Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this episode, Breht speaks with scholar Angie Bittar about the life, thought, and enduring relevance of Carl Jung. Together they explore Jung’s understanding of the unconscious, archetypes, the shadow, individuation, dreams, symbols, myth, and the modern search for meaning.

After introducing Jung on his own terms, Breht and Angie place Jung in conversation with Marxism, historical materialism, and revolutionary politics. They discuss alienation, spiritual hunger, reactionary projection, fascist myth, scapegoating, bourgeois individualism, and the ways unconscious forces shape ideology and political life. They also ask what radicals can usefully take from Jung, what they should remain cautious about, and how the left might confront its own shadow without reducing politics to therapy.

Check out a great new resource for revolutionary education, Unlearning Capitalism: https://unlearn.capital/

Files

Comments

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Breht, I truly learn so many things from you and the guests you have on Rev Left Radio. This was such a multifaceted and fascinating conversation that I’ll likely need to relisten to for a deeper understanding of what you and Angie discussed here.

Rev Left Radio

So glad to hear that, truly means a lot. Thank you for your support!

Lefty In Training

For people of my generation and background, we first ran into Jung's ideas through the Persona video game series. Characters use their shadow selves to fight manifestations of others' personal subconscious or the collective subconscious. Shadows are usually tied to archetypes based off tarot. Predictably, these concepts are used rather shallowly, but it was an interesting fusion of psychology and RPG mechanics.

Madeline

I love the dialectics you've been exploring between the internal and the external, the societal and spiritual-so so important and fruitful!!!

Brad Northcote

You and Angie both did a great job of analyzing Jung on his own terms and in a dialectic with Freud! I've also been more familiar with Freud (and thought about his idea of the unconscious under the influence of Schopenhauer's will). Most of my exposure to Jung has highlighted references by reactionaries or New Age ideology, so having a critical Marxist guidance is really helpful. I'll also have to give this another listen...and look forward to listening to that Dialectic of Enlightenment episode three times!

Rev Left Radio

I am very happy to hear that! That is the core of my upcoming book as well! Im glad the basic idea resonates with you, I have truly made it a core goal of mine to push this particular dialectic and highlight its importance. Ive seen time and time again meaningful organizing get undermined by the underdevelopment of the well meaning people involved and their inability to sideline their egos, navigate disagreement and criticism, or use organizing an ego-project instead of as a moral obligation to others! Its not a left problem, its a human problem - but our historical responsibilities in the 21st century as the left are too great to be undermined by our all too human but largely unnecessary frailities!

Rev Left Radio

Thanks Brad! And yes, the Dialectic of Enlightenment episode will be a monumental one, as the book itself is. Ive heard its notoriously difficult to read too. Still, im committed! And yes, the lineage of Schopenhauer/Nietzche to Freud/Jung is direct and intense, yet often overlooked and underdiscussed!

Burhan Alawadhi

Amazing episode. On to my second listen!

Max

This was such a fantastic episode. Thanks Angie! Thanks Breht!

Sarah

Really fascinating! It’s so interesting to examine how our society may be different if we’d adopted different psychologies - or potentially rather if our society was different what psychologies we may have embraced more fully

Morgan Ro

This is such an amazing episode, and glad I listened to it twice. Thanks to you and Angie.

Sean Thomas

Thanks so much for this Breht! I wanted to say there's a compelling evolutionary explanation for the collective unconscious when viewed through the lens of multi-level selection theory from thinkers like David Sloan Wilson. Re human evolution, the idea is that natural selection tipped in favor of group-level natural selection, such that it was advantageous for the human group to act _as individual_ rather than a group of individuals. So humans developed various "mechanisms of coordination" to think and feel the same thing at the same time, from a contagious yawn to religion. Thus, folks like Wilson would argue that we have a biological imperative to worship in community, and that humans are fiercely egalitarian by nature, etc etc. All this to say we came pre-packaged with a collective (un)consciousness and that _some_ archetypes (eg the wise elder) probably have a biological component. Alsoooo, would love to hear you and David Sloan Wilson riff. He's more of an anarchist or libertarian socialist, but I think the conversation would still be stimulating/generative.

Eli 🇵🇸

FANTASTIC episode! These episodes are rapidly becoming my favorites. I’m a better organizer for the things I learn here.

SaSeigneurie

This episode was way over my little brain (partially because I do not care much for psychoanalysis beyond what F Fanon did). That being said, two comments: - the image of the "white woman" is typical of western Europe, as in places like Central Africa white is associated with fear & evil, while in East Asia (China for instance) it is linked to death. - the idea that a "society is a male concept" is very anglo-saxon. Even in western Europe, for societies with gendered language (like french, italian, spanish, german, etc) this is not necessarily true. For instance, "la société" is female in French & encompasses the idea of femineity, including the concept of care - more generally, what I took from this discussion was that the under-riding ideology had huge anglo-saxon & protestant undertones which represent a tiny minority of the human societies Little note to Brent: hinduism (like judaism) are based on the ideology of the selected people chosen by a higher power, completely opposite to the universalism of christianity & islam (to take the 2 main monotheist religions). It is therefore surprising to me to hear you promote it as much as you do, even though I can understand why it did/does help you at a personal level. I highly suggest you try & dig through eastern christianity & islam (mainly modern synthesis of twelver & sevener shias) if you are interested in a modern synthesis of religion/spirituality that also includes material conditions & anti-imperialism.

Steven Phillips

A book called The American Shadow would be an amazing read. Breht, how about a third book on that contract?? 😉

David Duba

This episode was really interesting! All the episodes relating to spirituality and/or philosophy are my favorite and something I deeply appreciate about RevLeft. I was struggling with some friction toward a colleague and realized while listening to this that a lot of it came from insecurity in my own unconscious. I apologized to my colleague and we ended up resolving a lot of under the surface tension!

Liz Mooney

Omg, Breht! I have the same dreams! I call them my anxiety dreams. Never bothered to analyze them, but I’m always hurrying to get home and there’s not enough time. I have to pack or get on a train or plane or something and there’s this immense struggle to catch the transportation or get to the place and I know in my mind that it’s almost impossible that I’m going to make it but I spend the whole dream struggling to overcome hurdles. It’s recurring in different iterations for decades and I have just chalked it up to underlying anxiety but I haven’t really considered the cause. They are exhausting! I wake up feeling like I spent the night running a marathon or chasing something. 😂

Sarah Rea

For Angie/also Breht: While I'm wary of the women finding their "lost ancestral spirituality" and people who call themselves Jungian analysts, have either of you read "The Women Who Run With Wolves" by CP Estes? Any thoughts on that type of Jungian analysis? OR any thoughts on Sabina Spielrein's Destruction as the Cause of Coming Into Being?

Theo

I just listened to this. You two did an amazing job explaining Jung, which is not easy as his thinking shifts and evolves so much across his life. You did a good job capturing classical Jungian thought. I would add that there is a lot of work being done now in this field than in Jung's time. Depth psychology, or Analytical Psychology, is trying to understand the intergenerational transmission of collective trauma. My own work as a therapist who is also doing a PhD in depth psychology and training to be a Jungian Analyst touches on the transmission of genocidal trauma, the archetype of trauma, and how to heal from it.

Hana

Oh no! Really really no. Jung's personal history and political/social/sexual attitudes are horrendous! It's all mysticism, abstraction and "I dreamt I was Jesus". He wanted to establish a religion but that was even too open and he switched to the notion of a secret society. Closing off anything useful in psychoanalysis and rendering it all in spooky language. He states it in his own correspondence. Then there's the anti-Semitism (also written down by the man himself), the abuse of his cousin (pretty much written down but cloaked in clinical language)... This is not useful to Marxism and material analysis, it's exactly what it opposes - idealism, racism, self-obsession, narrow nationalism and mystification. We don't need this shit in our movement.