Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

In this patreon episode Breht traces and explains a subterranean philosophical lineage running from Spinoza through Hegel to Marx and Louis Althusser. Beginning with Spinoza’s conception of God or Nature as a single, immanent Substance, he explores how Hegel transforms Substance into a self-developing Subject, how Marx grounds the dialectic in material social life and class struggle, and how Althusser attempts to remove the final hidden Subject from Marxist theory.

Along the way, he examines the concept of immanent critique, Kant’s transcendental idealism, Hegel’s master-slave dialectic, Marx’s materialist transformation of idealism, and Althusser’s concepts of overdetermination, interpellation, theoretical anti-humanism, and history as a “process without a Subject.”

What emerges is an ongoing struggle over immanence, contradiction, human agency, and whether history possesses either a sovereign author or a guaranteed destination.

Listen to these related episodes to learn more:

Check out our new merch designs and support the show HERE

Files

Comments

Paddy League

Fantastic work here, Breht! Your rigorous academic training always comes through, of course, but it’s really great to hear you read from a script and not only learn new things/deepen my understanding, but also enjoy your true talent as a writer. And written in the backseat with three kids in the car, no less!!! 😂 I learned a lot from this episode, but I particularly appreciated the treatment of Kant as a bridge between Spinoza and Hegel, which I myself tend to overlook. Awesome episode, my friend.

Pk

Im excited to listen to this today. As well as the last 2 main feed episodes. But this one is first in queue because I do also trend to appreciate the philosophical and ontological discussions connected to Marxism. I love spinoza's work and philosophy and I connect it with panpsychism as I feel each provides bits for the other that history and philosophical development has gifted us. I'd love to hear Breht and Alyson do a deep dive on panpsychist work and connect it with marxism for a episode.

Brad Northcote

This should help get me through a 10-hour shift! On Althusser, that "process without a subject" passage has lingered in my mind since reading it last year and it'll be great to see what threads you weave from it.

JK

Looking forward to listening to this episode at work today Brett. Since you usually check Patreon comments and I don't know how else to feasibly reach you on the internet, I wanted to share with you discussions coming up at the World School of Communism in 10 days. You've given me thousands of hours of great Marxist insights to listen to over the years so I figure its only fair to repay the favor. https://schoolofcommunism.com/ Hundreds of revolutionary communists from across the world will be meeting in Italy to discuss the worlds most pressing issues, pouring through the history of Marxism, and helping plot a way forward for socialism within our lifetime. I'm sure there are bound to be several topics you'll find incredibly interesting and insightful. I think you'd agree there is a vacuum on the left for genuine Marxist leadership and in my mind, no one is putting the ideas forward more clearly and building actual organization better than the Revolutionary Communist International. Perhaps it could be a good springboard as well, if a particular speaker stood out to you, to invite them and discuss the ideas more. Would make for a brilliant Rev Left episode. Hope you're staying cool in this brutally hot summer comrade.

Brad Northcote

Fantastic episode! Quick afterthought on Althusser and agency: I can sympathize with the idea that removing the lingering Subject sacrifices something. At the same time, there's something intuitively laudable in the honesty. Whereas any argument strictly from *utility* for a Subject feels somehow paternalistic and manipulative, as if to say "Well you and I don't really believe it, but we need the pretense to get people motivated." That's distinct from positing the presence of a Subject as somehow logically necessary (i.e. as something prior and irreducible to overdetermined structure)...which of course faces the challenge of interpellation.

Max

As a sidenote regarding the block universe, I picked up a nice illustration from some TikTok video years ago, that has been following me ever since: Imagine being a three-dimensional apple that can experience itself only through two-dimensional slices. As it passes through a flat plane, it first appears as a point, then as a growing circle, reaches its maximum size, and finally shrinks back to nothing. To the apple, it experiences itself as change over time, feeling its growth and dreading its end as it shrinks towards its conclusion. But from the higher dimension, the complete apple remains a single, static object. In the same analogy, a human life can be understood as part of a four-dimensional whole: consciousness experiences only one three-dimensional “slice” at a time, moving from infancy through adulthood to old age. From a hypothetical four-dimensional perspective, birth, youth, and death would not replace one another but coexist as permanent parts of the same life. In a way, Dialectics is the grasp for this fourth dimension. Trying to follow an object throught its movement and conceptualising its totality. Its Eve's forbidden reach for the fruit of knowledge that throws us out of a comfortable ignorance.

shane bennett

This is so good, I've listened to you for a long time and the philosophy episodes are my favorite. There's alot of growth here, I can hear you coming to terms and gaining clarity on things I think you've struggled with a little bit in the past

Steven Phillips

Does it all end with Althusser, or where do you think this journey may lead next

Left Hand Notes

Great episode! I’m going to have to go read some Althusser now!

Alex M

Seems like I missed the moment, but if you’re ever back in Santa Fe I’d love to make your family dinner or buy you a beer or tea somewhere. This ep is amazing. I was raised by and around philosophy professors who all just danced around, avoiding Marx like it was the end of history, your podcast, Red Nation (got some local members here), upstream, death panel; resolve so much of my frustration with the head-in-the-clouds philosophy world. I refused academia in favor of working jobs and traveling and it’s really good rediscovering a healthy connection with it grounded in my material realities.

Rev Left Radio

I really appreciate this information and recommendation and I will absolutely check it out asap! Thank you so much!

Rev Left Radio

Thank you! And yes writing in the backseat of a family trip was actually easier than I would have imagined haha, I think I caught some car-wide nap waves XD So glad you enjoyed the episode and found it useful! Thank you for your ongoing support.

Rev Left Radio

No, it certainly doesnt imo, as Althusser represents more of an open question than a final destination. But, alas, I had to end the essay somewhere haha. There is a whole Fanonian trajectory I could take here that would be fascinating, but didnt have time here to do it justice! But the way Fanon expands not only Marxism, but Hegelian master-slave dialectic is really worthwhile, and would make for a great follow up essay.

Rev Left Radio

I hope you caught our episode on philosophy of mind and China Mieville that we did recently that discusses panpsychism to some extent - Alyson in particular seems really sympathetic to it. But yes, perhaps we could go deeper on that theory than that broader episode allowed!

Rev Left Radio

Yea, man, this stuff is still unsettled in my own mind as I feel myself to be quite sympathetic to both sides, and have clearly articulated a humanist marxism in my work for years. I think its indispensible ultimately, but still made sharper by the Althusserian critique. In any case, Althussers intervention remains vital, if open.

Rev Left Radio

Very interesting insight, as always, Max! That is a good illustration of the concept. Its still speculative, but ive always found that idea appealing.

Pk

I did catch that one (its rare I dont listen to an upload) and I got excited when it was mentioned. But that only made me crave a deeper dive more. Much love Breht, thanks for replying.

Rev Left Radio

Thank you Shane, that means a lot. And yes, I can feel that too. My engagement with philosophy is a spiral: I revisit thinkers over and over again through the yearrs, deepeing my understanding of them at each pass, then moving on to other interests, but always coming back. Truly I find philosophy in general to be an indispensible partner through life for me! Glad this resonates with you too, my friend.

JK

The live streams kick off this sunday and will go for nearly a week! Enjoy comrade

Rev Left Radio

I loved New Mexico so much, the beauty of the high desert meeting the moutains will never leave me and I hope to come back. Taos and Santa Fe were absolutely gorgeous and so unique. Only the Pacific Northwest is comparably unique as an ecosystem imo (at least for the ones ive personally visited). New Mexico instantly catapulted to a top three place in the US for me. I appreciate your hospitality/offer, I am sorry I missed you! So happy to here you reforged a love of philosophy more grounded in material reality. Academic philosophy can often be so abstract and disconnected from our lives that it lacks appeal for many. Trying to show its importance from a Marxist and dialectical perspective has def been a goal of mine for this show! THank you for youor support my friend.

Steven Phillips

Breht, thanks for all the work you do. We all appreciate it out here

toadtriller

i loved this episode, as well the the "philosophy of mind" episode. i have been on a personal identity journey after discovering neurodivergence a few years ago. ive started studying Buddhism through yoga teacher training and daily meditation. im currently reading the Tao Te Ching (Le Guin). this philosophical journey is compatible with my identity journey, feeling great euphoria drawing connections and forming my own ideology that actually makes sense. all this to say i find your philosophy episodes as significant as politcal ones; they help make sense of one another. thanks for the work you do and time you put into these episodes.

Andrew S

Great episode! I loved how you crafted a narrative, linking together relevant aspects of such monumental thinkers. This is one of those RevLeft episodes that I plan to listen to every now and then and let it strike me a little differently each time. Speaking as a Marxist humanist... while I've learned a lot from reading Althusser, my jam is his rival in the PCF: Henri Lefebvre. You were spot on by reminding us that Althusser also believed in the working class as having the power - and agency - to struggle for communism. But where Lefebvre took issue with the structuralists (e.g., Althusser), was that the forms and structures that supposedly have their own history, their shape and stability are illusory and constantly changing. (Btw, for Lefebvre, the illusory and irrational can be just as 'real' as anything else.) Moreover, the elements of space that don't fit within definable forms and structures yield a "residue" (i.e., leftovers). As Lefebvre would say, these forms, structures, functions, residues, etc. are all generative and reproduced in "everyday life". Marxist humanism doesn't disregard these things as altogether stale, but rather as not recognizing that forms and structures have dialectical meaning by their fluidity, interrelations, and interpenetrations which are overwhelmed by their contents (i.e., "everyday life"). All this to say... I'd love to hear an episode about Lefebvre. I've read (and loved) his three volumes on "The Critique of Everyday Life" (which Verso published as one complete volume), "The Right to the City" (which was published a couple months before the May 1968 uprisings), and I'm making my way through "The Production of Space". And you said you're diving into Hegel... a comrade of mine is reading selected works of Lefebvre on the relationships between Hegel, Nietzsche, and Marx.

Squiggle

Spinoza was definitely influenced by Kabbalah, which was forbidden in the Jewish communities of Amsterdam and Portugal in the 17th century. Breht, ping me and we can set you up with a reading list. No need to go all the way to India.