Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht sits down with Ashwin Shantha to discuss the argument that China’s green development is not only an environmental achievement, but also a profoundly political one. Drawing on Ashwin's essay “China’s Green Development is Both Anti-Imperialist and Socialist,” the conversation explores how China became the global leader in solar, wind, and electric vehicles through long-term planning, industrial policy, state capacity, and the disciplining of capital to broader social goals.

Together, they examine the relationship between green development, national sovereignty, and anti-imperialism, asking why China has been able to carry out a large-scale green industrial transition while Western capitalist states have largely failed. The discussion also takes up the deeper theoretical question at the heart of the essay: whether China’s model is best understood not as “state capitalism,” but as a socialist market economy in which capital is subordinated to national development, ecological sustainability, and public need.

Read more essays at Journal of International Solidarity HERE

Follow Ashwin's International Solidarity on IG HERE

Check out Breht's appearance on International Solidarity podcast HERE

Files

Comments

Clinton Fraser

Can't help thinking that despite the chaos of the cultural revolution those radical instincts of burning down the party hq once advocated by Mao could hold relevance in furthering Chinese socialism as a new generation of workers sense their own power beyond the constraints of the market and the state.anyhow thanks for the podcast not sure if I'm making any sense

Jacob Makes

Thanks for making the distinction about the Epstein class. It’s important that we are careful about using material language, and for those earlier in their political development, it can be dangerous to avoid calling out the bourgeoisie as such.

Mackenzie parvin

Id like to see someone championing chinas work in the south talk about the Chinese owned cobalt mines in the Congo .

.

https://xcancel.com/solzhenidiot/status/2040073116831944890#m Probably the most succinct understanding of what you are getting at. Also wanted to add 1/3rd of China’s LNG/oil imports come from the three states the U.S. empire and their vassal states have been targeting. Iran, Russia and Venezuela. This is not a coincidence. China is the ultimate goal of subjugation by western forces because they are creating a different, better world. Marco Rubio just explicitly states this https://www.reddit.com/r/EU_Economics/s/4fUSvtlroO So leftists should not be confused by tail wagging the dog tropes irg to Israel. The U.S. felt compelled to launch this war of aggression to attempt to stunt Chinas development in the global south as the alternative.

Franklin

Fantastic episode, really enjoyed listening.

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

This is a wonderful supplement to the Red Pen video on China that came out recently and set off a firestorm on Breadtube. A proper and correct and complete materialist understanding of China in the 21st-century could not be more crucial to socialist and communists today. Really love the episodes lately, Breht. Rev Left Radio is such a treasure for the revolutionary movement.

Luis Rosa

Not sure about China to be honest, sure they provide green Energy to Cuba but at the same time they provide drones to Indonesia that are used to kill people from West Papua and are major trading partners with Israel. Didnt have to do neither of these things to survive

SaSeigneurie

This was a very interesting episode. I do have a relatively big pushback that has to do with the idea that China is anti-imperialist. This is something we observe a lot in many leftoid spheres that have decided to jump “on the China wagon”. To understand the role of China regarding imperialism, one has to try and pinpoint the effective activities of China in its foreign policy dealings. It also requires a clear definition of what anti-imperialism is. Let’s assume the guest definition of imperialism, with its obvious caveats, and therefore define anti-imperialism as promoting sovereign technological development & control over resources. Within this framework, China has achieved internal control over resources & development. However, China does not appear to promote indigenous technological development as much as one would expect an ideological anti-imperialist state (like Cuba & Iran) do. Interestingly, China does promote the development of resource-rich countries in processing raw resources, but this promotion appears to be more verbal than actual. One interesting intellectual gymnastic in justifying the continued exploitative nature of Chinese firms with African countries for instance is to blame local elites & lack of experts in reviewing deals. Such arguments show that China is NOT ideologically anti-imperialist (and has not been since the Sino-Soviet split, when it decided to collaborate with imperial UsoA to fight the Vietnamese), and would benefit from unequal economic deal with those poorer countries. Obviously, whatever deal China proposes is 100 times better than anything the West would propose. But if we are to look objectively at anti-imperialism, one has to set standards based on nations that put actions to their words. Cuba is a great example where the country will not (as far as I am aware) “play the system until it breaks down” or is being challenged but proposes more equal deals from the start. To summarise, China is NOT imperialist, but there is no material evidence that it is anti-imperialist. At the same time, China does provide a much-needed breathing room to countries on the forefront of anti-imperial struggle, Iran and the Axis of Resistance being the current tip of the spear. Note that Iran has support for freedom struggle written in its constitution.

Rev Left Radio

Yes, I am sympathetic with that. We all know, as Mao taught, that class struggle increases during socialist transition. Seems inevitable that that particular contradiction will emerge robustly at some point. Overall national development and economic growth across the economy thus far has perhaps soothed that contradiction, but its always there. When it does emerge more vociferously, it will be very telling how the government handles it!

Rev Left Radio

I do think the China aspect of the Iran war is downplayed or ignored. When it first popped off, I made arguments that this is about China too, I bring up the railroad connecting China and Tehran being bombed and rebuilt immediately, the belt and road initiative and its route through Iran, etc. Trump is going to meet with Xi next month, so itll be interesting to see how that goes. Xi will probably play Trump instead of sabre rattle ofc, and will manipulate Trump's ego to benefit China in various ways. How that will impact the war in Iran is a genuine question mark. On a slightly related note, China offered Taiwan huge economic benefits if it agrees to a peaceful reunification. In light of the exposing of American military power limits in this war, Taiwan might end up taking a deal similiar to that sometime soon. Instead of a Chinese military reunification, it could be a peaceful economic one instead... We shall see

Rev Left Radio

This is a legitimate line of questioning and inquiry, and I genuinely think both (principled) sides of this debate have something of value to add to the Marxist understanding here. On one hand, it is indisputably true that China did not create the colonialist, extractive dynamics found in the Congo. It did not militarily invade, coerce, or impose any policy on the Congo as such. It approaches Congo on the basis of respecting national sovereignty, emphasizes South-South cooperation, weakens western colonial hegemony on the continent, and genuinely assists in the construction of modern infrastructure in Congo and in Africa more broadly in order to have access to Congolese minerals needed for the development of green technology and renewable energy. Any green transition anywhere on Earth will have to engage with Africa broadly and the Congo in particular in order to happen on any meaningful level, and we can at least say that China has been markedly better on this front than ANY western country. On the other hand, there is no doubt that China enters a context marred by centuries of colonialism, exploitative labor, mafia style violence surrounding the organization and policing of the mining industry, and supply chains riddled with human rights abuses at almost every level. Its first priority is national development and its extraction of minerals, like Cobalt, from the Congo, though not done at the barrel of a gun or through colonial administration, is meant to benefit China first and foremost. From a pure proletarian internationalist perspective, China can rightly be criticized for some of its failures on this front, and for the lack of concern it seems to really have wrt to exploitation embedded in that industry and in that supply chain. It isnt able to fix it all by itself, of course, and we shouldn't expect it to. But it has real leverage it could use to better conditions for Congolese people and workers, and on the whole, it doesnt seem overly concerned about that. To be fair, China touts its international approach as NOT coming with lectures or dictates or social impositions, as it respects other countries sovereignty, so this behavior is in-line with that state approach. At the same time, it can seem convenient for China to be able to get its cake and eat it too on that front. Overall china’s role in congo should not be collapsed into classical colonial imperialism nor overly-romanticized as genuine socialist internationalism. It is a *contradictory* relationship: one that can and does weaken Western hegemony on the continent and genuinely contribute to infrastructure and development, while still reproducing or at least passively engaging in extractive dynamics, asymmetrical benefit, and insufficient concern for the exploited labor conditions embedded in the mining supply chain. I think that is a fair, honest assessment, not an ideologically zealous one. Open to criticism on that, though, as always!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Daniel, that means a lot and I deeply appreciate your support of the show, my friend!

.

Malcolm X, 1964: "I go for Mao Zedong much more than Nehru because I think that Nehru brought his country up in a beggar's role. […] Though the West doesn't love China, the West respects China. Now, the West doesn’t respect India, but it loves India." Nothing has changed.

Rev Left Radio

China's development and their international relationships are, truly, *contradictory*. These are contradictions that they have to navigate, work through, and ultimately resolve as they deepen their material shift toward the secondary phase of socialist development. Their first and overarching priority, for better or worse, over the last decade plus is national development into an economic and military superpower. It sees itself as having to do that in order to not be destroyed, weakened, or bogged down by imperialist assault. In order to do that, they have made structural, moral, and ideological compromises. I think principled acknowledgment of that is fair, while at the same time understanding their position and their strategy for socialist development given what has happened to every other socialist experiment before it: from the Paris Commune to the Soviet Union to Socialist Cuba and beyond. Reasonable Marxists, acting and thinking in good faith, can fall on different sides of this debate. But my approach is to acknowledge and hold the contradictions up honestly, while still allowing the Chinese socialist experiment - born out of world historical revolution - to develop and pursue it own unique strategy. Succeed or Fail it will be an advancement for global socialism as we wrestle with its implications and fall out. So far, though, they are succeeding in terms of what they see as the primary stage of socialist development, which, from their view, comes with these inevitable contradictions, domestically and internationally.

Rev Left Radio

I think that analysis is fair and I am very sympathetic with it. You can scroll down and see my long written out responses to various people about China below, and I think you will find that my view resonates quite well with your own. In both the Iran and the China eps lately, which you have given critical feedback on, I did not fully and totally agree with either guest on every point, yet still, they present things that folks like you and I can wrestle with, analyze, critique, and clarify on the way to deepening both our own understanding as well as the understanding of others. I do not just say I largely agree with you about your criticisms of the Iran guest or this episode on China simply to be nice or avoid conflict. I say it from deep, thoughtful sincerity. I literally do agree with the overarching thrust of your arguments on both fronts. They are fair, well-reasoned, principled, and insightful. They genuinely align, on the whole, with my personal views. Though, of course, Rev Left is not just my personal views, its an exploration of views and topics on the broadly conceived revolutionary left, which always comes with contradictions, disagreements, differing lines, etc. This is inevitable and, imo, to be fully embraced by all of us as grist for the mill of our own critical engagement and development. Its dialectics at work at the level of intra-Marxist discourse and understanding.

Rev Left Radio

Here is what I said in response to another patron inquiring skeptically into China's role in the Congo. LMK what you think of this line of argument: This is a legitimate line of questioning and inquiry, and I genuinely think both (principled) sides of this debate have something of value to add to the Marxist understanding here. On one hand, it is indisputably true that China did not create the colonialist, extractive dynamics found in the Congo. It did not militarily invade, coerce, or impose any policy on the Congo as such. It approaches Congo on the basis of respecting national sovereignty, emphasizes South-South cooperation, weakens western colonial hegemony on the continent, and genuinely assists in the construction of modern infrastructure in Congo and in Africa more broadly in order to have access to Congolese minerals needed for the development of green technology and renewable energy. Any green transition anywhere on Earth will have to engage with Africa broadly and the Congo in particular in order to happen on any meaningful level, and we can at least say that China has been markedly better on this front than ANY western country. On the other hand, there is no doubt that China enters a context marred by centuries of colonialism, exploitative labor, mafia style violence surrounding the organization and policing of the mining industry, and supply chains riddled with human rights abuses at almost every level. Its first priority is national development and its extraction of minerals, like Cobalt, from the Congo, though not done at the barrel of a gun or through colonial administration, is meant to benefit China first and foremost. From a pure proletarian internationalist perspective, China can rightly be criticized for some of its failures on this front, and for the lack of concern it seems to really have wrt to exploitation embedded in that industry and in that supply chain. It isnt able to fix it all by itself, of course, and we shouldn't expect it to. But it has real leverage it could use to better conditions for Congolese people and workers, and on the whole, it doesnt seem overly concerned about that. To be fair, China touts its international approach as NOT coming with lectures or dictates or social impositions, as it respects other countries sovereignty, so this behavior is in-line with that state approach. At the same time, it can seem convenient for China to be able to get its cake and eat it too on that front. Overall china’s role in congo should not be collapsed into classical colonial imperialism nor overly-romanticized as genuine socialist internationalism. It is a *contradictory* relationship: one that can and does weaken Western hegemony on the continent and genuinely contribute to infrastructure and development, while still reproducing or at least passively engaging in extractive dynamics, asymmetrical benefit, and insufficient concern for the exploited labor conditions embedded in the mining supply chain. I think that is a fair, honest assessment, not an ideologically zealous one. Open to criticism on that, though, as always!

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

Correct me if I am wrong, but China’s attitude toward exploited countries is not to lift them up, but to provide the space and opportunity for them to lift themselves up. The latter takes a lot longer but results in more stable development. To paraphrase Eugene V Debs, if someone does something for you, it can be undone by someone else. But if you learn to do it yourself, that is an achievement that almost cannot be undone. So China is providing solar panels to Cuba as a way to help Cuba get itself out from under US hegemony; but China is not declaring Cuba to be a protectorate of the PRC and simply importing new infrastructure to build up the island nation for them. I do not fully agree that China is not promoting indigenous technological development; they are offering truly mutually beneficial economic partnerships and investing in BRI specifically as a way to allow global south nations to dig themselves out from under the boot of imperialism. I am very sympathetic to the impulse to take an aggressive, antagonistic position vis-à-vis imperialist nations and global capital. But that kind of approach is fraught with danger and uncertainty, and could end badly for all involved. In chess, there are generally two types of play styles: tactical and positional. Tactical players look for opportunities to be aggressive and win quickly. They are usually very fun to watch, because everyone who plays and studies chess loves a beautiful tactical combo to win a game. It is highly aesthetically satisfying. But positional players are slow, methodical, and, at first glance, very boring to watch. They make small moves that incrementally improve their position. Sometimes it looks like there’s a tactic available, but usually, the positional player will not risk defeat and instead will continue to build up their advantage. Eventually, the opponent is completely outmaneuvered everywhere on the board, and has to admit defeat. China is, imo, playing a masterful positional game. They are avoiding making mistakes themselves and simply making sure they cannot be outflanked, outmaneuvered, and are not tactically vulnerable to sudden attacks. And eventually, they will win. Like Breht, I am not completely pleased with some of the moves China is making, providing weapons and maintaining relations with Israel, etc. But it is not our game of chess to play, it is China’s.

Lefty In Training

Good episode with some good points to consider. I think a central consideration on the China question is whether their state is qualitatively different than the imperialist West or if they are simply quantitatively different by having a more well controlled capitalist system that attempts to smooth over contradictions. My fear is that China is the next adaptation for the imperialist world system. Just as so-called anti-capitalism was subsumed by capitalism, I wonder if so-called anti-imperialism could be subsumed by imperialism, even if that requires capital to take a temporary retreat. Although I didn't like some of his arguments, two points of S4A's I liked in his more recent China critique video is what are the actual metrics the CPC is using to know when to mNOake the socialist turn anHd why do we always compare China to the US as opposed to the USSR.

JK

The more i hear from these people defending China as socialist, the more firmly I believe they are simply economists and reformists. The perceptive listener will notice this guest never once talked about the Dictatorship of the Proletariat or the Working Class. I think the way he portrays political economy tells you everything you need to know: The goal is to discipline capitalism, not eradicate it, or get rid of it.....but instead to shake hands and collaborate with one another. Any Marxists would not call that Socialism. Wheeling and dealing around the international market is NOT going to overthrow capitalism. I appreciate that you straight up asked him about the rising inequality and criticisms of so-called Chinese Socialism, but really think you should have hammered the point home after he answered. "Its the PHILOSOPHY behind it. The form and not the content". Shortly before calling others idealists, he takes the idealist stance to answer your question, completely avoiding your materialist inquiry on HOW CHINA PLANS TO ELIMINATE CLASSES. You know....things that arn't bound in philosophy but on real material conditions. To support his claim, he compares China to..... India. A fucking capitalist country. "You dont think China is socialist? Well just look how bad India is doing comparatively". I understand the urge to be polite, but you should have held his feet to the fire on that. We need absolute clarity on the ideas if we ever hope to establish actual Socialism and Communism. Just like your guest was able to hand-wave away any concerns that China isnt socialist, he also proclaims that Imperialism with Chinese-characteristics is somehow different and nothing to be concerned about. In-fact, its the opposite; extracting other countries wealth for your own electric car industry is ANTI-Imperialist. Absolute clown show. Finally, this dude, along with so many others, are quick to claim that any criticisms of China (and not actually adhering to fucking Marxism) are the result of the western lefts chauvinistic vision of what Socialism should be. So naturally, and chauvinistically, China there-for should just build "Socialism" for its own people, within its own borders, cause fuck the international working class. You got a billion people and how many thousands of supposed cadres. Why have i never heard a blip of Chinese Communist propaganda inciting the overthrow of my own ruling class at home? Why don't they flood the internet with their immense strength to speak about the Epstein Class, or open up the books (finances) showcasing how the American (or any other capitalist country) ruling class are fucking their workers at home? You dont need to ponder the answer: its cause they arn't Marxists, do not want communism, and certainly do not want international global proletarian revolution. As your guest wanted to share, "socialism is when the government does stuff, and it can only happen super duper slowly......but dont worry, we will get there eventually. Trust me". Sorry, I'm not going to follow your theory for the prospect of Socialism/Communism 400 fucking years from now. We don't have that sort of time. Yes, the inheritance of the planned economy in China has allowed it to make substantial gains as compared to the cut throat ruthless capitalism that exists everywhere else. But it begs the question, what do we want: A state capitalist society where a bureaucratic caste runs the show, similar to Stalinism after the original Bolsheviks were killed/jailed/expelled..... or do we want power in the full hands of the Working Class? The only people who benefit from the long march to socialism are the Bourgeois, who upon realizing their mode of production is dying can worm their way into these positions of power and ensure they come out the other end on top. The working class will be made the ones to suffer for the mistakes of socialism as a stagist method done over the course of multiple generations, in one country at a time. This is not Dialectical. Marxist Voice just dropped an excellent podcast called: "Mao Zedong: His Life, Legacy, and Limits". Would be cool if you gave it a listen and shared your thoughts, cause I think it much more closely aligns with your understanding of Marxism. Anyway, love you Brett, hope you're doing well comrade.

SaSeigneurie

Another comment on China: I suggest you people follow the work of Ehsan Safarnejad who has been following the actions of China (and Russia) in relation to the Axis of Resistance, and has pointed out the backpedaling China has done on deals it had with the Axis because the imperial side provided them with a better deal. This goes to show once again the absence of an ideological anti-imperial mindset in the current chinese elite. And as Marx & Engels reminded us, the rulling ideas of a society are those of its ruling class.

Michael Murray

As an Irish physics PhD research in sustainable optical materials I find it truly fascinating how they have made capital subservient to the state. I think it would be really interesting if you could get Abbey Heffer on the show, she is an political science PhD student who specializes on Chinese politics and provides very in-depth unbiased analyses of the Chinese political economic system. She is quite prominent on Instagram, tiktok, youtube, ans substack. Think it would be very complementary :) Also, very grateful for this podcast and all your hard work thank you 🙏

BammEs

Very interesting episode! China's policy is anti-imperialist in a much more subtle way than we're used to. It opens up space for sovereign development across the Global South instead of simply helping countries break free from direct colonial rule. It's a long term game. But in refusing the more direct, radical anti-imperialist action, you'll see them do many things that contradict this too. Complete non-interference in countries' national politics is always going to be contradictory, but in the grander scheme of things, it furthers sovereign development