Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We have not done one of these in a while. Alyson has agreed to join Breht for an AMA!

Please comment below any question you may have for them.

Comments

Perro Wero

Hello Breht & Alyson! Could you please discuss the plausibility of the USA (out of frustration and desperation to maintain hegemony in West Asia) actually launching some type of nuclear strike against Iran. Not only how plausible that may be, but also what could be potential reactions by the global south, specifically by Russia, China & the DPRK. I know it's a big question, but your dialectical analysis on the subject would be appreciated. Thank you comrades. Solidarity! ✊🏼

latentcall

This is for Breht: When I found out you were based in Omaha, I was pretty proud as I’m from the state as well. Nebraska is a pretty “conservative” state with some fucked up electoral politics as of late. I understand you’re a parent (me too!) and my question is this: how did you reckon with that especially raising kids as you developed politically? Did you ever consider moving to another more “blue” state? What made you decide to stay? Thank you! You are a huge inspiration to me. Btw, loved your podcast about parenting.

Mickey Marx

Hello! You’ve mentioned you do a socialist night school in your home town - would you ever consider doing an online version of that course? I feel like we could help fund it. Ive been eager for more trusted education on socialism / Marxism and would help in inviting more to learn as well. Thanks for all you both do, love & solidarity from Phoenix, AZ 🌵🏜️

Gorgatron888

Hi Breht and Alyson, I'm a huge fan of the pod but my question is about something I'm a bigger fan of, and that's the history of losers. I'm fascinated by the losers of history that were smashed by progressive for es of history. The Confederacy, the Third Reich, etc. My question is what can we learn from the new interest on the right of their imagined promised land of Rhodesia( thankfully and correctly known as Zimbabwe.)? I have no love or respect for that former state, just very interested in how so many on the right ignore the disgusting nature of that country because idk people from England had farms or something. Anyway, thanks!

Pk

Hello Breht & Alyson! My question is; For newer leftists, who are looking for educational material. What are some resources for getting marxist current events /breaking news? I have been specifically been looking for sources that cover the socialist experiments around the world without the western propaganda, like china, cuba, etc.

Lana

Hi! I recommend Upstream Podcast/Patreon for coverage of Cuba, China etc. As for geopolitics from a Marxist lens, Elina Xenophontos is fantastic. Socialist Program is another “news” program that analyzes news from a socialist perspective.

Pk

Thanks comrade!

Tristan You

Hi Brett and Alyson! Me and my girlfriend love the pod and it has shaped a lot of our political tendency! We’re very grateful for yall. We’re encountering a very difficult situation involving one of our communities. We live in San Francisco and play ultimate frisbee as our main sport and community. This year on our club team, there is a player attempting to join the team who is a cop. This person was previously on the team and is in very good standing with various members of the community. We and some others obviously take major issue with allowing a cop on the team. Many others do not and have a biased perspective because it’s their friend and well they are all libs living in San Francisco. Many of them bring up very individualistic perspectives about how they might be a good cop, or they joined for good reasons, etc. It is difficult thing to grapple with because it’s a community of people we care about and get a lot of joy about playing a sport with. We want them to learn, and are doing our best to educate and to bring people out of their positions of comfort and privilege but it is difficult. We are grappling with what it means to be part of a community with such a political schism. Many of them simply operating from a completely (propagandized and indoctrinated) perspective. Do we just abandon them? Do we suck it up and say ok we will play with the cop? Thanks for the guidance!

Scott Brogan

Need better strategies on explaining the 3 way fight to family democrats liberals. Not sure i need a more direct approach, or something different.

Scott Brogan

If this trillion dollar data center investment by the mega rich, collapses. The the economy bust, what strategies of survival can we do, thinking roof top food like cuba, and things that get food on the table fast. It's not just about saving ourself, we need our comrade united together. Side note. Just using the Bolsheviks 4 shadowing the reasons not to go to war, world war one. If we set up strategies for survival in an economic collapse, the masses wil see, and remember. Something like that. Thank you

Scott Brogan

The scientific advancements in China have been very impressive. High trains and so much more. Have scientists in China, become less likely to move over to capitalist society for personal wage increase. What's convincing them to stay in China and support a more egalitarian society

Lana

Love AMA’s!! Could you dissect some of the ways that Buddhism and Marxism intersect/align and ways they are opposed? And why in your opinion (or why not) should Marxists should embrace Buddhism?

Left Hand Notes

Do you two have any advice for building up political education within a local socialist org? How much do you think we should focus on depth of education versus accessibility for those who might be put off by reading older texts (not necessarily because they’re against reading older texts, but just because they’re harder to read)? Thanks so much for doing this AMA!

Andrea Bolt

Very good recs by Lana. The Socialist Program is also a part of Breakthrough News or BT, they have a weekly rundown of world events. The hosts Rania Khalek and Eugene Puryear are fantastic. Also, the Grayzone with Matt Blumenthal and Aaron Mate is where it’s at for all things on the communist left, excellent reporting on current events, documentaries and expose pieces. I’ve learned a lot about Iran and Russia thanks to them!

Dingo

While not explicitly Marxist, Electronic Intifada is a great Anti-Imperialist news source for Palestine specifically and West Asia generally. Highly recommend you check them out! I second BTNews and Elina Xenophontos!

Dingo

Hi Breht and Alyson! I got into Fine Arts a few years back, specifically oil painting. I have been painting a lot lately, and I was listening to Rev Left while painting and I just wondered if you all ever dabbled with any arts. Even if you haven't, are there any artworks that really resonate with you? Art periods? Honestly I would just love to hear y'all riff about art. Thank you!

Moe G.

Cats, dogs, or both?

ZachyBeats 🇵🇸

Thank you for hosting this Q&A, comrades! My question is around your respective organizing efforts. I know that Breht is involved in political education through the night school he teaches and has shared that he has been involved with DSA locally, and that Alyson has been heavily involved in tenant organizing in LA. What keeps you both motivated to maintain your organizing efforts in spite of everything that you both have going on in your lives? And how do you make time to read Marxist theory (or the books of your guests before their appearances) alongside your organizing efforts, careers, and other life obligations?

Dan Ludwig

Hello from California! I have a question that’s mostly directed at Breht. I recall in an episode that Breht had mentioned that he looked into becoming a firefighter. I recently just finished all of my training to become a firefighter and I’m now a wildland firefighter for the state of California. Part of this process of training has been learning about the culture of firefighters and, at least in CA, it’s very conservative. I find that odd because my values as a socialist is what drew me towards firefighting and protecting the environment. Do either of you know any resources I can check out that intersects a radical tradition with firefighting? I feel like there has to be some literature out there but I’ve struggled to find much. Much love from San Diego you both have been integral to my own personal education which lead me towards firefighting in the first place.

Cassidy

How have you been able to overcome ideological differences in organizing with anarchists? I’m always curious how ML’s/MLM’s resolve differences with anarchists to work together for the benefit of the community. I’m an anarchist, really more of a Bookchinite tbh, and I have many MLM comrades I adore and have great admiration for the work they do in my community. But inevitably there’s shit talking on both sides and it really bums me out because it’s really unproductive. I wish we could spend more time engaging in good faith dialogue about how to create well-being for all.

Monty O’Blivion

Hi Breht and Alyson! I am wondering if y’all have any thoughts on the role of music in revolutionary movements, and/or suggestions on how musicians can be more principled and effective in contributing to the movement, whether it’s songwriting being used as effective propaganda, or how people interact with each other in the music scene or how local music scenes can connect better with organizations, etc. I’ve been struggling to figure out how to bridge these two worlds, and also have felt discouraged by the individualism that seems common in the music world but I also see so much potential in today’s underground music, I mean, it’s almost standard at this point for bands to say “fuck ice” during their set, and “free Palestine” to a lesser degree. How can we harness that energy and channel this moment into effective organizing? (Feel free to skip if this question if it’s too specific to music, I know, Breht, you’ve mentioned that you were part of your local music scene in the past, so just if you happen to have thoughts, I’d love to hear you and Alyson riff on it! Thanks!!)

Advait

Curious why you don't focus on educating your audience about MMT? One of the biggest obstacles to the progressive national agenda is the rejoinder "How you gonna pay for it?" This rejoinder refers to the completely false myth that national taxes and borrowing fund national spending (they don't). I think you're familiar with MMT (Modern Money Theory) so you know that on the national level, taxes and borrowing in no way, shape or form fund national spending. Progressives talk about taxing the rich to fund the progressive agenda. That's fine on state and local levels, but it's nonsense on the national level. I think as long as the majority of people and the majority of leftists don't understand MMT, then the progressive agenda will continue to fail. I feel sad when I see progressives shoot themselves in the feet when they proclaim "We'll tax the rich to pay for such and such national progressive program!" Such nonsense. I'm really curious why progressives and leftists are still afraid to speak economic truth and educate their supporters. Democratic Eco-Socialism plus MMT = a powerful and winning strategy. Solidarity!

Rams

My partner and I are in talks to take over an established vegetable farm. Our dream is to grow it to a size that can support 4-5 workers, and to have it be worker owned. What do we know as modern socialists and radicals about actually managing small businesses as worker owned enterprises? What are some of the best models throughout time?

Lana

Okay from one art maker to another, I LOVE this question, especially the part about hearing Breht and Alyson riff about art. An entire episode on art or even a light historical materialist analysis on various art movements in the West would be so DOPE.

Lana

Great question. the art world in general is so steeped in individualism; as a visual artist, I see it in the visual art world too. *siiigh*

Carli Leppard

Do you have any thoughts on the pressure to feel partnered in this current economy? (I get so depresso that it’s so much easier financially to split a one bedroom with a partner than paying double that on your own). Of course I just live with a roommate cuz it’s impossible in my city to afford that for myself but I get so sad sometimes that I … don’t want to feel pressured to find a partner (would love to let this happen on its own timing and be the right person) nonetheless I do feel that thought in the back of my head going “if only you had a boyfriend to live with, etc. You could have it easier financially AND a more harmonious living situation, but you don’t!” despite not wanting to think like that! Ways to combat this // is this the wrong way to look at things? Either way - thank you so much for your contributions to knowledge and teaching and I can’t express how much I enjoy and am grateful for RevLeft.

Zane Suhadolnik

Breht I was listening to your backlog and in one episode you mentioned your sister was being evicted, is she and her family okay now?

Jacob Bucci

Just picked up Graeber's "Pirate Enlightenment, or the real libertalia", and after reading the preface I'm considering a new personal policy of refusing to discuss history or politics with anyone who hasn't read it. Thoughts?

Clinton Fraser

Just curious as to American left views on JFK. I Have always thought that he was a cold war warrior but there's so much different takes .just wonder what your thoughts are?

Drea

How do you relate to "anti- state" tendencies of Marxism? Reading Chris Gilbert's book on Venezuelan communes and so far it includes a fair amount of critique of state socialist projects and an emphasis on Marx having been anti-state.

StinkLord

I just signed up to join a CSA, def look into that!

StinkLord

How do you discuss politics with your more reactionary coworkers? I have coworkers who are extremely liberal (they miss Obama, go to Starbucks, hate Trump, use ChatGPT for emails…). They don’t really delve into anything more deeply than what’s at face value. More recently, my Vietnamese American coworker was explaining to everyone how April 30 was the anniversary of the Fall of Saigon ….aka reunification day from the anti-imperialist perspective. It was a very annoying day lol. I know you mentioned meeting your coworkers where they are at, but I’m just curious how either of you manage to deal with it when they say something blatantly wrong/reactionary. Is it worth it to speak up at all? It feels like an opportunity to push them in a less reactionary direction.

Monty O’Blivion

Oh I’m sure! It’s ass backwards, art is supposed to be shared by everyone to enrich our lives, interpret our existence and make us feel connected to one another. But just like capitalism alienates us from each other and from our work and the fruits of our labor, same goes with art. Which, actually makes sense, because art is a form of labor, right? I think it was Stalin who said artists are the engineers of the soul. Anyway, I’m glad I’m not the only one feeling this! Haha

Mexican Stalin

Why did the Western left adopt self-destructive traits like being unhygienic, unpresentable, and neglecting self-care such as exercise or a healthy diet? Was it empathy toward the new problems we face in modern material conditions, or was it a rebellion against conservative puritanical ethics? To use myself as an example: I have a bad foot, and I work full-time at an auto parts store. After I get off work, my foot hurts so badly that I'm basically bedridden. This makes it hard for me to clean, shower, cook, and nearly impossible to exercise. So I can understand why losers like me are drawn to dialectical materialism as a way to make sense of our suffering. Or maybe I'm just projecting my own thoughts, and it has more to do with the hippie anti-war movement of the '60s and '70s.

Sleeper_Waves

How do you manage relationships with friends and family members who somehow still support Israel? I never want to cut someone off but I’m having a harder and harder time interacting with people who are essentially on the same level as Nazi sympathizers, in my book.

Rams

That’s great! We’re planning on basing our sales on the CSA model.

From The River To The Sea 🇵🇸

Do you have any thoughts about the recent CIA deaths in México? Any thoughts on Evo Morales being charged with human trafficking in Bolivia? Please consider doing an episode with the hosts of the podcast Soberenía.

Dragonfly Moth

Hi Breht and Alyson, I’ve begun to see a rise in the term “campism" to criticize leftists whose primary focus is on imperialism, war, and empire. I thought it was some online radlib nonsense, a new twist on “tank”, but even an anarchist friend I know irl offline called my focus on opposition to American Imperialism "campist". Perhaps he’s right! I view imperialism and colonialism (in all its forms, settler, neo, and traditional) as the primary contradictions which must be opposed, though those are inextricably linked with Capitalism. Just curious if you’ve encountered this and have any analysis of the existence of the term.

Wil

Imagine you could go back in time and meet your younger, un-politically conscious self. If you could give yourself a list of readings to do (in order from beginner friendly to more in depth), to send you on the path towards a fuller understanding of marxism, what would those readings be?

Dylan F

Maybe not the best question to answer on the podcast, but if Breht, Alyson, or anyone else in the comments have book recommendations for a soon to be parent, it would be much appreciated! I usually study and read history, but spirituality, philosophy, fiction, also resonate with me. Breht’s podcasts on raising children have really landed with me, so I thought this would be a great time and place to ask. Thanks to all!

Cat Ledue

Where’s the line between making a valid critique of liberal elitism and just being a class reductionist? When does the critique of liberalism just become a way to avoid addressing things that only effect women and Black and Brown folks, lgbtq issues, imperialism, micro aggressions, “cultural” issues, language…? - I’m thinking of the growing popularity of Vivek Chibber (who I don’t hate) and Dino Guastella (who I pretty much always disagree with!)

matt

hey alyson and breht, first off love and solidarity, the both of you are indispensable for deepening political education for so many. i have been been wanting to get involved in a local org for a while now, the one concern that sticks out to me is dealing with surveillance. i heard from another podcast that it be best that if you’re not openly a communist/leftist, it’s best to keep it that way, and do organizing in a much smaller, essentially underground fashion, with a cell of a handful people you would trust your life with, that you’ve literally known for years. i’m wondering what your recommendation would be in these times, given flock cameras, social media surveillance, and the NPSM-7 directive by the current admin. obviously the left has been plagued with state counterinsurgency, red scares, surveillance and infiltration for decades, and it’s a very real problem that persists and has evolved with the tech today. wondering if you all have any thoughts or recommendations on joining an above ground org versus the small-cell formation in these times.

chep

Damn. I am really proud of you for having this moral framework for your leisure activities. I find myself in the same boat when it comes to coalition building as a ML with groups that may be anti capitalist, but have members who have not done the work to be intersectional whatsoever. Very interesting question and dilemma. Who wants to play anything with a slave catcher lol

SaSeigneurie

Assuming AMA stands for "ask me anything", I would like to ask what many in West Asia are asking: where is the "jewish" John Brown? More broadly, why is it that so many (anarchist) westoids joined the kurdish forces of Syria & Iraq during the fight against ISIS (a western creation), none have joined the Axis of Resistance to fight the genocidal coalition of NATO + the USoA + the nazionist state. To this day we still have those westoids criticise "both sides" of the current anti-imperial struggle in West Asia. Why is it that most westoids are ready to do peaceful marches but not take actually constructive actions such as what the british-based Palestine Action? I have my own explanation, particularly for regarding amurikans, but It will be nice to hear from you guys. Note that Laith Marouf is one of the most english-speaking journalist who has been asking this to westoids (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14ksMU2KpN0)

Cat Ledue

If you have time, could you respond to the criticisms of “Who paid the pipers of Western Marxism”? (Other than saying academics’ critiques only proves Rockhills’ point). I think the CIA’s involvement in Left academia and Foucault’s complicity in anti-communism is inarguable - yet I still think we should read Foucault and the Frankfurt school…and Noam Chomsky…I don’t know I am overwhelmed looking at the backlash to Rockhill (including from academics I do trust) because I simply do not have the expertise to assess his methodology and evidence

Rance Orrell

I’m part of a local effort to stop a hyperscale data center from being built in my rural community and it’s brought up some really interesting questions for me regarding the political motivations and alignments of the other folks involved in both our local effort and similar efforts across the country. our group, like so many others in the anti-data center fights, includes people from a wider array of political persuasions than i have ever seen come together towards one goal. it’s also pitting certain factions of liberals and certain factions of conservatives against one another in new ways. this seems like a potentially major site of political realignment in the coming months and years, and I’m curious if y’all have thought much about it and what that could mean for the political landscape going forward?

chep

I wish there was a way for everyone on these comments to form a book club.

No-L

I'm interested in learning more about practicing Buddhism as a way to better ground myself in a world that feels sick and like it's constantly spinning out of control. Do you have any book recommendations for someone totally new to understanding Buddhism?

Eli 🇵🇸

I would GREATLY appreciate your feedback on this one, on air or not. Hearing about your intro into the union trades has really got me thinking about that as a path for myself. How did you land that opportunity, and what kind of advice could you offer for someone seeking a similar route?

Bill

Reform or Revolution? A modern debate where each of you (Breht and Alyson) pick one opposing side each and then argue it.

sarah

Do you have a favorite pundit that you often disagree with? For example I disagree with Ezra Klein 70% of the time but still listen to pretty much every episode of his show

Anton Pannekoek

The imperialist war against Iran has now gone on for three months, the straight of Hormus has be shot down for the same time . but still, we haven`t seen the price shock on oil markets that was expected and predicted. How exactly are western nation states and their finiancial systems manipulating the oil prices and how long can they keep this up before the price bumerang hits?

Pj

You've both expressed previously some agreements with broader MLM ideas, where do you see those in currently existing spaces and why do you think the (arguably) two biggest examples in the US (Avakian RCP-USA and Red Guards/CR-CPUSA) are the ones that really leaned into the cult of personality-type of leadership?

Cat Ledue

Not explicitly Marxist, but Democracy Now! and Propublica are really reputable and reliable and inherently Left-leaning just because they are so committed to being independent and covering stories the mainstream doesn’t - tbh I think it’s important to get my news from sources that aren’t committed to an ideology so I can make sense of the headlines myself and then I go and consult other sources for a deeper analysis - such as Novara Media and this podcast - I also read a lot of Damage Magazine pieces and Jacobin pieces and wherever Vijay Prashad is published; I often expose myself to analyses that contradict one another and my head spins - but I feel like it’s really productive to do so

sarah

Ok I have a new question. I am a high school teacher and I have a boy who is very open to left wing ideas but has been won to a lot of anti semetic conspiracy. We have talked extensively about the difference between Judaism and Zionism and all of that but I’m wondering if you have any advice of media you would recommend to a sort of traditionally masculine 16 year old boy to help him see the world more clearly!

Dustin Deane

Have you ever read into quantum mechanics/ entaglement? I find it extremely difficult as everyone does but I find the implications interesting. Though it is a completely different field that sometimes comes into contradiction with materialism, I can't help but draw the parallels to the dialectical worldview and even to a degree some of the concepts you discuss in more of your spiritual episodes. In any case, would you ever consider a guest from that field? Might prove to be an interesting dialog.

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Given your recent engagement with Too Black's "Nonviolence is Violence, Too" theory, and given your commitment to big tent discussion and to holding dialogue with leftist voices where you have substantial disagreement in some areas - would you be open to interviewing a scholar or scholars who are proponents of revolutionary nonviolence/revolutionary pacifism, in the spirit of open dialogue? Not reformists like Erica Chenoweth, you understand, but actual revolutionaries? I believe there's rich potential for such a discussion to generate illuminating and enlightening perspectives that you and your values may find highly valuable, even as I'm sure you'll be unpersuaded by your interlocutor's central thesis.

McMiller

Peter Hudis Marx alternative to capitalism on your radar at all?

Dylan R.

For both Alyson & Breht, how do you manage your socialist organizing efforts with your partner/ spouse? My partner is basically a center left liberal that likes CNN and gets annoyed if I talk politics. I normally hold my tongue to spare us both the frustration but I'm finding it very difficult to bring them over to socialism and have us both or at least one of us start organizing. Love & solidarity!

Rev Left Radio

Im actually going on the Macro n' Cheese podcast, a MMT podcast, soon to talk about Marxism. Ill see if I can in turn get them to come on and educate my audience on Modern Monetary Theory!!!

Rev Left Radio

If I had more time, Id do a rev left book club! Still might at some point. its a great idea for sure. Wondering how I m ight be able to faciltate the development of one without having to be too involved, so that you and others could start doing it without me.... hm, idk.

Rev Left Radio

Yes! That was quite a while ago, our audience came through in a big way, stabilized her housing situation via donations, I helped her construct a budget, and then she eventually found a job and they are doing fine now! Without our audience, they would have absolutely been evicted and their lives would have taken a dramatically worse trajectory... I am forever grateful for the generous support shown by our audience. Still moves me deeply to think about it...

Rev Left Radio

Yes, its a challenging but rewarding path. Unions offer a dignity to your work and a baseline class consciousness with your coworkers that you really cant find anywhere else. Union trades include electricians, steam fitters, insulators, Ironworkers, sheet metal workers, and more. You have to apply to the union apprenticeship program through your locals website. Find what trade you are interested in, then find what local union hall represents that trade in your city/metro, and go to their website to submit an application. The process of applying can be kinda long and annoying, as you need highschool transcripts and other paperwork, often have to pass an aptitude test (mostly college freshman level math and reading comprehension, at least I did in my trade), and then if you pass all that, youll have an interview with the committee. After jumping through all those hoops, youll be drug tested and upon passing, allowed in. My advice would be to go for it. Its one of the last areas of work where a working class person can make a living, not have to worry about being automated away or outsourced, and can have great medical care, multiple pensions, and high wages. The challenging part is adapting to the blue collar construction site lifestyle: work starts before the sun rises, you often work outside in the elements summer and winter, its grimey and gritty af, loud and potentially dangerous if you arent paying attention, and its physical labor. I remember being so sore walking off the job site the first week or two. Shitting in a portapotty in 100 degree heat or - 20 degrees F isnt fun either lmao. But if that isnt enough to dissuade you (and I dont think it should be!), then go for it. It changes you in a lot of ways. Working with your hands, building a new knowledge base, using tools and working with your union brothers and sisters on big projects, being out in the sun, rain, snow and mud, and being able to accomplish real, concrete things in the material world - standing back at the end of the day and seeing what you built from scratch - its all very very rewarding. It toughens you up mentally and physically. The Union offers immediate community for you and your family too: our union has events every holiday, events for union brothers and sisters who have passed away, golf and bowling leagues, etc. All while you learn a socially-valuable skillset that will always be needed. You will be literally helping build society, and that is just fucking cool. So yea, find a trade that speaks to you and interests you (commerical / industrial inside wireman or outside lineman are often perfect for thinking people) and apply! If you have any other questions hmu via email: andersonbrett2011@gmail.com. Ill help as much as I can! <3

Eli 🇵🇸

Bro, thank you so fucking much! What great insight. I really can’t tell you how much I appreciate you taking the time to answer that in such detail.

Rev Left Radio

criticisms of Rockhills approach aside, I agree with you, that even if we admit that they are complicit in anti-communism and might even have been played up or spread by our enemies, their work is undeniably interesting and useful. If you are already a marxist, it didnt work on you, so you can feel free to read all those thinkers and engage critically with them and their ideas, taking what is useful (and there is a TON that is useful) and leaving what is not! I have not been following the response to Rockhills book too closely tbh, but that would be my initial response to your question.

Rev Left Radio

I for one liked and enjoyed his book and think he is correct in general, and really like and respect him as a person and a thinker.

Rev Left Radio

haha this is a good one! Ill try to address it on air, but my initial statement would be that its a weak critique by anti-communists who do not understand or refuse to acknowledge the central role of imperialism in organizing capitalism globally. I dont find the label particularly deep or cutting, and am beyond confident that anyone who would lob that accusation at me could be dealt with intellectually quite easily. It is just another way of saying tankie, which isnt so much a serious philosophical analytical point of principled disagreement as much as it is a lazy pejorative wielded against anti-imperialists by people who want to critique the victims of western imperialism with the same spite and vitriol and totalizing hostility that they critique western states with, without having to account for the material realities of the world, the role their government plays in destroying lives and societies, and their own possible complicity in that criminal enterprise. Its an idealist critique at the end of the day; which isnt to say that no one on the Marxist left technically falls into a camp wherein they uncritically and unthinkingly side with, and even romanticize, the Imperialist West's opposition soley on the basis of them being in opposition to the Imperialist Wests, but in that case, I have to ask: is that seriously a problem worth focusing on? IF one is going to commit any political error or deviation, I'd say siding too strongly with countries facing off against imperialism is the best error one could make! lol Put that way, its an absurd thing to fixate on, combat vigorously, or care about. The error, in so far as there is one, isnt determinative; that contradiction is under-determined and, politically speaking, pretty irrelevant imo.

Advait

To be honest, I think you could do a great job yourself educating your audience about MMT. I think you know all the basics and it's easy to learn more with Grumbine's videos and "The MMT Podcast" episodes. I know I'm a broken record, but lack of understanding of MMT is the single biggest thing holding back the leftist progressive movement. Thanks for all your great videos! :-)

Redwhiskr

Can you explain vulgar materialism and how many marxists accidentally slip back into it? For example, to say that words and ideas dont matter at all is already dropping the dialectics of dialectical materialism. We accept that a "changed man" must first have changed circumstances, but it is people who changed those circumstances that change people. I think we can all agree a changed person will have new thoughts, ideas, and words that, along with new actions, then change circumstances. Lenin knew this after doing a deep dive on Hegal in 1915 that the people must also believe they could take control of their own conditions and existence and rip it out the hands of those that oppress them. Love your show, thanks for all you do!

Anonymous

For both, but especially Alyson since she is a tenant organizer. 1. As a tenant organizer, I’m curious if ya’ll are familiar with the Tenant Union Federation. They’ve had a string of big wins recently, mostly in red states, but don’t seem to be getting much attention on the left yet. They have a training called Union School which is absolutely transformative in my experience. 2. If every socialist only did tenant organizing we would be screwed but I know you’ve both spoken about how critical it is given our current material conditions (state of the labor movement, state capture of unions, deindustrialization, etc.) What can we do to push more socialists from activism, mobilizing, and electoralism into more concrete and highly accessible forms of organizing, like tenant organizing, especially in organizations like the DSA?

Kale Marx

This is something that I’ve been trying to work through recently and haven’t really had anyone to bounce it off of. Is Mao’s re-centering of contradiction - especially his move away from treating “negation of the negation” as a universal, teleological law - the key philosophical rupture that distinguishes MLM from ML? And if so, does that lingering Hegelian residue in Engels’s dialectics - this idea of development tending toward higher syntheses - help explain why ML traditions are structurally prone to revisionism? Put differently: if you take Mao Zedong seriously on contradiction as the only fundamental law, does that reframe revisionism not as a betrayal or error, but as something that emerges when dialectics is still implicitly teleological?

Tåhdong

Hey Dan! I used to be in Wildland, it’s very conservative. Check out grassrootswildlandfirefighters.com they’re doing some meaningful organizing to improve working conditions for firefighters and will give you talking point to frame debates on the line. Stay safe out there.

Beefdrip

Hey Alyson and Breht, hope I can catch in late. I'm also in software engineering like Alyson and I got laid off in the recent wave of mass layoffs in tech. I'm at an inflection point in my life and I am not sure I want to continue my profession. None of my work gets used and I don't event get to code most of the time. What is the point of pursuing quality if slop code gets pumped out? I spent a decade of my life on this and now I'm getting rejected job application after job application without an interview, as I'm in the crab bucket with hundreds of others. I'm honestly at the point where I want to pursue a different path in life, but this is all I've known. I have some hobbies I enjoy (woodworking, homebrewing), but the petty bourgeois mindset would ruin the enjoyment for me as I have to maximize profit.

Tåhdong

Feel free to connect with me alexmwhite@protonmail.com

Dave Peterson

Thank you for asking about this. I’ve been concerned about it myself even though I haven’t been able to spend too much time on it yet. But I wanted to jump in and share a couple of my thoughts, knowing that it’s kind of reactive but not wanting to come across as petty or mean spirited. I am definitely ambivalent about the school on some levels. But I do think that these attacks are not nearly as helpful as they are hurtful. 99% of the people hearing about these hits against the Frankfurt School haven’t seriously read any of the main texts - and they won’t. Maybe a handful of people have read One Dimensional Man by Marcuse. Maybe some have read The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction by Benjamin. But for the vast majority of people exposed to Rockhill’s campaign against them, there is no existing context for people to use to judge its sincerity or legitimacy. I have spent years seriously reading these philosophers, and they are really serious thinkers that took on an immense set of challenges. They were coming of age in the shadow of huge failures on the left and huge counterrevolutions. They were contemporaries of Freud, like Marx was a contemporary of Darwin. They were all exiles from fascist Germany. And they all returned to continue their work. As Jewish Marxist philosophers. Most notably, imo these attacks on the Frankfurt School show how many of the implications of fascism don’t seem to get treated seriously enough. Of these writers, I’ve read Adorno the most closely. To the best of my ability, I tried to engage in the philosophy specifically. I wasn’t concerning myself with other projects, such as biographical stories. But I am super unappreciative of the petty demonization of these antifascists by people like Rockhill, not to mention the 60’s German new left leftists who personally - very personally - attacked someone like Adorno. (In a real way, those attacks probably played a role in his premature death, actually.) I read Adorno very closely for years, especially Dialectic of Enlightenment and Negative Dialectics. I also really think Minima Moralia is a really important antifascist book by Adorno while in exile. So I can’t help but how Rockhill and his kind fit into an old assassination campaign. None of these people (I’d say this also applies even to Rockhill,) are perfect. The Frankfurt School took the enormous failures of the left in their time and the real failure’s represented by the ascendancy of fascism (which we are facing today, which is relevant to these attacks, imo,) seriously and in earnest. Their philosophical work is coherent , it’s important, and is concerned with our survival. In my personal opinion, their work is incredibly important for our understanding of fascism (and liberalism). (Maybe they are less helpful when it comes to conflicts within the Marxist left. I’m not sure.) The entire left, from the Soviet Union to Jewish German philosophers in exile to partisans and anti colonial leaders, *worked with the U.S. military and State Department* during antifascist struggles in the mid-twentieth century. Rockhill attacks a very particular group out of this bigger group of antifascists - according to these millions of podcast appearances he’s garnered, at least. Survival is the primary condition of any philosophical work today, and Adorno wrote about that. It’s not the easiest, but a close read of the introduction to Negative Dialectics can help someone curious see where Adorno was moving at the time of his early death. And no, I haven’t read Jordan Peterson or Gabriel Rockhill. But I can straight up vouch that some of the work of that group “western Marxists” are important contributions. It’s been hilarious in a way that very few people have been engaging seriously with their work for decades. They’re attacked by far right conspiracy theorists who don’t care one whit about philosophy of any kind, tbh. And now this stuff. I think these “leftist” attacks on these long dead philosophers and teachers serve more than one purpose. Maybe they are good for the left. Also - philosophy is dope. I hope people engage with these philosophers. They wanted to help us reflect on our survival from an authentic Marxist orientation, even if not acceptable to all of us.

Dave Peterson

Thanks, Cat - sorry for the long ass reply

Dave Peterson

Cat asked about the Rockhill/Western Marxism episode and I jotted down some notes while listening to this Fidel-epic-ama session - thank you Alyson and Breht! I love you all. My two cents hastily put together tonight are here. tldr; I think philosophy (and religion) are important, and i think the Frankfurt School is a serious group of philosophers. Thank you for asking about this. I’ve been concerned about it myself even though I haven’t been able to spend too much time on it yet. But I wanted to jump in and share a couple of my thoughts, knowing that it’s kind of reactive but not wanting to come across as petty or mean spirited. I am definitely ambivalent about the school on some levels. But I do think that these attacks are not nearly as helpful as they are hurtful. 99% of the people hearing about these hits against the Frankfurt School haven’t seriously read any of the main texts - and they won’t. Maybe a handful of people have read One Dimensional Man by Marcuse. Maybe some have read The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction by Benjamin. But for the vast majority of people exposed to Rockhill’s campaign against them, there is no existing context for people to use to judge its sincerity or legitimacy. I have spent years seriously reading these philosophers, and they are really serious thinkers that took on an immense set of challenges. They were coming of age in the shadow of huge failures on the left and huge counterrevolutions. They were contemporaries of Freud, like Marx was a contemporary of Darwin. They were all exiles from fascist Germany. And they all returned to continue their work. As Jewish Marxist philosophers. Most notably, imo these attacks on the Frankfurt School show how many of the implications of fascism don’t seem to get treated seriously enough. Of these writers, I’ve read Adorno the most closely. To the best of my ability, I tried to engage in the philosophy specifically. I wasn’t concerning myself with other projects, such as biographical stories. But I am super unappreciative of the petty demonization of these antifascists by people like Rockhill, not to mention the 60’s German new left leftists who personally - very personally - attacked someone like Adorno. (In a real way, those attacks probably played a role in his premature death, actually.) I read Adorno very closely for years, especially Dialectic of Enlightenment and Negative Dialectics. I also really think Minima Moralia is a really important antifascist book by Adorno while in exile. So I can’t help but reflect on the context I'm aware of that helps me see how Rockhill and his kind fit into an old assassination campaign. None of these people (I’d say this also applies even to Rockhill,) are perfect. The Frankfurt School took the enormous failures of the left in their time and the real failure’s represented by the ascendancy of fascism (which we are facing today, which is relevant to these attacks, imo,) seriously and in earnest. Their philosophical work is coherent , it’s important, and is concerned with our survival. In my personal opinion, their work is incredibly important for our understanding of fascism (and liberalism). (Maybe they are less helpful when it comes to conflicts within the Marxist left. I’m not sure.) The entire left, from the Soviet Union to Jewish German philosophers in exile to partisans and anti colonial leaders, *worked with the U.S. military and State Department* during antifascist struggles in the mid-twentieth century. Rockhill attacks a very particular group out of this bigger group of antifascists - according to these millions of podcast appearances he’s garnered, at least. Survival is the primary condition of any philosophical work today, and Adorno wrote about that. It’s not the easiest, but a close read of the introduction to Negative Dialectics can help someone curious see where Adorno was moving at the time of his early death. And no, I haven’t read Jordan Peterson or Gabriel Rockhill. But I can straight up vouch that some of the work of that group “western Marxists” are important contributions. It’s been hilarious in a way that very few people have been engaging seriously with their work for decades. They’re attacked by far right conspiracy theorists who don’t care one whit about philosophy of any kind, tbh. And now this stuff. I think these “leftist” attacks on these long dead philosophers and teachers serve more than one purpose. Maybe they are good for the left. Also - philosophy is dope. I hope people engage with these philosophers. They wanted to help us reflect on our survival from an authentic Marxist orientation, even if not acceptable to all of us. And sorry for the long ass comment..... peace! :)

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Oh splendid! I'm so glad to hear it. As I said, I think it will make for a very illuminating and enlightening conversation. I could share a list of potential sources I know here, or would it be better to discuss over email, do you suppose?

StinkLord

Hampton Think is not a news source but it has good commentary on it

Cat Ledue

No, thank you this was helpful! I haven’t done enough reading of any of these people to feel intellectually confident in this area, but my anthropology background makes me skeptical of anyone who uses concepts like “Western Marxism” or “Western thought” as if they are a stable, bounded unit of analysis - there are colonized and non-Western people who have always been a part of and influencing what we call the “western tradition” since the dawn of Marxism - since the dawn of philosophy!

Cat Ledue

I agree, and even scathing reviews concede that the CIA has played a dubious role in Left intellectualism; like I said to Dave below, I think my issue is more about methodology and treating “Western Marxism” as something neatly bounded and separate from the influence of Global South thinkers; I also think anti-intellectualism is so rampant in the u.s. that launching another critique of intellectuals is kind of low-hanging fruit (although in part valid) - there are many people in academia who constantly critique their own disciplines and are very aware of the ways power and knowledge production are inseparable - I mean I came to Marx through a discipline that has invented during colonialism to “study the other” - but I still emerged with deeply anti colonial and anti-racist and anti-capitalist frameworks that I could take with me into the real world. I think critiques of intellectuals are necessary - but I think the real issue is that we don’t have democratic access to education and this creates massive hierarchies when it comes to knowledge…sorry I digress!

shane bennett

I know this is an older post but I'm hoping you see this. Where can I learn MMT? Like, the theory itself. I looked up grumbine on YouTube since I seen you mentioned him but its mostly him on podcasts having back and forth convos with people. Is there a video where he just lays out the theory itself in detail?

Dark-Hoodied Exile Sorcerer

Well, the list of possible resources I've assembled is: George Lakey (highly recommend his "Strategy for a Living Revolution," though he's moderated his politics in his advanced years); Kazu Haga; Alexandre Christoyannopolous, Joseph Llewllyn, Brian Martin, Vinay Lal, Richard Jackson, Ned Dobos, and Stellan Vinthagen. (All but the first two were recommended me by an anarcho-pacifist comrade, and I've only engaged with a little bit of their work at most, so I can't personally speak to their credentials as a potential guest I'm afraid.