevent/deal with this apparent aspect of human nature would be welcomed.

Liz

He did an episode in August 2025, title starts with “Breht joins the trades.” Highly, highly recommend for lots of useful trade union info

Hamish Bradley

I vote the Spinoza/ Buddhism book. I think the niche you have found of spiritual/nondual communism is so fantastic and helpful to me. I also think it is extremely important and something that I have never found anywhere else. I also am sure you’ve already thought of this but maybe a couple of months after your first book release I would LOVE to get to do a reading group over zoom together so we can all discuss it and ask questions. Seeing as you always tell us to read and discuss with comrades, you kinda have to lol. I can’t wait to read it! Also I remember you’ve talked about your book connecting the spiritual and political and talking about the revolutionary bodhi satva. Is that still part of it or has it shifted away from the spiritual? As always thank you for another banger of an episode and all the work you do

BammEs

I love your book ideas! I think, for your philosophy book idea, I really think you'll have to look into enactivism, which ties together Buddhist philosophy and (Marxist) dialectics with theoretical biology and a thoroughly scientific outlook. I know people looked into relations with Spinoza's thought too but I never looked into it

Liz Mooney

Omg, please write book option 2, the Spinoza one. So glad to see others voting in favor of this. Imagine you’ve read Jason Hickel’s Less is More (quickly becoming my new favorite book). His last chapter makes the point about needing a paired spiritually rooted cultural shift to anchor the political/societal shift that needs to take place. Just as dualism was the basis for capitalism’s exploitation of the earth/animals/people (via racism), we need a new spiritual grounding that enables us to see the ecosystem of how we (the earth, animals, other humans) are all the same stuff, and how we are all rooted in love and “god” and the same matter, and how socialism/communism is way of living that is rooted in this belief. I think there’s maybe a little more to that then it just touching on Buddhism per se. There’s the idea of animism in general and the history of other historical cultures that have been annihilated, causing us to lose so much of what we once knew. So not to say you have to cover everything. But there is so little of this. And if there is one thing we know about people, it’s that religion/god/beliefs inform so much of what we do and are willing to accept. We are willing to accept the destruction of our own existence based on a belief that we are separate from each other and the earth. We need to build a different foundational belief if we are going to change the way we live and relate to the world.

Rev Left Radio

Great feedback, and beautifully stated overall too. Spot on, and this basic idea is def in my new book, but also something I want to keep emphasizing and deepening in whatever little ways I can.

BammEs

Linguistic Bodies by Ezequiel Di Paolo and colleagues is a lot about dialectics, but it's very dense!

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I think you are right! Still impressive, despite my deep anti-AI baseline sentiments lol

Rev Left Radio

Yes, Liz's rec is probably the best, if not only, time I really talk about it at length! Lots of little mentions of it spread around. I probably talked about it a lot on Shoeless in South Dakota, but dont remember exact episodes!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Ben, I appreciate that compliment about speaking extemporaneously! I like your feedback too, that issue in particular is super important!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you and vote noted!! Yes, we will def do reading groups, or at least I will try to make that or something like it happen for sure. There will in any case be online events around the book after its release in some form or another. I do have to haha! Yes, it is part of it! The entire second section is focused on it, and discusses the bodhisattva revolutionary ideal explicitly! :) Thank you for your continued support, Hamish!!

Hamish Bradley

Fantastic, thank you! I can’t wait to read and discuss it with everyone:)

Finn 415

"A letter to my revolutionary peers" would be a good follow-up imo - but of course it then could still be any of the options you listed. Im most compelled by the 3rd tho.

StinkLord

This kind of make me think of one of my liberal coworkers who I like well enough, but who is vehemently anti communist. Her parents are Vietnamese refugees and she was born and raised in the U.S. hearing the horror stories of the ‘communists invading Saigon and raping and murdering people in cold blood’. It’s clearly a very emotional issue that she’s likely never questioned. I don’t feel like I would be willing to argue with her on something so clearly emotional, but she does brings up the evils of communism frequently enough that it’s annoying . I don’t hate her at all, but I think I am just closed off to any deeper friendship because I don’t know how to handle whatever the conversation might be.

Bill

All great book ideas but I’m sort of biased toward the second option which ties Spinoza, Buddhism, Marxism. I think the ideas of non dualism are revolutionary and stand strongly opposed to capitalism, exploitation, and narcissistic individualism.

A Gardener

Hi, Breht. The 1st idea (defense of communism) could work well as a follow-on to your letter to young revolutionaries. It could provide historical and philosophical material for the young revolutionary to use when inevitably they are attacked or engage by bad faith actors. Plus you have many comrades and former guests with knowledge to help you. I would caution you about the 2nd option (Spinoza / Buddhism) in that there is already a lot of academic work on that discourse in Religious Studies that yours would be held up against. It could be akin to a PhD dissertation in order to do it well in a way that will hold up, and that can take several years. Maybe your 3rd book? Solidarity, comrade!

anon corgi

I vote on the first! philosophical Defense of Communism