Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

PATREON EXCLUSIVE: Breht reads parts 1 and 2 of Too Black's essay titled "Nonviolence is Violence, too" in anticipation of an upcoming public episode where Breht and Too Black discuss part 2.

Find the essay here: https://www.grassrootsthinking.com/nonviolence-is-violence-too-somebodys-gotta-die/ and https://www.grassrootsthinking.com/nonviolence-is-violence-too-part-2-were-all-in-the-gunk/

Listen to the Rev Left episode on Part 1 with Too Black here: https://revolutionaryleftradio.libsyn.com/nonviolence-is-violence-too-somebodys-gotta-die

Check out The Black Myths Podcast here: https://blackmyths.libsyn.com/

Files

Comments

Spiderdijo7

This made my day thanks Breht

Brad Northcote

I'm going to have to revisit the conversation on this essay! To quote a book title of a line former SNCC activist, "This Nonviolent Stuff'll Get You Killed". A sort of dialectical inversion of this thesis is the cynical imperialist term, "peace offensive". There were Cold War figures who saw denuclearization campaigns and diplomacy from socialism as active threats undermining imperialist interests in hegemony. Unfortunately, that "threat" failed to restrict, but rather galvanized a doubling-down on, imperialism.

Curtis

Thank you for reading the full essay to us. The conversation you two had about the essay had a huge impact on me. For a long time I've said I'm a recovering pacifist and now im more of a passthefist, and this essay puts into words everything I've wanted to and much more. Can't wait for pt 2

Rev Left Radio

Thats great to hear. I think there is something noble about pacifism, it comes from a very very good place - but as you know it tends to be unable to deal with the violence that surrounds it and contextualizes it! Part 2 is coming out soon, hopefully youll enjoy that one too!

Eli 🇵🇸

Too Black is an absolute boss for this. Y’all fundamentally shifted my thinking on this (false) paradigm when you discussed it a while back. Great episode!

Judah Riquelme

Hey. This isn’t directly related to this podcast episode but I felt I needed to insert this to you. You do a lot so I don’t mean to nag- just I think you should do an episode on data centers. Not to be bossy just a recommendation. The stuff going on in box elder county is startling. The water, energy, and resource use is alarming but also ai can extort + blackmail people, employ people, and defame people. I’m worried about it being a major leverage point in a counterrevolution- The hot air these data centers are pumping into the atmosphere 24/7 is scary. Iran is important, Gaza is important, understanding dialectical materialism is important to me- I think data centers are at the core of the Middle East conflicts happening right now. The military tech being demonstrated for the first time in Gaza is ai powered. I think data centers are one of most vital if the most vital lifeline of the capitalist class right now, outside of oil and labor. Thank you for your service thus far though- you’re one of my biggest role models and I know you’re busy I guess I’m not disappointed but just more surprised you haven’t talked more about data centers. It’s an issue that kinda crept up on us.. to be fair. You have talked about data centers yes- thank you and I haven’t listened to every episode but I can’t find a dedicated data center episode and I think it’s definitely one of the top 5 obstacles for a successful socialist revolution. One of the top five choke points / leverage points we need to take advantage of- revolutions don’t happen over night but these data centers gotta be one of the first things to go. Sure ai has benefits but if we aren’t mature enough to have ai then I think we should just destroy it until we can have a more collective form of power over it.

Jess W

Such an eloquent essay, and necessary for all revolutionaries to grapple with whether and how to use violence because it is ultimately a tool. Along that line, I keep relating these ideas to the show The Boys as it showcases strongly the various motivations of violent action as each character (“good or bad”) is faced with a decision to use it.

Rev Left Radio

This is a great point, and I actually have some unique insight into this issue in particular. We are going to do a patreon livestream on here this sunday at noon Central / 1pm EST. I will try to remember this, but if you want to ensure we at least address it (with alyson), putting it as a question in the comment section of our AMA post below would help remind me!! But yes, you are 100% correct, ill try to rectify that and talk about them more. Ive focused a LOT on Iran, west asia, geopolitics last few months for obvious reasons, but more domestic episodes would be useful too!

Chris Brinlee Jr

🚨 Sci-fi nerd alert🚨 : I can't help but think about the dialects explored in Star Wars, particularly with regards to violence / "non-violence." In "Revenge of the Sith," Chancellor Palpatine used an act of "non-violence" against his confrontation with Mace Windu in order to make the final appeal towards Anakin's transition to the dark side. In "Return of the Jedi" Luke also utilized "non-violence" to appear to Darth Vader's remaining compassion and humanity, and to use that to destroy the emperor. In both instances, "non-violence" when faced with violence was used as a catalyst to turn the tides of war. But like Too Black said, the very acts of non-violence cannot exist without the presence of violence. Just kind of a fun pop culture observation.

Ryan V.

agreed, that first ep and essay were really mind opening for me

Chris Swartz

I remember believing peaceful demonstrations were the way forward, then I started listening to Malcolm X and learned there's room for both. Reading about MLK solidified those beliefs, great read.