Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • ep-388-breht-o-shea-converted.mp3

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

“From each according to their ability, to each according to their need.” Steve’s guest, Breht O’Shea of Rev Left Radio and Red Menace podcast, believes that dedicating one’s life to fighting for this vision, even without knowing the outcome, is more meaningful than pursuing capital’s vision of wealth and status. Steve invited Breht to help tackle one of the most misunderstood and weaponized texts in Marxist theory: Vladimir Lenin’s Left-Wing Communism: An Infantile Disorder, a book sometimes misused as a cudgel to pressure leftists into voting for the Democratic Party.

To set the record straight, Breht places the 1920 pamphlet in its proper historical context. It was written after the successful Bolshevik Revolution to advise European socialist movements on how to avoid fatal mistakes. Together, Breht and Steve break down Lenin’s dual critique: the ultra-left “infantile” error of purity-spiraled sectarianism, and the right-wing “opportunist” error of liquidating the revolutionary movement into bourgeois liberal politics. Lenin’s strategic genius lies in maintaining firm revolutionary principles while remaining tactically flexible. The discussion extends beyond the text to cover the necessity of organization and discipline (democratic centralism), the constant threat of counter-revolution, the failure of social democracy, and how fascism functions as capitalism’s immune response to left-wing threats.

Breht O’Shea is the host of Rev Left Radio, the co-host of the Red Menace podcast, and author of the upcoming book “Letters to a Young Revolutionary” published by Iskra Books. 

Check out Real Progressives website HERE

Check out Macro n' Cheese podcast HERE

Subscribe to their Substack HERE

Sub to their YouTube page HERE

Files

Comments

Real Progressives

Really enjoyed this. We hope we can build some bridges and grow in this space. You were amazing and we are all very appreciative of the time and patience you demonstrated grace and a flair for educating that our organization and our listeners truly appreciated. Can't wait to talk more.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! I really appreciate you having me on and would love to keep working with you going forward!

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

Very entertaining and enjoyable conversation! Steve mentioned several times MMT. I also noticed MMT a few years ago, when it was kind of having a moment. I do think MMT has a place in our understanding of modern capitalism, and can be a useful tool. I’ve heard it said that a lot of leftists/Marxists “reject” MMT. If that is true, I think that’s a mistake. Do you have any episodes talking about that?

Rev Left Radio

Huge shout out to you and your show! While I dont have any eps on MMT, I am planning on having Steve on the show soon to do an episode on it!

The Sickle and the Hammer: A Socialist History of the Soviet Union

Would love to collab sometime again! We just had a baby though, so it might be a minute. If you ever need insights into anything about the Soviet Union, reach out! And yes, very excited to hear more about MMT. My understanding is just that it describes how certain states are able to conduct their fiscal policy, and sheds some light on just how much the question is about political willpower and not antiquated ideas of “scarcity” or the like.

Rev Left Radio

Yea, ive actually tried to have her on the show several times, i even had a friend who worked with her, but for some reason she simply never ever replied to any email Ive sent her, sadly.

Michael Murray

Really think this is a groundbreaking episode for those new to socialism. Breht so eloquently expressed ideas I couldn't agree more with and every time I listen to the podcast I am filled with hope. I am also curious about how far the 'red lines' should extend into our personal lives. For example, if offered a employment in a company that invests heavily in Israel, not necessarily military related but could be so-called 'dual-technology', should a principled Marxist refuse or accept? This is a contradiction I am wrestling with currently as someone who is living in the global north, unemployed, and has to support a family. In my field (physics) it is nearly impossible to find employment in an organisation that isn't in someway connected (maybe 2 or 3 degrees of separation from military applications for example) to imperialism towards the global south. It is so tempting and easy to just another neoliberal hyper individualistic subject and ignore our comrades in the global south. In my case it is exceptionally difficult to turn a blind eye as my wife is from the global south.

Nolan Alan Good

This is probably the best podcast episode for sending to someone unfamiliar with marxism as an intro that I’ve found. I am curious, though: do you have particular recommendations of episodes you’ve done that could serve that same purpose?